Personally, I think this episode would work better for someone like Nia, becuase 1. This is her 2nd winter ever, and 2. Maybe That Avalanche she was involved in China would give her PTSD
All that because Mattel hired 2 of the worst writers (like Becky Overton) of the show and forced them to write Percy that way, lack of Brenner’s guidance didn’t help either. I bet that’s how they want Percy to go heading into the shitty reboot
Percy Before: Destroys the mainline trio or Thomas anytime they treat him badly Percy Now: Cries because Thomas is supposedly ignoring him or that Gordon or James said something demeaning to him relying on others to defend him (Henry no longer applying here because he despite once being one of the biggest jerks before talking rudely to anyone just because he hates everything or yelling at anyone for annoying him now screams at the dumbest stuff) Can’t blame Gordon for being annoyed at the end of the episode here, felt like him and Cranky were the most sane and least dumb ones here in the Brenner era-onwards who haven’t lost their sanity
At least with Percy's new friends , you can argue that Sharon Miller could've made written a better film for Disney's 100th Anniversary than what ever wish was
Like with "Apology Impossible", I never got to see this episode, and I never will! It just forgets all the character development Percy had in Tale of the Brave and he's just so annoying! 😡 Definitely the second worst of the BWBA era!
Look, Percy’s one of my favorite characters in Thomas. But this episode does him as dirty as The Angry Birds Movie 2 did with Mighty Eagle (and both are installments associated with Ice and Snow, that also turn the characters in question (Percy and Mighty Eagle) into cowards, AND released around 2019). Only difference is I still like Percy despite Panicky Percy, I don’t like Mighty Eagle anymore because of TABM2.
Has Gator taught Percy nothing??? 😠💚 Times where I disliked Percy: Up, up and away! Percy's new whistle. Seeing is believing. What's the matter with Henry? Percy's new friends. 3 steam engines gruff. The Great little railway show. Percy and the monster of Brendam. How tight is that curve????
I liked Percy better when was usually angry and annoyed, like how he tries to stay clean but keeps getting dirty. And what happened to the cheeky engine he was? God I hate BWBA so much!
Yes I remember him in that way too. But since HIT taking over in 2004 they flanderized poor Percy into the baby of the bunch with a low I.Q. and had him act too nice, too cheerful and, as this episode showcases too panicky 🤦♂️💚
@dslade6559 At least Hit kind of handled Percy well, like "Percy and the Oil Painting," "Gordon takes Charge," (Though the rest of the Episode.) "James gets a new Coat," and so on.
They did my little green pal so dirty, he's still really bummed out about this episode having his reputation be dragged through the mud for the first two to three weeks after the episode first released, and let's just say poor Percy wasn't in the best headspace after the weeks of being made fun of and bullying stopped
How i would rewrite the episode is this, the title is called finding thomas which is a parody of the 2003 animated movie finding nemo by pixar. The plot has the same setting but percy and rebecca both look for thomas with no dream sequences and no percy being a baby.
Oh yes, this is by far my least favorite episode of the whole show - even worse than the Nitrogen era (which is already bad). It destroys Percy completely - yes I know avalanches are dangerous and something to worry about, but this honestly gave the wrong character. Heck, since Nia was a new character from Africa, why couldn't she be the main protagonist? Also, worst....crash....ever....of....Season 23!!!!!!
I think Thomas’ worst episode is easily Too Loud Thomas. It’s boring, annoying and frustrating cause it involves John Hasler doing the worst singing despite Thomas singing many times before.
Yes, do more of the worst character episode. I hope you would do Gordon next or maybe Thomas (but then again there are a lot of bad Thomas episodes). Or you could do Toby next.
What do you expect. These are BWBA episodes, of course the writers have to make James and Percy the worst personas to make them jerkish, silly, and giddy. Not sure why but I have the feeling that Mattel ordered the writers to forget about the character development they had in the previous episodes.
