Looking back at my own PhD defense and those of former colleagues in graduate school, I remember that the questions went on and on until the candidate said "I don't know." At that point one of the professors remarked "If you had said that half an hour ago, we would have been finished." You need to show a mastery of your chosen research but the faculty always want to remind you that you don't know everything. On a more serious note, by the time you are ready to defend your dissertation you should be the leading expert on your chosen topic. If you aren't then you are in for a difficult time.
besides acing a PhD defense, what should a candidate align himself with to have a great PhD submission. what are some great and impactful advice's you could give ?
Funny 😂 99% of the time the examination committee members don’t understand fully what you have done because you are much better than them in your field of research. You are an expert in what you're doing. In your case, I believe the questions went on and on until they got so stupid that the candidate could not answer them 😂.
@@jackyoung9691 The questions weren't stupid, but they slowly diverged from the main topic of my friend's dissertation until it wasn't really in his area. All the faculty was congratulatory afterwards with no hard feelings on either side. They were just making a point.
Does this apply to this research or the content of this presentation? Did the presenter in this video do this too. This comment sounds a bit like criticism of the speaker in the presentation in the video, considering it was commented on this video. TLDRL why did you comment this here? What is the connection? I don't see the connection and I think it distracts away from this researchers topic and achievement.
One of the things I learned from this presentation was that Jacques thoroughly enjoyed the entire research work and was eager to share her passion with her audience. Also, being a great communicator helped her a lot.
The mark of a great technical communicator is when the uninitiated (ahem, moi) hear their presentation and then say to themselves, "Gee, that's not so hard, *I* could do that!" Joel Spolsky, a software developer writes and presents the same way, so lucidly that groundlings are able to get an actual glimpse into the dark magic of the modern world.
I’m a high school student who clicked on this presentation out of sheer curiosity. With absolutely no idea or expectation as to what I would learn, I can absolutely say that Natasha flawlessly delivered her thesis defence in such a clear way, that I was able to grasp the ideas and concepts of her thesis. Very well done and very inspiring.
Dear Natasha Jaques, I’m fortunate enough to attend your defense and was thoroughly impressed by your exceptional presentation skills, as well as the depth and breadth of your knowledge on the subject matter. Additionally, your defense was truly extraordinary and one of the coolest I have ever witnessed. The way you presented your research with such clarity, precision, and passion was truly inspiring. Your ability to engage the audience and communicate complex ideas in a clear and concise manner is a testament to your exceptional academic skills and expertise.
Excellent work and presentation! You were flawless in your delivery and tackling questions. Also, you make it seem effortless by developing a sort of natural, progressive understanding of these complex topics. There is a lot to learn here for a graduate student like myself. Thank you so much for posting this.
I've been interested in machine learning as of the time in my undergraduate studies. really liked that this popped up in my recommended. i'm now seeing how a PhD student presents work in Machine Learning and am hopeful for that pathway in my life in the future!
Wow ! What a great presentation! It is not my research area but I like the way she defended her research. Excellent communication! Hats off! I will definitely inspire from this presentation to prepare my speech for my thesis defense in March 2023.
@@ZidaneTribal93 amazing 😍! As I have already published in top tier journals in my research area, I successfully defended my thesis. The jury gave me very honorable mention with committee praises.
Wow! Excellent, exceptional research! Kudos to you for such a vast coverage of the body of knowledge in this domain! Love and hugs 🤗 from a final year PhD Scholar in Cognitive Psychology from India!
Oh wow! I am about entering the second year of my masters program to be honest I feel a sense of doubt like do I even know where I am and what I am required to be doing but after watching this video there's been some level of excitement and just some relieve. Thank you so much Dr. Natasha Jaques probably you could also help me get clarity in this field of machine learning as I am lost.
