Why Graded Comics Are The WORST (And I LOVE Them)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 10 янв 2025

Комментарии •

  • @Shiznaft1
    @Shiznaft1 Год назад +20

    I have around 10k comics and none of them are slabbed. I have little interest in grading, it always felt like a hustle and I keep my books because I like them. I bag and board and keep them in a good environment but paying 30 to 40 dollars for a grade is not something I am interested in.

    • @doctornesneb3955
      @doctornesneb3955 Год назад +1

      I’m a fan of raw comic books as well. However, I am new to the hobby. I think I only have around 1,000 books. Are any of your books breaking down? Or do the bags and boards in a good environment protect them well?

    • @dankcastle9092
      @dankcastle9092 Год назад +3

      @@doctornesneb3955, I have 10k+ books also. If rarely handled and properly stored, the comics should be fine. However, I’ve noticed that over 7-10 years, I have to switch out some of the bag and boards because they get this weird dingy yellow look. I hoping the newer bag and boards are better quality.

    • @dankcastle9092
      @dankcastle9092 Год назад +1

      I went through a period where I went overboard with slabs…I find top loaders give me the same satisfaction

    • @ScoutReaper-zn1rz
      @ScoutReaper-zn1rz Год назад +1

      @@dankcastle9092 That's just oxidation. I also notice that certain comics make the bag bubbly and wavy, mainly pre 90's comics but some new ones as well.

    • @dankcastle9092
      @dankcastle9092 Год назад

      @@ScoutReaper-zn1rz interesting, now that you mentioned it, I have noticed in the past replacing bags and boards because of dinge and warped bags (on the older comics)

  • @M3n747
    @M3n747 Год назад +4

    I feel like I just watched a Chinese lecture on ancient Greek, basically. :D

  • @dantooine4279
    @dantooine4279 Год назад +1

    There are a lot of people dedicating their lives to tracking down 'raw' books and pressing/cleaning etc and sending off for grading - then flipping for a massive profit. I say good for them! It's not something I could give so much time and effort to, so it's not something I would do. But I can't knock people who do. I've got 15k comics and selling them off cheap just to clear my house! If someone makes a profit on them or just reads and enjoys them it's all good.

  • @The_Doom_Abides
    @The_Doom_Abides Год назад

    My oldest comic book is about a yr old. My entire collection from childhood on was stolen in a breaking and entering of my storage unit and I lost everything. Killed the hobby for me for a long time until last yr when I picked up a Dr doom cover of FF. I had the bug again immediately and now I have a small collection I'm working on but nothing worth what I once had unfortunately

  • @derrickfelsen7250
    @derrickfelsen7250 Год назад +2

    Yellow label books are not the most desired. Blue label books are the most desired. Signature series books have there place but most collectors want high grade blue label examples.... For example a Ultimate Fallout #4 Djurdjevic variant signature series 9.8 sold for 10,000.00 less then a blue label 9.8 example during the same auction at Heritage's Premiere Auction. Many collectors look at signatures on comics as defacing the book.

  • @andrewspecht6360
    @andrewspecht6360 Год назад

    I was given a copy of Avengers #66 (July 1969)when I was 6 from my groovy 1st grade teacher (I’d won some sort of best behavior contest) I kept that sucker flat and out of direct (or any) light it wasn’t till 5-6 years later that it was first bagged it and another 10 years before I boarded it. Around 8 years ago I decided (considering I had reader copies a digital copy and a hardcover with that issue) to slab it. The book came back a 9.0 with white/ off white pages! Proof positive that I was one of THE finickiest kids alive… and part of me still is! Oh and I freaking love Gene Colan’s art on Iron-Man (I’ve a 7.0 slabbed) The Avengers, Daredevil, Howard The Duck I’ve only recently discovered his Batman work which varies depending on who was inking it

  • @curtisnordstrom
    @curtisnordstrom Год назад

    As a 40 year old i have an Amazing Spider-Man 42 folded open to the “Face it Tiger you hit the jackpot” page and hanging on my wall. One of my 2 slabbed books is Amazing Spider-Man 39 because i wanted to display it on my desk as my favourite comic, cover and GG is my favourite villain

  • @dankcastle9092
    @dankcastle9092 Год назад +1

    There was a time I went overboard with slabs. Nowadays, I find the same satisfaction with toploaders.

