Palestinians: Would you marry a Jew?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 22 авг 2015
- This project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/coreygilshuster
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
People ask Israeli Jews, Arabs and Palestinians questions. I go out and ask random people to answer.
I live in the West Bank, and there's no mixing between the Palestinians and Israeli Jews, we don't share our schools, we don't share our epicenters where we shop, work, and play, etc. There aren't very many opportunities for this scenario to take place. I know it's a hypothetical question, but it's still absurd. Technically speaking, Muslim men are allowed to marry people of other Abrahamic faiths, and lots of them do when they live abroad and such, and they don't face any problems for it either. I'm 100% sure that if that question were to be asked to a practicing religious Jew their answer would be a resounding 'No' with no stipulations required. They aren't allowed to marry anyone outside of their faith whether male or female.
You are right.
I'm a American Muslim alot of Muslim brothers date and marry women of different faiths but women in my culture wouldn't maybe because she know the brothers will dislike her and call her names . African American Muslims are very overprotective with women .
Usually when we marry outside Islam it doesn't work anyway I personally wouldn't do it
We can be friends Jewish and Arab men. But marriage outside both peoples is forbidden. However, there is Romeo and Juliet. Young fools who seek a forbidden love that will end in death.
Lots of Muslim men abroad enter into interfaith relationships/marriages?!?! YOU ARE DREAMING!
Tbf there aren't many of them, they need to marry within the community to keep up the number of Jews. There are less Jews than there were before the Holocaust (or at minimum much fewer than there should be), and even fewer practicing Jews.
@@TheHoodVoice2024 It is forbidden in Islam for women to marry non-Muslim men.
I'm half Jewish and Russian my wife is a Libyan Muslim and she is my world! Some of these people have a lot of hate and fear there heart. It's sad.
It is normal because Jews and Christians consider Muslims to be enemies and foreigners
@@samirdizco2759 It's primitive, uneducated and sad
I wish you all the best , true love is a blessing . I have a friend she is muslim and im a jew (we both from isreal) and we love each other and having fun i say we all need to be free
@@samirdizco2759 some Muslims Christians and Jews think that, it doesn't make it normal, just sad
@@theholypootischurch same too you! Wish you a lifetime of happiness 😀
As a Jew I pray for peace and happiness in the middle-east and the world. When I see these people, regardless of what they think of others due to the circumstances that were created, I see brothers and sisters. We are all brothers and sisters and any loss of life is a devastating thing. 🙏🏻🌎❤️
I hope so, cuz we are all human beings and all religion sent upon to the earth is for seeking peace. But many human misinterpretation with essence what religion means. Btw im Indonesian Moslem and i happy know there's still people like u around this world today. Thank you for spread peace 🙏🏻 ♥️
Fadl Aziz thank you aziz!
As a spanish muslim I appreciate your comment and know many jews that have your view peace be apon you sir.
joey dediashvili I honestly agree with you. We are all brothers and sisters, love has no colour or religion, may one day we have peace in this world🙏🙏🙏🙏
Souad Clarke beautifully said! ❤️✨
How fun is when you know the both languages and you don't have to read subtitles or translation 😅
Samira Habib LOL I feel the same way sometimes but certainly not in this video!
Razumijete li moj jezik?
@@jehudabenhorin1329 da
@@jehudabenhorin1329 tak
lucky you!! I have the same with Finnish and Swedish,I understand and speak both,it is nice to be bilingual!
10:08 he got game lol
fr
Lol the 1st guy says she has to convert for him? I always heard that if you want to convert to Islam it has to be for Allah and not because of someone you love. Someone?
+LeSdfDu95 C'est le cas, mais il ne faut pas compter sur les musulmans de nos jours pour appliquer ce genre de principes. Toutes les valeurs et les principes moraux se perdent et les musulmans n'en font qu'à leur tête. Le problème c'est que les non musulmans croient que chaque musulman dans le monde applique à la lettre les principes du Quran, ce qui n'est pas le cas, et cela amène beaucoup à confondre musulmans réels et islamistes/ terroristes...
+LeSdfDu95 lol i thought the same hahah
+LeSdfDu95 Correct, but bear in mind that he's speaking the semantics of his own language, hence something rendered in English may not carry the same implications in Arabic. and vice versa. So the translator may have not been clear on what she meant to him when speaking in Arabic and vice versa when she translated from Arabic to English.
+Kristiemyluv “KristieMyLuv” Lubu Many Muslims ( not all) just have standards they hold by, just because you don't like those standards or because you have an inferiority complex since your standards are lower, doesn't mean Muslims are brainwashed, in fact it could mean you're brainwashed.
+Kristiemyluv “KristieMyLuv” Lubu So because you perceive Muslims as taking their standards more seriously, you resent Muslims. You seem to believe lowered standards and freedom are the same thing. They're not. Also your notion that "beheading" is the punishment for this is totally absurd and not evidence by any doctrine.
people often forget friendship , they can all be friends but when it comes to marrying it's more intimate
Brother you forgot the politics, israeli government hunt and kill palestinians, thats a fact. It doesnt mean all jews are like that, oh definetly not, but the government is. You need to understand that, at the end we all believe into the one and only god !
