@@PazyPlayz oh looks amazing though so you should definitely claim it Also thanks for replying to a comment a year later You, my friend, have a new subscriber 👍👍👍
I love John he’s one of my all time favourite characters it doesn’t make sense how some people Shit on John’s character just because they can’t play as Arthur in the Epilogue
@@IcySwagTag yess ikr. even tho i'm missing arthur while playing as john, i'm still so happy playing as him. in the first red dead i was so pissed to play as jack, so i'm really glad i'll be able to spend rest of the game with john this time 😂❤
John and Arthur are truely the best 2 characters in gaming history, theyve both my top place in my top gaming characters, so much emotion and pain no other character has made me feel the same while playing them
Niko Bellic was pretty good, Out of all the gta protag's I feel he deserved a sequel or a prequel into his past back in eastern Europe, initial service in the army committing terrible war crimes and then his criminal career shortly after up until he gets a lead on Florian which takes him on the ship to Liberty city, I feel like Rockstar could have done a whole lot more with his story than ''We used to Rob banks'' and ''I'm just a black youth trying to get out of the hood''
Also Dutch he is one of the most well written antagonists I've ever came across he is the villian that no matter how much you want to hate him you still have a soft spot for
Especially considering Dutch like Arthur and John both realized after it was already to late how the world works and that they made mistakes with who they chose to be. Arthur regretted all the bad he did. Dutch wished he didn't fall into his true nature that he did better but he knows that even if he walked off that cliff alive he'd still not be able to change and I think that's why he threw himself off not because he was trapped by John or because he was a coward. He wanted the war with his ego and his humanity to end
Arthur told John over and over to not look back. But he did. He went for Micah. Ross found him. John dies. If only he listened to Arthur John would have survived.
You are right, however I believe John Marston was a man with profound values and at the end, he had to finish what it was started. Micah destroyed the whole gang, which was initially a family, by persuading Dutch. Following that, Arthur gave his life for John, but mostly, Morgan teach Marston by example, being honorable and following the values that gave him peace in the last moments. It’s true that he would have lived a peaceful life the other way around, but as John says, he was responsible for his actions and he decided to be the end of Micah Bell because he did not deserve more time in this world after all he did. I truly believe that it’s all about redemption for both Arthur and John, facing every situation in his hard life as a valuable lesson and most importantly, as a revolutionary act of themselves to show the kind of men they were, by leading their lives according to those profound beliefs.
Fer Serrano you are 100% right. I kind of rushed the game and finished it really quickly but I’m going to go through it again more slower and look again more closely how these characters changed.
@party pooperdude In the Epilogue, when Sadie Adler and Charles come to Beecher's Hope to finally seek Micah Bell, John tries to make Abigail understand that is something he needs to do in order to be in peace with himself too, as he explains that if it wasn't for Arthur Morgan, Hosea, Lenny and everyone who were left behind, the dream of Beecher's Hope and the opportunity that they have in that moment won't exist. And moments before, in a bounty mission with Sadie, John clearly states that he is the only one responsible for his actions. He could not live peacefully letting that need of reckoning with Bell go. As Doc Holiday from Tombstone (Amazing western which I recommend) would say "Oh, make no mistake, it's not revenge he's after, it's a reckoning." Its all about having a chance, an opportunity to prove that, when everything is burning, good men will act seeking peace in their righteousness beliefs.
party pooperdude I know, just wanted to add that detail, as the story has so many of them that is hard to believe. Knowing Doc Holliday its a fact that makes me respect you sir. My hypocrisy only goes so far haha
The amount of love for these artificial characters from me and the whole community, its soo big that I don't even want to call them "artificial characters" or video game characters, I truly had emotions for both of them and that is extremely rare in a game, rockstar made a masterpiece
What really gets me though is everything Arthur died for was in vain, John lives his life as a rancher with Abigail and Jack for a little but ultimately they cut his life short too.... damn those pinkertons
Squanchie 420 John and his family lived a perfectly happy life too. He weren’t a threat to the Pinkertons and didn’t do anything illegal but as Dutch said to John “When I’m gone they’ll just find another monster, they have to,they have to justify their wages” (anything illegal or messed up the player does in both games I wouldn’t consider canon because John strived to live past the life of an outlaw)
Everyone that fell in love with Arthur and John cried when they died!!!!! John in Red Dead Redemption!!! And Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2!!! Rip both!
