Dear Dr Shabir Ally. I am a revert Muslim and your channel has removed all the doubts I had about Islam. My Allah bless you and guide the rest of the ummah to be as thoughtful as you.
This guy might be the only Islamic Scholar that I respect!!!!! He desrves the Identity of "A Scholar". I know I might not agree with him on everything, but I cannot agree more with anyother. If reverts need someone as a Basic Guide, I would no doubt recommend him.
How ironic is it that the verse is all about justice, yet some people use the verse to justify oppressing women by involving them in multiple wife positions when they dont want it. Before you yell at me at the replies, try to put your self into the shoes of those women. Thank you Dr. Ally for speaking out!!
@@aft0000 yup, it's the same with the verse allowing to slap the woman and it's the same with the verse about the woman being a field. Those verses have a reason and don't justify oppression, yet some people use them like that...
Muslim men must just do their level best to do justice and leave the rest to Allah. Even it’s difficult for parents to do justice among their children, or for a husband to do justice to his only one wife. No one is perfect but perfect intentions.
Couple of days ago I started reading Surah Nisa and It took me by surprise that the whole scenerio of marrying 2 3 4 was in a totally different context than what general perception was among the people. Quran is clearly talking about supporting the orphans.
Since 2008 Israel in their efforts to occupy, killed 158,286 Palestenians, nearly all civilians, women, children, elderly, since 2008 Palestenians in their efforts to defend against the occupation, killed 5,887 Israelis, mostly soldiers. search '' The Human Cost Of The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict'' These values do not include the dead of 70+ years of occupation, does not include the millions of evicted people, does not include the millions of people afflicted by the conflict due to malnutrition, lack of medical servives, education loss, income loss, broken families etc etc etc. While the occupiers celebrated what they were doing.
My country Turkiye has many times proposed that we muslims establish a peace keeping force and have our selves established in bases in Jordan and the region, but Arab countries have so far succummed to foreign pressures and not accepted such an offer, as yet. To all the Arab brothers and sisters; without falling out of Islamic etiquitte and manners, and without endangering yourselves or others, please rally your leaders/governments, so we can get together and do what's needed to stop all this, ...condemnation, throwing an aid pallet or two from airplanes and posing for the cameras for the media isn't right, we need to establish a peace keeping force to stop the brutality. We need to show a steady force, we need to first unite, please don't just watch, be active in your countries.... ....and all nations can join in on this peace keeping force, from all corners of the world, all beliefs, because this is about SANITY against INSANITY !
@@KenanTurkiye it's not the arabs fault, most arab countries with the strength or the money have civil war or they have a government ruled by zionists/American vassals...
I wrote about the issue in one of my books. Unfortunately most of our ulemas intentionally don’t mention the first part of the verse (4:3) where the clear condition is given, to hide it from the general Muslims. The verse revealed at a special circumstance after the Battle of Uhud when several companions were killed, ultimately leaving their wives and children vulnerable. The verse revealed to take care of the orphans at that dire situation. However, there is a general ruling for marriage in verse 24:32 which says, “Marry among you who are single…..”[Ankehu alayama minkum(i.e a man who has no wife and the woman who has no husband)]. It also should be borne in mind that Allah didn’t create multiple wives for Adam (pbuh). Most importantly, if Allah wanted to generalize it, He wouldn’t have to keep the world population’s proportion as 1:1.
@@HH-pv9ex Misconception about Islam, Realities of Muhammad’s (pbuh) Marriages, Misrepresentation of Islam, 100 Great Non-Muslims on Muhammad (pbuh), Misunderstanding Islam etc.
@@FrankeNamensKarim Prophet Muhammad (pbuh )also had multiple wives, but those are due to the required need and situation of that time. And those can’t be generalized in normal circumstances. Thanks. Jajak Allahu Khairan.
A man can marry upto 4 as long as he can be just that's what's the Quran clearly states. Why are other words being added to the translation?? The prophet, his companions, followers & follower followers married multiple wives due to many reasons not only to help orphans. Sheikh never try to corrupt Quran as Allah protects his religion U r killing ur time
@@Simarodra Allah preserves his revelation as stated in the Quran this man is adding & subtracting words from the translations that's dangerous for him
That is only his own interpretation. Everyone has the right to have their own interpretation about polygamy as long as they have read all verses related to marriage carefully and ready to be questioned by Allah in the accountability process in the judgment day.
@@lussamhassan4561 As far as I know, the Quran was revealed to be understood by all mankind without exception. There is not a single verse in the Quran that prohibits ordinary people who are not scholars from studying it, and then he might have his own opinion without imposing it to others Moreover, what is the definition of a scholar according to you? Are only those who graduate from Islamic universities entitled to be called scholar ? Can an autodidact not be called a scholar?
