Everywhere at the End of Time - ULTIMATE Heartaches Comparison

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 30 июн 2024
  • (k this is the last time I'm re-making this thing)
    For more information and how I made this video, check out The Caretaker Wiki!
    thecaretaker.fandom.com/wiki/...
    0:00 - Al Bowlly Version
    • Al Bowlly: Heartaches
    1:22 - Seger Ellis Version
    • Seger Ellis - Heartach...
    2:25 - Guy Lombardo Version
    • Guy Lombardo - Heartac...
    3:26 - A1 - It's just a burning memory
    4:21 - C3 - What does it matter how my heart breaks
    5:00 - E2 - And Heart Breaks
    5:41 - F4 - Burning Despair Does Ache
    6:24 - F5 - Aching Cavern Without Lucidity
    7:44 - F8 - Mournful Cameraderie
    8:29 - Post Awareness intro
    8:35 - G1 - Post Awareness Confusions 1 (G1SB)
    9:23 - G1 - Post Awareness Confusions 1 (G1SE)
    9:51 - H1 - Post Awareness Confusions 2 (H1SC)
    10:48 - K1 - Advanced Plaque Entanglements 1 (K1SE)
    11:04 - L1 - Advanced Plaque Entanglements 2 (L1SB1)
    11:13 - L1 - Advanced Plaque Entanglements 2 (L1SB2)
    11:22 - L1 - Advanced Plaque Entanglements 2 (L1SC)
    11:27 - M1 - Synapse Retrogenesis (M1SA1)
    11:41 - M1 - Synapse Retrogenesis (M1SC)
    11:48 - M1 - Synapse Retrogenesis (M1SC)
    12:01 - M1 - Synapse Retrogenesis (M1SA2)
    12:15 - EAEB - Entanglement Synapse Ache
    12:33 - O1 - A Confusion so Thick you Forget Forgetting (O1SC)
    I own nothing.
    Support The Caretaker here: thecaretaker.bandcamp.com/
  • ВидеоклипыВидеоклипы

Комментарии • 520

  • @ninaone9390
    @ninaone9390 3 года назад +1298

    Why is there so many burning memories get the fire extinguisher

    • @ggrab4114
      @ggrab4114 3 года назад +34

      Oh god the fire

    • @kasiakeen3734
      @kasiakeen3734 3 года назад +17

      AAH FIRE blasts water on fires with a hose

    • @Memerath
      @Memerath 3 года назад +58

      we don’t have many days to extinguish the fire c’mon guys

    • @cycoekiller119
      @cycoekiller119 3 года назад +19

      ... Fire? Whats that? Should I be worried?

    • @leafyclass
      @leafyclass 3 года назад +21

      @@Memerath yeah just go back benjamin

  • @trstnap
    @trstnap 3 года назад +1586

    People dont get what dementia is. They just say "Imagine one day you wake up and don't remember your family" Thats not it. At first you just mildly forget the names of people you love. It doesn't matter, you associate it with old age and you can still remember who they are. You then begin to forget their names more than you remember. You then begin to forget ABOUT them. You forget what grade they were in school, how old they are, but you may still remember THEM. After this point, it becomes a huge haze for them. They don't just wake up and forget everything. That's the scariest part.

    • @TheTinyDiamond
      @TheTinyDiamond 3 года назад +109

      That haze is the worst/best part I'd imagine, because I've always said I'd kill myself before succumbing to dementia, but by the time the haze set in and I _would_ have killed myself it'd be too late bc I'd've lost self awareness. The "forgetting details about people" stage is really the last point to catch that shit and go easy isn't it?

    • @blendyboi5023
      @blendyboi5023 3 года назад +34

      And then they mix the details about them

    • @carbonated_1304
      @carbonated_1304 3 года назад +21

      I'd honestly rather kill myself then have to live through dementia. The moment I hear I have dementia I'll say my goodbyes

    • @KOTEBANAROT
      @KOTEBANAROT 3 года назад +81

      Many dementia patients confuse their kids with their siblings and stuff. They remember love; they dont remember when exactly they loved this person, they get misplaced in time

    • @harod4656
      @harod4656 3 года назад +23

      Damn, so it must be hurtful for your family knowing your slowly straying your mind away from them.

  • @asskicka71
    @asskicka71 3 года назад +1027

    i actually can believe it’s just a burning memory...

    • @Imboredwithmylife
      @Imboredwithmylife 3 года назад +24

      I get it

    • @happypercussionist1
      @happypercussionist1 3 года назад +6

      I literally cannot but at the same time I can believe it's just a burning memory

    • @mrjr7984
      @mrjr7984 3 года назад +1

      Bruuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuh

    • @averanger
      @averanger 3 года назад +1

      cool

    • @LadyFurina24
      @LadyFurina24 3 года назад +1

      @@eldritchlemon but our hearts aren't on fire

  • @sorrelk6926
    @sorrelk6926 3 года назад +658

    I remember when my grandfather was bedridden from his alzheimers. He was gonna die in less than 3 days and grandma let me facetime him so i could say i love you one last time. I told him how much i loved him and he smiled for the first time since he was bedridden, and my voice was the last thing he smiled at before he died.

    • @ThePaupepa
      @ThePaupepa 3 года назад +52

      Damn, that's actually heartbreaking...

    • @KnellMortem
      @KnellMortem 3 года назад +65

      That right there’ll give you heartaches.

    • @t.487
      @t.487 3 года назад +36

      I hope the moment atleast filled you with a bit of joy before his passing. I hope the best for you.

    • @spycrab3723
      @spycrab3723 3 года назад +20

      Damn, that hurts. I hope your grandpa stays happy in heaven.

