now, it's at hundreds of thousands. the algorithm works in mysterious ways. albeit, this is way better than its usual recommendation of dozens of videos i've alr watched months prior.
This is the flip side of mainstream RUclips: Access to the cutting edge of fundamental research in physics. This is the cream of the crop, the latest news in black hole physics from the masters themselves. Astounding.
I feel like those of us for whom this thesis defense was algorithmically recommended are in a very exclusive group of content consumers for which I am extremely proud to be counted amongst their number. Cheers all! ❤
@@jet-official that's a good one and one my favs. Why is there more matter than anti-matter? It doesn't make sense. Why did matter win out? Open question!
@@ireneisahuman I second this. I love watching these defenses. I don't understand everything but its so interesting. I try to take notes to learn more everyday!
the animation at 17:00 is definitely one of the coolest physics animation/simulations i've seen. Clicked on this video not knowing what to expect, but this was awesome.
I am 19 years old and you are a great inspiration, I hope to become like you one day as I also love quantum physics and quantum mechanics. Someday I will win a nobel prize and I assure you that you will be one of those who inspire me to go far.
Congratulations, Dr Tyler McMaken! Awesome presentation. I am Ph.D. student from IIT Kanpur, India. Loved your animation style. Best wishes!! + Loved the fact that slides are in "black" background.
Just commenting to grt more of this content in my algorithm. I'm starting out my phd research snd this was a nice reassurance thst quantum gravity isn't dead
Just have started to read the book "Black Holes" by Bryan Cox. Penrose diagrams look even more amazing with a visualization. Proud to see the frontiers of the modern physics. Thank you!!
Excellent talk and honestly I'm glad YT recommended me this because it proved to me that you can actually get a pretty good intuitive understanding of literally PhD-level physics from just watching PBS Space Time and Sabine Hossenfelder videos lmao. Loved the graphical animations and numerical simulations, it was a great touch and definitely helped me better visualize your progress through the history of related work and how it arrives at your thesis conclusion.
Yes, just as you can get intuitive understanding of God and heaven by going to church and taking every spoken word from the priest as correct conclusions without any justification. Without math this is merely for entertainment only.
@@TheMajorpickle01 Thank you lmao. Being able to follow the reasoning of something doesn't mean one can contribute meaningfully to it. I just would never have expected to even be able to watch something like this with any understanding at all.
RUclips algorithm led me here only to crush my hopes and dreams of traveling through wormholes to discover parallel universes. Thanks for the great content.
Hello Dr. McMaken this is Keith and this was a lovely video. I was doing research on Kerr black holes and yours decided to pop up. Hope to stay in contact! Congratulations!
Omg!!! A Musician/Composer who pursued a STEM degree!!! You'll make no. 3 on my list 😂 Looks like I'll fit in perfectly when I get my PhD in Physics :)
I’m currently in my first year of college, majoring in astrophysics. I am just looking throughout the internet to catch a glimpse of what I will have to do in my potential future. I hope one day I get to reach this point in my life :)
I'm not far enough in acedmia to know any of the equations, but your visualizations and explanations are easy to solidify in the brain as you have really good presentation skills.
Wow this popped up and I’m hooked. I’ve Always have been interested in space and physics. Years ago I had to change my major from astrophysics to psychology due to my brain not being able to get through the higher level math classes no matter how many tutors I had! 😂. I’m still a bit sad i wasn’t good enough at the math and hard sciences. :(
As an beginner astrophysicist I clicked this video because I thought it was specifically recommended to me by YT. How on Earth does this have THIS many views? 😭😭😭
Black holes project quantum information through entanglement from the 'bulk' or singularity to the 'boundary' or event horizon. They are mirror reflections of each other.
Given that real-world blackbody radiation leads to a gradual cooling of the emitter until it stops emitting, I would expect that the inner horizon energy wall isn't infinite. It would be the sum of all energy emitted which enters the black hole, but that's a finite amount for any real emitter.
