Can Hamas be eradicated? | Battle Lines | Podcast

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 апр 2024
  • In this episode of Battle Lines, we reflect on the upcoming 6 month anniversary of the October 7th attacks in Israel that sparked an invasion of Gaza. We speak to the Telegraph’s Middle East Correspondent Nataliya Vasilyeva and Senior Foreign Correspondent Sophia Yan as they reflect on the past 6 months and what the future holds for Israel, Hamas, and a Palestinian state.
    Contributors
    David Knowles (Host) @djknowles22 on X
    Nataliya Vasilyeva (Middle East Correspondent) @Nat_Vasilyeva on X.
    Sophia Yan (Senior Foreign Correspondent) @sophia_yan on X
    For 3 months access to The Telegraph for just £1: www.telegraph.co.uk/audio |
    Email: battlelines@telegraph.co.uk

Комментарии • 70

  • @needmorecowbell6895

    No one is condemning Egypt for not opening the border. Why? Don't they care about Palestinian civilian casualties?

  • @LiamBarden

    Always international pressure on Israel to retreat.

  • @gw7594
    @gw7594  +17

    Sophia Yan states that October 7 was "atrocious". But, in the same breath, she legitimizes the action by claiming "there's a Reason militants felt the need to perpetrate such an attack". How shockingly duplicitous of her. Her bias is further exposed when she states,

  • @misterborak751

    From 15 comments to… 4.

  • @ears9506

    War, especially Urban warfare, is ugly. I pray for the day-after and for those brave souls left

  • @PolicyFailureIsExpensive

    Now hold on. The militants felt "compelled" to rape, burn, butcher, kidnap, and torture civilians?

  • @Alex-vk9rx

    Israel fought an 18 year war in Lebanon. People seem to forget about that one.

  • @sim-pit
    @sim-pit  +14

    Deleting comments like there's no tomorrow. Including one I'd made earlier.

  • @19785881

    How when it's an Ideology 😂?

  • @laurie9557

    Each side is the victim, and each side is the perpetrator. They need to be separated and protected from each other by a third party.

  • @seanoconnor8843

    Looking across the world, the standard of national governments is very poor. I'm aware of Churchill's quote but surely we can do better? Is there an ISO for government? As the power of individuals seems to be growing exponentially with AI, Internet etc. I'm thinking that there is a better way

  • @ph8077
    @ph8077  +1

    Better question: Can Humza be eradicated?

  • @Dbean48

    Yes it can be!

  • @ericsynchrona5495

    "ERADICATE!" - Starcraft

  • @FiveLiver

    Unlike in Ukraine, the Telegraph here has completely failed to understand the issue.

  • @wbiro

    Not as long as humans remain universally clueless.

  • @indunilfernando1336

    Aren't they Palestinians 😂😂😂

  • @redhammer9910

    Talk about sidestepping facts to tell the story. What an appaulingly inaccurate introduction. But it set the scene to invite those convinced of the lies to embrace it. Well done .

  • @jamesgordon8867

    Quit making excuses for Hamas!

  • @creepycrawlything

    The Telegraph achievement here, can be seen as akin to striving to hold an objective centre, in a vortex of conflicting ideological narrative currents. As such, very commendable. It's not then their position taking that is most pertinent, but rather what opportunity for reflection/discussion their position taking allows for.