Josh Duggar Hauled Into Judge's Chambers After His Defense Fell Apart, What Did He Say to the Judge?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 29 дек 2024
- #JoshDuggar #TrueCrime
In December, Josh Duggar met privately in the judge's chambers to discuss the next steps of his case. The meeting with the judge followed a tense exchange between Josh's attorneys and the US Attorneys in chambers.
During the exchange, the US Attorneys revealed details about a witness that had not been publicly disclosed. They also discussed Josh's younger Brother Jed. The reason why Jed never testified is found within this discussion.
When the judge ruled against Josh, Josh gave up and folded his defense. Then he met privately with the judge. What did he say?
Disclaimer:
Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact. Katie Joy discusses trending topics, current events, reality tv & More. This channel is for your entertainment. Please make sure you conduct your own research on any topics to verify any information.
Support the Channel By Becoming a Member:
/ @withoutacrystalball
Follow Katie Joy on Social Media:
Instagram: / withoutacrystalball
Twitter:
/ woacbofficial
/ katiejoyyt
Facebook:
/ withoutacrystalball
Without a Crystal Ball is a commentary channel. The views expressed by Katie Joy are her opinions and should not be considered fact.
All Clips Obtained through TLC RUclips & Used under Fair Use:
All clips obtained through TLC RUclips and used under Fair Use:
The Copyright Laws of the United States recognizes a “fair use” of copyrighted content. Section 107 of the U.S. Copyright Act states:
“NOTWITHSTANDING THE PROVISIONS OF SECTIONS 106 AND 106A, THE FAIR USE OF A COPYRIGHTED WORK, INCLUDING SUCH USE BY REPRODUCTION IN COPIES OR PHONORECORDS OR BY ANY OTHER MEANS SPECIFIED BY THAT SECTION, FOR PURPOSES SUCH AS CRITICISM, COMMENT, NEWS REPORTING, TEACHING (INCLUDING MULTIPLE COPIES FOR CLASSROOM USE), SCHOLARSHIP, OR RESEARCH, IS NOT AN INFRINGEMENT OF COPYRIGHT.”
THIS VIDEO AND OUR RUclips CHANNEL IN GENERAL MAY CONTAIN CERTAIN COPYRIGHTED WORKS THAT WERE NOT SPECIFICALLY AUTHORIZED TO BE USED BY THE COPYRIGHT HOLDER(S), BUT WHICH WE BELIEVE IN GOOD FAITH ARE PROTECTED BY FEDERAL LAW AND THE FAIR USE DOCTRINE FOR ONE OR MORE OF THE REASONS NOTED ABOVE.
It’s amazing to me how these so called Christians, can try to frame an innocent man without even blinking an eye! Jim Bob knows that Josh is guilty, yet has no problem accusing Caleb of this heinous act. Caleb should sue the Duggars for defamation of character.
To be clear, Caleb is not "innocent", he's pretty gross and predatory himself, but yes, he is innocent of the crimes Josh was on trial for. And the Duggars are truly evil IMHO.
@@ladyv5655 in this case he is innocent
A lot of evil is hiding behind religion and these parents have alot of secrets.
And Caleb has an airtight alibi. It just shows how dishonest and unchristian these louts are.
@@ladyv5655 you cannot compare Caleb's crime to Josh's disgusting crimes. Yes, Caleb did wrong, but nothing compared to josh.
The fact that they were fine with bearing false witness against Caleb Williams is quite telling of the moral character of Josh, his lawyers, and possibly JB and Jed.
Oh we know it all comes back to JB. He’s the “patriarch.” He controls everyone and everything.
*WHAT MORAL CHARACTER???*
Tbh I'm not that mad at his lawyer bc this is part of the job description of a defense attorney. Try to raise reasonable doubt by any means necessary. A defense attorney of an obviously guilty person is really just trying to raise doubt. This lawyer wasn't great bc he tried to feign innocence rather than only look for loopholes but he was still just doing his job
@@lauraklabe2259
Absolutely.
A defense attorney is just doing his VERY IMPORTANT job.
I should have clarified, I was talking about Josh, Jed!, & JB.
Thank you for mentioning that! 💗
@@redwoodrebelgirl3010 yea I feel bad for ~some~ DA's bc most prosecutors have to start out as DA's. Its like a training requirement. Some just get a bad rep bc of the mandatory job. Not all though
Thank you Katie for keeping us updated. Josh makes my skin crawl. Hope Anna wakes up soon. Glad he is behind bars. Throw away the key!!
Me too!!
I believe you have described perfectly, the effect of Josh Duggar! He does make one’s skin crawl! There is no better description!
