That was beautiful my cat didn’t need their head and my grandma didn’t need her liver. I’m just happy you had the guts to send out such a heartfelt and meaningful apology. ❤
Originally, I couldn’t forgive you. But after hearing this extremely sincere, genuine, and heartfelt song, I completely forgive you. An apology such as this is truly inspiring and I hope others can learn to apologize in a similar fashion.
I've seen many content creators come out with apology videos, but this has got to be one of the most genuine, heartfelt, and emotional apologies I've ever seen from anyone. Thank you Charlie for being so vulnerable with us. We forgive you.
Fr fr, words cannot begin to describe how awestruck I was listening to this, I never imagined a human being like charlie could be so sincere with us, I started crying tears of joy knowing that people like these exist, thank you Charlie, my faith in humanity has been restored.
Amazing, this guy made an incredible apology while playing his guitar, and made it sound like a ukulele. His voice also sounds like CG5. Incredible talent! You're forgiven!
@@Cup1d_L1f3What do you mean? No it’s not. Are you mad or something?! (In case you are unaware, saying CG5 sounds like CG5 is a meme. Saying this just in case you don’t know and think I’m crazy or something.)
I know your team probably advised that you dont speak on those issues, but im glad you found a loophole and sang your apology. That's pretty respectable.
You’ve caused so much pain towards me and my family, I didn’t know how else to move forward in life. I was planning on sueing. But after you’ve gifted me with this genuine and beautiful piece of work, I’ve decided, MERELY OUT OF THE GOODNESS OF MY HEART, to forgive for such a terrible and unforgivable action. Thank you for sharing this with me. I forgive you, CG5.
@@4rdency Honestly, I appreciate it. I promise that I don't do this often, as I don't want people to hate me. But thanks so much for the positive feedback :)
thank you so much for this very sincere apology to all of us. I feel like a lot of influencers make their apologies very half assed and rushed but this one felt real. Thank you for this Charlie, we forgive you.
I don’t think any apology in the world could be as sincere as yours. The way you played such a beautiful song on your guitar made me shed a tear. I owe you 5 bucks just for that apology, you are 100% forgiven
Personally, as someone who has been a victim of accidental decapitation, I respect the sincereness of this apology and immediately forgive you Also you sound kinda like CG5
This was such a sincere apology. We 100% forgive you for taking our grandma's liver. Your such a nice person to apology to us like this CG5. Keep up the good work
The chords truly brought tears to my eyes. Not only did you showcase your amazing guitar skills and upload an apology quicker than every other RUclipsr that walked themselves into drama, the apology itself came out better than Colleen's. Better than she could've ever done. We will always forgive you, CG5! 💖💖💖
I dont understand why people hate you, youre doing what you love and you love it. I personally like your music, and yeah i know commenting this isnt going to change anything, but hopefully you'll see this and i hope that atleasr raises your spirits a little bit.
CG5's Exceptional Apology Title: CG5's Exceptional RUclips Apology: A Case Study in Sincere Redemption Introduction: In the ever-evolving world of online content creation, apologies have become an integral part of maintaining credibility and trust with an audience. Among the many RUclipsrs who have faced the need to apologize, CG5 stands out for his exceptional RUclips apology. CG5, a talented musician and content creator, has exemplified the true essence of a heartfelt apology by demonstrating sincerity, accountability, and a commitment to personal growth. This essay explores the elements that make CG5's RUclips apology the best and sheds light on the significance of such apologies in the digital age. Body: Sincerity: CG5's apology resonated with his viewers primarily because of its genuine sincerity. He expressed remorse for his actions and the impact they had on his audience, acknowledging the disappointment and hurt he caused. His words were carefully chosen, demonstrating a deep understanding of the situation and a desire to make amends. By conveying his remorse in an authentic and vulnerable manner, CG5 established a genuine connection with his audience, allowing them to empathize with him and believe in his commitment to change. Accountability: One crucial aspect of a remarkable apology is taking full responsibility for one's actions, and CG5 did not shy away from this. Instead of making excuses or shifting blame, he owned up to his mistakes, acknowledging the negative consequences they had on others. CG5 demonstrated true accountability by not downplaying the severity of his actions, but instead acknowledging the pain he caused and expressing a genuine desire to make things right. This level of ownership in an apology demonstrates integrity and helps rebuild trust in the