Muslim Arab Israelis: Who do you want as your government? Israel or Palestine?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 26 авг 2024
- The Ask Project is made possible by donations from viewers like you.
Please donate to the project at:
* www.paypal.me/...
* / askproject
.
Want to know what Israelis and Palestinians in the Middle East really think about the conflict? Ask a question and I will get answers.
As an Israeli Arab citizen, any Arab that prefers Israel to not exist is delusional.
Israel is not perfect, but it’s better than all the other countries near it.
Every citizen in Israel has the chance to get educated, pick up a skill, build and prosper and live in dignity.
The biggest issue in Israel is war, and sadly that’s not single sided.
Not its not Saudi qatar oman Kuwait uae are better
So why is it hard for Palestinians ro get legal land in.west bank meanwhile they make it easy for Israelis
Excellent comment ❤
@@Trilliman707better get a map because the near countries are Egypt, Jordan, Syria and Lebanon
@@Trilliman707I think the commenter is talking about Arabs who are Israeli citizens, whereas I believe you may be referring to Palestinian citizens in the West Bank. One is in a better state of affairs than the other.
Unless you've been to Israel you won't realise that is normal. The 2 million Arab Muslim Israelis are very happy to be Israeli citizens because they have equal rights, women's rights, LGBT rights, democracy, secularism, human rights, Western values. There are Arab Muslims in the Knesset (Parliament) and in the judiciary. They own businesses, work and have equal status.
2 million arabs, mostly muslims and also christians. Saying all are very happy is a little over the roof 😅 i say it as a jewish living in israel
@@NoNeedJustFeedhe has to say it like that everything is perfect 😅😅😅if you are from Israel I want to ask you I know for a fact that it's not like what our friend in his comment saying that everyone is happy and they are singing together but is it that bad I mean the terrorist attack on their side and the extremist or Settlers or some of the people on your side killing Palestinians and saying kill the Arabs or it's all a propaganda
@@ObitoObito-hi3ft my friend you are getting confused, the israeli arabs indeed live good and in peace with us. The problem is in the west bank and gaza
@@elayasulin9489 you mean the problem with the Arab Muslims is that correct I know about the Arab Israeli but what I am asking is the Arab in Gaza and west bank can you tell me about the problem a lot of the people saying the Gaza and the west bank is like a big prison can't vote setllers killing Palestinans and a lot of racism and I am talking about the Muslim is that correct or just nonsense 🤔🤔🤔and what the solution to end this for good in your opinion
@@ObitoObito-hi3ft it is so complicated my friend for me to explain it here ( i am telling you this as an israeli who want peace in the region ) , you should check the rest of this guy videos and to get the mindset of many Palestinians
this is beautiful. Personally as a Muslim i love my Jewish brothers. I really think we should get united, forget all the hatreds.
I agree
ga
Yes people like u can forget
The innocent killing of the ummah
The small kids which is still traumatized !!
Shameless muslims will be united with the Jews
Tell that to Hamas and Abbas. They will never accept Israel or Jews.
Hey i think first you mist tell the Israel occupation to not sent missile of you want begin relation with Palestine
She said it clearly, compared to everyone else, Israel provides democracy and equal status. Under Palestinians, things would not be equal and would not be democratic...
Like all kalifates, a small minority reigns with iron fist and you're basically stuck in your socio economic class until you die and so will your children, grandchildren and so on... now look at how fortunes changed hands in western countries...
Yes, which is why Palestinians need help to have the opportunity at a better life along with education so they can be deradicalized. People need to learn to share and to get along, or nothing will change.
israel es un estado paria
In the current situation from Oct 7th I wish the world could see this video and not the mainstream media outlets.
May God bless you all. ❤
I agree with you completely
Mainstream media, and most “free Palestine” swine will actually call the situation Israel Arabs have inside Israel an apartheid.
Lies and ignorance, I grew up in Israel as an Arab, inside of Israel there is NO apartheid.
This does not mean Israel is perfect, but i wish it lasts as long as it can 🎉
As an Israeli Jew, I can tell you that the Jews are the first to want peace. The Israeli Arabs live here like kings, they can do anything here. even to be prime ministers. Until we lost trust in them completely. I'm sure there are good Arabs who want to live next to me, but every Arab I see on the street the first thing that comes to my mind is that he wants to murder me. Because throughout the entire time that our country existed and even before it was established, they carried out so many terrorist attacks, so many Jews were murdered. And now, after October 7, my trust in them will be zero. Until they prove again that they really want to live in peace and not kill us, only then will my trust in them be restored. Am Israel chai!❤❤
Trueeeeeee
You won't unfortunately, it is against the "message" so mainstream media won't ever show things like this, bless the internet.
I’m so happy I watched your video! I’m Israeli Jew and I very respect Arab citizens. I work in startup and we have many Arab employees that are my friends, my doctor is Arab, my daughter’s kindergarten teacher is Arab woman. I love that we can live in peace! I wish we could strengthen this.
Man u guys need to make videos and show the world. We need to see the love😢
Exactly! Even our terrorists are Arabs! 👌
@@Hshdzsskidi many muslim people dont want love. They prefer hatred
Arab and muslim here, we love the jews and hope my our country signs a peace treaty with Israel 😢 like other arab countries have done. My whole family wants that even my grandma from Gaza!
my doctor is Arab too. Also my pharmacist.
This video aged like fine wine I hope more people see this video
Why did it become obsolete? It is also valid for today.
@@NepToon10 True
does not fit the Palestine victim narrative. Israel has western values, so of course it is going to have equality, discrimination is a different issue. On average, the Arabs in minorities in Israel like Arabs, Ethiopians and Russians are discriminated more and are poorer in general
@@NepToon10 "To age like fine wine" doesn't mean "to become obsolete," it actually means the opposite, i.e. "to get better as it ages." You might be confusing it with "to age like milk" which means "to age very badly."
Yeah, these Arabs on the video have Stockholm Syndrome. Crazy how they like the government to be Jewish despite the lack of freedom of expression, the lack of equal rights and the regular attacks the settlers wage on Arab towns with the protection of the Israeli military.