Not exactly. You might be stronger in different fields. Also maybe you should take this as a motivation towards learning something harder and challenge yourself. Don't compare yourself to people who spent 20 years in an university studying physics, it's nonsense
Thanks! It's called the Black Hole Flight Simulator (jila.colorado.edu/~ajsh/insidebh/bhfs.html), and hopefully it will be open-source soon, but for now there are still some kinks to work out!
Better animate in Python Mercury’s precession, using gravity g = -G×M/(R²×exp[2GM/(Rc²)]) formula only. Then understand that gravitational time dilation D = exp[G×M/(R×c²)] < ∞ - time never stops, thus no "Event Horizon". Or even better, escape velocity ev = c × √ [1-exp(-2G×M/(R×c²))] < c, thus, no "Black Holes". All these formulas from 3-4-page article "Time Has Potential: Physicists Back to the Drawing Board".
Great overview of connecting music harmonics with time-frequency uncertainty. Only you excluded the overtones and undertones as being actually noncommutative. Please see Fields Medal math professor Alain Connes vid lecture, "Music of Shapes" for the correct understanding of time-frequency uncertainty originating from a deeper noncommutative nonlocality. Please see Professor Basil J. Hiley on how noncommutativity then debunks renormalization. thanks
Have no bad intention of my question but what part of this work is new? Some of it was bringing the audience up to stretch but I wasn't sure from which part became your own work.
thesis defense. He defends his thesis by showing others people formula to proof hi work. Essentially showing his work isn't the main objective, defending the worthiness is
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like you could literally work out the same conclusion with a simple gravitational time dilation model where you demonstrate the difference between infinitesimally small points as you approach the inner event horizon causes massive divergence in time.
Not Tyler, but according to his defense (the best I can interpret it, at least) is that the semi classical model forbids the portal or "wormhole" present in the classical approach due to the infinite energy present at the inner horizon, due to Hawking Radiation diverging
Let us build the Dr E Nordström theory,( not to be confused with G Nordström), of quantized non-sequential time, into the model and the outcome will be different and possibly work better at the quantum level!
6:20 a better representation is the funnel. It represents the time distortion factor better. It is easier to see the future event cloaked/censored from our flow of time. 11:46 It wraps according to spin. Also not seeing quantum boundaries/cutoffs. ( Electron, Barionic,Neutrino.) You also glossed pass the packing problems and fluidic neutrinos and such. Or probability and predictability. Particle production from quantum foam and gravitational waves. Or address the virtual infinity. Not infinite dinsity or another universe ether. The universe is not getting sucked in infinitely fast, and black holes do not poof fast. Black holes are finite systems. Finite to the mass they represent. Not to get into more complex. Quantum tunneling and cross collisions in coliding paths. Not to say you can make island models of a type. Mapping for perspectives from particles relative to each other and outside the black hole. 26:42 the worm hole your discribing is a time machine to the future through gravitational effects. The graviton misses the energy in space time and quantum foam and such. Total energy and mass of a given area. Interchangeable for the curvature. Also, the speed limit of light even if you want to look at it as blue shifted. Otherwise, you have to deal with cherenkov radiation also. Blue or red would just show collision type inside. 43:11 Please look into virtual infinity formed from time to the core event slips further forward in time. The black hole size gives one limit. The universe is another cutoff. Finite systems. Also, what about tidal events? Or Kerr flow and wrapping and quantum boundaries and condensation/degeneracy. Or the most looked over. The time distortion factors. There is a good reason black holes do not spin faster than the speed of light. Good luck in Wonderland.
12:30 Trevor Moore would have lost his mind. as you begin passing the event horizon, the universe becomes entirely flat and redshifted by your perspective. He once guessed this...as a joke. And here it is in quantum physics, years later. wild.