EVERYONE please make a playlist about Palestine like I have (4th playlist) and ask others to have such a playlist. Or copy directly the list I have and ask others to copy it from you, and they ask others copy from them. We need to spread the truth, millions, billions of us.
The verse is clear that one has to do justice and verse 4:129 makes it all the more clear, which states that we will never be able to do justice between our wives, even if it is our ardent desire
As-salaamu alaykum I’m an “African American” Muslim. While my community didn’t fight in the battle of Uhud, we’re fighting the war against social ills that plague us and one of those is the family structure. African American muslimahs desire to be married. The pool of men from our community is small. There aren’t other Muslim men from other communities lining up to marry them and to be honest, from what I’ve seen, they prefer men from their own community. Polygyny in Islam is a remedy for this. Directly. Polygyny is also for the women, so that they can be married. Polygyny may not fit well in communities like yours but we have to understand, Islam reaches and is for the entire world. The entirety of mankind. I respectfully disagree with this position and the translation of the Qur’an that you’re using. Since you’re taking a position of being a knowledgeable person of Islam, can you provide some alternatives for the “African American” muslimahs other than polygyny?
Its weird throughout the translations, though still the general idea and the verses all have the same meaning from 1400 years ago to today unlike the bible with added verses if you compare manuscripts like codex sinaiticus, etc
@@scorpi6501 Quran is very crystal clear in it's meaning but ppl are trying to change meanings & that's stated in the Quran they will fail as fusha Arabic is a clear & direct language
Because Arabic is a deep language and to understand it you have to add words but in my opinion best practice is to bracket explanatory words so people don’t believe that they are part of the text
@@grinningchicken adding & subtracting words in Quran is kufr & that's stated in the Quran. Also it's stated that Quran is direct & clear revelation of God nothing to do with Arabic being deep this person changed the whole context of the verse & made the verse only about orphans by adding a word of his opinion...
The exgedusese of Aisha RA and Ibn massoud said : These verses were revealed to shun men who used to target /get married to orphan young girls , with the intention of treating her or giving her less rights than they would have rather given to women who have a strong family support. (Mainly, make use of their inherited wealth and give them less Mahr ...etc) The instructions that followed were : If you fear you won't do justice to these vulnerable women/girls , therefore you better go marry two at a time (of those who aren't already suffering and do have a strong family support of men who will break your jaw if you are to mistreat her ) Mary two at a time or three at a time or four at a time . If you fear that's something that will lead you to injustice . Then , only Mary one .
If a man has good wifes who can controll themselfs, mind only their own marriage and don't think they have birthright to the man it can work just fine if everyone is willing to help.
People who are interested in this particular topic must read " Letters to Tahir" by G.A. Pervez and " Fiqh Al Quran" by Maulana Umar Ahmed Usmani. Dr Shabbir Aly prolly has read it bcz this exactly what is discussed in great detail in those books
Dr. Shabbir Ally is always interesting and never slanders Jesus, my lord, as cheeky and deluded dawahists do sometimes. Although I am Catholic I like him very much.
@Chris-wr9hv Any person who "slanders Jesus" or any prophet cannot be a Muslim !! They need to repent. 2:285 The Messenger has believed in what was revealed to him from his Lord, and [so have] the believers. All of them have believed in Allah (God) and His angels and His books (Scriptures) and His messengers, [saying], "We make no distinction between any of His messengers." And they say, "We hear and we obey. [We seek] Your forgiveness, our Lord, and to You is the [final] destination."
It's best to come back to the real Qur'an, not the translations and their secular values. The first verb QST قسط it's about Proportion and not really "to be Just" as say Dr Ally and his english Qur'an. Which proportionne ? of what ? The number of wife, till 4 as says Allah in this verse. The noun الْيَتَامَىٰ is not exclusivly for children, but also woman because this word said that is about people who need to be adopted, marry, to be joined and be fully in a group, inserted in a family. And then come the verbe A'dala عدل and this one is about justice in the way that the just person need to take care of all matters, listen and study a matter to deliver decision. So this verse doesn't say only the injust person has right to take only 1 woman. Really, the english qur'an is not Allah's words, and the interpretations done on the false qur'an can't be taken in serious. Learn arabic, or make researches on ahadith, the sunna.
@muhammadislaam9911 what lol. If you can't take care of the orphans marry 2-4 women. If you find you can't take care of those women, marry only 1 (to take care of the orphan)
@muhammadislaam9911 I know ,it doesn't say orphans mothers. How could it? The verse says 2 or 3 to 4, no one has more than 1 mother. However the reason for extra marriage still stands- fearing you aren't able to take care of orphans.
