Rigorous Planeswalker Criticism | War of the Spark Flavour Review | Spice 8 Rack

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 4 дек 2024

Комментарии • 687

  • @TheShinyFeraligatr
    @TheShinyFeraligatr 5 лет назад +841

    Since someone has to point it out, yes, that is in fact how Banding works. You mark 4 damage on Rhonas and 5 on Bontu and they live, and of course they deal enough to kill a 9/9.

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +218

      i KNEW i was right despite not doing ANY research into it!

    • @TheShinyFeraligatr
      @TheShinyFeraligatr 5 лет назад +123

      @@Spice8Rack Banding is actually deceptively simple. The only thing that makes it a mess is that it does somewhat different things if you're on defense as opposed to being on the attack, and what happens when it interacts with things like Trample... but, like, Trample is a mess with half the fucking combat keywords in the game anyway.

    • @chasebalcziunas4289
      @chasebalcziunas4289 5 лет назад +13

      Mattman324 like what happens when my deathtouch tramples tho

    • @PrettierNPastel
      @PrettierNPastel 5 лет назад +39

      @@chasebalcziunas4289 nothing special. The only reason trample is the least bit complicated is because people dont realize with trample you only assign exact toughness of the blocking creature then the rest "tramples over" the defending player

    • @PrettierNPastel
      @PrettierNPastel 5 лет назад +1

      I thought I only choose order of damage

  • @ramiritox19
    @ramiritox19 5 лет назад +1008

    Missed the fact that Bolas's -8 literally only kills nameless characters

    • @theomcinturff1213
      @theomcinturff1213 5 лет назад +251

      When the flavor wins but it tastes terrible.

    • @erickvinicius3443
      @erickvinicius3443 4 года назад +19

      Domri: am i a joke to you?

    • @Nyxlave
      @Nyxlave 4 года назад +19

      @@theomcinturff1213 You made a cockroach pie. You followed the recipe, so it is a perfectly-made pie. It still tastes like cockroaches, though.

    • @starduststriker8792
      @starduststriker8792 3 года назад +6

      @@Nyxlave ok but real talk would a cockroach pie actually taste bad? like id imagine that it might but also have no proof as to how insects in general might taste

    • @NovemberXXVII
      @NovemberXXVII 3 года назад +3

      @@starduststriker8792 TBH I think there would be texture issues if nothing else. Cockroaches have weird little arthropod bodies that when you get down to it are mostly goop [hemolymph, if ya fancy].

  • @amunra13
    @amunra13 5 лет назад +223

    Great video. Random lore thing: Arlinn can only transform under the silver moon on Innistrad, so any time she is away she walks as whatever form she was prior.

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +103

      Aaaaaaaah what a nugget of lore I missed! Thanks for the info!

    • @rasmusandersen2835
      @rasmusandersen2835 4 года назад +6

      Does that work when Emrakul is in there?

    • @Case2_0
      @Case2_0 2 года назад +1

      @@rasmusandersen2835 seems to work even better now

    • @funnyvalentine6144
      @funnyvalentine6144 2 года назад

      Source? I have never heard about that?

    • @Numbabu
      @Numbabu 2 года назад +3

      @@funnyvalentine6144 we made it up

  • @TheLangenator
    @TheLangenator 5 лет назад +447

    21:54. I feel like it’s a huge problem that Illharg wasn’t even mentioned in the entire story, despite the fact that A LITERAL GOD SHOWED UP TO THE FIGHT AGAINST BOLAS

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +110

      TheLangenator yeah this is a pretty HARD agree from me

    • @andrewsparkes8829
      @andrewsparkes8829 5 лет назад +39

      I know you didn't blame the writer anyway, but just for the record, that's is on the design team: Maro has said they originallly only had the 4 Amonkhet Gods in as a incomplete cycle, and then only added in Illharg right at the very end of design to complete the cycle. Just wanted to make a little sense of it for you!

    • @andrewsparkes8829
      @andrewsparkes8829 5 лет назад +1

      @@Spice8Rack Also, amazing song!