    • @foure2833
      @foure2833 3 года назад +3

      RIP

  • @leonardoaaronduenas4207
    @leonardoaaronduenas4207 3 года назад +760

    I love how it represents people with dementia, who listen to the original version but their disease makes it distort and change

    • @tadeath1697
      @tadeath1697 3 года назад +17

      si, es increible. The care taker hizo un trabajo hermoso

    • @condor2279
      @condor2279 3 года назад +38

      @@pedrofile2electricboogaloo58 It's Spanish

    • @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838
      @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 3 года назад +27

      @@pedrofile2electricboogaloo58 their post says "Yes, it's incredible. The Caretaker did a wonderful job"

    • @kimilsung8010
      @kimilsung8010 3 года назад +28

      I'm sorry, but I think you are missing the point. The songs represent memories, and the dementia slowly distort and entangle the different elements of the songs, as dementia does with normal memories. The 'Heartaches' probably represent the partner of the dementia victim, which would be logical because it is the most repeated song in this album.
      So dementia is not some filter that distorts music, but more the degredation of the brain and the inablity to correctly remember memories, and a whole lot of other symptoms of course.
      However I do agree that it is a masterpiece, although I do not 'love it how' it represents dementia.

    • @leonardoaaronduenas4207
      @leonardoaaronduenas4207 3 года назад +6

      @@kimilsung8010 well i think not beacuse im saying that our víctim that has dementia distort the music, AND the music are Like the memories, so going to that lógic im saying that the victim has a memorie and keep distorting It.

  • @H1PP1E88
    @H1PP1E88 3 года назад +901

    I like how their dementia is represented by the song titles changing into renditions of what they were. For example, heartaches and it's just a burning memory turn into burning despair does ache and so on

    • @cloudnite_vr
      @cloudnite_vr 3 года назад +28

      I didn’t even freaking realize that

    • @roux6715
      @roux6715 2 года назад +27

      What else that’s great about the name(just a burning memory) is that since it’s a line from the original song, it’s like they can’t remember much of the song, so they just took a part they do remember and named it that

    • @Project_lostmediafinder
      @Project_lostmediafinder 2 года назад +2

      @@roux6715 Burning memory?-

    • @namacator
      @namacator 2 года назад +8

      The song heartaches has a part where it says "I can't believe it's just a burning memory"

    • @deanos32
      @deanos32 Год назад +1

      I forgot liking this comment 💀

  • @tails183
    @tails183 3 года назад +319

    Someone feels proud hearing "Heartaches" in later stages and here you are demanding to know WHOSE in each part.

    • @tails183
      @tails183 Год назад +3

      Man, a couple years later and people have gotten way more extreme than this video.

    • @StridersBored
      @StridersBored 9 месяцев назад

      @@tails183I love these videos. I’m tryna find more of them. Recommend any?

  • @zeNUKEify
    @zeNUKEify 3 года назад +282

    A1: Very faithful to the description of the stage. It’s nostalgic. Slightly distorted but overall still positive.
    C3: Noticeably sadder. The notes drag. The pitch shifts down an octave. It’s tired and malnourished. Not cheerful at all.
    C4: Anxiety, borderline fear. The melody is dominated by a rising tension in the background . The distortion is more severe with sudden echoing. The music becomes confused but maintains its form.
    F4: A constant stream of confused, jumbled melancholy. The music jumps and stalls; the connections have disintegrated considerably. The song is broken.
    F5: Silence, ambient noise. White noise. Neither tranquil nor fearful.
    F8: The melody is barely there. It’s dominated by a dull, calm ringing.
    G1SB: The melody is irreversibly damaged. Snippets of the song remain in the confused garble, intertwined and entangled in noise. It’s active.
    G1SE: Noticeably more fear and lower overall mood. Repetitive, snippets of the original song
    H1SC: Low and calmer confusion. Sounds of a deep abyss with wild disconnected noise.
    Almost nothing of the original song exists beyond this point

  • @EditorSquare.
    @EditorSquare. 3 года назад +174

    Dude said
    “How much quality you want”
    this man said “yes”

  • @youraftermyrobotbee
    @youraftermyrobotbee 3 года назад +262

    i respect and fear anyone who can sift through the post awareness stages and pick actual samples out of it

    • @subliminalhotellyn_tbhc6036
      @subliminalhotellyn_tbhc6036 Год назад +9

      Honestly, same.

    • @danielpridemore3997
      @danielpridemore3997 Год назад

      If they can somehow dredge through hours of 2 channels of noise to find these samples then they are a step ahead towards conquering dementia

    • @EdgeM_Peezy
      @EdgeM_Peezy Год назад +8

      I used to agree, but after listening to it enough times the true horror of it is lessened, you mostly just listen for samples in the white noise

  • @tacwedie9898
    @tacwedie9898 3 года назад +323

    Imagine that you Once Heard these songs and liked it, And forgot about it, Then you listen to everywhere at the end of time, a album about Dementia, and realize something familiar with the songs but you don't remember, That would be really scary.

    • @MarkosKapox
      @MarkosKapox 3 года назад +11

      Oh god

    • @Delita45
      @Delita45 3 года назад +22

      That's literally me with every album someone shows me.
      It fucking sucks never being able to recall anything yet knowing a lot of what comes next and swearing you heard it somewhere, but unable to verify it

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад +5

      It would be more hurtful if you recognized the songs pkaying, but alter on PA stages it feel akwardly familiar, leaving you dazed.

    • @dianaburn2474
      @dianaburn2474 Год назад +2

      Thing is, that actually happened with me a bit. There's an orchestral suite used as a sample in the album, specifically the Grand Canyon Suite. Uses Painted Desert, Sunrise, and Sunset. I know I've heard these songs at least partially before, but didn't realize it until I was looking up samples...
      But, it happens. Especially when you listen to a lot of music!

    • @launderine
      @launderine 4 месяца назад

      the real dementia was inside us all along

  • @bobbysteele4639
    @bobbysteele4639 3 года назад +115

    "My connection isn't bad!"
    Their connection: 5:41

    • @Leo-rl7qi
      @Leo-rl7qi 3 года назад +16

      "myyyyyyy- co *______* ion ins't baaaaaaaaaa-d!"