I am ready for Josh to go away for at least 25 years.
Me too!
I'm ready also.
Yes!!!
40 years and 500k fine is minimum acceptable to me
They do religious but have no problem lying in COURT or out of COURT.
He's guilty plain and simple put him away for rest of his life. I'm so glad that someone else is not being convicted for his actions. I pray for his kids and hope they get the counseling they are going to need.
Oh me too!! So glad those plans didn’t pan out!!
His kids will not get counseling! It is evil to use a secular counselor. So thinks the duggars.
Yes could you imagine if trying to pin it on Caleb had worked?! How horrible on so many levels.
His kids will def need counseling - not just from being raised in this environment but I would also suggest that there may be a chance his kids have been abused as well. He was growing his own little harem of abuse victims and his wife wasn't doing anything to stop it.
I pray Anna gets a grip and opens her eyes otherwise those children have no chance and will be so mentally fvcked
I feel bad for Caleb Williams, because up until now his previous charges were never explained. I've been assuming that he did something similar to Josh & not that he had a teenage girlfriend, who was probably only a few years younger than him. That is a HUGE difference!
A lot of men on the sex offender registration were 18 to 20 guys dating/having intimacy with 14 to 17 year old girls. Not at all the same as a 21+ year old doing it with an minor. And definitely not the same as Josh.
A few years underage is still underage ffs
@@erismana2105 yes, I agree it’s still underage but it’s STILL a big difference!! And I don’t believe he had anything to do with the cp on Josh’s computer. Obviously using him as a scapegoat.
@@Deer548 these idiots trying to match Caleb's crime to Josh's. How can anyone compare the two??? It's like trying to compare some guy that peed outside and someone R-ing toddlers and they are both sex offenders now.
@@erismana2105 yes, because that compares to a baby being tortured and R by a grown man...keep telling yourself that.
It was a "caught red handed" moment.
For Caleb’s sake, I’m glad he didn’t testify. But if he did, that would have been hilarious because they have so much proof he wasn’t there
I'm obsessed I've been catching up with the whole trial with you. You do good work and sooooo excited to hear more!!
I can see Josh trying to influence the Judge and swear by his faith that he is innocent....you know, typical greasy persuasion!!!
Ugh! Yes, greasy is a word that describes him well. He's just disgusting.
Thank you for a very clear view of that mess. He still deserves 40 +years!!!!!
People that exploit and harm children make me sick!!
Im still wondering what is JIM BOB hiding?! I know he has to be hiding something other than trying to hide joshes disgusting behavior.
He's probably the start of it.
You look like you're finally feeling better, Katie. Thank you so much for going through these transcripts for us! We know it's a lot of work.
As a Christian you are taught the 10 commandments, one of them being…
You shall not bear false witness against your neighbor. How can JB say he is a Christian & then tell his son Jed to do just that? Those kids have to be a mess as they are taught mixed messages.
So glad that in the end, Josh was convicted. Think Jed could of gotten in trouble if he had testified, But he ole JB a would of been safe 😡! JB is a monster! Thank You Katie! 💞
I can’t wait until Josh is sentenced! He belongs in jail for at least 30 years.
Can’t wait to hear more!!!!
I just want Josh sentenced and put away.
With you!
This is the other slap that does not seem to ever go away!!! ... You doing a great job Katie Joy I appreciate what you bring to the table! 🤗
Absolutely this just keeps getting worse for Josh. And Katie is the best.
Maryam Al Fayed, we almost have the same name!
Katie is a true rockstar!!!!
The judge did that so that latter Josh can't say he had inadequate representation. The judge has it on record that josh is being represented very well
Judge has no right to talk with Josh privately. It's against the law!
Yep!! I like this Judge!!!!
@@alejandraalejandra4700 -Not always true … if Josh and his attorney consented to a one-on-one requested by the judge, then it’s not illegal. The judge wanted to make sure that Josh fully understood his rights as far as testifying and wasn’t being intimidated or influenced in any negative way by his attorneys. It is not uncommon for a judge to have a one on one meeting like that in felony cases given the seriousness of the crime and prolonged incarceration. This judge has been so careful to do everything by the book so this conviction doesn’t get overturned on appeal, and I find it hard to believe he would do something that’s illegal or gives attorneys grounds to get a new trial.
@@alejandraalejandra4700 not true
@@alejandraalejandra4700 I believe his lawyers were present.
Wow. The fact that this trial transcript is thousands of pages long, and the trial was only a week long (right?) makes me wonder: OJ Simpson’s trial was about six weeks long…how long was THAT transcript 😱?