Man you didn't understand it just say if there is need to it like in today times there many many poor people widows so if there is need to it and you can do justice in between which is very difficult you should do it, While tariq massod maybe telling because same reason the many women are helpless in this society so marry her
@@LeanOnPlants They would be called feminists,then if they do . The only time they will be asked to go for a job increticised , is after they have been leveraged by the elites and passed around from one to another ,(with a pre-intention of divorce) because they were seen as low value unwanted goods from the get go . THEN ,after their youth is taken away from them, they will be advised to go get a life (i.e a job ) and they will be told they have to stop crying about having no family or kids or companion because that's lack of Eeman
@ojammeh you'd rather take care of you sexual desires yourself, and when you find someone who is WORTHY of your hand in marriage, then marry him. But don't marry out of need.
We like revisiting matters that has already been conccluded and understood in a certain way by those who were present at the time of its revelation and those who followed them. You simply just need to read tafsir ibn kathir or other early tafsir to see that this explanation dosent fit
I don’t think that the Dr got this verse meaning correctly. Just to appear modern scholar or female rights activist you cannot change the meaning of Quran. When you say that it’s not just the verse of Quran but the understanding of Sahaba (R.A) you can see their practice of multiple marriages Moreover the present situation of Divorced and widows in the community there is definite role of multiple marriages- the only condition mentioned is to treat justly
You still don't understand he didn't say now there is no need for example lets forget the war and say there is poverty in your area and there are many hopless women so you can compare it to those times when it was needed he didn't say there is no need of it today times
Dr. You are doing wrong translation and interpretation of that verse , firstly it’s not orphans mothers but orphans themselves and you are skipping regarding concubines the last part of that verse , fear Allah not fear men
What makes a tevsir so special that it is needed to understand the message or the Qur'an of Allah? The person who writes the tafsir is ultimately reflecting his opinion and understanding of the Quranic verse with the knowledge and understanding he had at the time. Do you have to have two master's degrees, a PhD or a doctorate in Islam to understand the Qur'an? That can't be in the interest of Allah. Surely the religion can't be that complicated? I open the Koran, read it and try to put what I have read into practice. To be honest, I understand this verse just like Dr. Shabir Ally.
There are 2 billion of Muslims in the world. One dollar a month, 2 billion dollars for all orphanage is quite sufficient to keep them alive. Something is amiss some where 😅
Allah is referring to fatherless kids of single mothers, because women had very little to no economic freedom before the industrial revolution.. But today's orphans as we know them (without any parents) are very vulnerable and the foster system is infested with every kind of predator you can imagine... The number of orphans ruined by it and led into crime, drug use and poverty , shows you how big of a charity adoption is.
The verse has nothing to do with orphanage the prophet, companions & 2 best generations married multiple due to many reasons but this man is adding words to the original translation
Wow, I tried to read around 4:3 and found it completely incomprehensible. No context - who what when where why how. You are completely at the mercy of commentators or hadith writers who can make up just about anything to fit this verse. No wonder Dr. Ally chose a paraphrased translation, but any translation or commentary would have to insert a ton of extra words to make sense of it.
Are you able to say "I'll go to heaven 💯" through the Islamic faith ? It is not sure according to Quran. But true Christian say 💯 I'll go to heaven through the sacrifice blood of Jesus . Islam control people through hell fear ( if you don't do this and that u will go to hell), Allah never revealed himself anyone, no reply for prayers and no miracle still people need to do what was returned in Quran with people own strength, but Christianity not like that, god give his grace and holy spirit to do his will, answer prayers and do miracle cover people through the God's love. Think one time if Islamic fear bring you to dead end, what u will do? All religions says without sacrifice no redemption from sin. Do you have a experiences of joy of salvation, Free from sin, Forgiveness from sin, Free from fear of death, Born again experiences, Devine nature ....? If no, u can't enter to heaven. Those spiritual experiences we will received through the crucified Jesus. Jesus died on the cross for save you and me from hell. Please turn to Jesus. He is the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father(Heaven) except through Jesus. Dear Brothers and Sisters Jesus loves you...