    • @i_am_secretly_uncool
      @i_am_secretly_uncool 2 года назад +13

      Mario maker 2 online

    • @Nooahtroll19
      @Nooahtroll19 2 года назад +8

      @@i_am_secretly_uncool this is probably the funniest joke ive heard about eateot

    • @i_am_secretly_uncool
      @i_am_secretly_uncool 2 года назад +6

      @@Nooahtroll19 thank you :)

    • @ortherner
      @ortherner 2 года назад +6

      7:45

  • @therock1160
    @therock1160 3 года назад +67

    how ironic, I was just updating the Wikipedia page of the album by adding more info about heartaches

  • @mos_thoser1886
    @mos_thoser1886 3 года назад +171

    my smile literally turned to a frown when i heard A1

    • @tilsgee
      @tilsgee 3 года назад +9

      @@pedrofile2electricboogaloo58 yeah. R.IP al bowlly
      Who died by a fcking bomb >:(
      (I angry to those nutze. Not you :3)

    • @Luka2000_
      @Luka2000_ 3 года назад +5

      @@tilsgee his door caved his head in...

    • @gooolixx
      @gooolixx 3 года назад +6

      @@Luka2000_ yeah and his door fell because of a bomb

    • @cometcal7387
      @cometcal7387 2 года назад +2

      @sunrise it makes sense now.....Beaten by a door.....People frowned after.....

    • @cometcal7387
      @cometcal7387 2 года назад +1

      @sunrise I know, and it makes sense....

  • @shriki21
    @shriki21 3 года назад +110

    funny little quirk, at around 8:55 seger ellis plays clearly in the right and bowlly in the left ear channels

    • @justinsamuda727
      @justinsamuda727 3 года назад +22

      really good ear! the amount of detail put into this project is insane, and even crazier is the amount of work people will do to uncover funny little quirks like these. you know you've done something monumental when people pour hours into finding all the little hidden secrets

    • @zaries357
      @zaries357 2 года назад +4

      Almost all of stage 4 of not all has 2 songs playing at the same time 1 on the right channel and 1 on the left channel.

  • @RubyPiec
    @RubyPiec 3 года назад +481

    Lyrics:
    Al Bowlly (part shown in video) -
    Heartaches, heartaches!
    My loving you meant only heartaches
    your kiss was such a sacred thing to me
    I can't believe it's just a burning memory
    Heartaches, Heartaches!
    What does it matter how my heart breaks?
    I should be happy with someone new
    But my heart aches for you!
    Seger Ellis (part shown in video) -
    Heartaches, heartaches!
    What does it matter how my heart breaks?
    I should be happy with someone new.
    But my heart aches for you!
    Guy Lombardo (part shown in video) -
    (instrumental)
    A1 (if it had lyrics) -
    Heartaches, heartaches!
    My loving you meant only heartaches
    your kiss was such a sacred thing to me
    I can't believe it's just a burning memory
    Heartaches, Heartaches!
    What does it matter how my heart breaks?
    I should be happy with someone new
    But my heart aches for you!
    C3 -
    Heartaches, Heartaches!
    What does it matter how my heart breaks?
    your kiss was such a sacred thing to me...
    I can't believe it's just a burning memory!!
    E2 -
    Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me
    I can't believe it's just a burning memory
    Heartaches, heartaches!
    What does it matter how my heart breaks?
    I should be happy with someone new
    But my heart aches for you...
    F4 -
    Heartaches, heartaches...
    matter how my heart breaks???
    I I should be happy with with with with someone new
    I can't can't believe can't cant it's just a burning memory
    F5 -
    (instrumental) {SERIOUSLY, HO WDID ANYONE FIGURE OUT THIS WAS HEARTACHES?!}
    F8 -
    Heartaches, Heartaches
    matter how my heart breaks?????
    I I should be happy with new
    I can't can't burning memory
    G1 -
    Heartaches
    what does it matter how my heart breaks?
    Heartaches
    what does it matter how my heart breaks?
    G1 -
    (instrumental)
    H1 -
    heartaches
    K1 -
    [F8 playing faintly in the background]
    L1 -
    [F8 playing faintly in the background]
    L1 -
    [F8 playing faintly in the background]
    L1 -
    Heartaches
    M1 -
    [F8 playing faintly in the background]
    M1 -
    Heartaches
    M1 -
    [F8 playing faintly in the background]
    M1 -
    Heart
    M1 -
    [Heartaches by Seger Ellis]
    EAEB 16 -
    music
    O1.

    • @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838
      @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 3 года назад +18

      Interesting

    • @djscarlet169
      @djscarlet169 3 года назад +53

      F5 - it's just a distant and very slow instrumental, it's the feeling of "it's there but you don't know exactly what it is"

    • @RubyPiec
      @RubyPiec 3 года назад +11

      @@djscarlet169 yeah, true

    • @r3strt
      @r3strt 3 года назад +18

      in L1, i feel like the lyrics would've been "such a sacred thi-"

    • @beauboi3381
      @beauboi3381 3 года назад +5

      Your peach was such a snake racing to me,

  • @bigbat69
    @bigbat69 3 года назад +233

    Honestly I feel like the last thing we would forget would be love or loss. I think we all have those moments and they made us, us. I feel like the caretaker was desperately trying remember his love even if it was twisted. Eventually however he lost that too.

    • @marz8386
      @marz8386 3 года назад +16

      Hearing the tune from Heartaches echo in the beginning of stage four puts that into perspective. The Caretaker desperately didn't want to forget his love

    • @masonthechemistryfreak6894
      @masonthechemistryfreak6894 3 года назад +11

      @@marz8386 It's even more heartbreaking how Heartaches isn't the last thing The Caretaker remembers, playing for the last time in A confusion so thick you forget forgetting

    • @misodent9794
      @misodent9794 3 года назад +12

      love or loss you say?
      | | | l
      | | | _

    • @Cloud_Strife1997
      @Cloud_Strife1997 3 года назад +6

      @@misodent9794 you did it. you madman, you actually did it.

    • @grandmasteryoda2605
      @grandmasteryoda2605 3 года назад +5

      @@misodent9794 *looks at four panel comic*
      Heh, is this Loss?
      *handed comedy award, flowers, gets kissed by his highschool sweetheart, handed a bottle of champagne.*

  • @LARADEKA
    @LARADEKA 3 года назад +77

    *_Mournful Camaraderie is the "goodbye", the final moments. Well, until Stage 4 - 5 forces you to FLEX THOSE BINAURAL HEARINGS OR ELSE YOU'LL CRIPPLE INTO INSANITY._*
    _The whole album was SO good they made use of the effects to represent every single aspect..._

    • @jackpijjin4088
      @jackpijjin4088 3 года назад +8

      The effort and care Kirby put into the 'aural storytelling' of these albums is what's by far the most lacking thing in the 'Caretaker-like' fan albums. It's more than 'old songs', it's 'memories as old songs and how they break down'.

