Just revisited this video after first watching it 3 weeks ago, and here I am, a grown man, weeping. Never have I heard anything so profound, so moving, so touching...so heartfelt. And when I closed my eyes and meditated to the text as she sang "Herz und Auge weint vor dir bitterlich", my own strength utterly failed to hold back the tears. What nourishment for the soul!
I sincerely hope while listening to this magnificiant piece of nusic, you would perhaps think for one moment of the sufferings of those Syrian refugees battling the earth's seas to reach freedom.
It’s just so amazing, there aren’t words....and the violinist deserves very high praise, as well. I’ve listened to just about every version of this aria on RUclips, and there isn’t a singer who can touch Julia Hamari’s interpretation, in my opinion. However, I haven’t heard every version of this aria, bc it was around for a few hundred years before singers could be recorded. And musical taste is so subjective, and for some reason this is especially true for classical vocalists, so I can’t say it’s the best ever....I can only say-to my ears-this is perfect!!
@@voraciousreader3341 OTTO BÜCHNERS Violinspiel ist zum Weinen schön. OTTO BÜCHNER's violin playing is beautiful to cry. Le jeu de violon d’OTTO BÜCHNER est beau à pleurer.
Es ist schwer, nicht gerührt zu werden, wenn man Julia Hamari diese Arie singen hört. Buße, Barmherzigkeit und Hoffnung werden gefordert. Es ist ein Kompendium von so tiefen Gefühlen, dass unsere Seele vor Liebe weint.
Sono pienamente d'accordo! Questa musica è così perfetta e così assoluta che qualsiasi parola su di essa non può che essere inadeguata..e questi grandi interpreti lo hanno compreso perfettamente..ed è per questo che queste storiche interpretazioni colpiscono commuovono ed esaltano spiritualmente.. anche noi che viviamo nell'era digitale.
In the 50 years since this video was recorded, there have been many wonderful performances of this aria but none come close to the beauty and emotion of this performance. Exquisite!
You are absolutely right. The people who sing this today are almost always countertenors, and they lack vocal beauty and the necessary pathos. Also, modern baroque interpretations are empty emotionally and too simple.
I love music, but I have never heard such a flawless and heavenly inspired interpretation of St Matthew's Passion. Hungarian singer here, Julia Hamari’s voice was forged in heaven. The orchestra is amazing. Otto Büchner and Julia Hamari deliver an out of this world performance of an indescribably moving piece of music by Bach. It's one of the best things I've ever listened to. Her voice is pure, untrammelled, pure perfection. It could make any doubtful mortal, like myself, and believe in God immediately considering the theme.
Oh, God. I have studied classical music for 32 years now, and I have never, I mean NEVER heard such a flawless and inspired interpretation of St Matthew's Passion. Her voice was forged in heaven. It's almost a spiritual extracorporeal experience.
@@donnrutkoff922 Yes, why did we not know about her? I am from the Netherlands and a real Bach fan and who are you? WHY don't we know this gorgeous voice? Was she not allowed to our concert halls?
Know her since the eighties Tarkovsky movie 'Offret" , which includes Hamari's version. (little different version) which you can see here; ruclips.net/video/PlV4k2GNGmo/видео.html
+Whizzbizz Actually, it's the other way around. Violins were made to emulate the human voice but it's a rather pathetic attempt as the human voice is incomparable in its flexibility in timbre and expressiveness. You simply have to listen to Bach's arias and you will know.
My son (15) has German examns next week, I help him, together we watch YT, Marmor stein und eisen bricht, Marlene Dietrich, Kleine Italiener, Rocco Granata, Nina Hagen, Rosenstolz and Rilke. Then suddenly I realize I had never ever shared the greatest with him. Thanks for this recording, I was crying behind my PC and shared my deepest feelings with my sonny boy.
What an interpretation. Amazing Ms. Hamari with a voice from heaven. Mr. Buchner makes the violin sing as beautiful as Ms. Hamari. Great orchestra. Thank you Mr. Bach for such a marvelous music. I am a 70+ years old classical music lover. I discovered them recently. Where have you been RUclips all these years? Thank you for enriching our lives. Love to all.
Quand on pense que quantité de gens n'écoutent jamais de telles merveilles. Ce type de morceaux musicaux et lyriques devraient réunir la totalité des humains. Cela rendrait le monde plus uni et solidaire.