    • @Mognet_t
      @Mognet_t 5 лет назад +34

      You're assuming Ilharg showed up to fight Bolas. Ilharg's depiction on the flavor text of other cards shows us an ancient god, forgotten by all save special Gruul shamans, known as Druids of the Old Ways. Ilharg is seen as some sort of apocalyptic herald, the eater of civilization, akin to imagery found in real life apocalypse myths, like the 4 Horsemen of the Apocalypse. My assumption was that Ilharg showed up because Ravnica was burning down, and was looking to join in on the fun.
      The Raze-boar was freed to fulfill its ancient destiny, tearing down Ravnica brick by brick. It's no coincidence that Nikya, a Druid of the Old Ways, got a card in GRN. She's the one who backed Domri as leader of the Gruul, as she saw him as some sort of Ilharg-incarnate. and I think flavor text featuring her back in GTC was the first time we ever heard of Ilharg at all in MTG. And I think that if Ilharg had been depicted in the story, he would have been another obstacle, another evil god on a rampage, trying to return Ravnica to a world before the cityscape ruled the skyline.

    • @cadencenavigator958
      @cadencenavigator958 5 лет назад +7

      I got the implication from his dies ability that he was working with Bolas, for the same reason I got from Angrath's -2 that he was; mechanically, all of Bolas's gods have come back after death abilities, while other gods have just been indestructible.
      Unfortunately, Ilharg wasn't even slightly in the book, so y'know.

  • @catoticneutral
    @catoticneutral 5 лет назад +181

    seeing Amass on Angrath legitimately just made me think he was fighting for bolas it was a major flavor fail.

  • @eloquence_4143
    @eloquence_4143 5 лет назад +82

    So you’re telling me that Kasmina, Ashiok, Tamiyo, Narset, Tibalt and Kiora all get cards despite having basically no representation in the story, but Dack Fayden, who dies in the story for no reason, not only doesn’t get a card but also doesn’t appear on any cards in the set? I guess the greatest thief in the universe really got robbed.

  • @jimithanishere3123
    @jimithanishere3123 5 лет назад +366

    Spice 8 Rack on Game knights sounds amazing!

  • @emmettchan5545
    @emmettchan5545 5 лет назад +384

    Vince going on a rant about anarchy is my spirit animal.

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +91

      Emmett Chan He was amazing to work with!

    • @PleasantKenobi
      @PleasantKenobi 5 лет назад +111

      YES

    • @xpeterx
      @xpeterx 5 лет назад +2

      that was my favorite bit.

    • @wp6007
      @wp6007 5 лет назад +3

      I thought it was a cringe nostalgia critic bit

    • @mightyone3737
      @mightyone3737 4 года назад +1

      @@PleasantKenobi It really made me think about how anarchy doesn't have to be about narcissism, something I previously assumed it did.

  • @belugawhale8128
    @belugawhale8128 5 лет назад +146

    Ashiok should've never gotten a card, instead it just being a card for tezzeret (i hope I spelled that correctly) leaving the buy a box promo Planeswalker to be Dack Fayden

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +53

      Any way we could have gotten a Dack card would have been fine with me TBH

    • @Case2_0
      @Case2_0 2 года назад

      @@Spice8Rack the poor boy never got a chance to be in standard

  • @felixmortem1177
    @felixmortem1177 5 лет назад +51

    The Ethics of Mill Versus Discard or: How I Learned to Stop Worrying and Hate my Opponents

  • @flarenite1004
    @flarenite1004 5 лет назад +237

    Dovin looking like hes waiting for the doctor for a toe surgery

  • @Josh_Fredman
    @Josh_Fredman 5 лет назад +48

    I'm so mad that: 1) Nahiri's and Sorin's story was entirely offscreen; and 2) They are defined now in terms of their feud with each other rather than as independent characters.

    • @U1TR4F0RCE
      @U1TR4F0RCE Год назад +2

      Well now nahiri is a crazy villain now so not just a feud is her defining feature

  • @NinaFelwitch
    @NinaFelwitch 5 лет назад +174

    In my opinion the novel is garbage and lore on cards has priority over lore from other sources.
    Lovely video 💕

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +43

      100% Completely agree

    • @JKeays100
      @JKeays100 5 лет назад +4

      I no longer recognize novel as more canon than what is on the cards.
      The canon is on the cards

    • @joeytansey8466
      @joeytansey8466 5 лет назад +3

      But we don't get confirmed gay ral from just the cards!