    • @user-yy5di3qg5u
      @user-yy5di3qg5u 2 месяца назад

      @@jackpijjin4088 So all of them (judging by your statement) lacks that (and probably other stuff too)? I understand that fan works are usually statistically bellow official works in terms of quality and etc. but you could explain your comment in details (better late than never, eh).

  • @titaniumvulpes
    @titaniumvulpes 3 года назад +148

    As I listened to EATEOT, every time this song replayed it made me think of my great grandmother, especially the Stage 5 and 6 repetitions. I never met her, and my mom was very young when she got sick, but my mom's told me about her Alzheimer's. Apparently near the end, my great grandmother always thought my mom was my grandmother. She still _knew_ she had a daughter, but couldn't recognise her actual daughter as such, she thought her granddaughter was her daughter, because her memories had degraded so much that she could only vaguely remember her daughter as the concept of a child. But even at the very end, she still remembered that she had a daughter.
    That's the sort of thing I think the repetition of this song, more and more broken each time, represents. A child or a spouse, hell maybe even a pet or a job (I've seen all of these in dementia patients), something that is such an innate part of your person that they're still part of you even after you've forgotten everything else, even when you can't really remember _them_ anymore - just what part of you they became. The final star to burn out when your universe ends.

    • @modo69
      @modo69 3 года назад +1

      😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

    • @kajlihalilovic4438
      @kajlihalilovic4438 3 года назад +3

      Holy shit, this comment brought tears to my eyes. Thank you for sharing, OP. This is beautiful.

    • @gabiferreira6864
      @gabiferreira6864 2 года назад +2

      beautifully written

  • @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838
    @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 3 года назад +85

    I love how you can clearly hear it in Stage 5, but it's so distorted you can't recognize it

  • @mhum02
    @mhum02 3 года назад +65

    I still can't hear F5's rendition of Heartaches, I was in disbelief when I found out that that song sampled it.

    • @Derpy_fish63
      @Derpy_fish63 3 года назад +9

      I honestly can only truly recognize the first note. It feels like an echo chamber with just a few of the notes, along with sounds that make me feel like I'm in an underwater cave. Spooky stuff.

    • @grbr2006
      @grbr2006 3 года назад +5

      @@Derpy_fish63
      that's why it's called "aching *cavern* without lucidity"

    • @vinnytheplayer5500
      @vinnytheplayer5500 2 года назад +1

      I cant hear any heartaches at all after stage 4 expect for stage 6 when sped up

  • @ALE199-ita
    @ALE199-ita 3 года назад +46

    How the hell does a man sit listening to a 6 hour song just to get all the referances to ONE song.

    • @thevoidcritter
      @thevoidcritter 2 года назад +10

      It's a set of 6 different albums, so I imagine it's easier if you break it into chunks and listen to one at a time

    • @WereComingHomeBoyes
      @WereComingHomeBoyes 5 месяцев назад +1

      Those are 4.5 hrs of identifying heartaches from 6.5. First 3 stages are obvious

  • @poliwazawaza55
    @poliwazawaza55 3 года назад +19

    Fun fact
    Al Bowly
    AL
    AI
    A1 (its just a burning memory)

  • @777Rowen
    @777Rowen 3 года назад +207

    This song feels like Everywhere at the End of Time’s theme song showing the stages of dementia and how it deteriorates the mind. It’s the song that always stood out to me, and funny enough there’s actually 7 stages to dementia so this fits perfectly. Well done. 👏

    • @TheBert.
      @TheBert. 3 года назад +17

      This still works because stage 1 of dementia is nothing.

    • @bella_ciao4608
      @bella_ciao4608 3 года назад +24

      Yeah there’s 7 stages but the first stage is before the dementia causes any symptoms, so it’d be pretty hard to make an album like that, so it’d make sense to start where the symptoms begin.

    • @ortherner
      @ortherner 2 года назад +1

      you mean 7 stages of alzheimers. Dementia is a umbrella term for diseases that slowly kills neurons in the brain. Alzheimers happens to be the most common form of dementia.

    • @777Rowen
      @777Rowen 2 года назад

      @@ortherner Yes. Thanks for clarifying

  • @bigbaby1345
    @bigbaby1345 3 года назад +82

    its insane how you can clearly make out heartaches at 8:54

    • @defcool1889
      @defcool1889 3 года назад +12

      Yeah I think it’s because it’s still the first stage of post-awareness

    • @Lucian7066
      @Lucian7066 2 года назад +5

      And 11:44

    • @bigbaby1345
      @bigbaby1345 2 года назад

      @@Lucian7066 most certainly not

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад

      The first track of post awareness.

    • @carolrose2078
      @carolrose2078 2 года назад +1

      @@bigbaby1345 look at the red box. And hear a bit closer

  • @Chaseee_
    @Chaseee_ 3 года назад +24

    0.75x to hear it’s just a burning memory on original heartaches and 1.25 on it’s just a burning memory to hear heartaches

  • @LoG_9961
    @LoG_9961 2 года назад +18

    from heartaches to heart breaks to heart attacks

  • @kikisakura8189
    @kikisakura8189 2 года назад +39

    The scariest part of dementia has to be near the end. through the haze that has replaced your mind, you suddenly start to remember again. all the fun stuff you lived through and you finally remember your favorite song in full. blissful happiness before the end. terminal lucidity.
    but it's happy to know that my grandmother did remember me at least a little the last I saw her.

  • @SoraTheBlackie
    @SoraTheBlackie 3 года назад +46

    So my theory was right! At first I thought each song that played in the first stage was heartaches and then maybe different songs by Al Bowlly But I listened to thw album again and realized that The people who have dementia can only remember ONE song So it is Heartaches constantly repeating just slowly getting messed up until you can't even recognize it anymore

    • @superguy9834
      @superguy9834 3 года назад

      What?