People in the West Bank the Jews and Muslims are separated from each others in schools ; works so how they want them to be a friend 😂
Really great content. Keep up the good work
This kind of stuff is great.
We need to get people thinking about each other as human and to talk to each other.
Well done
it’s not Jews are smart
@@incogb6696
please rephrase that/ I dont understand what you are saying.
This is SO valuable.. such great material. Thanks for doing this!
4:50 my man knows what's up
Salam subscribe shokran Salam ruclips.net/video/L4lssaLjmHA/видео.html
Thing is both sides can say the same about the other. It's sad.
@@daniev6 no lmao. One has the power and the other doesn't
@@daniev6 hhhh they are all mixed
I just looove your channel, man! Keep up the good work and keep asking them questions! 👍
I am Lebanese and I am in love with an Ashkenazic Jew and I honestly think that you can't ask this kind of question to a people that are in direct conflict with each other at this moment I don't blame either side if they have hate to each other I don't think most people understand
I know a Lebanese who married an Ashkenazi Jew.
Sharmota
You are Lebanese (westernized) by about 85% , i dont think you fully comprehend whats really going on inside most of the Arab emotions toward Israelis injustice toward Palestinian people, for you look at it from “Western point of view”
Disgusting animal.
Does he recognise Palestinian sovereignity?
"theres no one better than the Palestinian women" 10:10
The translator blushes
Translator do be shy doe lmao
Bull Crap
@@jewchristian3082 u mad babygirl?
@@yousefalshiekh4074 ☪️ Islam is a Satanic Religion
@@yousefalshiekh4074 You Are So Brain 🧠 Dead. Jesus Christ is The Son of God and There is Evidence to Back it Up.
Jesus is God in the Flesh. Can You Prove Your False God Allah Exist ?
The way you ask the question changes their answers from NO to YES with exception of the last one . This proves they're generally not racist but angry people .
@@nexusanphans3813 it just shows how the women are being so disrespected compared to men. If I was a Muslim woman I would convert to Christianity or Judaism for getting basic permissions like marrying whoever I want.
@@unholygremlinug8786 both judaism and christianty disallow marrying outside the religion.
@@anon-iraq2655 yea but no one cares about that
@@mhmidk4639 plenty care
@@anon-iraq2655 maybe in the christianty
You don't need to marry someone to show you respect them
Exactly some just marry for material gains
It is too bad Corey Gil-Shuster's "The Ask Project" was not allowed when I was in junior high or high school. It would have been pretty interesting to have seen this is a Social Studies class. If this is successful enough, than maybe we could have more videos like this in other parts of the world: Australia, Philippines, Polynesian Islands, Tibet, etc.
I wish the host would after the person interviewed said no to marrying "jew and Israel" his next question is "Jew but not from Israel" I would love to see how many of them are fine with a Jew, if they are not from Israel.
I feel like a lot of these people have some very reasonable opinions considering that they have been in a racial war for a looooong time. It's understandable. but they answer very respectfully.
I respect that.
Informative video.
if it was the other way around, they would be crying Islamophobia. Double standards
@@Neothefish no one is crying islamophobia,they just to want be Palestinian in Palestine.
"Would you marry a Jewish woman?"
*Long discussion*
"He says yes..."
"Oh!"
"... To being filmed."
"Oh."
It’s a hard question during conflicts and wars, Same as if you are asking a jew to marry a nazi back in 1940s
😂😂😂😂😂
Yes, I was thinking the same thing. Or asking a French person whether they'd marry a German while France was under Nazi occupation. Also, when you say the word Jew to a Palestinian, they automatically equate this with Israeli or Zionist, since most of them have had no other experience of Jews.
@@zakmartin
Not the same thing.
A muslim marry a muslim.
@@ShuttingRetroM1N3CR4FT All religion is nonsensical. There is no god. There are only ignorant, superstitious people who are too weak willed and feeble minded to rely on their own resources.
@@zakmartin
This has nothing to do with what i'm saying, i'm talking about what these people think, for them, a muslim can only marry a muslim, so example with just ennemy countries is invalid
The guy at 4:48 seems like a really intelligent young man.
Yeah, I really like how he explained it. It's not just about religion.
"she wasn't born yesterday" that's weird, though.
KPopsicleSNSD he's saying she has a past and can't really change her views overnight
KPopsicleSNSD Do you think he is native speaker? What you're writing is stupid.
Kamal Muheisen I see, thx
They don't have to marry, all they have to do is stop killing each other. Martin Luther King said, (I'm paraphrasing): you don't have to like me, but you have to respect me. I don't like or agree with a lot of people, but I always show respect to them. Interestingly, when I get to know them, more than likely, I start liking them.
Martin Luther king? Where are you from?
Good
"just don't hate each other lol! Ignore the fact that they invaded your land!" Let me guess, you are american?
@@mw00295 because of a war wich the arabs started
Martin Luther King also said Israel has an unequivocal right to exist.
The last boy must have a very heart wrenching story to tell
Looks like it.
Properly PTSD
I felt it too
if he was real Muslim he never said this shit but he is just a Muslim with name nothing else
@@rexhepsaiti4986 you don't know his story, so stop judging him based on one line. They are getting killed every single day and all you doing for them is judge the oppressed? Let Allah judge us, stop your baseless judgement.