They need to give Josh 50+years and never let him out, he’ll just do it again if he’s free
You are correct,he definitely WILL re-offend. It is a proven fact that pedophiles will always be just that. For the sake of all children in JD's range,keep him locked up tight!
I hope he hadn't already touched his children in a bad way ,he should never get out of prison
Holy crap can you imagine trying to pin this horrible stuff on a completely innocent person? 😳
keep him and throw away the key
Josh went crazy on the “web” when Caleb was hired! He honestly thought he would never get the blame. He has a clean record and Caleb didn’t. That proves how inflated his ego is… don’t get me started on how he thinks he’s the smartest person on earth…next to his dad Jim Slob!
I love the Jim Slob bit!!!! You gave me a good chuckle!!!!
Lmao Jim Slob!! Love it
"Jim Slob" ....brilliant!! 🤣🤣
@@MittensForKittens2 I’m glad you like it! But I can’t take credit for it. I read it in a comment once and I laughed until my stomach hurt!🤣🤣
Caleb is a disgusting person, too, but it is truly sociopathic how Josh and Jim Boob ( that's my favorite name for him) think they would make Caleb the fall guy for Josh's crimes.
I’m glad the court does not allow random accusations of ppl to be used as a defence.
I just want to know if he did anything to his own children.
Why wouldn't he???
He preyed on his sisters & babysitter .
That was HARDER to get away with.
I bet he has. It was too easy to get away with in his own home. Anna wouldn't have done anything to stop him or help her kids when he did. I'd put money on it and I'm not a betting person unless I know I'm gonna win.🤷🏿♀️🤷🏿♀️🤷🏿♀️
I have no doubt he did things to his children. Pedos do not change, ever.
@@redwoodrebelgirl3010 yep! And he had such EASY access to his children! Sickening.
I hate to say this but I would be very surprised if he didn't do anything to his kids. I think Josh is a disgusting piece of you know what.
Josh will NEVER acknowledge his evil behavior. And sadly, his wife and several others will continue to support and defend him. So much for facts and evidence when it’s not what you want to hear and believe.
I used to be a court reporter, and I can tell you 8 volumes of transcript is *h-u-g-e* ! I know it's their job to produce the transcript, but it is still a very large task!
Thank you for the video. I can't wait for the next show.
how do people remember what happened on what date? I have a hard time remembering yesterday!!
So, basically, Jed was going to get on the stand and lie, and testify that Csleb was working at the lot, knowing full well he wasn't?? Did josh's attorney explain to him that perjury is illegal??
Such great Christians.
Jim Bob perjured himself as well, seems to be a family tradition. Jed would have been more than happy to do that!
Basically
Can’t wait to hear more of the transcript
I still think in the end... Josh will throw his attorneys under the bus in a Hail Mary appeal and say he deserves the verdict to be thrown out or he deserves a new trial due to ineffective attorneys. Josh will keep appealing until Jim Bob stops paying the lawyers.
If the FBI showed up at my work and was asking me these questions. My response wouldn’t be “I don’t want to say I’m not guilty “, etc. I’d be “hell no I didn’t do that and my passwords are…..”. He’s disgusting!
Geez, dude should had taken that plea deal...
Thanks for this. I enjoyed hearing this information. I'd rather not guess what was said in chambers etc. Glad you updated us. Thanks again! 💚💚
The Judge wanted to show that Josh was fully informed about his right to testify so he couldn’t later claim he wanted to testify but his attorneys kept him from doing so.
I didn't realize the court docs would also release the discussion in judge's chambers. Very interesting!!
Good afternoon Katie. Hope you had a great weekend.
I kinda feel that the other 2 people most likely were not called because of the same reasons celeb wasn’t. They could prove they weren’t present and the defense was trying to throw people under the bus to create reasonable doubt. I actually feel sorry for celeb. Our family will help you as long as we don’t find a reason to use you. All the values right out the window. I look forward to hearing more. Thank you for reporting on the new information just released. I look forward to hearing more.
Yeti yup pypooo
Can’t wait for the updates. We need something to pass the time as we wait for this new sentencing date they scheduled.
If Josh wants redemption, he should just admit what he done and accept his punishment. It makes me sick he's trying to get out of this.
Great video Katie
Curiosity... why was Jill listed as a possible witness.
I am addicted to your channel, Katie! I watched this video before my head came off the pillow this morning. You're the best and you look like you're feeling better.
Two in a row!! Thx for all your great work. Glad you're feeling better. 😊
In opening statements you can say whatever you want and don't have to follow up or anything, or that's what I went through as a juror. I was amazed. Glad Caleb had such a rock solid alibi. If be like idk where I was. What does my phone say?? Help!!??
