From Independence To 1949 The Untold Stories of Pakistan's Dirty Political History
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 27 сен 2024
- From Independence To 1949 The Untold Stories of Pakistan's Dirty Political History @raftartv Podcast with Naveid Siddiqui
Explore the early political history of Pakistan, focusing on the years immediately following its independence in 1947. We discuss critical events and decisions that have shaped the nation's political landscape, such as the dismissal of the NWFP assembly just days after independence, the shifting loyalties among parliament members, and the controversial removal of the Punjab Assembly in 1948. Additionally, we examine the role of the judiciary in undemocratic actions, the suppression of media freedom with the banning of major newspapers in 1949, and the influence of feudalism on politics.
Naveed Siddiqui, a veteran media executive, provides expert analysis and historical insights in this podcast. We also touch on the early involvement of the military and the establishment in politics, as well as Pakistan's initial steps in foreign relations during the Cold War. Unraveling the roots of Pakistan's political challenges and the lessons that history offers for the future.
#pakistan #india #history #pakistanindependence #untoldstory #history #dirty #politics
Please support us by subscribing to our channel, sharing our content, and engaging with us. Even if our work doesn't resonate with you, we'd appreciate your feedback. Raftar is not merely a content company that produces meticulously researched, high-quality videos about the economy, youth issues, gender roles, and sports. More than that, we represent a movement for social change. We cannot make a difference without your participation and support.
For more amazing content, SUBSCRIBE NOW!
RUclips
/ @raftartv
RUclips
/ @raftarnewsofficial
RUclips
/ @raftarsports
Website:
raftar.com/
Outstanding. This interview confirms William Faulkner’s famous quote from his speech: “Past is never dead. It’s not even past.” Shouldn’t Mr. Jinnah be aware of his dead past? Isn’t it obvious that an impoverished past allowed a misfit to represent naked nomads? He creates a nation but without a guiding idea. No one stood up and grab the half-dead skeleton by his throat. After a Holocaust of 1947 and a Genocide of 1971 and after the fact of a bankrupt Jihadi state, the dead are expected to revisit history. Who has the guts?
When India Hindutva does a Genocide that is all democracy. Gujrat 2002 under Modi. It's time to pull the plug on Modi and his Hate against Muslims.
BAKWASIAT at its worst. Jinnah Saheb had a good roadmap but the conspirators and foreign agents high jacked the Jinnah’s mission. Sadly most of the commentators today get the information / narratives from anti Pakistan, anti division writers from India and England.
His vision regarding Pakistan as a country for Muslims with equal rights for every citizen, also sovereignty of Falistine and Malaysia in 1940. Please read the 1940 Lahore Declaration.
Please read some real books of history and not You Tube’s goofy writers.
1947 🇵🇰
2047 Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil soooooooooon
The great Quaid divided your bhaarat maata into two. Your frustration is understandable.
@@nizamuddinahmadaali3244, your jinnah saheb asked for limousine when the bloodshed was going on in Kolkata and in Punjab, along with whole India.
If you study you will see how well he diplomatically went to bikaner, J&K royalties.
How good leader he was that he went to east pakistan and when he gave his first speech he confirmed that Urdu will be national language. To the people who proudly spoke Bengali.
So much so your leader got appreciation that when he was dying because of TB your Pam liakat ali was having a gala in US embassy in Pakistan. They did not care how to run the newly made state. Everyone was just wanted piece of power.
Masha Allah
v nice & iformetiv talkshow
Navaid siddiqui i m speachless that you have expensive information .
good job .
ماشااللہ نوید صدیقی صاحب کی تاریخ پر بہت گہری پکڑ ہے، اس نوجوانی میں بھی ماضی کے قصے ایسے بیان کررہے ہیں جیسے تمام واقعات ان کے سامنے پیش آئے۔۔۔۔ اور یہ تمام واقعات سنتے ہوئے مجھے بھی ایسا لگ رہا ہے جیسے یہ سب میرے سامنے ہورہا ہے، اُس وقت کی ایک فلم سی چل رہی ہے میرے خیالوں میں
Sach karwa huta he
Babara k barain me parhu
I believe its good to have a healthy discussions like this which can paves our way for the better future
Please bring Mr Hamid bashani on your channel he knows Pakistan top to bottom
Welcome to Pakistan
Hamid ji does not stay in Pakistan…. Not so easy to get him but he will be available for online podcast
That fantasy peddler. Nothing but lazy wrong conclusions.
Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil freedom moment Podcast
@@1979jlr 1947 🇵🇰
2047 Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil
As I understand, this is the difference between India and Pakistan:
The majority Hindu population is non-violent, settles conflict through negotiations, prioritizes education, and is patriotic... Indian leaders come from this community.
The Pakistanis readily resort to violent means to settle disputes, no love for higher education, everyone busy in making a fast buck even at the cost of the nation... Pakistani leaders come from here.
So it's not the poor circumstances of Pakistan. It's the quality of people.
Or else how do you explain the rise of Japan as a powerhouse after suffering 2 nuclear bombs.
تاریخ سے ہم نے یہ سیکھا کہ تاریخ سے ہم نے کچھ نہیں سیکھا
Mashallah doing great job
I truly believe Pakistan was founded by the British as a buffer zone against Russia and they had hired Jinnah to do this job but mostly uneducated Muslims they couldn’t understand this conspiracy but those leaders who had vision they were against this blunder from day first but government always had more power so they can change ordinary people’s mind.
Russia se british ko bachna tha or woh India chorh kr chale gye Bhai kehna kiya chaa rhe ho?
@@chotadinosaur8277iss ko khud naheen pats 😂 confused hai
No government can change millions of people's minds.
And to think that Jinnah could be "hired"?
Shame on you.
Agreed. They want someone from this region to act as police for them.
@@chotadinosaur8277mery bhai dimagh kholo aur kitabein parhu
from the very start, the guest set the tone to be against Pakistan when he said, ML was not prepared how to handle the new country. you should know that it was not planned. it was not known. the way you think of things now, imagine 70 years ago with no tv no cellphone, no social media it was hard to be in sync. with each and everything happening at that time. instead of blaming the dead who helped us get what we have now, think of what we are doing to it now.
Wrong approach, you need to identify the issues in the roots. If a plant has bad roots give as much sunlight, water and fertilizer it won’t grow. The issue in root needs solution.
@@farazahmed0we were never one nation. Initially Jinnah also believed in indian as one nation but he soon realized both Hindu and Muslim are two different nations. Hero of one nation is villain of other.
@@farazahmed0I am afraid, in trying to improve the condition of the roots, you are going to tear out the whole of the plant.
@@amjadmuhammadiqbal4721 If the solution lies in tearing the existing one and planting a new seed then that’s fine too.
@@farazahmed0 in my opinion the problem is not in the roots, but in our caring of the growth and development of the plant stem and it's various branches. We are not giving it proper amount of water and sunlight, and the right type of fertilizer. We start doing that and the plant will be fine inshaa'Allah ☺
Great contribution of information which this generation was not aware of
Hats off to team @Raftar👏
Wonderful
Awesome reporting 👌👍
تاریخ میں پہلے ، ہندو حکومت، پھر مسلم ،سکھ حکمران لیکِن پھر تاج برطانیہ کو عیسائی حکومت نہی کہا جاتا
Guest has balanced views; I concur with his interpretation of history and facts.
The guest is a pro-army person. Because from the Day one, Politicians were handling by the pak army.
pakistan ka pehla gair jamhoori amal jinnah sahab ne hi kr diya tha kpk ki elected government ko barkhaast kr ke to baqio se kia shikwa kare ko wo undemocratic kaam kio krte hai
75 سال میں ہم عوام اپنے حکمرانوں کو نہیں بدل سکے بلکہ خود ہی حکمرانوں جیسے بن گئے ہیں جس کا جدھر جتنا زور چلتا ہے وہ چلاتا ہے
Unusually well informed guest. He explains how everything that is wrong with Pakistan was present from the very beginning of the formation of the Country.
Journalists are always concerned with Freedom of Speech and Democracy? How many journalists have actually questioned their compatriots on misinformation and inciting violence? They have never questioned that how the first unanimous democratic leader Bhutto destroyed Pakistan’s economy. When systems and institutions are not pro-people, I’d rather have stability and governance than democracy and freedom of speech.
