I’m so happy for Lena Raine. I had already loved her work on my favorite game, Celeste, but hearing her music in Minecraft and everyone liking it feels really nice
@@Crimson_Knight-do you really need to push down anyone saying anything that's not directly about how greaaaaaaat c418 is? Go complain to Mojang, not people supporting Lena Raine
@@Crimson_Knight- C418 and lena raine have very different music styles in minecraft. C418's soundtrack heavily suits emptier, older minecraft, while lena raine's soundtrack is a lot more fitting for newer minecraft which is a lot less desolate. i think both soundtracks help to create two very different atmospheres. and the direction mojang wanted to go with minecraft was to make it more lively, because thats really the only way forward. you update a game by adding more stuff to it, meaning the old music doesnt fit as well as it did. i think people look at C418's music and old minecraft through rose tinted glasses, because while yeah his music is definitely great, but old minecraft is just objectively worse and the only thing going for it is the nostalgia value. this leads to people going "grrr i hate the new music c418 was better!!!!" because theyre fueled by nostalgia youre allowed to have preferences, but bringing up a comparison like that out of nowhere is pretty direspectful and uncalled for
No you're not. The thing is Stal is easily the most polarizing music disc. Many people absolutely love it and just as many people hate it with a small minority of people being lukewarm to it.
4:28 A couple ways to imagine this 1- the music box version is an early rendition, and is in it's youth (not being oxidized over time), while the full version is later in its "life" since it took time to fully complete it, and therefore oxidized. 2- the music box version is a short recreation of the far older original, and is made from fresher, non-oxidized metal. "3" (mostly a joke)- they forgot to wax the full version and couldn't strip off the rust.
As a person who would (and still does) regularly play legacy console edition, I still call "wait," "where are we now." And it's probably my favorite classic disc next to ward, stal, and strad
Fun fact: on the Legacy Console version, if you let the Cat disc sit in the Jukebox after it finishes playing, it'll start playing "Dog", a song that's otherwise exclusive to the soundtrack (as well as some old Pocket Edition ads).
@@galaxolotl0423 100% is my list as well. Creator is definitely top tier in my opinion. It's like a waltz song and I listen to it often because it massages my brain the right way
Creator is 100% the best disc now. Also, if you view the oxidization of copper in terms of progression, then creator is the fully progressed version, so it makes more sense for it to be the disc that is oxidized green rather than the virgin orange copper color.
Imo why the full instrumental version of creator music disc is the oxidized one is because with time, more musicians/people came and joined the play, each adding their own instruments and melody
I think 2 RUclipsrs named ParrotX2 and Wifies (if not some other RUclipsrs), have concluded that it was a story of the different Minecraft games. Going from sound effects from Minecraft, Minecraft Dungeons, and some other Minecraft game. All making a story at the same time when played all together.
on a similar note, I would argue that my 3rd favourite is Strad because it is TheMisterEpic's outro music (and because the ending of that song gives me goosebumps)
The copper thing with the Creator discs is because the oxidized one can be see as the original, and the new and shiny one is the music box version since music boxes are known to be imitations of existing melodies/tunes. That can also explain why they are two separate discs instead of being just one, since the brown one is new and made to be an imitation, while the green one is old and untouched, hence the oxidization.
I remember watching a supposed theory and lore video about Disc Eleven when I was younger and the guy concluded that it was just the sound of Notch fapping
I think the new gameplay music tracks are better as ambience, like they did a good job with the ancient city, but the old music are better as songs to hear when adventuring.
Newer ambient songs are better for caves Kumi Tanioka songs for the caves and cliffs update imo are the best of the newer for ambient overworld music (Floating dreams in the best one)
13:26 i literally fist bumped the air when you said that because it was one of my favorite music discs, and I was so upset when they quote unquote “removed it”, for I was looking for “Where are we now?” And since I rarely listen to music discs, I was unaware that it had a name swap, and was so, SO happy when I realized that its name was changed to “wait” !!!
