This scene is purely amazing. Like how Nina didn't understand what her father did wrong and how she just wanted her father to be happy. How she truly cared for her father. Because when Scar killed her father she cried even in her Chimera form. Her humanity was still intact not knowing how her father destroyed her life.
For me it's how it set the tone of the series and asked a very important question at the start of the story: "What kind of alchemist is Edward?" It tells us his morals and values and he will do anything to not be like this kind of scientist. Which he does follow through with throughout until the very end. And the little details like you said, how a child will cry for their parent even though the parent did them wrong and hurt them. Such great writing.
Yeah... Edward could have used his Alchemy to put Nina's soul in a doll or something until he got a philosopher stone and fixed her... or changed that chimera girl into a furry beast human like other chimeras... But no... they gave up and basically told Scar: "here, put her down. We literally aren't going to try anything to help this girl. We give up... but we are still going to try to fix our limbs and get Alphonse's whole body back from the void.... so... we ain't got time for Nina and her dog!"
@@lolololol7573 Tell that to Lust regenerating a whole body from nothing. Or Pride eating whole humans or Father making immortal bodied. Or Ed somehow getting into Pride's stone and not dying. Or a lizzard Envy having the conciousness of a human despite being inches tall or less. Or Alphonse having his whole body gone but haunting a suit of armor. This show gets really looney Tunes by the end and you are trying to complain that I refuse to believe that something done with Alchemy can't be undone with Alchemy?! That is exactly what the show is about: how using Achemy carelessly destroyed lives, yet using alchemy with godlike skill can fix anything. Alphonse didn't get his body back by cloning his body with science and putting his soul back in with some religious ritual. It was alchemy that did it.
@@julianmarco4185 You definitely misunderstood the premise of Fullmetal Alchemist. They definitely show just how amazing alchemy can be and what it can achieve, but in doing so they also demonstrate the folly of relying wholly on this science. There are a wealth of examples in the story, but I think the best foundational example is the brothers' original attempt at human transmutation: the resurrection of their mother. There, they researched diligently, measured accurately, and performed the alchemy perfectly. What did they get for their result? A soulless thing, reflected in grotesque body horror. Obviously, their understanding was incomplete, and you can make the argument that they needed more research so they can re-attempt the transumtation. But later in the story, the brothers' are caught flat-footed when a pregnant woman goes into labour. Their alchemy wasn't going to help in that situation, but luckily their childhood friend Winry was there to help the labour process along; not without alchemy, but through midwifery. It is in that episode that the brothers realise how awesome nature creating humans without alchemy are. The audience is also invited to compare birth with human transmutation. Alchemy requires some knowledge and ingredients only, but it leads to disaster. Childbirth is difficult, but a human with a soul is born. With the above examples alone, you can easily reach the conclusion that alchemy, while useful, can be an addictive shortcut to horrifying catastrophes. There are some things that alchemy should not be allowed to touch (e.g. human transmutation, which incidentally is outlawed in the story) and for nature to run its course. Don't believe me yet? You mentioned Lust, Gluttony (I'm assuming, as Pride doesn't make a habit of eating humans) and Envy, all homunculii that are the embodiment of the pinnacle of alchemy. Lust killed Mustang and Havoc easily, and sought to kill Riza. However, just when it seemed hopeless, it turned out that Mustand survived, cauterised his and Havoc's wounds, and burned Lust into ashes. You could that was because flame alchemy trumps Lust's alchemy-borne powers, but that doesn't explain how and why he managed to survive long enough to win. The correct takeaway is that Mustang was willing to go that far for his loved ones. Incidentally, the way Lust dies is an irony: she is lust, but it is love that defeats her. And this irony is extended to the other homunculii. Gluttony ate other humans, but died being eaten by another. Envy was an androgynous shapeshifter who can become anyone he wanted, which he used to hurt and kill humans, but at the end of his life he was an ugly little thing who didn't want to admit to being envious of humans for being determined to be better. The point is that alchemy has limits, and cannot fix everything. This irony goes even further with human alchemists. Alphonse was "haunting" a suit of armor, but the point was that he is unable to feel warmth of anything (including a mother's warmth, which was his punishment from Truth/God); but he found many friends and companions along his journey that warmed him irregardless. Izumi attempted human transmutation on her stillborn son (to the same horrifying result) and for her troubles lost her reproductive organs to Truth/God; but she became a surrogate mother to her apprentices the Elric brothers. Mustang both figuratively (and later literally) lost his sight; but in both instances Riza helped him overcome his blindness. Scar was a vengeful murderer who hated and was trapped by the use of alchemy; but he embraced his deceased's brother's alchemy research to help the country that destroyed his and was redeemed in the process. Edward lost his arm and leg to human transmutation; but both literally and figuratively he found someone he could lean on in the form of Winry, his automechanic and later wife. Therefore, to add to the earlier point, alchemy has limits and cannot fix everything, BUT BEING HUMAN CAN MAKE UP THE DIFFERENCE. What does all of this have to do with Nina's condition? When you find yourself in a hole, you don't say "I know! I'll DIG my way out". Same thing applies to Nina's condition; you have no idea how much more terrible Nina's situation could be when human transmutation is performed again. A horrible thing happened to her, yes, but that does not mean she should be defined by it, nor should she be denied companionship as a result. Or, in other words, you pull yourself out of the hole, and if the hole is too deep to pull yourself out of, have others help you out of the hole.
