Having had one of my parents die within the last few years, I feel there is one part of Applejack's personality you may not have considered/not addressed directly, Dr Wolf, so I thought I'd bring it up. While it's just guessing on my part, a lot of Applejack's pride and stubbornness probably stem from fear; specifically the fear of losing something important to her. Work all the time? Good, then you can earn enough to prevent any of your family from all that stress you had to go through. Got time for some silly frou-frou job? Then you don't know about the REAL work it takes to support your family. Have to rely on others? Then you're gonna lose the farm-Nevermind that that makes no sense in any context-you've failed to protect your family and anything bad that happens to them because of this is ALL YOUR FAULT. ...Not gonna lie, I hope Applejack gets her rainbow key by realizing how much of that delusional thinking is affecting the way she acts, as having gone through much the same kind of thing, I believe that fear controls her a lot more than it seems at first and I'd love to see her overcome it~ XD
Umm what? I suppose that could be a way for someone to deal with it, but clearly its not Applejacks. In all her episodes fear obviously doesnt govern her actions. Her love of family, her work ethic, and her integrity does. Its clear she doesnt use "delusional thinking".. shes the voice of reason of the group.
Applejack and her past really remind me of my own. I lost my mother at a young age, my father was always working just to provide for us but was just not around because of this. It fell to me to raise my three younger siblings, I had to stop being a young teen and become a man. It defines who I am even now almost two decades later. It's rather funny too because AJ and I both share a lot of the same strengths and suffer the same weaknesses. I love AJ and I feel like the writers have done one hell of a good job getting her character right.
Apple Jack will catapult to the top in the Mane 6 rankings if and when they address the loss of her parents. It will generate a lot of sympathy and it will allow her strength and will to persevere to shine. She's already in my top 3, but the instant we get to experience her loss might make her universal best pony and completely explain her less than desirable quirks of pride and her tendency to be overbearing.
It's true RD is and probably would still be my favorite pony. But seriously guys, would you not like AJ more if we get her coming of age story? Plus she does so much for the other ponies and her family, if it is explained why she is the way she is she would definitely jump away from the bottom of the poll. Maybe?
Honestly, I'd be interested in seeing something like that from her. It's just RD is irreplaceable at my top spot. AJ would be right behind her though. There's a good story to be had with her hopefully, if the writers are brave enough to tackle that subject matter. For the record I don't hate Applejack like cobb (sorry man).
I can't even describe how much AJ means to me. It was her attitude that got me into watching the show more and more. And I could feel my life was getting a whole new change at the time, and it still is to this very day. There will always be a place in my heart for this honest and hard working pony. Thank you AJ...
You're such a calm and eloquent speaker, it's really nice to listen to, especially with the well reasoned theorizing and analysis you bring to the table. You remind me of those people that do book readings for recordings, you know, the ones that they give to blind people so they can "read" the stories? I like that.
I have an older brother (quiet, doesn't voice his opinions, kinda shy), a younger sister (loud, always testing new things or hanging out with her friends), and both of my parents, thankfully. But my dad's often away and my mom sometimes needs help. I am almost like a guardian to my sister, and we're both a lot more comfortable around each other than anyone else. When it comes to her, I don't let anyone say anything bad, and when it comes to most things I like to think I'm right. I know quite a bit about how AJ feels, but not as full-on. Just weirdly close, haha, with more similarities than just family-wise. Great video :D
Douglass Whipple Wai-... Wut? Jus-... HUH?!?? Please, if you have anything you can impart on this PLEASE DO! I feel this would be a barrel of laughs to entertain myself with for a while.
Douglass Whipple LMAO!!! Please tell me their is a FanFic on this, I simply MUST have the details on such scandalous debauchery. *Grabs popcorn* I'm ready! XD ... OH! Ummm, but for the 'safety' of others, maybe send it in a PM. LOL Ahem, anyway. In all seriousness, how the frick? I mean, ya sure the timing SEEMS to accommodate for such a circumstance... but they're kinda dropping one teensy weensy ever so far-reaching detail; THIS SHOW IS AIMED AT KIDS! I mean sure, the writers have dropped a few jokes here and there but ANYTHING toward THAT end would get shot down faster then the Spruce Goose over... well, just about any country really. I mean if the show was more oriented toward, well audiences of a... I wanna say mature, I really do... but it just don't fit right. To say the least it would be a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT show altogether! Just, wow. Makes me skeptical about how far we've REALLY come when people are so ready to iterate stereotypes, kinda makes me sad. Ah well, all I know is it sounds hilarious. Stupid, Trite, superficial and lame... but like crack-pairings I find it easier just to laugh at how many hoops people jump through to MAKE it make sense then actually contemplate. If there was some evidence? Ehhh, maybe I'd think about it... AFTER I'm done laughing. Thanks for the speedy response btw. Till next time.
This was such a sweet and understanding episode for my favourite pony, you made so many people realise that her downsides don't make her bad, thanks a lot. 👏
+DRWolf001 the only problem with your theory is that it's been cannonicly stated that AppleJack's cutiemark is older than AppleBloom. meaning that by your assumption that their parents are dead either A.J.'s actually the shows sneakey attempt to tackle the topic of teen pregnancy or BigMac is A.B.'s dad and A.J. feels bad about not beiing able to tell her niece the truth.
ruste shackleferd No I would say that AJ's mom died of child birth meaning apple bloom was a baby I don't know how the dad would die but yeah that's how apple bloom was born at least
I love this video. You hit the nail right on the head with AppleJack. She happens to be my favorite character and the character I have the most in common with. My Dad passed away when I was younger, so did most of the people who raised me. I feel like that shaped my character greatly.
I did not only LIKE this theory. I loved it! Now is there one for Fluttershy and her character build or have I been blinded by all her cutsie wootsi-ness?
I don't get why the show won't just address this directly. I think it would mean a lot to kids, especially if some of them have lost a loved one themselves.
ok i did and now you make even less sense. by the logic your going by that would mean people think mentioning death is worst then actually showing it. If that is there train of thought then humanity is doomed beyond doubt
Dorian Kyles I bet if you watch any given anime where death happens, you will see it far more frequently than you will hear about it. Even in those where it's kind of a theme, like Shikabane Hime, Soul Eater, Death Note, and probably Another, it will be mentioned kind of disproportionately infrequently. I think it has something to do with a Buddhist taboo about speaking of the dead or something like that. However, when it comes to Western culture, it's usually the result of Morality Police thinking that exposing children to the idea of death in their media too soon will traumatize or worse, desensitize them. Which is kind of funny if you think about it, since the majority of Americans born in the past 50 years have probably been raised on Disney movies, where parental death is kind of a regular occurrence. In terms of MLP specifically, however, I think it might just be that the authors could feel it detracts too much from the intended light-hearted mood of the show. There is some conflict, and it is serious, but for the most part the good guys always win in the end. Something like what might've killed AJ's parents is probably one of those things you can't be good enough to overcome.
When I first started watching the show, Applejack was pretty low on my favorites list, maybe third to least favorite Mane 6. But as I continue to see her character grow, to see not only her strengths, but her flaws as well, and I, as you put it, have an increasing amount of respect for her. She's prideful, yes, but humble at the same time. She's stubborn, but she's down to earth (no pun intended) and determined. Over time, she has grown to be my favorite of the Mane 6, and second place for Best Pony (Maud). In this video, you definitely hit the nail right on the head with AJ, and you helped highlight that her flaws and struggles help shape her wisdom and strengths as the mother figure of the group.. Thanks for this video, and I can't wait to continue hearing from you in the future.
I noticed that Aplejack's and Applebloom's relationship is kind of similar to Tadashi's and Hiro's from Big Hero 6, heck I bet Hiro's tragedy became his strength to.
OH MY GOD I LOVED THAT MOVIE IT HAD SO MANY FEELS my big sister wanted to watch the movie and she was like this after the move "I didn't come here for feels :,'D"
Although Applejack may not be one of my favorite characters I have always respected her for being a such a diligent pony. I also really respect her for having such pure integrity for the core of her personality.
In the episode "Brother Hooves Social," there is so so so much more about Big Mac and I love how they make an episode all about him and his relationship with Applebloom. Also, in "Crusaders of the Lost Mark," Applejack mentions to her little sister that "If mom and dad were here.." I adore your theory and your channel for explaining so so much!!
Applejack and Apple Bloom's parents are only shown in the season 7 episode ' the Perfect Pear' flashback and also in the season 9 episode 10 flashback. You see, this episode flashback doesn't have Apple Bloom in it , but in the season 9 flashback, Apple Bloom is there along with her and Applejack's parents working together. Which means that Applejack's parents are just too busy too busy to see Applejack off in the season 1 Cutie Mark Chronicles flashback . Using Apple Bloom as proof, we can see that Applejack's parents didn't die until Apple Bloom was born. Plus, Apple Bloom is the spitting image of her dad , even though she is female.
Applejack is my favorite character for one main reason, I want to be like her. Not like exact or nothing, but she's a real cowgirl. Thanks fer the outlook, maybe it can help in a couple of things but as like applejack, stubbornness and pride will never go away. And I want to see more Big Macintosh too, hes like a uncle of mine and a man I've looked up to fer ages. Hes like the horse version of Hoss Cartwright off bonanza, played by Dan Blocker. Although he's been dead fer over 40 years now it's nice to know folks still think of his type. Thank ya fer the video, I enjoyed it.