eyes of his audience. Reflection and Growth: An effective apology involves demonstrating personal growth and a commitment to learning from past mistakes. CG5 embraced this crucial element by reflecting on his actions and acknowledging the lessons he learned from the experience. He expressed a sincere willingness to educate himself further, highlighting his dedication to becoming a better person and content creator. By demonstrating a genuine desire for personal growth, CG5 offered his audience reassurance that he would strive to avoid similar mistakes in the future, thus rebuilding their confidence in him. Transparency and Communication: CG5's RUclips apology excelled in its transparency and open communication. He provided a detailed explanation of the circumstances surrounding the incident, ensuring his audience had a clear understanding of the situation. CG5 also committed to maintaining open lines of communication, encouraging his viewers to express their thoughts, concerns, and questions. By fostering an environment of transparency and actively engaging with his audience, CG5 demonstrated a willingness to rebuild trust through ongoing dialogue. Conclusion: CG5's RUclips apology sets an exceptional example for content creators navigating the complexities of online interactions. His sincere expression of remorse, accountability, commitment to personal growth, and transparent communication showcase the qualities that define an outstanding apology. CG5's efforts in making amends and rebuilding trust with his audience deserve recognition and serve as a guiding light for others in similar situations. As online content creators continue to learn and grow, CG5's RUclips apology will undoubtedly be remembered as a remarkable example of a genuine and heartfelt apology that helped to repair and strengthen the bond between an artist and their audience.
You caused so much pain towards my family, it was a coincidence that my grandmother survived her liver removal. Kidnapping my family was a bit extreme as well, you phoned me saying you wanted 1 million pounds but the police arrived first because I knew before the phone call. My cat 'Felix' will be missed too, you served a good 20 years for everything you did but this has got to be the most heartbreaking and emotional apology I've ever seen. Thank you Charlie, you did a lot of bad, but I'll forgive you!
I was listening to this and I was like, “Oh, you did that to my grandma and parents? That’s fine, thanks for the apology.” Me after finishing the song; “You have chosen a death wish, Imma go look for a Shinigami, heck no, this man DECAPITATED MY CAT?!?!”
this is truly a very real apology. when you go to jail for what you did to grandma’s liver, you can bring the ukulele to sing yourself out. we all forgive you.. ❤
Honestly, when I first heard about what you did, I was shocked. I didn’t expect mister I See A Dreamer to commit murder, but after this apology, I completely forgive you. It was so heartfelt, I genuinely think you could get away with anything now.
Oh my god, this may be one of the best apologies on RUclips! I don't see why people won't forgive you! It's okay! I accept your very sincere and detailed apology!
I was tired when watching this video, but when I saw the first part of it, my eyes opened wide out of shock that this man made a song about stealing somebody’s grandmother’s liver
The fact that this is an obvious joke about that one creep's apology and half of this comments are clueless proves that this video was kinda well executed lmao
Видеоклипы
![CG5 Sings! [TommyInnit Talent Show]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/DpoerqAfz54/mqdefault.jpg)
This was such a sincere apology. We will forgive you
Woa ur here!!! :O
I'm glad he apologized
Before this blows up
Yes agreed
agreed
Honestly, I wasn't going to forgive you...but as soon as you pulled out the guitar, I knew I had no choice but forgiveness.
@@Yournotsofavoritefnaffan1hey, your little bit famous
He should have used otamatone
Ok
SULLY, YOU WATCH CG5?!
sully you should make an otamatone version of the youtuber's apology, it'd be funny
Even if the guitar doesn't quite sound like a ukulele, it was enough to gain my forgiveness.
We be going deep into the vault for this one 💀💀💀
That was beautiful my cat didn’t need their head and my grandma didn’t need her liver. I’m just happy you had the guts to send out such a heartfelt and meaningful apology. ❤
Wait what?
he probably took about 90% of your grandmas liver
@@zyronebiglang-awa6871Oh Charlie is so kind & caring! He left the 10%. Me & Grandma obviously forgave him♡
The fact that this is more sincere then Miranda's apology is something
Yeah, at least he says sorry
fr i would accept this apollogy bc it actually had work put into it 💀
Cuz Miranda's video wasn't an apology
@@Fauxvids Fair enough
@@Fauxvids Good point Good point
I loved how he acknowledged and took responsibility for what he did. Actually said the words "I'm sorry". We forgive you bro
Ok
I forgive give you for everything... EXEPCT DECAPITATING MY CAT BRING THE METAL GUTAIR ITS TIME FOR YOUR ETERNAL DOOM!
