I can't wait for all of you to see the mulan review I am working on, I have been at it since the start of this month putting more research into the specifics of it where hopefully it would be only around an hour long but I think it will be longer sadly and it's going to be a long time before you see it anyway
Mulan is my favorite Disney princess, though not my favorite film, given the lack of fantasy elements and minimal songs--but the remake was a travesty beyond words.
I hate how Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland seemed to set the standard for the looks of Disney remakes. Maybe Disney just has a thing for hiring directors that like greyish gritty styles, but seriously...every remake has this faded, dead feel to it. And even when they try to be colorful and warm, it still feels lifeless or robotic.
I think Cinderella avoids this, but even it has a soft watercolor feel that aside from her gown lacks vibrance. It has a very period piece feeling. The others all look like they have a green/gray colored filter on everything. This is turned up to 11 with the nw Peter Pan and Little Mermaid.
Is it just me or does Tim burtons Alice in wonderland technically feel like a sequel to the original animated movie, because it references that movie with the whole been there, done that attitude Alice has in the film; and the fact that she thinks it’s a dream references the end of the first movie.
I'd Switch Mulan and the Lion King on this list. I mean, Lion King didn't ruin its message and spit on the stories culture and wasn't filmed near a concentration camp
Honestly Cinderella is an easy win, because Disney technically has done it a uck more than you relised to the point where you should do a Cinderella ranking video.
101 Dalmatians movie from the 90s is my favorite reboot. Because of nostalgia but also, animals are great even though they're can't talk and Cruella's actress is fantastic.
Cinderella: This one leads by miles. As an adaptation its just so-so, but as a Cinderella retelling it is wonderful. Lady Tremaine steals the show and everyone's acting is high quality. I can put this one on equal or close footing with the original and it gets better each time I watch it...unlike B&tB which degrades with each rewatch. Jungle Book: While I'd still take the animated version any day, it's not bad and actually feels well made and not like it's an attack on the original. Maleficent: Loved it on first viewing, but it's just so melodramatic and unnecessary on subsequent viewings. The fairies were ruined and I prefer Maleficent being evil. At least it tried something new. Alice in Wonderland: I don't hate this one. It's bad. It's ugly and it's kind of like a nightmare. But it's also kind of fun. 101 Dalmatians: Glenn Close saved this from being near the bottom. Other than that, it's just okay. I do have fond memories of it. Beauty and the Beast: Lacks any sort of charm. I also like the Beast's song. But everything is so autotuned. Also, every last inch of Gaston isn't covered in hair, apparently. Lady and the Tramp: I agree. Nothing to hate here and nothing to love. The whole thing just exists and can't be lower or higher because it just doesn't matter. Aladdin: Cringe inducing and absolutely ruined Jafar and Iago. Unforgivable. Lion King: Why would anyone choose this over the original? Worse acting, worse songs, boring animals Mulan: boring, souless and has none of the charm or strength of Mulan. Pinocchio: This is an actual abomination. I haven't seen Dumbo, so I can't comment on it.
I saw Dumbo 2019 and I’ve never been this angry at a movie in my entire life. The story is nothing like the original, none of the animals talk, the human characters suck (except for the ringmaster and V.A. Vandevere), and it tries to add too many things to the point that it no longer has anything in common to the original.
It's not a coincidence that the good ones come from the Disney silver age (Cinderella through the Jungle Book). By this point, walt was fully invested in Disneyland, and the animated films suffered from not having his full attention. It doesn't help that the "string of pearls" narritive style of these films has aged like fine milk. Moral of the story: rather than remaking all time classics, like BOTB and Aladdin, Disney should focus on remaking beloved but flawed films from the 50's, 60's, mid-80's, and early 00's. Don't hire Tim Burton, and don't do a hack job just to put on Disney+.
I think Descendants is better than most of these live-action remakes because Descendants knows how to aim for the same audience as the animated fairytale Disney classics and retain what we liked about them in the medium of live-action, while not retelling the same story and instead choosing to focus on a new assortment of characters with a villain-to-hero redemption arc similar to what we liked in Megamind or Wreck-it Ralph. It was definitely better than the live-action Mulan remake and Cruella movies. April 20, 2023, 2:20pm
But you have an aging population. I think all this backlash is due to whites finally facing their mortality. They might not exist in a couple of decades and they're clinging onto the past
Descendents is also a series that knows not to take it's self to seriously and knows that the premise is kinda preposterous and the writers know that and are working with the idea and trying to make it fun rather then something to replace the original.
Or Finding Nemo or A Bug’s Life with the photorealistic CGI style from the 2019 Lion King remake. Who would want to see fish without emotional expressions or bugs looking less cartoony and more like realistic bugs? 🤢
@@lamplizard7767 The problem is that's not what they did, they told a completely different story with new characters given the names of the old ones, except the fairies who aren't even called the same things. They're the main characters of the original, and they get next to nothing to do in the so called "remake". It's fundamentally a different story in almost every way.
I don't see anything wrong with making a completely new story out of it, it's called Maleficent and not Sleeping Beauty for a reason after all so. And it's probably just me but I didn't care for the original story or the three good fairies. It's like criticizing fanfiction for branching out only one area of a story.
@@emargaux Why call it a remake then? It's consistently referred to as a live action remake. As long as it's referred to as a remake we can criticize it as a remake. And you not liking the fairies sounds a bit more like a you problem.
There should be made a whole new category just for these pieces of trash alone.....the only live action remakes I personally kinda liked was Maleficent and Alice In wonderland
I really loved Belle from the original Disney Beauty and the Beast and I thought the live action was disappointing in that regard, but I did really like the set designs and a couple of new things they added (like the music box and expanded LeFou, not the beginning of the curse or Belle's dress though, didn't like that much). So middling sounds about right. It's hardly suprising that Cinderella is the best, Cinderella has pretty much the most adaptations of all fairytales followed by Snow White I think, they're both fairly simple stories that you can add or change pretty much anything you want. Ever After is still the best live-action version hands down though.
