In the book, the bread tossing scene took place when Katniss was around 9 or 10 years old. She was a tiny girl, collapsed and starving to death. It's a powerful scene in the book. So I never understood the movie making the decision to use the adult actors for that scene. It made it look so stupid. Adult Katniss just sitting down and pouting in the rain.
@@emilylewis5373 Yes, I remember now. She was just a few months off being able to claim the tesserae for herself and family. But my comment still stands. She was a little kid during that scene. She was trying to sell some of Prims old baby clothes but no-one wanted to buy them. she was about to give up. It was one of the most powerful scenes in the movie. They completely ruined it. I guess the producers thought the audience would be too stupid to realise that it was a young Katniss and Peeta in the scene so they just used the adult actors.
honestly the thing i was most sad about in the finale was the fact that the mutant dogs were supposed to look like the fallen tributes, it was supposed to have a psychological horror effect of seeing these twisted versions of dead kids, but instead they went for generic terrible cgi dogs
I totally 100% agree with you. There's a really important part where she hesitates because of the dog that looks like Rue but there's just none of that emotion in the finale
Besides, they tortured Cato before they killed him. In the books he was screaming for hours they said. In this she shoots him and the dogs eat him. That’s all. Not nearly as hardcore.
That scene was the most horrific scene in the whole book (at least for me). Beside Peeta lost one leg in the book. And Kantiss was deaf in one ear after blowing up the supplies.
Putting that as the final sin was just perfect. If there was anything after it, it would have lost a lot of weight. But "This celebrity couple's name is Pee-niss" *ding* *cut* is perfect
6:00 actually, a lot of people say that the exercise foxface was doing here wasn't a memory or matching game, but was for identifying poisoned plants from safe ones. lends credence to the theory that her death by the berries was ultimately a suicide
He is. When he played that serial killer The Lovely Bones, it's scared me for life. Before I never saw him a villain, only a good, funny guy who always know what to say.
1:25 - Fun fact: In the books, Katniss received the pin from Madge, the mayor’s daughter. Madge is never mentioned once in this series, even though they’re acquainted with each other in the books.
If you watch enough EWW videos you'd know that he always says the books don't matter, and he's right, they're two different mediums of story telling and truthfully shouldn't be compared, because when you compare them the books are nearly always better.
I hate how the movie makes the 11 score seems like a reward for her boldness when in the books is heavily implied that its actually a punishment for her insolence as it made her an instant target for the careers
What implied that? I’m reading the page where she gets her score, the only thing said to explain it was haymitch saying “Guess they liked your temper, They’ve got a show to put on they need some players with some heat.” To me that doesn’t say they wanted to make her target
You're thinking of the second book when they give both her and peeta a 12, in the first book it's portrayed as good that she got an 11 because they were still trying to secure sponsors
yeah, i actually never noticed until this video pointing it out how much of the important plot points and symbols were left out for the sake of cinema (i.e. the mockingjay being a symbol of rebellion because they were never meant to exist, and lived against the capitols wishes)
@@blackrex828 yeah the books are good. I won't explain how to not spoil them, but the final creatures that come for them are way creepier in the book. It's another major loss in the translation to film.
Literally the whole point is that the people of the capitol don’t actually think about the events of the games and just think of them as a festivity. That means all of it, including the silly things, are seen as fun and cool. They never think about how those kids are being dressed up so that they might have a helping hand in not dying. That’s highlighted in the book.
18:00 the lame dogs were wayyyyy creepier in the books, that shit gave me goosebumps, if I remember correctly, they whispered in the same voices as those who died. Pretty sure even Rues voice was used.... Been a minute since I read the books, but that shit was creepy and also done in the third book.
I think they said something about them being engineered out of the dead tributes' corpses or some ridiculousness, to boot. Really dumb idea when you stop and think about it, but pretty effective in the moment. Unlike the movie, where they're just ... big dogs.
@@AzhreiVep They were just made to look like the tributes (same eyes and hair/fur). Katniss just gets really freaked out by them and worries that the eyes of the mutts were from the tributes because they looked so much like human eyes. She clears the idea from her head a bit later bc she realizes that wouldn’t make sense
Not to mention this is the film’s tenth anniversary. I can’t tell if I should be happy or scared about that because 1: It’s a good series. And 2: This is a movie that involves children killing each other.
It's funny you think that because those older ones had the most to-the-point and accurate sins instead of unnecessary sin padding tomfoolery that they do now. You, my friend, are the perfect audience for this channel
@@WilliamButtlicker I like Pitch Meetings as well which are also under 10 minutes. I feel those definitely don't need to be longer. But the cinemasin viewer of today is now used to 20+ minute videos, which does make the original less than five minute videos feel underdone.
@@Concepcion30 yeah it's the basic case of over saturation, but there are hardly just a few logical sins in their videos these days and most of it is just bullshitting. The only way I'm excited for a cinemasins video is that there's gonna be a Th3Birdman video to counter this.
@@WilliamButtlicker yes i love these videos just as much as i love the salty comments underneath it arguing with an obvious opinionated/ plain wrong sin put in just to anger them. it’s half the channel at this point.
Peeta burned the bread on purpose that’s why it’s burned like that. katniss knew that he got hit for her and never forgot about that. That’s why when he got called she said to herself “not him”. She always had a gratitude for him even if it wasn’t obvious to her.
The reason why Foxface (the girl from district 5) takes her backpack and only hers, it's actually very clever. It has been stated that she's the smartest between all the tributes, and that's no lie. If she had grabbed any of the other districts' backpacks, they for sure would've come after her. She didn't want this, in fact, her plan was to not get into confrontation, since her abilities in combat were not so good. Therefore, her being the first one to grab the backpack by being hidden in the Cornucopia before the backpacks were delivered, was the best plan. If anyone went after her, they would be risking the chance of getting their backpacks stolen by other tributes. So her plan would only work if she was the first to grab her backpack, and only hers.
17:14 although I would admit it is a bit odd that the district five girl would only take her own gift, but I do think that it may be because of the fact that she didn’t want anyone else to chase after her due to her severe disadvantage in combat.
17:14 we gotta remember that in each of those bags there was something they all “desperately needed.” So taking all bags would pretty much make her everyone’s target.
This was DIRECTLY stated in the book. That it was deliberate that Foxface did not take anyone else's supplies because everyone would've gone for her. Cinemasins obviously didn't read the book.