@ThyCrimsoncat AHAAHAHAHAHAA 😂
Now I want an Extended version for this Extremely sincere Apology.
the fact that this is better than the original solely because he actually apologises in these 30 seconds, unlike colleen in her 630 seconds
Originally, I couldn’t forgive you. But after hearing this extremely sincere, genuine, and heartfelt song, I completely forgive you. An apology such as this is truly inspiring and I hope others can learn to apologize in a similar fashion.
Eile
2⁸ likes, and 0 comment. Let me fix that
Elite reponce
I don’t understand anything, what he did to make us forgive him, I just don’t know
@@alexanimations95 they are just joking, probably
I've seen many content creators come out with apology videos, but this has got to be one of the most genuine, heartfelt, and emotional apologies I've ever seen from anyone. Thank you Charlie for being so vulnerable with us. We forgive you.
Fr fr, words cannot begin to describe how awestruck I was listening to this, I never imagined a human being like charlie could be so sincere with us, I started crying tears of joy knowing that people like these exist, thank you Charlie, my faith in humanity has been restored.
This apology is giving me the Colleen Vlogs vibes💀
@@creeperina0154that's the point 😜
@@creeperina0154that’s the point haha
@@creeperina0154that's the joke
You need to make a full version of this. Once you do, I am almost instantly putting it on my playlist
This apology is not ENOUGH! We want you now to play a ukulele apology!
Man, I feel really emotional and so empathetic for Charlie...I 100% forgive you and what you did with your grandma's liver.
Ok
Shat
What*
JELLO YOU GOT HEARTED :DDDDD
Same
Amazing, this guy made an incredible apology while playing his guitar, and made it sound like a ukulele. His voice also sounds like CG5. Incredible talent! You're forgiven!
That...... That IS CG5..... 🤣
@@Cup1d_L1f3What do you mean? No it’s not. Are you mad or something?! (In case you are unaware, saying CG5 sounds like CG5 is a meme. Saying this just in case you don’t know and think I’m crazy or something.)
I know he sounds just like GC5 it’s crazy
I know, I know. XD
@@aaronlopez5163
*🎵everybody told me that I sound like CG5🎵*
*🎵that would be because I am CG5🎵*
bro why dose this sound fire tho-
can we get a full version?????
Duolingo Bird when you miss lessons for a year and 5 months:
I know your team probably advised that you dont speak on those issues, but im glad you found a loophole and sang your apology. That's pretty respectable.
Bahahaha yeah "I'm glad you found a loophole" - said no one ever about Miranda's video
hi mario
colleen ballinger reference
1,000 like 🤪
My Miranda apology vid senses are tingling again🤔🤔🤔
He explained his life story in 26 seconds, what a legend.
Ayoooooo what does that mean
I love ur videos toby
Lmao
Haha yes!
I left this channel in 2021 and expected to comeback to insane masterpieces. He did more
The smile at the end just hits hard 🗿🗿
The fact that literally everyone knows exactly what this is referring to restores my faith in humanity
coleens terrible apology 😂
I was on vacation so I had no idea what this was
i didn't until today lmao
bro that apology actually just spawned a whole new meme genre
@@faceboy1392 Fr, and I'm here for it 😂
This man woke up and created a respectable 26 sec banger, respect.
Mr white
Why do I always see someone named Heisenberg comment on random videos?
U AGAIN
Why are you everywhere?
BOOTTT
Such an amazing apology.
I am sorry but I cannot forgive you even though the apology was extremely sincere.
But dude, look at his face, HE DIDNT KNOW BETTER
as someone who is currently around 5-10 minutes away from seeing my grandma, and owns three cats, I can say this is the best song I’ve ever heard.
Ok
This song is very accurate toward u
@@davidlol7654bet, nothing is worse than the _-Grimace Shake-_
Did you make it there yet?
Wjat
10/10 youtuber apology it was so sincere and you can really tell that he is willing to change for the better, we forgive you Charlie!!! ❤❤❤
Yes
@davidlol7654 no one will subscribe to your channel, bot
That "I'm sorry" part hit me just right, and I've replayed it about 15 times now.
what a beautiful apology, you are forgiven
This is still far more sincere than all other actual apology videos.