I agree with your assessments! Lion King didn't need to be remade because nothing about it is "live action" since no humans are involved, Mulan was terrible, and Cinderella is the best and actually a valuable addition! Don't waste your time watching Cruella. Both of the Emma actresses have fun with their roles, but the story never explains why Cruella becomes someone okay with killing puppies for her fur coats.
i think the cruella movie was just supposed to be a fun twist to cruella just like they did with maleficent, a reimagining of cruella not as someone who kills puppies for a fur coat, but a genius morally grey rebel fashionista
I think the point of these movies is to make money since they rely on nostalgia to fill up seats in the theaters. Honestly, there's nothing wrong with adding depth but I'm not gonna lie, I don't know if it's just the way these movies execute the new development but most of the changes aren't memorable imo I think what they did with Maleficent was really interesting though since it's from her point of view, I'll give that movie some credit! (I haven't seen Cruella personally, though I do know it's more about Cruella herself than the Dalmations, an origin story iirc??)
I think the problem is that depth didn't make sense with what they kept from the original film. Like they kept her giving those kids food but not expecting to pay, that worked in the original because she was naive to the outside world, here she's established to have left the palace a few times and even wants to be Sultana
*Seeing Him put my favorite remake Aladdin at 8* Big ooooof because I feel like this one is the one that has really stuck with me when watching it over the original. I still think the Original better but I like the remake more tbh!
Disney: Our Cinderella live action remake is a success! Let's make more live action remakes and get more money! Also Disney: *doesn't puts actual work and love on their other live action remakes*
My ranking Dumbo, I just love the original too much, so this was quite bad for me Lion King, some of the singing was fine, I guess, the rest was bad. Mulan: I liked the scenery, and some of the wire fu, but it does lack heart and I also liked the new Christina Aguilera song. Alice in Wonderland 10 year old me liked it, but now is just nope Beauty and the Beast I like the addition of the black death killing the mom as part of Belle's backstory, but I didn't feel the chemistry. Maleficent is fine, but nothing too impressive the performance by Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning is nice though. Aladdin while toning down Jafar as a villain, I quite enjoyed the other aspects of the movie. The Jungle Book: it was fun 101 dalmatians: it seemed more like a live action cartoon than all others and it was fun. Cinderella: my favorite one, they added where they needed to and for being a fairytale that is adapted so often by many studios, this one is great and I revisit it quite often, like it so easily could have been something like the Amazon Camila Cabello one, but instead we got a great movie.
In my honest opinion, the only great Disney remakes are the Jungle Book, Christopher Robin, The Lion King, Cinderella, Cruella, Aladdin, and some that were made in the 90s.
i feel like everyone's hope in live action was rekindled by cinderella. So everyone still watches the new live actions all hoping it would be as good as cinderella.
Franchises like kingdom heart and ABC’s once upon a time We’re able to get these fairytale Disney characters right! I also hate how safe the live action Disney remakes are I mean, it’s Disney but it’s ridiculous!
Yes, of course, Cinderella is the best Disney live action, because it preserved the heart of the story, deepening some things and giving us a great lesson in being brave and kind. Maleficent, the movie, incredibly reinvented the story now from the perspective of Maleficent who is as a hero or antihero at the same time.. My other liveactions that I did like are: The Lion King, Aladdin, Lady and Tramp and Beauty and the Beast, these weren't bad, I appreciated some changes and seeing the characters and history again.. In Dumbo, the new story was not bad at all for me, I just missed Timothy..
I just noticed that Michael Keaton and Danny DeVito where also in Batman Returns which is another Tim Burton movie. Colin Farrell and Danny DeVito both got a chance to play the Batman villain know as the Penguin.
I know this isn’t a popular opinion… but I actually love Tim Burton’s version of Alice in Wonderland. Yes, the CGI isn’t that good. Yes, a lot of the colors is drained out. And yes, the animation is not quite as charming as the original (though, it does have more life to it than The Lion King or Mulan or Peter Pan). However, the story is quite fascinating! I love that it’s about Alice learning to be herself, in a time where both her society and the Red Queen are trying to control her every move, and kill the imagination, whimsy, and creativity she dearly values in life. (In fact, I think the darker style of the movie further supports this plot!) The music is hauntingly beautiful, the lore of Wonderland (or “Underland”) is expanded in unique ways, and the characters are given their own lives (even if not enough time is spent with them to explore those lives.)
Totally on point with Cinderella, I just loved that film so much and I’m kinda sad that the same thing will probably not happen with my favorite one which is The Little Mermaid 😥. Excellent video.
I wish the new Mufasa Film will use that deepfake version to bring back expressions. Seeing the trailer was disappointing, maybe they are going to do the expressionless animals again, though the story might be better, can't expect plenty on this future film.
I have bias for Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland being a favorite of mine PURELY because of the wii game. I enjoyed that game so much, even now I have very fond memories of being lost in what to do but enjoying beating up the cards (and thinking alice is annoying HAH). Its nostalgic for me, even if I don't like him nor his work as much as I once did.
I heard from another video that Monstro's design in the remake is actually more accurate to how he was described in the book. He's meant to be a sea monster, not whale. I'm not defending the movie I just wanted to let you know that
Even then Monstro, or the Terrible Dogfish as he was called in the original novel, wasn’t over-detailed or exaggerated. He was still a simple sea monster by just being giant Dogfish. He didn’t need any tentacles or any extra crap to make him frightening.
If I had to rank these here it goes Great 😄 1. The Jungle Book 2. Cruella 3. Cinderella Good 🙂 4. Beauty and the Beast 5. Christopher Robin 6. Pete's Dragon Meh 😐 7. Aladdin 8. Maleficent 9. Mulan 10. Dumbo Bad 😡 11. The Lion King 12. Alice in Wonderland Belongs in the 🗑️ 13. Maleficent 2 14. Alice in Wonderland 2 15. Pinnochio
Don't don't like it on account of being a bit over the top and turning her into a good character, but I really really really enjoy maleficent. It's the best of them so far.