@@Evnen1 I agree with it though. I think that pigstep is a really good disc but I don't understand why people are getting upset over it being in number 8
I can kinda understand the pigstep rating since i think my opinion of the disc is heavily skewed by its remixes and the original disc isnt too amazing, on the other hand precipice is way worse, its so repetitive which is a problem both of the discs made by the new composer have
Honestly stall is just a banger. I love the flute design and how it just goes from chill jazz, to just absolute silliness. Also not putting pig step in S Tier is a crime.
the problem with creator music box is that its like they were too lazy to write a whole new song so they remixed creator (which is a masterpiece) and just made it... worse... but I dont think i agree with it being number 15, and i also don't agree with relic in c tier also I have a theory... maybe the reason creator is oxidized while music box is clean is because the developers wanted to add a little easter egg that the sound of the disc changes with oxidation, so music box is more soft and calm cuz it's clean, and the original is more clunky (ig) and more of an actual song because of the oxidation? idk weird theory but i think it's cool even though i think pigstep should be higher your point is pretty good, when it came out it was AMAZING but now it's just repetitive ig AND YES WAIT AND WARD ARE SOOOOOOOOOOO UNDERRATED THANK YOU
Speaking of piano in songs, the instrumental version of “A Stranger I Remain” from MGR literally has the sweetest sounding piano right at the beat drop.
Creator’s always given me the vibe of mystery and fantasy and something hidden under a faux royal vibe with corruption underneath. Like finding secrets never meant to be uncovered.
I noticed something interesting, because the old songs (Aria Math for example) are very nostalgic, and nostalgia is happy, thinking about the past, but then you feel sad, knowing it's gone, and the old songs are melancholy but hopeful, which plays into the nostalgia very well.
I LOVE creator. It gives of this kind of… cozy halloween feeling or something. I also love the last part before the music bix starts going again, it sounds like… idk its just something about it. The design of the disc item itself is very cool. Overall, its so fitting for so many things, i love it so much (Precipice, stal, pigstep are also very good🔥)
Far has always been my favorite music disc in the game. Ward is really nice, Wait (Where Are We Now) is also really nice, Mall is great, and I like the second half of Chirp (the first half of Chirp just reminds me of Little Big Planet). I respect your opinions for your rankings though. Also, love the use of Kirby music in the background and the outro! Kirby is my favorite video game series. :)
I don’t know if you and me are just polar opposites or something, but I IMMEDIATELY looked up the rest of Hill Top Zone’s theme because that squeaky noise just hit so right inside my ears.
Completly agree on the Creator (the one on oxydised disc), my monkey brain goes rabid for it too, however more for the reasons that it feels kinda steampunky in a whimsical way. About the colors of Creator and Creator(Music box), maybe it's because the Creator(music box) is cleaned from the rust, and along with it the non-music box part of the song got partialy scraped off, and in restoration attempt, only the music box part got left on unscathed
5:39 Calling Relic B-Tier should be punishable by death penalty imo but hey, lemme here him out. Edit: Alright nah I think you just gotta get your ears checked. It sounds nostalgic even if you've never played an 8-bit game.
@@vomitonastick9197 Man I really don't know what youre on about. Upon closer listening I hear it as kinda staticy but not that much at all. Still S-Tier or if it really bothers you A. But whateverrrr
It does not sound bad but it is so repetitive, the new composers discs are just so incredibly long and repetitive and i just cant shake the feeling i have heard so fan discs that are better which not something i can say about any of lena raines or c418’s discs
Thought on the creator disks, the clean one has less to it as its pure, smoothed out, while the oxidized one gained all the other sounds and such through the disk getting rougher
I actually agree with this tier list. I don't really like the first part of qard but the second part is just so good. That I just love this disc. And creator is just great. And all other discs have pretty good placements. Obly one or 2 positions from where I would rank them.
"scary noises" yes i see there no music... but it's a mystery within Minecraft (its still a music disc) but with Hidden lore in it i've seen a few theories on these disc's
The reason why I thing the Creator [the oxidied one] has like all the good stuff, but Creator (Music Box) [Not the oxidied one] just hasn't is (I thing) becuse the creator wanted to be like a hidden message that wult reveal it self by time. Just art making it self :D
In my opinion the reason why the full version of Creator is more oxidised is because it was recorded way earlier when there was some sort of ancient steampunk civilization thriving underground and making music. The music box version was probably made later by the last remnants of the civilisation as a last ditch effort to leave a lasting legacy and they hid them in decorated pots for people to hear since the real Creator disc is gatekept in an ominous vault. That's my lore explanation for the discrepancy.
blocks to me was weird as I never listened to the whole thing and was genuinely surprising to me I didn't like blocks at first but it became my favorite I feel like alot of people don't listen to the whole thing the last part is very good...