Percy’s involvement felt more as if he were a place holder or just shoved in for the sake of having the steam team in episodes for bwba and this is honestly his worst for how poorly they handled lil caterpillar
Bro this episode sucks harder than a Hoover vacuum cleaner. One thing that makes this episode worse for me is how grating Percy's voice is in both dubs. I really liked the new English VA's he got in S19 (especially the US voice), but after BWBA started, I think the voice direction changed because now I hate it. I have the same thing with Keith Wickham's Percy voice, it was actually pretty good in S17 and 18, but in the nitrogen era before it, it sounds how barbed wire probably feels to touch. I really loved the video, this episode is the worst of the entire show for me :)
Second worst episode of not just the Bwuba era, but of the whole show. Yes, I find this one worse than anything from the HiT Model era and even the Nitrogen era.
I’m sorry, but I feel like this is sort of offensive and not for one. It’s sort of offensive to the people Who have panic attack because it makes them feel like they’re crazy And I know that claim is a bit extreme, but that’s just how it is. I’m sorry
3:09 So, just now I’ve realized that he wasn’t even in that platform area so uh, apologies lol.
5:12-5:13 LOL where is that clip from?
@@victorgaminglounge3967 It’s from the “We’re Not Gonna Take It” music video from Twisted Sister
What if at 3:09 the scene took place at Vicarstown at the platform where there's a wall.
the bay platform area btw (no nerd emoji lol. it's overplayed)
You actually had me there for a moment 😂I got so confused and couldn't understand what you were talking about
Sometimes I wish "Letters to Santa" was Percy's last episode.
Agreed because it truly feels like it should have been the last one you get the feeling when you watch it this one it's just a big pile of mess.
And All in Vain should’ve been James’ last episode.
@@ryanfuller912 Or “An engine with many colors.”
What about The Great Little Railway Show? It has Percy better in the final season.
@@DavidBContentExtravaganza3967 Was this a Percy episode?
Personally, I think this episode would work better for someone like Nia, becuase 1. This is her 2nd winter ever, and 2. Maybe That Avalanche she was involved in China would give her PTSD
That is actually kind of brilliant! 😃
Curse you writers! You should’ve used Nia.
The episode would have been better if Nia was the main character but they were dumb enough to use Percy being the main character
@@ryanfuller912same here I agree
All that because Mattel hired 2 of the worst writers (like Becky Overton) of the show and forced them to write Percy that way, lack of Brenner’s guidance didn’t help either. I bet that’s how they want Percy to go heading into the shitty reboot
@danielalsop Very sadly, it pretty much IS how Percy is in the reboot, and it's no shock in the slightest...😔😑
Percy Before: Destroys the mainline trio or Thomas anytime they treat him badly
Percy Now: Cries because Thomas is supposedly ignoring him or that Gordon or James said something demeaning to him relying on others to defend him (Henry no longer applying here because he despite once being one of the biggest jerks before talking rudely to anyone just because he hates everything or yelling at anyone for annoying him now screams at the dumbest stuff)
Can’t blame Gordon for being annoyed at the end of the episode here, felt like him and Cranky were the most sane and least dumb ones here in the Brenner era-onwards who haven’t lost their sanity
At least with Percy's new friends , you can argue that Sharon Miller could've made written a better film for Disney's 100th Anniversary than what ever wish was
No she couldn’t, she’s a shit writer and is unwilling to change her style, that’s why she got sacked from the writing team during S15-16
H e r e I a r e
At least the Miller Era can be laughed at because of how corny it is. The BWBA era isn’t like that, it’s just bad.
Gordon: YOU MEAN I'VE ABANDONED MY PASSENGERS FOR NOTHING?!
James: Hey! Why wasn't I invited? What's going on here?
Percy: THOMAS IS IN DANGER!
Like with "Apology Impossible", I never got to see this episode, and I never will! It just forgets all the character development Percy had in Tale of the Brave and he's just so annoying! 😡 Definitely the second worst of the BWBA era!
Personally, I would rather watch Percy and the Haunted Mine over THIS Godforsaken episode.
Agreed
We're not _gnelves,_ we're not _gnoblins,_ we're _gnaughty gnomes,_ and _you've_ been, *_GNOOOOOOOOOOMED!!_*
At least his fear was justified in Haunted Mine, but here he’s just being scared for no reason.
@@ryanfuller912 Exactly.
I never had a problem with Percy And The Haunted Mine episode
1:50 That Womp Womp Was Personal 😂😂😂
Thomas's worst episode is "Thomas's Frosty Friend" and I don't recommend it to anyone.
