I don't think this is right to sing the song of Perumal. MURUGAN REG scavenger related work. It can be written as an article in news paper. Absolutely rubbish ridiculous to bring out in concerts. The image of singer also go to that level.it is very much pained to see the such a great musician to this low level of image. I hope he need some proper treatment under sychiotrist
my 2 cents for two decades i was having two normal eyes (right eye was Sri Sanjay subrahmanyan) and left eye was Sri TMK. but recent days i lost my left eye sight and right eye is kind of catract since changed from CM to musician. for years i used to have the habit of standing outside of Sri TMK’s house gate just to remember the concerts that i had attended around chennai city. i dont know why supporting musicians play for him. am kind of blind!
Excellent concert , good selection of songs had from Tagore to Dikshitar , Introducing a social Perumal Murugan in this concert creates so much negativity as I see the comments, it's a crazy world difficult to understand
To all who drops venom disguised as criticism [ not genuine productive criticisms ] ... Pls don't try to take monopoly of entire carnatic music and take pain of putting in your weak shoulders. Music in any form has no boundaries....it keeps refined and under go experiments...while some succeeds some breaks. Saw some one here berating TNKs slow paced music ....pity to his conservative ears who didn't hear pre ariyakudi era and beauty of leisurely paced music right from MDR to TMK and many others.... This stream of music will keep blooming with the contributions of TMK and many others..don't belittle his ways.....u can take only what you want from his music but don't make the mistake of writing him off ...u will fail for sure 🙏
TMK may be intellectually par excellence but DMK is the culprit that has fed him with poison!!! He has been using Carnatic music to hide behind- now has to face what the cosmos and devoted bhaktas of music has gifted him in his life's Karmic- platter.
I too agree that it is a pity that she people get into jobs of cleaning feacus. But it is not more dumped on them by any society. It is their own choice to do or not. Of course society has the moral.responsilbility to wards them. Do tmk instead of just singing perumal sir's songs should get into the job of helping them. He can create awareness after he initiates methods like providing gloves or some hygienic conditions for the people who are actually the most important to the society than even him....who just dings and entertains. It is unfortunate. There are ngos who don't just talk like him but get into jobs. Why does he just remain in words with regards to these renaissance. Tmk, please stop just talking or singing about this. Get into action..the unfortunate thing is that such people get into blaming others for not doing when they themselves are passive.
Under TM Krishna's leadership carnatic music will soon be renamed as carnage music. Why not sing about butchers and hookers in the next concert? Hats off to the enlightened ISB audience for subjecting themselves to such intolerable cruelty and listening to his bakwas in agony.
When you listen to somebody singing just listen to the quality of the persons presentation, his knowledge of music, like that. If you are not able to enjoy his kacheri without bias or you don't understand his music, it's none of his fault. There is no such rule that you should sing only about bhakthi and God. Why should you belittle those who understand TMK.
I am so happy madras high court denied tmk award on ms subbulaksmis name.This self proclaimed reformer does not deserve it.music academy is handle of anti sanatana dmk party
WHEN ONE HAS EGO N SUPERIOR THINKING OF HIMSELF IT WILL BE HARD EVEN TO HEAR ABOUT SOCIAL CRIME'S OF THEIR OWN SOCIETY. REMEMBER HE IS NOT SINGING IN A TEMPLE CONCERT. OUR GREAT ACHARYAS TILL BHARATHI HAVE WRITTEN AGAINST OUR MEAN HABITS. EVEN IF YOU DON'T WANT TO HEAR HIM SKIP BUT DON'T DEGRADE HIS HUMAN VALUES.🙏🏻
This fellow TMK doesn’t deserve any value. He is nothing but a cheap and crook to be in limelight. Please name one change he has made to music field other than toeing the line of Anti Hindu politics
This fellow TMK doesn’t deserve any value. He is nothing but a cheap and crook to be in limelight. Please name one change he has made to music field other than toeing the line of Anti Hindu politics
I like T M krishna when he sings proper traditional lineage gifted Carnatic..Horribly out of tune a@ 4.2-4.4 mins.....Ustad amir khan / recently passed away Ustad Rashid khan would have died before being so out of tune ... vocal .artists first and foremost aim...in Sa ,re ,ga ,ma ,dha ,ni ,sa,.... bhramadarshan....in a each aakar notes....He was good earlier...why he loosing his sharpness???
Wonder why ISB of all the classical singers brought this controversial character who of late become a torch bearer of the divisive, fascist dravidian ideology. I was taken aback to see him coining a song & compose it on the most controversial, venomous, Brahmin hater EVR ( widely known as Periar)who was an athiest. EVR was known for his obnoxious, obscene & filthy oration & phrases against Hindus & Hindu deities. Aghast to see how this fellow became ardent devotee of EVR who lost no opportunity to admonish St. Thiagaraja & Sri Ram whose kritis on one & only Sri Ram are sung & popularised by stalwarts of Carnatic Music till now. Sorry ISB, you should have done thorough due diligence before calling this dubious characterm
no bodty is questioning his musicsl knowledge; but it is he who makes derogatory comments on say smt MS Suubalakshmi; i think it is not justified. Einstein never criticised Newton!