@@rickole7404 Yeah, but at the same time cinema sins never considers the books (which honestly, fair, he’s rating it as a movie not just as a story). I was just pointing it out lol
The parts I always disliked of these movies, as compared to the books (I have read them a few times times) is that no one looks hungry, when in reality most are basically starving at home, the first movie makes it seem like Katniss was in the games a few days at most when it was weeks, and of course that you never get the aspect of katniss's inner dialog which you obviously can't do well in a movie. But her inner dialog is what really makes the series so special. She's a hero but she not the typical hero and she doesn't consider herself one at all. I wish the movies could have explored that a little more. And the hunger. No one seems hungry, at all lol
Katniss should have died after the 2nd movie if u being fr lol u can c in many scenes where she should have died but “magically” she doesn’t when everyone else does😂
8:40 Why would they have security? That's the whole point; the districts are so under their heel nobody would dream of striking back. Katniss' "attack" is the whole reason they have the protective shield in Catching Fire.
as someone who has a hyperfixation on the hunger games currently (the books and movies) i enjoy having it brutally judged by one of my favourite channels. thank you for this re-sin :)
@@ricchy404 yea, but they also made it happen for reasons. they gave context towards why she survived most of it, as she could hunt well at home so it was easy to get food in the arena.
its not plot armor, she was the most prepared to survive outside of the careers, and even more than them in terms of general survival instinct and ability to be self sustaining@@ricchy404
The anniversary re-sins are a good idea, especially when some of these original sin videos were shorter than 5 minutes. I bet there were plenty of other things to go back and re-sin that were missed the first time around.
Don’t forget Foxface. All three likable, minor characters were conveniently killed off - so that Katniss never has to kill anyone that the audience supports. Rue was killed by the trained psychopaths; Foxface ate poisonous berries; and Thresh was killed by the murder dogs.
Is the books, Thresh was actually killed by Cato(bless his pure soul) Rue was caught in a trap and Katniss failed to get to her in time before she was speared(bless her too) and Foxface ate the berries because she saw Peeta collecting them and thought they were safe. Night lock didn’t grow in her district so she had no idea they were poisonous. Don’t know why I’m commenting this.
her death in the book made me ugly cry. the movie.. didn't? i don't know how, probably because we get to see rue more in the book, gives us more time to get attached. in the movie, it felt like a fleeting moment
Okay so the reason Foxface only grabs her district five bag is actually quite clever and explained in the book. By immediately running to take her bag foxface gets what she needs but also leaves the other tributes at a crossroads. If they chase her, their bag will be stolen. So instead they all just leave her be because after all foxface only took her bag and the other tributes don’t want to risk losing their bag.
Rue’s odds being 7-1 is crazy considering the people that means she has a better chance of winning than. She’s pretty much right in line with all the career tributes and even better odds than her fellow district 11 competitor. You know the 18 year old strong man who’s almost 3x bigger than the 12 year old little girl.
Not jf you knew anything from the other 40+ hunger games or listened when they explained that most dont die from battle but incompetence of simple survival
She is smart, can climb the tallest trees and move undetected. She's also good at finding the right herbal medicine and she formed an alliance with Katniss, who is a strong contender. Brute force isn't everything to survive the arena. Cunningness is as if not more important. She is the one who shows Katniss the wasps and also gives her the idea to cut the branch. She spies on the rest and knows where they are and what they're up to. She managed to survive on her own for days (weeks in the book) when other kids her age died the first 5 mins. So yeah, she was one of the strong competitors.
5:40 she only gives up to thirty percent because 50% die at the very beginning of the games when they’re all rushing for the supplies. That leaves like 20% to die from combat and other things after the first day
Katniss missed the first shot in the skills showcase because she’s used to using the bow she made herself which is inaccurate so when she uses a bow that’s precise and accurate she misses the first time because she’s not used to a perfect bow. It explains it in the book.
it doesn’t say anything about her own bow (that her father actually made btw) being inaccurate. it’s simply made of different materials, with different tension etc. There’s nothing about it being "inaccurate". It’s just not what she’s used to and she needs a few shots to get a feel for the weapon.
The Amazing Spider-Man definitely needs a re-sin next month to celebrate 10 years of Cinema Sins, and the fact that it was the very first video on the channel
8:47 you missed the fact that every single tribute appears to not have a last name when caesar was annoucing the training scores except, of course, the main characters.
Yes, they elevated security measures after Katniss shooting at them by putting force fields to prevent any contestents from pulling it off again. It was indeed an oversight on their part
It actually makes a lot of sense that Glimmer and Cato would be joking about murder because they volunteered at the reaping. District 1 &2 willingly volunteer and train their whole lives to kill
5 only took her own pack at the feast because: - If she took someone else's pack, they would chase her - She's not a fighter, so she knows she's dead if she gets caught in a straight fight
In the books, some of the more affluent districts do pretty much what you say. They train their children to fight so that when they're 18, the best volunteer. Katniss volunteering was a surprise to the viewers since the more malnourished districts understandably tend to perform worse than their more well off counterparts.
I maintain a Haymitch centered Hunger Games story about dealing with the mental toll of being a winner and then being forced to train/mentor future tributes would have been much more interesting than Peta and Katniss.
Cinema Sins saying Haymitch is in a difficult spot trying to encourage both his entrants, even if they ultimately have to kill each other. It would be interesting to explore what that would do to you.....Serious alcoholism seems to be the answer.
I agree. Take out the whole revolution part of the story and focus more on how it affects the winners, tributes and their families and communities would have been 10x better. Also, keep the tyrannical government in power. It makes for a harsher ending. It's hard to believe a teenage girl with no training could be a better military leader than lifelong soldiers and overthrow an empire all before she could buy a beer.
@@brandocalrissian3294 In the books at least she is never really a leader. Her success in the games means she is used as a figurehead for the revolution but really she is just being used as a puppet by everyone who is actually controlling the war. Even her final act of assassinating the District 13 leader is something she is manipulated into by Snow in their final meeting.
his Games would be so interesting to see too, considering it was a quarter quell in which the amount of tributes was doubled. he pretty much waited until everyone else was dead but either way i would absolutely love a haymitch anthology or something of the like (not to mention woody harrelson was just perfect for the role
The mocking jay pin in the movie angers me to no end. They devalue it so bad compared to the book where she got it from the mayors daughter, the only person in the district who would even be able to afford to have one.
4:37 this one’s such a nitpicky sin but it’s absolutely hilarious and accurate. Wouldn’t they realistically use some sort of futuristic laser hair remover instead of wax strips? 😂
I'm guessing it's a way of being dicks to the poor kids being forced into a reality TV survival battle to the death. The rich and well off getting far easier hair removal procedures would be obvious.
@@bleakautomaton4808 I don’t think so, they treated them pretty good during their stays. They had them in luxury apartments, with famous designers, feasting on luxury food. I doubt they want to be dicks to them by making them get waxed. Plus when President Snow gets his hair cut they still use blades and shit so
@@changesme110yearsago9 I guess we could go with a second option of it somehow being a hipster thing. People in real life do what others may see as antiquated all the time, taking into account when this book was popular also I see this as an acceptable alternative as well.
@@bleakautomaton4808 I see that, honestly I think that we just give them too much credit. They weren’t really that advanced, they were just weird asf. The only thing that was super futuristic was the game arenas, aside from that they had all the same shit we do 😂
I always laughed in the movie when Katniss is in the tree and the careers are down on the ground..like they are supposed to be so deadly and dangerous yet not only were they unable to get her at the first attempt but they all just gave up and decided to wait her out? Didn't we earlier see Clove not miss a target with her knives? I get that it had to happen because Katniss couldn't just die there and then but even Glimmer..are you telling me she couldn't get Katniss with her bow and arrow? Why did Cato even do it when Glimmer is supposed to be skilled with a bow and arrow? 😅 I was always confused at this part haha
In the books, Katniss mentions that Glimer was basically a ditz, and that she used her beauty for support. She sucks at using the bow in the books aswell if I remember well.