Three years back on my flight to Tel Aviv, I got a chance to meet a few Muslim Arabs from Israel. It was exactly the same story. They said the life of Muslim Arabs in Israel was much better than their relatives in either Palestine or Lebanon. And they also told me not to believe in what the mainstream media showed us. It really came as a surprise to me because all that I had seen was constant fights between Arabs and the Jews in Israel.
lol u sound like an idiot. Ofc life is going to be better in an Israeli government for those that are allowed to live in Israel. The country is given billions by other countries and are technically advanced. Living in Israel as an Arab is obviously going to be better than living in poverty ridden countries.
hmm... yes... of course, Palestine is going to be poorly managed and have poor material welfare (eg. hospitals, etc.) considering that they do not have full nationhood *faceplam*.
@@RMatt2016 They were offered statehood many times but rejected it. Whose fault was that?
@@RMatt2016 there are around 20 Arab countries yet these people chose Israel. Says a lot
@@yaqo6577 Saudi Arabia has ~500,000 Palestinians, each of the neighbouring nations have 100,000 each. These figures don't include those who acquired nationality of the Arab country they live in. For example, in Kuwait, many Palestinians got naturalised in the 60s. So the figure of Palestinians holding Palestinians travel documents are ~1 million in the Gulf countries. If you add those who were naturalised, the figure goes up to ~1.5 million. The number of Arab citizens of Israel are around 1.8 million.
And in Jordan there are 3 million Palestinians. Much much more than the number of Arabs citizens of Israel.
Of course there are going to Palestinians who choose to become citizens of Israel for many reasons (eg. Marriage). Not every single Palestinian acts the same way. But the number of Palestinians in Jordan are higher than Arabs citizens of Israel. There are also many Palestinians in the Gulf. And we haven't even considered Palestinians in other Arab countries.
I am amazed that there are Arabs that want to live under the Israeli government. This is an eye opener.
They have a good life there and they know they won't have the same in any Muslim country
Check out Yoseph Haddad he is an Arab Israeli activist and he likes Israel better than a lot of Israelis lol
21% of Israeli population is NON-JEWISH (Arab Muslim, Arab christians, Druze). These Arabs on this videos are Arab Israeli citizens.
Most Israeli Jews are not religious! They're secular and live a Western lifestyle, like people in Europe or North America.
@@MelC-td9bg And your point is?
The world cheering for Palestine but the Muslims themselves n Palestinians themselves better off living in Israel governance. That says a lot .
That's why I believe most people talking about Israel never have been there. The last year I stayed there for 2 months, god willing, will stay there next year again. The Israeli people never talked bad about the arabs or palestinians, older people might have some predjeduces, but in the end enjoy working or living with them peacefully in Israel. You have to experience the country to get an real expertise on this conflict...
I don't believe the West is cheering for Palestine that much anymore, Look at what is going on in Europe,Canada and the US because of pro Palestine supporters. They're not only targeting Jewish people but Christians as well.
You'll be ostracized if you say otherwise, therefore Palestinians in Israel will choose Israeli.
This was 4 years ago. I wonder if they've changed their minds with recent events, or if they still have the same opinion. Would be interesting to find out.
@@zMooziii They can easily move to Palestine if that's what they wanted. What the hell are you talking about
I feel dumb, I really expected them all to say Palestine. This was very educational. They seem to have a good life there
Yes
nah they are paid interviewse, if they did say something bad they would get into jail
@@nostalgichunter337 hehe cap lol
Yes my friend because Israeli Government applies laws and no difference between citizens no matter the background is
Arabs in Israel have representatives in the Israeli parliament
Definitely Israeli Government is better
Well, it's up to them. That's their choice.
Amazing to see how the Arab Israelis are grateful to be under a Jewish democratic state with a Jewish government.
No they are facing religious extremism from Zionist government.
Dont forget that arabs have some political forces here.
I wish they were grateful, they like to live in a democracy, but then some of them chant "from the river to the see, Palestine will be free", and free Palestine from Israel.
Furthermore there are 10 Arab members of the Knesset
@@noazur I have not seen a single video showing Israeli Arabs doing that. It is the Palestinians who have moved to the West who are doing that.
And people still dare to claim Israel is an "apartheid"...
apartheid to palestinians in west bank dummy, how they would be apartheid tot heir own citizens? they have to applied to other people, the british did apartheid with british people or south african?
lo es
As an Israeli it was a ig surprise for me that Israeli Arabs want a Jewish government. Thank you for this amazing video. Ramadan Qarim, happy Easter and happy Passover to everyone.
לא חושב שזה הפתעה כל אחד עם קצת שכל יודע שהממשלה שלנו יותר טובה מהרשות הפלסטינית וחמאס
יש מצב שזו תאכייה, קח בעירבון מוגבל.
No one says you are not clever and bright people your cousins are thick and dumb that's why you managed to conquer them with all that oil wealth they have still achieved nothing
Shalom, and As-Salaam Alaikum, TO ALL! ❤❤❤
What stood out in many of the answers, are that Israelis have better technology and are more orderly.
This is not a surprise to me. I have lived with Jewish people in Australia. As a young man many of my friends were Jewish. They were good people. They know how to manage a business and I am sure they know how to manage a country. There is something sinister about antisemitism.
People don't understand antisemitism. They think its like racism, which is more direct and individual like "That black guy is a criminal", which is wrong as well but antisemitism is conspiracy based and directed to the group - "Jews are trying to take over the world" "Jews are lying to us about their intentions" "Jews do human sacrifice" "Jews steal organs" and other forms of blood libel (blood libel is an important one to understand) etc. You hear people talk about "The jews are doing this" but you don't get "The blacks are doing this", instead its "Black individuals are doing this" (still wrong just different)
People don't understand thats how it works, they force a western view of prejudice (racism) on them, and say "we aren't anti semitic because we don't have issues with individual jews", then follow it up with "its just the jewish movement that is committing genocide on the palestinians (which isn't true and is blood libel) and things like that which we don't like" and in the arab world they think "jews want to destroy al aqsa mosque" and "Jews steal organs" etc.
