Sane because he is an independent. Which is what Imran Khan was for 14 years as well, hence remained on the sidelines. Just wait till the establishment starts finding him worthy of high politics, you'll see his face change just like the rest.
For the first time, ve heard a politician talk about what is being taught to the aam awaam in public institutions. Everyone talks about setting up schools, colleges, universities, no one talks about the actual education students are receiving. Did FSc after O levels and realised how bad the quality of education is for majority of our people. No comparison of matric and fsc board system and O/A levels 💔 Brilliant questions by the host 👏 watched till the end.
Voted for him this time. Brilliant man. You can tell he actually cares about the country unlike politicians like IK who want to fulfill their personal selfish motives and want revenge
Another nice podcast . The guest is unfortunate to be just 1 person in the politics . But as he gave an example . In the books of history he will be known as the person who had good intentions to help pakistan. Good work Shehzad 👏
One of my favorite politician of Pakistan. He is relative of Taji khokhar, a well known don of Malik riaz, but interestingly he's so humble, enlightened and progressive. Thanks a lot shehzad once again
I like this guy. At least says the right things and isnt too afraid to call a spade a spade. Other politicians just come with their pre-rehearsed talking points and provide nothing of substance.
Loved the discussion on his class position. Rare to see this question posed so adamantly to Pakistan's political elites, who just take it for granted. Great interview.
4:45 the last internet shutdown cost my Freelancer friends 2 of his high paying long term jobs. From saving and dreaming to build a 5 marla house in Bahria, to selling his car and scrambling for funds, all the while trying to look for new clients. This is just one example of how internet shutdown affects freelancers.
A person who resign from Senate and condemn the wrong doing of his party. He could join any party and could easily take ministry but now fighting solo election for the rights of the country's people is no doubt on right track. ❤
Mr. Khokhar, you're that tiny bird with a mouthful of water heading directly toward the wildfire. May the good Lord be with you, sir, and may our beautiful home land see brighter days ahead for us all.
Namaskar Shahzad bhai. Mustafa bhai is Rajput? Plz make a Podcast on role of biradari poltics in Pakistan specially Punjab. Which are dominant biradaris of Punjab. Love from India
Really excited to watch this podcast 🎉 I also wanted to ask a question Shehzad Sir, you have been very silent on Twitter about whats happening to PTI these days. Wonder whats your take on it?
Remarkable Vlog A sane voice and my inspirational person, always stood for the rights of the people. My humble request with the host to kindly share the name of the Book, which he mentioned in the Podcast at 21st minute, while he presented the perspective on the major successful ratio of the non violence movements compared to the violent movements. I am anxious to know about the name of the book. Thanks
PTI didn't talk about reforms in Arm forces in their manifesto. It's a total disappointment. If somebody clearly does things against you and you cannot even say anything, you won't be able to do anything.
I have been following yiur podcast for sometime. This guest was the first person who has ever admitted that the decision of Yaha Khan and Bhutto to reject the 1970 election results was wrong.
Ap reforms kese karien gy jb har ak sector mein foj beneficiary ho gi.jese real state ki baat ki gyi DHA waly ko reforms krny dein gy?? Mere khyal mein Pakistan ki tarakki mein rukawat number one foj ki involvement in politics and in different sector hai and number two hamara energy sector
Hope He wins in election along with Jibran Nasir, Amaar ali jan and all other progressive candidates who think about poor people of the country. May the east india company (army) & their lickers loose!
Always love these deep insights into Pakistani politics 🙌 Just a small correction to what he said - as per official records (from electionpakistan), in 2013, from 48, he got 44984 votes, PTI got 57383 and PML-N got 94106. So the "5-6 hazar voton ke darmyan khel rahe the" line isn't really accurate. Obviously that doesn't reflect on him per se, just a statistical nitpick.
im happy to see you have finally realised the notion of “cult” for PTI supporters was stupid and the support did indeed come from a politically educated viewpoint whether the intellectuals like it or not
24:05 I had been trying to find a list of candidates for my area, but so far have not seen a single website listing all candidates for each NA AND PP. Does anyone know of one?
Highly impressed to see the good intentions of Mr Nawaz khokher. He should have joined PTI after his success in the election. I feel he should made his first suggestion in the assembly to eliminate the Army Act and all colonial rules and regulations from the constitution as well as eliminate the present judicial system and quick justice system like China or Singapore should be implemented.in education and training Singapore's model of education system is the best for our country.