    • @JKeays100
      @JKeays100 5 лет назад +13

      Yes we do. Look at the white scarve Ral Izzer Viceroy is holding and the red scarve Tomik is holding. Look on their cards

    • @joeytansey8466
      @joeytansey8466 5 лет назад +3

      @@JKeays100 Excellent point! It is an incredibly cute and well done inclusion on the card which expands the multiverse of magic :) However, without the book, we wouldn't have known for sure what those pieces meant, and they would have been relegated to the status of fan theory. While I do agree that the meat and potatos of lore should be on cards, there are only so many cards and so much room for flavor text. There are some smaller less plot related fun things which don't fit, and external media can share those bits to provide aditional context and meaning, enhancing the existing flavor of cards

  • @connorogilvie8194
    @connorogilvie8194 5 лет назад +121

    Would love to see you be a guest on both game knights and a LRR preprerelease

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +36

      I would lose: My shit

    • @feritperliare2890
      @feritperliare2890 5 лет назад

      Connor Ogilvie well he said some bad things about a wotc product and both those productions are wotc’s property so they wouldn’t like him to be there

    • @jaspershepherdsmith9047
      @jaspershepherdsmith9047 5 лет назад +7

      @@feritperliare2890 I seriously doubt wotc own, or have any real veto power, over either of those two productions. The professor has said bad things about wotc products (and business practices in general) several times and he's been on game knights, soooo...

    • @TheEvilCheesecake
      @TheEvilCheesecake 4 года назад +1

      @@feritperliare2890 suggest you see what LoadingReadyRun had to say about the Walking Dead Secret Lair. LRR have never hidden the fact that they do contract work for Wiz but have near complete freedom creatively and total freedom to say what they want about Wiz in their non-contract work.

  • @lyschyk19
    @lyschyk19 5 лет назад +230

    Chandra's Triumph should be called Lazav's Triumph smh

    • @DimT670
      @DimT670 5 лет назад +2

      That's the joke

    • @Bluecho4
      @Bluecho4 5 лет назад +13

      Eh, Lazev probably prefers that everyone but him get the credit. That way, he continues to work in the shadows.

  • @kobyhaigerty3157
    @kobyhaigerty3157 5 лет назад +34

    Would you ever consider doing a video on the importance of the color pie, and how it can be really cool (or not) when it's broken? Color pie breaking effects can be fun to play with, but often times aren't exactly flavorful.

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +18

      I think that's a pretty fundamental topic and one I'd love to explore in my own memish manner :D

    • @kobyhaigerty3157
      @kobyhaigerty3157 5 лет назад +3

      @@Spice8Rack Gotta say, I super appreciate the speed and consistency with which you reply to comments on your vids! Every time I see that you've actually taken time to answer my question or read my feedback it really makes my day! Thank you

  • @Phyrex5
    @Phyrex5 5 лет назад +115

    I've been waiting all week for this

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +6

      I hope it lives up :D

    • @Phyrex5
      @Phyrex5 5 лет назад +4

      @@Spice8Rack Another quality video spice! You've quickly become my favourite MTG youtuber!

    • @ANTREU96
      @ANTREU96 5 лет назад +1

      Grande Giampi

  • @MrInsight47
    @MrInsight47 5 лет назад +18

    For Jace, someone pointed out that his card’s abilities work very well in tandem with graveyard strategies, especially with the new Golgari mechanic, subtlety referencing his relationship with Vraska.

    • @TheEvilCheesecake
      @TheEvilCheesecake 4 года назад +3

      This is one of those times when creators make something underwhelming that accidentally, when looked at by fans in one hundred different ways, happens to produce one interesting coincidence.

  • @MatthewSmith-qd6du
    @MatthewSmith-qd6du 5 лет назад +50

    WAIT! Angrath was a good guy! Well imagine my Shock,
    Actually surprised by this

    • @starduststriker8792
      @starduststriker8792 3 года назад +7

      genuinely wondering whether all of the departments actually talked to each other

    • @FelipeASaito
      @FelipeASaito 2 года назад +7

      Angrath is just a dad who wants to stop being taken from his family every 30 minutes

  • @WowItsErin
    @WowItsErin 5 лет назад +134

    Spice, Chandra is clearly only named "Flame Artisan" to give her and her girlfriend Nissa matching epithets.

    • @SomeFreakingCactus
      @SomeFreakingCactus 5 лет назад +49

      But not girlfriends in a lesbian way. We can’t have MTG getting banned in Russia or China, now can we?

    • @WowItsErin
      @WowItsErin 5 лет назад +6

      @@SomeFreakingCactus But.
      Ralmik.