Fair enough Glimmer isn't skilled with a bow😆 But as I also said Clove didn't miss a target with her knives. I love the hunger games series..I was just making the point that there were 4 careers in total and none of them were capable of getting Katniss with any weapon😅
I don't remember what it says in the books, but I think the tree is supposed to be much taller than it's depicted so perhaps the knives couldn't reach. It's hard to throw knives upwards.
@@Zopheri as I said in my original post, I always laughed in the movie. But yeah true, knives would be hard to throw upwards. My point was more, we have 4 careers that are from the 2 districts that are supposed to be the best yet in the movie we see Glimmer attempt one shot and Cato attempt to climb a tree and fail once, so they just give up..and that's always made me laugh😅
13:33 considering this is a movie and most of the details (like what sponsers are and stuff) are given to us by Katniss' inner monologues, Haymitch and the commentators are a great way of introducing the concepts to the non readers
6:00 I appreciate the implication here that Cinemasins is some kind of multiversal entity, like some version of The Watcher, that just watches and silently judges/sins things. Never taking any action about it, mind you, just casually sitting there and judging to themselves. It’s a thought that makes me smile, even if it doesn’t actually make any sense.
The books actually point out that taking everyone's present in the feast would draw the other Tributes after you even more than before, because the Tributes want their gifts back.
I realized a few weeks ago that I've been watching this channel since the Prometheus video and it blew my mind a little, this truly have become a part of my life
Only gripe I have? The commentary on teenagers being a lot more likely to be giddy about killing someone. Teenagers are still in the developmental stages where they're deciding their own personal code of ethics and morality while still being VERY impressionable, so it's actually very much easier to influence teenagers to willingly, even gleefully, murder people than it is a full grown adult who has decided that's a line they're not willing to cross.
Not to mention the fact that these certain kids that are laughing about killing people actually volunteered to be tributes. Its the careers for christ sake.
These kids attended a school that taught them/prepared them to volunteer as tributes. At the end Cato kinda figures things out for himself and he has some dialogue about it all
Not to forget, they just did it, they didn’t have time to process it. Joking and laughing about it might as well be their way of dealing with it, especially after the first of them started with it. Makes it less meaningful, makes it easier. Who knows how they would have felt about it after the games if any of them had survived. But none of them lived long enough to get out of the situation I’m the arena. The only one who even lived long enough to (at least openly) realize the games were messed up was Cato and at that point he was completely alone and knew he was going to die. Interestingly enough, he chose not to kill Peeta when he could have - would have made no difference for him, he would have died either way and he knew it. But the others never got to that point and none of them could ever reevaluate the games after getting out of them. We can only speculate about how they would have felt about it afterwards. Also, the comparison between the military and the careers makes no sense, not only because the careers are still kids and soldiers aren’t. Soldiers don’t train from childhood on, they don’t grow up with the knowledge that they’ll be in an arena with 23 other people and only one will survive one day, most soldiers are pretty normal people. The careers, on the other hand, are brainwashed enough to volunteer for those crazy games where only one out of 24 will survive. They are already completely messed up when they enter the arena. It would make no sense for them to act like normal teenagers and definitely not to act like normal adults with a strong moral code.
Also, the idea of the four tributes from District One and District Two working together in harmony seems shaky to me. Yes, it’s easier to survive in a group. However, these three people are also your biggest threats - and the movie goes out of its way to portray these kids as evil. So, it doesn’t seem like they would care about loyalty to each other. At the very least, the movie could throw in a few lines about some kind of code. For example, maybe they’re trained to work as a pack - and, then, when it’s just them left, they divide up and hunt each other. With the info that we’re given, I feel like at least one of them would seize an opportunity to betray and kill off the group.
What really makes no sense is that the other districts don't have some sort of agreement to team up, even between their own two tributes a lot of the time it seems. They're mostly just happy to run off solo and let the careers hunt them down one by one.
It seemed so much more convincing in the books. Have you read them? The careers were portrayed less evil there and not completely cold. It’s been a while since I read them, but I remember when Clove died Cato begged her to stay with him, while in the movie they only show the careers’ cruel sides. I also think it was explained in the books they had this understanding to work together until the others were dead - every year the tributes from the career districts would do so, it was known to everyone. I suppose if one of them would betray another the tribute would be the next target of all the careers left so it wouldn’t be wise to betray another career. They also tried to hunt Peeta down when he betrayed them, but again, the book explained it much better. They should have taken a bit more time for that, just a few minutes.
@@Diana-qp2rw I have read the books and agree they flesh out much more how the teaming up of the careers is a well established thing that happens every time. Also as you say, almost any kid in this situation, trained or otherwise, is going to be traumatised by killing each other like this. I was just observing that it seemed like a failing in the books and films that none of the other tributes teamed up as well, from a tactical perspective it would make overwhelming sense to have at least a small team. Seems like this would have to be organised informally as there is no established teaming up other than the careers, but I would have been working on that pretty much the entire time they had training. Get a team in place so we can work together to give ourselves a chance against the careers. I say no-one else did it, but clearly Katniss and Rue did join up, so it obviously wasn't prohibited. There are problems down the line about when the coalition breaks, does it hold till just they are left or does someone backstab before then etc, but fundamentally a team has a much much higher chance of surviving it would seem.
I think the reason it’s rare for other districts to form alliances is the same it’s rare for them to volunteer. Most of them are completely clueless in terms of survival, have no hope of winning and are frightened of everyone else. Also, forming an alliance means you have to trust someone enough not to be backstabbed and be prepared for the idea to get to know someone (and humanize them) and maybe have to kill them later. This is why Katniss couldn’t let Peeta die after all, she didn’t even had to kill him, his leg wounds would bleed him to death on its own, but couldn’t allow this to happen after she spent days humanizing him (I know there is their past history to consider as well, but that didn’t stop her earlier in the ganes to throw a nest at his general direction) The careers don’t mind forming an alliance because they are completely brainwashed into buying the whole show, they volunteer and seem proud of being in the show, unlike anyone else
12:15 well different from soldiers, these people are conditioned from a very young age where they are way more impresionable and it easier to install concepts such as being okay with murder
19:16 "This celebrity couple's name is Pee-niss" - God damn dude, that hit perfectly. It caught me completely off guard and had me legit irl chuckling.
Rue’s score went up because she showed them how high and easily she could climb therefore staying out of the way and hiding. So they figured she would be hard to catch and find
Cinemasins launched my personal movie critiques and it will always have a special place in my heart. Time flys but you guys haven’t missed a single step, keep it up!
I told my wife to read the book before we saw the film so she would be ready for Rue's death, but she never got around to it. Then when that happened, she was about ready to get up out of the theater and leave.
As a 12 year old black girl who watched on opening weekend without having ever read the books, Rue's death hit me so hard that I was actually shaking- I wasn't even sad-crying, I was scared-crying. My mom was holding me and telling me "it's okay, it's just a movie" with tears clearly running down her own face. That remained the largest emotional bitch-slap I'd ever gotten from a movie until 10 years later with Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, when I, a 22 year old part Kenyan neuroscience/data science major named Zuri who had lost my mother Rhonda, went to see it while already exhausted and was stunned by Queen Ramonda's death like I'd been punched in the face. Some movies just stay with you forever, and usually it's because of things lile this.