17:55 Yes I agree he paid cost. In fact as a PTI supporter, I also found it a bad move at that time. But today, in hindsight, despite all the costs, I think it gave Khan's slogan of 'imported hakoomat' a lot more credibility on streets, as in, 'hey, look at this PDM that claims democracy! See how they're violating democratic values by hindering elections, pushing them past 90 days! See how they've forced themselves upon this country!'. Ironically, PTI even won Punjab elections in which Hamza was running. So this move has made Khan's stance appear more principled, like, we wont do any deals or compromise with the 'chor' and 'imported hakoomat'. IMO it also helped clean PTI party of all the kachra. People now have more awareness and are more sympathetic to Khan. In alternate timeline, outcome would have been the same as well (Khan imprisoned, etc.), but maybe people wouldn't be too enthusiastic to support him as it would have been just a re-run of Nawaz in jail and Khaqan as PM.
In 2018 Pakistan,s external and internal debt was Rs.24953 billion , in 2019, Rs. 32708, in 2020 Rs. 36399, in 2021 Rs 39866, in 202249242, in 2023, Rs.59247 billion means Rs. 59247,000,000,000.further translate this debt into dollar it becomes , 207, 884,210,526 means 66% of your GDP. These three parties snatched the right of dignity, prosperity, now they are once again want to come into power, they are with the help of establishment kidding us, what a joke.
Its a dilemma for politician like Mustafa, seen Ghafoor Sb. sticking to JI despite differences and in the end was marginalized. On the other hand Sher Baz Mazari left party politics and cant do nothing.
He didn't answer the question though: How will he provide job opportunities? Not just him, how does one create employment in a country like Pakistan at this time?
20:38 Anyone who can mention which book Khokhar sab is talking about? Off the topic, Tariq Ali book How to Bring Down a Dictatorship is also about revolutions, specifically uprising of youth in Ayub regime that weakened and eventually toppled his hegemony, but alas we had Yahya afterwards. What a bleak turn of events.
Khokhar sb I am lawyer based in twin cities. I am also researcher in children rights. Also, I fully endorse your point of view. I want to join your political journey.
2016 2017 my best years of life in Pakistan.... establishment ne hansta basta mulk ujaad dia ...allah pak in logon ko jahanam k nichlay tareen darjay me jaga de aameeen
India is independent today because of Subash Bose. The British handed over power to the Congress and Jinnah as they knew that they could not hold on to their jewel in the crown.
Fatima Jinnah was not only sister, she dedicated her life for the creation of Pakistan. Sadly she was humiliated and cursed by Ayub Khan in Public and finally was killed.
I’m from Lahore, Pakistan 🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai, Zafar Heretics and Harris Sultan. I’m happily Ex-Muslim Now….I need your help…❤
Me app ka bahot hi izat aur ihteram karta hun.kiunke app ik honest siyassat karte heen. Me kuch points pa app sa ihtelaf karta hun. 1)no violence moment vahan pa kamiab hotte heen. Jab app ka vasta kissi muhazib takat sa ho.jab app ka vasta pak army sa ho.too non violence moment sa kuch nahi hogha.app ne PTI. Mahrang baloch .Bangladesh ke non violence moment sa sik lia hogha.aghar app 50 hazar ka ik orgnized force bana leen. Too iss army ko deafet ho sakti ha.app barma(myanmar)ko dek leen. Ribellion jit rahi ha.afghanistan vale kabi bi azad na hotte.aghar voo non violence moment chalate too kabi azad na hotte..
All the independent candidates who are competing elections under PTI banner what guarantee is there they will stay with PTI after winning they can go in any Party by force or willingly
One of the sane voices in our political system. Huge Respect for Khokhar Sahab.
Sane because he is an independent. Which is what Imran Khan was for 14 years as well, hence remained on the sidelines.
Just wait till the establishment starts finding him worthy of high politics, you'll see his face change just like the rest.
Beautiful. Just beautiful. This channel is truly raising awareness. Also, MNK is a very sensible man.. a genuinely nice person.
🙌
One of the few Pakistanis who is held in high esteem by the masses.
No!! A gangster can't be respected. Remember how he punched the old man at Marriott because the old man was taunting lota politicians.
For the first time, ve heard a politician talk about what is being taught to the aam awaam in public institutions. Everyone talks about setting up schools, colleges, universities, no one talks about the actual education students are receiving. Did FSc after O levels and realised how bad the quality of education is for majority of our people. No comparison of matric and fsc board system and O/A levels 💔
Brilliant questions by the host 👏 watched till the end.