Let's consider Hawking Radiation. Much is said about Temperature but in a non-feeding Blackhole, there wouldn't be anything inside the event horizon (not particles, since they would spiral down into the Singularity, and no light, since light is created by charges and one is considering a neutral black hole). In other words, there are no particles that can have a dispersion in kinetic energy and no electromagnetic fields. So, no system that can have a temperature. With respect to Energy Conservation for the system Collapsing Black Hole + emitted Photon, this is the basis for claiming the need for particle formation. This argument does not specify the energy of the emitted photon and particles cannot be formed from any field that is lower than their inherent mass-energy equivalent. The second kink in the argument is that photons can only produce matter-antimatter pairs.This means that they cannot change the Baryonic Number of the Universe and thus they cannot provide "information" about the baryonic matter that disappeared inside the event horizon. The point of Hawking Radiation is to recover that baryonic matter "information" that disappeared inside the Black Hole.
As a fryer in a fish and chips bar I can confidently say I have no clue what is going on here
The fish is a photon and the lake is the black hole. But if the fish is too small it can’t escape the lake.
OI BRUV YOU GOT A LOICESE FOR THAT?
lmao
Dinosaur dejavu
at least you’re honest
Ah Physics PhD thesis defense RUclips, the best side.
I've never imagined I'd see a phd thesis defense with thousands of views.
now, it's at hundreds of thousands. the algorithm works in mysterious ways. albeit, this is way better than its usual recommendation of dozens of videos i've alr watched months prior.
We all clicked on it because we had no idea what was going on but we just wanted to see you win. Congrats!
I must be one of the few who understands this...yes, I study physics, lol
but u can’t implement
This is the flip side of mainstream RUclips: Access to the cutting edge of fundamental research in physics. This is the cream of the crop, the latest news in black hole physics from the masters themselves. Astounding.
Literally just at the tip of our fingers. When I step back to think about it all, it almost overwhelms me
Woah, im on the deep physics thesis defense part of RUclips again
@@Ryukachoo i keep getting recommended incomprehensible but pretty physics visualizations for papers
Finally. It's like slapping on warm pyjamas.
Again???
I feel like those of us for whom this thesis defense was algorithmically recommended are in a very exclusive group of content consumers for which I am extremely proud to be counted amongst their number. Cheers all! ❤
I have no idea what I'm doing here.
@@miseri338 Doesn't matter. You made it here which makes you one of us. Still counts. Get in here! lol
having an existential crisis about life and why theres something rather than nothing, happy to be here
@@jet-official that's a good one and one my favs. Why is there more matter than anti-matter? It doesn't make sense. Why did matter win out? Open question!
I like turtles!
As a unemployed 29 yo college dropout who's almost never even had a job I can confidently say this is accurate
same
Unfathomably based.
Black hole is your parents basement, where you supposedly spend your miserable existence
Get your shit together and get off welfare.
RUclips algorithm knew what I needed. I have to go through writing and defending my thesis too. So this helped a lot. Thanks
Post a vid of your defense too, would love to watch it
@@ireneisahuman I second this. I love watching these defenses. I don't understand everything but its so interesting. I try to take notes to learn more everyday!
@@MrAwesomeHero1 Yesss i can completely understand!
the animation at 17:00 is definitely one of the coolest physics animation/simulations i've seen. Clicked on this video not knowing what to expect, but this was awesome.
As a warehouse worker and writer who can barely do algebra, this was fascinating to watch even though I struggled to follow along!
I do Uber eats for a living don’t know why RUclips recommended this to me but I’m liking this
a kerr black hole is coming for all of us
i dig holes so i guess the algorithm kinda had the right idea
@@beamshooter
I am not sure why RUclips recommended this to me but I loved it, awesome lecture!
I am 19 years old and you are a great inspiration, I hope to become like you one day as I also love quantum physics and quantum mechanics. Someday I will win a nobel prize and I assure you that you will be one of those who inspire me to go far.