Anti semitism in the middle east didn't start with zionism, it started with Eastern European Christians bringing antisemitic pamphlets and books that were used to create the idea of "jews trying to take over the world" and accusations of sacrifice etc. (all bullshit used to get rid of jews from their countries or in cases like hitler to create a common enemy to unite your people as you as their leader) which led to massacres of jews specifically due to blood libel all through the 1800s - Aleppo (1810, 1850, 1875), Damascus (1840, 1848, 1890), Beirut (1862, 1874), Dayr al-Qamar (1847), Jerusalem (1847), Cairo (1844, 1890, 1901-02), Mansura (1877), Alexandria (1870, 1882, 1901-02), Port Said (1903, 1908), and Damanhur (1871, 1873, 1877, 1892)
Such lovely people. They are genuinely happy and I am happy for them. This is a great video, it should be broadcasted everywhere..
Does t take the way the oppression Palestinians face I. Gaza and west bank or Hebron Israel
@@Trilliman707 don’t blame Israel someone’s else failed government.
@@user-sf6wc9tr9o 100%
@@Trilliman707I saw a comment from an Israeli. He says it's the orthodox jews and they need to be dealt with so it's not all jews who are bad.U know Jesus always had fights with those Pharasies
@@Trilliman707what isn’t clear to you? West bank and Gaza are under Palestinian rule.
Anyone who’s says “whichever government treats its people right” are basically saying Israel, they are just afraid of other Muslims judging them.
100% correct!!!
Not all Palestinians are Muslims. Some are Christians too.
It's better to be an Arab in Israel than it is to be in any other Middle Eastern country. Better job prospects, higher life expectancy and fair treatment regardless of what sect of islam they follow.
pure and simple bro ! you are damm right !
as an israeli i confirm they have really good life and equal to mine .
Yeah I’m sure the Palestinians in East Jerusalem who have their homes stolen love Israeli rule!
No.. 100% Not
R osso Well because europe and us bombed our countries to dust..
Arabs in Israel 🇮🇱 enjoy more freedom, higher education, longer lives, better health-care, and more security than in any of the 22 Arab states.
They wouldn't want to live in any of them.
And they wouldn't even prefer to live in Germany, as Arabs from Arab states do. Millions of them pour into Europe from Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, Somalia, Sudan, Kuwait and even Saudi Arabia to escape the horrors of living in an Arab state.
But you will not find Arabs migrating from Jaffa, Acre or Nazareth. Because they have wonderful lives. Those are the basic facts.
To anyone who has ever been to Israel, this video is not surprising.
4:24 he says "for us, the people of Israel" and YES. He's part of the people, if so he wishes and identifies as. And I'm so glad he feels part of the people.
Israel is a terrorist state
@@kenshiroren7699 ok, why?
@@tihitihi391 Hard question.
He said in Arabic "عرب اسرائيل" ( Arab Israel ), but they translated it to "People of Israel", and yes, the Israeli Arabs are very happy in Israel.
@@sultandaudi5375
he spoke hebrew, said 3am israel - the people of israel. please learn hebrew and only then say what people said in hebrew in videos.
First world problems = wanting to change countries because your shopping is closed on Saturdays.
Kid doesn't realize how good his life is.
Lol imagine
Freedom comes at a cost.
But yes, you are right.
Closed shops on Saturdays requires some forward planning. Sunday opening only became widespread in England and Wales 25 years ago. There were huge objections under the banner of "keep Sunday special".
@@marksimons8861 in arab towns and villeges it is open 24/7
Amazon is open 24/7 kid
As a isreali jewish my self
Isreali arabs are very kind to me and very respectful bless them 😊🇮🇱❤✡☪❤🇮🇱
@@Lancer_balls ❤☪✡❤
@@Lancer_balls amen
Ali The best of luck to you in Iraq! If you ever want to tell your story on my channel you are welcome to anytime! It makes me very sad that the U.S. coalition spent so much in blood & treasure liberating Iraq, never took a drop of oil & most Iraqis say they were better under Saddam.
@@solvingpolitics3172 yeah 😔
Ali hey there I’m Israeli Jewish my family grandparents were from Algeria in Syria but we’re kicked out after the Arab-Israeli conflict I hope there would be peace one day
This is soooo different than what the media shows us
If you haven’t noticed, the media is there to exaggerate stories, they make money that way
If you still believe the media, you might want to reconsider
A dear Palestinian friend of mine who was part of the second Intifada told me some 14 years back that you can easily see the difference between the Arabic and Jewish quarters in Israel; the cleanliness. Moreover, he told me that he was working for a Jewish bar owner who used to give him a bonus and a leave on Islamic holidays. The sad truth about Arab leadership is... well, just look around, enough said... One thing he used to say "Although I am against occupation, I think they (the Israelis) have done much better by the land than what we would have done had we been in charge".
So basicly if there pride wasn't in the way they would be zionists
I’m Muslim and I’ve worked for isreeali Jewish employer, he was super kind and brought lunch for everyone. There was a Palestinian girl employee who always said bad things about isreeal but he never fired her. He was a great man and he gave me good pay. I’ve worked for Muslim employers and they would over work me, they wouldn’t even give me my pay. I like Jewish rule better 💞
Nice fake story you got there. You should write a fiction book.
Allah employs leaders on countries based on how the peoples character i. If you and I were better muslims maybe we would have better leaders. You should know that we can never be friends with jews or christians . As said in the Quran very clearly . That does not mean we want to kill them or banish them from our land but to live among us. But whatbthe jews have done to palestine is unforgivable.
@@waleedrao4558 If we want to get anywhere in this world, we need to stop thinking like we still live in the stone age. I don't know which Quran you read, but the version I know doesn't mention anything like that, and as per my knowledge, there is only one version of the Quran. If you really believe what you said, then you are a very lonely man with a very limited choice of friendships and connections in an increasingly globalized world. My best friend ever, whom I consider family, is a christian. Open your mind man. I do agree with one thing you said though, if we were better people, we would have had better leaders.
I am not Palestinian but muslim
But if I were Palestinian sure I will prefer to live under Israeli govt instead of Palestinian gov or Jordanian govt or Lebanese or hizballah gov or hamas govt in Gaza
Israel provide you a good quality of life . And who hold an Israeli passport he is respected over the entire world
The Palestinian of 1948 who gain israeli passports are soo lucky
I think like you❣️🇮🇱
@@esthers1126 yea if I were Palestinian I will prefer to live Israeli rules and govt
I prefer to live as Israeli muslim
@@Waleed-22996 me too. If I were Palestinian i will prefer to live Israeli rules❤️
@@SumSum030 How is the Israeli government not a secular government. You are all big talk about Israel, but even fail to mention how horrific all the other middle eastern nations are...