I can’t help knowing why I fell in love with John Marston’s character in the first Rdr because of the influence Arthur had on john’s life that impacted him to do better. In the end they were truly brothers 💔
Arthur says "I want you to not look back." But John does look back - he hunts down Micah and kills him to avenge Arthur - even though the game constantly points out that revenge is foolish. "Especially for things that happened a long time ago." And you know what? Killing Micah is what put the Pinkertons on his trail and set in motion the events of the first game. "Nothing get's forgiven. People don't forget."
That's the sad beauty of it. I think John knows on some level this will probably comeback for him eventually, but he couldn't forgive Micah for what he did and I can't really blame him even with the knowledge of how it all ends in the first game.
as much as i love Arthur, something about John's story hits different when you did what i did and played RDR2 first then went and played RDR1. like you've been with John from the start, sorta. you saw how it all went down, you grew connections to the people you end up having to hunt down and it just hits ya like a runaway train. i genuinely had a hard time shooting Bill in RDR1 cause i came to like him and grow close to him playing through RDR2, before i knew he would later become an antagonist. i hogtied Javier rather than shooting him. and Dutch was the hardest to face cause i liked him for his leadership qualities from the start, so not only was his betrayal at the end of RDR2 a slap in the face, but the fact that he continued to delude himself heading into RDR1 that John was the traitor and the rat was so upsetting.
but its nice that u made a video for John! I like John more, dont get me wrong I really like Arthur but I played the first one and when I play rdr2 and see Abigail and Jack it makes me kinda sad when I think about what will happen with John.... But Nice work with ur videos, both of them! John and Arthur's!
This is the best tribute I've seen so far, the editing is top notch and the music goes really well with the scenes you've chosen. I also loved the fact that this tribute is about the relationship of Arthur and John and not just about John. John is the man he was in the first game and later in epilogue of the second game thanks to Arthur. "Get the hell outta here and be a god damn man!" And so he went and became a great man. Thanks for this tribute, outstanding work really.
Thanks for the lovely comment. I always aim to showcase the excellent character arcs and writing. Video games are getting far more interesting with the level of depth and amount of time players spend with characters that I hope we will continue to get more relatable people like Arthur and John in particular. Once again, glad you enjoyed it!! 👍
PazyPlayz I really hope for that as well - this is a future of games and story telling! Thanks are on my side, I will definitely watch your tribute again. :) Great work!
Red dead 3 should take place right after john marston’s death and the main character be jack and it shows the time between john’s death and jack killing ross, then in the epilogue it shows jack create his own family with 2 sons he named arthur and john
I cannot choose between Arthur and John.. they both reprrsent two different times and games. They both were important in my life each one at a different time. I now have a save game with Arthur and one with John. I love them both.
It's so heartbreaking whenever you realize John's own death was his own fault, the only reason Ross found him was because he got revenge on Micah, had he listened to Arthur and never looked back he would have finally gotten to live the life he always wanted, John has nobody to blame but himself.
Wouldn't have mattered either way...the Pinkertons/Ross wanted the entire gang dead. Ross only used John to find Bill, Javier and Dutch later on in RDR1.
I would watch these videos forever, I don’t know what to do if John and Arthur be here for everyone, they just are so great people that I ever met in a game....😭💔
Arthur was my brother and every single day I think about how he saved me and my family and I wish I could just switch roles save him so he could or if I could have done while Arthur and Micah were fighting
@Hydra Hamad they die of their own stupidity and stubbornness. Had a Horse which stood on the Railroad Tracks and just committed suicide when the train came... RIP Shredder... F
Arthur going against Dutch is the moment Arthur turned into a legend, and the moment Dutch lost everything... without Arthur’s blind loyalty Dutch knew it was all crashing down for real
When John died, he quoted arthur Arthur: "listen to me, when the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back." John: "Jack, take ur momma and run and don't look back." I don't fully remember wat john said but it was something along the lines of that
1:If it weren’t for Arthur, Jack wouldn’t have He’s parents. 2: if it weren’t for Arthur, John wouldn’t have gotten that ring 3: if it weren’t for Arthur, red dead redemption wouldn’t have existed.