  • @goldschool9050
    @goldschool9050 Год назад +2

    Some comics need to be protected

  • @CoachDale_TopNotchMuayThai
    @CoachDale_TopNotchMuayThai Год назад +1

    Bro haha I found a ASM 323 signed by The Todd Father in a book store for $14. For that book, and it being my first book I’ve shipped out to get slabbed. I felt that one needed to be in a slab. With the Todd McFarlane sig on it, it means lots to me being able to own something like that, so I wanted it kept save so decided to slab that one.
    I only have 2 slabbed books right now because I’m a Raw kinda guy. I love reading comics, the smell of comics, holding them and just flipping through my boxes here and there.
    I get the whole slabbed market, and it’s cool. But for me it’s Raw books all the way

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад

      That's an awesome find for $14!

    • @CoachDale_TopNotchMuayThai
      @CoachDale_TopNotchMuayThai Год назад

      @@peterdaremedia Yea bro I was stoked ! I sent if off back in December and just got it back the other week. Came back a 8.0

  • @flipthrough6806
    @flipthrough6806 Год назад +1

    I took 20,000 this year and invested in Comics several key issues. So far today I have made $73,458 off that $20,000 investment. And that’s better than any stock I ever invested in. My friend two years ago made 300,000 give or take a couple of thousand on investing in Comics. How does that saying go? laughing all the way to the bank.😂😂😂

  • @FortressMT
    @FortressMT Год назад +3

    This is an outstanding presentation. Hope this gets a lot more hits. Great topic and a lot of people are interested to know this stuff. That being said, what do you recommend is the better grading organization and approach to getting comics graded? Could you give your viewers a walk-through of the grading process?

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +1

      I appreciate the kind words! And yes I'm hoping to do a video about the grading process in the near future, so stay tuned!

  • @retropyro
    @retropyro Год назад +1

    Honestly for me, I prefer the blue label over a yellow any day. I don't care about signatures at all. If anything, I think it ruins it.

  • @wtcvidman
    @wtcvidman Год назад

    I've been into comics since the 80s and I forget which was the absolute first one I got. It might have been those reprints that CVS used to sell in 3 packs featuring Marvel, DC, Epic and other comics. I got tons of Spider-Man, Batman & Superman books though, especially Spider-Man where I have every Amazing Spider-Man from 238 (Hobgoblin's 1st appearance) through somewhere in the 380s and started working my way backwards (also have #400 & a few newer ones) as well as most of the old Spectacular Spider-Man issues from #1 through somewhere in the 200s (I know I'm missing a bunch in the middle I still need to get) and Wed of Spider-Man #1 through the 110's (I think nothing missing) and some of the McFarlane 1990 Spider-Man series and other books with him & characters of the Spidey books like Venom, etc (Secret Wars I & II, The Trial of Venom Unicef book I sent away for, Deathtrap: The Vault, Spider-Man vs. Wolverine, etc). Also got some Flash, X-Men, Hulk, Masters of the Universe, Blue Beetle, Image & Valiant titles from 1993-1994 (some #1s & #0s), Quasar, Nighthawk, and many others I can't remember off the top of my head.
    The idea of people getting into comics because of a movie is garbage, though I believe you that it happens. Those movies all suck imo (last ones I enjoyed were in the 2000s and they were far from perfect) and to think Johnny Come Latelies show up and buy comics of a character they know nothing about is lame & pathetic. If they knew or cared about said character, they wouldn't need a movie to get them hyped to buy books on that character. Just so wrong like so many things these days.
    Good job on the video though. I like your style and the quality of the video, so keep up the good work. You got my subscription.

  • @kratoscraken5614
    @kratoscraken5614 Год назад +3

    Out of collecting, comics are the most popular of all fields of collecting. I'm a veteran collector and even I am still surprised at what I have and what I find so trust me bro I feel you in this video 👍

  • @RunMeThrough
    @RunMeThrough Год назад +1

    I have no desire to sell off my slabs. I don’t own many, I can literally count the amount on both my hands. That being said, I’m happy with anything that is an 8.5 or higher.
    I am also curious why you felt Adam Warlock was interesting in GotG3. Imo he was an ignorant, mamas boy that spent the entire movie falling down and passing out. They did him dirty. But, to each their own “they” say.