Your presentation was outstanding, delivering complex information clearly and engagingly. It captivated the audience with its insightful content and seamless flow.
wow, i am so impressed by you. im "only" doing my bachelor's degree, but i feel inspired to continue my studies in AI and machine learning after seeing your wonderful presentation. thank you -debbie from the netherlands
In your dictionary of counter are you playing a defensive structure meaning you see into the accident or after the accident happens then you start learning some of that you have to continuously put it in place to continuously learn about it
For the people outside academia, usually there are a maximum of 20-30 audience in a defence.. Most of them are from the same lab or colleagues.... Here the room is not only housefull, but have so many views on RUclips.... It's something else!
Remarkable the number of actual advantages to gain from ever expanding world of AI. Which is rapidly changing our communication patterns, ways and means of interaction among the public. With a bit of luck us homo sapiens shall remain in total charge of our own faculties for a foreseeable to prevent any cyborg revolution.
45 minutes is crazy. In Germany it's usually just 20-30 minutes, we barely can afford to crack a joke at this time, since the work of 5-7 years is summerized in this short period of time, which is almost imposible. But you made it look easy :)
And so it is mostly the case these days. A university's community usually doesn't have a clue that somebody is getting their PhD - because the defence is not open to the public.
@@thedog5k bruh... Are you the type of person who is pessimistic about others? Or narcissistic? .... because i said that as a humble comment... im actually the smartest person i personally know. Everyone smarter than me are in the internet.
In that concept thinking of agnostic and argumentative is that cypher or something pretty similar played inside out or back and forth looking at the name concepts or alternating the rotation of inner heat particles then stealing somebody's barcode and blueprints or even a lottery concepts of when lost structures
Hi, Natasha I watched your presentation and thank you very much for sharing it. I read in your introduction that you can access invisible emotional signals, so I was wondering if some kind of signal combined with the content of the exchange could be used to infer if the other person is lying, etc. Why is this question being asked? I've been doing research using natural language processing recently and with the development of generative AI technology, it's having an impact on the way we work worldwide. Remote working in corporate recruiting has become a nice spot for companies, then recruiting can be done at any time from geography to any country around the globe. Thinking how to develop a model of an intelligent interviewer using the method you mentioned to refer to the HR department by outputting a trustworthy report. Hope you can reply if possible, thanks.
I am too ignorant to understand this. As a beginner in AI i will work hard until i can add something or at leat follow this impressing presentation. Excellent work.
So do you not think with you skipping over that first part and then you jumping over into artificial or portrait landscape rotations of concepts of digital terabytes wavelengths as game constructions could be a problem if you're concept was just to completely just continuous flow of it not understand if it's at a different axis rotation or length meaning you'd always have a backward-death pool somewhere because you didn't take it in mind
Thanks for all of you for this noble post, can anyone develop small machine (like spider for example) that climbs high complex trees and harvest only grown fruits of different sizes like Mangos, figs and olives. and maybe use this machine again after few days to harvest again the newly grown fruits on the tree.
Is such a defence of a thesis common? Is it a requirement for getting the doctorate or is it simply being done because the topic is judged to be of wider interest?
Usually any MCI or DL should be used only in normal way not defence critical or nuclear power etc. Just service oriented. Minimal invasive. Any political can be sued.
Looking back at my own PhD defense and those of former colleagues in graduate school, I remember that the questions went on and on until the candidate said "I don't know." At that point one of the professors remarked "If you had said that half an hour ago, we would have been finished." You need to show a mastery of your chosen research but the faculty always want to remind you that you don't know everything. On a more serious note, by the time you are ready to defend your dissertation you should be the leading expert on your chosen topic. If you aren't then you are in for a difficult time.
besides acing a PhD defense, what should a candidate align himself with to have a great PhD submission. what are some great and impactful advice's you could give ?
Funny 😂 99% of the time the examination committee members don’t understand fully what you have done because you are much better than them in your field of research. You are an expert in what you're doing. In your case, I believe the questions went on and on until they got so stupid that the candidate could not answer them 😂.
@@jackyoung9691 The questions weren't stupid, but they slowly diverged from the main topic of my friend's dissertation until it wasn't really in his area. All the faculty was congratulatory afterwards with no hard feelings on either side. They were just making a point.