Very well said.
And bhutto was neither democratic nor unanimously elected.
Good
1947 سے کیوں شروع کررہے ہو ؟
1940 سے شروع کرو کہ کس طرح جناح انگریز استعمار کے اشارے پر تقسیم ہند کا مطالبہ اٹھا رہے تھے
To safeguard the very heart and soul of Pakistan, we are left with but one resolute course of action: to return our brave military to the sanctity of the barracks, allowing the vibrant spirit of our democracy to flourish unencumbered! We must rise together and demand a transformative reformation of federal governance, empowering the voices of the people! If the powers that be refuse to heed this calling, let them stand exposed and publicly accountable for their inactions, for the future of our beloved nation hangs in the balance!
Speechless yar.. kitni tareef chaye Raftar ap ko...... 100% best channel
ok, it is a mess. Now how do we fix it?
Guys, do something about auto generated sanskirit substitles. URDU OR ENGLISH
It's Hindi
PAKISTAN BANANEY MAIN MAHAJIR NEY APNI PORI ZINDAGI DEY DI MAGAR INKO DEWAAR SE LAGYA WAH HAI 1947 SE AB THK
Our forefathers just made trust on some shits and now we pay the price
@@sufyanali3127 Bhai aap ne to India tora. UP Dilli ki boli ko PBio par thopa. 10% ki juban ko Pak ki national language bana dia. Sabhi big posts Muhajir le gaye Local log mooh dekhte rahe. Panjabio ne sabh se jiyada suffer kiya, ohnu ne kabi Pak ki demand hi nahi ki. Batna to UP Bihar chaiye tha jo sari problem ki roots thi lekin totte kar ditta PB. United India ka koi aur suba k do tukre nahi kiye gaye.
Victim Card syndrome
ٹھنڈا گوشت میں فحاشی آپکو نظر نہیں آتی کمال ہے آپکی نظر پر
Guest seems to be the brother of Musharraf zaidi and host seems to be the brother of shahzeb khanzada
Both are NOT
Striking resemblance tho
@@raftartv Make a podcast on Khalistan
Critique krna bht asaan hy, Mulk banana mushkil.
Bht khubsorat andaz hai inka, or Urdu talufz bhi bht Zabardast hai...
Why quid azam murder Mistry not discussed
Faisal can you get someone to tell us what's the Pakistan ideology.
Next session upload plz
Zabrdst video.
Wonderful presentation and information. May Allah bless you both.
You Are Also Turning Your Unique Channel into podcast channel 😢 You should start another channel for podcasts... Please make documentaries only....
Very informative. Thanks.
Good to see Naveid Siddiqui sb.
Thanks
Azadi Mubarak Naveed sahab .
کُچھ بلوچستان ، کشمیر،دیر ،سوات ،گلگت کے معاملات پر وہاں کے صحافیوں سے بات کریں
Superb🎉
Will your guest tell us who started the quota system based on domicile/ province for hiring in government and Defense Department/ forces jobs. My grand father was rejected for agmission NED Engineering college, Karachi was an Urdu speaking Mahajir ( out total of 130 Karachi had 33 seats for Urdu speaking ), The same was true for his CSP job although he performed very well in tests, interview and physical exam.
Will your guest comment on renting Peshawar Air Force Base to USA and for how much. According to a letter by President Kennedy cash paid was one Billion dollars. Who got the money and how was it spent. In fifties this was big money.
Please comment on bribe to Ayub Khan in the form of General Motors plant in Karachi, later known Gandhara Industries.
آپ سے گزارش ہے ایک ڈاکومنٹری انڈیا میں بننے والی خالصتانی تحریک اور سدھو موسے والا پر بھی بنائیں یہ ایک بہت اہم موضوع ہے
لیکن اواز میں معظم شاہ کی چاہیے❤❤❤❤❤❤
سر واضح ھو رھا ھے کہ پاکستان بنا ھی غلط۔
Pakistan ke concept hi ghalat ga......from culture to ideology.....aj Nazar bi a rha ha ....kch angraazo ke kutta be yeh sub kia
U must have informed that NWFP ruling party have boycott the referendum.