7:35 They made Monstro an actual sea beast in order to not vilify actual whales 🐋 which I can respect & think was actually a good change as whales are the furthest things from monsters.
@@joshuasgameplays9850 they also vilified a cat, yet you’re not complaining about that 🤨 there are anthropomorphic animals in Pinocchio’s world & Monstro is not in that category & acts more wild but not like how a whale 🐋 would in the wild. When you anthropomorphise an animal, you can’t rely on that as a true reflection of the species.
I’m honestly surprised that you ranked Maleficent higher than The Jungle Book (2016). I didn’t really like it due to the fact that the writing took away everything that made Maleficent evil and scary. If you’re reading this, I know this is just your personal opinion. It’s just that I never expected this movie to be ranked this high.
I would put Beauty and the Beast under Aladdin, because of the horrendous autotune and the butchering of so many of the best scenes of the original was worse in my opinion, making some characters especially Belle and the Beast less likable than they were before.
For me, I would put Mulan higher than Pinocchio and Aladdin over BATB I feel like Lady and the Tramp could have been released in the cinemas too. Cinderella really is the best remake! I wish that Mulan could have done the same thing. It's fine if they removed the songs but somehow merged the original and Disney versions of the story and had better approach to make the story better. 18:39
Bruh Disney's marketing is literally dead. I'd never heard of the Mufasa sequel OR lady and the tramp remake before this video, wtf? Usually I'm the first to know about everything
my personal ratings: Alice in Wonderland - 6/10 Maleficent - 8/10 Cinderella - 7/10 Alice part2 - 7.5/10 The Jungle Book - 9.5/10 Beauty and the Beast - 8.5/10 Christopher Robin - 6/10 Dumbo - 5/10 Aladdin - 9/10 The Lion King - 8.5/10 Maleficent part2 - 7.5/10 Lady and the Tramp - 7/10 Mulan - 3/10 Cruella - 8/10 Pinocchio - 4/10 based on the trailer: Peter Pan and Wendy - 5/10 The Little Mermaid - 9/10 I did not include the old movies like the dalmatian movies
I would put Beauty and the Beast at the bottom because, for me, it took one of the greatest animations (to me, the best Disney movie) and transformed it in a mediocre movie. It has no passion at all. It's just standing there, nobody cares even to talk about it.
My favorite is Beauty& the Beast because I love they added in character lore with Belle's mother, the Enchantress who cursed the Beast and Adam's family. But I will have loved if disney made live action movies based on the Twisted tales stories books that are What if stories but Darker. Like what if Belle's mother cursed the Beast? Or What if Ariel had never defeated Ursula?
That sounds good to me! Since most of these live-action remakes or adaptations want to aim for a darker and edgier tone than their animated counterparts, that would be a nice way to take full advantage of not being in the medium of animation.
I honestly thought adding a backstory to her mom wasn’t a good idea. It didn’t go anywhere in the story and didn’t add much to Belle’s character (who was drastically different thnx to Emma Watson🫤). The Enchantress scenes were just her walking around while acting mysterious, or being in the background other than saving Maurice. She also interrupted the sad moment between Belle and the Beast at the end by saving him when it should’v been a private moment like in the animated movie. But that’s just my thoughts.
Something that honestly worked in Beauty and the Beast is that making the servants into antiques. Those were the few aspects i liked. Beauty and the beast 2017 was mehhh…
I would love to see a story were malphacent is a good guy and the royal family and the princess is the villen and she curses aurora because she doesn't want to kill her and maybe the needle thing is a warning agenst greed or something that she could resist but dosn't and gets cursed cuase to make bad choices.
Disney: Mystical Dragon Guardian: Too Fantasy Witch who can turn into a million birds and 1 bird who can do dark magic and witchcraft: Very Realistic honestly wtf was disney thinking with mulan?
Here we go. 15. Mulan(This is my least favorite movie of all time. I loathe it fully) 14. Maleficent 13. Dumbo 12. Pinocchio 11. The Sorcerer's Apprentice 10. Alice in Wonderland 9. Lady and the Tramp 8. Aladdin 7. 101 Dalmatians 6. Beauty and the Beast 5. Cinderella 4. Pete's Dragon 3. Christopher Robin 2. Cruella 1. The Jungle Book
You should do a review on The Sorcerers Apprentice! It is considered by some to be one of the first Disney live action remakes. It takes the sorcerer Mickey section of fantasia and turns into a full length film!
Very interesting rank, here's mine (of what I've seen). The ones that rank low for me either didn't bring anything new to the story or were changed in a way that pales in comparison to the animated films. The ones that rank higher I felt did better at offering an enjoyable experience blending classic traits with modern ones 1. Jungle Book 2. Aladdin 3. Maleficent 4. Dumbo 5. Cinderella 6. Beauty and the Beast 7. Alice in Wonderland 8. 101 Dalmatians 9. Pinocchio 10. Peter Pan and Wendy 11. Lion King
Something I want to tell you I despise the lion king remake. For many reasons: 1. The music is ruined. 2. The disrespect after I realized in more reviews. 3. How it ruined my love for the characters. 4. This garbage does have great animation. (A positive) 5. This movie made me cry (the only two positives.) Another note: I love the jungle book remake and the Aladdin remake. That’s my opinion but hey it’s just my opinion.
Oh my God I totally forgot Lady & The Tramp had a remake, I used to watch the good movie tons as a kid too. And fun fact the end shot of 101 Dalmatians, I counted 100 actual puppies. Which is amazing
I know that the Lion King remake isn’t seen as “good” (even though I personally like it) but how is it lower on the list than Mulan?? Mulan was just AWFUL.
8:25 this actor was the whole reason I didn’t like Dumbo as a remake - she was just so SOULESS in her acting & I have NO idea how she got the part other than looking sweet or cute 🤦♀️
To be honest I don't care about these movies... I mean, if I want to I will watch SOME of them like The Lion King, Pinocchio or Aladdin because I like these ones A LOT (and I don't care about people opinions).And although Cinderella is really high in this list I didn't liked that much.