Lol
You’ve caused so much pain towards me and my family, I didn’t know how else to move forward in life. I was planning on sueing. But after you’ve gifted me with this genuine and beautiful piece of work, I’ve decided, MERELY OUT OF THE GOODNESS OF MY HEART, to forgive for such a terrible and unforgivable action. Thank you for sharing this with me. I forgive you, CG5.
I hate to be that guy but uhh i made my own version of his video so yeahhh 😭
@@Renderfumeyour version is pretty funny
@@Lightingboiiii Thanks, always appreciate the support! :D
@@Renderfume As much as I hate it when people self promote in comments, I will indeed say your version was funny as well. Carry on with your day
@@4rdency Honestly, I appreciate it. I promise that I don't do this often, as I don't want people to hate me. But thanks so much for the positive feedback :)
The funniest part is the ukulele sound coming out of an electric guitar
Bro I really me made sad about my cat but this was all I needed thank you
thank you so much for this very sincere apology to all of us. I feel like a lot of influencers make their apologies very half assed and rushed but this one felt real. Thank you for this Charlie, we forgive you.
I hate to be that guy but uhh i made my own version of his video so yeahhh 😭
@@Renderfume i think you should stop copypasting this to every comment lol
@@pdandere will do sorry
I'm really confused of what's happening here
I saw the cover and i was like “OH HELL NAW” but this is the best apology video!
Also the way he stares into your soul…
Yeah he is so kind for this Sincere apology! Unlike SOME👀
yeah i have agree with yall but he was staring into our souls for this one
That is amazing 🤩
That's a nice apologize by the way we acssept your request.
I know this is fake, but honestly, your apology is more genuine than any other RUclipsrs lol
True
If this was serious, what would he be apologising for?
@@Gloverfield I was making kind of a joke there
@@ravenhanson1 I was just hoping to get an answer on why he got hated on back then, to the point where he had to upload this masterpiece 😅
@Gloverfield that I cannot answer unfortunately
Charlie...where's my cat?
Heyoooo!😃
2nd reply and 8th like :)
Ayy Caleb!!
Hi
I’ve been doing music since I was 7, and you inspire me. You are my favourite music artist and your music makes my day 100x better.
Bro is the aftermath of a loony toons anvil drop effect
Perfect 👌
@@davidlol7654bots
Ok
@@TheOneAndOnly_Muffin yeah, I literally saw him on the last video I watched
Eminem got competition
This man earning like fast sheesh
Best apology video EVER, really captures the essence of how they really are while also being a vibe. Nice.
Ok
This always beats the Colleen apology song thingy
I loved the end😍
I don’t think any apology in the world could be as sincere as yours. The way you played such a beautiful song on your guitar made me shed a tear. I owe you 5 bucks just for that apology, you are 100% forgiven
I hate to be that guy but uhh i made my own version of his video so yeahhh 😭
@@Renderfume don’t worry about it bro, I checked it out and it’s actually pretty funny 😁
@@toothlesslightfury1788 Thank you! Appreciate the support!
This was moving. This apology was so sincere. Honestly, thank you Charlie. You are forgiven. 😌✨❤️
I hate to be that guy but uhh i made my own version of his video so yeahhh 😭
I love how the ELECTRIC GUITAR sounds like soft ukulele
These parodies more genuine then the original.
Don't worry bro 🙏🙏 I forgive you. You had the courage to address this issue and we're very proud of you.
Yo
E
It's ok Charlie, my grandmother didn't need that liver anyway. Also I hated that cat. You need the money, it's alright.
PORQUÉ EL GATO/j
@@davidlol7654bullshit
Yes.
@@davidlol7654stop capping
Ok
the moment it started i started rolling
such a banger apology
Personally, as someone who has been a victim of accidental decapitation, I respect the sincereness of this apology and immediately forgive you
Also you sound kinda like CG5
waiting for someone to get wooshed...
hE Is cG5!!!!
@BNe0 lets start a comment argument
Okay, here we go! Sans is the worst character in Undertale
@Zakaudior/woooosh
Thank you for this. I was wondering where my Grandmother, Mother, Father, and Cater went. Now, I know thanks to this wonderful song. ❤
Yoo
Thanks for telling me how my gramma died and why my parents went missing and also thanks for telling me why I don't have a cat apology excepted
this has changed my broken soul. i forgive you.