Already applied for my serious lecturer in clinical science here, no need for informalities bro, your still young minded.
Does this apply to this research or the content of this presentation? Did the presenter in this video do this too. This comment sounds a bit like criticism of the speaker in the presentation in the video, considering it was commented on this video. TLDRL why did you comment this here? What is the connection? I don't see the connection and I think it distracts away from this researchers topic and achievement.
One of the things I learned from this presentation was that Jacques thoroughly enjoyed the entire research work and was eager to share her passion with her audience. Also, being a great communicator helped her a lot.
😊❤❤
Hi
The mark of a great technical communicator is when the uninitiated (ahem, moi) hear their presentation and then say to themselves, "Gee, that's not so hard, *I* could do that!" Joel Spolsky, a software developer writes and presents the same way, so lucidly that groundlings are able to get an actual glimpse into the dark magic of the modern world.
I’m a high school student who clicked on this presentation out of sheer curiosity. With absolutely no idea or expectation as to what I would learn, I can absolutely say that Natasha flawlessly delivered her thesis defence in such a clear way, that I was able to grasp the ideas and concepts of her thesis. Very well done and very inspiring.
somewhow it's not for me. and i have the gut feeling that there is a hole in what she's talking about
Dear Natasha Jaques, I’m fortunate enough to attend your defense and was thoroughly impressed by your exceptional presentation skills, as well as the depth and breadth of your knowledge on the subject matter. Additionally, your defense was truly extraordinary and one of the coolest I have ever witnessed. The way you presented your research with such clarity, precision, and passion was truly inspiring. Your ability to engage the audience and communicate complex ideas in a clear and concise manner is a testament to your exceptional academic skills and expertise.
hahhahahah
Calm down she has a boyfriend buddy she wont kiss you
@@lugia8888 LUL LUL LUL LUL
wow, I am currently during my MSc in computer science (UCL) and just wow. Im so motivated by this to go for a PhD
Excellent work and presentation! You were flawless in your delivery and tackling questions. Also, you make it seem effortless by developing a sort of natural, progressive understanding of these complex topics. There is a lot to learn here for a graduate student like myself. Thank you so much for posting this.
Lies again? Polite Home Delivery USD SGD
The media lab is such an exceptional place. Bridging the nature pf being human with our scientific and technological capabilities. Fantastic!
Just passed my PhD history defense. 320 pg Dissertation.
Congratulations
Congrats Frank..am wating for my viva..u from which discipline?
@@blissofGuruji History
Congrats. Respect doctor. 🎉🎈🍾🎉🍷🎊
I've been interested in machine learning as of the time in my undergraduate studies. really liked that this popped up in my recommended. i'm now seeing how a PhD student presents work in Machine Learning and am hopeful for that pathway in my life in the future!
Wow ! What a great presentation! It is not my research area but I like the way she defended her research. Excellent communication! Hats off! I will definitely inspire from this presentation to prepare my speech for my thesis defense in March 2023.
good luck! mine is in July sometime
How was it?
@@ZidaneTribal93 amazing 😍! As I have already published in top tier journals in my research area, I successfully defended my thesis. The jury gave me very honorable mention with committee praises.
@@remixmix7511 Congratulations!
@@remixmix7511 Congrats! What area of research are you in and what motivates you to do so?
Wow! Excellent, exceptional research! Kudos to you for such a vast coverage of the body of knowledge in this domain! Love and hugs 🤗 from a final year PhD Scholar in Cognitive Psychology from India!
Nobody cares about where you're from
This is incredible work Doctor, I find this subject so interesting! I am a junior computer science and stats major and all of this is my focus!
Amazing piece of work and excellent delivery. Congratulations is definitely in order. Well done, Natasha!
The passion- the passion of this young lady is of a true scholar.
That is a great presentation, you have demonstrated expertise in your area of research. I also like the way you keep the audience engaged
Really cool work - it proves that passion is key to success
I'm impressed by the immersed preparation and skillset displayed in your presentation.