@@Yanah_bruh "I can't change her back" "Oh, well, we don't have a reason to keep you alive then, Nina will be annoyed at me if I kill you, but she'll get over it"
@@samarjeetbhonsle6000 Yeah, I do watch AoT every week, and it's ending tomorrow. Please don't spoil me, if you're a manga reader, cause I don't read the manga
What’s the worst thing about this to me is that Nina’s innocence shines through. Despite having something this horrific done to her, she still shows some sort of worry for the man that did such an awful thing to her. She doesn’t realize the gravity of the situation and it’s heartbreaking. I really do think the most evil thing one could ever do is commit appalling acts on a child. They are too good for this world and need to be nurtured and protected. Violating that shows me that you don’t have a soul.
Too right. Children are the most precious things we have. There are few things more despicable than betraying the trust and innocence of a child, and manipulating and [ab]using that child as a means to an end...
It's slightly worse than you might realize, because many dogs have unconditional love; so it's both of their love for their father in one body that refuses to yield. So while everyone might feel that the beating is deserved, neither Nina nor Alexander would never accept it.
In my opinion the original 2003 show did a much better job of revealing this traumatizing event as there was 2 or 3 episodes which built up to it and you actually got to spend time with Nina so it hit even harder seeing what she had turned into
I agree... I was devastated... I wasn't even angry... Just so fking sad snot and tears flowing like a fking tsunami... That kid was happy!! So happy and well adjusted... Raised well by that thing... Just why🤧😭😭...
Yeah even the ending of it was sadder. I mean, that ending scene where hohenheim and a few scientists were trying to practice 'magic' in that other world. And then Ed trying to build a rocket so that he could travel outer space to get back to his real world.. Just exactly defines humanity as a hopelessly hopeful species.. 'To infinity and beyond' vibe right there for sure. 😭😭
This scene really had me thinking, like deeply. I think because you can see on Ed’s face that part of him knows that tucker is partly right, in the fact that a lot of scientists experiment on lives, animal and human. Although their situations are different because for the Elric brothers it was more of an agreed self-sacrifice than the selfish use of other people.
Yeah he hates that part of him agrees. He hates that 1 sacrifice could benefit countless others and that it had to be Nina because losing nameless people is easier to overlook.
Not really. They thought equivilant exchange was the ingredients they put in the transmutation circle, not Al's body and Ed's limbs. Where it differs is they were trying desperstely to bring someone back from the dead. Shou snuffed out his daughter's life in hopes of recognition/payout
@Nick Kiggers Yeah, at the end of the day only they were involved in their experiment. So no one really has the right to condemn them especially since they already paid the price for what they tried to do.
Also paints how truly messed up child/animal abuse is, because in their innocence, neither kid nor a dog understand what was done to them, and still love and trust their parent/owner.
Kimbley, Johan Liebbert, Matou Shinji, Griffith, King Fritz, *Eren Yeagger* (yeah cry about ut filthy fanboys!) Hitler, Nero, Leopold II, Genghis Khan, Uday Hussein, Ivan The Terrible, Madam Lalaurie... Fiction or not, it's hard to find people who can be or even just writte individuals so putrid and deserving of suffering and vengeful punishment. Poor Griffith can't even qualify as one of those.
I read the full manga in middle school and this part has made me cry and I refused to finish reading the book for a few days. It hit so hard and it made me sick to my stomach at the realization that he used his daughter, his wife, and his dog for his experiments. It traumatized me so bad I began to write fiction horror about illegal and unethical human experimentation that also used animals. I’m only remembering this now that I’ve seen the scene again.
when I watched this when I was a kid, It was a total nightmare. the darkness of it is beyond acceptance, they made Nina such an adorable kid and with this comparison of this Chimera with the long hair dropping down is just so damn shocking.