Tragedy can define you for better or for worse. I lost my mother when I was 12, and looking back, was so dependant on her for support and condidence that I strive for independance that I desire to do things on my own, without asking others for help (even when I might need it) and unfortunately having lost that main source of confidence, strikes down my self-confidence. on the other hand having a tradegy at such a young age makes me more resilient to future ones, such as when i got incredibly ill last fall up to the point of being hospitalized and managed to stay positive during the whole ordeal, while friends and family were worried about my health. looking at my siblings, especially my sisters, they must've tried to hard to fill that void left behind, and considering I was the youngest and most vulnerable, tried to look after me, seeing as my dad was at work most days.
How have you made me like two characters after just two videos like 10x more than I already did?! Good work on your second analysis and hope to see more.
yup here parents are out of the picture, watch the episode where the Cutie Mark Crusaders get their cutie marks. Applejack says "Mom and dad would be soo proud of you"
Now that's true strength. I know this is nothing compared to losing a loved one, but I feel some pain everyday. I have found myself to regret the decisions I've made when it came to sharing my feelings toward people. I've been betrayed and wrongfully confused and that should make me hate, but I don't see myself despising anyone. I now begin to take my heartbreak, and turn it into literature that I hope to one day share with the world. I've given advice that have helped my friends when they find themselves heartbroken and they think me wise. Like Applejack, I won't let anyone down
Tyson Hills You say that, but there's only been a few times Rainbow has really expressed her element. Applejack is extremely loyal to her friends and family, and very protective of them. Rainbow Dash can be brutally honest at times. I think their elements should've been switched, but I guess that could be just me. :T
yazmen103 The thing is, it's easy for AJ to be loyal because she doesn't have to sacrifice any thing. Her whole life is pretty much her family and friends. It's easy for her. RD struggles with her loyalty a lot because she has other goals and ambitions besides her friends. She could leave them anytime she wanted to live her dream and her friends probably wouldn't think any less of her for it, but she still chooses to stay with them when it really matters. It's way more compelling that way. I'd rather watch the ponies struggle with their elements than just be perfect with them all the time.
I was your 2000th subscriber. Nice. Also, this is why AJ is my favorite of the Mane 6. I've been saying this for months but this video summarizes my thoughts perfectly. Well done sir.
You have a particular genius for finding the cutest expressions for your screencaps. I mean, it is "fish in the barrel" territory with this show, but you're doin' it right.
To Dr.Wolf: Everyone has speculated that her mother and father have died tried to save them, AppleJack was trying to save her sister from Falling off a loose bridge, however the bridge balance became compromised and wounded falling one both of them hanging on for dear. Mother and father heard them scream quickly scrambled to their rescue in doing so they both went to save but in the process they wounded both falling off the bridge after Rarity saved AppleJack from being thrown to side. Thats how the story goes, i know the story i'm sorry if i can't provide you the info on who the youtuber did it. but Their ya go dr. wolf, and honestly I love AppleJack the best thing i love about her is how she brings the spirit of never giving up and keep going even when things seem dire and desperate she seems to always triumph even their's no victory in sight.
I had a death in my family on Easter back in 2011. I have changed entirely since then. I was raised in a religious, ultra-conservative environment. I was also extremely sheltered. While she didn't exactly influence how I was raised, her death sort of influenced the chain of events that brought me to being what I am today. I am no longer what I was raised to be. In fact, I am now the exact opposite and my life is so much better because of it. I am no longer the naive little conservative sheep I was raised to be. I have grown into the progressive free-thinker I am today. I miss her immensely and I will always miss her. However, I can not deny the impact her death has left on who I have become. I guess it's a "silver lining to a grey cloud" kind of thing.
Religion is like an umbrella: It is a good thing when we need shelter, but we can't remain under it forever. It's great for a starting-,point in general morality, but all that really amounts to is just being a good person. One should never remain sheltered. Love, respect and admiration, WhiteWolfSnowy. Nuff said.
Oh that old tweet of mine. Can't remember if I've seen this video in the past or not, but was interesting to watch through regardless. As with any of us, our pasts mold who we are and taking on so much responsibility at a young age forced Applejack to mature quickly as she had to accept and adapt to the harshness and reality of adulthood. She probably didn't have much of a carefree childhood, likely working on the farm while the other foals her age played and perused their various dreams. We also know that Granny Smith was a big influence on Applejack, and tasty old mare has a good prideful stubborn streak of her own.
Now, I'm 10 years old and not too long ago I had this cat which I had gotten in 1010, (I'm talking we got him when I was 4, and we had him for like 6 years here) and he recently died. This very much effected me, for my school life is.....stressful. I always had a fluffy cat to cuddle and talk to, and he seemed to understand. We hen he passed away, I tended to stay more calm in tough situations. Instead of straight up crying, I'd take a deep breath and try to work it out as calmly as possible. It's also forced me to be a bit more independent, and I started writing in a diary, which helped me. I tend to be cuddling when I sleep now, even if I'm just cuddling air, or a pillow. I do have another cat, but she's the shy squirmy type and doesn't like the sudden wave of attention she's being given now that she's our only cat. So, I guess the death of the best cat that ever lived help at least something. My skill at keeping cool, and being a bit more independent.
Thank you for giving headway to my favorite pony that never gets enough credit. Well done as well. Also, in the cutie mark flashbaok, seeing her off is Big Mac and Granny Smith. Where's Apple Bloom? I'd say she was either too young at the time to see her off (new born sleeping etc) OR she was so troubled by her sister leaving so soon after the parent tragedy, that she couldn't do it and as such was having a break down in her room at the time of AJ's departure.
This...This is why Applejack is one of my favourite characters in the show. I know what it's like to lose a parent to death. My mother died and I was too young to understand (I was only 2 years old) and because of that I spent every waking day thinking "She'll come back. I know she will I'll just keep waiting and things will go back to normal" But then I soon realized that she was never coming back and even though it wasn't my fault I always find myself blaming me for her death. Even today. I do believe that's why I became stubborn. Or as my friends call it "Easily argumentative" Mix that with depression which No one in my circle of friends and family know about and I think you get the picture.
I had come to the same conclusion once I realized her parents really were dead; she probably left the farm because it was a painful reminder of their death. Some people respond that way to losing loved ones. Leaving for a little while was just part of her healing process. I'm starting to appreciate her character more.
I'm totally for this theory. If you've seen Ink Rose's video on AJ's backstory, it supports this video quite well. I think that Ink's video also answers a lot of questions about the whole Apple Bloom thing. Honestly, I wonder what it must be like for Apple Bloom. I'm almost positive she wouldn't remember her parents at all. Just as this video shows how Applejack feels about Apple Bloom, I think that their parents death is the main factor in Apple Bloom's admiration of Applejack. I really would like to see a video that explores Apple Bloom more (if you couldn't tell, Apple Bloom is my favorite character in MLP XD). One of my theories on the death of their parents (which would only explain their mother's death, so Ink Rose's is probably better lol) is that AJ's mom died giving birth to Apple Bloom. That would leave a lot of ways for the father to die, and I've thought of a few (The two main ones for me is a stampede (which would also work in the case of both parents dying) or suicide after the mom died). Anywho, great video! Sorry for the long rant. xD
While both my parents are still alive, I lost my grandma when I was in the sixth grade and my grandpa died a few years back. I miss them both very much and I've always loved how, despite this tragedy in her life, AJ is such an upbeat pony
i know what thats like completely, what you said there, almost perfectly describes what happened to me, and what i did because of it. oddly enough, i found that "inner strength" a couple years before mlp, but after i understood AJ's character, she has been my favourite pony ever since. like a shining example of your past will only affect you if you let it. sorry for the long wall of text, but i saw the comment and it hit close to home, so cheers for overcoming such an event (^_^)/] You Rock!
I think Applejack's strength is born in part from her acknowledging the necessity of it. People who believe that their strength is not needed, or won't even help, tend to not be strong. It's a fundamental fact of natural adaptation. Further, as I have indicated in my comments on other pony videos, I don't think the ponies, especially the most influential ones, have much control over their destinies. AJ was the second child (unless Big Mac is just big for his age, which is possible but unlikely), and yet according to her, her cutie mark is a sign that she was fated to inherit the farm (and apparently some authority over the entire Apple clan). A point which none of her family members dispute, even in jest. I believe AJ is who she is because: A. She has no choice. and B. Strength of character is required of her. Although similar to the points you raised in this video, the difference I believe applies is that the former necessitates the latter. We haven't seen much of how AJ is handling her situation but we do see how she handles stress: by trying *harder*. In fact, I think the ponies can be paired by how they react to stress (assuming they acknowledge it). Twilight and Pinky worry themselves into fits. When it comes to violent, psychotic meltdowns, I believe that these two of the 6 have the highest probability, with Twilight taking the crown (lol) because Pinky is normally extroverted and as shown in Party of One, when she loses it, she becomes a shut-in. Fluttershy and Dash deny it until it blindsides them. Must be a pegasus thing, which would tie into my 'jock/soldier' headcanon about how pegasi think. Flutters (default mode) clearly lacks the disposition, but she was still raised under the same societal pressures. Applejack and ironically enough, *Rarity* react by trying harder. This seems endearing on paper, but not so much when you can see how much it tears them up. Obviously, there are differences given the individual pony's personalities, but I think the fact those traits are paired like that says something about the characters in question, especially since each listed pair is otherwise illustrated as polar opposites of each other. Anyway, back on topic. I think, as much as she had no choice in the matter of the way she would end up living her life (and the time spent up til gaining her cutie mark was just denial of the foregone), she was also driven by her inherent compulsion to help those she felt needed her. I believe that, more than the varying comfort levels, explains why she left the city life and ran home once Rainbow unintentionally pointed the way. The reason she is happy with this inevitable destiny is because she, like the other members of the 6 (except Dash), is only really happy when making others happy, something which she doubtless felt suffered stifled opportunities in the big city.