Indecent singing in public.. hope TMK will clean bathrooms in Music academy this year with like minded musicians and etc.. great service to humanity.. he should insist this idea to his deciples.. great thoughts
அதே பாடல்கள் திரும்ப திரும்ப.ஆயிரம் முறை இவர் ஜகதோதாரண இழுத்து இழுத்து பாடியாயிற்று.காம்போதி,பைரவி,முகாரி, தோடி-வேறே ராகங்களே பாட முயற்சிப்பதில்லை.சலித்துப் போய்விட்டது இவர் கச்சேரிகள்.
whats this gloves business by the mridangam player? a really weak mimicry of TS patterns. there has been a considerable drop in the quality of tanjore praveen kumars playing or is he managing the quality proportionate to the quality of tmks music... if yes, then its ok 😂
@ how did you infer that i listened to this fully? just 2-3 mins of thani is enough to understand. and pls learn to take criticism.(no need to absorb it if you dont agree, i never ask ppl to agree wid me) these people are not aloof of that.
@raghav1976007 aha what a comment by the doyen of mridangam. if only we listened to raghav1976007 all this time, carnatic music would have flourished, into the kakoos
What a performance! Sublime and mind blowing! Thank you for sharing
Great concert, as mesmerizing as always with TMK.
I don't think this is right to sing the song of Perumal. MURUGAN REG scavenger related work. It can be written as an article in news paper. Absolutely rubbish ridiculous to bring out in concerts. The image of singer also go to that level.it is very much pained to see the such a great musician to this low level of image. I hope he need some proper treatment under sychiotrist
Was here for my first carnatic concert. Loved it!
my 2 cents for two decades i was having two normal eyes (right eye was Sri Sanjay subrahmanyan) and left eye was Sri TMK. but recent days i lost my left eye sight and right eye is kind of catract since changed from CM to musician. for years i used to have the habit of standing outside of Sri TMK’s house gate just to remember the concerts that i had attended around chennai city. i dont know why supporting musicians play for him. am kind of blind!
He seems to be unconcerned and above all those who are engaged in mud slinging against him 😊
@@johnthomas7197 thomacha ithu palli pattalla... ariyathathine kurichu endina commentunnathu ... but yes u can have your opinion
@@raghav1976007രാഘവ ചട്ടങ്ങൾ പൊട്ടിച്ചു പുറത്തുവാ രാഘവ രാമ... മലയാളിയെ പറയിപ്പിക്കാൻ 😢😢😢😢😂😂😂
Excellent concert , good selection of songs had from Tagore to Dikshitar , Introducing a social Perumal Murugan in this concert creates so much negativity as I see the comments, it's a crazy world difficult to understand
Super 🎉🎉🎉🎉
To all who drops venom disguised as criticism [ not genuine productive criticisms ] ... Pls don't try to take monopoly of entire carnatic music and take pain of putting in your weak shoulders. Music in any form has no boundaries....it keeps refined and under go experiments...while some succeeds some breaks. Saw some one here berating TNKs slow paced music ....pity to his conservative ears who didn't hear pre ariyakudi era and beauty of leisurely paced music right from MDR to TMK and many others.... This stream of music will keep blooming with the contributions of TMK and many others..don't belittle his ways.....u can take only what you want from his music but don't make the mistake of writing him off ...u will fail for sure 🙏
TMK❤
The hate mail is reprehensible .Just enjoy the beautiful music !
Wonderful musician with free flow of good music.
Think about hismusic ,His 1:50:39 choice to do anything other that is not our concern
Interesting comments, looks tolerance levels are at its lowest ebb, nobody understands basic duties that one does daily, privileged society too does
TMK may be intellectually par excellence but DMK is the culprit that has fed him with poison!!! He has been using Carnatic music to hide behind- now has to face what the cosmos and devoted bhaktas of music has gifted him in his life's Karmic- platter.
🎉
Corruption is great minancice to society than that preached by vid.TMK.so he can change his lyrics corruption subject than others
You are good at this kind of kirtanas, please continue. Stop singing St. Thyagaraja, Deekshitar kirtanas. Enna sholla😢
Who are you?
ഐയറെ... എയറിൽ പോലും ന രക്ഷത്തും
@texlinesoxx nandri
I too agree that it is a pity that she people get into jobs of cleaning feacus. But it is not more dumped on them by any society. It is their own choice to do or not. Of course society has the moral.responsilbility to wards them. Do tmk instead of just singing perumal sir's songs should get into the job of helping them. He can create awareness after he initiates methods like providing gloves or some hygienic conditions for the people who are actually the most important to the society than even him....who just dings and entertains. It is unfortunate. There are ngos who don't just talk like him but get into jobs. Why does he just remain in words with regards to these renaissance. Tmk, please stop just talking or singing about this. Get into action..the unfortunate thing is that such people get into blaming others for not doing when they themselves are passive.
Under TM Krishna's leadership carnatic music will soon be renamed as carnage music. Why not sing about butchers and hookers in the next concert? Hats off to the enlightened ISB audience for subjecting themselves to such intolerable cruelty and listening to his bakwas in agony.