This performance has never been superseded. Absolutely astonishing. The dialogue of the voice with the violin is heart-wrenching. Indeed, Otto Buchner's violin play gives stability to this very fragile incantation of human suffering. Bach is unparalleled in his ability to give voice to this and help us connect with each other.
I've been obsessed with this video for nearly three years now. I keep coming back to it. The orchestra are amazing, but Otto Büchner and Julia Hamari deliver out of this world performances of an indescribably moving piece of music. It's still the best thing I've ever found on RUclips.
Well, notwithstanding, there are many beautiful performances on youtube and I hope you find all of them and I wish you good luck for you will need it. I, myself am still looking and keep finding such pearls such as this one.
Bach was inspired by Pachelbel, Buxtehude, Vivaldi and other composers. This is an excellent example of how one’s knowledge, skills and talent can benefit the entire society and future generations. I believe we have to thank Bach and other truly devoted teachers and professionals who share their experience in order to make our world a better place to live in.
Nothing wrong in what you write. But it's not near the truth: It must have been angels from heaven who inspired Bach's music - at least some parts of it!
I could stare at her singing this piece all day. She's perfect. The music's perfect. The camera work is terrific. Seven minutes and 34 seconds of delight.
How can this video have so many dislikes?You don't have to be religious to appreciate the sincerity, sadness and profoundity of this music. This is as perfect as art gets.
I’ve literally watched/listened to every version of this duet-male or female-that I can find on RUclips and, in my considered opinion, none of them comes close to the beauty of voice, the incredible legato (thus showing an impeccable technique), the depth of commitment of the singer to the lyrics, and the _fantastic_ lyrical playing by the violinist. Julia Hamari’s musicality and excellent taste is beyond amazing!
This is the most beautiful Bach creation I have listened to since JSB came into my life in 1951 during the St.Matheus performance in Utrecht, The Netherlands. Most solits singing this aria are inspired by the sublime musical balance between voice and instrument of this work, that they usually reach the optimum of their ability.
Comparing this with later interpretations, no one comes close. I remember when I first heard this on vinyl in my teens, the impression is the same, 40 years later. Genius.
It's a pity that nowadays Bach's works are almost always given in a hurried way which is neither appropriate for the content nor of the time the music was composed in. If you feel like dancing when listening to Bach's 3 Kyries at the beginning of his Mass in B Minor, something is terribly wrong!
Most beautiful performance I've ever heard of a mezzo- soprano singing Bach: Julia Hamari indeed was "In trance and out of this world!" Thanks so very much for sharing!!!
Julia Hamari is also on aria duty in Rilling's Matthew Passion recording from about 1979. Her Erbarme from that just shades the Gonnenwein, I would say, but I would be hard pressed to choose between it and the above effort, as there's something about looking at her singing which adds to the performance and clouds comparison. Her perfect intonation, soprano like clarity of tone, and deep emotion sets her up there near the top for me.
J'ai écouté des dizaine de versions, mais c'est définitivement cette interprétation magnétique de Julia Hamari qui est - de loin -supérieure aux autres. Effectivement elle est habitée, hors du monde... C'est absolument merveilleux. Et que dire du premier violon... Quel bonheur !
As many times as I have heard this aria sung by both men and women, nothing ever seems to compare in emotion, richness and "passion" as this version sung by Julia Hamari. Thank you. Your upload is the clearest on RUclips.
The beauty of this piece and the perfection of this performance is almost overwhelming. And what an incredible recording, both the audio and video. This really is a treasure.
Well, it depends on the aria. For example, the Agnus Dei from the Mass in D minor was performed most exquisitely by Hertha Topper with the same forces as in this recording.
@@juanstill This is interesting. Just woke up. Staring at this comment trying to understand that I'm not Juan Simon, and having a strong feeling that I wrote this. ⭐💪☕ God believes in Bach. How I love this point of view.
This is artistry at its finest. There is so much tenderness, warmth and passion in the sound of the violinist and contralto solo. It is the highest aspiration of what Bach should sound like. Thank you Julia and Rheinhard.
Julia Hamari est excellente et vraiment pénétrée par la dramaturgie de cet aria, peut être un sommet de la musique de tous les temps. Je la place au même rang que Nathalie Stutzman. Toutes deux absolument fabuleuses, bouleversantes. Le premier violon est sublime, envoûtant.