I sometimes watch these shows when nathan watches them (i'll tell you how he got into them later) and i think you are doing a great job with your videos. You're telling me more about the character that i did not know, it's really great. You are bringing out more of the Character's Character! You are doing so good! Now to tell you about how nathan got to like it. you tolld my dad to watch a certain episode, and nathan watched with him, so now he watches it non-stop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
At a very young age, my parents got divorced, and in the chaos surrounding it all, between constantly switching between living with my father and mother, and being bullied in both locations, I became very hostile towards others, and, admittedly, while I'd started to become less and less hostile throughout high school, my bottled anger towards my past hadn't really dissipated until I'd become a Brony in late 2011 (Wow... Time really flies...), and even then, a lot remained... Earlier this year, circumstances caused me to become slightly depressed, and I began to reflect on my past; I became determined to put together the pieces of my cloudy memories of my childhood, and now, everything is clear... And now, if fifteen days, at my sister's wedding, I will see my mother for the first time in nearly ten years... I really don't know how to react... To be honest, I'm shaking due to the conflicting emotions just thinking about it as I type this... Life goes on... Your past should make you better, not bitter... In the end, I'll be a better person for facing the past head on instead of avoiding it as I've done up to this point... I hope.
like fluttershy, i relate to applejack as well. she's hardworking, will do anything for her family and friends yet she is stubborn. i can relate my oldest niece and i are just as close as applejack and applebloom are. no my sister/her mom didn't die but when my niece was younger her mom/my sister worked a lot so i helped raise my niece. even today my niece at thirteen still asks me for advice and other things. so, like applejack family is important. i am sorry that her parents died i didn't know it was at such a young age, maybe that is why she is so protective of apple bloom. still apple jack and fluttershy are the two ponies i identify with and i hope they continue to shine.
I would also love to see an episode which shows how Applejack lost her parents, and how she (and the remaining members of the Apple Family) coped with said loss. It would certainly have a great lesson.
I've been wanting to go through Dr. Wolf's archives for quite some time now and I have to say I am pleased. With the show now 4 seasons in we just don't see that many head-cannon video's. At least not in the more established parts of the fandom. It's nice to see there are still things yet to be answered in the show. It provides a lovely little spark of controversy and discussion as the fans eagerly anticipate what the actual truth may be.
My interpretation of Summer from Pokemon Ranger: Guardian Signs is actually a lot like Applejack. She lost her entire family in a devastating fire when she was seven and decided to push herself to be the best she could so she could live up to her mother's memory. She's very stubborn and hardheaded, but she has strong moral compass as well as a deep well of caring for those around her. She gives help but doesn't like to receive it but she'll do whatever it takes to make sure the job gets done.
OMG!!!! I think I know why some ponies have three items for their cutie mark and some ponies only have one. It depends on how many people you help.Like Apple jack, if she didn't return to the farm the apple farm would be ruined, she helped Granny Smith, Big Mac and Apple Bloom(even though she wasn't born yet). But Rainbow dash on the other hoof, she only helped helped herself. Wait I know what your gonna say "but she helped the entire mane six" yes that's true but she didn't know that yet.Only Twilight had 1 big star with 5 little stars around it, because she's kinda the mane character. What do you think of this theory? Please reply!
I know this is old, but things like this on such of how just one's character can make a big impact on everything. The show could even change us to become a little nicer, a little more honest, loyal, and much more in real life, to care, and to really appreciate friendship and family bonds instead of doing so when it's too late.
I've actually seen an episode that gave me the closest to an explanation as to why Big Mac is so quiet as a teenager applejack told him to shut up for once in his life and he took that to heart I guess why can't I have siblings like him
I've Allways respected apple jack as a character and this video was very well done. She is probably my second favorite character . Pinkie just has the random comedy that is my siren song
i got molested at a young age...i suffered so much that my depression was making everyone else depressed. finding pinkie i learned to have fun but i also began to cover up my pain with a smile. i also would not admit my troubles to others. insted giving a simple 'im fine' to take place of everything i was feeling. seeing applejack i strived to be more honest. this worked out greatly even when the truth hurt. .le
I like the theory you're putting forth for AJ's background. I've always found it odd that in Apple Family Reunion, Granny Smith states that's where they first met Apple Jack. If that's the case, that would make her more of an orphan that was adopted into the Apple family. That made me wonder if it's possible that the entire Apple family is an amalgamation of orphan ponies that were adopted into the Apple family at different points in time.
As you take a closer look into AJ's cutie mark story you can see what was used in MLP several times now - grieving process, from the loss of her parents no less. You are able to pinpoint so much of those together it's hardly a coincidence.
While I absolutely agree that the loss of her parents made her strong, willful and dependable, (and an awesome character), I think the latest episode "Pinkie Apple Pie" is evidence that her stubborn pride is a familial trait. This can be seen when she and Granny Smith were butting heads on who should be in charge. Not all siblings may have inherited the same traits, but even Big Mac has a moment of stubborn pride when he refuses to admit that they can't handle so much stuff on their trip.
Unfortunately, the same can't be said about me. After my parents divorced, all I did was retreat into myself even further and pitied myself deeply. I still do it to this day.
I don't believe she is faking her happiness seeing as her cutie mark seems to fit her lifestyle perfectly, or that she even has the ability to fake it, given her element of honesty. I believe that she truly finds real happiness in every aspect of her life, which would make any coping she might have gone through that much easier.
This video can relate to me because hen i was little about 2 my mum and dad had a fight and i stayed with my mum. But then thanks to that happening i am now the person i am if i stayed with my mean dad i would of not be nice, Kind, loyal and many more!
The same can be said about Solana. She was the victim of horrific abuse but she turned around and became a Pokemon Ranger so she could help others. After she faces her father down after running away, she becomes an extreme advocate for victims of domestic abuse as well as exposing the corruption of Sinnoh's elite upper class.
There's also some physical evidence to Applebloom being influenced by her sister. She wears her mane in a very similar manner to Applejack. AJ is a character, for me, that I would love to love more, and everything stated here is enough to make me love her the most, but again, it's all speculation. I want a background story in hers, more so than any other character, really digging deep into her past. Also, I noticed 'Spike at your Service' did AJ a lot of justice for her character.
I am so sick and tried of people assuming that AJ is AB mother. Hey you guys maybe there's a better explanation for this. I remember reading for some where that the apple siblings parents were seller ponies. Mr. and Mrs. Apple( who's pregnant with applebloom) travel all around Equestria to sell their apple products. They were very busy, but still maintain with their filly and colt. However that time was short, since that they have to travel a lot, to sell their products. Now to me I see the ponies as physically (flexible)ponies with human brains, so I still believe their pregnancies last between 9 and 11 months, I would say about 10 months. When AppleJack left the farm, her mother was in her 4 month of pregnancy traveling with her husband/biz partner. And even when she( Apple Jack) got back her parents was still out selling apples and apple products. Maybe that why we didn't see AB, because she was still inside her mothers womb, travel in the safety of the womb, along with both of her parents. When they got back it was time for AB to come out. After giving birth and spending time with their new daughter for a few months. A call was made for them to sell 109 apples/apple products. Hearing this the apple parents got up and left Granny Smith in charge. The apple siblings ( AB still very young about 4 months old)waited, waited, and waited to from their parents. Until of an apple relative gave them the bad news, of their parents death. Another theory is that with the new foal coming. Mr. Apple was too busy helping is wife give birth. That probably why we didn't see AB or their parents. Well why didn't we see them when she came back.? Well like I said before they were seller ponies, and they might of left before AJ came home,for the it was emergency, so they have to leave quick thinking that they will meet GS and their foals again. And GS probably didn't want AB see her sister leave, or maybe she was still too young to be outside, and by the time she got back,she got the news that they're dead(after somepony had found the bravery )to tell her. However this my theory, so feel free to disagree or agree. 1 minute ago• About the apple sibling parents. Okay it didn't say that their parents are sell ponies, but it still add flovar to the theory on the apple sibling parents. Q: Where are Applejack's parents? To put it bluntly, we just never figured it out. I just liked the feeling of them living with their Granny, but keeping the family dynamic tight and small. To be honest, I would like to simply say that they passed away somehow, but it's just it would have likely been deemed too sad for a kids' show and I don't think it would have ever been approved. There was brief discussion of them being traveling salesponies or explorers, but since we never needed the information in an episode, nothing was ever made official. So it will have to remain a mystery until someone decides to define it. fyre-flye.deviantart.com/journal/FAQ-276161988. To get links press and click open.