“That might be a good relationship”
HAHAHAHA
Very interesting video! Keep up the questions! Stay safe!
4:48 I can c the pain of betrayal in his eyes 😔 he doesn't care about the religion but the state Israel 😔😔
What are you talking about? I only see hate
@@nad1ax2 Being anti Zionist doesn't make me anti Judaism
@@muhanadm.shakir236 yes it does.
@@mika-kv6tz no it doesnt
@@mika-kv6tz No, it doesn't
Zionist= Neo-Nazzi
They killed, slaughtered Palestinians. even members of the British army by exploding barrel bombs they are terrorists supported by corrupted media
I enjoyed this video, my dad and his family have always had contact with a palestinan gentleman, Sam, he was so cool, I remember him still, I wish we had stayed in contact.
Absolutely no surprises here. Great job, BTW, as usual.
you are doing great job
It's so sad, that there are so many divisions about this. We all are from One God and we should all love and respect each other. AMEN
You haven't tried living in the middle east i guess...
Easy to say when you're not a literal second class citizen with no equal rights in an illegitimate apartheid State
Let's get married den Martina😉
Thank you everybody for educating me and raising these points.
@Aryan Kumar force?!?!?
I really love how you never get angry
Coz he knows what Israel doing to Palestinians.
@@sharuk98ala no,he is just objective
@@Србомбоница86 he literally talk about occupation.
nice post !
Love how calm the guy in red answer to the question..
It is complete nonsense asking a member of a people who have been dispossessed, forced out of their own land into ghettoes, who are discriminated and abused because of their race and religion if they want to marry someone from the group that treats them like dirt.
Salim Al-Jabry Millions of people understand but the Western media pretends that we don't.
+Michael Howley It's the only way to deal with brainwashed sharia-law terrorist individuals.
Peter Hoffman All muslim resistance was secular for decades. The rise of radical Islam came when these movements were crushed. The source: Saudi Arabia, ally of the US. First outing a joint effort to spread radical Islam to Afghanistan.
The real cause of Palestinian grievance has everything to do with dispossession and brutal repression...
Terrorism is a response to injustice and "industrial" "legally approved" murder, torture and apartheid, the terror of depleted uranium. white phosphorous and chemical poisoning.
absolutely an excellent comment
The person who wants to marry them obviously loves them and would not do what his people did if they are ready to marry a person of a different religion and race.
You are making history my dear friend Corey.
4:48 this guy seems quite convincing with his logic.
Good and evil aren’t the same; counter evil with goodness, and if there was any enmity between you and the other, he)she will become a dearest friend.
Al-Qur'aan
I like the one saying "there is no woman more beautiful than the palastinian woman" real talk brother
Beauty is subjective, and thinking that your women are inherently better than others is the result of either narcissism or ignorance.
like the palastain woman that tried to blow herself up in a hospital full of sick children last year
she was a real "bomb"
if u know what I mean. 😑
+הודיה בר יוסף
you make jokes about these kinds of things, it is pretty obvious who supports terrorism the most today!
Christian Pettersen
oh and I make sad jokes about my life as well, so what? that is what desperate people do.
+הודיה בר יוסף
not sure what you mean, but ok!
10:12 "translator turns red"
That is hilarious
Now I know what to tell my future wife why I married her.
"This palestinian woman is very happy" That was hilarious haha
They have been hurt too much to answer that question from anyplace except trauma.
I love the “Are you stupid?” look the woman has in the thumbnail! 😆
I don’t know why so many are angry over this Q&A. Just because someone doesn’t want to mix religion or nationalities doesn’t mean they’re racist or antisemitic. As a Jew, I will befriend anyone of any religion or ethnicity but I wouldn’t marry someone who’s not a Jew (unless they truthfully convert). It’s personal preference.
AJ Slay I'm Muslim and i totally agree with you on this
converting for mariage is not halakhically acceptable - you surely know that, don't you? :)
It's wrong when the religion dictates your preference. And you take that religion seriously.
I feel the same way as a Christian.
@@royalaniket7473 this
you should ask the jews if they would marry an arab/muslim.. not just a "non jew" otherwise this test is not fair ;)
+Sarah Bucket . I will marry any of them
I’m Israeli. If I liked a women (was physically and emotionally attracted to her) then I would want to be with her and I wouldn’t care if she was Muslim or Arab.
Israelis marry Arabs all the time. Most Israelis are at least partially descended from Arabic Jews. My children, for example, are half Yemenite. Their maternal grandparents were born in Yemen. Racially, Jews have no problem intermarrying. It’s only a matter of religion. Judaism forbids intermarriage, for men and women. Islam forbids intermarriage for women but not men.
He has exactly such a video. And most of them said “sure” no questions asked.
The translator voice is very polite and loving, how can i see her?
Lets go back to 1942 and ask someone Jewish if they would marry a German.
So what 1.6 million arabs doing in Israel if its 1942 Germany? Always taqiyya with you abeeds
There were jews married to germans lol
@@beckyr.e1212 sure there were. All killed by 1940
The Quran is more Diabolical to Jews than Hitler's book. No wonder Hussenni loved Hitler so much. The Quran hates every single person ever created. Quran is the most hateful evil Satenic thing I've ever read.