Żalikal - documentation with way by instructing of practical with way. Islām requires documenting and documentation. Please emphasise this in your future videos. Thanks again. Assalamualaikum
Ofcourse it forbidden to married more than on. Married in real islam is not an joke its an very seriously step people making in them second life of living and thats why its soooooo important that boys and girls fallow the virgin harmony rules..its not about only them quality of living it has also to do with them reproduction. When you married the wrong one the love will not feeling for the child. There are more things also ... has to do with economic stumulation what you reproduce but not an child of living in peace and development in love
please see he is ahmadi viewpoint here that said dr shabbir said it is injustice to the first wife but is it no islam permits it like did cultures of those times and there is nothing wrong when you assume the mantle for a family other than your first wifes but it is clear it occurs when there is a shortage of men and children flourish not without them fathers they have so it is an exception that it is done and aisha had a suitor and the prophet asked for her hand in marriage even though the plan was for her marriage to him other and i know multiple marriages do occur in the heart of men while women are satisfied with one if he has faith for her and her childs needs so in this culture do allow it it is better than breaking the bond of marriage with first one he has and that is safe for your society as here men roam with access to women unlimited in kind and it is a better state to be married rather than adultery occur with death in spirit and children abandon law results there omar
First of all marriage is sacred. Stop assuming more than one wife is bad, it’s not. If it was bad, God wouldn’t have allowed the best amongst us humans (the prophets) to have more than one wife. A man marries a woman and she comes with a package of rights due to her. And in return man has his rights. As long as you fulfill the rights of each other, you’re a good human in the eyes of God. I just don’t understand why these people have to go out of the way to somehow subscribe to the view of one wife. If that’s what you want for yourself, go for it. But don’t talk for others please. God has clearly allowed it and kept it in the nature of the man too to be inclined towards doing it. As for the orphans, we should be good to them regardless of the marriage.
Affordability is not just justice,equality is not justice as some women may have more kids hence less time,equality is a lie justice is not leaving women alone every second day,nabi saw even split the nights
@@DheerajNavin-ln5wn no, it may be irrelevant today in some parts of the world, in other parts it's still relevant and it can become more relevant again
@@DheerajNavin-ln5wn It's illegal to marry more than one person in many countries, yet there are still christians and atheists with more than one partner - it has nothing to do with religion🤷 And why should it be ok to allow drugs like tobacco and alcohol, but marrying more than one person isn't ok? That makes no sense. Christian prophets also had more than one wife btw, king david in the bible had HUNDREDS of wives and concubines
@@FrankeNamensKarim The proud religious law-keepers came to Jesus. They tried to trap Him by saying, “Does the Law say a man can divorce his wife for any reason?” 4 He said to them, “Have you not read that He Who made them in the first place made them man and woman? 5 It says, ‘For this reason a man will leave his father and his mother and will live with his wife. The two will become one.’ 6 So they are no longer two but one. Let no man divide what God has put together.” (Matthew 19 :3-6). Monogamy was the norm intended in the Bible. If the prophets of the OT practiced polygamy it was in violation of God's laws.
Dear Dr Shabir Ally. I am a revert Muslim and your channel has removed all the doubts I had about Islam. My Allah bless you and guide the rest of the ummah to be as thoughtful as you.
@@sophiebjorkman2998 omg if you like him, you'll love khaled abou el fadl at the usuli institute. Omg.
This guy might be the only Islamic Scholar that I respect!!!!! He desrves the Identity of "A Scholar".
I know I might not agree with him on everything, but I cannot agree more with anyother.
If reverts need someone as a Basic Guide, I would no doubt recommend him.
I SALUTE YOU FOR THIS INTERPRETATION .. .THIS MAKES LOTS OF SENSE AND JUSTIFY THE WORD OF ALLAH . MAY ALLAH REWARD YOU
Excellent take on the verse. May Allah reward you.
How ironic is it that the verse is all about justice, yet some people use the verse to justify oppressing women by involving them in multiple wife positions when they dont want it. Before you yell at me at the replies, try to put your self into the shoes of those women. Thank you Dr. Ally for speaking out!!
@@aft0000 yup, it's the same with the verse allowing to slap the woman and it's the same with the verse about the woman being a field. Those verses have a reason and don't justify oppression, yet some people use them like that...
Muslim men must just do their level best to do justice and leave the rest to Allah. Even it’s difficult for parents to do justice among their children, or for a husband to do justice to his only one wife. No one is perfect but perfect intentions.
Couple of days ago I started reading Surah Nisa and It took me by surprise that the whole scenerio of marrying 2 3 4 was in a totally different context than what general perception was among the people. Quran is clearly talking about supporting the orphans.
Excellent explanation of this verse - thank you.
Since 2008 Israel in their efforts to occupy, killed 158,286 Palestenians, nearly all civilians, women, children, elderly,
since 2008 Palestenians in their efforts to defend against the occupation, killed 5,887 Israelis, mostly soldiers.
search '' The Human Cost Of The Israeli-Palestinian Conflict''
These values do not include the dead of 70+ years of occupation, does not include the millions of evicted people, does not include the millions of people afflicted by the conflict due to malnutrition, lack of medical servives, education loss, income loss, broken families etc etc etc.
While the occupiers celebrated what they were doing.
My country Turkiye has many times proposed that we muslims establish a peace keeping force and have our selves established in bases in Jordan and the region, but Arab countries have so far succummed to foreign pressures and not accepted such an offer, as yet.