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад +4

      @@superguy9834 dementia patients remember music the most. (Music, the power of mind!) Likely their fav music.
      So thats heartaches

  • @evanb2123
    @evanb2123 3 года назад +19

    Heart attacks

  • @Ponsy_J
    @Ponsy_J 3 года назад +42

    It's sad how the the notes of the song not only get smaller, but less recognizable...

  • @colemak5646
    @colemak5646 3 года назад +81

    F8s name is Mournful Cameraderie, The Caretaker purposely misspelt it

  • @aeyehm1816
    @aeyehm1816 3 года назад +27

    i think stage 3 is when it stops sounding like heartaches.

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад +7

      For me its when it stops being an love song and it becomes an actual heartache for the patient and its family.

    • @bovineking8927
      @bovineking8927 2 года назад +2

      Yep. Early stage 3 still sounds like it, but starting with F4...nah

  • @bonelessbones2934
    @bonelessbones2934 3 года назад +22

    the name “it’s just a burning memory” works really well for stage 1, because out of context from the original lyrics, it’s as if the patient forgot something and thought nothing much of it

  • @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838
    @finjaquetemumnomeaqui4838 3 года назад +31

    To hear Heartaches in F5, speed it up by about 1.5x and try remembering the Melody of C3 in your head

    • @grbr2006
      @grbr2006 3 года назад +6

      haha
      "remembering"

    • @dashainfernich
      @dashainfernich 3 года назад +4

      maybe in 1.75x? better hear heartaches with this speed

    • @NeilDjents
      @NeilDjents 2 года назад

      I forgo 🗿

  • @malfunctionnnn
    @malfunctionnnn 3 года назад +31

    listening to everywhere at the end of time when you've heard it a few times before is like rewatching a film after learning all the mistakes and easter eggs. you can sort of listen to it and think "hey, there's heartaches again!" during the post-awareness stages. i find it really interesting

  • @javivaki
    @javivaki 3 года назад +47

    WTF, I never processed C3 in G1SB despite it being the most obvious. Great work on this one.

    • @Derpy_fish63
      @Derpy_fish63 3 года назад +3

      Yea dude, when I first heard that I was fuckin shook. It's there. It's still there, holding on by a thread as you hear just the first few notes. It's haunting.

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад +1

      It sounded familiar to me, i heard guy lombardos version too before knowing eateot, it was so fucking scary feeling familiar but cant recall those snippets of music...

  • @_Anonymous__User_
    @_Anonymous__User_ 3 года назад +81

    I wanna be honest when I first discovered The Caretaker, I thought it was JUST MUSIC.
    But I now know there's a meaning to the album. "Its Just A Burning Memory" and the dementia stuff..
    Man.. :(
    But this song will always be a favorite and be easily recognized when I hear it.

  • @PheonixStarsx
    @PheonixStarsx 2 года назад +36

    I’m struggling with memory issues due to events and things that happened to me and my family , flashbacks , stress and dissociation etc etc , this song resonates with me as a lot of things feel like a dream , a burning memory

    • @Schizophrenic_Minds
      @Schizophrenic_Minds Год назад +1

      hope you get better

    • @user-hu6ys9wm8j
      @user-hu6ys9wm8j 10 месяцев назад +1

      @salemmidnight1785 I feel the same oddly. The notes that I've heard in E.A.T.E.O.T's Burning Memory hit hard and deep. It crumples me within because I listened to it so much.

  • @fattzo9525
    @fattzo9525 3 года назад +16

    At 12:50 it is very hard to hear it unless you use
    -noise cancelling headphones at 75% volume in a quiet room
    Extremely hard but i hear it

  • @owencole5774
    @owencole5774 3 года назад +30

    For some reason, I had a lot of trouble deciphering the stage 5 versions but the one in stage 6 I was able to faintly hear in the distant background. Mainly due to there being less chaotic noises in the background obstructing it.

  • @jermfanaccount
    @jermfanaccount 2 года назад +17

    how did some people even recognise some of the post-awareness samples? i could hear a bit of "The Prettiest Little Song Of All" in M1SC and what _might_ be some garbled instrumental from Heartaches, but that was about it. i'm impressed actually! that's some incredible musical ear work going on there.

  • @watermelion2364
    @watermelion2364 2 года назад +14

    i really like how slowly the amount of time each sample gets is shorter and shorter as the experience goes on, i didnt notice that in the original but to me its a lot like that feeling where you can think of snippets of a song but you cant quite remember in what order or it just keeps repeating in your own head, its a really nice touch

  • @sammy3212321
    @sammy3212321 2 года назад +6

    Now *that's* how you develop a motif

  • @ohnoohyeah3205
    @ohnoohyeah3205 2 года назад +6

    Having a dementia gene burning in me from both sides of my family, a love for music, a past laden with lsd, and now a deep dive into EATEOT..... whoa dude. Vedddy indodestink.

  • @100hundert
    @100hundert 3 года назад +12

    This album has spawned an entire subculture. I love it.

  • @FreedHellFire
    @FreedHellFire 3 года назад +21

    My heart aches for this channel

    • @modo69
      @modo69 3 года назад

      :/ :\

  • @bigwheelfromspidamahn1037
    @bigwheelfromspidamahn1037 3 года назад +17

    Heartaches also plays for 3 seconds at 0:13 seconds into stage 5

  • @Schattennebel
    @Schattennebel 2 года назад +4

    "Hard Eggs,
    Hard Eggs
    what does it matter it my eggs aches?"

  • @FreedHellFire
    @FreedHellFire 3 года назад +11

    I'm still trying to find out why Mournful Camaraderie sounds interesting to me

  • @filenotfound7471
    @filenotfound7471 3 года назад +21

    You truly are the legendary bulldozer

  • @averanger
    @averanger 3 года назад +24

    i have listen to this song that i have the lyrics in my head
    heartaches, heartaches
    my loving you ment only heartaches
    you kiss was such a sacred thing to me
    i can't believe it's just a burning memory
    heartaches, heartaches
    what does it matters how my heart breaks?
    i should be happy with someone new, but my heart aches for you

    • @Leo-rl7qi
      @Leo-rl7qi 3 года назад

      My head singed it before like this
      (im a mexican)
      Heart breaks, heart breaks!
      my loving you meant heart aches
      your kiss was a sacred thing to me
      i can't believe its just a Burning memory!
      heart breaks, heart breaks,
      what does matter how my heart breaks
      i should be happy with Someone new, but my heart breaks for you!