J'ai participé à l'interprétation de cette oeuvre lorsque j'étais enfant et membre d'une manécanterie.C'était à Rennes en 1982 ou 83 .Ce concert m'avait bouleversé, car me retrouver au coeur d'un tel orchestre était une première pour moi .Mais redécouvrir cette oeuvre par cette interprétation ci ... Le 1er violon et Julia Hamari en ont fait un diamant sans pareil ! Je pourrai l'écouter en boucle pendant des heures !
This should have more views then it gets, the hard work Bach put into making the Matthäus Passion. The tranquility of this piece leaves me to tears. Music today, isn't even music, it's utter trash. The Erbarme dich will (to me) be one of the greatest achievements in all music.
Incredible, extraordinary, powerful and yet so smooth. What an unbelievable performance from all involved in this interpretation, and I've heard this many times by other orchestras/singers. Bravo! As for JS Bach, there are no words to describe his music. Beautiful.
I'm an agnostic but Bach is my favorite composer. He understood human emotions more than any composer which leads me to believe he had his share of inner demons!
I am looking for the best interpretation to send this aria to a friend, so far this is by far the best. Her voice has so much power, You cannot give mercy unless you have power.
This music oversees almost all music ever written - it is the among the most profound all of Bach's output. It is beyond performance and beyond any sense of ego.
+Andre Berbie I fully agree with you: I just compared Hamari with Galou, Otter, Stutzmann...this is the best in all. What is astonishing for me is the perfect baroque interpretation of Julia Hamari, in a performance of probably 40 years ago. Well, the violin plays with a little much vibrato, but the sound is beautiful and the pathos really high.
I will sing this beyond the heavens aria on Palm Sunday this year. Julia and her voice are also beyond belief! Listen to her "chiaroscuro!" GOD=BACH SUNG INCREDIBLY. Inspiring!
Oh meu Deus! Tem piedade de todos aqueles que nasceram, que vivem e que morrerão sem nunca saberem que esta obra, absolutamente comovente e única, foi composta há séculos.
This is the benchmark forever, as far as it's about Bach's "Erbarme Dich" Das ist für alle Zeiten der Maßstab für die Interpretation von Bachs "Erbarme Dich"
This is the best interpretation of Bach by any voice that I have ever heard. I have heard quite a lot. Hamari has a remarkable range, but she also shows what she does with her lips while singing. She is absolutely gorgeous.
I have listened to many performances of this exquisite work, but this is the pinnacle, Delphine Galou and in Emmanuel Roth's interpretation notwithstanding. No one but Bach ever welded the human voice and an orchestral insrtument as brilliantly. Magical!
This is PERFECT. I don't know where there's room for criticism. This certainly seems to be the most definitive, flawless, perfect version on youtube. Whenever I'm in a fugue state, I hear this song in the back of my mind. Bach understands the soul like none other and Julia Hamari's rendition is gut-wrenching and beautiful.
Tarkovsky’s movie, Sacrifice has this music in the ending credit. It took me a while to find this piece.. i think her version matches closest to the one from the movie. The most beautiful cinematic scene was completed by this heavenly music.
j ecoute tous les jours cet air tirer de la passion st mathieux ,dans des versions differente : nathalie stuzman , galou , scholz , ou des versions plus ancienes , et chaque fois j en tire asser d energie pour continuer a vivre dans la plus grande joie et serenite . merci a ces interpretes de talent ! pierre-xavier de chassot .
This is a wake up call to all of us! We have all denied the Savior and yet have the opportunity for redemption and eternal life. Bach understood this, and his music - especially the St. Matthew passion extends that invitation to salvation to us all; don't miss it!
Bach understood that music can be a bridge between the earthly and the divine, but the despite him being a Lutheran it is written in the universal language of music and not some close minded religious dogma.
I pray this video will never ever disappear from the public internet.
You can always download it.
Bach schenkt mir Trost und noch fester Glaube im Gott...
you can tell by the look in her eyes that she is somewhere far beyond as she sings!
It is obviuous
Vor 300 Jahren komponiert, vor 50 Jahren analog aufgezeichnet, und 2023 immer noch extrem beeindruckend. Mein allerhöchster Respekt.
Just revisited this video after first watching it 3 weeks ago, and here I am, a grown man, weeping. Never have I heard anything so profound, so moving, so touching...so heartfelt. And when I closed my eyes and meditated to the text as she sang "Herz und Auge weint vor dir bitterlich", my own strength utterly failed to hold back the tears. What nourishment for the soul!
I sincerely hope while listening to this magnificiant piece of nusic, you would perhaps think for one moment of the sufferings of those Syrian refugees battling the earth's seas to reach freedom.
you are absolutely right and don't need anybody to tell you what you should be thinking about. This is the concentrating power of this music.