6:41 in the book it’s implied that Peeta purposefully burnt the bread so he could throw it to Katniss since his mom wouldn’t sale it knowing the consequences that his mom would beat him for burning it.
16:15 That camouflage was so good, it would take a cast of skilled makeup artists to even pull it off. But PETA did it on the fly, blind, AND bleeding to death. Just hahahahahahaha....hahahahaha.
17:13 ok the book nerd in me has to say, in the books its explained she did this because stealing others bags would have them chase after her. She grabbed it before everyone else, and because she didnt bother the others, they let her leave.
Once again, the amount of sins here that are explained in the are insane @17:19 for example, the girl from 5 didn't want to be followed, she was surviving by running away
It’s funny you talk about Hunger Games fans trying to turn the odd days in May into a holiday for Reaping Day because Suzanne Collins has said that the reaping takes place on the 4th of July. So if we wanted to celebrate Reaping Day that would technically be the day to do it.
Just throwing it out there, the demon dogs were supposed to have the dead tributes’ faces to mentally screw with the remaining survivors while they tear them apart
LOL....she didn't do the leaf-thing to attract the deer(I mean, what would the mechanism be: "Oh, shredded leaves, even before they come to my mouth. Delicious!!"). She checked for the direction of the wind to see if the deer would be upwind and not be able to smell her if she approachd from that direction.
to me this is a big improvement on the original. more clever lines, where the other one just felt like a few minutes of "this is stupid. this is also stupid. I don't understand this therefore this is stupid". Good job!
In the book, the bread tossing scene took place when Katniss was around 9 or 10 years old. She was a tiny girl, collapsed and starving to death. It's a powerful scene in the book. So I never understood the movie making the decision to use the adult actors for that scene.
It made it look so stupid.
Adult Katniss just sitting down and pouting in the rain.
She was 11 during the scene. The next year she was able to put her name in the drawling more times for extra food.
@@emilylewis5373 Yes, I remember now. She was just a few months off being able to claim the tesserae for herself and family.
But my comment still stands. She was a little kid during that scene. She was trying to sell some of Prims old baby clothes but no-one wanted to buy them. she was about to give up.
It was one of the most powerful scenes in the movie.
They completely ruined it. I guess the producers thought the audience would be too stupid to realise that it was a young Katniss and Peeta in the scene so they just used the adult actors.
@@Lyca31 I know right! That was so stupid! It was 4 years ago in the story!
EXACTLY!!! That always bothered me so much! Why couldn’t they have just hired two child actors?
yeah lmao
honestly the thing i was most sad about in the finale was the fact that the mutant dogs were supposed to look like the fallen tributes, it was supposed to have a psychological horror effect of seeing these twisted versions of dead kids, but instead they went for generic terrible cgi dogs
I totally 100% agree with you. There's a really important part where she hesitates because of the dog that looks like Rue but there's just none of that emotion in the finale
Yeah and then Peeta paints one of them in the next book because it was so traumatic he still has nightmares about it
Besides, they tortured Cato before they killed him. In the books he was screaming for hours they said. In this she shoots him and the dogs eat him. That’s all. Not nearly as hardcore.
That scene was the most horrific scene in the whole book (at least for me). Beside Peeta lost one leg in the book. And Kantiss was deaf in one ear after blowing up the supplies.
Yes! That irritated me. It was HORRIFYING in the original book.
"This celebrity couple's name is Pee-niss"
This had me laughing a lot harder than I think they meant for it to.
Me too! LMAO
I had to leave a comment for that name 😂
Same
Putting that as the final sin was just perfect. If there was anything after it, it would have lost a lot of weight.
But "This celebrity couple's name is Pee-niss" *ding* *cut* is perfect
This is the type of quality content I watch CinemaSins for
6:00 actually, a lot of people say that the exercise foxface was doing here wasn't a memory or matching game, but was for identifying poisoned plants from safe ones. lends credence to the theory that her death by the berries was ultimately a suicide
Berries
Berries
@@Black-Swan-007 berries grow on plants lmao
@@tabaxi Yes.
Does she do this game in the books?
Glad you took a sin off for Tucci. The guys a national treasure.
tucci gang tucci gang tucci gang
Because #tuccapaloosa isn't just a hashtack, it's a Lifestyle
He is. When he played that serial killer The Lovely Bones, it's scared me for life. Before I never saw him a villain, only a good, funny guy who always know what to say.
Check out Tucci’s upcoming projects. He has some exciting stuff coining out with some stellar casts!
Should do a video on everything wrong with her b**hole from her pornos!
1:25 - Fun fact: In the books, Katniss received the pin from Madge, the mayor’s daughter. Madge is never mentioned once in this series, even though they’re acquainted with each other in the books.
That's because her character was never in the movies
@@seahawk777goats3 the series mentioned IS the movies
The books don't matter
If you watch enough EWW videos you'd know that he always says the books don't matter, and he's right, they're two different mediums of story telling and truthfully shouldn't be compared, because when you compare them the books are nearly always better.
@@cattle-yq4gu Yes, this is true. But it does also highlight a problem with the films. In a way it reinforces the sin, rather then defends the film
I hate how the movie makes the 11 score seems like a reward for her boldness when in the books is heavily implied that its actually a punishment for her insolence as it made her an instant target for the careers
What implied that? I’m reading the page where she gets her score, the only thing said to explain it was haymitch saying “Guess they liked your temper, They’ve got a show to put on they need some players with some heat.” To me that doesn’t say they wanted to make her target
You're thinking of the second book when they give both her and peeta a 12, in the first book it's portrayed as good that she got an 11 because they were still trying to secure sponsors
You’re for sure thinking of the second book. Besides, Suzanne Collins herself was part of the production of the movie, it’s all canon
@@purplehawk2271 she also goes on to explain how a higher scoring tribute usually dies early on since they become targets for careers
Than why was it not a 12 like in the fir book
I always hated how the skipped out on the significance of the mockingjay. Like it's a huge part of the story and the movie never elaborated on it 😂
yeah, i actually never noticed until this video pointing it out how much of the important plot points and symbols were left out for the sake of cinema (i.e. the mockingjay being a symbol of rebellion because they were never meant to exist, and lived against the capitols wishes)
Ikr it was actually on the cover of the book
Hmmm so ya telling me I should buy the books, well I will then...
@@blackrex828 yesir, the books, as always, are better and go into more detail
@@blackrex828 yeah the books are good. I won't explain how to not spoil them, but the final creatures that come for them are way creepier in the book. It's another major loss in the translation to film.
"For a society that uses child murder as entertainment, they sure are entertained by simple things" that is the *entire* point of the series
Pretty dumb point. People are usually entertained by the "simple things" when there's not much entertained around. Wasn't the case here.
Literally the whole point is that the people of the capitol don’t actually think about the events of the games and just think of them as a festivity. That means all of it, including the silly things, are seen as fun and cool. They never think about how those kids are being dressed up so that they might have a helping hand in not dying. That’s highlighted in the book.