It was also dishonesty by British government where as they took votes in assembly for other provinces but for NWFP (where government was of congress) instead of taking vote from assembly they took the referendum
What about illegal invasion of Manipure , Sikkim & Heyderbad & Junagad
Mohammad Ali Jinnah did not have a plan for the newly formed country and it has been going on since 1947. No one who has come to power or grabbed it by any means has had a plan for this country and following in Jinnah's footsteps.
اپنا وطن اپنا ہی ہوتا ہے الحمد اللّٰہ ۔۔
معاشی حالات اوپر نیچے ہوں یا مہنگائی ہو کوئی بات نہیں اچھا گزارہ ہوجاتا ہے مگر نفرتوں اور آئے دن کے فسادات میں گزارہ بلکل بھی نہیں ۔۔ ہندوستان کا مسلمان 76 سال بعد بھی وہیں کھڑا ہے جہاں ہمارے آباؤاجداد چھوڑ کر آئے تھے، آج تک اپنی شناخت اور وفاداریوں کا ہی یقین دلا رہا ہے ۔۔
The Muslims of India would never be trusted ever now. They would always be looked with suspicion.
Plz interview Eng M Ali mirza
Yaani shuru k 10 saal democracy ka jism itna laaghir ho Chuka tha k Fauj k virus ne attack kia ya phir karna padha
Before 1947, India was never a country, nor a nation. It was always merely a region, nothing more.
Only Punjab, and Bengal were partitioned, not India, there's a difference. Recognise it.
Sindh frontier?
@@imranlion1996 what Sindh frontier?
Have you ever read anything about history? Or just childish idiotic Indian fantasies based on lies.
Babar came to HINDUstan. Greeks came to INDIA. Columbus was looking for INDIA. British came with East INDIA company. This whole region was called Hindustan or Bharat.
@@DonJuan-b9u yes REGION, not a country.
You recognise it's was merely a region, then what are you arguing about?
India, the country, was created in 1947.
@@youknow6968 Nation concept is a recent one and not applicable to subcontinent of India. India has existed for thousands of years unlike recent countries like Pakistan who has just 7 decades old.
Unionist party was party of landlords its merge in Muslim league before partition on promise of Mr Jinnah not to do land reforms
Underrated video
Dont think that Pakistan's initial problems come down to TAYARI, meaning it wasn't prepared. Yes it wasn't prepared becoz it didn't have the right vision for the future country. Thats y on numerous occasions when asked about the future course of the country, Quaid would silence the person, fearing backlash from the religious and secular lobby. In this backdrop of fear, silence and uncertainty, which we still face now, Pakistan came into being.
1938 me Sindh Karachi me Muslim leg ke sobai ijlas me Alag mulk ke qarardad pass hui the jisko bunyad pe Lahore qarardad pass hui Sindh ke qarardad 1940 se pahelli hui Jo shaikh Abdul majeed shaikh ne peshh ke qaid e Azam ne sadarat ke the
So the precedent of a man exhibiting autocracy was first made by Jinnah
Khan Abdul Jabbar Khan Sahab congress k qareeb zrur thy (secular views k wajah sy) but unki apni jammat thi jiski srhad mai hkomat thi congress ki hakomat ni thi sarhad mai
Kha Abdul gaphar khan ne pandit Neharu ko kahatha ke aap hame bhediyonke hawale Kar rahe ho.
Khan Abdul ghaffar Khan is the only Pakistani to be awarded the highest civilian award of India - bharat ratna
Yes
@@himanishdasgupta7217 Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil Jindabad
Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil Gaomuter kay pass hay
4 دن پہلے ایمل ولی خان سنیٹر انہوں نے پینٹ میں تقریر کی اور انہوں نے کچھ ایسے سوالات اٹھائے ان کے بارے میں رفتار کا کیا خیال ہے
ماضی میں کیا ہوا پاکستان غلط بنا سب باتیں اپنی جگہ لیکن اب اس ملک کو کیسے ٹھیک کیا یہ ضروری ہے
It was very clear who started mass violence by direct action day. Is there a really any doubt who started mass violence?
Current population of minority is the proof of that mentality that was started by Jinnah of mass massacre.