Voted for him this time. Brilliant man. You can tell he actually cares about the country unlike politicians like IK who want to fulfill their personal selfish motives and want revenge
1:40 I feel sad when I realize that 20 years from now, the young will speak of the musical chair of 2010-2020… just like we talk about the 90s
Another nice podcast . The guest is unfortunate to be just 1 person in the politics . But as he gave an example . In the books of history he will be known as the person who had good intentions to help pakistan.
Good work Shehzad 👏
🙌
One of my favorite politician of Pakistan.
He is relative of Taji khokhar, a well known don of Malik riaz, but interestingly he's so humble, enlightened and progressive.
Thanks a lot shehzad once again
🙌
Look how he punched an old man at Marriott and you'll see the humbleness.
One of the best political discussion to date.
I like this guy. At least says the right things and isnt too afraid to call a spade a spade. Other politicians just come with their pre-rehearsed talking points and provide nothing of substance.
Shahzad bhai name of the book or research jo Kokhar saab Political movements k barey me keh rhey? (20:58)
Love and best wishes from New Delhi to you shehzad bro 🎉
❤️
These are so much better than conventional media talk shows.
🙌
your podcast is going to make an impact in the long run for this nation. never stop doing this
🙌
Loved the discussion on his class position. Rare to see this question posed so adamantly to Pakistan's political elites, who just take it for granted. Great interview.
🙌
4:45 the last internet shutdown cost my Freelancer friends 2 of his high paying long term jobs. From saving and dreaming to build a 5 marla house in Bahria, to selling his car and scrambling for funds, all the while trying to look for new clients. This is just one example of how internet shutdown affects freelancers.
Your podcast is best.Please request the guests to mention the books name that they are using as reference.
🙌
So much clarity in thought and in plans when compared to Bilawal or quite a few other party heads and senior leaders.
A person who resign from Senate and condemn the wrong doing of his party. He could join any party and could easily take ministry but now fighting solo election for the rights of the country's people is no doubt on right track. ❤
52:09 Bravo 👏 This has been a relaxing podcast, full of positive vibes
🙌
*From India 🇮🇳 but interesting in Pakistan 🇵🇰 Politics tomuch...*
Mr. Khokhar, you're that tiny bird with a mouthful of water heading directly toward the wildfire.
May the good Lord be with you, sir, and may our beautiful home land see brighter days ahead for us all.
One of the finest and educated politician i know ever since he was part of PPP i was a fan of Mustafa Bhai !
No merit, no educational system, no governance, no justice, no equality, nothing for masses!!☹️
Namaskar Shahzad bhai. Mustafa bhai is Rajput?
Plz make a Podcast on role of biradari poltics in Pakistan specially Punjab. Which are dominant biradaris of Punjab. Love from India
Really excited to watch this podcast 🎉 I also wanted to ask a question Shehzad Sir, you have been very silent on Twitter about whats happening to PTI these days. Wonder whats your take on it?
Follow the Tpe account
Shehzad asks very tough questions to his guests.Kudos to this channel.
🙌
Please have an episode with Ashir Azeem, the former Customs officer, on
Remarkable Vlog
A sane voice and my inspirational person, always stood for the rights of the people.
My humble request with the host to kindly share the name of the Book, which he mentioned in the Podcast at 21st minute, while he presented the perspective on the major successful ratio of the non violence movements compared to the violent movements.
I am anxious to know about the name of the book. Thanks
Mustafa has my vote
PTI didn't talk about reforms in Arm forces in their manifesto. It's a total disappointment.
If somebody clearly does things against you and you cannot even say anything, you won't be able to do anything.
I have been following yiur podcast for sometime. This guest was the first person who has ever admitted that the decision of Yaha Khan and Bhutto to reject the 1970 election results was wrong.
We’ve probably talked about it 50 times before this
اس ملک کی بہتری اور خوشحالی کے لئے سب سے بہترین پارٹی PTI ھی ھے جسکی ساری پالیسی ملک اور عوام دوست ھے۔
Always impressed by nawaz Khokar, hope he never compromises on his principles
20:21 He talked about book but couldn't mentioned its title. Any idea?
Hi. Can you please ask him about the title of the book he's talking about @20:00. Is it Poor People’s Movements by Piven and Cloward?
my guess is he is talking about How Nonviolent Resistance Works by Erica Chenoweth and Maria Stephan.