7:40 While I'm sure you may not care. But they were making monstro more like a monster from the original story unlike the whale from Disney since that's what it was mean to be. (as for why they did it. who knows)
In my opinion: S Tier: 101 Dalmatians (Cruella carries this movie so hard, i love it.) A Tier: Alice in Wonderland, Maleficent B Tier: Lady and the Tramp, The Jungle Book, Cinderella, Beauty & the Beast C Tier: Aladdin, Dumbo D Tier: Pinocchio F Tier: Mulan, The Lion King
1. The Jungle Book (2016) 2. Cinderella 3. Christopher Robin 4. Pete's Dragon 5. Cruella 6. 101 Dalmatians 7. Aladdin 8. Lady and the Tramp 9. The Sorcerer's Apprentice 10. Beauty and the Beast 11. Maleficent 12. The Jungle Book (1994) 13. Dumbo 14. Alice in Wonderland 15. The Lion King 16. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil 17. Alice Through the Looking Glass 18. 102 Dalmatians 19. Mulan 20. Pinocchio 1-4 range from amazing to great, 5-8 range from good to okay, 9-14 range from mediocre to bad, and 15-20 range from terrible to abysmal.
I can really sense your dislike for the 2019 Lion King. However, when I went to see it, I knew what I was getting, so I didn’t feel cheated or duped like how others felt. Also, Disney never said it was a live action remake. They just said it was a remake. Everyone else called it “live action” because it looked love action, but I digress. If I were to make a ranking of the Disney Remakes, I’d list them like this, because I feel there are some on here that are far worse than the Lion King that were ranked higher. But, it’s your channel and you’re ranking what did or didn’t work for you.
What fails in the live action movies is that they focus so much on the visuals that they completely ignore the story, acting performance, conflict, voice acting, emotions, actors singing capabilities, and expression.
My list from worst to best: Mulan (2020) 0/10 Pinocchio (2022) 0/10 The Lion King (2019) 1/10 Lady and the Tramp (2019 1/10 Beauty and the Beast (2017) 2/10 Aladdin (2019) 2/10 Dumbo (2019) 3/10 The Little Mermaid (2023) 4/10 Cruella (2021) 5/10
I hate Mulan 2020 because this director is missing the point to the original. I get this person want something realistic however what’s not realistic is when the Rorens we’re running up the wall instead using the grappling hook like the OG. Same with the phoenix, which has no purpose to Mulan and same thing with the witch. I hate Mary sue because it’s stupid and not realistic. I’m not sure who’s idea to make Mulan Mary sue, he/she probably confuse with reality to fiction. I don’t blame the actress who plays Mulan in 2020 but once saw her act, she shows no emotion. And I don’t like her behavior towards the soldiers because she thinks she’s better than them just because she has chi power. Again, dumbest idea ever. 😒 I don’t understand why they took out Shang, in the OG, he wasn’t inappropriately taken advantage to Mulan/Ping, he was respectful and took his job seriously as captain. So it’s okay a soldier to do things with Mulan but not Shang. Once again that nameless soldier serves no purpose for Mulan as a character. Phoenix makes absolutely no sense, all it did just flies around looking dumb instead helping or guiding Mulan to her journey. Mushu who actually guides Mulan to her path and became the hero of China. The witch is also pretty stupid, I don’t k ow what are o say to that, still pretty stupid.
I can't wait for all of you to see the mulan review I am working on, I have been at it since the start of this month putting more research into the specifics of it where hopefully it would be only around an hour long but I think it will be longer sadly and it's going to be a long time before you see it anyway
Mulan is my favorite Disney princess, though not my favorite film, given the lack of fantasy elements and minimal songs--but the remake was a travesty beyond words.
I hate how Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland seemed to set the standard for the looks of Disney remakes. Maybe Disney just has a thing for hiring directors that like greyish gritty styles, but seriously...every remake has this faded, dead feel to it. And even when they try to be colorful and warm, it still feels lifeless or robotic.
I think Cinderella avoids this, but even it has a soft watercolor feel that aside from her gown lacks vibrance. It has a very period piece feeling. The others all look like they have a green/gray colored filter on everything. This is turned up to 11 with the nw Peter Pan and Little Mermaid.
@@saintfighteraqua there’s also Aladdin, that movie was incredibly colorfull and happy looking
At the start of the 2010s, none of us knew this film is just the beginning of the decade of unneeded remakes
Does that count as a remake? it looks and feels more like a sequel.
@@AlvaroIbacacheS Aladdin and Cinderella are my favorites that I have seen
I love the Cinderella remake. Lilly James and Cate Blanchett did great. The lack of talking animals was a good choice by Branagh
The Lion King remake feels like a really long commercial for Animal Kingdom.
I never saw the Live action version, and never will.
somehow Aslan from narnia which came out over a decade looks better than all the lions in lion king
LMAOOO
@@nightwish1453 That's a damn shame. Disney ain't S***.
Is it just me or does Tim burtons Alice in wonderland technically feel like a sequel to the original animated movie, because it references that movie with the whole been there, done that attitude Alice has in the film; and the fact that she thinks it’s a dream references the end of the first movie.
Right. It is rather a sequel than an adaptation of the original animated movie, or of Lewis Carroll's book.
I'd Switch Mulan and the Lion King on this list. I mean, Lion King didn't ruin its message and spit on the stories culture and wasn't filmed near a concentration camp
Honestly Cinderella is an easy win, because Disney technically has done it a uck more than you relised to the point where you should do a Cinderella ranking video.
101 Dalmatians movie from the 90s is my favorite reboot. Because of nostalgia but also, animals are great even though they're can't talk and Cruella's actress is fantastic.
That's the only remake Disney really needed. Not the Lion King or Dumbo.
@@Unsweetened8618The Original Dumbo was pretty racist…. but The Lion King was already perfect as it was.
Cinderella: This one leads by miles. As an adaptation its just so-so, but as a Cinderella retelling it is wonderful. Lady Tremaine steals the show and everyone's acting is high quality. I can put this one on equal or close footing with the original and it gets better each time I watch it...unlike B&tB which degrades with each rewatch.