To all the Arab brothers and sisters; without falling out of Islamic etiquitte and manners, and without endangering yourselves or others, please rally your leaders/governments, so we can get together and do what's needed to stop all this,
...condemnation, throwing an aid pallet or two from airplanes and posing for the cameras for the media isn't right, we need to establish a peace keeping force to stop the brutality.
We need to show a steady force, we need to first unite, please don't just watch, be active in your countries....
....and all nations can join in on this peace keeping force, from all corners of the world, all beliefs,
because this is about SANITY against INSANITY !
@@KenanTurkiye it's not the arabs fault, most arab countries with the strength or the money have civil war or they have a government ruled by zionists/American vassals...
I wrote about the issue in one of my books. Unfortunately most of our ulemas intentionally don’t mention the first part of the verse (4:3) where the clear condition is given, to hide it from the general Muslims. The verse revealed at a special circumstance after the Battle of Uhud when several companions were killed, ultimately leaving their wives and children vulnerable. The verse revealed to take care of the orphans at that dire situation. However, there is a general ruling for marriage in verse 24:32 which says, “Marry among you who are single…..”[Ankehu alayama minkum(i.e a man who has no wife and the woman who has no husband)]. It also should be borne in mind that Allah didn’t create multiple wives for Adam (pbuh). Most importantly, if Allah wanted to generalize it, He wouldn’t have to keep the world population’s proportion as 1:1.
What are some of your books titled ?
@@ahmfarooq1823 tru, but musa, daud, and so on also had multiple wives
@@HH-pv9ex Misconception about Islam, Realities of Muhammad’s (pbuh) Marriages, Misrepresentation of Islam, 100 Great Non-Muslims on Muhammad (pbuh), Misunderstanding Islam etc.
@@FrankeNamensKarim Prophet Muhammad (pbuh )also had multiple wives, but those are due to the required need and situation of that time. And those can’t be generalized in normal circumstances. Thanks. Jajak Allahu Khairan.
A man can marry upto 4 as long as he can be just that's what's the Quran clearly states. Why are other words being added to the translation?? The prophet, his companions, followers & follower followers married multiple wives due to many reasons not only to help orphans. Sheikh never try to corrupt Quran as Allah protects his religion U r killing ur time
The first time I heard about Kaskas translation. I will definitely check it out. Thank you, Dr. Shabir.
@@Simarodra Allah preserves his revelation as stated in the Quran this man is adding & subtracting words from the translations that's dangerous for him
Very good teaching.
That is only his own interpretation. Everyone has the right to have their own interpretation about polygamy as long as they have read all verses related to marriage carefully and ready to be questioned by Allah in the accountability process in the judgment day.
That's not how Islam works!! Imams and scholars are the ones who interpret not the common person, so no, you can't make up things in Islam
@@lussamhassan4561
As far as I know, the Quran was revealed to be understood by all mankind without exception. There is not a single verse in the Quran that prohibits ordinary people who are not scholars from studying it, and then he might have his own opinion without imposing it to others
Moreover, what is the definition of a scholar according to you? Are only those who graduate from Islamic universities entitled to be called scholar ? Can an autodidact not be called a scholar?
@@lussamhassan4561 scholars are normal people.
EVERYONE please make a playlist about Palestine like I have (4th playlist) and ask others to have such a playlist.
Or copy directly the list I have and ask others to copy it from you, and they ask others copy from them.
We need to spread the truth, millions, billions of us.
You've got the message Dr. ❤
Respectfully, why does he skip over the Malakat? ( Women who you Maintain) It says you can choose from them as well.
The verse is clear that one has to do justice and verse 4:129 makes it all the more clear, which states that we will never be able to do justice between our wives, even if it is our ardent desire
As-salaamu alaykum
I’m an “African American” Muslim. While my community didn’t fight in the battle of Uhud, we’re fighting the war against social ills that plague us and one of those is the family structure. African American muslimahs desire to be married. The pool of men from our community is small. There aren’t other Muslim men from other communities lining up to marry them and to be honest, from what I’ve seen, they prefer men from their own community. Polygyny in Islam is a remedy for this. Directly. Polygyny is also for the women, so that they can be married. Polygyny may not fit well in communities like yours but we have to understand, Islam reaches and is for the entire world. The entirety of mankind. I respectfully disagree with this position and the translation of the Qur’an that you’re using.
Since you’re taking a position of being a knowledgeable person of Islam, can you provide some alternatives for the “African American” muslimahs other than polygyny?
@@LucyLove1810Respectfully, I heard something different and I already know how many wives I can marry.