Janab Eis Saray Story Mai Balochistan Province Ka Zikar Hei Nhi Howa🙄Or Na Hei Prince Khan Of Kalatt ka Zikar Houwa🙄Aakhir Aisa Q?
Qaum main ghairat nahee
Invite to kamran from Mqm party ,he did very well for karachi development
Also Mr Shabbar Zaidi , Nazia Elahi, Istiaque Ahmed and Sajid Tarar
and Amritpal , Gurpeet Singh Pannu ?
Why you start from 1947 why not from 1940؟؟
Ali khameine biography
Sarah’s ma referendum hua thah kia ?
What happened about Shoaib Akhter story……????
Yeh bhi Pakistan ke bhut kam secular logo me se ek lagtr hai
Ek cheez honorable guest nhn samjh rahay quotation to bilkul achi hai insanity wali pr log different same cheez kar rahay hn to khn se seekhainge hr Naya Banda samjhta hai k wo different tariqay se same cheez kar raha hai. Jo power ki bhook rakhtay thay aaj wo margaye lekin aaj walay bhi aglay 20-30 salon mn mar jaegay iska mtlb ye hai is mulk mn Jo Thora bhi taqat Wala hai wo apnay aap ko invincible samjhta hai
Hari pyara jawan sagara ye poem tab hi likhi gayi hogi 20.50
تاریخ ہماری شرمناک رہی ہے ۔ مھربانی آپ نے تاریخ کو واضع کیا ہے خاص کر کے اج کے نوجوانوں کے لیے۔ جو غلط تشریح حکومتی کتابوں میں بتاءی گئی ہے۔ پہلے دن سے ملک چند لوگوں کے ہاتھوں میں تھا جہاں کوئی قانون کی کوءی چیز نہیں تھی۔ کل بہی جاگیردار اج بہی جاگیردار کل بیروکریٹس کے ساتھ آج اسٹیبلشمینٹ والوں کے ساتھ۔ فرق یہ نظر آرہا ہے۔
Itna arsa pehle ye sb kaha thee aaj ye fitne q Khul Rahe ha
یہ سارے بےشرم لوگ ہیں جس ملک کا کھاتے ہیں اسی کے خلاف پروپیگنڈا کرتے ہیں جو اپنے لیڈر کو مسائل کا سبب قرار دے رہا ہے اس نمک حرام کو دفع ہو جانا چاہیے
Jis mulk ke name Cambridge ma likha ja rha ha.....us je apna kia ho ga ....think about it
Sir,make your facts correct because only Muslim demand seperate electorate not congress. Congress protested against segregation on the basis of religion.
24:23 BS
Pakistan to aaj tak bhi nhi ban saka aur na hi ban sakega. Allah Tala janat naseeb Kare Mohammed Ali Jinnah ko by whom efforts we got separation from you.
😂😂🙏🏽thanks Jinnah 😂😂😂😂
For making Pakistan and taking Punjabi with you
Khalistan Freedom is pending
Nagaland Kashmir Tamil also want freedom from uneducated UP-Bihar
Brother AMJAD you need to grow up if Pakistan was created by Jinnah how about all those small gulf countries like UAE Qatar quwait who were behind theirs partition they were belong to same religion same culture language , for your information it was British policy create small countries because it was in their best interest.
I believe Jinnah was most stupid person who was responsible even today Pakistani’s suffering.
Mhujeer
Video ko upload krny se phele puri tasdiq zaroori hai ibtida me ap quaid e azam pe bohtan laga rahy . Ap ko sharam arahi yeh bataty huwe k pakistan k banny k sath hi sarhad me Afghanistan k zarye puri ek proxy war shuru ki gayi .. yeh jo gher jhamhori bat ap kr rahy pakistan jhamhoriat k lye bana hi nahi tha kya apko allama iqbal ka jhamhoriat pe shair yaad nahi .. ap mutabik liaquat ali khan America group me gaye apko yeh bataty sharam arahi k soviet involve tha afghan proxy me jo pakistani sarhad disturb horaha tha.. jab is qadar jahalat hogi adha sach dikhana aur adha sach chupana tou new generation ka mind divert nahi hoga?? Inshort ap yeh kaho pakistan ko starting se ab tak jageer daaro wadero aur sardaro ny tabah kya hai. Yeh elit group hai yehi media . Judiciary. Thanay . Parliament chalata araha hai ..