I could never get over this scene in the original FMA..it lingered on for years. My heart just sank when I saw this scene, and I have to admit that I cried for an hour or so.
I remember as a little kid I tried to watch this show but couldn’t get past this episode. Then a couple months ago I finally went through brotherhood and loved it
That happiness he had just before the reveal. That's what's real heartbreaking. He truly hadn't even thought such a thing until that one phrase was said... 😰
Remember watching this as a kid for the first time and it was the first real " there aren't always happy endings" story I ever saw/heard. Broke my heart.
This was such a chilling, sad scene - even more so as Ed eventually figures out what Tucker really did. He went from "wow, that actually worked" to "hold on" to "YOU BASTARD!!!". Poor guys actually spent so much time with that girl just so it could be irreversibly destroyed by that monster of a man. Every child deserves a parent, not every parent deserves a child.
0:30 it literally took 1 sec for Edward to figure out the entire thing. That's why he is Full Metal. He is basically Einstein of the alchemy world. Once in a generation genius.
What made this even more depressing is that *he didn't even have to make Nina and Alexander into a chimera*. There were already soldiers who could change into their human and animal forms at will already. It was Shou's hunger for fame and ambition that led him to do this.
Nah when you read the manga and you actually see how adorable she is and how sweet and innocent it’s like 10x worse. And then the fact that she was wondering if her dad was okay 🥺🥺🥺🥺
One of the most complex and well written stories with best ending. At first you think wth is happening but as the story unfolds and the climax takes place ❤️ It's a masterpiece. Every character has it's significance rather than highlighting one character to make him famous.
The last time I ve seen this scene,10 years ago, I felt betrayed, sad and I cried.. I promised I will never see it again, and here I am again watching it after 10 years, still the same feeling, heartbroken... The poor Nina & Alexander 💔 💔
the unsettling background music, the cold narration of the scientist, the weak belows of ed..ward.. all building up to the tension of those two dreaded words "big brother". And when confronted with the fact ed himself has done human experimentation you see him fighting so hard to distance himself from the truth. The truth that he did try and fiddle with someones life and he made others pay for his actions. Ed knows his motives are different, but he can't cope with the reality that what he did was wrong and is wanting so hard for what he(edward) is saying to be true. 100000/10 a true masterpiece
I'm glad that the author showed Nina and Alexander flying to heaven and Shou falling straight into the deepest pit in hell in the manga. Nina and Alexander deserved better, and this part really broke me as a kid.
Actually hell is the worst punishment you can receive. We only think of torture in the human perspective. The tortures of hell work on the spirit and any pain felt by the flesh is much less painful than wounds inflicted on the spirit. The punishment Tucker is to take will be so horrific that any earthly torment would be bliss. There's no way anything could follow up on that. To quote Castiel from supernatural pertaining to Sam's soul: "you do not want that thing back inside of him, it looked like it had been flayed alive"
Dr:We are the same you and me! Yeah, Edward and Alphonse trying to bring back their mother because they have no one is as equal as turning cold bloodedly wife and daughter to chimera.
I haven't seen brotherhood. But i watched the Original. It felt like some part of me died along with this scene . & after this the Wnding was unique and special only for Nina & the Dog😭
from all my years of watching psychological thrillers serial killer documentaries this is what got to me really messed with my head when I saw it as a child
This was the scene where I realised for the first time.
What fullmetal alchemist brotherhood is gonna be...
Same dawg
@@shehryaarweeb8761 bruh deep cool dark awesome best
What makes it worse is that this is eerily reminiscent of the real horrific experiments people do
@@spacetacos7574 The OG version is even worse because it shows Nina's corpse
Same
When I first saw this scene, it wasn’t until Edward asked “Nina and Alexander. Where are they?!” when I figured out what went down.
I’m sorry but I don’t understand what happened? A friend told me to watch this cuz it was disturbing but I think I’m missing some context
@@itsatomiccc he created the chimera out of Nina and her dog. He combined them.
@@jordangreen4719 oh damn.. well now I get it
@@itsatomiccc he passed the alchemy exam the first time doing the same thing to his wife and then to his daughter and dog
Read the wiki, but seeing the realisation hit them made me feel so bad
This scene really gave me chills from up to down.
same
Dude his face is scary
I dont get what so scary from this scene?