    • @rhymeswithmoose228
      @rhymeswithmoose228 5 лет назад +9

      @@SomeFreakingCactus Too late! Tomik and Ral are in love.

    • @donb7519
      @donb7519 4 года назад +5

      @@rhymeswithmoose228 yea but neither of them have a netflix series do they

  • @U.Inferno
    @U.Inferno 5 лет назад +7

    28:30 Davriel might have survived that due to the fact that he didn't "absorb" the spell, instead, he literally took it from the Eternal's mind, making it unable to even complete it.
    Even if it didn't work, it can be waved away chalking it up to his Entity, which according to some theories, is the literal soul of a Plane. It had been described it prevents him from dying due to certain means. Even then the Elderspell is a pretty fucking big deal.

  • @tomavent2283
    @tomavent2283 5 лет назад +7

    1. Loved the video
    2. Just to clarify, Davriel can actually steal spells from people’s (and eternals) minds. When he does this that person either permanently or temporarily loses the ability to cast/use that spell and Davriel can use that spell a certain number of times depending on the spell itself. This causes him and the person pain though, and the more powerful the spell, the more painful it is. So when he saved Nissa he basically just stole the Eternals ability to use the despark spell

  • @Conflux4761
    @Conflux4761 5 лет назад +98

    Suggestion for your next video: a review of elves in the history of magic like you did with goblins; that was your best video in my and the interwebs' opinion. I strongly suggest you include at least a minute of content about the elven/elvish debate

  • @ironpage
    @ironpage 5 лет назад +17

    "After this is over, I'm taking you to the Old Town Road." Gideon Jura, hunk.
    That is the quality content I suscribed for.

  • @cpudraner
    @cpudraner 5 лет назад +77

    No one:
    MTG Lore RUclipsrs: How many ways can we spell out how much wizards fucked up war of the spark?
    Love the content

  • @moodystrategy7803
    @moodystrategy7803 5 лет назад +46

    Spice wearing a shirt saying "It's a cold and its a broken Waluigi" is the pinnacle of RUclips

    • @luislegood68
      @luislegood68 3 года назад +1

      It's from the song "waleluja"

  • @5ManaAndADream
    @5ManaAndADream 5 лет назад +16

    you picked the wrong into for raal, the homoelectrical one was best.

  • @savsa-yt
    @savsa-yt 5 лет назад +9

    I'm still wheezing because of the Samut segment.
    Thank you for all your videos.

  • @jasonsmith7530
    @jasonsmith7530 5 лет назад +4

    You can put out a video once a year and still have the best Magic content on RUclips. The amount of detail and care you put into your videos is absolutely amazing. 10/10.

  • @Dominik-ye7hj
    @Dominik-ye7hj 5 лет назад +14

    I always thought that on Ob Nixilis' Cruelty he was pulling apart some creature or another but only now I realize he's incinerating a bird.
    Also *EXXXXXTRA SPEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEEED*

  • @seryntheon8195
    @seryntheon8195 5 лет назад +5

    49:37
    DAMN YOU WEISMAN!
    (echoes off into the distance as camera pans outward and off into the sky)

  • @sugargoblin7710
    @sugargoblin7710 5 лет назад +88

    I haven't seen a Spice8Rack video in a while, this will be great! You're going to mention Ral, right?

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +11

      You best believe it!

    • @SomeRandomDude821
      @SomeRandomDude821 5 лет назад +5

      @@Spice8Rack
      How could we forget someone so lovely and gay?

  • @Daedalus8K
    @Daedalus8K 5 лет назад +9

    Domri: "it's not a phase Bolas!"

  • @jnine8828
    @jnine8828 5 лет назад +10

    27:01 honestly if you listen to his MTGA voice actor you'd be forgiven for calling him "daddy cane"

  • @Skylos
    @Skylos 5 лет назад +2

    43:44 It doesn't actually make it redundant. That abbility gives haste in case you'd spend her last loyalty counter on that abbility (or her being destroyed after the abbility is activated by some other means)

  • @pill0w.climbs
    @pill0w.climbs 5 лет назад +16

    Spice 8 for game knights

  • @toomanyowlz
    @toomanyowlz 5 лет назад +4

    It hasn’t even premiered yet and I can tell we will all love this vid. Happy days @Spice8Rack !