Ap reforms kese karien gy jb har ak sector mein foj beneficiary ho gi.jese real state ki baat ki gyi DHA waly ko reforms krny dein gy??
Mere khyal mein Pakistan ki tarakki mein rukawat number one foj ki involvement in politics and in different sector hai and number two hamara energy sector
If you think that any civilian will convince GHQ to cease and desist indefinitely, then I've got news: Ain't never ever gonna happen chief!!!!
Excellent podcast with an amazing guest ❤❤❤
❤️
Mustafa Sahab 2018 or 2024 mai bht farq hai, 2018 mai PML N k pass shair ka nishaan zaror tha.
He is honest and intelligent person I would love to join him if he made some party 🥳🥳🥳✌️
Mustafa is a Nice Guy and Shez you always great 😍
Hope He wins in election along with Jibran Nasir, Amaar ali jan and all other progressive candidates who think about poor people of the country. May the east india company (army) & their lickers loose!
52:46 I think he was referencing to 1984 when he said big brother state 😂 not too sure if Shehzad got the reference 😂
Great man
Always love these deep insights into Pakistani politics 🙌 Just a small correction to what he said - as per official records (from electionpakistan), in 2013, from 48, he got 44984 votes, PTI got 57383 and PML-N got 94106. So the "5-6 hazar voton ke darmyan khel rahe the" line isn't really accurate. Obviously that doesn't reflect on him per se, just a statistical nitpick.
🙌
Mustafa you are good, i hope you will be successful
Shehzad bhai, live Q&A bhi karen, I have too many things to ask.
Election day live karte hain
What is the name of book which he's mentioning about political movements?
“Self-accountability”-grand idea/step
Nice work shehzad. You are arguably the most unbiased podcaster rn regarding the elections.
@@ThePakistanExperiencewhy are pakistani complain India border situation this time most peaceful Nebhighor for Pakistan is India
Really enjoyed this podcast
🙌
im happy to see you have finally realised the notion of “cult” for PTI supporters was stupid and the support did indeed come from a politically educated viewpoint whether the intellectuals like it or not
The PTI cult exists, denying it is denying reality, I’ve always said not every PTI supporter is a member of the PTI cult though
Please avoid abbreviations in your conversation. I couldn't understand SAMC though I was enjoying the podcastbut it interuupted me
24:05 I had been trying to find a list of candidates for my area, but so far have not seen a single website listing all candidates for each NA AND PP. Does anyone know of one?
GEO just created a website for all the candidates you can see there
which book @21:00
2022 mai PMLN keh rahi thi khan agar KP or Punjab assembly khatam kr dy tuo general election ho jaen gy tuo assembly torna ya chorna galat kaisy hua,
Thought ❤
Highly impressed to see the good intentions of Mr Nawaz khokher. He should have joined PTI after his success in the election. I feel he should made his first suggestion in the assembly to eliminate the Army Act and all colonial rules and regulations from the constitution as well as eliminate the present judicial system and quick justice system like China or Singapore should be implemented.in education and training Singapore's model of education system is the best for our country.
17:55
Yes I agree he paid cost. In fact as a PTI supporter, I also found it a bad move at that time. But today, in hindsight, despite all the costs, I think it gave Khan's slogan of 'imported hakoomat' a lot more credibility on streets, as in, 'hey, look at this PDM that claims democracy! See how they're violating democratic values by hindering elections, pushing them past 90 days! See how they've forced themselves upon this country!'. Ironically, PTI even won Punjab elections in which Hamza was running. So this move has made Khan's stance appear more principled, like, we wont do any deals or compromise with the 'chor' and 'imported hakoomat'. IMO it also helped clean PTI party of all the kachra. People now have more awareness and are more sympathetic to Khan. In alternate timeline, outcome would have been the same as well (Khan imprisoned, etc.), but maybe people wouldn't be too enthusiastic to support him as it would have been just a re-run of Nawaz in jail and Khaqan as PM.
my vote for mustafa in election 2024.
Is it right to say the elections will be Heads, establishment wins, tails, establishment wins ? How free and fair do you think it might be ?
I like this guy✨
You’re are right it is Selection not election
how the Gb govt disolved .this establishment manipulated
Guest Manzoor pashteen in your podcast if you want to be most watched❤❤❤
Khokhar Sahab ap tanshan na len, Ap hollywood ke movies ko dubbed kar k Pakistan me sale karian.
Ap ka vocal MashahAllah boht acha hai.
