Jean Baudrillard's "Simulacra & Simulation" (Part 1)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 28 дек 2024

Комментарии • 47

  • @CausticCreations
    @CausticCreations 3 года назад +16

    04:10 the 3 types of reality
    5:29 2nd order simulacra
    6:15 the Hyper-Real
    15:15 the Disney Land Theory
    24:45 the balance of terror is the terror of balance.
    30:28 Cinema killed History
    32:13 Don't downplay the effects of JB's symbols
    36:46 The CODE
    37:58 The Paper Cut
    38:38 Money and Wealth have lost meaning, now Millionaire's just collect zeroes.

  • @denislyons
    @denislyons 2 года назад +2

    Your intelligence is a rare gift. Thank you! I started reading the book and realized I had zero reference, other than the Matrix, and I was having difficulty visualizing the material. Then I found this video and you lay out the playing field so beautifully that reading is infinitely more enjoyable.
    Subscribing to and recommending!

  • @kostaborojevic498
    @kostaborojevic498 2 года назад +3

    So psychosis is simulacre par exellance?

  • @dixztube
    @dixztube 2 года назад +1

    Just started this. Boy first 10 pages were challenging to grasp. Some of it i think I got but I’m excited to get through it

  • @sultanaljuhani1571
    @sultanaljuhani1571 6 лет назад +15

    Oh man. Thank you so much. I've been researching this subject for months and your presentation is awesome. Hope if you can work on improving the quality of the sound. You can buy a cheap recorder, I suggest "zoom h1". Please keep up the good work

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  6 лет назад +4

      Haha ya I think I figured out my sound quality problem. I won't mention what it was specifically, because it will make me appear incredibly dumb.

  • @ashamazon2262
    @ashamazon2262 2 года назад +1

    Did the Matrix sequels correct the issues of the first?

  • @sugarraywbc
    @sugarraywbc 4 года назад +1

    Superb and illuminating analysis

  • @kostaborojevic498
    @kostaborojevic498 Год назад +2

    Im definitely slowly drowning in this kind of simulation.

  • @samidogan8852
    @samidogan8852 5 лет назад +4

    Great work! Thank you!

  • @Finncelot
    @Finncelot 6 лет назад +3

    Great video, keep up the good work

  • @JAMAICADOCK
    @JAMAICADOCK 4 года назад +8

    99 out of 100 intellectuals would've rode the popularity of the Matrix. Not Baudrillard. Which showed that Baudrillard rather than being some intellectual clown, as his detractors would have it, was a man of enormous integrity. Still a Marxist at heart.
    And naturally he was right about the film. The Matrix was a crude approximation of his ideas. The gnostic Neo-Platonism was the weakest part of the trilogy and had nothing to do with S&S
    'Embarrassing no less. Pretentious and pseudo intellectual. Sure it made 100s of millions. but Baudrillard was obviously unimpressed by either money or adulation.

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  4 года назад +1

      Oh for sure.

    • @andrewryan2814
      @andrewryan2814 4 года назад +1

      The first film didnt adhere to the principles in the book, but in the sequels it is revealed that the prophecy is another form of control. The "real world" in the Matrix reacts to this false narrative as if it were true, confining them to a hyper-reality while never truly experiencing the freedom they believe they have.

    • @kellyrankin8844
      @kellyrankin8844 4 года назад +2

      Baudrillard moved beyond Marxism because he didn't agree with the focus on production

    • @JAMAICADOCK
      @JAMAICADOCK 4 года назад +1

      @@kellyrankin8844 By the end, Baudrillard had moved beyond ideology. Just seeing everything as a battle between hyper reality, and reality.
      Get the feeling Baudrillard just saw one way out of our current stasis, and that was the total destruction of
      mass media.
      It wasn't so much that Baudrillard had moved beyond Marxism, the simulacrum had moved beyond ideology. All ideology. All what was left was the simulation of ideology.

    • @kellyrankin8844
      @kellyrankin8844 4 года назад +1

      @@JAMAICADOCK I think that he did move beyond it because he felt it ultimately served the same masters and produced the same problems albeit with some improvements. If you wanted to say he was more sympathetic to Marxism than Capitalism, I'd probably agree, but I still think he ultimately rejected it. I'm happy to hear more thoughts on the subject, though.

  • @Franz_Josef_Murau
    @Franz_Josef_Murau 5 лет назад +3

    where would you recommend starting with baudrillard?

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  5 лет назад +22

      That is a tricky one. I would recommend starting with "America." Then, "The Transparency of Evil," then "The Mirror of Production," then "Seduction," then "simulacra," then "symbolic exchange," then "for a critique," then "the perfect crime," then read them all again because they make no sense lol

    • @Franz_Josef_Murau
      @Franz_Josef_Murau 5 лет назад +2

      @@TheoryPhilosophy thanks :)

  • @jaycobyart
    @jaycobyart 4 года назад +1

    Very much like that idea that objects are kept to validate their presence or survival into the current. Im going to be mulling over that for a while now.. it reminds of that idea that we replay or setup problems for ourselves that we constantly face., maybe to validate that we (as individuals) exist in some concrete way. To let go of the need of a concrete self would we also let go of the need to surround ourselves with its evidence? Thank you for sharing these incredible texts. Much aplreciation

  • @Overprotected1111
    @Overprotected1111 2 года назад +1

    15:15 I want to move to Disneyland since I was a kid- like I belong there or something

  • @nishantthakur9958
    @nishantthakur9958 4 года назад +1

    Is it me or did you remove this series from Spotify?

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  4 года назад +1

      It was never on there I don't think. I was uploading the wrong file type. Look in the description and you'll find a link to podbean for the podcast episode there :)

  • @ericthegreat7805
    @ericthegreat7805 5 лет назад +4

    Wonder what Beaudrillard would think about Trump, social media and the proliferation of Hollywood remakes, prequels and sequels 🤔 #peaksimulacra

    • @dungeonmystic
      @dungeonmystic 4 года назад +3

      Find his essay, "Conjuration of Imbeciles"

  • @ChanceTEK
    @ChanceTEK 2 года назад +2

    The Matrix brought me here…

  • @efrainhidalgo4741
    @efrainhidalgo4741 5 лет назад +6

    what

  • @yuriythebest
    @yuriythebest 5 лет назад +4

    TL:DR everything is now "pretend", fake, and just a reference to the real

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  5 лет назад +5

      I'd want to nuance that by asking you, what is the real?

    • @ericthegreat7805
      @ericthegreat7805 5 лет назад +1

      Well not so much real, but it is certainly second order referentially

    • @ericthegreat7805
      @ericthegreat7805 5 лет назад +1

      Maybe not so much real but second order knowledge?

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  5 лет назад +1

      @@opinionatedrobot2750 Indeed!

    • @TheoryPhilosophy
      @TheoryPhilosophy  5 лет назад +1

      @@ericthegreat7805 But what is that?????

  • @johnferry7778
    @johnferry7778 7 месяцев назад

    We’re there any French philosophers that didn’t smoke?

  • @JoelLopez-dh9cn
    @JoelLopez-dh9cn 2 года назад +1

    ROFL all Bible qoutes are simulated. A simulated thing pretends to be something it's not,..