Only one comment….JOSH’S GOOSE IS COOKED!!!!! 😂🤣😂😂🤣🤣🤣
Katie: thank you for the clarification as to why Jed was not called to testify…. Any insight about why Jill was prepared to testify and then not called?
I’m disgusted that they would plot to blame Caleb. Makes me sick
Thank you for bringing this info to us. It is so interesting.
katy you have the best videos ever you go girl!!!
Can someone please give me a link to the transcript of the trial? Thanks!
It's OK to lie if you are protecting your clan...not
Hi katey joy
You look great
Thanks for another great duggar dive
JAIL TIME
St. Louis in da house!
I wanted to go through the transcripts. Just too much for my dyslexic brain. I much prefer you providing the interesting info, Katie!
I will be doing videos about the transcripts all week
@@WithoutACrystalBall - SWEET! Thank you!!!
Thank you Katie!
@@WithoutACrystalBall Thank you Katie for all you do for us. So glad to see that you are feeling better!
Of all the things they have done, I feel like what they did to Caleb Williams is among the worst.
Katie, as always, I love your clothes.
Thank you!
Where do I go to read these documents? What is the site?
Just finished the video about Anna at the wedding.
Great job on this, Katie. You are doing wonderful work.
Love that you’re going into detail on all this
This is really interesting! I appreciate all the work you put into these videos! I have learnt a lot about the court/ legal system through your videos. Excellent reporting! Thank you!
I have been waiting for this!!!! Sorry you have so much heavy reading to do. Go easy on yourself
I would like to be able to go back and watch every show, from the beginning. I watched this family faithfully, wishing that I had been part of this wonderful family etc. It would be I interesting to go back and be able to re watch it all through a different set of eyes.
Many scenes will have you double taking
@@rainbowintheskylie right???
I never wanted to be part of these cult weirdos.
It all seemed contrived & I never saw LOVE there, or anything that looked like real happiness.
Plus, I already grew up in a cult.
They always struck me as creepy, & I was not at all shocked when a paed*phile came to light.
I, frankly, believe that many more (in this family & cult) will come to light before the fat lady sings. 💔
Good information Katie! I always appreciate your work🌸
Just finished the one before this! Love it!!! 2 in a row!
Thank you for all you do once again another fabulous video.
Is it normal for the defendant 2 meet privately w the judge 2 talk?
I wonder if the judge was circumventing an appeal based on ineffective council. I could see Josh saying he wanted to testify and his lawyers wouldn't allow it and try to get an appeal on those grounds.
He is not going to be able to blame anyone else.. His lawyers did not make any serious mistakes.
@@truffles2721 you are right but I can see him trying
The judge cut him down at his knee’s at every turn …In the end Josh will not have a leg to stand on!! He messed with the WRONG judge..I think Josh has met his match he has finally found someone he cannot manipulate!!
If a defendant wants to testify they are allowed. Their lawyers can advise against it, but they can't stop them .
Btw... keep up this excellent service 💜
Was just starting to read the transcripts-this is better!
Do you have a link to get the court transcripts?
I would like that link too please
@@cathynuytten798 it’s on PACER you have to sign up for the account and then pay a small fee for the documents if you choose to view them
Great job, Katie.
Duggar Jim Bob and Michelle should be ashame of there selfs very sickening parents .
When is the sentencing???
Has there been a sentencing yet?
Probably unpopular opinion but I think the judge should I have let him just because he said, “no, not at this the time”. Which could prove he didn’t understand the consequences of not testifying. He could also say his attorney didn’t explain it to him and he didn’t trust his councils judgment. Why? Because he may have an easier time at an appeal after sentencing. It’s always possible. Remember, the judiciary system is corrupt, and money talks. While the Duggars may not be as wealthy as they once were, they know plenty of people that are.
I don’t think they can manipulate this judge and they know it!!
@@biancacox9699 sure, but if he wins an appeal, he would get a new judge
Wow! This makes me think of his Judgement day What is excuses do you have left Josh? How can you possibly be saved when you stand in front of God? Going down this road I don't see His Judgement Day after he dies being any different. Excuse maker blamer we can see right through you!!!!
Everyone can be saved on judgment day even the worse of the worse our God is loving and all forgiving even if we dont understand so we really should not bring God into this mess that is between Josh and his God period!
Repentance is the only way to be forgiven.
If he has repented of his sins his judgement day will be fine.
Jamie bourgeault you don't understand God obviously. Everyone certainly will NOT be forgiven by God at judgement. Certainly those that haven't repented of their sins. Duggar won't even acknowledge that he is guilty to the court. No I hardly think so.