Vaidare, hookers&butchers are also mere humans. Not Brahmanical mocking jockers.
Sorry..
When you listen to somebody singing just listen to the quality of the persons presentation, his knowledge of music, like that. If you are not able to enjoy his kacheri without bias or you don't understand his music, it's none of his fault. There is no such rule that you should sing only about bhakthi and God. Why should you belittle those who understand TMK.
Awesome rendition of music 🎵 in Kedara gowla ragam
❤❤❤❤
I am so happy madras high court denied tmk award on ms subbulaksmis name.This self proclaimed reformer does not deserve it.music academy is handle of anti sanatana dmk party
WHEN ONE HAS EGO N SUPERIOR THINKING OF HIMSELF IT WILL BE HARD EVEN TO HEAR ABOUT SOCIAL CRIME'S OF THEIR OWN SOCIETY.
REMEMBER HE IS NOT SINGING IN A TEMPLE CONCERT.
OUR GREAT ACHARYAS TILL BHARATHI HAVE WRITTEN AGAINST OUR MEAN HABITS.
EVEN IF YOU DON'T WANT TO HEAR HIM SKIP BUT DON'T DEGRADE HIS HUMAN VALUES.🙏🏻
This fellow TMK doesn’t deserve any value. He is nothing but a cheap and crook to be in limelight. Please name one change he has made to music field other than toeing the line of Anti Hindu politics
This fellow TMK doesn’t deserve any value. He is nothing but a cheap and crook to be in limelight. Please name one change he has made to music field other than toeing the line of Anti Hindu politics
I like T M krishna when he sings proper traditional lineage gifted Carnatic..Horribly out of tune a@ 4.2-4.4 mins.....Ustad amir khan / recently passed away Ustad Rashid khan would have died before being so out of tune ... vocal .artists first and foremost aim...in Sa ,re ,ga ,ma ,dha ,ni ,sa,.... bhramadarshan....in a each aakar notes....He was good earlier...why he loosing his sharpness???
Wonder why ISB of all the classical singers brought this controversial character who of late become a torch bearer of the divisive, fascist dravidian ideology.
I was taken aback to see him coining a song & compose it on the most controversial, venomous, Brahmin hater EVR ( widely known as Periar)who was an athiest. EVR was known for his obnoxious, obscene & filthy oration & phrases against Hindus & Hindu deities.
Aghast to see how this fellow became ardent devotee of EVR who lost no opportunity to admonish St. Thiagaraja & Sri Ram whose kritis on one & only Sri Ram are sung & popularised by stalwarts of Carnatic Music till now. Sorry ISB, you should have done thorough due diligence before calling this dubious characterm
Woke vidwan
❤
Joker artist
Mental case...
no bodty is questioning his musicsl knowledge; but it is he who makes derogatory comments on say smt MS Suubalakshmi; i think it is not justified. Einstein never criticised Newton!
Indecent singing in public.. hope TMK will clean bathrooms in Music academy this year with like minded musicians and etc.. great service to humanity.. he should insist this idea to his deciples.. great thoughts
Loser!
That was for you Murali, not TMK. TMK is awesome.
@@sv4105 you can join him in cleaning the bathrooms.. he is Awsome
@@sv4105 yes he is an Awsome cleaner.. he sings in the 9.30 slot.. you could join him to serve the public..I wish him all the best
@muralik1954 thanks for your comment, we can only pray that the sewage disposal takes you along with it, you certainly belong there
Tmk abused ms subbulakshmi and now wants award...hypocrite..thank god courts put saw it straight...
The traditonal songs were good. His own composition stank and does not find a place here.Dress also matters,.
அதே பாடல்கள் திரும்ப திரும்ப.ஆயிரம் முறை இவர் ஜகதோதாரண இழுத்து இழுத்து பாடியாயிற்று.காம்போதி,பைரவி,முகாரி, தோடி-வேறே ராகங்களே பாட முயற்சிப்பதில்லை.சலித்துப் போய்விட்டது இவர் கச்சேரிகள்.
It shows how an institution like ISB can go wrong in inviting wrong people to their forum. It’s quite pathetic and shameful to see this guy at ISB.
This is the way any great institution can be broken....maybe an initiative of the super power countries to bring down the growth of india
Pity the listenes
Needs some treat ment,
whats this gloves business by the mridangam player? a really weak mimicry of TS patterns. there has been a considerable drop in the quality of tanjore praveen kumars playing or is he managing the quality proportionate to the quality of tmks music... if yes, then its ok 😂
Hi, if you dislike both TMK and Praveen Kumar's music, why spare your valuable time to listen to this?
@ how did you infer that i listened to this fully? just 2-3 mins of thani is enough to understand. and pls learn to take criticism.(no need to absorb it if you dont agree, i never ask ppl to agree wid me) these people are not aloof of that.
@raghav1976007 aha what a comment by the doyen of mridangam. if only we listened to raghav1976007 all this time, carnatic music would have flourished, into the kakoos
@@anupamakrishnan6690why do you dislike the comment?
aha, great comment by Raghavendran T, the only keeper of carnatic music