Compelling ARGUMENTS against GOD'S EXISTENCE | Substantia Nigra
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 17 ноя 2022
- Compelling ARGUMENTS against GOD'S EXISTENCE | Substantia Nigra
In this video, Substantia Nigra is going to be discussing some of the Compelling ARGUMENTS against GOD'S EXISTENCE.
#GKL224 #Hindi #Urdu #GhalibKamal
Support on Patreon: / ghalibkamal
Subscribe to ScienceKahani: / sciencekahani
Scientanium: / scientanium
Infidel Ghalib(Channel for Urdu Monologues): ruclips.net/user/infidelghal...
Ghalib Kamal [Hindi/Urdu]:ruclips.net/user/ghalibkamal...
Ghalib Kamal [English]: ruclips.net/user/pakistanifr...
Ghalib Kamal Website: ghalibkamal.com/
Realistic Approach(جراتِ تحقیق) Website: www.realisticapproach.org
Telegram Channel: t.me/Ghalib_Kamal
Twitter: / theghalibkamal
Ghalib Kamal Facebook Profile: / ghalibkamalpk
Nawa e Sarosh(نوائے سروش) Facebook Page: / nawa003
Ghalib Kamal Facebook Page: ghalibkamalfreethinker
Pakistani Freethinkers on Facebook: / 1766152503419935
After listening the video I am ex Muslim atheist
"God is itself a Creature of two Parents...
1. Limited Knowledge and
2. Unlimited Fear of primitive man"
•Substantia Nigra
Ye Teri soch hai bhai
Tum to wo bhatke hue insaan ho
Jo apne baap ko dekhkar use apna baap maanne se mana kar denge
Or bechare baap ko saboot Dena padega
Or wo saboot nahi de payenge
Kyonki ye kisi saboot ko maante hi nahi
J@@mohammedirfaan4133 agar koi baap hota hai to uske maa bhi hoti hai. Tum Mulla maulvi Bata maa Kaun hai Teri.
Love to hear you, substantia nigra bhai you're always showing academic behavior very logical I'm always impressed similar way of Ghalib bhai
Substantia nigra is always amazing to listen to 🙌🏻
Ghalib bhai and substantia Nigra you guys are true legends yar .... simply speechless... 🥰🥰🥰🥰
" (خود آ)خدا ایجاد ھے انسانی محدود علم اور لامحدود ڈر کی " انسانوں نے اپنی اپنی سوچ ، معاشی ،معاشرتی مقام کی بنا پر ، اپنی ضروریات ، خواہشات کی تکمیل کیلئے " اجتماعی ارتقائی عقل" کو مختلف القاب اور خوبیوں سے نوازا ھے
And whoever realized or understood this human fear, He used it for his own worldly or political purpose by slight modification of the God and claiming to have a divine connection with him. These smart men are called prophets. 😊
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
@@abulfaij9660
because of strong indoctrination and deprivation of the capacity to reason using your own mind.
Aj bhe to Knowledge limited hay aj bhe to nahi pata k universe kyu or kesy bn gai, big bang kyu hua us se pehly kia tha...And fear bhe aj usi tarha paya jata hay insan main jesy pehly insano main paya jata tha...
Phir aj kyu khuda ko nahi manty ap ?
Agr ye waqai primitive man ki soch the, en caller k mutabiq...
@@khurramdar1423
Jis tarah science ne farishton ke concept ko debunk kar diya hai uss tarah ek din big bang ya universe ki creation ko explain kar ke God ke concept ko bhi khatam kar de gi. Waise by the way God ke concept ko maanane mein koi haraj nahi lekin God ki characteristics jo religion mein hain woh creator of universe par set hi nahi hoti.
Sab se pehle saare religion wale decide kar lein ke kis ka khuda sacha hai phir uss khuda ko non religious logon ko present kar lein. Agar logic or reasoning ke according hua to maan lena chahiye for now.
This is one of the most valuable channel on RUclips share of knowledge is splendid.
So impressed with the caller.
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Aj bhe to Knowledge limited hay aj bhe to nahi pata k universe kyu or kesy bn gai, big bang kyu hua us se pehly kia tha...And fear bhe aj usi tarha paya jata hay insan main jesy pehly insano main paya jata tha...
Phir aj kyu khuda ko nahi manty ap ?