C M khodo of sindh was disqualified for theft of typewriter from his office
😜🤣
And his 3 generations have ruled in Sindh eversince. Siyasi Shaheed!
how can he steal type writer when he was wealthy?
Khoro ka gunah ye tha usne Jinnah sb ko nanga kia tha
jese Fatimah Jinnah ne system ko nanga kia
Khoro ko bezat kia gaya Fatima ko mar dia gaya
@@SyedaYasmin-g9w
Aur Khoro koi inqilabi nahi tha, “Khan Bahadur” Khoro aur unionist Party k doosray leader Muslim league ko hijack kr chukay they.
Sindh jo Taalpur, Khoro, Bhutto ki malkiyat raha hai, Pakistan ka sab say resourceful province honay k bawajood sab say peechay kyu hai?
Khud Khoro ki beti nay jo kitab likhi hai us may Angrez k zamany say us ki corruption air incompetency ka zikr hai.
In families ki 3 generations rule kr chuki hain sindh par chahay koi bhe President, dictator ya PM ho. Jinnah aur unki behan say ek rupay ki corruption sabit nahi,
lekin in feudals ki corruption hm nay, hamaray walidain nay ankho say dekhi hai.
How conveniently the biased historian ignores major facts.
1- partition was totally messed up by the colonial masters - remember what Field Marshall Auchinleck said - why he never came back to the UK.
2- the leadership of the majority community did not do an iota to give minorities any comfort that they will be treated as equal and protected. Just see how Mandela treated the minorities and saved the country descending into violence.
3- no proper funding of the new country and proper structure.
The agents of colonial forces keep avoiding saying a word about the colonial masters like Mountbatten.
Yes there were agents of colonial masters who till today are working for those forces.
Keep spreading lies and keep talking nonsense.
Why are Pakistani so called experts so ignorant.
Sarhad government was led by a party that opposed Pakistan, it lost.
It opposed the referendum, it lost.
It was in alliance with the Congress party, the people rejected them.
If you want to discuss democratic values, then they should have resigned voluntarily, that's the right thing to do.
Morally no party can continue to rule, when the people keep rejecting your political positions. They did not have the moral authority to rule.
They should have resigned themselves.
Pak study graduate
Please don't check whole of history, just check the number of people who had to do migration after the Second World War in Europe.
It's a far larger number, then in South Asia.
That's the problem, these people read 1 dimensional history, and they think that's the only thing that ever happened. Look around, and read around. You'll learn something.
Lol which migration of europe
@@SimranDhillon186 please don't be bleeding ignorant. Rather than posting childish comment use Google and read a little, I've provided the time frame. Stop acting like a troll.
Pols didnt had the population even close to united punjab.italians never left peninsula.Spaniards and portugese wasnt part of war effort.nordic countries combined didnt had population of half of bengal.
@@SimranDhillon186 India was a region, you can't pick and choose your facts.
You haven't even read anything, and commenting like a child out of kindergarten.
Read again, how many Germans and east Europeans were uprooted.
Regarding India/South Asia, there are 3 different kind of migrations, for 3 different reasons.
1. People of Punjab and Bengal migrated because these were the only areas partioned, not India. The boundary was announced on 17th August, and there was no plan, creating an disorganised and dangerous situation by design, mountbatton and Congress.
Nehru was shown the bound long before 15th.
That's around 10 million.
2. People who moved for ideological reasons, people who wanted to live in India, and those who wanted to live in Pakistan.
People from Sindh, balochistan and frontier, these were small populations, today Sindh province is still about 9% Hindu.
And Muslims from UP, Bihar, Hyderabad, bombay moved.
This second group was around 5 million in both directions.
3.
Muslims who faced a genocide in Jammu, which had over 60% majority, was turned into a 30% minority. 250,000 were killed by Hindus and maharaja forces in a organised manner.
The refugees are hard to number, because no proper study has been done, but probably around 500,000 plus.
All of the above was not part of the negotiations, it only happened because the handover of power was ill planned by mountbatton, and the Congress. Part of the reason was to ensure Pakistan is unable to handle the situation and doesn't survive as a country.