While we are talking about Applejacks stubborness and pride, have you ever noticed that the writers puts these aspects always in a negative way? I don't think that AJ have had a single episode where her pride and stubborness have been showed in a positive light and I think it could be a good episode where she gets to shine. I imagine a episode where Applebloom gets lost in the Everfree forest and everyone is looking for her and in the end is AJ the only one who won't stop looking for her.
Dr.wolf thank u for that video.....same thing about Me and a.j (Apple jack) r in common a lot but u make me happy bc of the videos that u make.....again thank u
I don't get why loads of ppl are like "no parents in a kids show?!?! that's a bad message for kids" no its not. it happens. parents can die, they're not invincible, even if their kids think so. telling your kids lies like "yes she does have parents they just live some where else" isn't going to help them. everybody will die some day, and it'll just be more of a shock if you try to keep them away from death when they actually experience death. like assuming that someone without parents is a bad influence and can't be around your child is NOT fair. oh and FYI, teaching your child that if they don't behave their parents will leave is not good. especially if they repeat it to other children. trust me, I know. so to all you death-hating over - protective looking-over-shoulder parents, gfy. -Wolfie P.S. I don't care if I have a foul mouth. I. really. don't.
Your mouth is only full of truth, I hate too when parents tell their kids: "if you don't behave I will tell the doctor to inject you" or "I will tell the dog to bite you (srsly??)" and then the kids develop a fear for doctos, vaccines and animals, and parents have the guts to wonder why ¬¬ I hate it so much, they're taking away their confidence like that...
This theory could also be the explanation for the other big mystery, why AJ seems to be so attached to her hat (to the point of sneaking it on during the wedding). I think that, to her, it's a symbol of that promise she made, that she would be there for the farm and family no matter what. I am in the camp that still thinks her dad probably wore a hat just like hers and gave her the first one (this gets around the fact she has more than one). She wears it as a constant reminder that she HAS to take over her parents role (you talk about AJ being AB's surrogate mother, but in a certain sense, she is her surrogate father too; she's AJ's protector as well as nurturer*) You notice she didn't have the hat when she left, and I don't think it was because it wouldn't fit her yet. Big Mac already had his horsecollar (which is probably HIS version of the hat) even though it doesn't fit him all that well yet.
My thoughts on Applejack: AJ is best poni. ^^ nuff said. seriously though, I really like her character, and how she contributes to the story. Great vid BTW ^^ subscribed!
Hmm... maybe her parents left her at a young age, and the two shooting stars in the sky in the one episode was supposed to represent her parents supposedly leaving the reunion, or possibly her parents DID die... possibly in an accident? because in the episode Somepony to Watch Over Me, Apple Bloom takes over Apple Jack's job in delivering her pies to the town, but then discovers how dangerous it can be with mixed animals trying to EAT the young filly, and even the flames shooting out of the ground at random times. Is it possible that maybe they DIED on that trip? And leaving Apple Boom at such a young age must not have effected her as much as it did Big Mac and Apple Jack, not knowing her and all... Maybe the reason Apple Jack seems to independent and reliable is having to take over raising Apple Bloom herself and help out with the farm work with Big Mac as you said. This is starting to get a little long, so the point is that Apple Jack was effected greatly, and just matter of working by herself with so many responsibilities just overcame a motherly sense that wasn't supposed to overtake her until a little later to work as hard as independently as she does.
honestly i think the idea of her leaving manehattan is just as the show depicted. she didnt fit in. not her need to fulfill responsibility. her parents death may had something to do with it. i wish the show would delve deeper into applejacks history. over all very good analysis
It doesn't really have anything to do with responsibility, but my brother really changed and matured since our cat passed away over the summer. He and I drifted apart as friends as we grew, but when the cat who had so casually wandered into our lives eighteen years ago died in my bed, he was suddenly friendlier to me than he had been in years. It was like the jerk I had come to know and love as my older brother was...gone. There was a new big brother in his place. To be honest, though, I don't miss the old brother.
Me too! Her and Big Mac cause Big Mac probably filled the fatherly role for both his sisters given Applejack's line in "Bridle Gossip": "I'M GONNA TELL BIG MACINTOSH ON YOU!"
Applejack's parent's passed on when she was about 8, Big Mac 12, Applebloom 3 month's and Granny Smith 24. Just look at Ink Rose's head-cannon back-stories, OK!?
I became a todal introver after my loss, stayed in that shell for most of my young life with only that close ring of friends, I'm in my 20's and have only started opening up to people again but even thats strained
You make a good point when you say Applejack is a good mother figure for Apple Bloom. I thought Applejack was Apple Bloom's mother at first when I saw Call of the Cutie, the first episode I watched.
Personally, if they decide to make the parents passing official, I'd really like to see an episode dedicated to this. Possibly a bonding moment for AJ and Applebloom to discuss what happened, that it's a normal part of life and have their relationship grow and strengthen from it. Although I doubt Hasbro would allow an episode like that be made or aired on The Hub. It seems the subject of death has become too taboo a topic to discuss in children's media nowadays.
I think Applejack is Applebloom's Mother! Think about! Applebloom doesn't have the the same colors as Applejack and Big Mac (who themselves have different colors), and she does not appear to yet exist when Applejack Returns from Mainhattan. and there is also the Fact that Applejack treats Applebloom more like a Daughter rather than a little sister. i Think Applejack did more than just go to Fancy parties in Mainhattan, i think she might have mixed with some rotten apples and conceived Applebloom during her stay in Mainhattan.
Ariana Csoncsik i imagine some Filly (now a stallion) from her stay in Manehattan. most likely from the typical "cool" fillies, with whom she got into bed with, because she was trying integrate her self and be accepted, and that's what the cool "grown up" fillies do. i think you can imagine the rest.
She can't be her mother because remover the episode when applejack was being to protective and she said "sorry I was being to protective LITTLE SIS....."
They need to to show a Big Mac/Apple Bloom episode. Where the moral of the episode even though you don't have a lot in common. You still love each other and are still family or friends.
Here's my theory on AJ's parents: They gave birth to Big Macintosh and then a couple of years later, gave birth to Applejack, then only weeks or maybe even days after giving birth to Applebloom, they both passed away. Maybe because of an illness or an injury or maybe their mother could have passed away because of Applebloom's birth and their father was so heartbroken by this, that he passed away soon after. Poor little Applebloom never met her own parents....
I know Hasbro won't mention the death of AppleJack's parents, but I wish they would at least mention her parents. For example "I remember when mom gave me this ____ when I was a filly" Something subtle
Hard past you had. Hope you'll find someone trustworthy. I know bad people that wants to use me for their good. But my family and friends I trust with all strength. They helped me many times.
Funny thing about AJ is that while she not be the most "Popular" pony, I feel that she's the pony that a lot of people would hang out with the most or go to the most if they needed help with something... Making her in a way the most popular pony. Make sense?
Here's something you could consider reviewing: In the Esquestria Girls movies, you'll notice that human Applejack doesn't have as much of a bond with human AppleBloom, even after finding friendship. We barely even see Human AppleBloom in the movies.
It's a movie. The plot of the Equestria Girl movies were not to focus on family bonds or problems in life, but saving the world/healing broken friendships.
someone pointed out where did Applebloom go in the magical mystery cure. this may be a clue to when Applejack parents past away. the two questions about this are Did she here about her parents death by letter and the baby? or did she leave because it was too painful? i believe the later choice. she clearly has a deep rooted foalhood trama. she is faking being happy on the farm. she hides it from her friends and family. this may also be the reason of her stubborness too.
Having had one of my parents die within the last few years, I feel there is one part of Applejack's personality you may not have considered/not addressed directly, Dr Wolf, so I thought I'd bring it up.
While it's just guessing on my part, a lot of Applejack's pride and stubbornness probably stem from fear; specifically the fear of losing something important to her.
Work all the time? Good, then you can earn enough to prevent any of your family from all that stress you had to go through.
Got time for some silly frou-frou job? Then you don't know about the REAL work it takes to support your family.
Have to rely on others? Then you're gonna lose the farm-Nevermind that that makes no sense in any context-you've failed to protect your family and anything bad that happens to them because of this is ALL YOUR FAULT.
...Not gonna lie, I hope Applejack gets her rainbow key by realizing how much of that delusional thinking is affecting the way she acts, as having gone through much the same kind of thing, I believe that fear controls her a lot more than it seems at first and I'd love to see her overcome it~ XD
Umm what? I suppose that could be a way for someone to deal with it, but clearly its not Applejacks. In all her episodes fear obviously doesnt govern her actions. Her love of family, her work ethic, and her integrity does. Its clear she doesnt use "delusional thinking".. shes the voice of reason of the group.
Applejack and her past really remind me of my own. I lost my mother at a young age, my father was always working just to provide for us but was just not around because of this. It fell to me to raise my three younger siblings, I had to stop being a young teen and become a man. It defines who I am even now almost two decades later.
It's rather funny too because AJ and I both share a lot of the same strengths and suffer the same weaknesses.
I love AJ and I feel like the writers have done one hell of a good job getting her character right.
you deserve a brohoof /)
Ultimas Dragon /)
Apple Jack will catapult to the top in the Mane 6 rankings if and when they address the loss of her parents. It will generate a lot of sympathy and it will allow her strength and will to persevere to shine. She's already in my top 3, but the instant we get to experience her loss might make her universal best pony and completely explain her less than desirable quirks of pride and her tendency to be overbearing.