    • @Leo-rl7qi
      @Leo-rl7qi 3 года назад

      then i learned English and i know how the lyrics is.

    • @averanger
      @averanger 3 года назад

      @@Leo-rl7qi i heared the song a *LOT LOT OF LOT* of times that i knew the lyrics from a beginnig, they are kind of easy to understand Leonardo, good job

  • @rotisseriepossum
    @rotisseriepossum 2 года назад +8

    11:57 i laughed so hard at this little beep, it sounds kind of like a clown horn

  • @nich3897
    @nich3897 2 года назад +6

    I never even realized how many different versions of the song were sampled, I thought it was all Al!

  • @AudibleCrying
    @AudibleCrying 2 года назад +5

    A1 was stuck in my head and I finally found it, I keep having dreams that remind me of this song in such distortion and change

  • @Derpy_fish63
    @Derpy_fish63 3 года назад +76

    The squares really helped to discern which noises was actually heartaches(also useful as to which sample). Do you have any plans to give the libets delay vid the same treatment?

  • @lilligunner
    @lilligunner 3 года назад +14

    i wish the g1sb one lasted longer

  • @amethyst4578
    @amethyst4578 3 года назад +6

    Everywhere at the End of Time but it's only the parts people actually know

    • @OctoBirb8Claws
      @OctoBirb8Claws 2 года назад +3

      A1 - It's just a burning memory
      A2 - Childishly fresh eyes
      D1 - Quiet dusk coming early
      E1 - Back there Benjamin
      E2 - Libet's all joyful camaraderie
      E3 - Long Term Dusk Glimpses
      F1 - Gradations of arms length
      F2 - Drifting time misplaced
      F3 - Mournful camaraderie
      H1 - Post Awareness Confusions
      K1 - Advanced plaque entanglements
      R1 - Place in the world fades Away
      yes, i did letter and number them wrong on purpose

    • @ortherner
      @ortherner 2 года назад +5

      but only the parts people *remember*

  • @PDD555
    @PDD555 3 года назад +14

    Wow, just some hours ago I saw the last version and now its updated :D you really put effort on it

  • @lukealexanderrobertsthefir458
    @lukealexanderrobertsthefir458 3 года назад +6

    My great aunt constance roberts was married to Al bowly

    • @ProphetOfGaster
      @ProphetOfGaster 3 года назад

      Was he a cool guy?

    • @lukealexanderrobertsthefir458
      @lukealexanderrobertsthefir458 3 года назад +2

      @@ProphetOfGaster I don't know it was a short marriage only lasting two years but she could tell so.evtales on being in thst circle of people.
      Al died during the blitz

    • @ProphetOfGaster
      @ProphetOfGaster 3 года назад

      @@lukealexanderrobertsthefir458 Interestling.

  • @schmoogledoink2738
    @schmoogledoink2738 3 года назад +36

    Play in reverse order to simulate a dementia patient being saved by a cure
    (was on the old video, so I thought I'd put it here too)

  • @jonathannavarro3522
    @jonathannavarro3522 3 года назад +33

    Seger Ellis and Guy Lombardo versions sound depressing af man, why fuck with a song that way?

    • @princereechaos133
      @princereechaos133 3 года назад +21

      To be fair, the subject matter of Heartaches is pretty depressing
      If anything, the Al Bowlly version could maybe be considered strangely cheerful

    • @biblicallyaccurateangel4433
      @biblicallyaccurateangel4433 3 года назад +5

      @@princereechaos133 There is another version of the song sang by The Four Aces,,,it very upbeat and cheerful, way different from the ones used in the EATEOT album.

    • @VinVonVoom
      @VinVonVoom 2 года назад

      Seger Ellis is good, although the vocals feel a lot less rhythmic but the Guy Lombardo version is straight garbage. It tries to make it happy or something and it doesn't work in the slightest. They're both used very effectively in EATOT though.

  • @sloppyslobster
    @sloppyslobster Год назад +2

    What's weird is everyone that was born near 1910 are all dying at this moment.

    • @Cain1251
      @Cain1251 Год назад

      My grandma passed away roughly 2 weeks ago, she was born in 1929 and yes, she was developing dementia already...

    • @sloppyslobster
      @sloppyslobster Год назад

      ​@@Cain1251 I am sorry for your loss. my Great grandmother is 93 and has dementia. I know how it feels to have some one be lost like that. She couldn't remember Halloween and told my Grand father" I heard there's this thing were the kids go and get candy at peoples doors." It is really sad.

  • @kritikal965
    @kritikal965 3 года назад +10

    Heart... aches?

  • @grbr2006
    @grbr2006 2 года назад +14

    al bowlly, seger ellis and guy lombardo:
    the great statue is built. the amazing things this great figure did will be remembered from this statue. hopefully nothing bad happens...
    A1:
    decades later, someone rediscovers the statue in an underground place. the statue looks familiar, so they bring it back to the surface to show people what they have found.
    C3:
    during that person's adventure back to the surface, the statue begins to lose some details, but overall still looks human.
    E2:
    the person realizes that the statue is beginning to break. they try to find the surface faster but it's no use. this piece of history might be lost forever.
    F4:
    the statue is beginning to crack, it's limbs are starting to fall apart. the person didn't bring any glue to put it back together.
    F5:
    the person accidentally loses the statue. they must retreve it, but it's too dark.
    F8:
    they eventually recover the statue, but it's in an even worse condition.
    G1:
    the cave that person is in is starting to crumble, so they run. but as they run, pieces of the statue start flying away.
    H1:
    the limbs of the statue are gone. all that's left is the torso, head and face.
    K1, L1 and M1:
    those parts eventually start falling apart too.
    O1:
    the person has finally reached the surface, but when they looked at the statue's condition, all that was left was remnants of what once was.
    the statue is gone.

