She didn’t deserve that medal! Shannon’s difficult made her look like a joke. Look how low her chest was on that landing of the double tuck. That whole team was full of lies. Screw the Russians and I say that for today too!
@@johnhazel3551 while the Soviet Union did mess with a great number of results and usurp many a deserved medal from other, better routines, THIS gold was very much deserved. Shannon had a couple of little things herself and wasn’t completely perfect either. Back then a low chest landing wasn’t as serious a markdown as it is today.
the goddesses of beam routine, to me: 1- catalina (the cat: pretty, agile and mysterious); 2 - sanne (the butterfly: fluidity in motion w those spins); 3 - nastia (the swan: ellegant and gracious, a feather in the air)
I realise that this video is based on medals and reputation, and that some of the all-time greats are short on actual titles, but a video called 'Best Balance Beam Specialists of All Time' really should have Yang Bo, Fan Ye, Li Shanshan, Olga Mostapanova, Natalia Shaposhnikova, Ekaterina Vandisheva and Svetlana Grozdova in it.
I think Nastia's lines and flexibility are better, and wonderful presence. The scoring system during her era encouraged a few things in her routines I didn't care for as much, but one has to adapt to their environment.
Most of these are not really specialists. Only Wevers, Schaefer and Guan. And I’m still not over Yang Bo never getting a world or Olympic medal- she was the best ever!
I'm with you on Yang Bo. It's an absolute travesty that she only has the 1990 World Cup victory to show for her magnificence. She was simply magnificent. This video is about beam medallists rather than actual beam specialists.
The first girl was really talented but she needs to point her toes then again I could be just a retired ballet dancer who would like to see more dance moves in the Beam and Floor Excersize like "in the old days" but we do have rhythmic gymnastics to fill that niche
@ I would use the term specialist for someone who focuses on 1 or 2 events…like Stephen Nedoroscik being a pommel horse specialist…he literally does not train/compete other events…if someone medals in All-Around I think they can have stronger events…but I would not say they were event specialists. 🤷🏻♂️
@@gymnasticfan9148is “excels at one thing”…Simone is #1 on the Beam Specialist list…but wouldn’t she also be a Vault Specialist, a Floor Specialist, and All-Around Specialist?
This is based on success at Meets. Shawn was far from perfect. She never once stuck that dismount and her chest was low in nearly all of her acrobatic skills. she landed that standing full with her chest practically against her thighs every single time I saw her do it. Just because she was consistent and didn’t have many balance checks doesn’t mean she was perfect. Liukin was consistently superior in several ways and was more successful in competition.
@@evoandy She only competed at 2 major competitions. She fell in the 2007 Worlds Final and won the Gold at Olympics. I’m pretty sure she would’ve won the gold in a normal day.
@@gymnasticfan9148 Se as outras que estão abaixo dela tivessem as mesma oportunidades, provavelmente iriam ter mais que ela. Simone ultimamente não faz trave tão bem. Só ganha ponto por dificuldade e ligação.
@@fenny1430 Não faz a trave tão bem? É só a trave mais consistente dos últimos 12 anos. E isso é muito importante kkk, ela só não é mais de longe a melhor trave como era no ciclo de 2016. Mas conseguiu se manter sempre ali no top 2-3 do ciclo.
100% agree! Although her beam routine is very pretty to watch, there is low risk in learning difficult turns. Gymnasts who combine artistry with difficult acrobatic skills have a far superior routine.
Biggest waste how? Only she can do these difficult turns and the turn combo on beam. You don’t have to be great on everything to get a medal. Besides, on-beam acro difficulty is useless thanks to the beam code. Most importantly, she hits when it matters on beam.
@@lizk1780 it’s not of low risk. No one does double L turn and triple turn on beam. “Difficult acrobatics” is a lie because many people’s most difficult acro excluding the dismount is an aerial nowadays.
The part that made Lysenko’s gold so nice was it came after so many mistakes and injuries. Great to see her finally have success.
She didn’t deserve that medal! Shannon’s difficult made her look like a joke. Look how low her chest was on that landing of the double tuck. That whole team was full of lies. Screw the Russians and I say that for today too!
@@johnhazel3551 while the Soviet Union did mess with a great number of results and usurp many a deserved medal from other, better routines, THIS gold was very much deserved. Shannon had a couple of little things herself and wasn’t completely perfect either. Back then a low chest landing wasn’t as serious a markdown as it is today.
Please Simone just needs an OG gold on beam before she retires. So close this year.
So fun to watch all of these great beamers through the ages! Simone's 2023 World gold performance was so perfect!
the goddesses of beam routine, to me:
1- catalina (the cat: pretty, agile and mysterious);
2 - sanne (the butterfly: fluidity in motion w those spins);
3 - nastia (the swan: ellegant and gracious, a feather in the air)
I realise that this video is based on medals and reputation, and that some of the all-time greats are short on actual titles, but a video called 'Best Balance Beam Specialists of All Time' really should have Yang Bo, Fan Ye, Li Shanshan, Olga Mostapanova, Natalia Shaposhnikova, Ekaterina Vandisheva and Svetlana Grozdova in it.
Props to the gymnast at 7:25 for throwing her dismount with her left heel off the beam on the round off!