@@PCMan8922 What about Wonky Whistle? That seems more like Thomas Worst Episode
I think it’s no secret to why Andrew Brenner left in 2018. And honestly, I wish they ended the show after Season 21.
Agreed with you there.
I wish this episode actually starred Nia and showed us struggling with snow as she’s from a country where it never snows.
All of that Tale of the Brave development
Gone
Look, Percy’s one of my favorite characters in Thomas. But this episode does him as dirty as The Angry Birds Movie 2 did with Mighty Eagle (and both are installments associated with Ice and Snow, that also turn the characters in question (Percy and Mighty Eagle) into cowards, AND released around 2019).
Only difference is I still like Percy despite Panicky Percy, I don’t like Mighty Eagle anymore because of TABM2.
That's a weird coincidence...I think that it's true.
Awesome Job Also I Love Percy The Small Engine He’s One Of My Favorite Characters
I wish the Percy from season five was the definitive version that stuck. 🙁
He was still like that, for example: Percy’s Chocolate Crunch
3:11 Actually, the tracks curve around that wall
Has Gator taught Percy nothing??? 😠💚
Times where I disliked Percy:
Up, up and away!
Percy's new whistle.
Seeing is believing.
What's the matter with Henry?
Percy's new friends.
3 steam engines gruff.
The Great little railway show.
Percy and the monster of Brendam.
How tight is that curve????
I liked Percy better when was usually angry and annoyed, like how he tries to stay clean but keeps getting dirty. And what happened to the cheeky engine he was? God I hate BWBA so much!
Yes I remember him in that way too. But since HIT taking over in 2004 they flanderized poor Percy into the baby of the bunch with a low I.Q. and had him act too nice, too cheerful and, as this episode showcases too panicky 🤦♂️💚
@dslade6559 At least Hit kind of handled Percy well, like "Percy and the Oil Painting," "Gordon takes Charge," (Though the rest of the Episode.) "James gets a new Coat," and so on.
Gator : wtf
Gator: Did I teach you nothing????
They did my little green pal so dirty, he's still really bummed out about this episode having his reputation be dragged through the mud for the first two to three weeks after the episode first released, and let's just say poor Percy wasn't in the best headspace after the weeks of being made fun of and bullying stopped
How i would rewrite the episode is this, the title is called finding thomas which is a parody of the 2003 animated movie finding nemo by pixar.
The plot has the same setting but percy and rebecca both look for thomas with no dream sequences and no percy being a baby.
hear me out
Gordon’s worst episode.
Oh yes, this is by far my least favorite episode of the whole show - even worse than the Nitrogen era (which is already bad). It destroys Percy completely - yes I know avalanches are dangerous and something to worry about, but this honestly gave the wrong character. Heck, since Nia was a new character from Africa, why couldn't she be the main protagonist? Also, worst....crash....ever....of....Season 23!!!!!!
Funny thing is my least favorite episode of every era is a Percy episode
I think Thomas’ worst episode is easily Too Loud Thomas. It’s boring, annoying and frustrating cause it involves John Hasler doing the worst singing despite Thomas singing many times before.
@@AntluvstrainsI wonder if Joseph May and John Hasler actually lost their voices when recording their Thomas lines.
For me, this episode fundamentally ruined Percy as a character.
At least this episode doesn't treat avalanches as a joke, unlike a certain Season 5 episode.
Percy still has PTSD from "Put Upon Percy" and "Tale of the Brave".
@@PCMan8922Where's Gator when he needs him...
Man, I forgot how bad this episodes was....
AEG Percy > BWBA Percy
I feel like this episode should have been a Nia episode if she was afraid of the snow. It would be understandable
Yes, do more of the worst character episode. I hope you would do Gordon next or maybe Thomas (but then again there are a lot of bad Thomas episodes). Or you could do Toby next.
What do you expect. These are BWBA episodes, of course the writers have to make James and Percy the worst personas to make them jerkish, silly, and giddy. Not sure why but I have the feeling that Mattel ordered the writers to forget about the character development they had in the previous episodes.