The first game needs a serious remake. I think the ending of the first game should play out different depending on your honor level. If you play the game honorably, then that marshal from Armadillo, Bonnie MacFarlane, her father and a few others you've helped along the way. Show up and help John and his family fight off the government agents and the army. Maybe they show up to the ranch to visit, and during the visit the agents show up. They have a big gunfight and since John has help. He doesn't have to sacrifice himself. Then after it's over, maybe the marshal could explain how John helped him out, and gets him pardoned of his past crimes. At the same time the marshal uses the attack on the Marston family as evidence against Ross and the army. However if you play dishonorably, then you get the ending we all know. There also needs to be moments and easter eggs that pay tribute to Arthur. Maybe John still carries Arthur's journal. Maybe Dutch brings up how those last moments with Arthur. The look in his eyes, as he laid there on that mountain top, slowly dying haunts him, and how it's been slowly driving him insane. While holding the pipe that Arthur gave him. Maybe Dutch finally admits that he failed them all, and that he just wants it all to end. Maybe Dutch even goes as far to say that a part of him wishes that it ended at the end of John's gun. That dying by the hand of one of the people he failed is something he deserves. But John can't do it, so Dutch kills himself. I also think that Bill Williamson's lines need to be rewritten a bit in the first game. Because the character that he is in the first game, doesn't really match up with who he is in second game. Sure he's angry and a bit of a fool sometimes, but there's several moments where Bill seems to have more of a heart than Javier. I was surprised the first time I heard Bill express regret and sorrow for the loss of Sean and especially Kieran. A very different person from the Bill Williamson in the first game, who seemed more of the cold blooded murderous type. I understand that the events of the second game probably pushed Bill over the edge, but I think there needs to be a moment where Bill expresses what he's going through. In fact all the surviving members of the gang need to have moments of reflection on the events and characters in the second game.
Awesome video! People forget Arthur was modelled after John in a lot of ways, not in the story telling but from a practical standpoint as the original red dead came out in 2010 was it? So before you all flock to Arthur, remember John has one hell of a tale to tell and for me is everybit as good/badass as Arthur if not more. 2 sick characters.
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - The Evolution of Arthur Morgan || Fan Tribute || [4K]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/d4X6GMBACP0/mqdefault.jpg)
![Red Dead Redemption 2 - The Evolution of Arthur Morgan || Fan Tribute || [4K]](/img/tr.png)
Here's a sad Arthur Morgan Tribute- ruclips.net/video/uiYcLrXWaMA/видео.html
You spelt gang like gain in the description. Just FYI.
1:02 was amazing where you made Arthur’s face appear for a second well done 👍👍
@@kurtcobain5466 I think it was actually a glitch on my old PC when it rendered lol
@@PazyPlayz oh looks amazing though so you should definitely claim it
Also thanks for replying to a comment a year later
You, my friend, have a new subscriber 👍👍👍
I love it just when John proposes to Abigail and he pulls the ring off that picture of Arthur and Mary
(sorry, late) First playthrough I thought that Mary walked and John saw her, that would be even more sadder.
@@sadieadler5219 i love you sadie😍
even though we have fallen in love with arthur, we still love you john ❤
Indeed
That's right
I’m glad you said this
I love John he’s one of my all time favourite characters it doesn’t make sense how some people Shit on John’s character just because they can’t play as Arthur in the Epilogue
@@IcySwagTag yess ikr. even tho i'm missing arthur while playing as john, i'm still so happy playing as him. in the first red dead i was so pissed to play as jack, so i'm really glad i'll be able to spend rest of the game with john this time 😂❤
You’re a good man Arthur Morgan.
*a fine man, a fine man
You're my brother
@@thepringIeking I know... I know.