RD will always be best pony. AJ can't top her no matter what she does.
Tyson Hills Same. I hate Crapplejack.
It's true RD is and probably would still be my favorite pony. But seriously guys, would you not like AJ more if we get her coming of age story? Plus she does so much for the other ponies and her family, if it is explained why she is the way she is she would definitely jump away from the bottom of the poll. Maybe?
Honestly, I'd be interested in seeing something like that from her. It's just RD is irreplaceable at my top spot. AJ would be right behind her though. There's a good story to be had with her hopefully, if the writers are brave enough to tackle that subject matter.
For the record I don't hate Applejack like cobb (sorry man).
i like aj, pinkie and rarity the most
I can't even describe how much AJ means to me. It was her attitude that got me into watching the show more and more. And I could feel my life was getting a whole new change at the time, and it still is to this very day. There will always be a place in my heart for this honest and hard working pony. Thank you AJ...
You're such a calm and eloquent speaker, it's really nice to listen to, especially with the well reasoned theorizing and analysis you bring to the table.
You remind me of those people that do book readings for recordings, you know, the ones that they give to blind people so they can "read" the stories? I like that.
I have an older brother (quiet, doesn't voice his opinions, kinda shy), a younger sister (loud, always testing new things or hanging out with her friends), and both of my parents, thankfully. But my dad's often away and my mom sometimes needs help. I am almost like a guardian to my sister, and we're both a lot more comfortable around each other than anyone else. When it comes to her, I don't let anyone say anything bad, and when it comes to most things I like to think I'm right. I know quite a bit about how AJ feels, but not as full-on. Just weirdly close, haha, with more similarities than just family-wise. Great video :D
Oh thank god, when I first clicked the link I thought it was one of those Applejack is Apple Bloom's mother fan films
Douglass Whipple Wai-... Wut? Jus-... HUH?!??
Please, if you have anything you can impart on this PLEASE DO! I feel this would be a barrel of laughs to entertain myself with for a while.
Douglass Whipple LMAO!!! Please tell me their is a FanFic on this, I simply MUST have the details on such scandalous debauchery.
*Grabs popcorn*
I'm ready! XD
... OH! Ummm, but for the 'safety' of others, maybe send it in a PM. LOL
Ahem, anyway.
In all seriousness, how the frick? I mean, ya sure the timing SEEMS to accommodate for such a circumstance... but they're kinda dropping one teensy weensy ever so far-reaching detail; THIS SHOW IS AIMED AT KIDS!
I mean sure, the writers have dropped a few jokes here and there but ANYTHING toward THAT end would get shot down faster then the Spruce Goose over... well, just about any country really.
I mean if the show was more oriented toward, well audiences of a... I wanna say mature, I really do... but it just don't fit right. To say the least it would be a COMPLETELY DIFFERENT show altogether!
Just, wow.
Makes me skeptical about how far we've REALLY come when people are so ready to iterate stereotypes, kinda makes me sad.
Ah well, all I know is it sounds hilarious. Stupid, Trite, superficial and lame... but like crack-pairings I find it easier just to laugh at how many hoops people jump through to MAKE it make sense then actually contemplate.
If there was some evidence? Ehhh, maybe I'd think about it... AFTER I'm done laughing.
Thanks for the speedy response btw.
Till next time.
rainbowshine06
www.fimfiction.net/story/35931/4/the-truth/1
oh sorry wrong person
ChaosKaiser www.fimfiction.net/story/35931/4/the-truth/1
@@Kimshu6 That makes much less sense than the possibility of Sweetie Belle being the daughter (of Rarity).
This was such a sweet and understanding episode for my favourite pony, you made so many people realise that her downsides don't make her bad, thanks a lot. 👏
+Stuart Sarson Glad to be of service.
+DRWolf001 the only problem with your theory is that it's been cannonicly stated that AppleJack's cutiemark is older than AppleBloom. meaning that by your assumption that their parents are dead either A.J.'s actually the shows sneakey attempt to tackle the topic of teen pregnancy or BigMac is A.B.'s dad and A.J. feels bad about not beiing able to tell her niece the truth.
ruste shackleferd No shit it's part of her strength; I've got a whole frickin' case file on my phone studying that strength.
ruste shackleferd No I would say that AJ's mom died of child birth meaning apple bloom was a baby I don't know how the dad would die but yeah that's how apple bloom was born at least
@@DRWolf001 how are your doing Dr wolf
I love this video. You hit the nail right on the head with AppleJack. She happens to be my favorite character and the character I have the most in common with. My Dad passed away when I was younger, so did most of the people who raised me. I feel like that shaped my character greatly.
Glad to hear that you can respect Applejack because you relate to her. She really is an inspiring character.
@@DRWolf001 so glad to meet you Dr wolf
I did not only LIKE this theory. I loved it! Now is there one for Fluttershy and her character build or have I been blinded by all her cutsie wootsi-ness?
I don't get why the show won't just address this directly. I think it would mean a lot to kids, especially if some of them have lost a loved one themselves.
Amelia Bee Cartoon censorship. Death is also mentioned very rarely even in anime, despite it happening quite frequently there.
Dairo512 BULL! sorry but anime is japanese animation and i don't know what you watch but in anime people die, people die A LOT.
Dorian Kyles You might want to reread my statement.
ok i did and now you make even less sense. by the logic your going by that would mean people think mentioning death is worst then actually showing it. If that is there train of thought then humanity is doomed beyond doubt
Dorian Kyles I bet if you watch any given anime where death happens, you will see it far more frequently than you will hear about it. Even in those where it's kind of a theme, like Shikabane Hime, Soul Eater, Death Note, and probably Another, it will be mentioned kind of disproportionately infrequently. I think it has something to do with a Buddhist taboo about speaking of the dead or something like that.
However, when it comes to Western culture, it's usually the result of Morality Police thinking that exposing children to the idea of death in their media too soon will traumatize or worse, desensitize them. Which is kind of funny if you think about it, since the majority of Americans born in the past 50 years have probably been raised on Disney movies, where parental death is kind of a regular occurrence.
In terms of MLP specifically, however, I think it might just be that the authors could feel it detracts too much from the intended light-hearted mood of the show. There is some conflict, and it is serious, but for the most part the good guys always win in the end. Something like what might've killed AJ's parents is probably one of those things you can't be good enough to overcome.
When I first started watching the show, Applejack was pretty low on my favorites list, maybe third to least favorite Mane 6. But as I continue to see her character grow, to see not only her strengths, but her flaws as well, and I, as you put it, have an increasing amount of respect for her. She's prideful, yes, but humble at the same time. She's stubborn, but she's down to earth (no pun intended) and determined. Over time, she has grown to be my favorite of the Mane 6, and second place for Best Pony (Maud). In this video, you definitely hit the nail right on the head with AJ, and you helped highlight that her flaws and struggles help shape her wisdom and strengths as the mother figure of the group.. Thanks for this video, and I can't wait to continue hearing from you in the future.
I noticed that Aplejack's and Applebloom's relationship is kind of similar to Tadashi's and Hiro's from Big Hero 6, heck I bet Hiro's tragedy became his strength to.
OH MY GOD I LOVED THAT MOVIE IT HAD SO MANY FEELS my big sister wanted to watch the movie and she was like this after the move "I didn't come here for feels :,'D"
Although Applejack may not be one of my favorite characters I have always respected her for being a such a diligent pony. I also really respect her for having such pure integrity for the core of her personality.
In the episode "Brother Hooves Social," there is so so so much more about Big Mac and I love how they make an episode all about him and his relationship with Applebloom. Also, in "Crusaders of the Lost Mark," Applejack mentions to her little sister that "If mom and dad were here.." I adore your theory and your channel for explaining so so much!!
You're making me love all the characters even more
Applejack and Apple Bloom's parents are only shown in the season 7 episode ' the Perfect Pear' flashback and also in the season 9 episode 10 flashback. You see, this episode flashback doesn't have Apple Bloom in it , but in the season 9 flashback, Apple Bloom is there along with her and Applejack's parents working together. Which means that Applejack's parents are just too busy too busy to see Applejack off in the season 1 Cutie Mark Chronicles flashback . Using Apple Bloom as proof, we can see that Applejack's parents didn't die until Apple Bloom was born. Plus, Apple Bloom is the spitting image of her dad , even though she is female.
finally! some pony talking about AJ without bashing on her for literally not being any other character! thank you doc.
Applejack is my favorite character for one main reason, I want to be like her. Not like exact or nothing, but she's a real cowgirl. Thanks fer the outlook, maybe it can help in a couple of things but as like applejack, stubbornness and pride will never go away. And I want to see more Big Macintosh too, hes like a uncle of mine and a man I've looked up to fer ages. Hes like the horse version of Hoss Cartwright off bonanza, played by Dan Blocker. Although he's been dead fer over 40 years now it's nice to know folks still think of his type. Thank ya fer the video, I enjoyed it.
Tragedy can define you for better or for worse. I lost my mother when I was 12, and looking back, was so dependant on her for support and condidence that I strive for independance that I desire to do things on my own, without asking others for help (even when I might need it) and unfortunately having lost that main source of confidence, strikes down my self-confidence. on the other hand having a tradegy at such a young age makes me more resilient to future ones, such as when i got incredibly ill last fall up to the point of being hospitalized and managed to stay positive during the whole ordeal, while friends and family were worried about my health. looking at my siblings, especially my sisters, they must've tried to hard to fill that void left behind, and considering I was the youngest and most vulnerable, tried to look after me, seeing as my dad was at work most days.