Agr ye waqai primitive man ki soch the, en caller mutabiq
@@khurramdar1423agar pata nai hain kui bana that doesn’t mean tumaharai allah nai banaya hain have better argument substancia sir ki argument dekho apna dekho pathetic
Wohi lambi lambi bongiyan
Respected Sir good evening
Bahot gahri baten bataye sir ne
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Very impressive👏
Substantia Nigra making SOLID points here 👏👏
He always does
Most intelligent points by the person speaking to Ghalib. Please bring such people to your program, makes lot of sense
Very nice video ghalib 💓💓💓💖💖💖💖💖💖💖
Great sir , yakeen kijiye mere mind mein bhi yahi question aate thy sir ke allah exam q lyta hy us ko to sb kch pata hai
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Aj bhe to Knowledge limited hay aj bhe to nahi pata k universe kyu or kesy bn gai, big bang kyu hua us se pehly kia tha...And fear bhe aj usi tarha paya jata hay insan main jesy pehly insano main paya jata tha...
Phir aj kyu khuda ko nahi manty ap ?
Agr ye waqai primitive man ki soch the, en caller k mutabiq...
@@khurramdar1423 apko kuch samajh ni ai caller ki video ko dobara dekhe or gor kre
Kya yaar bhai aap in chutiyon ki baaton me aa gaye
Itni si baat to baccha bhi jaanta hai ki
Duniya me hi bahut si nishaniyan hain jo ye sabit karti Hain ki god hai
Apne aap ko hi dekh lo simple👌
Substantia Nigra you are truly phenomenal. I salute and admire your knowledge. I can listen to you for hours and hours
बेहद अच्छी जानकारी और अच्छा एक्सप्लेन भी किया उन्होंने।
मैं सहमत हु।
बहुत शुक्रिया शेयर करने के लिए।
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Ghalib bhai....sabsantia nigra ke discussions key puraney videos bhi upload ker dijiyega😍😍
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Bohut khub
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
शाखें रही तो फूल भी, पत्ते भी आएंगे,
ये दिन अगर बुरे है,तो अच्छे भी आएंगे
🌻💐🌻💐🌻💐🌻💐🌻💐🌻💐🌻💐
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
wah bohat khob
Very much impressed by Ghalib and sabtiania
Nobody can understand the creation without creator
Very interesting point sir
Great caller having indepth vision.
Excellent
میرے خیال سے شیطان پر بھی بات ہونی چاہیے۔ کیونکہ اگر باریک بینی سے دیکھا جائے تو۔ شیطان کا بھی ایک خاص کردار رہا ہے۔ لوسیفر۔
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
The Question. Is very very simple
How we can understand the purpose behind the creation without understanding the creator ?????
APPRECIATED.
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Aj bhe to Knowledge limited hay aj bhe to nahi pata k universe kyu or kesy bn gai, big bang kyu hua us se pehly kia tha...And fear bhe aj usi tarha paya jata hay insan main jesy pehly insano main paya jata tha...
Phir aj kyu khuda ko nahi manty ap ?
Agr ye waqai primitive man ki soch the.
@@khurramdar1423 Duniya mein Har insaan woh kaisa bhi ho Kisi na kisi chiz par Bilive karta hai koi sincedano ko Khuda manta hai koi Patthar ko patthar pe Bilive kar lete Hain log halaki dekhte Hai ki ye kuch na bol sakte hai na hi sun saktey hain usi tarah sincedano ko log maante hain aur dusri baat ye hai ki Since alag hai sincedaan alag hm since ko maante hain lekin koi sincedaan be akali chiz bta ta hai toh fir uski nhi Maante hain isliye ki hmare pas bhi dimaag hai toh Jo maanne wali chiz hai wahi maante hain since ke jariye khuda ka pta nhi chalta hai q ki khuda ne apna ptaa asaan kar rakhkha hai har jahil insaan har baccha taaki khuda ko jaan sakay yahi sabse badi baat hai
@@abulfaij9660 سائنسدانوں کو کوئی خدا نہیں مانتا چول انسان
@@abulfaij9660 how stupid this argument is
God (Abrahamic God in particular) is nothing but the attributions of a medieval king.
GOD is perfect..jahan tak yeah question hai k GOD mein koi kami thi jo us ne universe ko create Kiya tu g Haan aik kami thi aur wo yeah k GOD ko recognize karne ki..GOD chahta tha k usko pehchana jaye ..Answer this Mr ghalib
But an examiner is most of the times never dependent on person being tested. For example, a student giving 10th grade exam is giving that particular test for himself not for the teacher.
Great ghalib .
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Sankhya Darshan is the best theory till now Which has potential to explain the Existence of Universe .......even bigbang is also inspired by the Sankhya Darshan
S N salute to u ❤
Koi jawab nai mila God ko disprove krne me kiu ke God is created men and knowledged
But an examiner is most of the times never dependent on person being tested. For example, a student giving 10th grade exam is giving that particular test for himself not for the teacher. 8:13
However, I think the point is that humans have collectively devised the system of putting the students through tests and exams because humans are dependent on the capabilities of next generations. This is because ultimately the point of testing the students is to ensure that they learn the skills which they will put to use to serve other humans and society. By that token, the collective future of examiners and their next generations is dependent on average on the body of students they train and put to test. As such, the very concept of test or exam is only a human need to run this world and cannot be applicable to any god. Humans mistakenly apply their own lens to first propose a higher power and then associate human qualities to that power.