@@RichbeStunnin *GIVES ANTIBIOTICS *
Wrong video
John and Arthur are truely the best 2 characters in gaming history, theyve both my top place in my top gaming characters, so much emotion and pain no other character has made me feel the same while playing them
Don't forget about jack
Don't forget about RD1
Niko Bellic was pretty good, Out of all the gta protag's I feel he deserved a sequel or a prequel into his past back in eastern Europe, initial service in the army committing terrible war crimes and then his criminal career shortly after up until he gets a lead on Florian which takes him on the ship to Liberty city, I feel like Rockstar could have done a whole lot more with his story than ''We used to Rob banks'' and ''I'm just a black youth trying to get out of the hood''
Also Dutch he is one of the most well written antagonists I've ever came across he is the villian that no matter how much you want to hate him you still have a soft spot for
Especially considering Dutch like Arthur and John both realized after it was already to late how the world works and that they made mistakes with who they chose to be. Arthur regretted all the bad he did. Dutch wished he didn't fall into his true nature that he did better but he knows that even if he walked off that cliff alive he'd still not be able to change and I think that's why he threw himself off not because he was trapped by John or because he was a coward. He wanted the war with his ego and his humanity to end
> Video about John Marston
> Tribute about John Marston
> Only RIP and love for Arthur Morgan
John - I am a joke for you?
John Marston ha
we been mourning john for almost a decade and still not over it...Arthur wounds are still fresh
@@jessenokka4813 That scares me... sometimes.
Isaias Sabino thats rockstar for ya 😂
@@jessenokka4813 Sure ;-;
Arthur told John over and over to not look back. But he did. He went for Micah. Ross found him. John dies. If only he listened to Arthur John would have survived.
You are right, however I believe John Marston was a man with profound values and at the end, he had to finish what it was started. Micah destroyed the whole gang, which was initially a family, by persuading Dutch. Following that, Arthur gave his life for John, but mostly, Morgan teach Marston by example, being honorable and following the values that gave him peace in the last moments. It’s true that he would have lived a peaceful life the other way around, but as John says, he was responsible for his actions and he decided to be the end of Micah Bell because he did not deserve more time in this world after all he did. I truly believe that it’s all about redemption for both Arthur and John, facing every situation in his hard life as a valuable lesson and most importantly, as a revolutionary act of themselves to show the kind of men they were, by leading their lives according to those profound beliefs.
Fer Serrano you are 100% right. I kind of rushed the game and finished it really quickly but I’m going to go through it again more slower and look again more closely how these characters changed.
@party pooperdude In the Epilogue, when Sadie Adler and Charles come to Beecher's Hope to finally seek Micah Bell, John tries to make Abigail understand that is something he needs to do in order to be in peace with himself too, as he explains that if it wasn't for Arthur Morgan, Hosea, Lenny and everyone who were left behind, the dream of Beecher's Hope and the opportunity that they have in that moment won't exist. And moments before, in a bounty mission with Sadie, John clearly states that he is the only one responsible for his actions. He could not live peacefully letting that need of reckoning with Bell go. As Doc Holiday from Tombstone (Amazing western which I recommend) would say "Oh, make no mistake, it's not revenge he's after, it's a reckoning." Its all about having a chance, an opportunity to prove that, when everything is burning, good men will act seeking peace in their righteousness beliefs.
party pooperdude I know, just wanted to add that detail, as the story has so many of them that is hard to believe. Knowing Doc Holliday its a fact that makes me respect you sir. My hypocrisy only goes so far haha
Ross would have found him away. Him killing Micah didn’t led to Ross finding John they were already looking for him
The amount of love for these artificial characters from me and the whole community, its soo big that I don't even want to call them "artificial characters" or video game characters, I truly had emotions for both of them and that is extremely rare in a game, rockstar made a masterpiece
Johns death hurts more now, knowing all what Arthur went through to try and save him from the life
Velvet Thunder if its any consolation. at least jack is well and good...far as we know
Yeah good point, he went on to write a book about Arthur and johns life called red dead redemption, it's on franklins shelf in GTA v
@@bermonz does Franklin even read that book
What really gets me though is everything Arthur died for was in vain, John lives his life as a rancher with Abigail and Jack for a little but ultimately they cut his life short too.... damn those pinkertons
Squanchie 420 John and his family lived a perfectly happy life too. He weren’t a threat to the Pinkertons and didn’t do anything illegal but as Dutch said to John “When I’m gone they’ll just find another monster, they have to,they have to justify their wages” (anything illegal or messed up the player does in both games I wouldn’t consider canon because John strived to live past the life of an outlaw)
At least Jack ended up avenging everyone in the gang by brutally killing Edgar Ross
Arthur : I don’t see many white hairs on you
John : Guess it wasn’t worth it Arthur
U know the GTA v Easter egg about the rdr book written by jack marston I hope that s Canon so it would the story less painful
Everyone that fell in love with Arthur and John cried when they died!!!!! John in Red Dead Redemption!!! And Arthur in Red Dead Redemption 2!!! Rip both!