  • @Beefman.0
    @Beefman.0 5 лет назад +8

    You know what? FINE, this 50 minute video has been in my recommended for the last month. FINE, I’ll watch it.
    Edit: okay that was pretty entertaining

  • @Kryptnyt
    @Kryptnyt 5 лет назад +8

    Wait a second, did the part where Rakdos was Gideon's mount ever happen in the book?

  • @rhyderrek6155
    @rhyderrek6155 5 лет назад +2

    I’m glad to know that I’m not the only that thinks of Angrath as having a Cockney accent.

  • @altromonte15
    @altromonte15 5 лет назад +1

    oh god, I just noticed: In samut sprint art, she is running on a wall, and the Bloas statue can be seen behind her, making it look like she is running away from the battle. That card is hilarious now, it looks like Samut is just running away really really fast. "Fighting Bolas? You crazy? So long suckers!" *zooms away*

  • @sharlockshacolmes9381
    @sharlockshacolmes9381 5 лет назад +16

    "Modern Horizon has been fully spoiled already"
    *Laugh in Core20*

  • @ikahekathesnake4233
    @ikahekathesnake4233 5 лет назад +2

    25:20 I come from the future and that’s a good point. How come Rowan, Will, and Oko weren’t on Ravnica? Garruk was officially said to be quarantined away by bolas so he didn’t murder anybody before bolas could, but why weren’t the commander planeswalkers / Koth there either?
    Cheetos

  • @sadlytemporary4143
    @sadlytemporary4143 5 лет назад +1

    In regard to Davriel Cane: in the children of the nameless novella it becomes pretty clear that his spell absorption targets the ability to cast a spell. Basically plucking it out of his target's head. So my reading for that scene is that he caught an eternal mid-windup for a desparking, and plucked out the elder spell before it was cast. It's a stretch.

    • @sadlytemporary4143
      @sadlytemporary4143 5 лет назад +1

      Sorry not trying to be pedantic, just saying that he isn't Taking an Elderspell to the Chest and Surviving it, he's preventing the casting at all. At least that's what I thought, I will fully admit to skimming most of the book after a certain point.

  • @seangoldman6833
    @seangoldman6833 5 лет назад +1

    31:50 When in doubt blame Tefairi. Time magic was obviously used to give them time to finish their fight to figure out who will be on top.

  • @StarkMaximum
    @StarkMaximum 5 лет назад +1

    Also I just wanted to point out, most of the uncommon planeswalkers were designed as blank cards and then assigned planeswalkers. This is the actual reason why Angrath has amass - they wanted amass on a black/red planeswalker because that's two of the three colors it's in but no character in the story fit getting that ability, so they put it on Angrath and justified it as him getting control of the Eternals. Yes, I was confused and thought Angrath was being pigeon-holed into "angry brute villain played by the smart villain" hole too. Yes, I'm very glad he's not. Yes, I'm frustrated that his card isn't a great representation of him as a character. But I accept they did it how they had to.
    Plus, he makes for a fun build around card, and I'd much rather build around him than someone like Tibalt or Ob.

  • @CrimsonFox36
    @CrimsonFox36 4 года назад +3

    Im STILL mad about Dack Fayden's death. just a few months before this set was spoiled, my Dack Fayden cosplay was completed.
    I was livid.

  • @ChiralWolf
    @ChiralWolf 4 года назад +3

    31:09 did weisman actually misspell Ojutai and it was left in? How did this make it past any editor?

  • @funnyvalentine6144
    @funnyvalentine6144 2 года назад +1

    In regards to the logic behind the title "anarch of", its not an nonsensical as it first appears, if you think about it as not a self given title but as how bolas and other characters see him
    Bolas had supported domri so that he could destabilize ravnica, and from bolas' view, everyone is either a pawn like tezzeret or a nuisance like the gatewatch, so while from domri's perspective him attempting to team up with bolas is a mutually beneficial alliance, from bolas' perspective domri is just another pawn who is there to serve him until he stops having use for him, and, regardless of whether or not domri realises, bolas has manipulated him into being "his" anarch, in the sense that he is an anarch, who's actions only benefit bolas, and who is under bolas' control

  • @millenialmonster
    @millenialmonster 5 лет назад +1

    I do hope we keep on getting novels. While they have always been kind of hit-or-miss, some of the older ones like "The Thran", "Nemesis", " The Gathering Dark" or the first Ravnica cycle were really thrilling and, while sometimes somewhat inconsistent with the gameplay (Where are the Teratogen? Isn't there supposed to be only one gorgon left on Ravnica after the events of Dissension? Lyzolda or Yzolda?), they did fuel the flavor for future cards by adding uncarded characters. There's no reason not to combine novels with the kind of great in-game storytelling we got in War of the Spark.