6:43 thats what batman wants
Again why are extra words are being added to the original translation? Islam is perfect & complete religion
Its weird throughout the translations, though still the general idea and the verses all have the same meaning from 1400 years ago to today unlike the bible with added verses if you compare manuscripts like codex sinaiticus, etc
You right they add words to change the meaning ie corrupters of the deen
@@scorpi6501 Quran is very crystal clear in it's meaning but ppl are trying to change meanings & that's stated in the Quran they will fail as fusha Arabic is a clear & direct language
Because Arabic is a deep language and to understand it you have to add words but in my opinion best practice is to bracket explanatory words so people don’t believe that they are part of the text
@@grinningchicken adding & subtracting words in Quran is kufr & that's stated in the Quran. Also it's stated that Quran is direct & clear revelation of God nothing to do with Arabic being deep this person changed the whole context of the verse & made the verse only about orphans by adding a word of his opinion...
The exgedusese of Aisha RA and Ibn massoud said : These verses were revealed to shun men who used to target /get married to orphan young girls , with the intention of treating her or giving her less rights than they would have rather given to women who have a strong family support. (Mainly, make use of their inherited wealth and give them less Mahr ...etc)
The instructions that followed were : If you fear you won't do justice to these vulnerable women/girls , therefore you better go marry two at a time (of those who aren't already suffering and do have a strong family support of men who will break your jaw if you are to mistreat her ) Mary two at a time or three at a time or four at a time .
If you fear that's something that will lead you to injustice . Then , only Mary one .
Thank you
Not quite. It clearly says to help orphans
If a man has good wifes who can controll themselfs, mind only their own marriage and don't think they have birthright to the man it can work just fine if everyone is willing to help.
You didn't listen to the video.
People who are interested in this particular topic must read " Letters to Tahir" by G.A. Pervez and " Fiqh Al Quran" by Maulana Umar Ahmed Usmani. Dr Shabbir Aly prolly has read it bcz this exactly what is discussed in great detail in those books
I prefer 2 but I don't have even 1!
Dr. Shabbir Ally is always interesting and never slanders Jesus, my lord, as cheeky and deluded dawahists do sometimes. Although I am Catholic I like him very much.
No Muslim could ever slander Jesus (AS), he is a respectable prophet for us.
@@blitzbreaker Good Information. Among the Muslims are good and bad ones , as everywhere.
It is blasphemous for any muslim to slander Jesus so the only time a muslim would do that is if they were insane.
@Chris-wr9hv Any person who "slanders Jesus" or any prophet cannot be a Muslim !! They need to repent.
2:285 The Messenger has believed in what was revealed to him from his Lord, and [so have] the believers. All of them have believed in Allah (God) and His angels and His books (Scriptures) and His messengers, [saying], "We make no distinction between any of His messengers." And they say, "We hear and we obey. [We seek] Your forgiveness, our Lord, and to You is the [final] destination."
Jesus (As)is not Lord,God is
It's best to come back to the real Qur'an, not the translations and their secular values. The first verb QST قسط it's about Proportion and not really "to be Just" as say Dr Ally and his english Qur'an. Which proportionne ? of what ? The number of wife, till 4 as says Allah in this verse. The noun الْيَتَامَىٰ is not exclusivly for children, but also woman because this word said that is about people who need to be adopted, marry, to be joined and be fully in a group, inserted in a family. And then come the verbe A'dala عدل and this one is about justice in the way that the just person need to take care of all matters, listen and study a matter to deliver decision. So this verse doesn't say only the injust person has right to take only 1 woman. Really, the english qur'an is not Allah's words, and the interpretations done on the false qur'an can't be taken in serious. Learn arabic, or make researches on ahadith, the sunna.
Thank you.
Wrong translation it doesn't say orphan mothers but the word An-nisa is used meaning women.
The verse is talking about orphans though.
@Lovergirl2466 By mentioning women, it becomes general rule not just only concerning orphans.
@muhammadislaam9911 what lol. If you can't take care of the orphans marry 2-4 women. If you find you can't take care of those women, marry only 1 (to take care of the orphan)
@Lovergirl2466 The point is that the scholar does not translate the verse correctly.
@muhammadislaam9911 I know ,it doesn't say orphans mothers. How could it? The verse says 2 or 3 to 4, no one has more than 1 mother. However the reason for extra marriage still stands- fearing you aren't able to take care of orphans.
Tariq Masood should listen to this as he advises men to marry multiple women even if the man is inquiring about keeping a pet dog 🙄
Man you didn't understand it just say if there is need to it like in today times there many many poor people widows so if there is need to it and you can do justice in between which is very difficult you should do it,
While tariq massod maybe telling because same reason the many women are helpless in this society so marry her
@Dr. Ally. What is to be done nowadays with surplus women? Should they just be patient in terms of their sexual and financial needs ?
No, they have to be leveraged by UNCAPABLE kids ,until they find their virgins
They should educate themselves, get a career, and stand on their own two feet.
@@LeanOnPlants what of their sexual desires which i think is naturally part of them ?
@@LeanOnPlants They would be called feminists,then if they do .