I personally think the teeny tiny single nice thing about this is the fact that duck at least appears but still this episode is horrible
Personally I didn't agree with the James one but I agree with this one. The only thing I like about the episode is the appearance from Duck.
That crash was so garbage why did BWBA just forget how physics work?
How tight is that curve???
@@_MyNameIsAJ_How tight was that curve???
1:54 Diesel LOLZ XD!
Percy’s especially dumb in the Miller era
The BWBA era might be his worst...
He did have 6 crashes in that era.
Me: This isn’t time to panic!
Percy: This is the perfect time to panic!
Percy’s involvement felt more as if he were a place holder or just shoved in for the sake of having the steam team in episodes for bwba and this is honestly his worst for how poorly they handled lil caterpillar
Bro this episode sucks harder than a Hoover vacuum cleaner. One thing that makes this episode worse for me is how grating Percy's voice is in both dubs. I really liked the new English VA's he got in S19 (especially the US voice), but after BWBA started, I think the voice direction changed because now I hate it. I have the same thing with Keith Wickham's Percy voice, it was actually pretty good in S17 and 18, but in the nitrogen era before it, it sounds how barbed wire probably feels to touch. I really loved the video, this episode is the worst of the entire show for me :)
2:20 that how Percy is the best character
Percy’s my fav character I do have to say
Evan after this dreadful episode?
@@florjanbrudar692 he always has been
@@florjanbrudar692yup
I love his theme, I love his cheekiness and I love his irl engine, he’s just like me
I have to agree Panicky Percy is darn awful just like Apology Impossible starring James! I'd never watch this nonsense!
Classic Percy: 😡DON’T CALL ME PANICKY PERCY!!!!!!!!
What's the worst henry episode? In your opinion
Probably the one where he’s scared of chicken pox, really hate that one.
@@D10Studios235 suggestion then "Henry Spots Trouble The WORST Henry Episode."
Not sure if i got the title episode right lmao
@@Abandoned_Channel1You Did And The Episode SUCKS 👎
Percy, you’ve been through so much worse
@@calebtucker7677 Exactly, he braved bad weather and was buried alive for goodness sakes!
@@ryanfuller912 I have a fever
3:08 Not on the tracks that he’s *IN-FRONT* of!!!
4:15 Also hehe voicecrack
I'm not sure if this is the worst for me but, its definitely in the top 3
The writers and animators really shit the bed with this one
Percy still works on the main line, right?
Can you do the the worst Gordon episode?
When we getting the Lil Jimmy and Spanky retrospective
whenever i finally wake up
Great video! Whats the worst Gordon episode in your opinion?
Not sure on that one lol
Gordon Gets The Giggles is by far the worst.
Worse than wonky whistle and push me pull you
What is the Worst Diesel 10 Episode/Special?
Even if D10 has one actual episode, id say that’s his worst appearance. He’s super whiny in that one
As a Fan who of TTTE who even has D10 (TATMR D10 of course!) as Favorite Character I can agree with you!
Percy shouldn’t have to take mail all the time
That's right. Before it was Thomas who also pulled the mail with Percy, until it was decided to make Percy the only one capable of pulling it.
2:55 lol
So Percy’s going to speed to China to find Thomas cause that’s where Thomas and Nia were in the movie
Please can you do Henry's worst episode next?🙂
I’m planning to do Edward next, but I’ll definitely do Henry after!
Tf did Percy do to get treated like this😭
i've hated this episode since the day it came out so nice to see it getting some... hate
1:04
BWBA really did ruin everything
I so agree
Second worst episode of not just the Bwuba era, but of the whole show. Yes, I find this one worse than anything from the HiT Model era and even the Nitrogen era.
What about goodbye sir Topham Hatt?
3:07 you do know that percy is on platform 1 right? Platform 3 and 4 is where the rails end lol 😅
@@americanengine458 look at the pinned comment
I mean, at least he gave us a nice crash
How tight is that curve???
Now thomas
Oh
Percy's New Friends is better than this episode
I’m sorry, but I feel like this is sort of offensive and not for one. It’s sort of offensive to the people Who have panic attack because it makes them feel like they’re crazy And I know that claim is a bit extreme, but that’s just how it is. I’m sorry
Exactly
Henry’s worst episode?
I like Edward favorite ❤