Jungle Book: While I'd still take the animated version any day, it's not bad and actually feels well made and not like it's an attack on the original.
Maleficent: Loved it on first viewing, but it's just so melodramatic and unnecessary on subsequent viewings. The fairies were ruined and I prefer Maleficent being evil. At least it tried something new.
Alice in Wonderland: I don't hate this one. It's bad. It's ugly and it's kind of like a nightmare. But it's also kind of fun.
101 Dalmatians: Glenn Close saved this from being near the bottom. Other than that, it's just okay. I do have fond memories of it.
Beauty and the Beast: Lacks any sort of charm. I also like the Beast's song. But everything is so autotuned. Also, every last inch of Gaston isn't covered in hair, apparently.
Lady and the Tramp: I agree. Nothing to hate here and nothing to love. The whole thing just exists and can't be lower or higher because it just doesn't matter.
Aladdin: Cringe inducing and absolutely ruined Jafar and Iago. Unforgivable.
Lion King: Why would anyone choose this over the original? Worse acting, worse songs, boring animals
Mulan: boring, souless and has none of the charm or strength of Mulan.
Pinocchio: This is an actual abomination.
I haven't seen Dumbo, so I can't comment on it.
I saw Dumbo 2019 and I’ve never been this angry at a movie in my entire life. The story is nothing like the original, none of the animals talk, the human characters suck (except for the ringmaster and V.A. Vandevere), and it tries to add too many things to the point that it no longer has anything in common to the original.
Don’t forget the controversies surrounding the Mulan remake…
dumbo is a snooze fest at best and a class study on bad writing at worst.
It's not a coincidence that the good ones come from the Disney silver age (Cinderella through the Jungle Book). By this point, walt was fully invested in Disneyland, and the animated films suffered from not having his full attention. It doesn't help that the "string of pearls" narritive style of these films has aged like fine milk. Moral of the story: rather than remaking all time classics, like BOTB and Aladdin, Disney should focus on remaking beloved but flawed films from the 50's, 60's, mid-80's, and early 00's. Don't hire Tim Burton, and don't do a hack job just to put on Disney+.
I think the only ones I've enjoyed were Cinderella, Maleficent, and Cruella (Im really interested in fashion so I kinda ignored everything else)
My parents watched the Mulan remake and tried to convince me it was somehow good. As an animation student currently in university, I was offended.
I think Descendants is better than most of these live-action remakes because Descendants knows how to aim for the same audience as the animated fairytale Disney classics and retain what we liked about them in the medium of live-action, while not retelling the same story and instead choosing to focus on a new assortment of characters with a villain-to-hero redemption arc similar to what we liked in Megamind or Wreck-it Ralph. It was definitely better than the live-action Mulan remake and Cruella movies. April 20, 2023, 2:20pm
But you have an aging population. I think all this backlash is due to whites finally facing their mortality. They might not exist in a couple of decades and they're clinging onto the past
Descendents is also a series that knows not to take it's self to seriously and knows that the premise is kinda preposterous and the writers know that and are working with the idea and trying to make it fun rather then something to replace the original.
oh my lord imagine a cars live remake
Or Monsters Inc
Or Finding Nemo or A Bug’s Life with the photorealistic CGI style from the 2019 Lion King remake. Who would want to see fish without emotional expressions or bugs looking less cartoony and more like realistic bugs? 🤢
NO
No Pixar movie should ever be made live action 💀
@@BrotatoeGodor Ratatouille
Honestly really liked Maleficent, it's probably my favorite live-action remake.
Sad that they completely ruined the original story and the characters of the three good fairies.
The whole point of it was to tell the story in a different way which in my opinion is so much better than just copy pasting the original but with cgi
@@lamplizard7767 The problem is that's not what they did, they told a completely different story with new characters given the names of the old ones, except the fairies who aren't even called the same things. They're the main characters of the original, and they get next to nothing to do in the so called "remake". It's fundamentally a different story in almost every way.
I don't see anything wrong with making a completely new story out of it, it's called Maleficent and not Sleeping Beauty for a reason after all so. And it's probably just me but I didn't care for the original story or the three good fairies.
It's like criticizing fanfiction for branching out only one area of a story.
@@emargaux Why call it a remake then? It's consistently referred to as a live action remake. As long as it's referred to as a remake we can criticize it as a remake. And you not liking the fairies sounds a bit more like a you problem.
There should be made a whole new category just for these pieces of trash alone.....the only live action remakes I personally kinda liked was Maleficent and Alice In wonderland
I really loved Belle from the original Disney Beauty and the Beast and I thought the live action was disappointing in that regard, but I did really like the set designs and a couple of new things they added (like the music box and expanded LeFou, not the beginning of the curse or Belle's dress though, didn't like that much). So middling sounds about right.
It's hardly suprising that Cinderella is the best, Cinderella has pretty much the most adaptations of all fairytales followed by Snow White I think, they're both fairly simple stories that you can add or change pretty much anything you want. Ever After is still the best live-action version hands down though.
I agree with your assessments! Lion King didn't need to be remade because nothing about it is "live action" since no humans are involved, Mulan was terrible, and Cinderella is the best and actually a valuable addition! Don't waste your time watching Cruella. Both of the Emma actresses have fun with their roles, but the story never explains why Cruella becomes someone okay with killing puppies for her fur coats.
i think the cruella movie was just supposed to be a fun twist to cruella just like they did with maleficent, a reimagining of cruella not as someone who kills puppies for a fur coat, but a genius morally grey rebel fashionista
i had enough of Souless remakes
I don’t think there’s anything wrong with giving more depth to jasmines character as that’s the literal point of the live action adaptations
I think the point of these movies is to make money since they rely on nostalgia to fill up seats in the theaters. Honestly, there's nothing wrong with adding depth but I'm not gonna lie, I don't know if it's just the way these movies execute the new development but most of the changes aren't memorable imo
I think what they did with Maleficent was really interesting though since it's from her point of view, I'll give that movie some credit! (I haven't seen Cruella personally, though I do know it's more about Cruella herself than the Dalmations, an origin story iirc??)