@@javedraheem7975 totally disagree, there are number of people who never use their skills for sake of humanity etc. this all concept of examiner getting any benefit is nullified immediately. Have you ever met your kindergarten teacher or is she/he even alive to get that benefit? The way they nullify the existence of God by simply claiming that having a purpose itself is claim that there is a gap in almighty. No these are just bogus statements that can only impress people who never do critical analysis. A random mixture of science, philosophy and religion like a person who is cutting meat of his own choice just to make perfect meat balls. Not a single argument made me convince on their points.
@@javedraheem7975 the concept of test or examine is well justifiable if u see it from a broader perspective. I really want to have a look on perfect example of atheist believes with implementation where a child who is being killed without any crime will get justice. How can millions of people who were being victim of those crimes be justified if there is no afterlife and test? I want justice for all those people and I have examples of alot of people who were atheists and did all the crimes because they thought it is the only world and they can do whatever they want.
Baral insan create ho chuka wa hai islie koi chara nai he khuda k bgair rehna
Galib bhai aap kabhi beerbiceps ki videos dekhi aapki hasi nahi rukegi...waha pe religious bAte aise batayenge ki kya batau
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Uske liye soch ki azadi honi zaruri hai bhai...uske liye bekhouf hona zaruri he....uske liye har chiz ki behtar samaj hona zaruri hai...hum chize apne hisab se dekhte sochte ya dhundte hai...jaise aap mazhabi ho to aap athiest ki galtiya nikalne k liye video dekho ge and vice versa...agar aap neutral ho kar bas ye socha muje sach jaanna he aur jo chize muje dikh rahi he mehsus ho rahi he uske hisab se har mazhabhi baato ko sochoge to shayad aapko humara point samje ya shayad naa bhi samje par jo dimag humare pass he usko hum apne pure potential pe bhi to use kar payenge
Limited knowledge 9f primitive man with unlimited fear
Yeh sawal tub hee paida hosakta hy jub hum khuda kee jagha par ja k faislay karin insan kee haisiat min.
Jahan tuk imtehan kee baat hy tu esko tu pora bayan Kia hy k wahan jawab dahi kee bunyad Kia hogee - aamaal. Bayshuk Allah jantay hain k hamara result Kia hoga lakin aunhon nay mjhy raastay bhi bata diyay hain. Aab main jo rasta aapaonga auska natija bhi khuda nay bata dia hy mjhy k kis tarha pichlee nations kaamyab hoin hain ya naqam.
unhone hame paida kyun kia?
You are the creature of earth planet which almost has no value before the whole univers
Our knowledge about the universe is nothing
Just a few percent knowledge about the universe we have
With this limited knowledge we cant discuss about the cteator
Kia hur cheez ko apni ankhoon sat dekh kar hee believe karo gay??
Science tu khud bhi yeh kehtee hy k jo chezin observation aur experiments k tehat nahin aateen tu aunko indirect evidence ya inference say bhi maloom keen jasaktee hain
How would you deny your existence ! Your perfect existence tells you that you are creation and you will miunh must have to accept what knowledge you are given
too much evidence is not good for us from The God Delusion
Koi jawab nai mila God ko disprove krne me kiu ke God is created men and knowledged ap jo bhi daleel dere hen ye god ko disprove nai kr sgte
Farishton k kaam zaroor batay hain aur Faristay buhat taqat wur hain.
अगर तुम जैसे नास्तिक सिर्फ अपने जिस्म की बनावट और इसके काम करने के तरीके को ही समझ लो तो तुम्हारा जिस्म ही तुम्हारे सारे जवाब दे देगा के वाक़ई ये किर्येशन सिर्फ खुदा ही कर सकता है बाकी तो तुमसे अपनी एक टूटी हुई उंगली ही ढंग से नही जुड़ पाती है लिये लिये घूमते हो उसे एक डॉक्टर से दूसरे डॉक्टर के पास।
Yahih tu hamara imtehan hy k dalail say maaningein na k israr karingy k pehlay dekhingy k phr maaningein. Yeh ilm e ghaib tu hy. Aab hur baar tu wohee nahin aaigee na. Aik waqat tuk Rasool aatay rahy. Ab Quran bhi Mehfooz hy tu phr aany kee Kia zaroorat hy. Scholars kee understanding tu insani kaam hy difference of opinion tu hota rahy ga qn k woh methodology different use kartay hain aur evidence bhi tu aekhtelaf tu hoga. It's natural
😢😢Sirf ligon ko bhatkane ka kaam hua hai or kuchh nahi.
baki sab bakwaas
Useless stream
Only time waist😢😢
And donate from what We have provided for you before death comes to one of you, and you cry, “My Lord! If only You delayed me for a short while, I would give in charity and be one of the righteous.”