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +2

      I definitely think Warlock was a little under-powered in the movie, but that’s pretty close to how he is in his very early appearances. I’m curious to see how they handle him in the future

    • @RunMeThrough
      @RunMeThrough Год назад +1

      @@peterdaremedia I can’t argue with that. To the future of Marvel movies 🍻

  • @christophermosca4547
    @christophermosca4547 Год назад

    I agree with with @Shiznaft1. I've been reading comic books for nearly 50 years. In the all the years of reading, and collecting, in the old days, if you bought from a dealer, you had to accept the pricing and grading that they gave. To now have people insisting they won't pay you guide price, because it's not been valued by CGC , is beyond ridiculous and seems to reek , scam. Another aspect is that if you wanted to grade all of your older books that could cost tons of $$$. would you even recoup the money ? I don't think so. We're having to trust in the skill of random reviews by people we're trusting know what they're doing , and randomly have to do this, to get full value ? What if the dealer I bought a classic Silver Age comic , did the best he could, charged me good price, and it's Good - , or slightly less, based on the CGC team. What if they're too nitpicky and the dealer was actually more spot on ? Then we paid one price, the allegedly professional evaluator is off, and now we have a book that has an incorrect value that we'd have sell at the incorrect price, if you want to do it the new "right way". And what happens to the Overstreet price guide ? and again, I'm going to go back and say.... what about all the decades of buying at non CGC pricing. I think the CGC thing is overblown and helping to hurt the industry. Now we're setting up multiple standards that didn't exist , and these companies are getting rich off the misinformation about this service.

  • @terryfloyd3505
    @terryfloyd3505 Год назад +1

    agree with most of this. But, comis werent meant to last forever. and even in those tombs that people put them in, they are a paper product, which degrades, even in there. SO, sooner or later, all those people that have those comics in those tombs, they are gonna have to come out of them. ANYTHING that the grading companies offer you can do yourself. Even art that is in museums need to be taken down and worked on from time to time. If there was a way to make them last forever they probably would be using it. And if you take one of those 100 buck slabs with the 3 dollar comic in them with a 9.8 in it, break it open, and try to sell the book to someone thats right there watching you do it, do you think they are going t pay you 100 bucks or 3, Thanks, keep up the good videos:P

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +1

      Thanks for the comment! I agree with your sentiment pretty much. I find it really interesting how comic books seem to be treated differently in terms of preservation than other art forms

  • @Jezee213
    @Jezee213 Год назад

    I bought A bunch of issues of She Hulks first solo series a few years ago and when the show came out the values went up! I got 2 graded at 9.0 and 9.2 on the first issue and last, I still have them all I don't own a lot of graded stuff but any issue that means something to me I consider getting graded so yea...

  • @josh27021
    @josh27021 Год назад +2

    I always graded mine after one read , I'm 45 now so I got some gems : )

  • @JasonJulian-fi5ud
    @JasonJulian-fi5ud Год назад +1

    thought you were DONE with comics, dude. Thats what you CLAIMED. I knew it.....
    SMH!

  • @harrisonprice2118
    @harrisonprice2118 Год назад +2

    I was super surprised when I saw your subscriber count! With this high quality video you will be gaining subs super fast! Love the video keep it up!

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +2

      Thank you so much!! I appreciate the support

  • @aftacomics5865
    @aftacomics5865 Год назад

    Yes! You're right on the money! "Not for sale at any price!" I get it. I am not a slabber, but I certainly understand it. I think (Even if I view myself as your age) I'm one of those older collectors who started in 1969 and still read my books. But if I were selling? That would change/
    I'm glad I found your channel!

  • @greaseball83
    @greaseball83 Год назад

    I always buy double one for investing and one for reading. I'm not going to read a Hulk 180 or 182 first print. I'll read a reprint

  • @WakandaForever1776
    @WakandaForever1776 Год назад

    There's gonna be another comic crash with all these slabbed comics and still making variant covers. What's even dumber is graded video games, specially new already sealed games. Some company was making sealed boxes with no games and selling them on Ebay ....then you wonder if that game you just bought is even in the sealed slab.

  • @jarredsmith9187
    @jarredsmith9187 Год назад

    I been collecting for over 15 years and only buying keys,low print runs and rare variants cause those are the only books that will hold there value but my collection is almost complete,I just have 4 books left to get but they cost thousands a Batman#1,X-Men#1, AMS#129 and TMNT#1 then I am done collecting .Can you do a video on your top 10 comics?

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +1

      Good idea! I’ll add that to my list of potential comics

  • @ThatJohnKillion1970
    @ThatJohnKillion1970 Год назад

    I have a few 70's Superman comics. I had some Spider-Man, but those are long gone.

  • @joncarroll2040
    @joncarroll2040 10 месяцев назад

    If you're not buying for speculation purposes (a fool's game unless you're able to afford to deal in super high value gold/silver/bronze age books), you're much better off getting a book you like professionally framed than paying for a grade.