I think the problem is that depth didn't make sense with what they kept from the original film. Like they kept her giving those kids food but not expecting to pay, that worked in the original because she was naive to the outside world, here she's established to have left the palace a few times and even wants to be Sultana
*Seeing Him put my favorite remake Aladdin at 8*
Big ooooof because I feel like this one is the one that has really stuck with me when watching it over the original.
I still think the Original better but I like the remake more tbh!
Twisted sweeps both tbh
Disney: Our Cinderella live action remake is a success! Let's make more live action remakes and get more money!
Also Disney: *doesn't puts actual work and love on their other live action remakes*
ok, but you SHOULD watch the Cruella movie. It was an actually competent movie. Probably one of the better films to come out during the pandemic!!!
My ranking
Dumbo, I just love the original too much, so this was quite bad for me
Lion King, some of the singing was fine, I guess, the rest was bad.
Mulan: I liked the scenery, and some of the wire fu, but it does lack heart and I also liked the new Christina Aguilera song.
Alice in Wonderland 10 year old me liked it, but now is just nope
Beauty and the Beast I like the addition of the black death killing the mom as part of Belle's backstory, but I didn't feel the chemistry.
Maleficent is fine, but nothing too impressive the performance by Angelina Jolie and Elle Fanning is nice though.
Aladdin while toning down Jafar as a villain, I quite enjoyed the other aspects of the movie.
The Jungle Book: it was fun
101 dalmatians: it seemed more like a live action cartoon than all others and it was fun.
Cinderella: my favorite one, they added where they needed to and for being a fairytale that is adapted so often by many studios, this one is great and I revisit it quite often, like it so easily could have been something like the Amazon Camila Cabello one, but instead we got a great movie.
In my honest opinion, the only great Disney remakes are the Jungle Book, Christopher Robin, The Lion King, Cinderella, Cruella, Aladdin, and some that were made in the 90s.
Uh oh, here we go!
i feel like everyone's hope in live action was rekindled by cinderella. So everyone still watches the new live actions all hoping it would be as good as cinderella.
Franchises like kingdom heart and ABC’s once upon a time We’re able to get these fairytale Disney characters right! I also hate how safe the live action Disney remakes are I mean, it’s Disney but it’s ridiculous!
Yes, of course, Cinderella is the best Disney live action, because it preserved the heart of the story, deepening some things and giving us a great lesson in being brave and kind. Maleficent, the movie, incredibly reinvented the story now from the perspective of Maleficent who is as a hero or antihero at the same time.. My other liveactions that I did like are: The Lion King, Aladdin, Lady and Tramp and Beauty and the Beast, these weren't bad, I appreciated some changes and seeing the characters and history again.. In Dumbo, the new story was not bad at all for me, I just missed Timothy..
9:57 snakes aren't slimy. Nor they are evil. They are really nice animals actually.
I just noticed that Michael Keaton and Danny DeVito where also in Batman Returns which is another Tim Burton movie.
Colin Farrell and Danny DeVito both got a chance to play the Batman villain know as the Penguin.
You can make the argument that this all started with jack the giant slayer
I know this isn’t a popular opinion… but I actually love Tim Burton’s version of Alice in Wonderland. Yes, the CGI isn’t that good. Yes, a lot of the colors is drained out. And yes, the animation is not quite as charming as the original (though, it does have more life to it than The Lion King or Mulan or Peter Pan). However, the story is quite fascinating! I love that it’s about Alice learning to be herself, in a time where both her society and the Red Queen are trying to control her every move, and kill the imagination, whimsy, and creativity she dearly values in life. (In fact, I think the darker style of the movie further supports this plot!) The music is hauntingly beautiful, the lore of Wonderland (or “Underland”) is expanded in unique ways, and the characters are given their own lives (even if not enough time is spent with them to explore those lives.)
Totally on point with Cinderella, I just loved that film so much and I’m kinda sad that the same thing will probably not happen with my favorite one which is The Little Mermaid 😥. Excellent video.
Cruella was my favorite.
I wish the new Mufasa Film will use that deepfake version to bring back expressions. Seeing the trailer was disappointing, maybe they are going to do the expressionless animals again, though the story might be better, can't expect plenty on this future film.
I have bias for Tim Burton's Alice in Wonderland being a favorite of mine PURELY because of the wii game. I enjoyed that game so much, even now I have very fond memories of being lost in what to do but enjoying beating up the cards (and thinking alice is annoying HAH). Its nostalgic for me, even if I don't like him nor his work as much as I once did.
Oh yeah I remember that game, it was pretty fun!
I think the Golden Compass has the same effect because that Wii game was super engaging and fun.
Nice ranking
Where Pete’s Dragon?😢
I heard from another video that Monstro's design in the remake is actually more accurate to how he was described in the book. He's meant to be a sea monster, not whale. I'm not defending the movie I just wanted to let you know that
Even then Monstro, or the Terrible Dogfish as he was called in the original novel, wasn’t over-detailed or exaggerated. He was still a simple sea monster by just being giant Dogfish. He didn’t need any tentacles or any extra crap to make him frightening.
If I had to rank these here it goes
Great 😄
1. The Jungle Book
2. Cruella
3. Cinderella
Good 🙂
4. Beauty and the Beast
5. Christopher Robin
6. Pete's Dragon
Meh 😐
7. Aladdin
8. Maleficent
9. Mulan
10. Dumbo
Bad 😡
11. The Lion King
12. Alice in Wonderland
Belongs in the 🗑️
13. Maleficent 2
14. Alice in Wonderland 2
15. Pinnochio
Maleficent, Jungle Book and Cinderella were at least something of new
Don't don't like it on account of being a bit over the top and turning her into a good character, but I really really really enjoy maleficent. It's the best of them so far.
7:35 They made Monstro an actual sea beast in order to not vilify actual whales 🐋 which I can respect & think was actually a good change as whales are the furthest things from monsters.