I’ve been a fan of Ward since my Xbox360 days, it too just sort of spoke to me and kept me coming back to it. Mellohi is also a personal favorite as that was the menu song used in a Minecraft tower defense browser game so whenever I saw or played the disc it made me think of that game
4:23 i felt the same confusion about the colors of the creator discs, but it made sense the more i thought about it. you get the music box disc rarely from decorated pots which are warm in color. for the actual creator disc, you get it from the ominous vault, and the whole color scheme of the ominous trials are filled with blueish elements (soul flames and the ominous trial keys). based on the visual context of how you obtain each disc, i think mojang made the right call on what color the discs should have. if you really think about it, the clean unoxidized disc would be the "stripped down" version since it's "stripped" of the oxidation ,:)
For the creator music discs, i feel like it has something to do with time. Like copper, music changes as it gets older, or the more you work on it. i feel like the normal copper works for the music box cause you could label it as the ‘first version’ and then the oxidize copper for the actual creator is the final piece that’s been worked on and finished instead of it being just a music box. It made more sense in my head but i hope it makes sense
I feel like the color of the "Creator" discs makes perfect sense. It takes time for copper to oxidize and turn green the same way it takes time to develop a single musical idea into a full piece. But that's just me.
I’m still trying to wrap my head around the fact that creator is an official music disk. I’m loving the new producer from Minecraft and I cannot wait for new discs In the future.
My ranking: F tier: "The worst of the worst". 19. Disk 13. It is so ear grating, like nails on a chalk board. D tier: "The bad disks". 18. Disk 11. The scariest disk, at least to me. Still bad, but not as annoying as 13. 17. Disk 5. The best scary/lore disk. Not much else to say. C tier: "The okay disks". 16. Blocks. Its fines, but very repetative and a bit ear grating at times. 15. Ward. Has some good parts, but mostly mediocre. 14. Far. Same story as Ward, but more good parts. B tier: "The start of the good disks". 13. Relic. Ineresting is the best way to describe it. Reminds me of the game Fez for some reason. 12. Mellohi. Mellow, but with some uncertainty thrown in the mix. 11. Mall. Got super close to the top 10. Feels like Blocks, but better in every way. A tier: "Oh wow, these are great". 10. Creator (Music Box). Good rendition of the song, but couldn't put it much higher because it's just a remix. 9. Cat. Simple, yet affective. Great addition as one of the first disks added. 8. Stal. The recorder isn't that annoying to me, and the sax is just great. 7. Precipice. A bit underrated in my opinion. The only issue is that its a bit repetative, but not as much as Blocks. S tier: "The best of the best". 6. Otherside. A bit overrated in my opinion, but still absolutly amazing. 5. Strad. Two words: simply iconic. The steal drums make it stand out, and give it a wierd tropical vibe, but still great. 4. Chirp. The begining is just amazing, and the rest of the song follows suit. Simply wonderful. 3. Wait. Best clasic disk. Calm and relaxing at its finest, and always brings me nostalgic memories. 2. Creator. The slow music box begining building up to the elctric guitars and other instruments is always satisfying. I can see why it became such a fan favourite. 1. Pigstep. Always felt to me like some sort of final boss music. It also brings me some nostalgia as 1.16 is the final update I played Minecraft regularly. I still watch Minecraft content, but I always didn't like survival mode, and I didn't have any passion to build anything in creative.
I'm so glad I didn't update my legacy console addition to bedrock so I can still head that in game. It was worth it to buy Minecraft again to have both.
what i like about otherside is that it makes you feel like you can climb a mountain barehanded. which fits with the fact that it was added in 1.18, AND the fact that Lena Raine has already worked on songs about climbing mountains
That guy really just called Chopin's funeral march "some funeral ass music" 💀
Ain’t no way 💀
Funeral ahh moment
I’m so happy for Lena Raine. I had already loved her work on my favorite game, Celeste, but hearing her music in Minecraft and everyone liking it feels really nice
Still worse than C418
@@Crimson_Knight-do you really need to push down anyone saying anything that's not directly about how greaaaaaaat c418 is?