@@trankobuskas1572 unfortunately we cannot reach freedom while living, only another shore
@@trankobuskas1572 Not to mention the billions of animals that are holocausted each year.
@@trankobuskas1572 I'm sure Bach had them at the forefront of his mind.
The best interpretation of this piece of Bach ever ... Julia could make you fly with the angels with this voice pure and profound ...
It’s just so amazing, there aren’t words....and the violinist deserves very high praise, as well. I’ve listened to just about every version of this aria on RUclips, and there isn’t a singer who can touch Julia Hamari’s interpretation, in my opinion. However, I haven’t heard every version of this aria, bc it was around for a few hundred years before singers could be recorded. And musical taste is so subjective, and for some reason this is especially true for classical vocalists, so I can’t say it’s the best ever....I can only say-to my ears-this is perfect!!
Julia hamart sur Bach c'est
Le rêve
@@voraciousreader3341 OTTO BÜCHNERS Violinspiel ist zum Weinen schön. OTTO BÜCHNER's violin playing is beautiful to cry. Le jeu de violon d’OTTO BÜCHNER est beau à pleurer.
She is the same spirit as Christa Ludwig with Karajan.
I can't agree, too old schoolish. It sounds more moving on period instruments
The best piece of music on Earth. And the best interpretation on behalf of the violinist and the singer I have ever heard. Incredible.
wenige wissen dass die Sängerin eine Ungarin ist. - sie ist heute 81 . hat lange in Düsseldorf u. Stuttgart gewirkt. (Metropoliten, Salzburg usw, )
Es ist schwer, nicht gerührt zu werden, wenn man Julia Hamari diese Arie singen hört. Buße, Barmherzigkeit und Hoffnung werden gefordert. Es ist ein Kompendium von so tiefen Gefühlen, dass unsere Seele vor Liebe weint.
Sono pienamente d'accordo! Questa musica è così perfetta e così assoluta che qualsiasi parola su di essa non può che essere inadeguata..e questi grandi interpreti lo hanno compreso perfettamente..ed è per questo che queste storiche interpretazioni colpiscono commuovono ed esaltano spiritualmente.. anche noi che viviamo nell'era digitale.
Ne güzel anlatmışsınız
Julia Hamari hat eine "ungarische Seele..." -sie kommt hier durch....
Someone said once not every musician believes in God, but all musicians believe in Bach. I would say I believe in God because of Bach!!
very nice
B G beautifully said.
I don't believe in God but this is heaven.
the St. Matthew passion is possibly the biggest argument for Christianity.
May be that's why the philosopher Cioran said that " God owes a lot to Bach" !
In the 50 years since this video was recorded, there have been many wonderful performances of this aria but none come close to the beauty and emotion of this performance. Exquisite!
ruclips.net/video/_E7zjNiz2ZI/видео.html
yes..... yes
Абсолютно с Вами согласна.
You are absolutely right. The people who sing this today are almost always countertenors, and they lack vocal beauty and the necessary pathos. Also, modern baroque interpretations are empty emotionally and too simple.
unübertrefflich..... Engelsgesang !
Maybe the most beautiful music ever created.
So tiefempfunden kann nur eine gläubige Frau singen. Ich habe nie eine bessere Interpretation gehört.
❤
wunderschön , zum weinen schön ,himmlisch ,göttlich
I love music, but I have never heard such a flawless and heavenly inspired interpretation of St Matthew's Passion. Hungarian singer here, Julia Hamari’s voice was forged in heaven. The orchestra is amazing. Otto Büchner and Julia Hamari deliver an out of this world performance of an indescribably moving piece of music by Bach. It's one of the best things I've ever listened to. Her voice is pure, untrammelled, pure perfection. It could make any doubtful mortal, like myself, and believe in God immediately considering the theme.
Maathaus-Passion is not opera
The World is so much richer because it was visited by JS Bach. Thank you for this great performance of a true masterpiece.
Definitely true.
And it’s richer for ritcher too
¡Así es!
¡Absolutamente!
👍👍👍👌👌👌👏👏👏
My most favorite version of this piece. So beautiful and heartfelt.
Oh, God. I have studied classical music for 32 years now, and I have never, I mean NEVER heard such a flawless and inspired interpretation of St Matthew's Passion.
Her voice was forged in heaven.