4:42 is the cutest thing ever
5:16 woah applejack... woah
How have you made me like two characters after just two videos like 10x more than I already did?! Good work on your second analysis and hope to see more.
yup here parents are out of the picture, watch the episode where the Cutie Mark Crusaders get their cutie marks. Applejack says "Mom and dad would be soo proud of you"
+Kimi Cat Gamer I watched ink rose
+Kimi Cat Gamer yes, I know. plus I got the inside scoop from the creator of MLP
+Kimi Cat Gamer Eyup!
+Kimi Cat Gamer What? Don't believe me?
Well, she said " aw sugarcube. If mom and dad were here, they'd be so proud.
Now that's true strength. I know this is nothing compared to losing a loved one, but I feel some pain everyday. I have found myself to regret the decisions I've made when it came to sharing my feelings toward people. I've been betrayed and wrongfully confused and that should make me hate, but I don't see myself despising anyone. I now begin to take my heartbreak, and turn it into literature that I hope to one day share with the world. I've given advice that have helped my friends when they find themselves heartbroken and they think me wise. Like Applejack, I won't let anyone down
*Cries a million tears after "the perfect pear"
Yet another reason why Apple Jack's element should be loyalty.
RD deserves it more.
Tyson Hills dude we get it. Rainbow Dash is your favorite.
Tyson Hills You say that, but there's only been a few times Rainbow has really expressed her element. Applejack is extremely loyal to her friends and family, and very protective of them. Rainbow Dash can be brutally honest at times. I think their elements should've been switched, but I guess that could be just me. :T
yazmen103 The thing is, it's easy for AJ to be loyal because she doesn't have to sacrifice any thing. Her whole life is pretty much her family and friends. It's easy for her. RD struggles with her loyalty a lot because she has other goals and ambitions besides her friends. She could leave them anytime she wanted to live her dream and her friends probably wouldn't think any less of her for it, but she still chooses to stay with them when it really matters. It's way more compelling that way. I'd rather watch the ponies struggle with their elements than just be perfect with them all the time.
Very true aj is loyal to her friends family and her country
And that is why applejack is my favorite pony
***** you and me both
***** I think it's hilarious.
I was your 2000th subscriber. Nice.
Also, this is why AJ is my favorite of the Mane 6. I've been saying this for months but this video summarizes my thoughts perfectly. Well done sir.
You have a particular genius for finding the cutest expressions for your screencaps.
I mean, it is "fish in the barrel" territory with this show, but you're doin' it right.
To Dr.Wolf: Everyone has speculated that her mother and father have died tried to save them, AppleJack was trying to save her sister from Falling off a loose bridge, however the bridge balance became compromised and wounded falling one both of them hanging on for dear. Mother and father heard them scream quickly scrambled to their rescue in doing so they both went to save but in the process they wounded both falling off the bridge after Rarity saved AppleJack from being thrown to side. Thats how the story goes, i know the story i'm sorry if i can't provide you the info on who the youtuber did it. but Their ya go dr. wolf, and honestly I love AppleJack the best thing i love about her is how she brings the spirit of never giving up and keep going even when things seem dire and desperate she seems to always triumph even their's no victory in sight.
My sister's death made me who I am today
I had a death in my family on Easter back in 2011. I have changed entirely since then. I was raised in a religious, ultra-conservative environment. I was also extremely sheltered. While she didn't exactly influence how I was raised, her death sort of influenced the chain of events that brought me to being what I am today. I am no longer what I was raised to be. In fact, I am now the exact opposite and my life is so much better because of it. I am no longer the naive little conservative sheep I was raised to be. I have grown into the progressive free-thinker I am today. I miss her immensely and I will always miss her. However, I can not deny the impact her death has left on who I have become. I guess it's a "silver lining to a grey cloud" kind of thing.
Religion is like an umbrella: It is a good thing when we need shelter, but we can't remain under it forever. It's great for a starting-,point in general morality, but all that really amounts to is just being a good person. One should never remain sheltered. Love, respect and admiration, WhiteWolfSnowy. Nuff said.
Oh that old tweet of mine. Can't remember if I've seen this video in the past or not, but was interesting to watch through regardless.
As with any of us, our pasts mold who we are and taking on so much responsibility at a young age forced Applejack to mature quickly as she had to accept and adapt to the harshness and reality of adulthood. She probably didn't have much of a carefree childhood, likely working on the farm while the other foals her age played and perused their various dreams. We also know that Granny Smith was a big influence on Applejack, and tasty old mare has a good prideful stubborn streak of her own.
Now, I'm 10 years old and not too long ago I had this cat which I had gotten in 1010, (I'm talking we got him when I was 4, and we had him for like 6 years here) and he recently died. This very much effected me, for my school life is.....stressful. I always had a fluffy cat to cuddle and talk to, and he seemed to understand. We hen he passed away, I tended to stay more calm in tough situations. Instead of straight up crying, I'd take a deep breath and try to work it out as calmly as possible. It's also forced me to be a bit more independent, and I started writing in a diary, which helped me. I tend to be cuddling when I sleep now, even if I'm just cuddling air, or a pillow. I do have another cat, but she's the shy squirmy type and doesn't like the sudden wave of attention she's being given now that she's our only cat.
So, I guess the death of the best cat that ever lived help at least something. My skill at keeping cool, and being a bit more independent.
Thank you for giving headway to my favorite pony that never gets enough credit. Well done as well.
Also, in the cutie mark flashbaok, seeing her off is Big Mac and Granny Smith. Where's Apple Bloom? I'd say she was either too young at the time to see her off (new born sleeping etc) OR she was so troubled by her sister leaving so soon after the parent tragedy, that she couldn't do it and as such was having a break down in her room at the time of AJ's departure.
Good theory.
This...This is why Applejack is one of my favourite characters in the show. I know what it's like to lose a parent to death. My mother died and I was too young to understand (I was only 2 years old) and because of that I spent every waking day thinking "She'll come back. I know she will I'll just keep waiting and things will go back to normal" But then I soon realized that she was never coming back and even though it wasn't my fault I always find myself blaming me for her death. Even today.
I do believe that's why I became stubborn. Or as my friends call it "Easily argumentative" Mix that with depression which No one in my circle of friends and family know about and I think you get the picture.
I had come to the same conclusion once I realized her parents really were dead; she probably left the farm because it was a painful reminder of their death. Some people respond that way to losing loved ones. Leaving for a little while was just part of her healing process.
I'm starting to appreciate her character more.
I'm totally for this theory. If you've seen Ink Rose's video on AJ's backstory, it supports this video quite well. I think that Ink's video also answers a lot of questions about the whole Apple Bloom thing. Honestly, I wonder what it must be like for Apple Bloom. I'm almost positive she wouldn't remember her parents at all. Just as this video shows how Applejack feels about Apple Bloom, I think that their parents death is the main factor in Apple Bloom's admiration of Applejack. I really would like to see a video that explores Apple Bloom more (if you couldn't tell, Apple Bloom is my favorite character in MLP XD). One of my theories on the death of their parents (which would only explain their mother's death, so Ink Rose's is probably better lol) is that AJ's mom died giving birth to Apple Bloom. That would leave a lot of ways for the father to die, and I've thought of a few (The two main ones for me is a stampede (which would also work in the case of both parents dying) or suicide after the mom died). Anywho, great video! Sorry for the long rant. xD
While both my parents are still alive, I lost my grandma when I was in the sixth grade and my grandpa died a few years back. I miss them both very much and I've always loved how, despite this tragedy in her life, AJ is such an upbeat pony
i know what thats like completely, what you said there, almost perfectly describes what happened to me, and what i did because of it. oddly enough, i found that "inner strength" a couple years before mlp, but after i understood AJ's character, she has been my favourite pony ever since. like a shining example of your past will only affect you if you let it. sorry for the long wall of text, but i saw the comment and it hit close to home, so cheers for overcoming such an event (^_^)/] You Rock!
I think Applejack's strength is born in part from her acknowledging the necessity of it. People who believe that their strength is not needed, or won't even help, tend to not be strong. It's a fundamental fact of natural adaptation. Further, as I have indicated in my comments on other pony videos, I don't think the ponies, especially the most influential ones, have much control over their destinies. AJ was the second child (unless Big Mac is just big for his age, which is possible but unlikely), and yet according to her, her cutie mark is a sign that she was fated to inherit the farm (and apparently some authority over the entire Apple clan). A point which none of her family members dispute, even in jest. I believe AJ is who she is because:
A. She has no choice.
and
B. Strength of character is required of her.
Although similar to the points you raised in this video, the difference I believe applies is that the former necessitates the latter. We haven't seen much of how AJ is handling her situation but we do see how she handles stress: by trying *harder*. In fact, I think the ponies can be paired by how they react to stress (assuming they acknowledge it).
Twilight and Pinky worry themselves into fits. When it comes to violent, psychotic meltdowns, I believe that these two of the 6 have the highest probability, with Twilight taking the crown (lol) because Pinky is normally extroverted and as shown in Party of One, when she loses it, she becomes a shut-in.