The only time they will be asked to go for a job increticised , is after they have been leveraged by the elites and passed around from one to another ,(with a pre-intention of divorce) because they were seen as low value unwanted goods from the get go .
THEN ,after their youth is taken away from them, they will be advised to go get a life (i.e a job ) and they will be told they have to stop crying about having no family or kids or companion because that's lack of Eeman
@ojammeh you'd rather take care of you sexual desires yourself, and when you find someone who is WORTHY of your hand in marriage, then marry him. But don't marry out of need.
Thank you
So if u can justice to orphans....this mean preference for widow and if u can justice to the children of that woman
We like revisiting matters that has already been conccluded and understood in a certain way by those who were present at the time of its revelation and those who followed them. You simply just need to read tafsir ibn kathir or other early tafsir to see that this explanation dosent fit
I don’t think that the Dr got this verse meaning correctly. Just to appear modern scholar or female rights activist you cannot change the meaning of Quran. When you say that it’s not just the verse of Quran but the understanding of Sahaba (R.A) you can see their practice of multiple marriages
Moreover the present situation of Divorced and widows in the community there is definite role of multiple marriages- the only condition mentioned is to treat justly
You still don't understand he didn't say now there is no need for example lets forget the war and say there is poverty in your area and there are many hopless women so you can compare it to those times when it was needed he didn't say there is no need of it today times
Dr. You are doing wrong translation and interpretation of that verse , firstly it’s not orphans mothers but orphans themselves and you are skipping regarding concubines the last part of that verse , fear Allah not fear men
Allahul musta’an. Oh muslims please see Tafsir ibn kathir of this verse. Modern day ‘intellectual’ interpretations of the book of Allah is misguidance
What makes a tevsir so special that it is needed to understand the message or the Qur'an of Allah? The person who writes the tafsir is ultimately reflecting his opinion and understanding of the Quranic verse with the knowledge and understanding he had at the time. Do you have to have two master's degrees, a PhD or a doctorate in Islam to understand the Qur'an? That can't be in the interest of Allah. Surely the religion can't be that complicated? I open the Koran, read it and try to put what I have read into practice. To be honest, I understand this verse just like Dr. Shabir Ally.
So if a Muslim man can provide for his 4 wives it was allowed the polygamy…
Well, why not? There are also European atheists who like polygamy and have relationships like that
@@FrankeNamensKarim , so what are they complaining about?? Polygamy is allowed in Islam!!!
@@olanmanila ok wait, I don't get your problem. Are you against polygamy or do you think it's ok?
@@FrankeNamensKarim , I’m against of polygamy my friend..
@@olanmanilathen listen to the video my friend? Did u not understand ?? 😂
100
Also why is cousin marriage allowed ? Please shed light on this also...
because God thinks its alright, remember Abraham marrying his niece/half-sister in the Bible?
Good question
Genetics proven other wise
Cuz Quran clearly states what a person can marry & not marry. And clearly states that a person can marry his cousins
Where is it illegal?
As a member of the labour party many years ago and fighting for equal rights for women.. even this presenter with head covered i find offensive
Polygamy is African too.
Liberalisation of Islam?
There are 2 billion of Muslims in the world.
One dollar a month, 2 billion dollars for all orphanage is quite sufficient to keep them alive.
Something is amiss some where 😅
Allah is referring to fatherless kids of single mothers, because women had very little to no economic freedom before the industrial revolution..
But today's orphans as we know them (without any parents) are very vulnerable and the foster system is infested with every kind of predator you can imagine... The number of orphans ruined by it and led into crime, drug use and poverty , shows you how big of a charity adoption is.
Most Muslims are not able
The verse has nothing to do with orphanage the prophet, companions & 2 best generations married multiple due to many reasons but this man is adding words to the original translation
❤
Wow, I tried to read around 4:3 and found it completely incomprehensible. No context - who what when where why how. You are completely at the mercy of commentators or hadith writers who can make up just about anything to fit this verse. No wonder Dr. Ally chose a paraphrased translation, but any translation or commentary would have to insert a ton of extra words to make sense of it.
@@peterhwang352 well, as a good muslim it should be normal to look into the context of the verses and to study the hadith
Does it not strike you that the perfect eternal speech of Allah is so dependent on shaky stories of men?@@FrankeNamensKarim
@@FrankeNamensKarimWe all know that most 'muslims' aren't even really muslim at all.
Are you able to say "I'll go to heaven 💯" through the Islamic faith ? It is not sure according to Quran. But true Christian say 💯 I'll go to heaven through the sacrifice blood of Jesus .
Islam control people through hell fear ( if you don't do this and that u will go to hell), Allah never revealed himself anyone, no reply for prayers and no miracle still people need to do what was returned in Quran with people own strength, but Christianity not like that, god give his grace and holy spirit to do his will, answer prayers and do miracle cover people through the God's love. Think one time if Islamic fear bring you to dead end, what u will do?