Great beam compilations!!!! Thanks
Thanks for the great video :)
Nadia is the original BEAM QUEEN
Where's Shawn Johnson? She deserves to be here
3:55
On my subjective list, she would be placed much higher.
on that I agree but it’s based on number of medals specifically for beam. If it was overall metals she would be much higher.
Sui Lu fantastica! Korbut fenomenale eleganza! Comaneci magnifica! Biles esorbitante!
Not seeing Kui Yuan Yuan here hurts and like Gina did not deserve that gold at all.
Nadia is the best because she had long limbs and was so graceful. Not matched by any others.
I think Nastia's lines and flexibility are better, and wonderful presence. The scoring system during her era encouraged a few things in her routines I didn't care for as much, but one has to adapt to their environment.
Most of these are not really specialists. Only Wevers, Schaefer and Guan.
And I’m still not over Yang Bo never getting a world or Olympic medal- she was the best ever!
I'm with you on Yang Bo. It's an absolute travesty that she only has the 1990 World Cup victory to show for her magnificence. She was simply magnificent.
This video is about beam medallists rather than actual beam specialists.
Yelena shuchunova
Melhor de todas
The first girl was really talented but she needs to point her toes then again I could be just a retired ballet dancer who would like to see more dance moves in the Beam and Floor Excersize like "in the old days" but we do have rhythmic gymnastics to fill that niche
It's too bad the Miller isn't still in the CoP.
When i see bb i think in Catalina Ponor
Silivas, Weven, Luikin
Simone Nadia ☆LL
Where is Sunisa “Suni” Lee?
This ranking is based on World and Olympic medals.
Where was Svetlana Boginskaya?
WC -1
OG- 3
WC -2
I mean can you really call World and Olympic ALL-AROUND medalist “Beam Specialists”?!?
@@ArtByDesign80 Can’t a person be specialist in more than one thing? Or be be a specialist in one apparatus and good in the rest?
@ I would use the term specialist for someone who focuses on 1 or 2 events…like Stephen Nedoroscik being a pommel horse specialist…he literally does not train/compete other events…if someone medals in All-Around I think they can have stronger events…but I would not say they were event specialists. 🤷🏻♂️
@ You can use specialist for both, a person who focus in only 1 thing and a person who excels in one thing
@@gymnasticfan9148is “excels at one thing”…Simone is #1 on the Beam Specialist list…but wouldn’t she also be a Vault Specialist, a Floor Specialist, and All-Around Specialist?
@ One doesn’t exclude the other, you can be specialist in more than one thing, that’s what I’m saying since the beginning
Shawn Johnson should be way higher. I mean she's perfect! And Nastia's 9th so it's not fair to Johnson who was better or as good
This is based on success at Meets. Shawn was far from perfect. She never once stuck that dismount and her chest was low in nearly all of her acrobatic skills. she landed that standing full with her chest practically against her thighs every single time I saw her do it. Just because she was consistent and didn’t have many balance checks doesn’t mean she was perfect. Liukin was consistently superior in several ways and was more successful in competition.
@@evoandy She only competed at 2 major competitions. She fell in the 2007 Worlds Final and won the Gold at Olympics. I’m pretty sure she would’ve won the gold in a normal day.
@@evoandy It's actually the only skill she had a low landing. Everywhere else was great. And Nastia just competed more.
@@KaylaTheDaughterOfAthena The only acrobatic skill she HADN'T a low landing was her back layout
Look, she's my favorite gymnast. Let's just agree to disagree.
Shannon waa great at "cheating" her tumbles on the beam.
Simone Biles em 1° sem nunca ter ganhado ouro olímpico no aparelho? 🤔
based on medals ya, but overall suni and shawn are the best beam workers of all time
@@hellotoeveryone8045 My top 2 all time favorites are Shawn and Sui Lu
Simone in first? LOL
@@fenny1430 I only see 1 gymnast with more than 2 Golds at Worlds here.
@@gymnasticfan9148 Se as outras que estão abaixo dela tivessem as mesma oportunidades, provavelmente iriam ter mais que ela. Simone ultimamente não faz trave tão bem. Só ganha ponto por dificuldade e ligação.
@@fenny1430 Não faz a trave tão bem? É só a trave mais consistente dos últimos 12 anos. E isso é muito importante kkk, ela só não é mais de longe a melhor trave como era no ciclo de 2016. Mas conseguiu se manter sempre ali no top 2-3 do ciclo.
@@fenny1430 Só não é disparada na frente aqui pq rogaram praga nela nas olimpiadas, ela tinha a melhor trave de 2016 e 2021.
Her beam consistency is unreal. She’s not a “paper difficulty” beam queen.
Boring Gina Gogean! I was so mad in 97 when she won over Kui!
Lysenkos was very boring
Sanna Wevers????? Lmao that was the biggest waste of a medal ever! Performing a level 3 dismount at the Olympics please
100% agree! Although her beam routine is very pretty to watch, there is low risk in learning difficult turns. Gymnasts who combine artistry with difficult acrobatic skills have a far superior routine.
Biggest waste how? Only she can do these difficult turns and the turn combo on beam. You don’t have to be great on everything to get a medal. Besides, on-beam acro difficulty is useless thanks to the beam code. Most importantly, she hits when it matters on beam.
@@lizk1780 it’s not of low risk. No one does double L turn and triple turn on beam. “Difficult acrobatics” is a lie because many people’s most difficult acro excluding the dismount is an aerial nowadays.