@@hysh9483 he turned his daughter to this dog so yeah this......
The most emotional part is when Hohenheim died after going back to his wifes grave
This scene is purely amazing. Like how Nina didn't understand what her father did wrong and how she just wanted her father to be happy. How she truly cared for her father. Because when Scar killed her father she cried even in her Chimera form. Her humanity was still intact not knowing how her father destroyed her life.
For me it's how it set the tone of the series and asked a very important question at the start of the story: "What kind of alchemist is Edward?" It tells us his morals and values and he will do anything to not be like this kind of scientist. Which he does follow through with throughout until the very end. And the little details like you said, how a child will cry for their parent even though the parent did them wrong and hurt them. Such great writing.
Yeah... Edward could have used his Alchemy to put Nina's soul in a doll or something until he got a philosopher stone and fixed her... or changed that chimera girl into a furry beast human like other chimeras...
But no... they gave up and basically told Scar: "here, put her down. We literally aren't going to try anything to help this girl. We give up... but we are still going to try to fix our limbs and get Alphonse's whole body back from the void.... so... we ain't got time for Nina and her dog!"
@@julianmarco4185 That's.. I think you might be misunderstanding the series and the timeline a little bit.
@@lolololol7573 Tell that to Lust regenerating a whole body from nothing. Or Pride eating whole humans or Father making immortal bodied. Or Ed somehow getting into Pride's stone and not dying. Or a lizzard Envy having the conciousness of a human despite being inches tall or less. Or Alphonse having his whole body gone but haunting a suit of armor.
This show gets really looney Tunes by the end and you are trying to complain that I refuse to believe that something done with Alchemy can't be undone with Alchemy?! That is exactly what the show is about: how using Achemy carelessly destroyed lives, yet using alchemy with godlike skill can fix anything.
Alphonse didn't get his body back by cloning his body with science and putting his soul back in with some religious ritual. It was alchemy that did it.
@@julianmarco4185 You definitely misunderstood the premise of Fullmetal Alchemist.
They definitely show just how amazing alchemy can be and what it can achieve, but in doing so they also demonstrate the folly of relying wholly on this science. There are a wealth of examples in the story, but I think the best foundational example is the brothers' original attempt at human transmutation: the resurrection of their mother.
There, they researched diligently, measured accurately, and performed the alchemy perfectly. What did they get for their result? A soulless thing, reflected in grotesque body horror.
Obviously, their understanding was incomplete, and you can make the argument that they needed more research so they can re-attempt the transumtation. But later in the story, the brothers' are caught flat-footed when a pregnant woman goes into labour. Their alchemy wasn't going to help in that situation, but luckily their childhood friend Winry was there to help the labour process along; not without alchemy, but through midwifery. It is in that episode that the brothers realise how awesome nature creating humans without alchemy are. The audience is also invited to compare birth with human transmutation. Alchemy requires some knowledge and ingredients only, but it leads to disaster. Childbirth is difficult, but a human with a soul is born.
With the above examples alone, you can easily reach the conclusion that alchemy, while useful, can be an addictive shortcut to horrifying catastrophes. There are some things that alchemy should not be allowed to touch (e.g. human transmutation, which incidentally is outlawed in the story) and for nature to run its course.
Don't believe me yet? You mentioned Lust, Gluttony (I'm assuming, as Pride doesn't make a habit of eating humans) and Envy, all homunculii that are the embodiment of the pinnacle of alchemy. Lust killed Mustang and Havoc easily, and sought to kill Riza. However, just when it seemed hopeless, it turned out that Mustand survived, cauterised his and Havoc's wounds, and burned Lust into ashes. You could that was because flame alchemy trumps Lust's alchemy-borne powers, but that doesn't explain how and why he managed to survive long enough to win. The correct takeaway is that Mustang was willing to go that far for his loved ones. Incidentally, the way Lust dies is an irony: she is lust, but it is love that defeats her.
And this irony is extended to the other homunculii. Gluttony ate other humans, but died being eaten by another. Envy was an androgynous shapeshifter who can become anyone he wanted, which he used to hurt and kill humans, but at the end of his life he was an ugly little thing who didn't want to admit to being envious of humans for being determined to be better.
The point is that alchemy has limits, and cannot fix everything.