I believe in you
You have no idea what awaits you
nobel prizes happen on their own, would not recommend pursuing research for the sake of one; however, best of luck :D
@@ryeria if you're average
@@Lopez-my7us even if you're a genius, there's so much competition that you're not assured to win the nobel
Exceptional thinking, at least by my standards. I hope to refer back back to this dissertation many more times in my life. Thank you
Thank you for advancing our civilization. Love the visualisations, great job here! And congratulations for you from a stronger from the internet
Dude kewl , can’t believe this is free . Great lecture.
black hole was strong enough to pull me to this part of youtube
Congratulations, Dr Tyler McMaken! Awesome presentation. I am Ph.D. student from IIT Kanpur, India. Loved your animation style. Best wishes!!
+ Loved the fact that slides are in "black" background.
Just commenting to grt more of this content in my algorithm. I'm starting out my phd research snd this was a nice reassurance thst quantum gravity isn't dead
Just have started to read the book "Black Holes" by Bryan Cox. Penrose diagrams look even more amazing with a visualization. Proud to see the frontiers of the modern physics. Thank you!!
Kudos Dr. McMaken, it was a pleasure to have email exchange with you in the past and I hope we keep in touch in the future!
Great defense! I was lucky enough to see it in person 😊
Watching this from Algeria it's impressive
Yeah...that is called translation invariance.
Congratulations Tyler! That was an amazing presentation. Best wishes on the next steps of your Journey!
Excellent talk and honestly I'm glad YT recommended me this because it proved to me that you can actually get a pretty good intuitive understanding of literally PhD-level physics from just watching PBS Space Time and Sabine Hossenfelder videos lmao. Loved the graphical animations and numerical simulations, it was a great touch and definitely helped me better visualize your progress through the history of related work and how it arrives at your thesis conclusion.
Yes, just as you can get intuitive understanding of God and heaven by going to church and taking every spoken word from the priest as correct conclusions without any justification. Without math this is merely for entertainment only.
@@KovacsAttila-ts3be I don't think the chap was suggesting he could now research physics lmao lighten up
@@TheMajorpickle01 Thank you lmao. Being able to follow the reasoning of something doesn't mean one can contribute meaningfully to it. I just would never have expected to even be able to watch something like this with any understanding at all.
RUclips algorithm led me here only to crush my hopes and dreams of traveling through wormholes to discover parallel universes. Thanks for the great content.
Hello Dr. McMaken this is Keith and this was a lovely video. I was doing research on Kerr black holes and yours decided to pop up. Hope to stay in contact!
Congratulations!
Have you heard of the thunderstorm generator?
@@gordobush2618 No please tell me what it is.
Visually stunning presentation. Love the black background and animated pictures.
Omg!!! A Musician/Composer who pursued a STEM degree!!! You'll make no. 3 on my list 😂
Looks like I'll fit in perfectly when I get my PhD in Physics :)
0:33:30 - thank You sir, the acoustics reference here is much appreciated.
Awesome! Insane your thesis defense caught the RUclips algorithm, I can see why
I’m currently in my first year of college, majoring in astrophysics. I am just looking throughout the internet to catch a glimpse of what I will have to do in my potential future. I hope one day I get to reach this point in my life :)
This was actually an enjoyable watch. Congrats!
Top-edge research is always intriguing to watch, thanks.
Edging research here
Congratulations Dr. McMaken!
I'm not far enough in acedmia to know any of the equations, but your visualizations and explanations are easy to solidify in the brain as you have really good presentation skills.
Congratulations and thank you for uploading this
17:22 - "now we're in a new universe! :)" excuse me
Wow this popped up and I’m hooked. I’ve Always have been interested in space and physics. Years ago I had to change my major from astrophysics to psychology due to my brain not being able to get through the higher level math classes no matter how many tutors I had! 😂. I’m still a bit sad i wasn’t good enough at the math and hard sciences. :(
Whoa, I’ve found myself back on the deep physics thesis defense side of RUclips again!
I am actually super fascinated by this work and I would love to see the results for the desitter and anti-desitter space.