Go complain to Mojang, not people supporting Lena Raine
@@Crimson_Knight- C418 and lena raine have very different music styles in minecraft. C418's soundtrack heavily suits emptier, older minecraft, while lena raine's soundtrack is a lot more fitting for newer minecraft which is a lot less desolate. i think both soundtracks help to create two very different atmospheres. and the direction mojang wanted to go with minecraft was to make it more lively, because thats really the only way forward. you update a game by adding more stuff to it, meaning the old music doesnt fit as well as it did. i think people look at C418's music and old minecraft through rose tinted glasses, because while yeah his music is definitely great, but old minecraft is just objectively worse and the only thing going for it is the nostalgia value. this leads to people going "grrr i hate the new music c418 was better!!!!" because theyre fueled by nostalgia
youre allowed to have preferences, but bringing up a comparison like that out of nowhere is pretty direspectful and uncalled for
@@Crimson_Knight-I was about to comment but two people have already shown how stupid your comment is.
@@xela953that’s the main reason why people like C418, because new Minecraft sucks.
am i the only one who loves stall?
stal would be my top 3 if the recorder wasnt in it, lowkey hurts my ears
best disc
No, i dont kniw why everyone hates the flute, its the best part
No you're not. The thing is Stal is easily the most polarizing music disc. Many people absolutely love it and just as many people hate it with a small minority of people being lukewarm to it.
No not at all
I haven’t played Minecraft in so long I thought they got rid of “where are we now”, but I just realized that they changed it to “wait” lol
@@kyle--859never heard of that unless you mean how did we get here
@@TheSkullSnatcher Yeah, I misremembered it
4:28
A couple ways to imagine this
1- the music box version is an early rendition, and is in it's youth (not being oxidized over time), while the full version is later in its "life" since it took time to fully complete it, and therefore oxidized.
2- the music box version is a short recreation of the far older original, and is made from fresher, non-oxidized metal.
"3" (mostly a joke)- they forgot to wax the full version and couldn't strip off the rust.
bro did chirp dirty
Fax, banger fr
Literally best disc
To me the first part sounds like a broken disc player playing a damaged disk in an apocalyptic wasteland
fr
Bro doesn't respect opinions
As a person who would (and still does) regularly play legacy console edition, I still call "wait," "where are we now." And it's probably my favorite classic disc next to ward, stal, and strad
@@kfpocs I thought they changed WAWN to wait in later legacy console updates, is that right?
@@GamingBren yes, but my XBOX 360 is stuck on one of the earlier versions before the change happened
Strad is peak
Fun fact: on the Legacy Console version, if you let the Cat disc sit in the Jukebox after it finishes playing, it'll start playing "Dog", a song that's otherwise exclusive to the soundtrack (as well as some old Pocket Edition ads).
I personally like otherside and creator because it gives me the goosebumps ending that i just cant explain how amazing it is, definitely my top 2
Same, and my third is probably wait
@@galaxolotl0423 100% is my list as well. Creator is definitely top tier in my opinion. It's like a waltz song and I listen to it often because it massages my brain the right way
Bro, these two are literally my favorite as well.
I agree and third is Strad
the 2nd half of otherside is by far the most glorious song I have ever listened to in my entire life
Creator is 100% the best disc now. Also, if you view the oxidization of copper in terms of progression, then creator is the fully progressed version, so it makes more sense for it to be the disc that is oxidized green rather than the virgin orange copper color.
Relic is better
Precipice better
@@GamingBren 1.21 fanbot💀
That is so true , I could listen to it for HOURS because its so good
@@EduPintilie -creator simp ☠- oh sorry I didn’t know you hate creator
(also I'm a real person)
I feel like nobody loves melohi like I do
I actually would probably rank Mellohi in my top 3
Imo why the full instrumental version of creator music disc is the oxidized one is because with time, more musicians/people came and joined the play, each adding their own instruments and melody
Bro your profile picture is so cute ! Just wanted to say that
Bro your profile picture is complete garbage! Just wanted to say that
@@crunchywashere3513Bro your profile picture is so cute! just wanted to say that.
@@Dream_Florida Thank you bro
@@crunchywashere3513 :)
If you count to 13 and play 5, 11, and 13 respectfully, it goes into the true story of the Warden
Wondering how the Endersent is included in this (its noise is heard in 5)
Try playing all the discs at the same time. I assure you, it will be the last orchestral performance you will ever listen to again.
I think 2 RUclipsrs named ParrotX2 and Wifies (if not some other RUclipsrs), have concluded that it was a story of the different Minecraft games.
Going from sound effects from Minecraft, Minecraft Dungeons, and some other Minecraft game.