It's almost a spiritual extracorporeal experience.
angelicakm Bach domine toujours.
She is the voice and hand of our creator. And I only learned of her recently by grace of this you tube and Karl Richter.
@@donnrutkoff922 Yes, why did we not know about her? I am from the Netherlands and a real Bach fan and who are you? WHY don't we know this gorgeous voice? Was she not allowed to our concert halls?
angelicakm me neither
Know her since the eighties Tarkovsky movie 'Offret" , which includes Hamari's version. (little different version) which you can see here; ruclips.net/video/PlV4k2GNGmo/видео.html
I don't want to brag but I'm a great composer I have to admit.
...de acuerdo Maestro
You are the greatest
The God of Music
Nicht Bach sondern MEER solltest Du heißen!
Dein LUDWIG
@@moteflomoteflo3710 wie schön! :*
She sings as if her voice itself was a violin. Magnificent.
+Whizzbizz Actually, it's the other way around. Violins were made to emulate the human voice but it's a rather pathetic attempt as the human voice is incomparable in its flexibility in timbre and expressiveness. You simply have to listen to Bach's arias and you will know.
+Dan Possible. Nonetheless... :-)
Whizzbizz That's how the violin evolved basically
anybody knows who is the violinist ?
@@veroniquebouscasse1348 Otto Büchner
My father used to put this masterpiece when i was a little kid, nowadays at 23 yr old it's one of my favourite pieces of art ever! Thank god ❤
My son (15) has German examns next week, I help him, together we watch YT, Marmor stein und eisen bricht, Marlene Dietrich, Kleine Italiener, Rocco Granata, Nina Hagen, Rosenstolz and Rilke.
Then suddenly I realize I had never ever shared the greatest with him. Thanks for this recording, I was crying behind my PC and shared my deepest feelings with my sonny boy.
The pizzicati in the bass sounds like Peter's heart beat as he pours out his soul to the Lord. A blessed Good Friday to all, 2023.
What an interpretation. Amazing Ms. Hamari with a voice from heaven. Mr. Buchner makes the violin sing as beautiful as Ms. Hamari. Great orchestra. Thank you Mr. Bach for such a marvelous music.
I am a 70+ years old classical music lover. I discovered them recently. Where have you been RUclips all these years? Thank you for enriching our lives. Love to all.
Quand on pense que quantité de gens n'écoutent jamais de telles merveilles.
Ce type de morceaux musicaux et lyriques devraient réunir la totalité des humains. Cela rendrait le monde plus uni et solidaire.
The violin player is Otto Büchner (1924-2008), a close friend of Karl Richter.
he is a genius
Ralph Zedler My voice teacher the late Soprano, Chloe Owen worked with Karl Richter.
This performance has never been superseded. Absolutely astonishing. The dialogue of the voice with the violin is heart-wrenching. Indeed, Otto Buchner's violin play gives stability to this very fragile incantation of human suffering. Bach is unparalleled in his ability to give voice to this and help us connect with each other.
ruclips.net/video/_E7zjNiz2ZI/видео.html
I've been obsessed with this video for nearly three years now. I keep coming back to it. The orchestra are amazing, but Otto Büchner and Julia Hamari deliver out of this world performances of an indescribably moving piece of music. It's still the best thing I've ever found on RUclips.
banginghats2 absolutely the same with me
Well, notwithstanding, there are many beautiful performances on youtube and I hope you find all of them and I wish you good luck for you will need it. I, myself am still looking and keep finding such pearls such as this one.
I've been obsessed with this video for five years …..we doing good!
I would have agreed with you... until I heard Nathalie Stutzmann and Orfeo 55 doing it. It is richer and deeper and, oh just perfect!
... together with Strauss's Four last songs by Masur and Jessye Norman
La voce di Julia Hamari è divina.
Bach was inspired by Pachelbel, Buxtehude, Vivaldi and other composers. This is an excellent example of how one’s knowledge, skills and talent can benefit the entire society and future generations. I believe we have to thank Bach and other truly devoted teachers and professionals who share their experience in order to make our world a better place to live in.
Nothing wrong in what you write. But it's not near the truth: It must have been angels from heaven who inspired Bach's music - at least some parts of it!
@@fidelio5390Bach himself always gave the credit to God.
The BEST interpretation ever. She is great
Best interpretation ever! God and Bach were obviously working together on this masterpiece.
"Erbarme dich mein Gott" after "This very night, before the rooster crows, you will disown me three times". That's why it's so painful
I can listen to this a million times and it still doesn't get old. How strange is that?