Fluttershy and Dash deny it until it blindsides them. Must be a pegasus thing, which would tie into my 'jock/soldier' headcanon about how pegasi think. Flutters (default mode) clearly lacks the disposition, but she was still raised under the same societal pressures.
Applejack and ironically enough, *Rarity* react by trying harder. This seems endearing on paper, but not so much when you can see how much it tears them up.
Obviously, there are differences given the individual pony's personalities, but I think the fact those traits are paired like that says something about the characters in question, especially since each listed pair is otherwise illustrated as polar opposites of each other.
Anyway, back on topic. I think, as much as she had no choice in the matter of the way she would end up living her life (and the time spent up til gaining her cutie mark was just denial of the foregone), she was also driven by her inherent compulsion to help those she felt needed her. I believe that, more than the varying comfort levels, explains why she left the city life and ran home once Rainbow unintentionally pointed the way. The reason she is happy with this inevitable destiny is because she, like the other members of the 6 (except Dash), is only really happy when making others happy, something which she doubtless felt suffered stifled opportunities in the big city.
she moved to Manhattan with her aunt and uncle orange because she wanted them to be like parents to her.
I sometimes watch these shows when nathan watches them (i'll tell you how he got into them later) and i think you are doing a great job with your videos. You're telling me more about the character that i did not know, it's really great. You are bringing out more of the Character's Character! You are doing so good! Now to tell you about how nathan got to like it. you tolld my dad to watch a certain episode, and nathan watched with him, so now he watches it non-stop!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I hope that there will be an episode were we will learn about applejacks parents and why she has such a close bond with applebloom
I knew AJ was my favorite pony and before I didn't know why. Thank you for making me fully realize this
At a very young age, my parents got divorced, and in the chaos surrounding it all, between constantly switching between living with my father and mother, and being bullied in both locations, I became very hostile towards others, and, admittedly, while I'd started to become less and less hostile throughout high school, my bottled anger towards my past hadn't really dissipated until I'd become a Brony in late 2011 (Wow... Time really flies...), and even then, a lot remained... Earlier this year, circumstances caused me to become slightly depressed, and I began to reflect on my past; I became determined to put together the pieces of my cloudy memories of my childhood, and now, everything is clear... And now, if fifteen days, at my sister's wedding, I will see my mother for the first time in nearly ten years... I really don't know how to react... To be honest, I'm shaking due to the conflicting emotions just thinking about it as I type this... Life goes on... Your past should make you better, not bitter... In the end, I'll be a better person for facing the past head on instead of avoiding it as I've done up to this point... I hope.
I know that feel bro /)
like fluttershy, i relate to applejack as well. she's hardworking, will do anything for her family and friends yet she is stubborn. i can relate my oldest niece and i are just as close as applejack and applebloom are. no my sister/her mom didn't die but when my niece was younger her mom/my sister worked a lot so i helped raise my niece. even today my niece at thirteen still asks me for advice and other things. so, like applejack family is important. i am sorry that her parents died i didn't know it was at such a young age, maybe that is why she is so protective of apple bloom. still apple jack and fluttershy are the two ponies i identify with and i hope they continue to shine.
I would also love to see an episode which shows how Applejack lost her parents, and how she (and the remaining members of the Apple Family) coped with said loss. It would certainly have a great lesson.
Thanks for making the show morbid. :P
I've been wanting to go through Dr. Wolf's archives for quite some time now and I have to say I am pleased. With the show now 4 seasons in we just don't see that many head-cannon video's. At least not in the more established parts of the fandom. It's nice to see there are still things yet to be answered in the show. It provides a lovely little spark of controversy and discussion as the fans eagerly anticipate what the actual truth may be.
My interpretation of Summer from Pokemon Ranger: Guardian Signs is actually a lot like Applejack. She lost her entire family in a devastating fire when she was seven and decided to push herself to be the best she could so she could live up to her mother's memory. She's very stubborn and hardheaded, but she has strong moral compass as well as a deep well of caring for those around her. She gives help but doesn't like to receive it but she'll do whatever it takes to make sure the job gets done.
OMG!!!! I think I know why some ponies have three items for their cutie mark and some ponies only have one. It depends on how many people you help.Like Apple jack, if she didn't return to the farm the apple farm would be ruined, she helped Granny Smith, Big Mac and Apple Bloom(even though she wasn't born yet). But Rainbow dash on the other hoof, she only helped helped herself. Wait I know what your gonna say "but she helped the entire mane six" yes that's true but she didn't know that yet.Only Twilight had 1 big star with 5 little stars around it, because she's kinda the mane character. What do you think of this theory? Please reply!
Gravity Grace
Fluttershy?
I know this is old, but things like this on such of how just one's character can make a big impact on everything. The show could even change us to become a little nicer, a little more honest, loyal, and much more in real life, to care, and to really appreciate friendship and family bonds instead of doing so when it's too late.
I've actually seen an episode that gave me the closest to an explanation as to why Big Mac is so quiet as a teenager applejack told him to shut up for once in his life and he took that to heart I guess why can't I have siblings like him
I've Allways respected apple jack as a character and this video was very well done. She is probably my second favorite character . Pinkie just has the random comedy that is my siren song
i got molested at a young age...i suffered so much that my depression was making everyone else depressed. finding pinkie i learned to have fun but i also began to cover up my pain with a smile. i also would not admit my troubles to others. insted giving a simple 'im fine' to take place of everything i was feeling. seeing applejack i strived to be more honest. this worked out greatly even when the truth hurt. .le
I like the theory you're putting forth for AJ's background. I've always found it odd that in Apple Family Reunion, Granny Smith states that's where they first met Apple Jack. If that's the case, that would make her more of an orphan that was adopted into the Apple family. That made me wonder if it's possible that the entire Apple family is an amalgamation of orphan ponies that were adopted into the Apple family at different points in time.
I feel like you are a very under-rated youtuber. How do you not have more views on videos?
As you take a closer look into AJ's cutie mark story you can see what was used in MLP several times now - grieving process, from the loss of her parents no less. You are able to pinpoint so much of those together it's hardly a coincidence.
While I absolutely agree that the loss of her parents made her strong, willful and dependable, (and an awesome character), I think the latest episode "Pinkie Apple Pie" is evidence that her stubborn pride is a familial trait. This can be seen when she and Granny Smith were butting heads on who should be in charge. Not all siblings may have inherited the same traits, but even Big Mac has a moment of stubborn pride when he refuses to admit that they can't handle so much stuff on their trip.
Applejack is by far the best pony
Unfortunately, the same can't be said about me. After my parents divorced, all I did was retreat into myself even further and pitied myself deeply. I still do it to this day.
I don't believe she is faking her happiness seeing as her cutie mark seems to fit her lifestyle perfectly, or that she even has the ability to fake it, given her element of honesty. I believe that she truly finds real happiness in every aspect of her life, which would make any coping she might have gone through that much easier.
This video can relate to me because hen i was little about 2 my mum and dad had a fight and i stayed with my mum. But then thanks to that happening i am now the person i am if i stayed with my mean dad i would of not be nice, Kind, loyal and many more!
The same can be said about Solana. She was the victim of horrific abuse but she turned around and became a Pokemon Ranger so she could help others. After she faces her father down after running away, she becomes an extreme advocate for victims of domestic abuse as well as exposing the corruption of Sinnoh's elite upper class.
There's also some physical evidence to Applebloom being influenced by her sister. She wears her mane in a very similar manner to Applejack. AJ is a character, for me, that I would love to love more, and everything stated here is enough to make me love her the most, but again, it's all speculation. I want a background story in hers, more so than any other character, really digging deep into her past. Also, I noticed 'Spike at your Service' did AJ a lot of justice for her character.
I am so sick and tried of people assuming that AJ is AB mother. Hey you guys maybe there's a better explanation for this. I remember reading for some where that the apple siblings parents were seller ponies. Mr. and Mrs. Apple( who's pregnant with applebloom) travel all around Equestria to sell their apple products. They were very busy, but still maintain with their filly and colt. However that time was short, since that they have to travel a lot, to sell their products. Now to me I see the ponies as physically (flexible)ponies with human brains, so I still believe their pregnancies last between 9 and 11 months, I would say about 10 months. When AppleJack left the farm, her mother was in her 4 month of pregnancy traveling with her husband/biz partner. And even when she( Apple Jack) got back her parents was still out selling apples and apple products. Maybe that why we didn't see AB, because she was still inside her mothers womb, travel in the safety of the womb, along with both of her parents. When they got back it was time for AB to come out. After giving birth and spending time with their new daughter for a few months. A call was made for them to sell 109 apples/apple products. Hearing this the apple parents got up and left Granny Smith in charge. The apple siblings ( AB still very young about 4 months old)waited, waited, and waited to from their parents. Until of an apple relative gave them the bad news, of their parents death. Another theory is that with the new foal coming. Mr. Apple was too busy helping is wife give birth. That probably why we didn't see AB or their parents. Well why didn't we see them when she came back.? Well like I said before they were seller ponies, and they might of left before AJ came home,for the it was emergency, so they have to leave quick thinking that they will meet GS and their foals again. And GS probably didn't want AB see her sister leave, or maybe she was still too young to be outside, and by the time she got back,she got the news that they're dead(after somepony had found the bravery )to tell her. However this my theory, so feel free to disagree or agree.
