@@jeffstrosmchats7259 and? A cutter ( even at 103 mph) depends on strong defense. He got a lot of soft contact and gave up a hr. Happens to literally everyone at times.
Most of that team is underappreciated, Im from DC, and I also play with them in the Show ranked, its hilarious to beat on everybody that relies on the Dodgers in that game😂
I personally think that Guerrero jr. should get bonus points since he threw a big screw you at superstition and had an amazing season as the show's cover athlete.
Id say its definitely Ohtani but Betts is closer than stats give him credit. Shohei is big super soldier type guy, big hits big plays. Betts is more like a Mr Fantastic, he'll basically be whatever the team needs
Note on Dansby, I wouldn’t call his base running or anything he does surprising, the guy has the fundamentals down and as a rival in the NL East watching him for years while he wasn’t a killer (im sure hes had his fair share of clutch daggers and walkoffs just going off memory watching him against my team) he would beat you by just doing everything right defensively offensively hes just a super solid player you cant hate on him honestly cause he also does it with class
I think Miamis best player was Jake Burger his bat was great in 2024, its just that hes on the marlins and had no protection in tha their line up what so ever
Calling Gunnar Henderson the Orioles' best player over the entire AL MVP class? Bold. But saying Jared Duran could outshine Rafael Devers as the Red Sox face? That’s pure chaos fuel...
People get mad when you call "availability" a skill, but if you call it "durability" they just nod their head and agree. Why is this? I have no idea, because they're essentially the same kind of value you want in a good player.
My question is how Brent Rooker got the Silver Slugger over Yordan, but Yordan won the All-MLB team over Rooker... Both were ranked as a DH so no defense.
15:19 you can’t tell me that Bobby isn’t the player that contributed the most to his teams success after that. If Judge, Soto and Ohtani all place higher in MVP than Witt and Lindor. Better change the award name to Best Player in that case.
the Rockies are not as horrible when looking at prospects, Condon, Dollander, Veen, Amador, Fernandez, Sullivan, Hill, Montgomery, Hughes and several more, all of the Rockies minor league affiliates made their respective playoffs, Luis Peralta showed big things in 11 or so innings this year, and in the AFL Evan Justice did not give up a single hit
can agree with jose for my guards but clase deserved a mention too. also the mariners should’ve gotten a mention for Kirby, dude would rather give up a HR than a walk. could just be a me thing, but he had crazy great control
@@SuperCatacata oh I agree. Mookie was the mvp until he got hurt and missed 2 months. Around the time Marte got hurt, I thought he should be mvp then Ohtani became a 40/40 followed by first 50/50 guy and it was his mvp no matter what
Old and dumb take, even a full player like Lindor in NL can't even get close to his WAR even with DH penalty. Mets fan shut up after Ohtani6 /6 game and you should too.
Agree with Jose Ramirez, but should've at least mentioned Clase with his 672 ERA+
That's fair, he was a beast too!
@@madethecut 5 earned runs allowed all year. Worth a mention. Probably will come in 2nd for the Cy Young award.
@@refusetolose05dude sucked in the postseason
@@jeffstrosmchats7259 and? A cutter ( even at 103 mph) depends on strong defense. He got a lot of soft contact and gave up a hr. Happens to literally everyone at times.
@@refusetolose05and if he didn’t have a terrible playoffs he would probably be the best
Now we need every teams most underrated/under appreciated player
and, to complete it, each teams most overrated player
Fr
@@mackenziecoleman8103fr
Cubs I would go with Shota, due to consistency. Dansby struggled after his injury, and started to hit well, when it was too late.
Kyle Tucker could've been in mvp conversation man
7:30 Skenes DID finish top 3 Cy Young. He’s a Cy Young finalist so he’s one of the top 3 vote getters
Every teams best player of all time, that could get controversial. And id love to see it!!
Yes
I'd love to see all 3 of those.
Merrill had and has insane clutch+ value
Excellent content, ty. Enjoy your presentation style too.
As a Nats fan, I believe not even mentioning Kyle Finnegan is more than criminal
Most of that team is underappreciated, Im from DC, and I also play with them in the Show ranked, its hilarious to beat on everybody that relies on the Dodgers in that game😂
As a giants fan I agree with Matt Chapman
The best ability is availability.
162 game players are goated
I personally think that Guerrero jr. should get bonus points since he threw a big screw you at superstition and had an amazing season as the show's cover athlete.