In 2018 Pakistan,s external and internal debt was Rs.24953 billion , in 2019, Rs. 32708, in 2020 Rs. 36399, in 2021 Rs 39866, in 202249242, in 2023, Rs.59247 billion means Rs. 59247,000,000,000.further translate this debt into dollar it becomes , 207, 884,210,526 means 66% of your GDP. These three parties snatched the right of dignity, prosperity, now they are once again want to come into power, they are with the help of establishment kidding us, what a joke.
Its a dilemma for politician like Mustafa, seen Ghafoor Sb. sticking to JI despite differences and in the end was marginalized. On the other hand Sher Baz Mazari left party politics and cant do nothing.
Honest person
Brilliant
🙌
amazing guest
He didn't answer the question though: How will he provide job opportunities? Not just him, how does one create employment in a country like Pakistan at this time?
@25:20 oh dam!! That was a low blow hahaha
20:38 Anyone who can mention which book Khokhar sab is talking about?
Off the topic, Tariq Ali book How to Bring Down a Dictatorship is also about revolutions, specifically uprising of youth in Ayub regime that weakened and eventually toppled his hegemony, but alas we had Yahya afterwards. What a bleak turn of events.
Only Mustafa Kamal and Ali Muhammad Khan these both are credible personalities in politics right now they should colab and make new party 😎😎😎👍
Regional integration k liy open minded hona aur human rights ko improve krna pre ga
Tough questions but he escaped successfully 😂
Mafia ,qabza group
Khokhar sb I am lawyer based in twin cities. I am also researcher in children rights. Also, I fully endorse your point of view. I want to join your political journey.
Selection har bar nai hoti kiya ya bhai agr election win kar jaty ha to kis party main jain gy
2016 2017 my best years of life in Pakistan.... establishment ne hansta basta mulk ujaad dia ...allah pak in logon ko jahanam k nichlay tareen darjay me jaga de aameeen
India is independent today because of Subash Bose. The British handed over power to the Congress and Jinnah as they knew that they could not hold on to their jewel in the crown.
Fatima Jinnah was not only sister, she dedicated her life for the creation of Pakistan. Sadly she was humiliated and cursed by Ayub Khan in Public and finally was killed.
👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
14:14 this podcast is way too short…
The best way to unlock capital locked in real estate is to tax it. No one says this because of DHAs and personal interests.
جب تک اسٹیبلشمنٹ کو آٸینی حدود میں مقید نہیں کیا جاۓ گا۔ ملک نہ آزاد ہوسکتا ہے اور نہ ہی ترقی کے منازل طے کرسکتا ہے۔
44:13 we do not need to decrease our defense budget, the real danger is the pensions for civilians and armed forces.
As per law, independent MNA has to join any party in 3 days.
I’m from Lahore, Pakistan 🇵🇰 I left Islam after reading Quran and listening Adam Seeker, Sahil Bhai, Zafar Heretics and Harris Sultan. I’m happily Ex-Muslim Now….I need your help…❤
Me app ka bahot hi izat aur ihteram karta hun.kiunke app ik honest siyassat karte heen. Me kuch points pa app sa ihtelaf karta hun.
1)no violence moment vahan pa kamiab hotte heen. Jab app ka vasta kissi muhazib takat sa ho.jab app ka vasta pak army sa ho.too non violence moment sa kuch nahi hogha.app ne PTI. Mahrang baloch .Bangladesh ke non violence moment sa sik lia hogha.aghar app 50 hazar ka ik orgnized force bana leen. Too iss army ko deafet ho sakti ha.app barma(myanmar)ko dek leen. Ribellion jit rahi ha.afghanistan vale kabi bi azad na hotte.aghar voo non violence moment chalate too kabi azad na hotte..
Ask about his uncle taji khokhar and his criminal empire.
The rise of TTP and where PDM and the Establishment have failed - Mustafa Nawaz Khokar - #TPE 248
ruclips.net/video/8ZfLwGnjim0/видео.html already did
Ghiaz bhai :)
All the independent candidates who are competing elections under PTI banner what guarantee is there they will stay with PTI after winning they can go in any Party by force or willingly
0
Why Quaid was taken to ziarat where nothing was available even pain killers???
There are cedar (Sanober) forests near the Ziarat Residency that were believed to be beneficial for patients of Tuberculosis.
😊❤🎉
👍👍
That last joke. ❤🎉
😅
urdu thumbnails likhnay lagay ho , smart move more views
Bhai china 140billion ki population h per woh or population chahtay h 1single child ko cancel ❌ kar dia h