  • @djnotnice8416
    @djnotnice8416 4 года назад +2

    If I may reach here, jace's abilities kinda fit in a vague way. The mill representing digging for an answer where each thing that doesnt work out cost him, like Gideon's failure to kill bolas leading to gideons death. Then his passive showing how he found victory after he believe all hope was gone and was at his wits end (an empty deck). Like a said, a helluva reach, but yeah, there ya go

  • @jesusmunguia5236
    @jesusmunguia5236 5 лет назад +72

    "A canonically queer planeswalker.". Yeah, you're the best magic RUclipsr of all time.

  • @Enja_Near
    @Enja_Near 5 лет назад +11

    This was a fantastic video!
    The cringy comedy is hilarious, the points were on point, and it pointed out quite a few small things I did not notice before.
    Keep up the good work! I'm looking forward for the next video!

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +7

      Only I can post a cringe and GAIN subscriber

  • @maxryan186
    @maxryan186 5 лет назад +1

    I am extremely impressed with the quality of commentary and especially editing during the ENTIRE 50 MINUTE VIDEO. THATS NUTS. TALENT. DEDICATION.
    and banding is like declaring blockers but with attackers

  • @purpleboye_
    @purpleboye_ 5 лет назад +11

    Why does Teyo have the same face as James Charles

  • @PaulGaither
    @PaulGaither 5 лет назад +2

    We are blessed yet again to have this joy of a person speak about Magic the Gathering. Strap in fpr 50 minutes of ear pleasure.

  • @rahuhe4102
    @rahuhe4102 5 лет назад +8

    Man, from yhe bits of the book you showed, Greg had a fetish for listing how many people each planeswalker was killing per attack.

    • @TheEvilCheesecake
      @TheEvilCheesecake 4 года назад +6

      He really has a talent for giving every possible unnecessary detail and yet not enough important detail.

  • @sanityisrelative
    @sanityisrelative 5 лет назад +1

    0:59 so *that's* what they mean when they talk about spoilers on cars. Neat.

  • @NerdySatyr
    @NerdySatyr 5 лет назад +6

    Damn Spice, that was some cute nail varnish

  • @warwerewolf777
    @warwerewolf777 4 года назад +1

    45:01 You should do an alignment video for all the characters

  • @JimFaindel
    @JimFaindel 5 лет назад +8

    That shirt gives me strength.
    Also, IS THAT A MOTHERFUCKING FUNHAUS REFERENCE?!

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +3

      You're goddamn right it is.

  • @joshbublitz4657
    @joshbublitz4657 5 лет назад +4

    Maybe liliana breaking the chain veil was an artist mistake?

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +4

      Josh Bublitz I have to imagine *shrug emoji*

    • @TheShinyFeraligatr
      @TheShinyFeraligatr 5 лет назад

      @@Spice8Rack I mean it still makes more lore sense than Tsabo Tavoc's card.

  • @TinedAlarm
    @TinedAlarm 5 лет назад +1

    As someone who homebrewed a Naya Horse Modern deck and is currently brewing a 5C horse tribal EDH deck with morophon, you caught me really fucking off guard. Thank you Mr Spice8Rack for appreciating the horse players out there.

  • @JREG
    @JREG 5 лет назад +3

    PREMIUM content

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +1

      You're literally the channel that taught me that anarcho-monarchism is a thing and the reason I put it in this script. Curse you. Love your stuff.

  • @hammdogporkington3058
    @hammdogporkington3058 5 лет назад +4

    Spiceman, how do you feel about the Wanderer is Emrakul theory?

    • @feritperliare2890
      @feritperliare2890 5 лет назад +1

      Hammdog Porkington doesn’t make sense as no one is losing its mind around it and it’s not comparable to emrakul’s power and is colored and is a plainswalker all of those contradicts her being emrakul also I’m pretty sure emrakul cant reach ravnica while it has some of its power stuck on the silver moon

  • @copperfield42
    @copperfield42 5 лет назад +1

    32:25 what if that is just what remains of Bolas's statue on the ground after it fall?
    otherwise, I'm suppose to think that they are like DBZ character and fight while flying around and end up in the top of that statue that look like the tallest place around just because?