@@mhmhm5337 Israel is a secular country, but Netanyahu's friends threaten secularity. I have an Israeli citizenship myself because my father is Israeli, and he agrees
As a Jewish Israeli I am always so amazed by how many people outside of Israel know very little about the people here. Not perfect, no. But it really is shocking. I've met visitors here from Jordan, and Egypt who were shocked, because what they were taught was so opposite to what they experienced and saw in Israel. I hope one day more in the Arab world will stop using Zionist as a slur, and start seeing us as partners. The only way to bring peace and justice to the region is to work together.
I am so tired of everyone that can't call you 'a effin Jew' so instead they call you a 'zioniiiisssstttt' because that's all they are allowed to say.
yeap i used to be muslim and pro palestine... when i did my research i turned around 180 and i even visited israel. its nothing like what people perceive it to be.
i dont know if you know the meaning of the word implied, but it's not implied. i said it quite explicitly. @@YonikMalik
@@iamtheportal I mustve been sleepy or something lol
pues trabajaen por un estado palestino con fronteras del 48 ya estan tardando
Arabs that live in Israel live a very good life compared to most other arab countries (I realize that there are exceptions)
Arabs can become citizens of Israel, but in many other Arab countries (the Gulf ones), citizenship is reserved only for Arabs.
For example, in Saudi or UAE even if you're a Pakistani Muslim, you will never be able to become a citizen.
In the same Arab countries, it's illegal for Arabs to be Christian. They only allow Pilipinos and Indians to be Christian. Bibles in Arabic are banned.
@@han1218 That's not true. In the case of Saudi Arabia, there is no such ethnic restriction on naturalization -- only linguistic requirements pertaining to fluency in Arabic. So, e.g, a Pakistani Muslim who has laid down roots in the country and mastered Arabic would not be de jure excluded from receiving citizenship on virtue of his origins.
UAE does have modified naturalization regulations for ethnic Arabs, but there is a nominal -- though admittedly arduous -- path to citizenship for non-Arabs. It requires 30 years of residence. A long game, but not a categorical impossibility, as you make it out to be.
@@han1218 that's wrong citizenship is not even granted for Arabs, also it is granted sometimes to wealthy hindu investors.
@@qaissaif7905 The "palestinian" Arabs that are now citizens of Israel were granted citizenship. Most Palestinians refused citizenship, and left their homes, thinking they will come back when the Arabs will win the war against Israel. The smart ones remained and accepted the citizenship.
@@han1218 I was talking about the gulf states
I’m israeli arab
And love my home israel 🇮🇱✌🏻💙🤍
أنتي واحد من الاثنين يا أما مستعربة يا أما جاهلة
מלכת עולם!♥️
And we love you 💙
Am Israeli arab I fight for Israel and abolish Hamas
@@hanji2091
لا تتكلم عن الجهل وانت ما تعرف ان مصطلح فلستينوس اطلقوه الرومان لما احتلو ارض اسرائيل في القرن الثاني ستدرس التاريخ ثم تتحدث حالياً سكرلي هالثم
The last dude hahah
Imagine that your biggest problem in the Middle East is, that the shops are closed on Shabbat.
Damn that must be a wonderful life
@Mas Gonderawi Don't know what you're referring to but materialism is not Jewish but Western.
@Mas Gonderawi You antisemites need to make up your mind about whether we're materialist greedy capitalist pigs, or bolshevik communist traitors. I'm sure it won't cross your mind that we may be neither, or extremely diverse in opinion among our own.
I think the author of this video is portraying a versatile and pluralistic Israel vs a dense and unexamined Palestine. The problem is that he is right, and very sophisticated . Ask any Palestinian what to do with mentally challenged kids or gays.. The results will vary but I guarantee there is less compassion on the Arab side.
@Mas Gonderawi So generalizing all Jews is okay then? Also you know exactly what he meant when he said you were anti-semetic. At least be honest here considering you are already making a fool of yourself so might as well be honest :)
@Mas Gonderawi "please define what is an antisemite" - read the dictionary. It refers specifically to Jews only, and in the word's historical context there's good reason for that.
The fact that the political philosophers who co-founded the ideas of capitalism and communism were Jews, is not damning at all, as most Jews disagreed with them at the time, and continue the debates to this day. We are a people of creative thinking, debate, argument, exploration of ideas, NOT a people fixed to an ideology. Certainly not fixed to capitalism or communism. Get this very simple point drilled into your mind and you may still have hope to overcome the paranoid delusional sickness named antisemitism.
I claim. Arab citizens of Israel are much better than Arabs in other Arab countries in the world. Most of them are educated and can become judges, prosecutors, police officers and doctors very easily. The government does not discriminate at all, but some people may.
I clicked on this video FOR SURE thinking they would all immediately say Palestine. Really interesting to see their responses.
The conditions in gaza and west bank for Arabs are not pleasant and Israel is responsible for that so not sure why you are surprised these people chose comfort as second class citizens over the hard life of pursuing freedom.
@@hlfbrwnhlfamzng Most palestinians in the west banks are mostly ruled by abbas, (area a and b) and are you sure there will be freedom if palestinians got their own government? as if there are any competent arabic/islamic(i dont support islamophobia) based nation except those ultra rich oil countries. And apparently there are no such thing as second class citizen for palestinians israeli if you watch the video when they say that they got their social benefits fully.
@@hlfbrwnhlfamzng if israel was resposible, then remove the PA and hamas, cuz rn they are in control, so blame them dumbass
@@zocon6 entire world is watching social media clips of the idf routinely running roughshod on Palestinians while illegal settlers get a free pass, these things have consequences.
@@hlfbrwnhlfamzng if is Israel is responsible why all other arab states are states without freedom, opportunities, equality and prosperity for all their nation?