  • @jadecasssie
    @jadecasssie Год назад

    First comics i ever got were the Spiderman collectibles series. I had every issue and they got destroyed when our basement flooded. I plan to buy them all as a set soon as i can

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +1

      Sorry to hear that happened to you!! Best of luck picking up the set again

    • @jadecasssie
      @jadecasssie Год назад

      @@peterdaremedia thanks!

  • @roberterwine7650
    @roberterwine7650 Год назад

    I don't understand why pay so much money for a book and then display it , exposing it to light and damaging it ?

  • @PainInTheS
    @PainInTheS Год назад

    54 000 comics.....none graded, no backboards....F that nonsense. Now bags I understand against yellowing, but other than that.....meh!
    I have comics where pages are loose, but I got them early in life and will not part with them.

  • @douglassallenbach3975
    @douglassallenbach3975 Год назад

    Darkhawk #1. It was the first floppy i bought. Its faded, bent, toen, and well read.

  • @fraticelli510
    @fraticelli510 Год назад

    I just bought venom #1 lethal protector un-graded I was super happy

  • @dalemoyers8881
    @dalemoyers8881 Год назад

    This is the first time watching one of your videos. I really enjoyed the content. Your views on the subject are similar to mine. I only collect for my personal use and not to sell them. I do not currently own any graded copies but I am considering sending several off to be graded that I just want to preserve for the future. Keep up the good work. 😎

  • @LandMisfitComics
    @LandMisfitComics Год назад

    For CGC labels i like the gold label aka Pedigree books from the likes of the Mile High Collection, San Francisco, Larson, Rockford and recent Promise Collection. Grading is subjective and CGC made a lot of mistakes which you can publicly see in the CGC and other forums. For me no slabbing for me until the day my son and i decide to sell it all. I hate grading but it does provide higher liquidity vs raw.

  • @phoenixmight5971
    @phoenixmight5971 Год назад

    Personally I don't see the reason to speculate on modern comics. I can't think of many that hold real value

  • @blackmagicfan3431
    @blackmagicfan3431 Год назад

    The only thing I like about graded comics is being able to buy a book that has been graded by a third party to avoid restoration and the like when you can't buy the book in person but it really isn't my jam to keep a book slabbed.

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад

      that totally makes sense. do you have a good process for cracking open slabs? I've definitely considered doing it if I find a good deal

    • @blackmagicfan3431
      @blackmagicfan3431 Год назад

      @@peterdaremedia I used to do it the way most on others do but now start by pinching the label end in a vice grip and zip the edges with a dremel first... not enough to go through, just to make it easier

  • @BrettL-p2s
    @BrettL-p2s Год назад +1

    where are people buying and selling comics these days?

    • @peterdaremedia
      @peterdaremedia  Год назад +1

      Mostly eBay, also still a big presence at conventions and local shops

  • @bluesclues9766
    @bluesclues9766 4 месяца назад

    a 9.8 is nice but a real goal is to try and get a 0.1.

  • @LandMisfitComics
    @LandMisfitComics Год назад

    My MARVEL Transformers #1 is dear to me as my parents bought me that straight from the local comic store. It was sat on by my dad accidentally. I color touched the spine WTF?? Nevertheless i have 4 copies total now along with a sealed 3 pack that you find hanging on those spinner racks!

  • @michaeldy3157
    @michaeldy3157 Месяц назад

    I would open it up and read it. Do not care about grading

  • @buffbeenstuffed
    @buffbeenstuffed Год назад

    cool new channel that stumbled into my feed wish you the best and I'll be watching

  • @hoardershide
    @hoardershide Год назад +1

    How do you only have 90 subs?

  • @Vp-jt3vl
    @Vp-jt3vl Год назад +1

    Great vid, new sub!

  • @doctorvonhoot
    @doctorvonhoot Год назад +1

    New sub. Great video. Nice one!

  • @MetalBum
    @MetalBum Год назад

    I love comics. Graded and non graded raw. Both. 😊😊

  • @Ready4Wednesday
    @Ready4Wednesday Год назад +2

    Great video👍

  • @DrHUGEshow
    @DrHUGEshow Год назад

    BlackRock owns CGC. Ew

  • @LegionofComics
    @LegionofComics Год назад

    Awesome video. You got my sub #WeAreLegion

  • @davidallen4026
    @davidallen4026 Год назад

    I liked Solo!

  • @tylerdurden788
    @tylerdurden788 Год назад

    Interesting subject.

  • @johncruelty20
    @johncruelty20 Год назад

    interesting, you've got a sub

  • @michaelhband
    @michaelhband Год назад

    👍👍👍❤❤❤