That's a PhD after all
Well great presentation, the coverage of the knowledge content was magnificent. you explained things beautifully. Thumbs up
It was an amazing presentation by Natasha Jaques. Young lady what I appreciate and mainly I learn a lot from you. Thank you so much!
Oh wow! I am about entering the second year of my masters program to be honest I feel a sense of doubt like do I even know where I am and what I am required to be doing but after watching this video there's been some level of excitement and just some relieve. Thank you so much Dr. Natasha Jaques probably you could also help me get clarity in this field of machine learning as I am lost.
Your presentation was outstanding, delivering complex information clearly and engagingly. It captivated the audience with its insightful content and seamless flow.
Thank youThis encourage me to do my thesis coming years
whenever i need some motivation in my PhD i just come back to this
Extraordinary PhD defense!!!!Hats off
wow, i am so impressed by you. im "only" doing my bachelor's degree, but i feel inspired to continue my studies in AI and machine learning after seeing your wonderful presentation. thank you -debbie from the netherlands
Dear all great gentle
Very sweet good morning 🌞🌞🌄🌄🌄
Very great news about the PhD.
Thank you very much 🙏🙏
Inspiration for me as shortly I will be defending my thesis of PhD too. And Subject is almost same.
I am currently in Msc cybersecurity, and you motivate me to ongoing to PhD
This is fantastic! You’re an amazing presenter :))
Brilliant presentation!
Really amazing thought ever, really fantastic and more motivational. I really want to help in my PhD defense .
What a great presentation.
Impressive. Thank you for sharing.
Great research and well articulated to audience in the more intuitive way
great work and awesome presentation. I enjoyed my time to watch it
What an excellent presentation
Excellent Natasha, Congratulation!
Hello Dr. Natasha
The defense perfect about your thesis... Good job
Great work. Learning a lot as i prepare for this journey
To present for 1hour + , babe is too good!!!!
Excellent Natasha - You are a star!!!
Stop simping
@@ABHAYKUMAR-rh4jcWe can't give out compliments to people anymore?
In your dictionary of counter are you playing a defensive structure meaning you see into the accident or after the accident happens then you start learning some of that you have to continuously put it in place to continuously learn about it
Great research work in AI Social Learning from Humans. Congrats. Best wishes for your future endeavors !
This an excellent thesis defense awesome work Natasha
Awesome work. Proud of you 😊
Nice Presentation and Defence as well. Congratulations 👏👏👍
可以说是presentation的典范了，真的很优秀啊👍
Some people were just blessed with brains... I didn't understand a shit but I'm just a bus driver...
You do an important job, I can’t drive a bus.
Bus driving also takes brains. Don't look down on yourself and your occupation in comparison to others
Your role is important too.
She wants your job..ofcourse using artificial intelligence
Right????? I wish I had a cool brain like this hood for her😊
Quick and easy steps! Love it! 👌📝
PhDs aren't for me but always amazing to see how much work goes into it
so excellent and confident, I really admire the state of you at that time.
Dear Natasha that was superb❤🎉
Great findings.. Super positive presentation
Bellman and its equation will be proud of you 😆 great work 😊
For the people outside academia, usually there are a maximum of 20-30 audience in a defence.. Most of them are from the same lab or colleagues....
Here the room is not only housefull, but have so many views on RUclips.... It's something else!
Nice work, nice personality...I'm just going through the ML/DL Research work.
Remarkable the number of actual advantages to gain from ever expanding world of AI. Which is rapidly changing our communication patterns, ways and means of interaction among the public. With a bit of luck us homo sapiens shall remain in total charge of our own faculties for a foreseeable to prevent any cyborg revolution.
45 minutes is crazy. In Germany it's usually just 20-30 minutes, we barely can afford to crack a joke at this time, since the work of 5-7 years is summerized in this short period of time, which is almost imposible. But you made it look easy :)
Gracias por el video, bro. Funciona de forma excelente.
Our defense in the UK was by an external and internal examiner in a viva. It was a closed session.