This irony goes even further with human alchemists. Alphonse was "haunting" a suit of armor, but the point was that he is unable to feel warmth of anything (including a mother's warmth, which was his punishment from Truth/God); but he found many friends and companions along his journey that warmed him irregardless. Izumi attempted human transmutation on her stillborn son (to the same horrifying result) and for her troubles lost her reproductive organs to Truth/God; but she became a surrogate mother to her apprentices the Elric brothers. Mustang both figuratively (and later literally) lost his sight; but in both instances Riza helped him overcome his blindness. Scar was a vengeful murderer who hated and was trapped by the use of alchemy; but he embraced his deceased's brother's alchemy research to help the country that destroyed his and was redeemed in the process. Edward lost his arm and leg to human transmutation; but both literally and figuratively he found someone he could lean on in the form of Winry, his automechanic and later wife.
Therefore, to add to the earlier point, alchemy has limits and cannot fix everything, BUT BEING HUMAN CAN MAKE UP THE DIFFERENCE.
What does all of this have to do with Nina's condition? When you find yourself in a hole, you don't say "I know! I'll DIG my way out". Same thing applies to Nina's condition; you have no idea how much more terrible Nina's situation could be when human transmutation is performed again. A horrible thing happened to her, yes, but that does not mean she should be defined by it, nor should she be denied companionship as a result. Or, in other words, you pull yourself out of the hole, and if the hole is too deep to pull yourself out of, have others help you out of the hole.
As soon as she said “big brother” tears instantly began forming in my eyes.
Ture actually i never cried in horrifying scene but i don't know how my tears coming out when i sww this scene
@@noobboylogan9042 amen
i didnt feel anything when i saw the scene though maybe your soft or im just emotionally numb
@@Hazel564fr i mean it's fucked up but it's meh if anything he should of killed the father right then and there tho.
@@Yanah_bruh "I can't change her back"
"Oh, well, we don't have a reason to keep you alive then, Nina will be annoyed at me if I kill you, but she'll get over it"
It's been over 8 years now since I watched this scene for the first time. Goodluck to folks who find this show, keep your napkins ready.
Yep, I finished it a month and a half ago, and I can confirm that this is truly peak fiction.
@@ameyadeshpande3448 FMAB & AOT are just the best pieces of Fiction
@@samarjeetbhonsle6000 Ikr
@@ameyadeshpande3448 are u caught up on the manga of AOT? Or even Season 4?
@@samarjeetbhonsle6000 Yeah, I do watch AoT every week, and it's ending tomorrow. Please don't spoil me, if you're a manga reader, cause I don't read the manga
I had already buried this trauma.... WHY NETFLIX!!??😭😭
They like giving us pain.
no I searched for this idk y
For State Alchemy, ofc
Like Ed's pocket watch says
Dont Forget
It makes me sad gets my feelings every time sick people like the Doctor
this scene made me cry like a baby. so so so heartbreaking.
Same
Me too
It's not
I never watched the show
This is not sad
soy soy soyboy
Can u explain what happened
PTSD just from my name. 💔 When Nina asked if her Dad if he was hurt, I broke into pieces.
Did you change your name?
@@WeNeedAMeteor38274 her name is joe biden now
What’s the worst thing about this to me is that Nina’s innocence shines through. Despite having something this horrific done to her, she still shows some sort of worry for the man that did such an awful thing to her. She doesn’t realize the gravity of the situation and it’s heartbreaking.
I really do think the most evil thing one could ever do is commit appalling acts on a child. They are too good for this world and need to be nurtured and protected. Violating that shows me that you don’t have a soul.
Too right. Children are the most precious things we have. There are few things more despicable than betraying the trust and innocence of a child, and manipulating and [ab]using that child as a means to an end...
It's slightly worse than you might realize, because many dogs have unconditional love; so it's both of their love for their father in one body that refuses to yield. So while everyone might feel that the beating is deserved, neither Nina nor Alexander would never accept it.
man uh no there are some monster children in this world, but in the case of nina you would be correct tho
Yeah, because dogs aren't innocent at all and don’t view humans as equals and as family...
The whole lets play is both the kid and the dog
In my opinion the original 2003 show did a much better job of revealing this traumatizing event as there was 2 or 3 episodes which built up to it and you actually got to spend time with Nina so it hit even harder seeing what she had turned into
Plus the special ending they made specifically for when she died
That's what im saying, the 2013 version overall was a better show, but the 2003 version is really good for special moments like these and Hughes.
I think fma 2003 did most of the emotional/dark scenes better but brotherhood overall has better flow and a good satisfying ending
I agree... I was devastated... I wasn't even angry... Just so fking sad snot and tears flowing like a fking tsunami... That kid was happy!! So happy and well adjusted... Raised well by that thing... Just why🤧😭😭...