All making a story at the same time when played all together.
#19. “11”
#18. “13”
#17. “Five”
#16. “Mellohi”
#15. “Creator (Music Box)”
#14. “Stal”
#13. “Relic”
#12. “Chirp”
#11. “Blocks”
#10. “Mall”
#9. “Strad”
#8. “Pigstep”
#7. “Far”
#6. “Precipice”
#5. “Cat”
#4. “Otherside”
#3. “Wait”
#2. “Ward”
#1. “Creator”
You’re welcome.
Delete this so nobody gets spoiled
@@Sajedgxnoone cares if its spoiled its a reaction lmao
Putting Precipice in high A and not S is some criminal work
There is an old one called “dog” just a more upbeat version of cat iirc. Though understandable not to rank it since it is not in the game really.
In old console minecraft, dog would play right after cat on the cat music disc
@@Tygjc yep
I have heard it and don't like it. D tier for me
I still have Xbox 360 edition and Xbox 1 edition since they gave the option to upgrade to bedrock but didn't require it. I'll need to go listen to it
It was also used in some of the earlier Pocket Edition ads.
My personal favourite is Mellohi. Mainly because it was featured in Trey the Explainer's "New Spinosaurus" video, which I have a lot of nostalgia for.
I like it to
Mellohi has been my favorite since AvM season 3. It’s just a good song.
Only bad thing about Mellohi is that it is too short
on a similar note, I would argue that my 3rd favourite is Strad because it is TheMisterEpic's outro music (and because the ending of that song gives me goosebumps)
I can’t say I agree; Mellohi is my second least favorite only except for 11
The copper thing with the Creator discs is because the oxidized one can be see as the original, and the new and shiny one is the music box version since music boxes are known to be imitations of existing melodies/tunes. That can also explain why they are two separate discs instead of being just one, since the brown one is new and made to be an imitation, while the green one is old and untouched, hence the oxidization.
Nah this kid really said pigstep wasn't that good, and then put Ward in the 2nd spot 💀
Agreed brother
I’m gonna be completely honest. I think pigstep is just ok
i have never seen the appeal to pigstep tbh, its an alright song
I think he has a point that Pigstep has fallen off since its introduction
@@Mr_Blah cap
I remember watching a supposed theory and lore video about Disc Eleven when I was younger and the guy concluded that it was just the sound of Notch fapping
Then what does the 11 mean?
@IridiumA03 how many minutes it took
@@SnazzySkelly Dark humor really does go over your head doesn't it?
@@IridiumA03 ...?
I was just replying to your thing lil bro
I have a hot take that lena reine made the best music discs but c418 made the best ambient music
I think the new gameplay music tracks are better as ambience, like they did a good job with the ancient city, but the old music are better as songs to hear when adventuring.
@@tristanshaltz2769 ancestry slaps ngl
Newer ambient songs are better for caves
Kumi Tanioka songs for the caves and cliffs update imo are the best of the newer for ambient overworld music
(Floating dreams in the best one)
My bias towards the Minecraft era when disks were first added means I’ll have to disagree.
Cat is some S tier melodies to me, I always dance to it ingame. I'm so glad I always find it really easily in survival.
Cat is #1. Easy. No hesitation.
You managed to change my opinion on Far completely, it really is a beautiful track. Well done!
@@sirjafferson2476 Far is amazing
lkr now im always playing it
13:26 i literally fist bumped the air when you said that because it was one of my favorite music discs, and I was so upset when they quote unquote “removed it”, for I was looking for “Where are we now?” And since I rarely listen to music discs, I was unaware that it had a name swap, and was so, SO happy when I realized that its name was changed to “wait” !!!
3:59 Number 15:
Burger kind foot lettuce
Far is my number 1, my number 2 is precipice. 3 is c a t, 4 is c h r i s, it makes me wanna build a well.
Bro did (insert favorite music disc here) dirty
Relic is my favourite, perfect tune to tend to my base to!
I kinda dig this List but I can’t stand by Precipice being better than Pigstep Ever sorry 😅. Also wasn’t expecting Creater (Music Box) to be so low
i know my pigstep take is very unusual lol
@@Evnen1 I agree with it though. I think that pigstep is a really good disc but I don't understand why people are getting upset over it being in number 8
I can kinda understand the pigstep rating since i think my opinion of the disc is heavily skewed by its remixes and the original disc isnt too amazing, on the other hand precipice is way worse, its so repetitive which is a problem both of the discs made by the new composer have
@@Evnen1I feel like I’m the only one who agrees
1:33 my yt glitched and paused on "i almost immediately eja-"
Honestly stall is just a banger. I love the flute design and how it just goes from chill jazz, to just absolute silliness. Also not putting pig step in S Tier is a crime.