I think the point is also that the richest of society feed off the hardworking poor and we should unite to destroy toxic parasitical capitalism
@@Suchwerewolf that is in no way related to the comment you replied to. Also, turn it down a notch with your marxism
@@jaakkoparikka6060 how bout no, scott
Those 10 extra sins for Rue's death are sweet, in a CinemaSins way.
“In a CinemaSins way” is the _best._
“I was fine with all the bodies bodies bodies, but rue is unacceptable!” 😂
@@J_Bb 😜💜🖤
He shoulda taken sins off for that one
@@aztecwrrior1997 NO BC WE STAN RUE AND WE WISHED SHE COULD HAVE LIVED
18:00 the lame dogs were wayyyyy creepier in the books, that shit gave me goosebumps, if I remember correctly, they whispered in the same voices as those who died. Pretty sure even Rues voice was used.... Been a minute since I read the books, but that shit was creepy and also done in the third book.
I think they said something about them being engineered out of the dead tributes' corpses or some ridiculousness, to boot. Really dumb idea when you stop and think about it, but pretty effective in the moment. Unlike the movie, where they're just ... big dogs.
@@AzhreiVep They were just made to look like the tributes (same eyes and hair/fur). Katniss just gets really freaked out by them and worries that the eyes of the mutts were from the tributes because they looked so much like human eyes. She clears the idea from her head a bit later bc she realizes that wouldn’t make sense
@@AzhreiVep Artificial Flood doesn't sound not-effective.
@@thewinterjule Ah, okay. Forgive me, I haven't read that book since before the movies were a t hing.
@@AzhreiVep Which covers the "conservation of matter" argument.
It's still crazy to think I've been watching Cinemasins for ten years
Same. Their content is awesome
Cinemasins raised me
Not to mention this is the film’s tenth anniversary. I can’t tell if I should be happy or scared about that because 1: It’s a good series. And 2: This is a movie that involves children killing each other.
Right???!!
@@likecascade7015 she´s a woman grown now...
I did always think the older ones were too short. Now we can get a full 15+ mins of cinema sins pissing off die hard fans
I hope they give this treatment to all of their old sins videos!
It's funny you think that because those older ones had the most to-the-point and accurate sins instead of unnecessary sin padding tomfoolery that they do now. You, my friend, are the perfect audience for this channel
@@WilliamButtlicker I like Pitch Meetings as well which are also under 10 minutes. I feel those definitely don't need to be longer. But the cinemasin viewer of today is now used to 20+ minute videos, which does make the original less than five minute videos feel underdone.
@@Concepcion30 yeah it's the basic case of over saturation, but there are hardly just a few logical sins in their videos these days and most of it is just bullshitting. The only way I'm excited for a cinemasins video is that there's gonna be a Th3Birdman video to counter this.
@@WilliamButtlicker yes i love these videos just as much as i love the salty comments underneath it arguing with an obvious opinionated/ plain wrong sin put in just to anger them. it’s half the channel at this point.
Fun fact, the leaf thing Katniss does isn’t to track the deer, but to make sure she’s downwind so it doesn’t smell her and gtfo before she can kill it
Could've just licked her finger and stuck it in the air
@@julesdebeckker627 yeah but it's not as visually interesting
Reminds me of those hunting deer missions with Trevor in GTA V
Peeta burned the bread on purpose that’s why it’s burned like that. katniss knew that he got hit for her and never forgot about that. That’s why when he got called she said to herself “not him”. She always had a gratitude for him even if it wasn’t obvious to her.
The reason why Foxface (the girl from district 5) takes her backpack and only hers, it's actually very clever. It has been stated that she's the smartest between all the tributes, and that's no lie. If she had grabbed any of the other districts' backpacks, they for sure would've come after her. She didn't want this, in fact, her plan was to not get into confrontation, since her abilities in combat were not so good. Therefore, her being the first one to grab the backpack by being hidden in the Cornucopia before the backpacks were delivered, was the best plan. If anyone went after her, they would be risking the chance of getting their backpacks stolen by other tributes. So her plan would only work if she was the first to grab her backpack, and only hers.
Also the book said the other tributes would have to fight it out for the other backpacks
17:14 although I would admit it is a bit odd that the district five girl would only take her own gift, but I do think that it may be because of the fact that she didn’t want anyone else to chase after her due to her severe disadvantage in combat.
Exactly. Everybody was watching her.
They say this in the books too
fr, Cato went after Thresh when he took his so she was smart
@@insertsarcasm oh wait they do?
It's explicitly stated in the book that she took only her own bag so as not to give the other contestants a reason to chase her down.
17:14 we gotta remember that in each of those bags there was something they all “desperately needed.” So taking all bags would pretty much make her everyone’s target.
Thought the exact same thing 🙂 #Bookclub😂
Cinema Sins obviously didn’t read the book
This was DIRECTLY stated in the book. That it was deliberate that Foxface did not take anyone else's supplies because everyone would've gone for her. Cinemasins obviously didn't read the book.
@@rickole7404 Yeah, but at the same time cinema sins never considers the books (which honestly, fair, he’s rating it as a movie not just as a story). I was just pointing it out lol
@@rickole7404 ya and then there is the whole fox face purposely eating the night lock so she could go out on her own terms
The parts I always disliked of these movies, as compared to the books (I have read them a few times times) is that no one looks hungry, when in reality most are basically starving at home, the first movie makes it seem like Katniss was in the games a few days at most when it was weeks, and of course that you never get the aspect of katniss's inner dialog which you obviously can't do well in a movie. But her inner dialog is what really makes the series so special. She's a hero but she not the typical hero and she doesn't consider herself one at all. I wish the movies could have explored that a little more. And the hunger. No one seems hungry, at all lol
Katniss should have died after the 2nd movie if u being fr lol u can c in many scenes where she should have died but “magically” she doesn’t when everyone else does😂
@@ricchy404 just curious, have you read the books?
is no one going to mention how jeremy said "pretending as if josh hutcherson were not a dish."?
He predicted an epidemic
8:40 Why would they have security? That's the whole point; the districts are so under their heel nobody would dream of striking back. Katniss' "attack" is the whole reason they have the protective shield in Catching Fire.
as someone who has a hyperfixation on the hunger games currently (the books and movies) i enjoy having it brutally judged by one of my favourite channels. thank you for this re-sin :)
Same!
Katniss shoulda died many times in the movies u can tell they made her lucky on purpose by the directors
@@ricchy404 yea, but they also made it happen for reasons. they gave context towards why she survived most of it, as she could hunt well at home so it was easy to get food in the arena.
@@ricchy404 yeah plot armour i thought that aswell
its not plot armor, she was the most prepared to survive outside of the careers, and even more than them in terms of general survival instinct and ability to be self sustaining@@ricchy404
The anniversary re-sins are a good idea, especially when some of these original sin videos were shorter than 5 minutes. I bet there were plenty of other things to go back and re-sin that were missed the first time around.
can't wait for Dark Knight Rises re-sin. it's so much more full of sins than the original video gave it credit for!
prolly cause back then he didn't pad the run count with unnecessary garbage sins
Don’t forget Foxface. All three likable, minor characters were conveniently killed off - so that Katniss never has to kill anyone that the audience supports. Rue was killed by the trained psychopaths; Foxface ate poisonous berries; and Thresh was killed by the murder dogs.