Haha
Why would she?
Why would they marry somebody who killed their mother and father? and murdered the entire village so they steal the land.
not lies, 400-600 palestinian villages were destroyed in an attempt to get rid if Palestinians. your beloved terrorist groups called the irgun and hagana carried this out. Learnt a lot from the nazis.
+IL__KINGDOM ABRAHAM
u want to open THAT PADORA's box?
@IL__KINGDOM ABRAHAM read this back to yourself. You sound like a Nazi you hasbara troll. Lol there's a reason as to why jews were chased down in more than 100 countries. Give evidence as to where we've been "always killing you." Stop acting as if you're the damn victim in every case. It's as if you're forgetting history, who was it that saved you from the atrocities of the Spanish inquisition? Who saved you when the Catholics were slaughtering you? Who was it that granted you universal libraries in Spain and allowed you to somewhat "re-establish" your faith and allow you to build synagogues and allowed you to have respectful positions in royal courts and other professions? Who was it that said after the fall of Spain, "we cannot protect you anymore" and in return gave back your jizya and were ready to leave to go back to Morocco and Algeria. Who was it who wanted to go with these people to Morocco and Algeria to which they were granted protection in these safe havens TILL THEY BETRAYED THE STATE, mind you you're own "respectable scholars" such as " Isaac ben Sheshet (Ribash) and Simeon ben Zemah Duran (Rashbatz).[1]" were amongst those who went to these lands. IT WAS THE MUSLIMS WHO DID THIS. IT WAS THE MUSLIMS WHO GAVE YOU REFUGE AFTER THE HOLOCAUST, NONE OF YOUR EUROPEAN ANCESTORS WANTED YOU GUYS. WE GRANTED YOU SAVE HAVEN IN PALESTINE AND OTHER MUSLIM COUNTIRES ONLY FOR YOU TO BETRAY US. ONE EXAMPLE IS ALGERIA, WHEN THE FRENCH COLONIALISTS WERE IN ALGERIA AND THE MUSLIMS WERE RESISTING THEIR MOVEMENT IT WAS THE JEWS WHO SECRETLY AIDED THE FRENCH BY BEING SUPPLIERS AND INTERPRETERS ETC. NOT ALL JEWS BUT MANY DID. So do humble yourself you Nazi fool. Hasbara troll smh. What have you done for the Muslims can I ask you that?
@IL__KINGDOM ABRAHAM as we speak right now illegal settlements are being built on Palestinian land you hasbara troll. This is what you guys wanted, so please shut up with the whole "iF wE wAnTeD tO GeT OF YoU We WoUldVe dOne It". By slowly and silently doing it and on the other side attempting to speak of peace, you've got anither thing coming your way.
Nobody,NOBODY is entitled to any land anywhere,it has to be fought for and taken as it has throughout history,e.g.-the western side of Turkey used to be Greek,Pakistan used to be India,etc.that's why countries have borders(all man-made,geographical or not) and defence forces,the Israeli's are no different to anyone else,they want to live in peace but the constant threat of terrorism from their neighbours and Iran have made them highly alert and security conscious,declare war on them if you must but don't be surprised if they fight back with ferocity,they will be fighting for their very survival.BTW, if by some chance you managed to destroy Israel do you think it would end there ? think about it!
4:48 guy looks like zayn malik a bit
I like that speaks of him who says it's just religion like Christians
@Galaxy MYT That's because you don't believe that Jews are a people, not just a religion. The Jews are an ethno-religious group, as most used to be before the Western Enlightenment. And it shows among the people who hate Jews as people, not just because of their religion. Haters don't stop and ask a Jewish person about their beliefs; they just cause harm. If a Jewish person converts to Islam, they may be accepted as a literal thing, but they face a lot of social rejection.
I knew a Muslim woman (by birth, from Indonesia) who married an American Christian who converted to Islam (his family wasn't religious). He was sincere in his devotion to Islam. Later, they moved from Indonesia to the U.S. because he became a college professor. She discovered that when they moved to a particular area, the only mosque was mostly Arab Muslims. Although she was raised Muslim, it wasn't the custom in her family to wear a hijab or super-conservative garments. But she faced tremendous pressure to dress and behave like the Arab women. She talked to me about this because my partner at the time was her husband's brother. So we were almost family, and I wasn't raised Christian so we bonded. She shared with me how difficult it was for her to fit in as an Indonesian Muslim, where they were living. They eventually moved to a larger city with an Indonesian-majority mosque. (This is from the mid-1990s, I'm not longer with my former partner so don't have updated info.)
The point is that ethnicity and culture count for a LOT, no matter what the religion. If a Moroccan woman marries a Bosnian Muslim, and goes to Bosnia to live with him, most likely her mother-in-law and his family and friends will judge her based on their culture, and she'll have to adjust. And it may not go well, or be easy for either of them. So just asking about what happens if a Jew converts to Islam to get married is overly simplistic. I'm sure that if a Jew from an Egyptian-Jewish family converts and marries an ethnic Egyptian Muslim, they'd get along much better than if a British Jew converts and marries an ethnic Egyptian Muslim. Religion is only one factor.