  • @carumsarene
    @carumsarene 5 лет назад +2

    I've been tempted to get the book and completely rewrite it from scratch with proper grammar and story. Completely free.

  • @Larry_02
    @Larry_02 5 лет назад +1

    Also liliana's planswalker card from w.o.t.s does not show her wearing the veil, yet she wears the veil pretty much the whole book

  • @samarahochstapler2522
    @samarahochstapler2522 5 лет назад +1

    I gotta say, I love everything about your videos, but most of all I love the editing for your bits is just things slapped on things slapped on things

  • @killerkirby366
    @killerkirby366 4 года назад +1

    Okay here's my time to shine this is more. A reference to jaces ultimate goal to learn all possible his mill is reoresentive of his ability to instill amnesia in pepole I hope that helps you it more to do with his charecter and not what he's done in the books while it’s not good for the story but it’s more about his general character

  • @coyoten8897
    @coyoten8897 5 лет назад +1

    good lord i love your graduation pic, also great intro for Ral

  • @andrewamann8855
    @andrewamann8855 5 лет назад +15

    I haven't actually bothered reading the novel, or tracking down your audiobook, but all the excerpts I've seen, every last one, have been so awful that I'm kind of embarrassed for the rest of the creative team....

    • @bulink5087
      @bulink5087 5 лет назад +2

      I have never (ever) seen a story where something was out in parentheses, until this.

    • @DatBrasss
      @DatBrasss 5 лет назад +2

      It's like they published the author's cliff notes before he wrote the actual story.

  • @guywithaguitar8521
    @guywithaguitar8521 5 лет назад +3

    just found your channel, was not expecting such a high quality video! keep up the great work!

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад

      Tbh, even I don't expect high quality content from me. I'm glad you found me

  • @JohnSmith-cl3jg
    @JohnSmith-cl3jg Год назад +1

    OK, I know I'm 3 years late to the party BUT! Liiana's passive is flavorful as when her eternals die it takes less focus to control them all as her mental strain lessens she is able to think of new tactics gaining knowledge and thus drawing cards

  • @lostmarble540
    @lostmarble540 5 лет назад +1

    I like the flavor text on Spice's chest. It's a cold and it's a broken waluigi. In comic sans. Excellent flavor.

  • @finkelzo
    @finkelzo 5 лет назад +13

    Wotc should let you voice Liliana in Arena

  • @Squishyobsidian
    @Squishyobsidian 5 лет назад +2

    F*****g love it!!! Keep up the amazing original content creation and dope editing!

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +2

      squishyobsidian hef I’m f*****g glad you enjoyed it!

  • @ryanmalinowski7529
    @ryanmalinowski7529 5 лет назад +5

    Can't stop laughing about all the SPEED that Samut has

  • @death-kyun
    @death-kyun Год назад

    18:07 Maybe its supposed to hint that she doesnt actually want her zomies to kill anyone (since she's under Bolas's influence), so the card draw on your own creatures death represents her gaining some peace of mind.

  • @wrennthewizard144
    @wrennthewizard144 5 лет назад

    49:36
    Yes, ofcourse, Since the first one turned out so well

  • @jacobjohnson6384
    @jacobjohnson6384 5 лет назад +1

    As a wherewolf, Arlin only transforms because of innistrads moon, which is why she can’t transform on Ravnica.

  • @andyspendlove1019
    @andyspendlove1019 5 лет назад +1

    Love the video. I do feel like it would be reasonable to concede, though, that anarchy on Ravnica would look a lot different than anarchy on our world. Since the entire Ravnican planet is comprised of just one, monolithic super-government, as opposed to our world's many to choose from and be let down by, and since that super-government quite intentionally shafted the Gruul millennia ago by charging them to take care of the wilderness and then systematically dismantling that wilderness with ever more urban expansion, I think Ravnican/Gruul anarchy would be accurately described as any effort that aims tol completely dismantle that super-government, by any means necessary, even if that means pledging allegiance to a new despot, because even the new despot's (Bolas') world would look radically different from the old. No more guilds, no more urban expansion, no more Gruul getting the shaft. Even under Bolas' tyranny, Ravnica would be fundamentally and irrevocably altered. Unlike in our world where overthrowing one despot and their little clutch of power inevitably leads to just another despot with a similar-looking clutch of power.