I can’t help knowing why I fell in love with John Marston’s character in the first Rdr because of the influence Arthur had on john’s life that impacted him to do better. In the end they were truly brothers 💔
Arthur says "I want you to not look back." But John does look back - he hunts down Micah and kills him to avenge Arthur - even though the game constantly points out that revenge is foolish. "Especially for things that happened a long time ago." And you know what?
Killing Micah is what put the Pinkertons on his trail and set in motion the events of the first game.
"Nothing get's forgiven. People don't forget."
That's the sad beauty of it. I think John knows on some level this will probably comeback for him eventually, but he couldn't forgive Micah for what he did and I can't really blame him even with the knowledge of how it all ends in the first game.
I completely understand why John and the others felt it was their duty to kill Micah, but if Arthur could speak he would have begged John not to go.
as much as i love Arthur, something about John's story hits different when you did what i did and played RDR2 first then went and played RDR1. like you've been with John from the start, sorta. you saw how it all went down, you grew connections to the people you end up having to hunt down and it just hits ya like a runaway train.
i genuinely had a hard time shooting Bill in RDR1 cause i came to like him and grow close to him playing through RDR2, before i knew he would later become an antagonist. i hogtied Javier rather than shooting him. and Dutch was the hardest to face cause i liked him for his leadership qualities from the start, so not only was his betrayal at the end of RDR2 a slap in the face, but the fact that he continued to delude himself heading into RDR1 that John was the traitor and the rat was so upsetting.
I feel like Dutch’s mind got fucked up when he bashed his head on the trolley in Saint Denis with Lenny and Arthur
Thats it also the reading fucked him
Blessed are the peacemakers. ( If you don't know what I'm talking about, that's what's John's gravestone says)
Is that so partner ?
Micah says it at the beginning of the mission were you get kidnapped by the colm
very nice!!!! but I would love to see a few rdr 1 scenes
Yeah I used some of the audio but the graphics are so much better in the new game it looked strange combining both games :)
@@PazyPlayz Thats true
but its nice that u made a video for John! I like John more, dont get me wrong I really like Arthur but I played the first one and when I play rdr2 and see Abigail and Jack it makes me kinda sad when I think about what will happen with John.... But Nice work with ur videos, both of them! John and Arthur's!
"Blacklivesdontmatter" who hurt you? LuL
@@vadci. what u talking
It’s sad to think that Abigail and John think it’s over but in reality we all know that it’s far from over
R.i.P John and Arthur My Brothers
One of the best games ever, story wise, graphics wise, experience wise. Including how it ties into RDR1. This is absolutely amazing.
This is the best tribute I've seen so far, the editing is top notch and the music goes really well with the scenes you've chosen. I also loved the fact that this tribute is about the relationship of Arthur and John and not just about John. John is the man he was in the first game and later in epilogue of the second game thanks to Arthur. "Get the hell outta here and be a god damn man!" And so he went and became a great man. Thanks for this tribute, outstanding work really.
Thanks for the lovely comment. I always aim to showcase the excellent character arcs and writing. Video games are getting far more interesting with the level of depth and amount of time players spend with characters that I hope we will continue to get more relatable people like Arthur and John in particular. Once again, glad you enjoyed it!! 👍
PazyPlayz I really hope for that as well - this is a future of games and story telling! Thanks are on my side, I will definitely watch your tribute again. :) Great work!
John is one of my favorite characters from video games in general alongside Arthur! His journey of redemption is truly epic!
Red dead 3 should take place right after john marston’s death and the main character be jack and it shows the time between john’s death and jack killing ross, then in the epilogue it shows jack create his own family with 2 sons he named arthur and john
But before that we'll get a DLC, Red Dead Nightmare 2, undead Arthur and John. Brothers reunited
And do what exactly the wild West is dead, what they need to do is go all the way back to the golden era of outlaws with new protagonists
@@HellSpawn_Dre talking about undead nightmare? Not regular Red Dead.
@@thewintersoldier8387 I was talking to the op not you
@@HellSpawn_Dre My bad G
Two great protagonist ever to set foot into the gaming world!