And so it is mostly the case these days. A university's community usually doesn't have a clue that somebody is getting their PhD - because the defence is not open to the public.
Amazing presentation
Wow! Great job Natasha Jaques👏👏👏👏👏👏
Great learning options here.
I am slightly confused, in some web pages i see WHAT ELSE MOTIVATES PEOPLE and in others WHAT ELSE MOTIVATE PEOPLE......What is correct?
Terrific Thesis Defense! Learn a lot. Thanks!
Made me think im not qualified to pursue post grad.
@@prico3358 Maybe you aren't. But they spend multiple years working on this.
Also, if you can, its still prob not worth it.
@@thedog5k bruh...
Are you the type of person who is pessimistic about others? Or narcissistic? .... because i said that as a humble comment... im actually the smartest person i personally know. Everyone smarter than me are in the internet.
nice presentation, hopefullty i will continue my master degree.
In that concept thinking of agnostic and argumentative is that cypher or something pretty similar played inside out or back and forth looking at the name concepts or alternating the rotation of inner heat particles then stealing somebody's barcode and blueprints or even a lottery concepts of when lost structures
Nice presentation ❤❤
so beautiful, so powerful
45 minutes is so generous. Here at Simon Fraser University math dept the length is only 25 minutes
That's good enough, I have less than 15 minutes for presentation, and there is more than 1 hour for Q&A.
u go girl, impressive presentation
wow she is amazing I hope I could present like her in my master dissertation defense
Good thing they didn't video my PhD of many years ago as i had an argument with a member of the audience. Guess who won the argument?
😂😂😂😂
Hi, Natasha I watched your presentation and thank you very much for sharing it. I read in your introduction that you can access invisible emotional signals, so I was wondering if some kind of signal combined with the content of the exchange could be used to infer if the other person is lying, etc. Why is this question being asked? I've been doing research using natural language processing recently and with the development of generative AI technology, it's having an impact on the way we work worldwide. Remote working in corporate recruiting has become a nice spot for companies, then recruiting can be done at any time from geography to any country around the globe. Thinking how to develop a model of an intelligent interviewer using the method you mentioned to refer to the HR department by outputting a trustworthy report. Hope you can reply if possible, thanks.
I am too ignorant to understand this. As a beginner in AI i will work hard until i can add something or at leat follow this impressing presentation. Excellent work.
Why do people have to turn around every time someone asks something....
this wall is NOT a dryerase whiteboard
String Theory, perhaps a pause on grad students to whom the PhD they seek.
So many bright minds at MIT, but you still need a sign that effectively says: "this is just a wall." :D
So in what I’ve heard so far is that someone trained or educated in military defense has influence in this student’s PhD.
didn't understand a word but you sounded amazing, congrats XD
This is some great work
Fascinating talk, and congratulations!
honor to see you in internet
Very nice work.
This is such an interesting thesis!
great presentation! very interesting :)
Anyone knows how to create animation like the one at 11:30 ?
Great Session
0:10 the camera was zoomed because of one reason
-Have a good day-
learned from you ! so great, thanks!
So do you not think with you skipping over that first part and then you jumping over into artificial or portrait landscape rotations of concepts of digital terabytes wavelengths as game constructions could be a problem if you're concept was just to completely just continuous flow of it not understand if it's at a different axis rotation or length meaning you'd always have a backward-death pool somewhere because you didn't take it in mind
Cool social learning is good for cultural evolution❤❤
Thanks for all of you for this noble post, can anyone develop small machine (like spider for example) that climbs high complex trees and harvest only grown fruits of different sizes like Mangos, figs and olives. and maybe use this machine again after few days to harvest again the newly grown fruits on the tree.
Is such a defence of a thesis common? Is it a requirement for getting the doctorate or is it simply being done because the topic is judged to be of wider interest?
They are always a part of getting a PhD
Excellent explanations 💐🙏🏽
Congratulation Natasha
Usually any MCI or DL should be used only in normal way not defence critical or nuclear power etc. Just service oriented. Minimal invasive. Any political can be sued.
Exceptional presentation