Greg, It's not strange I never tire of her otherworldly truly
Gott, Bach und seine Musik sind ja zeitlos - meine Dankbarkeit dafür ist auch...
I could stare at her singing this piece all day. She's perfect. The music's perfect. The camera work is terrific. Seven minutes and 34 seconds of delight.
Michael Shurkin a singer who sings musically is a gift to the world. :)
totally agree!
How can this video have so many dislikes?You don't have to be religious to appreciate the sincerity, sadness and profoundity of this music. This is as perfect as art gets.
Антилайков столько, сколько античеловеков посетили эту страницу. А мы уже больше двух лет знаем, что их много на нашей планете.
I’ve literally watched/listened to every version of this duet-male or female-that I can find on RUclips and, in my considered opinion, none of them comes close to the beauty of voice, the incredible legato (thus showing an impeccable technique), the depth of commitment of the singer to the lyrics, and the _fantastic_ lyrical playing by the violinist. Julia Hamari’s musicality and excellent taste is beyond amazing!
Otto Buchner was a great violinist devoted mostly to chamber music and orchestral work.
She's my idol in Bach music..No one can sing Bach better than her.
This is the most beautiful Bach creation I have listened to since JSB came into my life in 1951 during the St.Matheus performance in Utrecht, The Netherlands.
Most solits singing this aria are inspired by the sublime musical balance between voice and instrument of this work, that they usually reach the optimum of their ability.
Comparing this with later interpretations, no one comes close. I remember when I first heard this on vinyl in my teens, the impression is the same, 40 years later. Genius.
It's a pity that nowadays Bach's works are almost always given in a hurried way which is neither appropriate for the content nor of the time the music was composed in. If you feel like dancing when listening to Bach's 3 Kyries at the beginning of his Mass in B Minor, something is terribly wrong!
Csodálatosan énekelt, kedves Júlia
Julia Hamari, Otto Buchner and Karl Richter have achieved immortality with this.
OTTO BÜCHNERS Violinspiel ist zum Weinen schön. OTTO BÜCHNER's violin playing is beautiful to cry. Le jeu de violon d’OTTO BÜCHNER est beau à pleurer.
Most beautiful performance I've ever heard of a mezzo- soprano singing Bach: Julia Hamari indeed was "In trance and out of this world!" Thanks so very much for sharing!!!
Julia Hamari is also on aria duty in Rilling's Matthew Passion recording from about 1979. Her Erbarme from that just shades the Gonnenwein, I would say, but I would be hard pressed to choose between it and the above effort, as there's something about looking at her singing which adds to the performance and clouds comparison. Her perfect intonation, soprano like clarity of tone, and deep emotion sets her up there near the top for me.
her wide eyes and look is somewhere else, she sees something beyond...
words cant explain the feeling that she has and i have too..
Adel Askari
....love your Comment! :)
me too😍
me too ...
This is plaintive musical poetry that inhabits the spirit. Thank you, Julia and Otto, for taking us there.
Perfect breath control. A true master of her craft.
how can there be such sad, wonderful beauty in this world?
In some sense all beauty is sad, since nothing, including beauty, lasts forever.
@@marcialay1188 alas yes it is the tragedy and triumph of all great art
J'ai écouté des dizaine de versions, mais c'est définitivement cette interprétation magnétique de Julia Hamari qui est - de loin -supérieure aux autres. Effectivement elle est habitée, hors du monde... C'est absolument merveilleux. Et que dire du premier violon... Quel bonheur !
As many times as I have heard this aria sung by both men and women, nothing ever seems to compare in emotion, richness and "passion" as this version sung by Julia Hamari. Thank you. Your upload is the clearest on RUclips.
The beauty of this piece and the perfection of this performance is almost overwhelming. And what an incredible recording, both the audio and video. This really is a treasure.
I am Braziliam and love this piece of Bach.
The God bless Bach and this oschestra.
She is hungarian as i..i am proud over her..
I don't understand
But i listening my fell so so sad,😢
You can!
I'm proud over her wherever she would be.
I know of no other alto that achieved what Julia Hamari achieved singing Bach. To my knowledge she is top of the heap.
Ferrier.
Well, it depends on the aria. For example, the Agnus Dei from the Mass in D minor was performed most exquisitely by Hertha Topper with the same forces as in this recording.
Otto Buchner was an incredible violinist.