This was such a sincere apology. We 100% forgive you for taking our grandma's liver. Your such a nice person to apology to us like this CG5. Keep up the good work
You're *
The chords truly brought tears to my eyes. Not only did you showcase your amazing guitar skills and upload an apology quicker than every other RUclipsr that walked themselves into drama, the apology itself came out better than Colleen's. Better than she could've ever done. We will always forgive you, CG5! 💖💖💖
I laughed when he said "Im sorry that i took your grandmas liver"
Most sane youtuber apology video:
We appreciate your braveness of going against what your legal team suggested we will forgive you because of your sincerity ❤
This was so emotional. Your apology was so sincere, and heartwarming. You deserve a crown, king.
Best twenty five seconds of my life.
Bro, your humor, it matches mine perfectly, I laughed so hard watching this-
Crazy how Charlie can take the most out of pocket things of all time and STILL make it sound good
its not out of pocket
@@ThatWasReallyCoolYT it's pretty out of pocket
@@BurningSparks this vid was a roast
I love this, it's simply a masterpiece that only CG5 himself would think to create 💀
Ok
Fr like man has TALENT 😂
Eminem got competition
Ye really
thank you for making this video as an apology to my friend❤
I dont understand why people hate you, youre doing what you love and you love it. I personally like your music, and yeah i know commenting this isnt going to change anything, but hopefully you'll see this and i hope that atleasr raises your spirits a little bit.
CG5's Exceptional Apology
Title: CG5's Exceptional RUclips Apology: A Case Study in Sincere Redemption
Introduction:
In the ever-evolving world of online content creation, apologies have become an integral part of maintaining credibility and trust with an audience. Among the many RUclipsrs who have faced the need to apologize, CG5 stands out for his exceptional RUclips apology. CG5, a talented musician and content creator, has exemplified the true essence of a heartfelt apology by demonstrating sincerity, accountability, and a commitment to personal growth. This essay explores the elements that make CG5's RUclips apology the best and sheds light on the significance of such apologies in the digital age.
Body:
Sincerity:
CG5's apology resonated with his viewers primarily because of its genuine sincerity. He expressed remorse for his actions and the impact they had on his audience, acknowledging the disappointment and hurt he caused. His words were carefully chosen, demonstrating a deep understanding of the situation and a desire to make amends. By conveying his remorse in an authentic and vulnerable manner, CG5 established a genuine connection with his audience, allowing them to empathize with him and believe in his commitment to change.
Accountability:
One crucial aspect of a remarkable apology is taking full responsibility for one's actions, and CG5 did not shy away from this. Instead of making excuses or shifting blame, he owned up to his mistakes, acknowledging the negative consequences they had on others. CG5 demonstrated true accountability by not downplaying the severity of his actions, but instead acknowledging the pain he caused and expressing a genuine desire to make things right. This level of ownership in an apology demonstrates integrity and helps rebuild trust in the eyes of his audience.
Reflection and Growth:
An effective apology involves demonstrating personal growth and a commitment to learning from past mistakes. CG5 embraced this crucial element by reflecting on his actions and acknowledging the lessons he learned from the experience. He expressed a sincere willingness to educate himself further, highlighting his dedication to becoming a better person and content creator. By demonstrating a genuine desire for personal growth, CG5 offered his audience reassurance that he would strive to avoid similar mistakes in the future, thus rebuilding their confidence in him.
Transparency and Communication:
CG5's RUclips apology excelled in its transparency and open communication. He provided a detailed explanation of the circumstances surrounding the incident, ensuring his audience had a clear understanding of the situation. CG5 also committed to maintaining open lines of communication, encouraging his viewers to express their thoughts, concerns, and questions. By fostering an environment of transparency and actively engaging with his audience, CG5 demonstrated a willingness to rebuild trust through ongoing dialogue.
Conclusion:
CG5's RUclips apology sets an exceptional example for content creators navigating the complexities of online interactions. His sincere expression of remorse, accountability, commitment to personal growth, and transparent communication showcase the qualities that define an outstanding apology. CG5's efforts in making amends and rebuilding trust with his audience deserve recognition and serve as a guiding light for others in similar situations. As online content creators continue to learn and grow, CG5's RUclips apology will undoubtedly be remembered as a remarkable example of a genuine and heartfelt apology that helped to repair and strengthen the bond between an artist and their audience.