All religions says without sacrifice no redemption from sin. Do you have a experiences of joy of salvation, Free from sin, Forgiveness from sin, Free from fear of death, Born again experiences, Devine nature ....? If no, u can't enter to heaven. Those spiritual experiences we will received through the crucified Jesus. Jesus died on the cross for save you and me from hell. Please turn to Jesus. He is the way and the truth and the life. No one comes to the Father(Heaven) except through Jesus. Dear Brothers and Sisters Jesus loves you...
This typical misunderstanding come from a shallow understanding of the arabic verses.
Please go back to the original language
💯
Żalikal - documentation with way by instructing of practical with way.
Islām requires documenting and documentation.
Please emphasise this in your future videos.
Thanks again.
Assalamualaikum
Stop being so apolgetic Dr.Shabir... watch ahmed deedath
Ofcourse it forbidden to married more than on.
Married in real islam is not an joke its an very seriously step people making in them second life of living and thats why its soooooo important that boys and girls fallow the virgin harmony rules..its not about only them quality of living it has also to do with them reproduction. When you married the wrong one the love will not feeling for the child. There are more things also ... has to do with economic stumulation what you reproduce but not an child of living in peace and development in love
So marry one
??
Hmm
please see he is ahmadi viewpoint here that said dr shabbir said it is injustice to the first wife but is it no islam permits it like did cultures of those times and there is nothing wrong when you assume the mantle for a family other than your first wifes but it is clear it occurs when there is a shortage of men and children flourish not without them fathers they have so it is an exception that it is done and aisha had a suitor and the prophet asked for her hand in marriage even though the plan was for her marriage to him other and i know multiple marriages do occur in the heart of men while women are satisfied with one if he has faith for her and her childs needs so in this culture do allow it it is better than breaking the bond of marriage with first one he has and that is safe for your society as here men roam with access to women unlimited in kind and it is a better state to be married rather than adultery occur with death in spirit and children abandon law results there
omar
First of all marriage is sacred. Stop assuming more than one wife is bad, it’s not. If it was bad, God wouldn’t have allowed the best amongst us humans (the prophets) to have more than one wife. A man marries a woman and she comes with a package of rights due to her. And in return man has his rights. As long as you fulfill the rights of each other, you’re a good human in the eyes of God. I just don’t understand why these people have to go out of the way to somehow subscribe to the view of one wife. If that’s what you want for yourself, go for it. But don’t talk for others please. God has clearly allowed it and kept it in the nature of the man too to be inclined towards doing it. As for the orphans, we should be good to them regardless of the marriage.
Is Islam about marying wives???
If that's what you think, then you still have alot to learn.
Hijab 6th century toi toi mobile toilet till women moving in, you must oil it as 21st century mobile WC make a video
Modern apologetics?
That is exactly what is happening here. sad 😔
Its not modern its islam,justice is never possible so women can leave verse 4:130 so you either like it or get out of islam
Crass misguidance!!!
Why 4? What is magical about 4? Why not more if you can afford, just like the Prophet himself? More wives, more enjoyment.
Affordability is not just justice,equality is not justice as some women may have more kids hence less time,equality is a lie justice is not leaving women alone every second day,nabi saw even split the nights
So this verse is irrelevant in our modern time. Should this verse be abrogated then?
@@DheerajNavin-ln5wn no, it may be irrelevant today in some parts of the world, in other parts it's still relevant and it can become more relevant again
@@FrankeNamensKarim Polygamy is illegal in present day Canada and it should remain so due to our Christian values and worldview.
@@DheerajNavin-ln5wn
It's illegal to marry more than one person in many countries, yet there are still christians and atheists with more than one partner - it has nothing to do with religion🤷
And why should it be ok to allow drugs like tobacco and alcohol, but marrying more than one person isn't ok? That makes no sense.
Christian prophets also had more than one wife btw, king david in the bible had HUNDREDS of wives and concubines
@@FrankeNamensKarim The proud religious law-keepers came to Jesus. They tried to trap Him by saying, “Does the Law say a man can divorce his wife for any reason?” 4 He said to them, “Have you not read that He Who made them in the first place made them man and woman? 5 It says, ‘For this reason a man will leave his father and his mother and will live with his wife. The two will become one.’ 6 So they are no longer two but one. Let no man divide what God has put together.” (Matthew 19 :3-6).
Monogamy was the norm intended in the Bible. If the prophets of the OT practiced polygamy it was in violation of God's laws.
@@DheerajNavin-ln5wn why was it ok in the ot when god wasn't ok with it?
Islam says ghost and magic exist but i never seen it also is copy of Christianity
Quran two edge sword of deception