I agree. Such a pity he did not get more attention for his talent and so few solo recordings of him exist!
@@Amade1756 I take your point but the mans music is on the voyager golden record. I'd say his talents have been duly recognised
@@funk44actually I don’t think it was. I’m pretty sure it was Hanscheinz Schneeberger
you are going to a wedding, most people say the bride is so beautiful, others say the acolyte wore a pretty dress 🙂
@@thomaslovse4329 no it was Otto in the Brandenburg Concerto with Karl Richter.
This song makes me understand that Bach believes in God.
❤️
God believes in Bach
@@juanstill This is interesting. Just woke up. Staring at this comment trying to understand that I'm not Juan Simon, and having a strong feeling that I wrote this. ⭐💪☕ God believes in Bach. How I love this point of view.
@@mairaleikarte43 That's a strong connection ☺️. I just followed your playlist. Are you russian?
@@juanstill... Congratulations! You've just unlocked Latvia! Or Latvija, to be more specific. 😂🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻🇱🇻
i dont understand a single word but this song touches my soul. you can feel the emotion !
Sincere, honest, opened and naked.. This is the way this God Music Must Be Performed.. Thank You...
We don't have to wait to go to heaven to hear the angel sing this singer is brought angel voices and the sounds of music, to your living room
So beautiful, it's almost unbearable.
This is artistry at its finest. There is so much tenderness, warmth and passion in the sound of the violinist and contralto solo. It is the highest aspiration of what Bach should sound like. Thank you Julia and Rheinhard.
Angel Music Studios
Vivaldi was only 7 years older than Bach
Julia Hamari est excellente et vraiment pénétrée par la dramaturgie de cet aria, peut être un sommet de la musique de tous les temps. Je la place au même rang que Nathalie Stutzman.
Toutes deux absolument fabuleuses, bouleversantes. Le premier violon est sublime, envoûtant.
Had Julia Hamari's "Erbarme Dich" played at my mother's funeral. Best ever interpration i.m.h.o.
.....creo que fue una muy adecuada elección para un momento tan triste
J'ai participé à l'interprétation de cette oeuvre lorsque j'étais enfant et membre d'une manécanterie.C'était à Rennes en 1982 ou 83 .Ce concert m'avait bouleversé, car me retrouver au coeur d'un tel orchestre était une première pour moi .Mais redécouvrir cette oeuvre par cette interprétation ci ... Le 1er violon et Julia Hamari en ont fait un diamant sans pareil ! Je pourrai l'écouter en boucle pendant des heures !
This should have more views then it gets, the hard work Bach put into making the Matthäus Passion. The tranquility of this piece leaves me to tears. Music today, isn't even music, it's utter trash. The Erbarme dich will (to me) be one of the greatest achievements in all music.
Words fall short... The best interpretation I heard so far.
Incredible, extraordinary, powerful and yet so smooth. What an unbelievable performance from all involved in this interpretation, and I've heard this many times by other orchestras/singers. Bravo! As for JS Bach, there are no words to describe his music. Beautiful.
Translation:
Have mercy, my God,
For the sake of my tears!
See here, before you
Heart and eyes weep bitterly.
Have mercy, my God
Great. Would love to know it all.
I'm an agnostic but Bach is my favorite composer. He understood human emotions more than any composer which leads me to believe he had his share of inner demons!
I am looking for the best interpretation to send this aria to a friend, so far this is by far the best.
Her voice has so much power,
You cannot give mercy unless you have power.
ruclips.net/video/yHbvDEtZZME/видео.html
This music oversees almost all music ever written - it is the among the most profound all of Bach's output. It is beyond performance and beyond any sense of ego.
Wolfgang1782 Bach domine toujours.
Божественное произведение. ГОСПОДИ КАК ЭТО ПРЕКРАСНО.
The Greatest Of All Time right here folks! This is a REAL masterpiece. GOD BLESS EVERYONE!
I've listened to just about every rendition posted on RUclips and this, to me, is the best. Mme. Hamari is perfect....simply ethereal.
Julia Amery est je pense la plus grande interprète de Bach .Savoix et son interprétation nous arrachent ds larmes .
J.Hamari is one the best to sing this "Erbarme dich" really is it very great interprétation. Thank you very much.
andré
Yes, it is the best performance that I have ever heard.
+Leonid Odin agree
+Andre Berbie I fully agree with you: I just compared Hamari with Galou, Otter, Stutzmann...this is the best in all. What is astonishing for me is the perfect baroque interpretation of Julia Hamari, in a performance of probably 40 years ago.