Yeah even the ending of it was sadder. I mean, that ending scene where hohenheim and a few scientists were trying to practice 'magic' in that other world. And then Ed trying to build a rocket so that he could travel outer space to get back to his real world.. Just exactly defines humanity as a hopelessly hopeful species.. 'To infinity and beyond' vibe right there for sure. 😭😭
This scene really had me thinking, like deeply. I think because you can see on Ed’s face that part of him knows that tucker is partly right, in the fact that a lot of scientists experiment on lives, animal and human. Although their situations are different because for the Elric brothers it was more of an agreed self-sacrifice than the selfish use of other people.
Yeah he hates that part of him agrees. He hates that 1 sacrifice could benefit countless others and that it had to be Nina because losing nameless people is easier to overlook.
Not really. They thought equivilant exchange was the ingredients they put in the transmutation circle, not Al's body and Ed's limbs. Where it differs is they were trying desperstely to bring someone back from the dead. Shou snuffed out his daughter's life in hopes of recognition/payout
Yeah, I mean it's not like they kidnapped a person off the street to use as a sacrifice for the transmutation.
@Nick Kiggers Yeah, at the end of the day only they were involved in their experiment. So no one really has the right to condemn them especially since they already paid the price for what they tried to do.
Exactly. Edward is nothing like Tucker.
Also paints how truly messed up child/animal abuse is, because in their innocence, neither kid nor a dog understand what was done to them, and still love and trust their parent/owner.
*parent. Alexander most likely viewed him as his parent as well.
Kimbley, Johan Liebbert, Matou Shinji, Griffith, King Fritz, *Eren Yeagger* (yeah cry about ut filthy fanboys!) Hitler, Nero, Leopold II, Genghis Khan, Uday Hussein, Ivan The Terrible, Madam Lalaurie... Fiction or not, it's hard to find people who can be or even just writte individuals so putrid and deserving of suffering and vengeful punishment. Poor Griffith can't even qualify as one of those.
I read the full manga in middle school and this part has made me cry and I refused to finish reading the book for a few days. It hit so hard and it made me sick to my stomach at the realization that he used his daughter, his wife, and his dog for his experiments.
It traumatized me so bad I began to write fiction horror about illegal and unethical human experimentation that also used animals. I’m only remembering this now that I’ve seen the scene again.
What chapter is that?
You wouldn’t happen to have drafts saved would you? Sci-fi psychological horror makes for a fascinating read even if refinement is needed.
@@s_p5321 its five chaps in
Man o man
Shou Tucker deserve his hate
when I watched this when I was a kid, It was a total nightmare. the darkness of it is beyond acceptance, they made Nina such an adorable kid and with this comparison of this Chimera with the long hair dropping down is just so damn shocking.
There is a reason why Fullmetal Alchemist has the highest IMDB rating❤️
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC no
No, Breaking Bad has that
@@psychoticgamer6853 its above average
@@darwinnunez5793 its 9.4
@@vegitoking5028 yessssir
Me:This scene still gives me chills
Also Me: Netflix Is giving spoilers😦😦😦😦
Please subscribe my chanel sir
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC no
@@username-mj6dn please subscribe my chanel sir I am facing to much problem please help me sir my last hope you please
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC nikal
What spoiler it is your will to click on video when it is clear in thumbnail and title
Plz why you are giving me pain netflix.i already started to cry when I first saw this scene seriously. Nina deserved a better father.
Please subscribe my chanel sir
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC nope
@@kunshwadhera8634 please subscribe my chanel sir please
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC stop spamming.
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC why should I subscribe pubg chanell?
Can never get over this trauma!
I feel you...I feel you
The lifeless eyes, the music, the lowered voice, the moments leading up to the reveal, chills...
i-sa aLmasIh yEshuA jEsUs KhrIst yEsUs krIstUs 🇺🇦🇵🇸 🇰🇷🇲🇾 jhO lOw bEbaskan victoria amelina jhO lOw free gaze jhO lOw bEbaskan mh37zErO jhO lOw PercUma zayn rayyan am
I don't think this is the saddest scene. But it is the most horrifying
what makes it horrifying?
@@bradenbeck1886 infusing two different species in a crude and unnatural way is pretty fucking horrifying
@@bradenbeck1886 literally the fact he trasformed his daughter into a dog
Which is saddest
@@bradenbeck1886 well, for one a crazy dad, turning his daughter and wife into chimeras.