1 minute ago•
About the apple sibling parents. Okay it didn't say that their parents are sell ponies, but it still add flovar to the theory on the apple sibling parents.
Q: Where are Applejack's parents? To put it bluntly, we just never figured it out. I just liked the feeling of them living with their Granny, but keeping the family dynamic tight and small. To be honest, I would like to simply say that they passed away somehow, but it's just it would have likely been deemed too sad for a kids' show and I don't think it would have ever been approved. There was brief discussion of them being traveling salesponies or explorers, but since we never needed the information in an episode, nothing was ever made official. So it will have to remain a mystery until someone decides to define it. fyre-flye.deviantart.com/journal/FAQ-276161988. To get links press and click open.
I always felt like Applejack should've been the element of loyalty.
While we are talking about Applejacks stubborness and pride, have you ever noticed that the writers puts these aspects always in a negative way? I don't think that AJ have had a single episode where her pride and stubborness have been showed in a positive light and I think it could be a good episode where she gets to shine. I imagine a episode where Applebloom gets lost in the Everfree forest and everyone is looking for her and in the end is AJ the only one who won't stop looking for her.
Applejack is my favorite pony:)
Dr.wolf thank u for that video.....same thing about Me and a.j (Apple jack) r in common a lot but u make me happy bc of the videos that u make.....again thank u
I don't get why loads of ppl are like "no parents in a kids show?!?! that's a bad message for kids" no its not. it happens. parents can die, they're not invincible, even if their kids think so. telling your kids lies like "yes she does have parents they just live some where else" isn't going to help them. everybody will die some day, and it'll just be more of a shock if you try to keep them away from death when they actually experience death. like assuming that someone without parents is a bad influence and can't be around your child is NOT fair. oh and FYI, teaching your child that if they don't behave their parents will leave is not good. especially if they repeat it to other children. trust me, I know. so to all you death-hating over - protective looking-over-shoulder parents, gfy.
-Wolfie
P.S. I don't care if I have a foul mouth. I. really. don't.
Your mouth is only full of truth, I hate too when parents tell their kids: "if you don't behave I will tell the doctor to inject you" or "I will tell the dog to bite you (srsly??)" and then the kids develop a fear for doctos, vaccines and animals, and parents have the guts to wonder why ¬¬ I hate it so much, they're taking away their confidence like that...
This theory could also be the explanation for the other big mystery, why AJ seems to be so attached to her hat (to the point of sneaking it on during the wedding). I think that, to her, it's a symbol of that promise she made, that she would be there for the farm and family no matter what. I am in the camp that still thinks her dad probably wore a hat just like hers and gave her the first one (this gets around the fact she has more than one). She wears it as a constant reminder that she HAS to take over her parents role (you talk about AJ being AB's surrogate mother, but in a certain sense, she is her surrogate father too; she's AJ's protector as well as nurturer*) You notice she didn't have the hat when she left, and I don't think it was because it wouldn't fit her yet. Big Mac already had his horsecollar (which is probably HIS version of the hat) even though it doesn't fit him all that well yet.
This is really cool! I really do love your explanations of A.J.
My thoughts on Applejack: AJ is best poni. ^^ nuff said.
seriously though, I really like her character, and how she contributes to the story.
Great vid BTW ^^ subscribed!
Hmm... maybe her parents left her at a young age, and the two shooting stars in the sky in the one episode was supposed to represent her parents supposedly leaving the reunion, or possibly her parents DID die... possibly in an accident? because in the episode Somepony to Watch Over Me, Apple Bloom takes over Apple Jack's job in delivering her pies to the town, but then discovers how dangerous it can be with mixed animals trying to EAT the young filly, and even the flames shooting out of the ground at random times. Is it possible that maybe they DIED on that trip? And leaving Apple Boom at such a young age must not have effected her as much as it did Big Mac and Apple Jack, not knowing her and all... Maybe the reason Apple Jack seems to independent and reliable is having to take over raising Apple Bloom herself and help out with the farm work with Big Mac as you said. This is starting to get a little long, so the point is that Apple Jack was effected greatly, and just matter of working by herself with so many responsibilities just overcame a motherly sense that wasn't supposed to overtake her until a little later to work as hard as independently as she does.
honestly i think the idea of her leaving manehattan is just as the show depicted. she didnt fit in. not her need to fulfill responsibility. her parents death may had something to do with it. i wish the show would delve deeper into applejacks history. over all very good analysis
It doesn't really have anything to do with responsibility, but my brother really changed and matured since our cat passed away over the summer. He and I drifted apart as friends as we grew, but when the cat who had so casually wandered into our lives eighteen years ago died in my bed, he was suddenly friendlier to me than he had been in years. It was like the jerk I had come to know and love as my older brother was...gone. There was a new big brother in his place. To be honest, though, I don't miss the old brother.
Me too! Her and Big Mac cause Big Mac probably filled the fatherly role for both his sisters given Applejack's line in "Bridle Gossip": "I'M GONNA TELL BIG MACINTOSH ON YOU!"
The Apple Bloom thing also might help with ages. If Bloom is 7-10 now and Aj was 7-10 in the flashback, then that would make Aj between 14-20 now.
Applejack's parent's passed on when she was about 8, Big Mac 12, Applebloom 3 month's and Granny Smith 24. Just look at Ink Rose's head-cannon back-stories, OK!?
I became a todal introver after my loss, stayed in that shell for most of my young life with only that close ring of friends, I'm in my 20's and have only started opening up to people again but even thats strained
You make a good point when you say Applejack is a good mother figure for Apple Bloom. I thought Applejack was Apple Bloom's mother at first when I saw Call of the Cutie, the first episode I watched.
Personally, if they decide to make the parents passing official, I'd really like to see an episode dedicated to this. Possibly a bonding moment for AJ and Applebloom to discuss what happened, that it's a normal part of life and have their relationship grow and strengthen from it. Although I doubt Hasbro would allow an episode like that be made or aired on The Hub. It seems the subject of death has become too taboo a topic to discuss in children's media nowadays.
I think Applejack is Applebloom's Mother! Think about! Applebloom doesn't have the the same colors as Applejack and Big Mac (who themselves have different colors), and she does not appear to yet exist when Applejack Returns from Mainhattan. and there is also the Fact that Applejack treats Applebloom more like a Daughter rather than a little sister. i Think Applejack did more than just go to Fancy parties in Mainhattan, i think she might have mixed with some rotten apples and conceived Applebloom during her stay in Mainhattan.
Ok,If Applejack is Applebloms mother then who's the father?
Ariana Csoncsik i imagine some Filly (now a stallion) from her stay in Manehattan. most likely from the typical "cool" fillies, with whom she got into bed with, because she was trying integrate her self and be accepted, and that's what the cool "grown up" fillies do. i think you can imagine the rest.
She can't be her mother because remover the episode when applejack was being to protective and she said "sorry I was being to protective LITTLE SIS....."
Mackenzie T who ever said that applebloom knows the truth?
Ariana Csoncsik apple mac duh
They need to to show a Big Mac/Apple Bloom episode. Where the moral of the episode even though you don't have a lot in common. You still love each other and are still family or friends.
THIS! THIS! This is why I love apple jack all those reasons this is why apple jack best pony! :3
sound like applejack is apple bloom more than a sister figure
Apple jack is the sweetest pony next to flutter shy. AJ is not stubborn!
Here's my theory on AJ's parents:
They gave birth to Big Macintosh and then a couple of years later, gave birth to Applejack, then only weeks or maybe even days after giving birth to Applebloom, they both passed away. Maybe because of an illness or an injury or maybe their mother could have passed away because of Applebloom's birth and their father was so heartbroken by this, that he passed away soon after. Poor little Applebloom never met her own parents....
I know Hasbro won't mention the death of AppleJack's parents, but I wish they would at least mention her parents.
For example "I remember when mom gave me this ____ when I was a filly"
Something subtle
Hard past you had. Hope you'll find someone trustworthy. I know bad people that wants to use me for their good. But my family and friends I trust with all strength. They helped me many times.
Applejacks mom died during labor, and her dad went into a depression after the loss of his wife, eventually killing himself. Such sad.
I just realized that this is uploaded on my birthday. And I realized that I like this video and relate to the facts in it 0_0 coincidence?
Funny thing about AJ is that while she not be the most "Popular" pony, I feel that she's the pony that a lot of people would hang out with the most or go to the most if they needed help with something... Making her in a way the most popular pony. Make sense?
Here's something you could consider reviewing: In the Esquestria Girls movies, you'll notice that human Applejack doesn't have as much of a bond with human AppleBloom, even after finding friendship. We barely even see Human AppleBloom in the movies.
It's a movie. The plot of the Equestria Girl movies were not to focus on family bonds or problems in life, but saving the world/healing broken friendships.
True.
Applejack should have been the element of loyalty
SWEET CELESTIA! You just made Applejack's Cutie Mark even more meaningful. 3 apples=3 Apples!
someone pointed out where did Applebloom go in the magical mystery cure. this may be a clue to when Applejack parents past away. the two questions about this are Did she here about her parents death by letter and the baby? or did she leave because it was too painful? i believe the later choice. she clearly has a deep rooted foalhood trama. she is faking being happy on the farm. she hides it from her friends and family. this may also be the reason of her stubborness too.