Well, the violin plays with a little much vibrato, but the sound is beautiful and the pathos really high.
Marian Anderson was better
300 jaar gescheven en gedaan
Heilig is deze Muziek
Wat moeten wij met de Wereld
Vandaag de dag
Allermooiste wat een Mensch ooit geschreven heeft
I will sing this beyond the heavens aria on Palm Sunday this year. Julia and her voice are also beyond belief! Listen to her "chiaroscuro!" GOD=BACH SUNG INCREDIBLY. Inspiring!
What a great violinist and what a beutiful voice and interpretation. Thank you for sharing!
How Beautiful Voice Julia Hamair , I Love Bach very much.
Erbame dich sublime , interprétation bouleversante à vous arracher des larmes .Un grand MERCI
Oh meu Deus! Tem piedade de todos aqueles que nasceram, que vivem e que morrerão sem nunca saberem que esta obra, absolutamente comovente e única, foi composta há séculos.
mon dieux quelle tres belle voix ! merci julia hamari pour ces instants de bonheur intense ! pierre-xavier de chassot
this is more than my heart can take
Remarquable. Emouvant. Quelle puissance et quelles expressions de J HAMARI..... !
Meu Deus! Indescritível. Não há adjetivo que possa fazer jus à Música, ao Compositor, à Orquestra e à Intérprete. DIVINO!
This is the benchmark forever, as far as it's about Bach's "Erbarme Dich"
Das ist für alle Zeiten der Maßstab für die Interpretation von Bachs "Erbarme Dich"
my heart is bleeding every time I come back to this piece thank you J.S.Bach
This is the best singing I have ever heard, life or recorded. Thank You Lord!!!
When I'll be old, laying on my bed death, this is the last piece I want to listen.
Wow, Dionis, what a divine thought!
Mine too.
I will want -> Vide Cor Meum
How about "Who knows where the time goes" - traditional interpreted by Sandy Denny?
I want Stabat Mater to be played at my funeral
This is the best interpretation of Bach by any voice that I have ever heard. I have heard quite a lot. Hamari has a remarkable range, but she also shows what she does with her lips while singing. She is absolutely gorgeous.
I have listened to many performances of this exquisite work, but this is the pinnacle, Delphine Galou and in Emmanuel Roth's interpretation notwithstanding. No one but Bach ever welded the human voice and an orchestral insrtument as brilliantly. Magical!
I couldn't help burst out crying as I watched this one. it was really unbelievable experience to me.
Jungin Kim Try "Zerfliess Mein Herz"!
One of the best arias in the history of music and one of it's best inerpretations.
Thank you very much!
This is PERFECT. I don't know where there's room for criticism. This certainly seems to be the most definitive, flawless, perfect version on youtube. Whenever I'm in a fugue state, I hear this song in the back of my mind. Bach understands the soul like none other and Julia Hamari's rendition is gut-wrenching and beautiful.
Her singing voice is out of this world,
I seem to be in Heaven
true - direct from the source
The last prayer you will ever say, and the most appropriate for the human condition: My God, have mercy, miserere, erbarme Dich! Because of my tears.
Tarkovsky’s movie, Sacrifice has this music in the ending credit. It took me a while to find this piece.. i think her version matches closest to the one from the movie. The most beautiful cinematic scene was completed by this heavenly music.
j ecoute tous les jours cet air tirer de la passion st mathieux ,dans des versions differente : nathalie stuzman , galou , scholz , ou des versions plus ancienes , et chaque fois j en tire asser d energie pour continuer a vivre dans la plus grande joie et serenite . merci a ces interpretes de talent ! pierre-xavier de chassot .
This is for me an example, where music becomes art and touches the very heart of my soul.
Этот голос навсегда...... Впервые услышал Юлию Хамари в "Жертвоприношении" Андрея Тарковского.
Это лучшее исполнение арии среди всех мною слышанных. Ни у кого такого звучания скрипки нет, только у Отто Бюхнера. Светлая ему память!
This is a wake up call to all of us! We have all denied the Savior and yet have the opportunity for redemption and eternal life. Bach understood this, and his music - especially the St. Matthew passion extends that invitation to salvation to us all; don't miss it!
Go away.
Bach understood that music can be a bridge between the earthly and the divine, but the despite him being a Lutheran it is written in the universal language of music and not some close minded religious dogma.
Best perfomance ever. Speechless