@@R3LKZz this guy put pigstep in A tier and called it “repetitive” while he put other side in S tier, which is just as repetitive as pig step
@@AmarOterosSpeedy sorry I meant yeah and not waht I read it wrong lol
@@AmarOterosSpeedy PIGSTEP IS THE GOAT
@@R3LKZz it’s fine, but yea pigstep is one of the goats
Pig step is kind of a banger I would only use it in like a colosseum build for music
creator is the goat
the problem with creator music box is that its like they were too lazy to write a whole new song so they remixed creator (which is a masterpiece) and just made it... worse... but I dont think i agree with it being number 15, and i also don't agree with relic in c tier
also I have a theory... maybe the reason creator is oxidized while music box is clean is because the developers wanted to add a little easter egg that the sound of the disc changes with oxidation, so music box is more soft and calm cuz it's clean, and the original is more clunky (ig) and more of an actual song because of the oxidation? idk weird theory but i think it's cool
even though i think pigstep should be higher your point is pretty good, when it came out it was AMAZING but now it's just repetitive ig
AND YES WAIT AND WARD ARE SOOOOOOOOOOO UNDERRATED THANK YOU
That is mostlly right , but idk , i think creator music box isn't that bad , it's kinda cool and mysterious
Speaking of piano in songs, the instrumental version of “A Stranger I Remain” from MGR literally has the sweetest sounding piano right at the beat drop.
Creator, has most instruments, so it's my favorite, and it also has clarinet, my first instrument
honestly its kinda mid
@@vicid1415 but it has clarinet...
@@vicid1415 you shan't disrespect thy clarinet
@@TCMCGMB alpha by c418 has clarinet
@@Chaseee_ really? Can U give Me The Name?
Creator’s always given me the vibe of mystery and fantasy and something hidden under a faux royal vibe with corruption underneath. Like finding secrets never meant to be uncovered.
never did i expect a youtube ranking to give wait the respect it deserves :0
bro wait is pretty chill, wait and far just feel "minecrafty". they're just more ambient like the volume alpha soundtrack.
I noticed something interesting, because the old songs (Aria Math for example) are very nostalgic, and nostalgia is happy, thinking about the past, but then you feel sad, knowing it's gone, and the old songs are melancholy but hopeful, which plays into the nostalgia very well.
I LOVE creator. It gives of this kind of… cozy halloween feeling or something. I also love the last part before the music bix starts going again, it sounds like… idk its just something about it. The design of the disc item itself is very cool. Overall, its so fitting for so many things, i love it so much (Precipice, stal, pigstep are also very good🔥)
Far has always been my favorite music disc in the game. Ward is really nice, Wait (Where Are We Now) is also really nice, Mall is great, and I like the second half of Chirp (the first half of Chirp just reminds me of Little Big Planet). I respect your opinions for your rankings though. Also, love the use of Kirby music in the background and the outro! Kirby is my favorite video game series. :)
I don’t know if you and me are just polar opposites or something, but I IMMEDIATELY looked up the rest of Hill Top Zone’s theme because that squeaky noise just hit so right inside my ears.
Completly agree on the Creator (the one on oxydised disc), my monkey brain goes rabid for it too, however more for the reasons that it feels kinda steampunky in a whimsical way.
About the colors of Creator and Creator(Music box), maybe it's because the Creator(music box) is cleaned from the rust, and along with it the non-music box part of the song got partialy scraped off, and in restoration attempt, only the music box part got left on unscathed
I love both old and modern music, they make the world of minecraft feel alive and mysterious
"please dont hurt me " after calling the best disc number 8
6:42 The music disc also sounds like something from Little Big Planet
I feel like so many people sleep on Ward. Thank you for doing it justice!
The funeral beginning goes really hard and the rest of the song makes me genuinely feel a bit sad. Sharing top 3 with Mellohi and Cat.
creator has such a steampunk-ish vibe and i love it
3: Pigstep
2: This archelogy disc
1: The gray trial chamber disc
I believe it’s a clarinet or clarinet synth that plays throughout a lot of creator, especially its starring moment after the first music box section
The copper disc textures was the first thing I thought when I listened to them. The textures should absolutely be swapped.