I think it is your wonderful presentation of this thesis that makes it easy to follow
idk enough to understand this but it feels like the future
Fuck yeah, let’s go Tyler.
THEY DONT WANT THERE TO BE INFINITE POINTS AT THE EVENT HORIZON! Yes! Legendary drop bro!
Well done. Very digestible and well articulated!
The RUclips algorithm once again reuniting us in utter randomness.
Finally I get to see equations in action.
As an beginner astrophysicist I clicked this video because I thought it was specifically recommended to me by YT. How on Earth does this have THIS many views? 😭😭😭
Go buffs! And nice presentation!
Black holes project quantum information through entanglement from the 'bulk' or singularity to the 'boundary' or event horizon. They are mirror reflections of each other.
So refreshing and Impressive. Good job thanks
I like that you used a lot of pictures and spoke freely
Great job Man!
Thanks for a fascinating presentation! More importantly though, the bird is fine :)
Given that real-world blackbody radiation leads to a gradual cooling of the emitter until it stops emitting, I would expect that the inner horizon energy wall isn't infinite. It would be the sum of all energy emitted which enters the black hole, but that's a finite amount for any real emitter.
Wow great youtube recommendation. This is very interesting.
Not sure what’s happening but good job Tyler 😂😂
Hmm yep I’m going to go ahead and concur with all of that thanks.
Glad you posted this. I was starting to think I had above-average intelligence. Thanks for keeping me in check and reminding me I’m a dumb mfer.
Not exactly. You might be stronger in different fields. Also maybe you should take this as a motivation towards learning something harder and challenge yourself. Don't compare yourself to people who spent 20 years in an university studying physics, it's nonsense
guys I'm so high and I thought the thumbnail was looking at me 💀
The picture was a hoot!
😂
Congrats! Thats awesome!
Great lecture!
"A place called Boulder on the wild Colorado" was the only thing i thought about when realing the description
All congratulations for your defend Doctor ! :)
Love the visualisations! What is the software and is it available?
Thanks! It's called the Black Hole Flight Simulator (jila.colorado.edu/~ajsh/insidebh/bhfs.html), and hopefully it will be open-source soon, but for now there are still some kinks to work out!
Better animate in Python Mercury’s precession, using gravity g = -G×M/(R²×exp[2GM/(Rc²)]) formula only.
Then understand that gravitational time dilation D = exp[G×M/(R×c²)] < ∞ - time never stops, thus no "Event Horizon". Or even better, escape velocity ev = c × √ [1-exp(-2G×M/(R×c²))] < c, thus, no "Black Holes". All these formulas from 3-4-page article "Time Has Potential: Physicists Back to the Drawing Board".
@@alexandrekassiantchouk1632Ah, okey
What an age ,, We get a thesis defence on black hole quantum dynamics from the comfort of our homes
Great overview of connecting music harmonics with time-frequency uncertainty. Only you excluded the overtones and undertones as being actually noncommutative. Please see Fields Medal math professor Alain Connes vid lecture, "Music of Shapes" for the correct understanding of time-frequency uncertainty originating from a deeper noncommutative nonlocality. Please see Professor Basil J. Hiley on how noncommutativity then debunks renormalization. thanks
I’m currently studying mechanical engineering, first semester of the first year.. now i want a PhD in Physics as well.. FUCK
Wonderful work!
Back for my 10th rewatch
Have no bad intention of my question but what part of this work is new? Some of it was bringing the audience up to stretch but I wasn't sure from which part became your own work.
thesis defense. He defends his thesis by showing others people formula to proof hi work. Essentially showing his work isn't the main objective, defending the worthiness is
Correct me if I'm wrong, but it seems like you could literally work out the same conclusion with a simple gravitational time dilation model where you demonstrate the difference between infinitesimally small points as you approach the inner event horizon causes massive divergence in time.