لو كانت الحكومات الاسلامية افضل لما هرب الملايين العرب المسلمين من سوريا وفلسطين والعراق والمغرب والجزائر وتونس الى اوروبا. لماذا لا يعيش عرب فلسطين جنبا الى جنب مع بقية شعب اسرائيل ليتمتع بنظام اوروبي ديمقراطي متطور علميا وصحيا واجتماعيا بدلا من المعانات للهجرة الى اوروبا ؟ ماذا قدمت الحكومات الاسلامية لشعوبها غير الذل والاحتقار والفساد والارهاب والفقر والبطالة والنزاعات الطائفية والحروب من العراق الى اسفل زاوية من المغرب؟
Ya pero la diferencia esta en que nadie les a robado las tierras,te parece poco? ah por cierto satanyahu esta o lo juzg
Good for them God bless Israel from a Jordanian my neighbors and my brothers long live the state of Israel. Palestinians seem very happy under Israel control . I wish for peace and co-existence between nations.
Well said, i hope all you guys can prosper in peace soon. When you visit IL , please skip eilat.
@@dogbert52 why Eilat ?
@@thejordanianphilosopher6666 its hot, expensive , and i wasnt amazed. Not a lot to see other then the dolphins .
U jordans are disgusting. Not helping a single palestanian when they are ur neighbours
shk, they're liberated from Zionist rule and have the PA. Shouldn't they be happy??
It's really telling that almost every muslim israeli would prefer an israeli government.
Truth is all these jews came from the west and brought the good culture with it...it's not like them jews with horns can do shit..it's the European culture and it is indeed sueprior to current Arab one...and i am a muslim and Arab
@@Bambotb ok the fact that you say to be Muslim but then say that Islam is inferior makes me wonder on the truthfulness of what you are saying. But tell us, what are these superior traits?
@KA I agree with you, but that doesnt change the reality. If one country does a better job of keeping allies that help out their population, of course their citizens will prefer that leadership. I don't see how that makes my statement invalid.
Say the roles were reversed and muslims had more support and jews enjoyed living in muslim areas because of that. Would you still be using the same argument to criticize the arab nations because jews only like it there for the opportunities brought on by foreign aid?
@KA not completely true. israel didn't always have the financial backing of the US and would have been able to build the country from the kibbutz system which they were doing before they had the backing of the US. The kibbutz was a group where everybody worked and nobody got payed, but it was for the greater good and to build and develop for upcoming generations.Kind of like a form of communism
Because they ask arab on israel.. Why they do not have Arab in gaza.. And you Will know their answer
Note that this is the only country in the Middle East where Arabs can openly criticize the government in the country they reside in.
Hehe that's so true.
Tambien es el unico ente de okupacion de medio oriente que los gobernantes les importa un rabano lo que piensen y digan los ciudadanos
not true lebanese do it
Many Arabs serve in the IDF and are proud of it, as are their families.
Many IsraeliS choose to get jailed instead of serving IDF
@@serlyavt8016 Their problem.
@@serlyavt8016 not many.
@david guez This is why I will always support Israel. Israel allows others to exist, whilst theocracy would not. Unfortunate, but Hamas controlling the region Israel controls now would be absolutely absurd.
@@saintskillerdntfkwth Hamas poisons their youth's minds, medieval ideologies doesn't apply in 2021
What I have noticed is no Israeli Arabs protesting in favor of Hamas . They have been respectful of their country. Great citizens
Meanwhile western Gen Z students right now : FrEe PaLeStInE
the whole world can see how Israel care about their citizens , if its Jewish ,Arabs , Christians or any other.
Israel is the only real democracy and western country in the middle east, most Jewish & Arabs are in good relation .
its time the whole world to see it and admit about Israel which is here forever for all of her citizens .
all the others haters are because of politics reason and money problems.
god bless all of the good Arabs people who want to leave peaceful life in/with Israel as regular citizens without old thoughts .
at the end ,we are all brothers(Abraham sons) who separates by different stories
These people are not stupid, they have a good life & they know what would be coming under Hamas/Hezbollah…
Great Video. BBC and mainstream media should show this.
Problem is they get paid by muslim extreamists to push their agenda. They edit those viewpoints to fit the narrative
ISRAEL is a beacon of hope for the Middle East.
From a supporter of Israel from Pakistan.
God bless you
I never thought there were supporters in Pakistan .thx.
Thus, beacon is forbidden in Islam
And I hope that India invade you , and let see your answer , you are a traitor ..
@@The00802Why aren't you mad at the UAE ? Oh wait, then you can't go begging to the sheikhs for money.
Because they get full citizenship,
They have full rights as a Jew.
Why would they want Muslim government that would not give them full rights?
Like every other Muslim country
@Lilia murah
Maybe start with typing like a human being, not like a robot
Oh shit i didn't expect that
Most Israeli Muslim Arabs I met were like in the video happy living in Israel rather than a Palestinian state. I guess if you wanted to live in Palestinian Authority area or another Muslim country you could vote with your feet and go live in those places but there don't seem to be many people doing that. Free speech and fair voting is not an option in the Palestinian Authority areas or any of the many Muslim countries.
"but there don't seem to be many people doing that"
there are 3 million Palestinians in Jordan mand of whom are citizens now. There are about 500,000 Palestinians in Saudi, and about a 100,000 each in every other Gulf nation.
the total number of Arab-Israeli are ~1.8 million. There are more Palestinians in the Arab countries.
@@RMatt2016
500,000-700,000 Arabs fled from Israel to Arab Countries and became refugees.
850,000-950,00 Jews fled from Arab countries and became refugees.
Your ancestors and leaders with Arab countries have opened a war of annihilations on Israel and lost.
Palestinian leaders are the puppet of Israel even there own people hate mehmoud Abbas but there are many Arabs countries and Muslims countries where Jews are living with Muslims cousins . According to Israelis we are the God chosen people .
@@RMatt2016 I wouldn't count the peninsular Arab states since they live there as disposable second class non-citizens. Even my own country sends millions of underpaid immigrants a dime a dozen. As for Palestinians in Jordan, refugee is a more appropriate term. They never sought Jordan as a sea of dreams the way the seek Israel and the West. It's still a third world country at the end of the day.
@@adity.atiwari in Saudi Arabia, Palestinians often get renewable residence permits to remain in the country even if they runout of work. I didn't say that these people have "refugee" status. Just a special status that even other expat workers don't hold.
I am a citizen of Israel. I am not a Jew or an Arab but I still prefer the Jewish government because the Jews were able to make paradise in the Middle East. For half a century, Jews have been able to create a powerful economy, quality and affordable medicine, culture, science and social security. This country will continue to develop and soon become better than the most successful countries in Europe. Good luck to the Jews in creating paradise on earth.