I ain’t READing all THAT 💀💀
@@EnergizedFantaDude, read it.
They took the time to make it so we should respect and read it.
@@thegiantjjDude, they used ChatGPT.
WE NOT READIN ALL THAT UH UH WE IS NOT IN SCHOOL
@@veshremyisbest803 warmup for school
You caused so much pain towards my family, it was a coincidence that my grandmother survived her liver removal. Kidnapping my family was a bit extreme as well, you phoned me saying you wanted 1 million pounds but the police arrived first because I knew before the phone call. My cat 'Felix' will be missed too, you served a good 20 years for everything you did but this has got to be the most heartbreaking and emotional apology I've ever seen. Thank you Charlie, you did a lot of bad, but I'll forgive you!
MY CATS NAME IS FELIX
WHY DID YOU SEND THE GUY TO PRISION 20 YEARS WE FORGIVE HIM BUT YOU??
OH HELL NO
@@thegiantjjlol 😂
Best apologize video of the year it was awesome
HER LIVER, YOU TOOK IT, GIVE IT BACK!!!!
I've never been touched on such a spiritual level by an apology, I forgive you 100% and I'll give you my whole paycheck.
Funniest part us thus was still a better apology than Colleen's. You took accountability, and I think we all forgive you
at least you actually can count above 0 the amount of times he said "sorry"
We all make mistakes in the heat of passion, Jimbo
I was listening to this and I was like, “Oh, you did that to my grandma and parents? That’s fine, thanks for the apology.”
Me after finishing the song; “You have chosen a death wish, Imma go look for a Shinigami, heck no, this man DECAPITATED MY CAT?!?!”
CG5 after making a meme apology that actually sounds fire
This is the RUclips apology we should all come together and show pity and forgiveness to.
Good job, CG5.
This guy's head is like when you move every slider to the left in character creation
(not supporting colleen)
as someone without any type of cat, i see this as an absolute win
this is truly a very real apology. when you go to jail for what you did to grandma’s liver, you can bring the ukulele to sing yourself out. we all forgive you.. ❤
Oh my God. I'm on the floor crying from how beautiful this is. Thank you for such a sincere apolgym
its incredible how he made the exact sound of an acoustic ukulele with a big electric guitar 🤩
After watching this 5 month slater I still enjoy it
This is gonna sound hella weird, but you’re literally so amazing. I hope to write songs as good as you one day.
💀
Does bro get it 💀
Honestly, when I first heard about what you did, I was shocked. I didn’t expect mister I See A Dreamer to commit murder, but after this apology, I completely forgive you. It was so heartfelt, I genuinely think you could get away with anything now.
I like this song so much that i remember the lyrics. 💀💀💀
Bro i thought this was another spinoff off of Miranda sings apology💀
Oh my god, this may be one of the best apologies on RUclips! I don't see why people won't forgive you! It's okay! I accept your very sincere and detailed apology!
I hate to be that guy but uhh i made my own version of his video so yeahhh 😭
@@Renderfume u good bro?
CG5s songs can just be the randomest things ever but be such a jam
It’s a joke bc of the Colleen ballinger apology
I was tired when watching this video, but when I saw the first part of it, my eyes opened wide out of shock that this man made a song about stealing somebody’s grandmother’s liver
This song is so sincere. It touched me in places even my teacher couldn't.😢
The fact that this is an obvious joke about that one creep's apology and half of this comments are clueless proves that this video was kinda well executed lmao
And 0:26
nah it's fine, this fire
You first
🥇
Real first
1
Ok and
This was the best apology i’ve ever seen! I forgive you Charlie😀😀😀
Omg I forgive u this is beautiful 😭
Thank you very much for gathering the courage to make such a apology. I will definitely forgive you, thank you for your honesty!
I'm not very on the internet that's why I ask
Am I the only one who really wants a full length version of this apology song? Because this 27 seconds of it deserves its own full length masterpiece!
Agreed
Yes
a 10 minutes song like the original so he can monitize it, no joke that would be very funny
I love how everyone ignored the stuff that she did over a song just look in the comments of hi.
This one was actually good