    • @ShwappaJ
      @ShwappaJ 2 года назад +3

      Indiana Jones adventure bruh

    • @yigit-nh2vn
      @yigit-nh2vn 2 года назад +2

      so your telling me these ####### 6 hour music was just over a statue?

    • @grbr2006
      @grbr2006 2 года назад +1

      @@yigit-nh2vn
      yeah! it had history attached to it, *just like the memories...*

    • @yigit-nh2vn
      @yigit-nh2vn 2 года назад

      @@grbr2006 well atleast he got back there Benjamin

  • @Freakphone
    @Freakphone 3 года назад +3

    I was listening to EATEOT for the 5th day in a row and the thought that I wanted to find a video that showed all uses of Heartaches spawned in my head, and when I went to my youtube frontpage to search for a video like that, this video was the first one recommended. Scary.

  • @Arslan35
    @Arslan35 3 года назад +18

    the place where you advised to skip to 3:26 to hear A1, you spelled A1 as S1

  • @theyoozer9390
    @theyoozer9390 3 года назад +3

    E2 sounds like a train

  • @zedlz
    @zedlz 3 года назад +7

    please let this vid blow up I really enjoyed it.

  • @bgelinski2785
    @bgelinski2785 2 года назад +3

    Thank you, this was exactly what I was looking for

  • @orangeandthehothogs6513
    @orangeandthehothogs6513 2 года назад +2

    Its all just a burning memory

  • @Derpy_fish63
    @Derpy_fish63 3 года назад +5

    I 100% thought I was hearing All that follows is true in G1SE. I never even thought that could be heartaches, let alone there was a 3rd version used. Wild.

  • @AwesomeSpr6Gamer
    @AwesomeSpr6Gamer 3 года назад +3

    Cant believe it's just a burning memory

  • @jalapenoandbanana
    @jalapenoandbanana 3 года назад +3

    Al Bowlly: 3 songs
    Guy Lombardo: 2 songs
    Seger Elis: Idk there's a lot

  • @jackpijjin4088
    @jackpijjin4088 3 года назад +71

    wow the Guy Lombardo version is dreadful

    • @happygamer_18
      @happygamer_18 3 года назад +2

      It sounds like it’s on the verge of tears.

    • @fletchqc9900
      @fletchqc9900 3 года назад

      How about seger ellis, it sounds terrifying at first

    • @jackpijjin4088
      @jackpijjin4088 3 года назад +12

      @@fletchqc9900 it at least fits the tone of the song
      Guy Lombardo was trying to be TOO bombastic with his arrangement

    • @fletchqc9900
      @fletchqc9900 3 года назад +7

      @@jackpijjin4088 true, it sounded borderline psychotic, but it didn't really make me feel sad or terrified, just weirded out

    • @San-ln7sp
      @San-ln7sp 2 года назад +2

      When i could recognize it on stage 4 i feel *real* dread.

  • @donnaquixote7538
    @donnaquixote7538 2 года назад +5

    Didn't know there was also a Guy Lombardo version. ❤

  • @ianj1l1enjoyer
    @ianj1l1enjoyer 2 года назад +2

    9:11, you forgot (oh no) to put a red box for "Your kiss was such a sacred thing."

  • @inhalant_snow1471
    @inhalant_snow1471 3 года назад +54

    hey, right at 9:10, isn’t that the first note of some version of heartaches? it’s in a different key and mostly just the first note so I guess it’s hard to tell
    edit: yeah I’m pretty sure there are two versions of heartaches playing at the same time right there.

  • @mcnugget677
    @mcnugget677 2 года назад +5

    A1:
    Heartaches, heartaches,
    My love in you meant only heartaches!
    Your kiss was such a sacred to me…
    I can’t believe it’s just a burning memory!
    C3:
    Heartaches, heartaches,
    My love in you meant only heartaches!
    Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me…
    I can’t believe it’s just a burning memory!
    E2:
    I should be happy with someone new…
    But my heart aches for you!
    F4:
    Heart… h-heart… heart… h-heart… heeeeaaaaart… aches- you- my love- you- meant-
    F8:
    Hært… h-hært… hært… h-hært… hēêèéëàáâäãrt… ãçhëß- ÿøū-

    • @ortherner
      @ortherner 2 года назад

      ow the cringe

    • @kikirizki8399
      @kikirizki8399 2 года назад +2

      @@ortherner how?

    • @DWARFAVISI
      @DWARFAVISI 9 месяцев назад

      A1 - Heartaches! Heartaches! By loving you meant only heartaches!
      Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me.
      I can't believe it's just a burning... Memory!
      C3 - Heartbreaks.... and aches.... My matter oh how my heart...
      Your lips were very holy to me.... It is a faded memory...
      E2 - Your....... thing.... happy...... Thing to......
      F4 - happy...................
      F8 H x-

    • @DWARFAVISI
      @DWARFAVISI 9 месяцев назад

      A1 - Heartaches, Heartaches! My loving you meant only heartaches
      Your kiss was such a sacred thing to me! I can't believe it's just a burning memory! h-Eartaches! Heartaches!
      C3 - Heartaches. Breaks, aches? Aches! Heart!
      E2 - H- ... A heart broke...., h-

    • @WereComingHomeBoyes
      @WereComingHomeBoyes 6 месяцев назад

      // - echo/silenced
      () - note
      HeartaaAaAa-rtache-hea-heaaa heactaches /heartaaaches/
      -loviIng yOU me- -nly heaaaartaaa/aches/
      yo-your kiss was such a sacr- such a a a /a a a/ meeee
      i- i(reversed) i i - bel- i it’s just burning mee-eem(reversed)-mee/mory/
      -eaaar-eee(E from ‘aches’)-aaarte-artaches /-aches -aches -aches/
      myYy loving you meant-nly-yln(reversed ‘(o)nly’) heeeeart -eart -eaaaaa/aaches/
      /you- your kiss/ -uch a sacred thing to meeEeEe
      -can’t believe it’s just bu- me- uurn- meee-ryyy
      Heaaaaaartee- he(ac’he’s)-aaa-ache-artaches- /-eartaches/
      /My-ym(reversed ‘my’)/ -oonly heaaaaaar-eaaaaaartaache-eaaaaaar-
      -(y)our kiiss was such a sacred th-acred-ing to meee/eeeeee/
      I caaaaa-aaaaaa(reversed)-lieve it’s-ieve-it’s- burning me-bu-me-bu-eeeeeemoryyy-yyy(reversed)
      /heeeeeaaa/-rtache-rte-artacheeeees
      (Very weird sound here)wha-(weird soun again)-oes it matter hooow-ooow -eart breaaaaaaks
      Your kiss wa(very short ‘a’)-iss-was /such a/-thing to meeEeEe
      - -(can’t start next line)-lieve it’s /-ieve/ -bu-me-burning-burning-/burning-burning/-ry.
      It was painful to do.