  • @raidenmakoto7168
    @raidenmakoto7168 5 лет назад +1

    42:51 the freakin green hill zone im dead lol

  • @Lobo_Loco
    @Lobo_Loco 5 лет назад +1

    Completely new world for me ;-)
    Thank you for the credits
    Lobo

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад +1

      Sandsofa - Lobo Loco - Musikbrause Yo your music ROCKS! Thanks for putting it up on FMA XXX

  • @sephapplewhite8477
    @sephapplewhite8477 5 лет назад +1

    I always assume that magic content can't be this funny, but you regularly make me full on chuckle. Out loud! Gadzooks!

    • @Spice8Rack
      @Spice8Rack  5 лет назад

      Sebastian Applewhite, love a good Gadzooks! Thanks for such a nice comment

  • @CharletteAndMo
    @CharletteAndMo 5 лет назад +1

    17:31 All this time and I had no idea you were Robert Pattenson!

  • @ollieblob2042
    @ollieblob2042 5 лет назад +15

    Welp you heard it here first! Spice 8 Rack doesn't give us quality content

  • @rodolfolazo7638
    @rodolfolazo7638 4 года назад +1

    I want to point out that the "ghost assasin" bit was picked up by Django Wexler, the writer of prequel, in the form of banter between Kaya and Hekara.
    10/10

  • @123silverslash
    @123silverslash 5 лет назад +1

    We get our first Viashino planeswalker and they get merked before we even learn their name!!

  • @LokNWykLeer
    @LokNWykLeer 4 года назад +1

    16:03 To be fair, I legitimately laughed out loud about this one!

  • @dem7556
    @dem7556 5 лет назад +4

    I bet Wizards never expected someone to do this much research.

  • @danielkings2443
    @danielkings2443 5 лет назад +29

    My friend. What in the hell is wrong with Dovin’s toe?!

    • @monowhite7989
      @monowhite7989 5 лет назад +4

      He is supposed to have 6 toes.
      So he aded 1 to the picture, for some sweet Canon

    • @danielkings2443
      @danielkings2443 5 лет назад +5

      @@monowhite7989 Its. backwards. Is that canon?!

  • @CromCruachTheElderK
    @CromCruachTheElderK 5 лет назад +1

    Wow, positively connoted appearance of anarchism. Glorious!

  • @seveneightlp
    @seveneightlp 5 лет назад

    23:29 Don't remember that flavour text.... but I'm sure it's accurate and I am not going to investigate further.

  • @dunamoose3446
    @dunamoose3446 5 лет назад

    25:22 Elspeth is dead, Will and Rowan don't have sparks yet because Battlebond takes place five years after WAR, Garruk has a *hedron* stuck in his chest, Koth can't planeswalk for some reason (maybe hes dead).

  • @zoltanwolfe1260
    @zoltanwolfe1260 5 лет назад +4

    *It's a cold and it's a broken waluigi.*

  • @rodolfolazo7638
    @rodolfolazo7638 4 года назад +1

    The "ghost assasin" bit also happens in The Gathering Storm prequels, but between Kaya and Hekara. However, the two seem to be more amused by the exchange than Karn ever was.

  • @grimtopia4804
    @grimtopia4804 3 года назад

    46:50 That is literally what original planeswalker Bolas has +3 Destroy Target Noncreature Permanent, so I agree he should have it

  • @dieciluna_mt4618
    @dieciluna_mt4618 5 лет назад +7

    Saheeli & Huatli should have summoned the dinosaurs automatons they were working in the conclusion of the Ixalan story, how cool would it have been for them to be operating FREAKING DINOSAUR GUNDAMS?!?!

  • @PALAD1N_005
    @PALAD1N_005 5 лет назад +1

    About angrath having amass, if he gives all of the creatures you control menace, which I guess him keeping them safe by keeping the eternals at bay, would kinda make sense if YOU BELIEVE HARD ENOUGH. Amass could maybe be that if you make only one army and all your creatures have menace the army can’t block/ kill them because he’s keeping them at bay, which still wouldn’t make sense because YOUR making it but hey, WHAT CAN I SAY EXCEPT YOUR WELCOME.
    Love your content man, keep up the good work!