@@theresadouglas6529 I hope that he has accepted Christ already. If not, I pray that he does. As christians we should hope that for everyone. Remember even Dahmer had accepted Jesus b4 his death. There is no sin so bad that Jesus cannot forgive
Could someone please tell me when Josh is going to be sentenced??
May 25 sentencing day
Thank you 😊
The sad thing about this is that it paints a dirty picture of Christians. It gives them a bad name. Can I just say ALL Christians do not fall into this category. I am one and I do not approve of lying, period. JB supposedly went on TLC all those years ago in order to spread the Gospel. Now look. I am not to judge but obviously something doesn't add up here. That makes me sad for the Christians who try to live by Godly principles.
Well done with all of your efforts here Katie. I support you for what you do and I hope for the best with your channel and your personal life as well. Keep up the great work and giving us the information that you provide. It’s clearly very well done and you inform people about things that we wouldn’t know without you, or would have to be doing ourselves to get the information you have. I respect your efforts and pray for your success.
Great job Katie, on the coverage, ,
Didnt we already know this though? Like why those guys weren't called and the discussions in chambers - it was hashed it out in their post trial motions/responses/decisions
There have been no decisions post trial
Josh could have shared the videos. With some of the other Duggar boys. Guys, are interested in anything having to do with S-Acts. But, Josh is the sickest, in that clan.
I doubt Josh is the only one, & I even doubt that he is the WORST among them (family, or cult). 💔
They are a DISGRACE
When will josh find out how many years he'll spend in prison and at which prison? I can hardly wait!!
When is his sentencing??
Someone here said May 25.
Can anybody explain why it benefits Josh for them to delay his sentencing??
After sentencing, Josh will go to federal prison, which will be worse for Josh than the jail he is in now.
Great question ⁉️⁉️⁉️ I've been trying to figure it out myself.
Thanks y'all, that makes total sense.
Delay delay delay. Doesn't want to go to club fed.
@@mariettaberry1711 so he is a scared baby now, not a hero anymore?
First up from Sacramento!
From Chico!
I lived in Vacaville….I love that area!
Do you think Jim bob knows the truth or does he believe Josh's lies
I think he knows the truth but will never say it publicly
JB. Knowa
Knows
I think he knows and maybe has been involved in something that Josh knows about
Tbh I think he could have abused his own children just like his own sister's. Anna is so naive and won't open her eyes, so do u really think she would come out and say he did if he did? NO she wouldn't. I don't feel for Anna at all.
I agree on all points.
Maybe it’s me and doing the guilty by association thing … but creeps usually talk about their creepy behavior. So who else knew about what was on that computer and what was on it ? My point being - I believe Caleb wasn’t there on the day for those Specific dates (who knows what else and when josh accessed anything I’m sure it wasn’t the first time ) what a weird timing to be getting a new phone.
I’m from Australia, Caleb wouldn’t even be on the list here, legal age to consent to have in “relations” is 16 except for in two sates where it’s 17 but in those states from the age of 16 you can have “relations” with someone who is up to 2 years older than you without the older party being prosecuted. Also if you are between 16-17 you can have “relations” with someone up to 2 years younger than you and not be prosecuted I believe nation wide, if not in all but 1 or 2 states, and if both are underage neither can be prosecuted.
Since the videos had literal babies in it getting SA nobody can argue consent. A minor can't consent to P videos for any reason. Even if a teenager is caught with such images will get charged. 18 is the age of consent for such images.
Caleb was 23 and the girl was 16, but he was messing with her for 3 years before that!
@@DANNYTHEFROG123 I wasn’t talking about the videos, I was talking about the girl he got pregnant.
Just bc they CLAIM to be Christians doesn't mean they are. The Bible teaches You Reap What You Sow.
This Josh Duggar fiasco has given christians a bad name
What is the last thing he says to the sheriff in the opening of this vid. I can hear search it nothing else. X
Whether or not Josh abused his own children, I can't wrap my head around what his children have been told and will be told when he goes to prison. They are so close in age but Mackenzie is 12 and I'm sure she'll figure things out on her own. Sadly, I think Anna will tell the kids that Daddy is innocent and shouldn't be in prison. Those poor kids! She won't be able to keep them off of the computer forever. Josh even said that the kids know his password to play games, etc.
I can bet he did things to his kids. I hope he goes away as long as the law allows.(he deserves life and all the other pedos!)
@@Justagirlnamedshawn I think he did too. I hope the children are in therapy now but since they don't really believe in it I doubt they are. If not, that is not only selfish of the parents but also unfair to the childrens' mental health and well being.