I love your channel, its really intertaining.. No hypocrite, no edited, no scripted.. More followers to come..
This is interesting. Corey it would be pretty cool if you learn the arabic language, not complaining at all but It would give you more freedom to your conversation.
+DeepInYourLady Frow what I've watched, the translator is really really accurate and doesn't deform what is being said
+KahroSynetic Yes I confirm that the new translator (the Palestinian lady) is doing a great job. I have seen a number of clips which she translated and every word she'd translated was spot on. Good job changing the old translator, Corey.
Manar Nabut I would gladly do , but as I live in morocco, I don't know anybody who could need it over here :D
Wich dialect do u like then
Darija is not really arabic, and arabic speaker couldn't understand darija dialect because it's inspired from amazigh and phoenician
At the end of the day we are all people. Greetings from Armenia.
It’s different when you destroy someone home kill the residence and build a house on top the rebel and call it your new home 😉
abo aldadson Armenians know all about that...have you heard of the Armenian genocide?
אתה כלב Schlomo Shillman Shekelstein or a zionist a former terrorist from irgun or lehi
Bob Cratchit have you heard About the genocide of the americas by europeans ?
We are all humans no matter what accept it.
I think answers are influenced political results, and social surroundings are has tarnished there ability to see clearly, and noise of darkness is drowning the truth that is at the core of all existence. Ask some deeper questions that would help ease the pain within their community.
Maybe they should also be asked...if they go against your wishes and marry anyway...do you disown them or accept it
The Arab Peace Initiative (Arabic: مبادرة السلام العربية) is a comprehensive peace initiative first proposed in 2002 at the Beirut Summit of the Arab League by then-Crown Prince, King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia, and re-endorsed at the Riyadh Summit in 2007.[1] The initiative attempts to end the Arab-Israeli conflict, which means normalizing relations between the entire Arab region and Israel, in exchange for a complete withdrawal from the occupied territories (including East Jerusalem) and a "just settlement" of the Palestinian refugee crisis based on UN Resolution 194 (which calls for a diplomatic resolution to the conflict and resolves that any refugees "wishing to return to their homes and live at peace with their neighbors" should be able to do so or, if they otherwise wish, should be provided with compensation).[2] The Initiative was initially overshadowed by the Passover Massacre, a major terrorist attack that took place on March 27, 2002 (the day before the Initiative was published) and that had been claimed by the Izz ad-Din al-Qassam Brigades, Hamas' military wing.[3] The Arab League has since readopted the Initiative on several occasions, including during the 2007 summit.
then it time to stop fighting and be part by the name of peace
If they start marrying each other the conflict would eventually come to an end and what a disaster that would be..
You'd marry someone who robbed you???
@@oxladealex9369 who robbed who?
outline israel robbed Palestine
@@yazanarafat5997 palestine belonged to turks to english and now its back to being judea.
@@oxladealex9369 you robbed the whole world jeehadee
The question from the previous video is very differrent concept.. between hating someone or not.. and between commited to one relationship for life.. i think its a major flaw
You can see here that the problem is not religious but political, it's sad to see how politics are behind so much hate.
The comparison between Israel and Nazism is an outstanding misknowldge of history and its processes. If this is YOUR point, Nazism has not disappeared toward Jews, indeed.
The difference between Israelis and Palestinians - One can tolerate and feel free living around and with the other, while the other one in almost completely intolerant. I think its pretty easy to figure out which is which.
One is the oppressor and the other one is the victim...I think is easy to figure out which one is what
this is so stupid. you’re asking the people who have watched their land get taken away from them, who have been kicked out of their homes, who have been tortured and killed by these people for years if they would want to marry them. what the hell do you think the answers are going to be??
I have a feeling you don't know too much about who is the victim in this conflict. Both sides are at fault
@@Leo-vq7kl Victim? I'm pretty sure you don't know what Palestinians have to go through, in terms of oppression, how are "Israelis" oppressed? Do they have freedom of movement (yes) Do they have to wait in checkpoints and be dehumanized on a daily basis (no), are their young being killed and sniper bulleted just by walking on the street? (no) do they face demolishing of homes (again no), are their livelihoods being taken away from them (no), are they allowed to travel by plane by using Tel Aviv Airport (yes), Palestinians have to go to Jordan to travel from country to country. Are their lands being confiscated (no), is it the Israelis that are facing annexation (no) so who are the victims? Not the Israelis. Definitely not.
@@mnljh711986 During the Second Intifada Israelis were killed walking down the street.
@@Leo-vq7kl i m a jew. We are not victim. We are taught to have victim mentality. Even our people own a lot of global wealth. I support palestine and any religion dude should do this. F the talmud
Many from both sides are afraid those kind of marriages increase and dissolve their community.
However it is the best signal to show really wanting peace and create a common state without discrimination!
The problem is politics , not religion
I love people without differences of nationality or religion, but I would never marry anyone who does not belong to my religion. I can not share life with somebody who does not have same beliefs. He can be any race or nationality.
Question submission -
Please ask Palestinian's and Israeli's about their views of the opposing side. And then as a follow-up question, please ask if their parents were a integral part in their values and beliefs. I believe everyone gets their views based on conditioning around us. And this would be on way of examine that.