Never let bro cook ever again🙏🔥🔥
Why
Ever* opinion invalidated
sorry
@@Lari-se2shsuspend his cooking license for 7 days for not putting pigstep in top 5
Never let bro say his opinion
5:39
Calling Relic B-Tier should be punishable by death penalty imo but hey, lemme here him out.
Edit: Alright nah I think you just gotta get your ears checked. It sounds nostalgic even if you've never played an 8-bit game.
plz dont kill me 😨😨
Relic is my least favorite disc in the game. Gives me ear cancer.
@@vomitonastick9197 Man I really don't know what youre on about. Upon closer listening I hear it as kinda staticy but not that much at all. Still S-Tier or if it really bothers you A. But whateverrrr
It does not sound bad but it is so repetitive, the new composers discs are just so incredibly long and repetitive and i just cant shake the feeling i have heard so fan discs that are better which not something i can say about any of lena raines or c418’s discs
Thought on the creator disks, the clean one has less to it as its pure, smoothed out, while the oxidized one gained all the other sounds and such through the disk getting rougher
I know it’s your opinion but creator slaps so hard for no reason. Generally the beginning of it sounds like something straight out of hollow knight.
There’s lore in 13
If you count to 13 and play 5, 11, and 13 respectfully, it goes into the true story of the Warden
I can’t believe disc 11 and 13 are dead last! They were my favourite discs. 😢
stalls flute recorder combo is amazing. its in my top 3
Finally, someone who actually likes ward
FOR REAL
I actually agree with this tier list.
I don't really like the first part of qard but the second part is just so good. That I just love this disc.
And creator is just great.
And all other discs have pretty good placements. Obly one or 2 positions from where I would rank them.
Bro forgot D tier
Ja
Yeah
はい
Да
Так
Now rate all the ambient tracks
😏
"scary noises" yes i see there no music... but it's a mystery within Minecraft (its still a music disc) but with Hidden lore in it i've seen a few theories on these disc's
Finally someone who actually Put "Wait" on the top, And that is my favorite ome too
The reason why I thing the Creator [the oxidied one] has like all the good stuff, but Creator (Music Box) [Not the oxidied one] just hasn't is (I thing) becuse the creator wanted to be like a hidden message that wult reveal it self by time. Just art making it self :D
Wet hands is the best Minecraft song of all time
Wait in top 3 is incredibly based
In my opinion the reason why the full version of Creator is more oxidised is because it was recorded way earlier when there was some sort of ancient steampunk civilization thriving underground and making music. The music box version was probably made later by the last remnants of the civilisation as a last ditch effort to leave a lasting legacy and they hid them in decorated pots for people to hear since the real Creator disc is gatekept in an ominous vault. That's my lore explanation for the discrepancy.
Idk why but chirp always makes me think of old scp-173 (you know, the statue that looks like a peanut)
blocks to me was weird as I never listened to the whole thing and was genuinely surprising to me I didn't like blocks at first but it became my favorite I feel like alot of people don't listen to the whole thing the last part is very good...
Glad to see Ward getting the praise it deserves after a decade of going unnoticed
Creator gives me shivers. I agree with the placement of it
precipice from minceraft ❌
precipice from subnautica ✔
I’ve been a fan of Ward since my Xbox360 days, it too just sort of spoke to me and kept me coming back to it. Mellohi is also a personal favorite as that was the menu song used in a Minecraft tower defense browser game so whenever I saw or played the disc it made me think of that game
Ward is sooooo good you're doing it great justice
Good to see Ward getting the love it deserves.
I will go into the trial chambers only to find Creator
As someone who did ballroom dancing creator HITS
every note
Bro I literally forgot relic even existed
I agree about the creator texture. Why is the rusty sounding disc not the rusty looking one ??