What a heart warming story about a girl and her dog and how they're inseparable.
💀💀💀
…godfuckingdammit take my vote and get the hell out of here
💀💀💀 no bro no you cant
💀💀💀Bro, why you gotta say it like that?
💀Bro why
I could never get over this scene in the original FMA..it lingered on for years. My heart just sank when I saw this scene, and I have to admit that I cried for an hour or so.
Out of any show I have watched in my entire life, this scene will always stay with me forever.
The way Al immediately realizes what Ed is getting at the second he asks about Nina and Alexander still gets me.
This hits differently when you’ve seen it before you had kids and Then watch it when you have kids. Just hits differently
I’m not having kids tho 😂
Same 💀
This scene gives me goosebumps I remember that day when I see this secne
Oh this scene alone worth rating IMDB-10❤️❤️❤️
Please subscribe my chanel sir
@@AGE-OF-DIVULGES-ETC ain't gon work like that bruv
@@anakynnn2075 lmoa
I remember as a little kid I tried to watch this show but couldn’t get past this episode. Then a couple months ago I finally went through brotherhood and loved it
This show is definitely not for children. You dodged a bullet by not watching it earlier 😂
I don't think I can ever forget this scene it's been years and it's still in the back of my mind
This scene is still scarring. No matter the version. 😭
What do you mean by version
@don romantikoYT it’s just called Fullmetal Alchemist, it was released in 2003
He means there's the original 03, the there is brotherhood which is kind of like DBZ Kai to original DBZ
@@TaggedByTaz what's better to watch? Did they skip some content with the remake?
In the original series, Ed first asked when his wife went home and when he created his first chimera
He asked in brotherhood too but that scene was cut in this🙄
I had a really hard time getting over this scene and now you show me this again. I really burst into tears.
That happiness he had just before the reveal. That's what's real heartbreaking. He truly hadn't even thought such a thing until that one phrase was said... 😰
Remember watching this as a kid for the first time and it was the first real " there aren't always happy endings" story I ever saw/heard. Broke my heart.
I was watching fullmetal alchemist brotherhood on Netflix when the notification for the video came
It still gives me goosebumps 😭😭
This scene was actually more emotional in fullemetal alchemist(2003), where scar kills nina against a wall outside the house, while it was raining😭
I feel ya bro
@P J if u haven't watched FMA then why the hell are you even here😑
@@MrVIRAL-zj8lq because you don't need to watch FMA to see this video
@@alfie0then go and watch it
@@alfie0 This video gives the spoiler, dammit Idiot
This was such a chilling, sad scene - even more so as Ed eventually figures out what Tucker really did. He went from "wow, that actually worked" to "hold on" to "YOU BASTARD!!!". Poor guys actually spent so much time with that girl just so it could be irreversibly destroyed by that monster of a man. Every child deserves a parent, not every parent deserves a child.
This show truly depicted the difference between the traditional meaning magic and alchemy. Also this scene set the tone for the whole show .
Brutality of Bad Parents...indeed tragic yet powerful scene to haunt us forever!
This scene traumatized when I saw it for the first time. I'll never forget it.
This scene right here not only traumatised me but made me cry like a baby back then. Now I'm traumatized again.😭
0:30 it literally took 1 sec for Edward to figure out the entire thing. That's why he is Full Metal. He is basically Einstein of the alchemy world. Once in a generation genius.
This scene made my stomach turn…. Ive never once in my life experienced this from a show.
What made this even more depressing is that *he didn't even have to make Nina and Alexander into a chimera*. There were already soldiers who could change into their human and animal forms at will already. It was Shou's hunger for fame and ambition that led him to do this.
Yeah... Like the one who lifts his leg to pee. ...yes they made that joke
This still gives me goosebumps
My heart went full metal after watching this.
That was the only scene that made me cry hard. Especially when she cared about her dirt if he's hurt.
Nah when you read the manga and you actually see how adorable she is and how sweet and innocent it’s like 10x worse. And then the fact that she was wondering if her dad was okay 🥺🥺🥺🥺
There was no point in making me go through this pain again, TF Netflix?!
This scene gives me chills everytime I see it
Still get chills watching this scene
Romi park is amazing, i love her voice acting 😍😍
This is so freaking heartbreaking every time.
I start watching fmab today and i watched this scene and Netflix is giving me chills again
Full metal alchemist always gonna be masterpiece ❣️❣️💯
One of the most complex and well written stories with best ending. At first you think wth is happening but as the story unfolds and the climax takes place ❤️ It's a masterpiece. Every character has it's significance rather than highlighting one character to make him famous.