Some of them are probably thinking, “WTF?!?”
These are not the only two cultures that do this.
The general conclusion (what I pick up from the majority): Ethnicity doesn't matter, only religion.
yep
Arabs usually don't allow their women to marry outside their nationality/tribe/family so asking the women is pointless. I am an white European Muslim there is no chance in hell an Arab family would allow their daughter to marry me. I know so many Yemeni guys who are married to their first cousins because their families wouldn't allow for nothing else. It is unimaginable for me...
Aboleo80 I'm a Yemeni but times have changed, it was like that years ago. I don't know where you live but I know many Yemeni girls from Birmingham UK who have married muslim white & black converts and from other ethnic communities.
But you will find people who won't change.
+Yaz A I live in Southeast Michigan. There is many Yemeni people here in Detroit area. I'm originally from Bosnia.
Aboleo80 Yes I agree, the Yemenis in America are still very traditional when it comes to marriage.
Aboleo80 are u kidding me! I am yemenite born in Bahrain for god sake I do not even wear the veil! And in my family we NEVER marry our cousins! Get ur facts straight those yemenites in America do not represent us all
shay 12
I got my facts from the source. So they are as straight as it gets. I had a good Yemeni friend in high school here. His parents sent him back to Yemen his Junior year of hs to marry his first cousin. I also have people from Yemen working with me and many of them are married to their cousins. I also know few of them who had wives back in Yemen but they couldn't bring them over here right away and they were dating American and many Bosnian and other girls while married. They were mostly young Yemeni guys who were born here in America but have very traditional parents who would disown them if they knew they were dating. Meanwhile I was making it my mission to flirt with Yemeni girls while in school just to piss them off and lets face it Yemeni girls are very pretty :) Ahhh still miss Bushra. Sweetest girl ever but we could have never dated because her parent would have literally have killed her if they found out so we just flirted a lot during class.
05:00 he gave the best answer 👏👏👏
no he just expose his hate or the one of his relatives. thats why there is no peace there.
@@feyd1955bruh the large majority if not all of Palestinians have lost some part of their family from aggressive jews and israel and their settlers, your trying to demonize them by making their resentment just hate out of no where piss off
@@feyd1955 "I can't live with who's tortured my people and destroyed their life by doing such a bad things for them"
Expose hate❎ his right ✅
You should’ve asked “what if she was absolutely smashing hot?” You might have got some more interesting answers.
Lmao
Marrige is a very important moment in islam
So it cannot be taken from a prespricetive(wtf)
Of sex only
Thats actually very haram and dangerous
Are you American? Cuz that's pretty shallow...
@@mrcrush3r534 Are you honestly suggesting you wouldn’t prefer to have sex with someone who was amazingly attractive than someone who was horrible to look at? Don’t pretend to be so pious. You’re full of shit.
@@antman2826 Alhamdulilah I've been taught not to follow my sexual desires. Any girl in the world you can have sex with, it doesn't matter, they're all females, what does matter is to pick a good woman who know her religion well, has kind heart, would raise the children very well, if you marry for look then it is guaranteed after 1 month you'll brake up. That why it is always you choose qualities and personality over looks. In my opinion all women are beautiful you don't need to look at their chests, they are beautiful for who they are
Oh my, if everyone thought like this the world would be on fire...
robin jacobsson come and live in Ramallah for one month and see what these people are going through every single day ...
The 20yr old guy is hilarious, "she wasn't born yesterday!" Just how I think, nothing racial wise, but love lol.
Suffer 50± years
Meanwhile in America my doctor (dermatologist) is Jewish from Maghreb and married a muhajiba from Syria... and he lets her keep on the hijab. They just finished 25 years married.
That would likely be the case there too if Palestinians had equal rights and were treated as equals. People expecting them to love or have any desire to marry their oppressors are on some other shit.
The 22 year old made the most sense. It wasn't about being prejudiced against a religious group for him. It was about not being okay with occupation. Very different things.
Since I was born to Jewish parents but adopted by Christians, I think it would be interesting to see if Palestinians would agree to adopt a Jewish child, and vice versa, and what their respective feelings towards that would be. I think the answers would be interesting going off their sentiments towards this issue.
That’s a great question!
I think you can only adopt orphans in islam
Children are all considered as muslims in islam
You can adopt anyone muslim or not. But marriage for women they are not allowed to marry different religion unless they convert. I think for jews they are not allowed to marry out of their religion unless they convert. And add to thzt the conflict it's bit hard.
They cannot are ruled by Kaffala system only can adopt Muslim orphans and they keep their original family name. When grow are told are adopted. Adoption is not well seen in Islam people prefer biological children. I asked to a friend this questions years ago. System not same as in Western countries.
now, now, folks , let' s notbe harsh on corey. he's a super nice guy who just like to probe people's mind. i am a muslim but i hope i can sit and have coffee with with him one day.
In group, out group, this is as old as time.
No body is below anyone.
Corey I feel like you have to make clear the religions of the Palestinians whom you've chosen to answer your questions, because many of your followers will not think whatsoever that the person who is answering is a Christian (if they are) unless they have a crucifix on or whatever.