Video bhi dekhi k comment kr k bhaag gye ho
He is an enigma ❤️
Aur yeh itni complex dunia Kia aap aap say wajood min aagai hy es ka koi designer nahin hy??
Main khud bhi makhlooq hun eska tu koi inkar bhi nahin karsakta
Kia kabhi aesa bhi hoa hy kisee zamanay min k kisee nay kaha hu k khuda hy hee nahin???
Shirk kee misalin tu miltee hain lakin shirk khud aik saboot hy k khuda tu mojood hy!!
Science min tu indirect evidence par bhi tu bharoosa Kia jata hy.
G han Atheists hamesha se thay
Aur hamesha Rahenge (InshaAllah)
Abu Hanifa ka Atheist k saath munaazry wala waqiya nahi suna kia aapne? Usme Abu Hanifa b yehi kehte hen k itni Complex Qayinaat Kese wujood me aagyi..?
Me puchta hun k Qayinaat complex kese hai? Aur complexity hoti kia hai?
Universal level par Afaat millions and Billions of years me aati hain (kisi solar system ka khatam hojana ya kisi galaxy ka collapse hona).
In Billions of years k beech me agar kisi Planet par life Wujood me aajati hai to ye koi heraani ki baat nhi.
Also, Oxygen, Atmosphere, Water aur food hamare liye nhi banaya gya. Bal-k ham in tamaam hi recourses ki mojudgi me Evolve kiye hen. Issi liye ham inpe dependent hai.
Ye Hargiz impossible nhi ki kisi Aur planet par life mojood ho aur wo Nitrogen par Zinda ho.
(Universe Complex hai to sirf Insaano k liye, Because we can't see things in their Entirety)
Pichlee qoumon ko tu dunia min hee azab mil jata tha tu yeh bhi aik proof hy k prophets aatay rahy
Kia proof he k unhe azaab mila? Aur most importantly Azaab Khuda ki taraf se aaya
Isse sabit kro.
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Kon sy doory pr Gaye Bhai tume
Kiu k tum brainwashed ho
Because you're lacking brain 🧠
Aj bhe to Knowledge limited hay aj bhe to nahi pata k universe kyu or kesy bn gai, big bang kyu hua us se pehly kia tha...And fear bhe aj usi tarha paya jata hay insan main jesy pehly insano main paya jata tha...
Phir aj kyi khuda ko nahi manty ap ?
Agr ye waqai primitive man ki soch the, en caller k mutabiq...
Wo god ke pass bhi nhi h
Ghalib, I will be very upfront here. "Substantia Nigra", the name sounds extreme elitist and it feels like someone who has run out of names and just too scared! He might have good intentions but He can't change the world at the least because he sounds too much like a person who wants to put an elitist view and then recede to the bed in the evening for a good nap without trouble. Sorry to say but this type of an approach can't change the world at all but an upfront approach like yours can. For any Islamic reformation or for that matter any religion, you got to be on the face with your logic, straight and simple which even the lowest common denominator can understand or at least acknowledge in some form- anger or even indifference..
This is not being 'upfront', this is Ad Hominem in its most pathetic form. Just scroll through all the other comments to see how much yours stands out for its undeserved prejudice. I would like to know how much of the world you have changed by just being a gibberish-typing keyboard warrior. Your handicap is clearly visible from your inability to comprehend an erudite discussion; better you watch content that is designed for the lowest common denominators like yourself. And all this coming from someone who after submerging in intense reflective thought so courageously came up with the name 'The Indus Valley Chief' which sounds so ''non-elitist, racially inclusive and egalitarian''.
Muhammad ka Love Da. 😂
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
@@abulfaij9660 AllA and Muhammud both are Fake.
Islaam is a cult created by a group of dirty people, to Loot and destroy other culture and religion in the name of God. 🧕🐷🧕🐷🧕🐷🧕🐷🧕
This is clearly written in so called holy books of qurran and hadeess.
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain
Yaar Tum Logo ke points hamare upar q nhi asar karte hain Jabki tum koi mor Bird waigra ki kahani bata te ho woh hm Maan lete koi tumhari since ki knowledge ko bhi accept kar lete hain lekin jab tum khuda ke bare kuch be akali mangharat baat btaate ho toh ye tumhari baat hm par q nhi asar hoti hain