But vilifying foxes is still ok 👍
@@joshuasgameplays9850 they also vilified a cat, yet you’re not complaining about that 🤨 there are anthropomorphic animals in Pinocchio’s world & Monstro is not in that category & acts more wild but not like how a whale 🐋 would in the wild.
When you anthropomorphise an animal, you can’t rely on that as a true reflection of the species.
@@sparxstreak02 I forgot the cat existed tbh
If we were to put this next to Disney’s animated catalog, they would all be in F tier and then Jungle Book in C and Cinderella in B
I like to think of the red queen having a big head as a physical representation of the metaphor
I’m honestly surprised that you ranked Maleficent higher than The Jungle Book (2016). I didn’t really like it due to the fact that the writing took away everything that made Maleficent evil and scary. If you’re reading this, I know this is just your personal opinion. It’s just that I never expected this movie to be ranked this high.
The live action lion king has special place in my heart as u watched it with my friends in 4th grade
Love the videos, man. Keep it up!!!
I would put Beauty and the Beast under Aladdin, because of the horrendous autotune and the butchering of so many of the best scenes of the original was worse in my opinion, making some characters especially Belle and the Beast less likable than they were before.
For me, I would put Mulan higher than Pinocchio and Aladdin over BATB
I feel like Lady and the Tramp could have been released in the cinemas too.
Cinderella really is the best remake! I wish that Mulan could have done the same thing. It's fine if they removed the songs but somehow merged the original and Disney versions of the story and had better approach to make the story better. 18:39
Bruh Disney's marketing is literally dead. I'd never heard of the Mufasa sequel OR lady and the tramp remake before this video, wtf? Usually I'm the first to know about everything
Cinderella well deserved to be No1, its such a great movie. I love it.
I also plan on ranking the remakes once I watch all the original movies.
my personal ratings:
Alice in Wonderland - 6/10
Maleficent - 8/10
Cinderella - 7/10
Alice part2 - 7.5/10
The Jungle Book - 9.5/10
Beauty and the Beast - 8.5/10
Christopher Robin - 6/10
Dumbo - 5/10
Aladdin - 9/10
The Lion King - 8.5/10
Maleficent part2 - 7.5/10
Lady and the Tramp - 7/10
Mulan - 3/10
Cruella - 8/10
Pinocchio - 4/10
based on the trailer:
Peter Pan and Wendy - 5/10
The Little Mermaid - 9/10
I did not include the old movies like the dalmatian movies
I would put Beauty and the Beast at the bottom because, for me, it took one of the greatest animations (to me, the best Disney movie) and transformed it in a mediocre movie. It has no passion at all. It's just standing there, nobody cares even to talk about it.
Any interest in Laika Studios?
My favorite is Beauty& the Beast because I love they added in character lore with Belle's mother, the Enchantress who cursed the Beast and Adam's family.
But I will have loved if disney made live action movies based on the Twisted tales stories books that are What if stories but Darker. Like what if Belle's mother cursed the Beast? Or What if Ariel had never defeated Ursula?
That sounds good to me! Since most of these live-action remakes or adaptations want to aim for a darker and edgier tone than their animated counterparts, that would be a nice way to take full advantage of not being in the medium of animation.
I honestly thought adding a backstory to her mom wasn’t a good idea. It didn’t go anywhere in the story and didn’t add much to Belle’s character (who was drastically different thnx to Emma Watson🫤).
The Enchantress scenes were just her walking around while acting mysterious, or being in the background other than saving Maurice. She also interrupted the sad moment between Belle and the Beast at the end by saving him when it should’v been a private moment like in the animated movie.
But that’s just my thoughts.
@@tototats16 I absolutely agree with your thoughts
7:38, good question
because they might going to demonize off whales just like what Universal did when they're making Jaws
Alice in Wonderland is the only one I have a heart for, because it’s at least unique. The other ones are simply that soulless …
Something that honestly worked in Beauty and the Beast is that making the servants into antiques. Those were the few aspects i liked. Beauty and the beast 2017 was mehhh…
I would love to see a story were malphacent is a good guy and the royal family and the princess is the villen and she curses aurora because she doesn't want to kill her and maybe the needle thing is a warning agenst greed or something that she could resist but dosn't and gets cursed cuase to make bad choices.
Disney:
Mystical Dragon Guardian: Too Fantasy
Witch who can turn into a million birds and 1 bird who can do dark magic and witchcraft: Very Realistic
honestly wtf was disney thinking with mulan?
I love live actions Disney’s Pocahontas, Tangled, Frozen and moana.❤
Cinderella is the best, and Mulan is the worst for me (though Malrficent 2 is a close 2nd). Snow White has a LOT to live up to, twofold.
I can’t believe you actually made this. Props to you sir 🫡
You need to watch Cruella! It’s my favorite of the live action remakes along with 101 Dalmations and Maleficent
Here we go.
15. Mulan(This is my least favorite movie of all time. I loathe it fully)
14. Maleficent
13. Dumbo
12. Pinocchio
11. The Sorcerer's Apprentice
10. Alice in Wonderland
9. Lady and the Tramp
8. Aladdin
7. 101 Dalmatians
6. Beauty and the Beast
5. Cinderella
4. Pete's Dragon
3. Christopher Robin
2. Cruella
1. The Jungle Book
Can you do a other ranking video.
I’ll never forgive the lion king for making the “can you feel the love TONIGHT” scene during the day
1 Cinderella
2 Beauty and the Beast
3 Alice
4 Cruella
5 Jungle Book
6 Maleficent
7 Aladdin
8 Pinocchio
9 Mulan
10 The Little Mermaid
The only good live action Disney remake to me is Cinderella.
What about Oz the Great and Powerful and The Nutcracker & the Four Realms? Or thoughts on Mary Poppins Returns?
You should do a review on The Sorcerers Apprentice! It is considered by some to be one of the first Disney live action remakes. It takes the sorcerer Mickey section of fantasia and turns into a full length film!