***** The israeli christians, but not the case of the palestinean christians. One of the most famous episodes of the Second Intifada was when a group of monks offered refugee to Hamas terrorists inside the Church of Nativity in Bethlem.
+Nir Hakimian No that's definitely not true.
+Nir Hakimian and +Starryeyed girl based on what? Any of you Palestinian? Christian/Muslim? Live in a Christian/Muslim crowded Palestinian area? I'm intrigued.
+Nir Hakimian lol what? :D I'm sure you live on planet earth but the two of you have contradicting points of view. So I just wanted to see who is more credible.
***** Are you a religious or a secular jew?
"Never do any enemy a small injury for they are like a snake which is half beaten and it will strike back the first chance it gets."
Where's that quote from? It's quite good
@@thestan2941 machiavelli
Everyone has right to an opinion.
You are brave brother... Hope you are asking these question for the betterment of the society.
If you pay attention he asked all types of question. It's good cause it allows us to hear 2 different opinions
Those videos are made with utmost absurdity and lack of basic common sense. What do you expect from people who have been persecuted, killed, have their relatives killed with daily terror and imprisonment and continuous sense of insecurity? To hug them with an open arms!!! Absolutely and in the most sensical way, NO!!! I do have many friends that are Jews and highly disagree with what Israeli State is doing in Palestine.
+Mohammad Nazzal: Yes. Persecution. That is why Muslims have conquered 98% of the Middle East and North Africa that used to have Jews, and why the Israelis have 2% of land remaining. You are right. It is down to persecution. However, that 1400 years of persecution means nothing to you.
Rationalific Jews were never expelled by Muslims. In fact, Jews have lived in peace and harmony alongside Muslims for century upon century. They are living now in peace and harmony in countries like Morocco and Tunisia. There were jews living side by side with Muslims and Christians in Palestine before the Zionist movement came in to establish the so-called state of Israel (which many jews who were already living in Palestine at the time opposed).
It was actually the crusaders who persecuted the Jews, especially the ones who used to live in Al-Andalus with Muslims. When the crusaders persecuted and killed the Muslims, the Muslims who survived had to flee, and with them fled the jews. That's why you find them in North Africa living in peace in their own communities without any conflict. Also, Hitler wasn't Muslim. Also, the prophet rose from his seat in respect for a passing-by funeral that belonged to a deceased Jewish man. No Muslim has ever minded them. Until Israel came to be and the majority of the Jews living there embraced it. Now Jewish usually comes hand in hand with Israeli, and Israeli comes hand in hand with Jewish. Which isn't right, but stereotypes are born from somewhere. They don't pop out of nowhere.
+Al Sondos: Your points have some validity. However, the delusion of a happy liberal Muslim Golden Age Utopia is just that...a delusion. For example, regarding the history of Jews in Morocco (which like Muslim-controlled Spain and Tunisia was one of the very best places for Jews in the entire Islamic world, and which was never representative of the Islamic world as a whole), it is still the case that "between 1035 and 1068, the invasions of the Almoravides and Almohades, fanatic Muslim sects caused destruction, fear and chaos to the Jewish community in Fez. It is estimated that about 6,000 Jews were massacred during those events. Al-muwahhids, was a militant dynasty who was determined to expel all those who did not share his religious beliefs, such as Jews. The Jews were forced to convert to Islam; those who refused were exiled. Some of the Jews who converted to Islam still kept in secret their faith and kept both identities together." Also, under the relatively "moderate" Almoravids, "Yusuf Ibn Tashfin forbade Jews living in the capital city Marrakesh. It was allowed for them to trade there, but if a Jew was caught in the city during night hours it was punishable by death." In 1148, during the Almohad conquests, "Abd al-Mumin ... the leader of the Almohads after the death of Muhammad Ibn Tumart the Mahdi ... captured Tlemcen [in the Maghreb] and killed all those who were in it, including the Jews, except those who embraced Islam. ... [In Sijilmasa] One hundred and fifty persons were killed for clinging to their [Jewish] faith. ... One hundred thousand persons were killed in Fez on that occasion, and 120,000 in Marrakesh. The Jews in all [Maghreb] localities [conquered] ... groaned under the heavy yoke of the Almohads; many had been killed, many others converted; none were able to appear in public as Jews." Later, the Marinids conquered the area and "The Marinids proved themselves particularly friendly toward the Jews. When the still-fanatic mobs attacked them in 1275, the Merinid sultan Abu Yusuf Yaqub ibn Abd Al-Haqq intervened personally to save them."
Quotes from: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_the_Jews_in_Morocco
Before Israel became a state and nearly all Jews were killed or expelled (which is something I don't hear about all that much), around 300,000 Jews lived in Morocco, which was the largest number in the Islamic world. However, over 500,000 Jews lived in Germany in 1933, and over 9 million Jews lived in largely Christian Europe before the Holocaust. To say that the fact that some Jews survived (until they didn't) in the Islamic world means that they were "treated nicely and not persecuted" until 1948 is the same as saying that the fact that 9 million Jews survived (until they didn't) in Christian Europe means that they were "treated nicely and not persecuted" in Christian Europe. Anyone with knowledge of history will know that neither of those statements are true. Also, if you say that "some population surviving to produce offspring" means that they are not being persecuted, then you must also say the same thing about the Muslims living in Israel, as their numbers in 2017 are larger than they were in 1948.