Is the books, Thresh was actually killed by Cato(bless his pure soul) Rue was caught in a trap and Katniss failed to get to her in time before she was speared(bless her too) and Foxface ate the berries because she saw Peeta collecting them and thought they were safe. Night lock didn’t grow in her district so she had no idea they were poisonous. Don’t know why I’m commenting this.
@@valllll9470 Isn't it implied that she committed suicide because she had no chance at winning?
@@wasserruebenvergilbungsvirus Not in the books, no. Katniss said that Foxface was Peeta’s unintentional kill.
@@wasserruebenvergilbungsvirus it is a really popular fan theroy that has pretty much been wanted by everyone (really hope that Collins confirms)
Why is it important that she kills herself? Why can’t she just have eaten the berries on accident?
This movie has been out for a long time, and still every time Rue dies I cry. Well deserved sin 😭
Well deserved 10 sins 😭
her death in the book made me ugly cry. the movie.. didn't? i don't know how, probably because we get to see rue more in the book, gives us more time to get attached. in the movie, it felt like a fleeting moment
Me too :(
The fact that Rue actress is now a grown ass woman is hard to accept.
Okay so the reason Foxface only grabs her district five bag is actually quite clever and explained in the book. By immediately running to take her bag foxface gets what she needs but also leaves the other tributes at a crossroads. If they chase her, their bag will be stolen. So instead they all just leave her be because after all foxface only took her bag and the other tributes don’t want to risk losing their bag.
Rue’s odds being 7-1 is crazy considering the people that means she has a better chance of winning than. She’s pretty much right in line with all the career tributes and even better odds than her fellow district 11 competitor. You know the 18 year old strong man who’s almost 3x bigger than the 12 year old little girl.
Not jf you knew anything from the other 40+ hunger games or listened when they explained that most dont die from battle but incompetence of simple survival
She is smart, can climb the tallest trees and move undetected. She's also good at finding the right herbal medicine and she formed an alliance with Katniss, who is a strong contender.
Brute force isn't everything to survive the arena. Cunningness is as if not more important. She is the one who shows Katniss the wasps and also gives her the idea to cut the branch. She spies on the rest and knows where they are and what they're up to. She managed to survive on her own for days (weeks in the book) when other kids her age died the first 5 mins.
So yeah, she was one of the strong competitors.
5:40 she only gives up to thirty percent because 50% die at the very beginning of the games when they’re all rushing for the supplies. That leaves like 20% to die from combat and other things after the first day
Katniss missed the first shot in the skills showcase because she’s used to using the bow she made herself which is inaccurate so when she uses a bow that’s precise and accurate she misses the first time because she’s not used to a perfect bow. It explains it in the book.
it doesn’t say anything about her own bow (that her father actually made btw) being inaccurate. it’s simply made of different materials, with different tension etc.
There’s nothing about it being "inaccurate". It’s just not what she’s used to and she needs a few shots to get a feel for the weapon.
This movie always felt like they assumed everyone had read the book
The Amazing Spider-Man definitely needs a re-sin next month to celebrate 10 years of Cinema Sins, and the fact that it was the very first video on the channel
Was it really the first cinemasins video? That's wild. The first one i remember watching was their Kick-Ass video.
8:47 you missed the fact that every single tribute appears to not have a last name when caesar was annoucing the training scores except, of course, the main characters.
8:42 funnily enough, there's a special detail where those men are protected by a force field in the second book/movie because of her arrow shenanigans
Yes, they elevated security measures after Katniss shooting at them by putting force fields to prevent any contestents from pulling it off again. It was indeed an oversight on their part
That final sin was unexpected and absolutely hilarious. Well played sir.👏👏
10:57
The book does. If I’m not wrong Haymitch actually chooses to encourage Katniss over Peta, to better the odds
That’s actually revealed in Catching Fire.
I thought that's just the side effect of the first Perpektive in the books.
It actually makes a lot of sense that Glimmer and Cato would be joking about murder because they volunteered at the reaping. District 1 &2 willingly volunteer and train their whole lives to kill
Beisdes it could be there way to cope with things. Or to cover up how they truly feel.
Or they actually relish the thought of killing other districts for the fame and reward. Never forget Glimmer, was going to gleefully remodel Katniss
5 only took her own pack at the feast because:
- If she took someone else's pack, they would chase her
- She's not a fighter, so she knows she's dead if she gets caught in a straight fight
Anyone feel old after remembering Hunger Games when it first came out on cinema?
Can we please not talk about it. Now excuse me whilst I check my taxes 😩😩😩😩
@@leewolf6434 loser millennial needs to check his/her taxes
In the books, some of the more affluent districts do pretty much what you say. They train their children to fight so that when they're 18, the best volunteer. Katniss volunteering was a surprise to the viewers since the more malnourished districts understandably tend to perform worse than their more well off counterparts.
I maintain a Haymitch centered Hunger Games story about dealing with the mental toll of being a winner and then being forced to train/mentor future tributes would have been much more interesting than Peta and Katniss.
this is kinda like when the four book came out to be the end of the divergent series
Cinema Sins saying Haymitch is in a difficult spot trying to encourage both his entrants, even if they ultimately have to kill each other. It would be interesting to explore what that would do to you.....Serious alcoholism seems to be the answer.
I agree. Take out the whole revolution part of the story and focus more on how it affects the winners, tributes and their families and communities would have been 10x better. Also, keep the tyrannical government in power. It makes for a harsher ending. It's hard to believe a teenage girl with no training could be a better military leader than lifelong soldiers and overthrow an empire all before she could buy a beer.
@@brandocalrissian3294 In the books at least she is never really a leader. Her success in the games means she is used as a figurehead for the revolution but really she is just being used as a puppet by everyone who is actually controlling the war. Even her final act of assassinating the District 13 leader is something she is manipulated into by Snow in their final meeting.
his Games would be so interesting to see too, considering it was a quarter quell in which the amount of tributes was doubled. he pretty much waited until everyone else was dead but either way i would absolutely love a haymitch anthology or something of the like (not to mention woody harrelson was just perfect for the role
The mocking jay pin in the movie angers me to no end. They devalue it so bad compared to the book where she got it from the mayors daughter, the only person in the district who would even be able to afford to have one.
The final Pee-Nis joke made me laugh harder than I have in months, probably years. Thank you for that.
4:37 this one’s such a nitpicky sin but it’s absolutely hilarious and accurate. Wouldn’t they realistically use some sort of futuristic laser hair remover instead of wax strips? 😂
I'm guessing it's a way of being dicks to the poor kids being forced into a reality TV survival battle to the death. The rich and well off getting far easier hair removal procedures would be obvious.