Don’t get me wrong. Creator is a great disc but it definitely does not deserve number one honestly, I would put it in B
15:37 actual jumpscare☠️☠️☠️ i was scared out of my @$$ bro😂😂😂
Fr
4:23 i felt the same confusion about the colors of the creator discs, but it made sense the more i thought about it.
you get the music box disc rarely from decorated pots which are warm in color. for the actual creator disc, you get it from the ominous vault, and the whole color scheme of the ominous trials are filled with blueish elements (soul flames and the ominous trial keys). based on the visual context of how you obtain each disc, i think mojang made the right call on what color the discs should have.
if you really think about it, the clean unoxidized disc would be the "stripped down" version since it's "stripped" of the oxidation ,:)
Top 5
1: Otherside 12:08
2: Relic 5:36
3: Wait 13:27
4: Creator 15:18
5: Pigstep 8:30
Creator is peak Lena Raine. I love her style so much
Mellohi in 16th? I refuse to hear the rest
Hot take: Blocks is my least favourite non-numbered disk (5,11,13). It's fine, but nothing more.
For the creator music discs, i feel like it has something to do with time. Like copper, music changes as it gets older, or the more you work on it. i feel like the normal copper works for the music box cause you could label it as the ‘first version’ and then the oxidize copper for the actual creator is the final piece that’s been worked on and finished instead of it being just a music box.
It made more sense in my head but i hope it makes sense
I feel like the color of the "Creator" discs makes perfect sense. It takes time for copper to oxidize and turn green the same way it takes time to develop a single musical idea into a full piece.
But that's just me.
Mellohi is my favorite, its a waltz
I’m still trying to wrap my head around the fact that creator is an official music disk. I’m loving the new producer from Minecraft and I cannot wait for new discs In the future.
Chirp sounds at the start like a old ass 1990s commercial
Mellohi and Creator (music box) are very underrated
My ranking:
F tier: "The worst of the worst".
19. Disk 13. It is so ear grating, like nails on a chalk board.
D tier: "The bad disks".
18. Disk 11. The scariest disk, at least to me. Still bad, but not as annoying as 13.
17. Disk 5. The best scary/lore disk. Not much else to say.
C tier: "The okay disks".
16. Blocks. Its fines, but very repetative and a bit ear grating at times.
15. Ward. Has some good parts, but mostly mediocre.
14. Far. Same story as Ward, but more good parts.
B tier: "The start of the good disks".
13. Relic. Ineresting is the best way to describe it. Reminds me of the game Fez for some reason.
12. Mellohi. Mellow, but with some uncertainty thrown in the mix.
11. Mall. Got super close to the top 10. Feels like Blocks, but better in every way.
A tier: "Oh wow, these are great".
10. Creator (Music Box). Good rendition of the song, but couldn't put it much higher because it's just a remix.
9. Cat. Simple, yet affective. Great addition as one of the first disks added.
8. Stal. The recorder isn't that annoying to me, and the sax is just great.
7. Precipice. A bit underrated in my opinion. The only issue is that its a bit repetative, but not as much as Blocks.
S tier: "The best of the best".
6. Otherside. A bit overrated in my opinion, but still absolutly amazing.
5. Strad. Two words: simply iconic. The steal drums make it stand out, and give it a wierd tropical vibe, but still great.
4. Chirp. The begining is just amazing, and the rest of the song follows suit. Simply wonderful.
3. Wait. Best clasic disk. Calm and relaxing at its finest, and always brings me nostalgic memories.
2. Creator. The slow music box begining building up to the elctric guitars and other instruments is always satisfying. I can see why it became such a fan favourite.
1. Pigstep. Always felt to me like some sort of final boss music. It also brings me some nostalgia as 1.16 is the final update I played Minecraft regularly. I still watch Minecraft content, but I always didn't like survival mode, and I didn't have any passion to build anything in creative.
I recommend Cat fans listen to Dog, a fun feature of legacy console edition is that it plays after Cat finishes on the disc
I'm so glad I didn't update my legacy console addition to bedrock so I can still head that in game. It was worth it to buy Minecraft again to have both.
Wait reminds me of a tribute to Minecraft which makes me like it a lot more
creator is just some haloween ahh music
Creator (oxidised) reminds me of the main theme of Howl's Moving Castle
what i like about otherside is that it makes you feel like you can climb a mountain barehanded. which fits with the fact that it was added in 1.18, AND the fact that Lena Raine has already worked on songs about climbing mountains
«Errhmm actually, it was 1.19🤓»
No but seriously i agree with you
@@vemijoev otherside wasn't added in 1.19 tho? that's disc 5
@@Cool_Name-idk oh actually your right! My bad
I agree with you on Creator, once you listen to it, it stays in your head forever...
thx for the playlist recomendations
Swap relic with creator, stal with other side, and cat with wait. That would be my list