🙏❤️🇮🇱❤️🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏🙏
can't blame these people for living the good life. Who wants revolution just for the fun of it?
@@RBlindWarlockR To be fair, it’s like that on both sides.
@@RBlindWarlockR as long as you live your not lost
Economics. People who's livelihood is secure are less likely to care about other rights and privilege
right!!
They live a good life in Israel. If it was a Palestine State, then their lives would be miserable like it is in Egypt, Jordan, Lebanon, Syria, etc.
Why would you hate a country/government that treats you well? Israeli Arabs, Jews, Muslims, Christians, Druze are Israeli, and all of them are given equal rights because Israel is a democratic country, it doesn't have "state religion" like Islamic countries. Israel is also a prosperous country, Jews are good in business and in governing a country. Even you, why would you want a government that harsh and poor like Hamas (terrorist organization), Palestinian government who hurts its own people...
@@phralvim cuz palestin never got a chance to grow. Always war. And israel got money from usa from the first time it made
@@wetakedown6860 they spend all their money on weapons what do you expect?
They want a free and fair state based on secular principles, where one community doesn’t get to impose their ways on the other, but all are free to live according to their values.
@david guez not right now
@david guez so we agree
Tell that to the Arabs controlling entire middle East... And imposing their ways on the minority communities
@@trendzservices9000 examples please
@@trendzservices9000 so would you apply the same standards to Europeans or any other race of people? Do you tell Europeans to fix Belarus or Japanese people to sort out the mess in North Korea? What have Palestinians got to do with Yemen or Syria or Iraq?
It's almost as most most people just want to live normal lives and the government's religion doesn't matter as much as how well they govern, and all the fighting is really. stupid....hmmm....
Because they live too well to pretend that their main problem is Israel
@KA goes to show when u put ur money in the right place u can flourish when I can’t say the say about most Arab nation getting funded cough cough Afghanistan getting trillions
@KA
Numbers please.
She asked for democracy...where can she find democracy in Arab countries?
"do you want insanity to govern or sanity to govern you"?
Funny, the leftists of the EU and the USA do not want to hear this))
Or Israel and Trump, they don’t want Palestine to exist at all
What is there to hear? It's just Israelis bigging up Israel... Ask Palestinians and they'll big up Palestine
dae lu maybe because the peace plan means taking more land from Palestine? No wonder they rejected the idea they only talked to Israel about it and not with the people they are trying to make peace with
@@SpeedyWings2323 Palestine is the Roman name for the territory in which the State of Israel was and where the Jews fought against the Roman Empire.
So who are the Palestinians? ))
Rogharg Trumpeldorf so you are basically telling me the current Palestine shouldn’t exist?
And here we are empathizing and sympathizing with the palestinians. It tur s out the're having better lives than we do in Morocco. More videos like these, please.
Yeah sorry no one is occupying your land bro.
@@KRAK107 Spain is. And to be honest moroccans living in ceuta and mlilia, the two cities occupied, are much much better.
@@yassineelhouari3085 Please provide us with your source of history information. Ceuta and Melilla have been (specially Ceuta) under christian governments for more centuries that some of european cities. And that is a clear sign of bonding with the western culture, and therefore, with Spain. Not Morocco. But please, show us your source of information and prove us wrong if that is the case. There is no occupation in Ceuta and Melilla.
These two cities are sovereign Spanish territory. They take up... I'm guessing around 0.0001% of Morocco's territory ? Calling that occupation is simply false.
@@ygm9913 When you provide yours, I'll provide mine. Everything I've read in your comment is just an empty claim of a land. Right now everybody is claiming that land, and it is under the sovereignty of Spain. When you go back to the history of Morocco and north Africa, you'll find that the first people to ever rule that land were the natives of north Africa, not the Europeans. It was then controlled by the Carthaginians , Greeks, Romans, Muslims/Arabs, and then the Spaniards. And now Morocco is claiming it because it belongs the native north Africans aka the current Moroccans.
There was a time when Morocco occupied most of Spain for almost 800 years. And that was way before Spain took over Ceuta and Melilla(which was given to Spain by Portugal I believe 200 years later byw) And there are a lot of cities in Spain that still hold Arabians Names, maybe Morocco should claim them as well.
My point is, if you dig deeper enough in history, everybody is entitled to every land you can think of. What matters is how long are you ready to go back in history. I don't wanna waste time in this. As for me, you have my total blessing. Keep it. And I'm planning to leave Morocco as a whole, so you can take it too if you want.
as Libyan Muslim, I prefer Israel than Palestine, because our Jews brothers respect Islam and Muslims and Quran recognized Israel and I can prove it
however, Palestine was one of Sykes-Picot plans that supported Pan -Arabism and made problem between Arabs and non Arabs in Middle East
🇱🇾❤🇮🇱 ☪️❤✡
I am Jewish Libyan from Israel.
I hope Netanyahu and Haftar will sign a peace agreement. My maternal granparents are from Tripoli and Benghazi.
....Wow , when you see that most of them said Israel , it suddenly makes you think Differently .....
This is a great question, and one of the best videos of the project.
I used to work as a trucker, 80% of my co-workers were israeli muslims - arabs and bedouins. We literally lived in trucks, making money like crazy. Every morning we used to get out of our trucks and pray together. Jews and muslims as one - for good day, good money, safety and less cops.
West bank and gaza....totally different story. I wont tell you how much rocks i got delivering goods for them. Like, you bring them food and they hit you. So much hate - no way to fix it.
Go back to Europe and return the land solution fixed it or else face the sequences in the future
@@ghst4487 who are you to tell me what to do?
@@Iron-Lion-Zion go ask your thief mom who I am invader. You will not prosper in that land you have to return it
I love your approach.. relaxed respectful loving and understanding.. you give people their voice just by asking questions on real matters.
wow, that was actually good. Young people are more idealistic, so they prefer Palestinian type of things but realistically, Arabs who live in Israel with citizenship and lived there for a long time, obviously prefer Jews to government them because they are more orderly.
Different education systems and media sources.
Respect to people who love their motherland and are not shy to admit it.