Where to acquire radial data
I'm at that amazing side of RUclips, again.
this would make an awesome osumania chart
Tyler McMaken's secret name is Gordon Freeman.
Congrats 🎉
Very good lecture, but negative temperature is very difficult concept to grapst
mass of accretion disc can dictate the escape velocity
Congratulations!
So black holes can be portals to other universes?
Not Tyler, but according to his defense (the best I can interpret it, at least) is that the semi classical model forbids the portal or "wormhole" present in the classical approach due to the infinite energy present at the inner horizon, due to Hawking Radiation diverging
I had a course in GR and one in Cosmology and it was never mentioned that the singularity would be a plane instead of a point 🙁.
i cant believe i actually watched the 'hole' thing. the only thing i took from this was the pretty pictures.
Some good info.
Let us build the Dr E Nordström theory,( not to be confused with G Nordström), of quantized non-sequential time, into the model and the outcome will be different and possibly work better at the quantum level!
i watched this to make me feel smart
Nice lecture
well done!
Wait im in a different universe? Just like that?
I would have loved to pursue a career in Astrophysics and/or Astronomy. Unfortunately my maths are woeful at best, so I didn't.
Congrats
Somebody remind me after 25 this month so i can watch this after my exam.
Don't forget to watch this.
@@abel3557 Thanks.
Did you get your phd after this?
6:20 a better representation is the funnel. It represents the time distortion factor better. It is easier to see the future event cloaked/censored from our flow of time. 11:46 It wraps according to spin. Also not seeing quantum boundaries/cutoffs. ( Electron, Barionic,Neutrino.) You also glossed pass the packing problems and fluidic neutrinos and such. Or probability and predictability. Particle production from quantum foam and gravitational waves. Or address the virtual infinity. Not infinite dinsity or another universe ether. The universe is not getting sucked in infinitely fast, and black holes do not poof fast. Black holes are finite systems. Finite to the mass they represent. Not to get into more complex. Quantum tunneling and cross collisions in coliding paths. Not to say you can make island models of a type. Mapping for perspectives from particles relative to each other and outside the black hole. 26:42 the worm hole your discribing is a time machine to the future through gravitational effects. The graviton misses the energy in space time and quantum foam and such. Total energy and mass of a given area. Interchangeable for the curvature. Also, the speed limit of light even if you want to look at it as blue shifted. Otherwise, you have to deal with cherenkov radiation also. Blue or red would just show collision type inside. 43:11 Please look into virtual infinity formed from time to the core event slips further forward in time. The black hole size gives one limit. The universe is another cutoff. Finite systems. Also, what about tidal events? Or Kerr flow and wrapping and quantum boundaries and condensation/degeneracy. Or the most looked over. The time distortion factors. There is a good reason black holes do not spin faster than the speed of light. Good luck in Wonderland.
12:30 Trevor Moore would have lost his mind. as you begin passing the event horizon, the universe becomes entirely flat and redshifted by your perspective. He once guessed this...as a joke. And here it is in quantum physics, years later. wild.
Trevor Moore from wkuk 😂?
Let's consider Hawking Radiation. Much is said about Temperature but in a non-feeding Blackhole, there wouldn't be anything inside the event horizon (not particles, since they would spiral down into the Singularity, and no light, since light is created by charges and one is considering a neutral black hole). In other words, there are no particles that can have a dispersion in kinetic energy and no electromagnetic fields. So, no system that can have a temperature.
With respect to Energy Conservation for the system Collapsing Black Hole + emitted Photon, this is the basis for claiming the need for particle formation.
This argument does not specify the energy of the emitted photon and particles cannot be formed from any field that is lower than their inherent mass-energy equivalent. The second kink in the argument is that photons can only produce matter-antimatter pairs.This means that they cannot change the Baryonic Number of the Universe and thus they cannot provide "information" about the baryonic matter that disappeared inside the event horizon.
The point of Hawking Radiation is to recover that baryonic matter "information" that disappeared inside the Black Hole.
This is like kewl