The last time I ve seen this scene,10 years ago, I felt betrayed, sad and I cried.. I promised I will never see it again, and here I am again watching it after 10 years, still the same feeling, heartbroken... The poor Nina & Alexander 💔 💔
The fact this really happening in our world just amplifies this episode
I felt very bad at this episode and almost cried when scar killed nina.😭
FMAB is just a Masterpiece!! Whosoever still dint watch it, please you should watch it as soon as possible!!❤️
I remember the first time I saw this, it broke my heart in a bad way.
I firstly saw this scene when I was 12 and my tears fall, like today...
One of the few animes where the English translation is just as emotional and impactful.
Honestly I wouldn't even say this was the saddest scene
If you want to describe 2020 with an episode. This is it 🌚
Never once seen this, or have any background knowledge of what the rest of the show is, but I almost teared up at this scene alone
the unsettling background music, the cold narration of the scientist, the weak belows of ed..ward.. all building up to the tension of those two dreaded words "big brother".
And when confronted with the fact ed himself has done human experimentation you see him fighting so hard to distance himself from the truth. The truth that he did try and fiddle with someones life and he made others pay for his actions. Ed knows his motives are different, but he can't cope with the reality that what he did was wrong and is wanting so hard for what he(edward) is saying to be true.
100000/10 a true masterpiece
This is the scene in this story (whatever version you're watching) that lets you know EXACTLY what kind of tone you're going to be in for.
I'm glad that the author showed Nina and Alexander flying to heaven and Shou falling straight into the deepest pit in hell in the manga. Nina and Alexander deserved better, and this part really broke me as a kid.
Hell is too good for Shou
Actually hell is the worst punishment you can receive. We only think of torture in the human perspective. The tortures of hell work on the spirit and any pain felt by the flesh is much less painful than wounds inflicted on the spirit. The punishment Tucker is to take will be so horrific that any earthly torment would be bliss.
There's no way anything could follow up on that. To quote Castiel from supernatural pertaining to Sam's soul: "you do not want that thing back inside of him, it looked like it had been flayed alive"
Damn you for kicking up such a devastating PTSD...
When I was younger I really didn't care or feel anything when I watched this, but now I have kids, it hits differently.
3 years later after seeing this in the original, brotherhood and the live action movie this moment still hurts
Everybody who watched this scene for the first time:
*I’m never going to emotionally recover from this*
Damn even without context can still make you cry huh
I watch this when i was 13 and i dont have any idea how deeply sad and traumatic this scene is 😭 now im 27, it makes me cry 😭
i really LOVE fma’s background music
2:48 Let's play... Let's play the replay 😭😭😭
Damn this still gives me chills😶
This scene gave me chills
“What do you mean 'lower myself'? That's the only thing I've ever been. Just a simple human who couldn't save a little girl. Not even with alchemy.”
the way she says “let’s play let’s play.” is heartbreaking
More than crying honestly it gave me chills like seriously was too afraid to even sleep so i don't get weird dreams i was 14 back then😣
That was really heartbreaking moment for me
Dr:We are the same you and me!
Yeah, Edward and Alphonse trying to bring back their mother because they have no one is as equal as turning cold bloodedly wife and daughter to chimera.
It was heart breaking to watch second time more when I finally realised it but it still hurts today
this scene broke me years ago, i still am not able to rewatch this series
This scene hurts so much, not only emotionally but also physically...
This one and Ed's sacrifice are the 2 most hard hitting moments.
This makes me cry every time, it's sadder than Rem
Goosebumps ❤️
What a masterpiece!❤ I had goosebumps
i watched this when i was far too young, and it still brands me to this day
This is far more traumatizing in fma 03, actually this scene is where I realised fma isn't gonna be kidding around.
Fma isnt that much traumatizing if u look at it , it's much happier than most shonen animes
@@swayamprakashpani10froll-48 true. Things get easier ahead and the ending is satisfying too
I haven't seen brotherhood.
But i watched the Original. It felt like some part of me died along with this scene .
& after this the Wnding was unique and special only for Nina & the Dog😭
from all my years of watching psychological thrillers serial killer documentaries this is what got to me really messed with my head when I saw it as a child
I remember.crying for this episode and not sleeping at all.
this was pretty sad and scary at the same time 🥺
0:55 he's voice kinda similar to naruto
It's actually Hange Zoe