Or maybe there are those who are actually objective to the truth 🤣 Israel is the most free place in the Middle East
@@danielhunter6059That's why Israeli forces killed the Palestinian Journalist Yasser Mortaja while shooting their crimes? Is that how you define freedom?
@@docorwhatever2168 Well you can just say a name what was the intelligence behind them taking him out ? And what does that have to do with Arab Muslims having the most freedom in Israel
@@danielhunter6059 If freedom means being ok with the Israeli Forces killing my people , then fuck freedom.
@@docorwhatever2168 So is it okay for Hamas and the PLA having hits out on Israeli citizens
My favorite thing here was said around the middle of of the video where the Arab gentleman clearly referred to himself as Am Yisrael. עם ישראל חי ❤
Please send this video to all of the ignorants who say that Israel is an apartheid state.
Corey Gil-Shuster I like your videos because we get to hear opinions straight from the mouth of people instead of reading what the media has to say about them.
I commend all of these people for giving thoughtful answers to the questions. It's nice to see rational thinking. Also, if my biggest problem was a closed store on a Jewish holiday, my life would be awesome.
My son lived in Israel for a year and a half. As an American in Israel, one of the hardest adjustments is that their weekend is Friday and Saturday, with the workweek starting on Sunday. Also, on major holidays, the highways shut down, and it's illegal to drive on them. The younger Tel Aviv residents go out and do highway walks. My son said that was so cool! LOL!
Nice to hear your perspective! One small correction, there is only one day a year when people do not drive and that is Yom Kipur. I am not religious, but I think it’s a beautiful tradition that mixes the secular with the religious. I’m sure having one day a year with no cars is something we can do! And probably would benefit from doing more often…
Also of course if you have an emergency or anything like that, you can drive, say… to the hospital.
I wish for peace for everyone leaving here, and soon. We need it!
You know life is Good when they complain of not being able to shop on Saturday.
❤️🕊️❤️
I'm a Jew in America and we have laws which close shopping on Sundays in some parts of the country. Israel can have it too.
Same in Europe.
It depends on municipality laws and population size.
Please delete those laws
Thanks
which laws are these? source?
@@alinedasilvafrost7720 Sunday Blue Laws. Look at the laws in your state.
Why isn't this being reported to the USA by the USA media
As a non-muslim I want a secular state not like the Taliban.
Ask Pakistan to stop middling in Afghanistan’s affairs
@@khyberakberzai666it’s now coming back to bite pakistan
I have plenty Israeli Arab people, thier worst dream is to be under Arab country rules and specialy Palestinian rule...
At the end, no-one goes from a democratic state( even of not perfect) to a dictatorship for no reason
This is where distinguishing Israel proper (1967 borders) and the occupied territories becomes important. In the former, Palestinians enjoy the benefits of democracy, rule of law, and economic opportunities. This does not apply in the occupied territories, which were conquered (justly) in 1967 but remain frozen in a state of continuous military rule, settler expansion, and violent confrontation due to the failure of various attempts to find a long-term, peaceful arrangement.
Excellent video! Continue your great work! You may think it is a small way to educate the globe but it's huge! Thanks so much! 😊
Somebody send this to the bbc. Peace to all Jews and Arabs in Israel. X
And they call this an "Apartheid state"
Lol, the BBC would edit the shit out of this video...
👍👍👍👏🙏❤️🇮🇱❤️🇮🇱
Very enlightening!!!!
This video just restored a bit of hope in me.. just watched the video where you asked Palestinians in the west bank what their views on Israel were and it was very disheartening to hear people talk that way about their Jewish cousins. This video shows that there are many Israeli Arabs that are not radicalized, and are logical, rational people that only want to live in peace and prosper. Love this
This video is eye opening
Yes now I know that 🇮🇱 treat their ☪️ citizens in a good way
But I will still say that land belongs to 🇵🇸
But I don't want 🇮🇱 to be vanished anymore
☪️❤✡
THIS SAYS IT ALL!!!!!
But but but how!!! We thought israel is apartheid 🤣🤣🤣
@Archie TM 100%
But there are areas where if you aren't Jewish you can't live there. What would you call that?
@@cinnaminson0653 and the area that if you aren't an arab you can't live there what would you call that?
I am a Sri Lankan living in Sri Lanka. I have been following Israeli politics for 40 years. Israel is one of the best technologically and financially advanced countries. But Israel has the most weird politics in the world, even within Jews apart from Palestine issue . May god bless Israel. We are with you!.
No one shouts out their age like a Sri Lankan
As an Israeli Jewish I am so thankful for this video! Now all the ignorants can see the truth...🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱
🇮🇳❤️🇮🇱
🇮🇱 ❤🇸🇾
Dude, I agree on the shabbath (Saturday) issue but here in Egypt in Ramadan, they close like 90% of store, in some areas all stores are closed.
Shabbat sucks even to many secular jewish Israelis
great point. jews need just one place where we can live our lives, that's all. i know it's inconvenient for non-Jews in Israel on holidays, and I'm sure it can always be made better. being persecuted in the Muslim and Christian worlds for 2500 years with nowhere to go was inconvenient too tbh 😅
In New Jersey, all big stores/malls are closed Sunday. Super annoying, but I'm not moving countries due to that 😂😂😂😂
I'm not Christian but I miss when stores were closed on Sundays.
off course , the richest Arab middle class in the middle east , why would they want to change that
Avi Gayegos Really, no Arab country can compete?
Right, I want to hear from the poor.
@perakole no , because they had the opportunity and they used it . totally for it , good for them
@@AgeofReason there are poor people in any country but at least nobody dies in the streets and nobody is hungry
@perakole interesting points you made. By the way the state also confiscated christian and jewish properties and still didnt return it. A buddy of mine is still working on a lawsuite HIS GRANDPA started :/
What are the haters who say Israel is an apartheid gonna say now, this video hurts these haters feelings!
The thing is that most Palestinians don’t have isreali citizenship and they don’t have any rights and settlers keep taking over their houses. Isreal should let those people apply for citizenship but they must become Israeli and want isreali as one state for a better life and they would get the same rights as isreali but they must be loyal to the state of Isreal
Exactly! Is everything 100% fair? no. For one, Jewish Israelis have to fight in the IDF, it’s not compulsory for Arab Israelis. Arab Israelis can be discriminated against, but the Knesset works to enact discrimination laws to prevent that. Just like any other democracy, there are problems. But a democracy is the best possible way to run a country. By advocating for the destruction of Israel, protestors are trying to push an Islamic theocracy onto all people and, as you can see, not even the Israeli Arabs want that!