In India everything was intact, they just swapped chairs, the British gave them a fully functioning organised machinery.
Pakistan was forced to build everything anew, they deliberately made the situation much worse.
That's why.
@@SimranDhillon186 search, Forced Migration in Europe after World War two.
You and every Indian needs to, so do Pakistanis.
You people read something and think that's the only thing that ever happened in the world.
It's pathetic, if it wasn't funny.
Pls invite Hassan nisar sahab
Khalistan Jindabad
This channel is only for Karachi people
Hassan Nisar is in Punjab
History Parhne k baad itna to pata chal gaya k Nehru Jinnah se ziada qabil insan tha Q k jab January 1947 me Lord Mount Battin k sath meeting huwi us me Nehru ne India k liye baqaida constitution pesh kiya lekin Jinnah gadhe k pallay kuch nahi tha or kharabi yahin se shuru huwi
بکواس بند کرو اپنی جس کو لگ رہا ہے کہ یہ ملک غلط بنا ہے وہ دفع ہو جائے یہاں سے
Jinalal poonjalala thakkar qayde azam😮
Khalistan Nagaland Kashmir Tamil freedom
I think islamobhobia is not a key of success
India had not eat but give you cororo tel the world
700 bande mar deye they munafiq sach bol aur bullets k paise b unki families se leye gaye they. Kpk mein Jo hua us mein jinnah b onboard tha
ye bhai sahab zinda thay 40s me? ajeeb bus bukwas krte raho kisne verify krni hen..
نئی نسل کو گمراہ کر رہے ہیں اور کچھ بھی نہیں
Aap ker lein verify. Aap ko parrhnay se kis ne roka hai?
Eilm Sekna Or Tahqeek karna koi Gunnah tou nhi👍
It seems we haven’t learned any lesson from our unfortunate history and no hope for better sense to prevail
Brother AMJAD you need to grow up if Pakistan was created by Jinnah how about all those small gulf countries like UAE Qatar quwait who were behind theirs partition they were belong to same religion same culture language , for your information it was British policy create small countries because it was in their best interest.
I believe Jinnah was most stupid person who responsible even today Pakistani’s suffering.
Very interesting and informative
First thing that went wrong in Pakistan, was when Jinnah became the Governor General, but ruled the country and conducted the cabinet meeting as if he was the leader. GG post is ceremonial. GG does not hold the post of the chief. that is the job of the prime minister. Liaquat was sidelined and GG was ruling the country. That does not sit well in a parliamentary system.
Pakistan Islam k naam per nahi Islam ka naam istemal kr k banaya gaya aur yaha jis tarha islam ka mazak banaya hua hai phr ye sub tou hona hi hai
The guest seems to be a secular person who has learnt history of multiple cultures without having any bias or hatred for any religion 🙏🙏🙏🙏
You are obviously not a smart person.
Seem like you don’t know much about Pakistan. Im quite religious and have similar views about Pakistan.
Khalistan Jindabad
@@Djwgevs ha kpk aur Sindh bacha lo phele😂
Apne media se bahar niklo to pata chalay k wo to bacha hi howa hai @@rajvanshsingh8165
Shame on you both for maligning Quaid e Aazam M A Jinnah
but mate criticism is vital
Quaide Azam was not a prophet he did some mistakes and its good to have a proper debate
@@sktirmizitruth hurts
He’s not questioning Quaid e Azam’s intentions, opportunists usually surround leaders to have things done their way and hijack the movements.
If Quaid e Azam had lived for a few years, the mullas would have charged him with blasphemy and the army would have charged him with treason. To move forward, one must have an open discussion and be willing to understand other point of views. Or else we’ll continue to have tribal mindset of waderas, chaudries and tribal sardar with an overdose of twisted clergy and skewed patriotism.
Brother, I am a law student and QMAJ is my role model. Being honest with you, I actually stepped in, in this field because of him. The purpose of this is to tell you, there is nothing wrong if you criticise anyone’s ACT or disagree with his/her ideology. We (Pakistanis, Indians, Bangladeshis) are especially tilted towards emotions rather than facts and figure because we have been taught like that and schools collages also have failed to develop the level of intellect of students.