  • @kerenb14
    @kerenb14 3 года назад +6

    oh dang this video is super new, well that's neat

  • @Mag_Nus32
    @Mag_Nus32 2 года назад +2

    Thanks for making this. There are good things about the internet!

  • @fishbone-yq8ts
    @fishbone-yq8ts 2 года назад +4

    My favorite is Al Bowlly's version.

  • @AlphVA
    @AlphVA 2 года назад

    Hearing the same sample throught out its stages could represent one of the great memories that someone can cherish: the love of your life, your best friends or just a very special moment that makes you feel alive and glad you had it in your life that could be part of your own identity, with every deterioration being a wish to keep those things with you, being unable to fully recover it, getting desperate of loosing something being very important for you, but still having fragments of it till the end where it becomes unrecognizable, like loosing part of your own identity.

  • @bamboeng2014
    @bamboeng2014 3 года назад +3

    what does it matter how my head breaks?

  • @masonthechemistryfreak6894
    @masonthechemistryfreak6894 3 года назад +8

    Jesus... how did people even find it in acstyff?
    Edit: I really wish stage 3-4 transition songs from eaeb were kept in the album. Advanced plaque camaraderie and Entangled synapse ache are such chilling titles. It's like The Caretaker still wants agency over their mind, like how people with dementia often want to drive or manage finances again in the moderate stages. Unfortunately, we can see the disease is eating any hope of doing that again.
    The last thing done for someone with Alzheimer's is the last time ever.

  • @jrk1666
    @jrk1666 3 года назад +5

    a whole new meaning for burning memory eh

  • @skrskrrr
    @skrskrrr 3 года назад +4

    anyone else can hear a voice saying heartaches at 13:00?

    • @TheCaregiverSITMOB
      @TheCaregiverSITMOB Год назад

      That sounded like the Troll Song at first, but now that I think about it, you might be right!

    • @I-have_phonophobia
      @I-have_phonophobia 11 месяцев назад

      I hear it, it appears to sound like some low pitched demonic choir

  • @klasky678tv4
    @klasky678tv4 2 года назад +3

    EATEOT but heartaches
    Stage 1
    A1 - Heartaches
    A2 - I can't believe...
    B1 - It's just a burning memory
    Stage 2
    C1 - Does it matter how my heart breaks
    C2 - What does it matter how my heart breaks
    D1 - Heart breaks
    Stage 3
    E1 - Some heart breaks
    E2 - And heart breaks
    E3 - Burning despair breaks
    F1 - Burning despair does ache
    F2 - Aching burning despair without lucidity
    F3 - Aching cavern without lucidity
    F4 - Aching camaraderie without lucidity
    F5 - Aching camaraderie
    F6 - Mournful camaraderie
    Stage 4
    G1 - Camaraderie Awareness
    G2 - Camaraderie Awareness confusions
    H1 - Post Awareness Confusions
    Stage 5
    I1 - Advanst Awareness Entanglefusions
    J1 - Advanced Awareness Entanglements
    K1 - Advanced Plague Entanglements
    Stage 6
    M1 - Synapse Plague Entanglements
    N1 - Synapse Entanglements
    O1 - Synapse Retrogenesis
    P1 - Synapse Fades Away
    Q1 - Place Fades Away
    R1 - Place in the World Fades Away

  • @pezdespencer8899
    @pezdespencer8899 2 года назад +3

    I remember the first time I heard burning despair does ache and I was about to jam out to the little piano riff on where heartaches would be if it had words and it was distorted and that has an indescribable sadness around it for me the music is forgetting what it sounds like

  • @Doomsayers_
    @Doomsayers_ 3 года назад +4

    This song is lovely in its own way

  • @edwardlovesbigmacs1693
    @edwardlovesbigmacs1693 2 года назад +3

    3:26 your welcome

  • @Jay-uu5lu
    @Jay-uu5lu 2 года назад +1

    10:58 temporary bliss state can faintly be heard

  • @Xgrish
    @Xgrish 3 года назад +2

    Safety in phills sophie

  • @Sonicthehedgeho4
    @Sonicthehedgeho4 3 года назад +3

    When i heard heartaches in stage 4 i was like OMG ITS HEARTACHES

  • @colemak5646
    @colemak5646 3 года назад +4

    exactly what i needed!

  • @Jamieconstable
    @Jamieconstable 2 года назад +2

    We need more videos like this on yt

  • @HollyLamovsky
    @HollyLamovsky 3 года назад +2

    AAA BURNING MEMORY GET FIRE EXTINGUISHER

  • @vinnytheplayer5500
    @vinnytheplayer5500 2 года назад +1

    Entanglement synapse ache also appears in post awareness confusions 2 and when speed up it sounds like mournful camaraderie

  • @lisandro5612
    @lisandro5612 3 года назад +2

    Stage 1:Heartaches,heartaches,my loving you meant only heartaches,i should be happy with someone new,but my heartac-,Can you tell me the name of the song?
    Stage 2:Heartaches,What does it matter how my heart breaks?,but my heartaches for yo-,Can you tell me your name again?
    Stage 3:Heart breaks,and my heart breaks for yo-....,who are you,why are you in my house?
    Stage 4:Heart-...who-i,a-....
    Stage 5:W-.....h-
    Stage 6:

  • @user-qc4rq4jr8k
    @user-qc4rq4jr8k 2 года назад +4

    12:55