Arthur Morgan and John Marston
Both are equal legends to me :)
Same
Listen to me. When the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back. This is over.
Stfu Dutch you let the snake Micah mess up with your mind...Weak fool!
@@almutairi201 Idiot he lost his mind after he hit his head in the trolley
Some trees flourish others die
John Marston damn.... *WAIT A MINUTE AREN’T YOU DEAD*
Gamer gangster I’m undead
Of course he died! He was born in the 1870s
Wait a minute, I’m sorry I forgot you just re spawned back in Blackwater
@@johnmarston6479 ha ha ha
I approve of this Beautifully made Tribute to me and My Brother Arthur
The best tribute of John and Arthur..
Love these videos just discovered your channel and can’t stop watching them
Masterpiece of a tribute, thanks alot for making it.
I cannot choose between Arthur and John.. they both reprrsent two different times and games. They both were important in my life each one at a different time. I now have a save game with Arthur and one with John.
I love them both.
I love Arthur more but same I love them both
R.I.P Arthur Morgan, you are a Legend.
The Legends never die
Thanks
webe e shut the fuck up this is my tribute you little sack of shit
John Marston john ur the best im loyal
I had a goddamn (voice crack) PLAN
Awesome video
@John Marston from rdr1 is better john
Who the hell are you guys
I might be a stranger but how's the boy?
Lol
Best duo in video game history
It's so heartbreaking whenever you realize John's own death was his own fault, the only reason Ross found him was because he got revenge on Micah, had he listened to Arthur and never looked back he would have finally gotten to live the life he always wanted, John has nobody to blame but himself.
Wouldn't have mattered either way...the Pinkertons/Ross wanted the entire gang dead. Ross only used John to find Bill, Javier and Dutch later on in RDR1.
Best video for John yet! Arthur and John are so connected I wish Arthur never died 😢
Preacher: "God doesn't care who you were. He only cares who you are now."
I would watch these videos forever, I don’t know what to do if John and Arthur be here for everyone, they just are so great people that I ever met in a game....😭💔
That was more of a tribute to what Arthur did for John but beautiful none the less.
Very good work. Everything look nice.
Arthur was my brother and every single day I think about how he saved me and my family and I wish I could just switch roles save him so he could or if I could have done while Arthur and Micah were fighting
Don't blame yourself John...it's in the past
You were a son to ME and yet you betrayed me
@@dutchvanderlinde2002 YOU FINALLY LOST YOUR DAMN MIND
@@Robert-el2kj Don't lose faith in me. Have some GODDAMN FAITH IN ME!
@@dutchvanderlinde2002 your plan sucks bolls
Dutch had a choice. Dutch could have saved John. John looked back, killed Micah got spotted by Edgar. And died. John should've listened to arthur.
the same would have happened if he did not look back
You should of showed more of John Marston like how he finds Micah or how he finds Charles, Sadie and Uncle
I feel so appreciated right now. Apologies to everyone having to play as Jack in the end.
Amazing Edit, I truly got goosebumps..I wish they added a character selector like GTA v so we could play as Arthur
This is just too beautiful 😭😭😭
This is great and all but now make a Tribute to Arthur's Horse.
Or Hamish
Lol just him running into rocks and trees 😂
@Hydra Hamad they die of their own stupidity and stubbornness. Had a Horse which stood on the Railroad Tracks and just committed suicide when the train came... RIP Shredder...
F
The inception soundtrack just perfect
An amazing story... (Tears)
you made me cry.
Finally a video dedicated to John. 🙏
Arthur going against Dutch is the moment Arthur turned into a legend, and the moment Dutch lost everything... without Arthur’s blind loyalty Dutch knew it was all crashing down for real
Which is the moment Arthur went behind his back to save John from certain death.
I like the thumbnail
This music and all the scenes just make it amazing, you sir are talented
That's make sad cry
with the inception’s music, i had to let a like ;)
If only people now a days new what loyalty meant
Thank you for this magnificent video 🌹❤️
Very nice! Loved it!
Dude... this was absolutely beautiful... top job my friend.
When John died, he quoted arthur
Arthur: "listen to me, when the time comes, you gotta run and don't look back."
John: "Jack, take ur momma and run and don't look back."