@@mirrorocean3852but Palestinians are not part of Israel. Why should they have Israelis rights and citizenship? They chose the Palestinians authorities and hamas to be their government. If they want to be an Arab-Israeli its w different story, as many as the people in this video chose, but Palestinians dont want it.
@@goolibay That’s because you fail to take full control of their education system. Normally when you won the war, you don’t expel local people but the education system and everything have to be under your control. You can pass assimilation laws. Most people want to live in peace in their homes, as long as you treat them as your citizens, people will follow. There would definitely be extremists that you have to get rid of. But for most people, you can take over by control their education system and medias. Promote inter marriage. Re education for adults too. That’s how you take over the territory and live in peace.
@@goolibay if equal rights, pretty sure Palestinians will have better quality of life under isreali Gov rather than PA. You need to take over their education system. Can’t let them grow up obsessing about liberation. They need to grow up thinking they are isreali or inseparable part of isreal. Give it a few decades and just annex the whole thing, but you must re educate them and treat them well.
That´s a GREAT question.
I stand with Israel.
Arabs are living in a good life in Israel. I have many jewish friends. They don't have discrimination. P
Among the people who answered they want full equality but with an Israeli / Jewish government - What this means is that Israel will join all Palestinians under Israel government and let all civilians have equal rights, including voting. The issue with this is that Israel will lose its legitimacy and demographic majority once that happens. Soon after, the jews will become a minority and the government will become arab, losing the first point made that Israeli / Jew government is better.
Besides that, what will probably happen later is that the Jews will be back to square one - they will be expelled again from their own country, with no state in the world as home.
The 1947 UN partition program came to solve that, stating clear lines and the clear difference between 2 different countries, but that was lost a long time ago.
Solutions are in search for 75 years now :)
The arabs should have accepted the 2 state solution in 1947 UN Partition Plan. They rejected it.
There was never a country or state called Palestine! 😮
What is the conviction rate of Palestinians in Israel?
95% of cases in the military courts end in conviction. Approximately 50% of Palestinian child detainees are held in prisons in Israel in breach of Article 76 of the Fourth Geneva Convention.
Here is how I sum up Arab Israelis:
Q: Do you live under occupation?
AI: Yes obviously!
Q: So you would prefer if you're under a Palestinian administration over Israeli?
AI: No heck wtf!
Right? This gives me a whiplash!! 🤯
On that video, someone gave the reason for being occupied that she can't visit other Muslim countries with her isreali passport. Total occupation!
I'm pretty sure because she has a Israeli passport. That's why Muslim countries don't want her in there because they don't like Israel.
@@lisastrecker6052 Whether Arab countries denied Arab Israelis to enter their country or not is not decision taken by Israel. They should blame those Arab countries themselves for denying their brethren.
I want to be ruled by Israel too lol. Loved the country
The last guy has no accent at all. There is no situation I would have thought he was an Arab if he had not identified himself.
כן, מטורף. הוא ישראלי לכל דבר. הוא בטוח לא יכול להתלונן על אי-שוויון, אי אפשר לזהות שהוא לא יהודי-ישראלי... שזה רק מראה כמו הוא חלק מהמדינה וכמה טוב לו במדינה שלנו 🇮🇱🇮🇱❤
Last guy is full fledged israelis even speaks with the same hand motions, nobody would be able to ever tell he is arab
My son lived in Israel for a year and a half. Arabs are very satisfied in Israel and treated very well. Tensions can run high in Jerusalem, largely due to the shared holy site of Al-Aqsa Mosque and the Temple Mount, but 99% of the time, life in Israel is peaceful, contemporary, and progressive with a good life for all people living in Israel...Israelis, Arabs, Europeans, Americans...everyone!
On kibbutz in Israel many years ago, I recall Arab Israelis saying how well treated they were by kibbutz people
Very interesting, should be streamed on Main Media…
The rest of the world think Israeli and Jew is the same, unfiltered interview like this is so eye opening.
You mean the world thinks 100% of the citizens of Israel are Jews, which is false.
3:44 explained the reasons why people living in Arab speaking countries wants to immigrate to 1st world countries.
Also because we’ve spent decades bombing their countries.
Arabs in Israel 🇮🇱 enjoy more freedom, higher education, longer lives, better health-care, and more security than in any of the 22 Arab states.
They wouldn't want to live in any of them.
And they wouldn't even prefer to live in Germany, as Arabs from Arab states do. Millions of them pour into Europe from Morocco, Algeria, Tunisia, Libya, Egypt, Syria, Lebanon, Iraq, Yemen, Somalia, Sudan, Kuwait and even Saudi Arabia to escape the horrors of living in an Arab state.
But you will not find Arabs migrating from Jaffa, Acre or Nazareth. Because they have wonderful lives. *Those are the basic facts.*
@@SimonKanner-si3it You do pose a point there. Peace and unity is the work of both parties.
@@SimonKanner-si3it Germany is Anti-Semitic which means racism for Jews and muslims, I know I'm 5 months late but anti-semitism is now illegal in germany
Then why u are attacking Gaza strip and occupied West Bank the these are the only area Palestinean has
What do you mean? At least Arabs are willing to live in the UAE, Qatar, and Kuwait
Simon Kanner
So why don’t they flock to the west if they have it so bad under isrealis? Please stop making excuses for them
'It's more than what I earn, but that's ok' 🤣
This is not just an Israeli issue, No one want to live in a non secular Muslim world. Not even the Muslims. The problem is when Muslim become the majority, the secularity of the state start to fade.
Wouldnt it be amazing if the two could live peacefully side by side, an let the world visit unrestricted an see the land were the three religions came from
@efopo full military occupation of the area ?
@efopo ya cant fly to palestine direct,
@efopo That land is where the three religions came from its referenced in all the holy books. Some day Israel an Palestine will live side by side , peacefully an be greatful of each others company.
@efopo Have a little read of the Christian bible . Goes into detail.
@@martinorourke7483 as peacefull as jugoslavia