@@bleakautomaton4808 I don’t think so, they treated them pretty good during their stays. They had them in luxury apartments, with famous designers, feasting on luxury food. I doubt they want to be dicks to them by making them get waxed. Plus when President Snow gets his hair cut they still use blades and shit so
@@changesme110yearsago9 I guess we could go with a second option of it somehow being a hipster thing. People in real life do what others may see as antiquated all the time, taking into account when this book was popular also I see this as an acceptable alternative as well.
@@bleakautomaton4808 I see that, honestly I think that we just give them too much credit. They weren’t really that advanced, they were just weird asf. The only thing that was super futuristic was the game arenas, aside from that they had all the same shit we do 😂
Would be good to see the re-sin count vs the first count and the rate of inflation
I always laughed in the movie when Katniss is in the tree and the careers are down on the ground..like they are supposed to be so deadly and dangerous yet not only were they unable to get her at the first attempt but they all just gave up and decided to wait her out? Didn't we earlier see Clove not miss a target with her knives? I get that it had to happen because Katniss couldn't just die there and then but even Glimmer..are you telling me she couldn't get Katniss with her bow and arrow? Why did Cato even do it when Glimmer is supposed to be skilled with a bow and arrow? 😅 I was always confused at this part haha
In the books, Katniss mentions that Glimer was basically a ditz, and that she used her beauty for support. She sucks at using the bow in the books aswell if I remember well.
But Glimmer isn’t skilled with a bow. Didn’t the movie show her miss while training?
Fair enough Glimmer isn't skilled with a bow😆 But as I also said Clove didn't miss a target with her knives. I love the hunger games series..I was just making the point that there were 4 careers in total and none of them were capable of getting Katniss with any weapon😅
I don't remember what it says in the books, but I think the tree is supposed to be much taller than it's depicted so perhaps the knives couldn't reach. It's hard to throw knives upwards.
@@Zopheri as I said in my original post, I always laughed in the movie. But yeah true, knives would be hard to throw upwards. My point was more, we have 4 careers that are from the 2 districts that are supposed to be the best yet in the movie we see Glimmer attempt one shot and Cato attempt to climb a tree and fail once, so they just give up..and that's always made me laugh😅
13:33 considering this is a movie and most of the details (like what sponsers are and stuff) are given to us by Katniss' inner monologues, Haymitch and the commentators are a great way of introducing the concepts to the non readers
6:00 I appreciate the implication here that Cinemasins is some kind of multiversal entity, like some version of The Watcher, that just watches and silently judges/sins things. Never taking any action about it, mind you, just casually sitting there and judging to themselves. It’s a thought that makes me smile, even if it doesn’t actually make any sense.
It makes perfect sense. That's kinda what they are
I love the compound v reference. all I could think of is Hughie disapperating and showing up somewhere naked
The books actually point out that taking everyone's present in the feast would draw the other Tributes after you even more than before, because the Tributes want their gifts back.
If you look at that fight between Katnis and Marvel she is actually really slow on the draw. He had the spear in Rue before her arrow was even fired.
The producers where meat riding her the whole series 😂she shouldn’t be alive from movie 2 frfr
this is because she'd just been deafened when blowing up the careers' supplies, so naturally her response time would be much slower
Well the thing with foxface grabbing her own bag was actually a really smart plan because no one would follow her out of fear of losing their own bag
I realized a few weeks ago that I've been watching this channel since the Prometheus video and it blew my mind a little, this truly have become a part of my life
Thats actually a good one for a re-sin since it started the running joke they use of the "prometheus school of running away from things"
Only gripe I have? The commentary on teenagers being a lot more likely to be giddy about killing someone. Teenagers are still in the developmental stages where they're deciding their own personal code of ethics and morality while still being VERY impressionable, so it's actually very much easier to influence teenagers to willingly, even gleefully, murder people than it is a full grown adult who has decided that's a line they're not willing to cross.
Also keep in mind that plenty of teenagers are edgy and think harming people is fun.
@@Kuronii01 precisely.
Not to mention the fact that these certain kids that are laughing about killing people actually volunteered to be tributes. Its the careers for christ sake.
These kids attended a school that taught them/prepared them to volunteer as tributes. At the end Cato kinda figures things out for himself and he has some dialogue about it all
Not to forget, they just did it, they didn’t have time to process it. Joking and laughing about it might as well be their way of dealing with it, especially after the first of them started with it. Makes it less meaningful, makes it easier. Who knows how they would have felt about it after the games if any of them had survived. But none of them lived long enough to get out of the situation I’m the arena.
The only one who even lived long enough to (at least openly) realize the games were messed up was Cato and at that point he was completely alone and knew he was going to die. Interestingly enough, he chose not to kill Peeta when he could have - would have made no difference for him, he would have died either way and he knew it. But the others never got to that point and none of them could ever reevaluate the games after getting out of them. We can only speculate about how they would have felt about it afterwards.
Also, the comparison between the military and the careers makes no sense, not only because the careers are still kids and soldiers aren’t. Soldiers don’t train from childhood on, they don’t grow up with the knowledge that they’ll be in an arena with 23 other people and only one will survive one day, most soldiers are pretty normal people. The careers, on the other hand, are brainwashed enough to volunteer for those crazy games where only one out of 24 will survive. They are already completely messed up when they enter the arena. It would make no sense for them to act like normal teenagers and definitely not to act like normal adults with a strong moral code.
I was clapping and laughing so hard on that 5 sins for the sweetheart. Was exactly what I was yelling at the screen watching you go over it.👏🏼😂
7:19 absolutely killed me.
"Pretending as if Josh Hutcherson were not a dish."
Also, the idea of the four tributes from District One and District Two working together in harmony seems shaky to me. Yes, it’s easier to survive in a group. However, these three people are also your biggest threats - and the movie goes out of its way to portray these kids as evil. So, it doesn’t seem like they would care about loyalty to each other.
At the very least, the movie could throw in a few lines about some kind of code. For example, maybe they’re trained to work as a pack - and, then, when it’s just them left, they divide up and hunt each other. With the info that we’re given, I feel like at least one of them would seize an opportunity to betray and kill off the group.
What really makes no sense is that the other districts don't have some sort of agreement to team up, even between their own two tributes a lot of the time it seems. They're mostly just happy to run off solo and let the careers hunt them down one by one.
It seemed so much more convincing in the books. Have you read them?
The careers were portrayed less evil there and not completely cold. It’s been a while since I read them, but I remember when Clove died Cato begged her to stay with him, while in the movie they only show the careers’ cruel sides.
I also think it was explained in the books they had this understanding to work together until the others were dead - every year the tributes from the career districts would do so, it was known to everyone. I suppose if one of them would betray another the tribute would be the next target of all the careers left so it wouldn’t be wise to betray another career. They also tried to hunt Peeta down when he betrayed them, but again, the book explained it much better. They should have taken a bit more time for that, just a few minutes.
@@Diana-qp2rw I have read the books and agree they flesh out much more how the teaming up of the careers is a well established thing that happens every time. Also as you say, almost any kid in this situation, trained or otherwise, is going to be traumatised by killing each other like this.
I was just observing that it seemed like a failing in the books and films that none of the other tributes teamed up as well, from a tactical perspective it would make overwhelming sense to have at least a small team. Seems like this would have to be organised informally as there is no established teaming up other than the careers, but I would have been working on that pretty much the entire time they had training. Get a team in place so we can work together to give ourselves a chance against the careers.