Very interesting rank, here's mine (of what I've seen). The ones that rank low for me either didn't bring anything new to the story or were changed in a way that pales in comparison to the animated films. The ones that rank higher I felt did better at offering an enjoyable experience blending classic traits with modern ones
1. Jungle Book
2. Aladdin
3. Maleficent
4. Dumbo
5. Cinderella
6. Beauty and the Beast
7. Alice in Wonderland
8. 101 Dalmatians
9. Pinocchio
10. Peter Pan and Wendy
11. Lion King
Something I want to tell you I despise the lion king remake. For many reasons:
1. The music is ruined.
2. The disrespect after I realized in more reviews.
3. How it ruined my love for the characters.
4. This garbage does have great animation. (A positive)
5. This movie made me cry (the only two positives.)
Another note: I love the jungle book remake and the Aladdin remake. That’s my opinion but hey it’s just my opinion.
Cinderella is still by far the best standalone live action remake. The jabs at the lion king though were truely warranted 😁
Oh my God I totally forgot Lady & The Tramp had a remake, I used to watch the good movie tons as a kid too. And fun fact the end shot of 101 Dalmatians, I counted 100 actual puppies. Which is amazing
I know that the Lion King remake isn’t seen as “good” (even though I personally like it) but how is it lower on the list than Mulan?? Mulan was just AWFUL.
The way they ruined Belle😭 I’ll never forgive Disney
The singing was TERRIBLE. I wanna cry
8:25 this actor was the whole reason I didn’t like Dumbo as a remake - she was just so SOULESS in her acting & I have NO idea how she got the part other than looking sweet or cute 🤦♀️
No Disney remake will ever even touch Hook
To be honest I don't care about these movies... I mean, if I want to I will watch SOME of them like The Lion King, Pinocchio or Aladdin because I like these ones A LOT (and I don't care about people opinions).And although Cinderella is really high in this list I didn't liked that much.
7:40 While I'm sure you may not care. But they were making monstro more like a monster from the original story unlike the whale from Disney since that's what it was mean to be. (as for why they did it. who knows)
In my opinion:
S Tier: 101 Dalmatians (Cruella carries this movie so hard, i love it.)
A Tier: Alice in Wonderland, Maleficent
B Tier: Lady and the Tramp, The Jungle Book, Cinderella, Beauty & the Beast
C Tier: Aladdin, Dumbo
D Tier: Pinocchio
F Tier: Mulan, The Lion King
I disagree on Alice and Maleficent, both are way worse than Beauty and The Beast.
Cinderella 2015 better be number 1... 💙✨💙✨
I didn’t even know that their was a lady and the tramp live action remake.
1. The Jungle Book (2016)
2. Cinderella
3. Christopher Robin
4. Pete's Dragon
5. Cruella
6. 101 Dalmatians
7. Aladdin
8. Lady and the Tramp
9. The Sorcerer's Apprentice
10. Beauty and the Beast
11. Maleficent
12. The Jungle Book (1994)
13. Dumbo
14. Alice in Wonderland
15. The Lion King
16. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
17. Alice Through the Looking Glass
18. 102 Dalmatians
19. Mulan
20. Pinocchio
1-4 range from amazing to great, 5-8 range from good to okay, 9-14 range from mediocre to bad, and 15-20 range from terrible to abysmal.
Wow Had enough rage over 20 minutes, Aldone? 😁
I can really sense your dislike for the 2019 Lion King. However, when I went to see it, I knew what I was getting, so I didn’t feel cheated or duped like how others felt. Also, Disney never said it was a live action remake. They just said it was a remake. Everyone else called it “live action” because it looked love action, but I digress.
If I were to make a ranking of the Disney Remakes, I’d list them like this, because I feel there are some on here that are far worse than the Lion King that were ranked higher. But, it’s your channel and you’re ranking what did or didn’t work for you.
Mushu is like half of mulan just imagine mulan without mushu that’s the live action “ of course with awful garbage writing “
If it were a Disney movie, where would the Charlotte's Web 2006 remake go?
Could you do it best to worst next time? It's more suspensful this way!
I can’t wait for the Among us live action movie
id pay to watch that in theaters
You forgot Pete's dragon
I'm being doing this too on my Letterboxd account...I'm also ranking their animated film counterparts~~
What fails in the live action movies is that they focus so much on the visuals that they completely ignore the story, acting performance, conflict, voice acting, emotions, actors singing capabilities, and expression.
My list from worst to best:
Mulan (2020) 0/10
Pinocchio (2022) 0/10
The Lion King (2019) 1/10
Lady and the Tramp (2019 1/10
Beauty and the Beast (2017) 2/10
Aladdin (2019) 2/10
Dumbo (2019) 3/10
The Little Mermaid (2023) 4/10
Cruella (2021) 5/10
I hate Mulan 2020 because this director is missing the point to the original. I get this person want something realistic however what’s not realistic is when the Rorens we’re running up the wall instead using the grappling hook like the OG. Same with the phoenix, which has no purpose to Mulan and same thing with the witch. I hate Mary sue because it’s stupid and not realistic. I’m not sure who’s idea to make Mulan Mary sue, he/she probably confuse with reality to fiction. I don’t blame the actress who plays Mulan in 2020 but once saw her act, she shows no emotion. And I don’t like her behavior towards the soldiers because she thinks she’s better than them just because she has chi power. Again, dumbest idea ever. 😒 I don’t understand why they took out Shang, in the OG, he wasn’t inappropriately taken advantage to Mulan/Ping, he was respectful and took his job seriously as captain. So it’s okay a soldier to do things with Mulan but not Shang. Once again that nameless soldier serves no purpose for Mulan as a character. Phoenix makes absolutely no sense, all it did just flies around looking dumb instead helping or guiding Mulan to her journey. Mushu who actually guides Mulan to her path and became the hero of China. The witch is also pretty stupid, I don’t k ow what are o say to that, still pretty stupid.
Did Disney started all this reimagined live action wave by ripping off Universal's two Huntsman-films?