Rationalific Rationalific Oh I don't believe in a liberal Muslim Golden Age Utopia. Islamic communities have been far from utopic. And throughout history you will find names of corrupt "Muslim" leaders, one after the other, who tortured Muslims themselves and put them through hell, all in the name of Islam, when it was in fact a political battle in many cases, or for personal gains, or just mere fanaticism just like the Muwahideen you mentioned, who persecuted the Muslims before anyone else and invented religious restrictions that didn't even exist anywhere in the book. Muslims were happy to be liberated from their rule, just like ISIS today. So, no, the Islamic Utopia is a delusion. But what is also a delusion is to say that the persecution that Jews had suffered should be paid for by a people who had no business in the whole issue, on a land where Jews, Muslims and Christians proudly identified as Palestinians, where no one claimed that God gave it to the people of his/her own religion, therefore make it ok to drive people out based on their beliefs. This, in itself, is the persecution that they were fighting against, presently practiced by them now.
"Let's record voice only" records body
Yeah, I noticed that too. It's sooo disrespectful.
@@lahoreaskari2651 why?
@@daddy8518 What why? Didn't you see that instead of pointing the camera to the ground, he was pointing the camera at their bodies. That was very rude.
Smacking with the shoes 😂
How can people think there can be any peace when they have so much respect, peace start when there is understanding first, not in one minuets
You cannot ask Muslim women if they would marry a Jewish man because it is strictly forbidden for Muslim women to marry any man outside of Islam. So it isn’t a matter of choice or preference. I would’ve stuck to only asking the men (when it came to the Muslim Palestinians). Most Arab Muslim men will not marry outside of Islam, even if it were permissible. And then within Islam they are picky on who they will marry. I am a convert and I cannot tell you how many men scolded me because I wasn’t a virgin. 🙄
My sister Islam erases what has passed
@@moncef9778
Assalamualaikum,
I am aware of this, but those men who spoke to me appear to be worshipping their culture more than the deen.
We, as Muslims, are allowed to marry Jewish and Christian daughters because we believe in the Prophet Moses and the Prophet Jesus. We believe in them as messengers from God. As for Jews and Christians, they are not allowed to marry Muslim daughters because they do not believe in the Prophet Muhammad as a messenger from God.
@@EL_Amir
What you said agrees with everything I said. I am a Muslim as well....
For the people who said they wouldn't marry a Jew, they should also ask if they would marry a Christian just to be clear about whether it's an issue of disliking Jews as a group as opposed to worrying about family stability.
They did in another video and some said yes and some said no. In this videos it seems like they dont like jews at all at least the palestinians
@@s1rm0rr1lswdsx3 No. For Muslim men marrying Jewish and Christian women are allowed. For Muslim women it is not allowed unless he convert to Islam. Now in the case of Israeli and Palestine there is a political issue. It is not what you think.
Muslim women are not allowed to marry anyone except a Muslim however, a Muslim man can marry a Jew or Christian woman.
Excellent love it
They same people who expressed in this video that they wouldn't marry Jews wouldn't marry Shia'tes either and they're Muslims.
damn this world is so divided
Better there was no religion at all 😀
I will marry my son to Jewish girl or Christian
@@ancienttimes4762 and what religion are u?
@@aymanus04 MUSLIM
@@ancienttimes4762 this isn't going to be good, u better not do that if u love ur son and his future children
We live in a sad world love should know no boundaries
Their language sounds pretty cool. I sometimes try to imitate the words but I can't make the correct sounds for it. I wonder how they do it?
hi Corey, are you related to Meyer? thanks form the videos. (I knew M.). David
Why marring here, marring there? Why do so many people assume you have to marry to live together and have kids? I grew up with unmarried parents and know a lot of people who have unmarried parents it's totally fine!
Why would someone marry their oppressor?
Many jewish women and paleatinian men marry.
@@mrspotato20
Yeah. There were 2 and to they both were found strangled.
Israelis are human beings too
Under your mind Israelis are all opressor? How is that different from saying Muslims are all terrorists?
I heard hebrew and Arabic are similar he could learn it for better conversations
Why are on top of the subtitles another subtitles wich say the same?
Of course it's a no no. The hate is eating up these people.
Do nation and religion really overcome love?
damn YES!!!
Not nationality, but religion of course
How about if you asked, would they marry and Israeli or Jew if there the occupation and apartheid were to end and everyone was treated equally, with respect and no-one was being killed, all one people. Maybe the answer might be different.
Putting way to many words in their mouth. the way the asked was perfect and the people being asked explained why they believe what they believe perfectly well.
Way to complicated a question , you can’t make too many stipulations like that , no one will take that serious
this video is so biased because I don't hear anyone talk about how the Palestinians with Hamas are conducting terroristic acts every day on Israel. That is not peace! The bombs and murders of innocent people in Israel is horrible! That is worse than anything else going on! There is NO apartheid going on by Israel. Anyone who thinks that does not know what the meaning is or what is really happening! Israel is a free state where people of all religions live happily. Including Muslims.
5:34 If human beings are human beings why should there be borders?
"Who hits someone with a shoe? I mean, really?" said Austin Powers.