I say no-one else did it, but clearly Katniss and Rue did join up, so it obviously wasn't prohibited. There are problems down the line about when the coalition breaks, does it hold till just they are left or does someone backstab before then etc, but fundamentally a team has a much much higher chance of surviving it would seem.
I think the reason it’s rare for other districts to form alliances is the same it’s rare for them to volunteer. Most of them are completely clueless in terms of survival, have no hope of winning and are frightened of everyone else. Also, forming an alliance means you have to trust someone enough not to be backstabbed and be prepared for the idea to get to know someone (and humanize them) and maybe have to kill them later.
This is why Katniss couldn’t let Peeta die after all, she didn’t even had to kill him, his leg wounds would bleed him to death on its own, but couldn’t allow this to happen after she spent days humanizing him (I know there is their past history to consider as well, but that didn’t stop her earlier in the ganes to throw a nest at his general direction)
The careers don’t mind forming an alliance because they are completely brainwashed into buying the whole show, they volunteer and seem proud of being in the show, unlike anyone else
You should probably watch a few episodes of "Survivor".
This situation occurs multiple times each season.
Katniss just wanted to go for a walk.
A very enthusiastic walk.
Oh look...a fellow TFS fan out in the wild.
This is a deep cut that I respect the hell out of
And she's sorry about shooting the career. But if he looks deep into his heart... which is currently all over that tree
is this some kind of reference? i don't get it
This was my first Sins video, 10 years of excelent work!
16:42 "I think about that all the time. How I tossed you that bread." "Peeta." "No whole wheat."
😭😭😭
12:58 Jeremy doesn’t know what a scabbard is. DING!
Gideon doesn't know what a joke is. DING!
@@Grim_Beard Sorry! Only kidding.
“This gave Jeffery bazos the idea for flying drones, and giving Jeffery bazos an idea is ALWAYS a sin” made me laugh
12:15 well different from soldiers, these people are conditioned from a very young age where they are way more impresionable and it easier to install concepts such as being okay with murder
4:54
Just now realized those two actors played scientists in Captain America (Dr. Zola and Dr. Erskine)
I’ve been watching you for 10 years and your sense of humor has never gone stale. Keep up the good work mate
I love how in the original video, the narrator was crushing on Gale, and hating Peeta, and in this one it's the other way around. 😂
19:16 "This celebrity couple's name is Pee-niss" - God damn dude, that hit perfectly. It caught me completely off guard and had me legit irl chuckling.
Rue’s score went up because she showed them how high and easily she could climb therefore staying out of the way and hiding. So they figured she would be hard to catch and find
Cinemasins launched my personal movie critiques and it will always have a special place in my heart. Time flys but you guys haven’t missed a single step, keep it up!
7:55 to be fair district 3 centers around being tech nerds, while 1 2 and 4 are the districts with career tributes
I told my wife to read the book before we saw the film so she would be ready for Rue's death, but she never got around to it. Then when that happened, she was about ready to get up out of the theater and leave.
As a 12 year old black girl who watched on opening weekend without having ever read the books, Rue's death hit me so hard that I was actually shaking- I wasn't even sad-crying, I was scared-crying. My mom was holding me and telling me "it's okay, it's just a movie" with tears clearly running down her own face. That remained the largest emotional bitch-slap I'd ever gotten from a movie until 10 years later with Black Panther: Wakanda Forever, when I, a 22 year old part Kenyan neuroscience/data science major named Zuri who had lost my mother Rhonda, went to see it while already exhausted and was stunned by Queen Ramonda's death like I'd been punched in the face. Some movies just stay with you forever, and usually it's because of things lile this.
6:41 in the book it’s implied that Peeta purposefully burnt the bread so he could throw it to Katniss since his mom wouldn’t sale it knowing the consequences that his mom would beat him for burning it.
Been waiting for this one to get redone ever since the longer videos, so excited about it
18:13 iirc the book has Thresh die in battle with Cato
16:15 That camouflage was so good, it would take a cast of skilled makeup artists to even pull it off. But PETA did it on the fly, blind, AND bleeding to death.
Just hahahahahahaha....hahahahaha.
17:13 ok the book nerd in me has to say, in the books its explained she did this because stealing others bags would have them chase after her. She grabbed it before everyone else, and because she didnt bother the others, they let her leave.
Once again, the amount of sins here that are explained in the are insane
@17:19 for example, the girl from 5 didn't want to be followed, she was surviving by running away
@7:56 career districts
About Foxface (around 6:07) I’ve recently been thinking that she was matching poisonous plants with their antidotes for some reason
It was a reflex test
we can call the entire month of may, Mocking May, and then a random person is assigned to be mocked.
It’s funny you talk about Hunger Games fans trying to turn the odd days in May into a holiday for Reaping Day because Suzanne Collins has said that the reaping takes place on the 4th of July. So if we wanted to celebrate Reaping Day that would technically be the day to do it.
Just throwing it out there, the demon dogs were supposed to have the dead tributes’ faces to mentally screw with the remaining survivors while they tear them apart
8:50 The Hughie joke is just perfection 😂
Foxface only took her own pack because she knew taking anyone else's would make them chase her and potentially kill her
i just imagine the foxface girl spitting the berries up when katniss yells “you’ll be dead in a minute” saying “they fucking what???”
LOL....she didn't do the leaf-thing to attract the deer(I mean, what would the mechanism be: "Oh, shredded leaves, even before they come to my mouth. Delicious!!"). She checked for the direction of the wind to see if the deer would be upwind and not be able to smell her if she approachd from that direction.
Never thought about but I’ve really been watching this channel for over a decade
6:41 he burned it intentionally so he could give the bread to katniss
14:51 went from a background character whos purpose is to die immediately to an Mc...well done
1:20 you MAY hate May the 4th but the Revenge of the 5th is even worse
1:30 No, they're only treating it as special because it's a recognizable symbol attached to Katniss, the hope for the rebellion.
There are so many good lines that I'm dying. "Don't bring a knife to an exposure fight." I'll be proud if these are the last words I ever type.
What a good reference to Bodies, Bodies, Bodies with Rue because Amandla later starred as the lead in that film!
By the way, the “a motherless child” thing is Snow referring to himself. He lost his mother.
“I watched you going home everyday… EVERY. DAY.”
I laughed a lot harder at the “Pee-nis” joke than I should have
to me this is a big improvement on the original. more clever lines, where the other one just felt like a few minutes of "this is stupid. this is also stupid. I don't understand this therefore this is stupid". Good job!
@8:53 🤣🤣🤣 thank you! I haven't seen this movie in years and as soon as his face came on the screen at 8:45 I was like waaaaait... Is that???
“Pretending as if Josh Hutcherson were not a dish” 😭
The nostalgia of watching this in 2012 on mom's iPad
I remember watching this back on free form back in 2013 after watching Catching Fire on rental. Good times
Now it's "No movie without RE-sin??"
Surprised he didn’t sin Cato snapping that one kid’s neck which is physically impossible to do with that much ease