I don't fully remember wat john said but it was something along the lines of that
you make good trailer stuff man. keep it up
Thank you :) glad you enjoy!!
But kieran he was so kind
من أفضل الألعاب الي لعبتها 😭🖤🖤
Well done
Arthur will go down as probably gamings greatest protagonist
John is still my favourite character but Arthur was great and in the end he gave John more time for his family
Love you Arthur morgan and jonh
Arthur will always be my brother
Thank you, I needed this.
Go and never look back your a brother Arthur
Great work
Arthur and John. The Goku and Vegeta of rockstar.
Lovely job mate! Very nice !
1:If it weren’t for Arthur, Jack wouldn’t have He’s parents.
2: if it weren’t for Arthur, John wouldn’t have gotten that ring
3: if it weren’t for Arthur, red dead redemption wouldn’t have existed.
If it wasn’t for Arthur, John would of died
If it wasn’t for Arthur the gang wouldn’t survive
@@TbYolo John still did die, but years later
John Marston ❤️🙏🏼
Nice Arthur tribute
I can hear the inception main theme playing in the background
Yes you can it's called time by Hans Zimmer 👍
PazyPlayz I know I seen the film
The first game needs a serious remake. I think the ending of the first game should play out different depending on your honor level. If you play the game honorably, then that marshal from Armadillo, Bonnie MacFarlane, her father and a few others you've helped along the way. Show up and help John and his family fight off the government agents and the army. Maybe they show up to the ranch to visit, and during the visit the agents show up. They have a big gunfight and since John has help. He doesn't have to sacrifice himself. Then after it's over, maybe the marshal could explain how John helped him out, and gets him pardoned of his past crimes. At the same time the marshal uses the attack on the Marston family as evidence against Ross and the army. However if you play dishonorably, then you get the ending we all know.
There also needs to be moments and easter eggs that pay tribute to Arthur. Maybe John still carries Arthur's journal. Maybe Dutch brings up how those last moments with Arthur. The look in his eyes, as he laid there on that mountain top, slowly dying haunts him, and how it's been slowly driving him insane. While holding the pipe that Arthur gave him. Maybe Dutch finally admits that he failed them all, and that he just wants it all to end. Maybe Dutch even goes as far to say that a part of him wishes that it ended at the end of John's gun. That dying by the hand of one of the people he failed is something he deserves. But John can't do it, so Dutch kills himself.
I also think that Bill Williamson's lines need to be rewritten a bit in the first game. Because the character that he is in the first game, doesn't really match up with who he is in second game. Sure he's angry and a bit of a fool sometimes, but there's several moments where Bill seems to have more of a heart than Javier. I was surprised the first time I heard Bill express regret and sorrow for the loss of Sean and especially Kieran. A very different person from the Bill Williamson in the first game, who seemed more of the cold blooded murderous type. I understand that the events of the second game probably pushed Bill over the edge, but I think there needs to be a moment where Bill expresses what he's going through. In fact all the surviving members of the gang need to have moments of reflection on the events and characters in the second game.
I agree with everything you said
RIP John Marston
I think everyone forgot about the most important death...
THE HORSE's death, The horse went with us on our journey almost everywhere
Javier didn't point his gun at them, if you didn't notice
U could've used the song "Compass" for this one. Its the song that is played when u finally deal with Dutch and return to your family in RDR
The OG marston
JOHN IS THE BEST CHARACTER IN ALL ROCKSTAR
After John came back saying Dutch left him, that shouldve changed Bill and Javier to Arthurs side
Especially after Micah shot Mrs. Grimshaw
They only cared about themselves they weren't choosing sides
Awesome
Awesome video! People forget Arthur was modelled after John in a lot of ways, not in the story telling but from a practical standpoint as the original red dead came out in 2010 was it? So before you all flock to Arthur, remember John has one hell of a tale to tell and for me is everybit as good/badass as Arthur if not more. 2 sick characters.
Arthur is better tbh but John is cool af too
You should’ve put John marston theme
2:04 you gotta love arthur
Hosea tribute
2:25 best part
Amazing :)
Remeber the main character of the story is john not arthur
''Get the hell out of here and be a goddamn man!''
Loved it.
Kieran saved Arthur
He sure did. I wonder if John remembers him
I love and hate Rockstar, damn, that's was sad.