Id say its definitely Ohtani but Betts is closer than stats give him credit. Shohei is big super soldier type guy, big hits big plays. Betts is more like a Mr Fantastic, he'll basically be whatever the team needs
Betts getting utility silver slugger award is a good nod to that flexibility
I’m a red sox fan and don’t watch a ton of cubs baseball but dansby seems underrated
Note on Dansby, I wouldn’t call his base running or anything he does surprising, the guy has the fundamentals down and as a rival in the NL East watching him for years while he wasn’t a killer (im sure hes had his fair share of clutch daggers and walkoffs just going off memory watching him against my team) he would beat you by just doing everything right defensively offensively hes just a super solid player you cant hate on him honestly cause he also does it with class
9 WAR AS A DH? Big papi could never
Paul Skenes did finish top 3 in cy young
I think Miamis best player was Jake Burger his bat was great in 2024, its just that hes on the marlins and had no protection in tha their line up what so ever
Jackson Merrill is HIM
Calling Gunnar Henderson the Orioles' best player over the entire AL MVP class? Bold. But saying Jared Duran could outshine Rafael Devers as the Red Sox face? That’s pure chaos fuel...
People get mad when you call "availability" a skill, but if you call it "durability" they just nod their head and agree. Why is this? I have no idea, because they're essentially the same kind of value you want in a good player.
* Cal Raleigh with a Platinum Glove
My question is how Brent Rooker got the Silver Slugger over Yordan, but Yordan won the All-MLB team over Rooker... Both were ranked as a DH so no defense.
I personally don’t agree with the Brent rooker pick. Miller was a top 3 reliever for the entire year, in his rookie season.
Best Player of All-Time.
15:19 you can’t tell me that Bobby isn’t the player that contributed the most to his teams success after that. If Judge, Soto and Ohtani all place higher in MVP than Witt and Lindor. Better change the award name to Best Player in that case.
Best player of all time
Bobby Witt Jr. is truly the people’s MVP this year
A classic player
Nope
“Which will be relevant for a couple guys” pans to judge
the Rockies are not as horrible when looking at prospects, Condon, Dollander, Veen, Amador, Fernandez, Sullivan, Hill, Montgomery, Hughes and several more, all of the Rockies minor league affiliates made their respective playoffs, Luis Peralta showed big things in 11 or so innings this year, and in the AFL Evan Justice did not give up a single hit
Let’s see a most valuable starter from each team
This kind of is just a list of the top 10 players as well as 20 shortstops
As a cubs fan Dansby wasn’t a great hitter only good at fielding and base running shota is better
Tovar > Doyle. Lead the NL in doubles and was high up on total bases
I would've gone for Tovar
Brandon Lowe's last name is pronounced Lao
NL East is out of order. Braves finished 2nd, Mets 3rd
can agree with jose for my guards but clase deserved a mention too. also the mariners should’ve gotten a mention for Kirby, dude would rather give up a HR than a walk. could just be a me thing, but he had crazy great control
Took a dude having a all time season to get that MVP off my guy Lindor.
Luis Garcia Jr >>> CJ Abrams
Next video: each team's most average player
All Arizonans everywhere have a Ketel poster in their bedroom
Before his late season injury and Ohtani going nuts to get 50/50 I thought he should have been NL MVP
@@PresidentDennis_Tbh by that logic, Mookie was a lock for MVP until he got hurt and missed 2 months.
It's all about staying healthy.
@@SuperCatacata oh I agree. Mookie was the mvp until he got hurt and missed 2 months. Around the time Marte got hurt, I thought he should be mvp then Ohtani became a 40/40 followed by first 50/50 guy and it was his mvp no matter what
8 views in one minute bro fell off
Need at least 9
@@madethecutLol 😂
I got 9 don’t worry
Salvation: repent(change your mind about sin and attitude to the way God sees it.) and trust in Jesus
Hey, you didn't cover the Prison League! Franco got 14 WAR. Insane!
Not funny.
Lol
@@isiight. depends on your sense of humour to be fair
@@isiight. Only cause Wander Diddy hasn't got arrested yet
Nah it’s literally imanaga
Bad edition
It’s so confused to tell which team and which player you are talking abont.
DANSBY. ARE YOU INSANE?! I’m a Cubs fan and he wasn’t good.
Disspontment
Dodgers are ruining baseball so unfair my brewers may never win a world series or even going back to one smh 🤦 😤
The Dodgers aren't your problem. The Brewers keep doing this to themselves.
Literally one of the biggest frauds in October over the last decade.
Contreras is a top 2 catcher, and he ain't number 2
bro you gotta learn how to talk normally
He's improved. It looks like he's working on it.
0 views in 0.00001 second smh this channel irrelevant now fr
Hot take: Ohtani shouldn’t win MVP. DH only plays half the game. Should go to pitchers or players that play both sides of the ball
Going off that logic, pitchers shouldn’t get it because they only play one part of the game not even every day
Your own logic destroyed your reasoning.
It should go to the player who gives the most value to their team. That’s obviously Ohtani with the Dodgers
Old and dumb take, even a full player like Lindor in NL can't even get close to his WAR even with DH penalty. Mets fan shut up after Ohtani6 /6 game and you should too.
"Dh only plays half the game"
Proceeds to say pitchers should win instead who only plays half the game