They say a masterpiece is a work you keep going back to...but what do you say to a masterpiece that just gets better everytime you go back to it? That is the genius of Beethoven, every note enters into your cells.
Einmalig, exzellentes Konzert,! Alles stimmt, die Solisten jeder ein Meister in ihren Instrumenten, das HR Symphonie Orchester und der Direktor, Bravo Bravo!! Für mich, die beste Version des Beethovens Trippel Konzert überhaupt!
Watched this again, becoming my favorite version of the Tripelkonzert! - many others available, but the magic of this one is neverending... it is a musical monument that typifies in a small way... what CIVILIZATION is all about.
I love Gil so much, with his incessant smile and pure joy he approaches every piece, but this particular time Anne Gastinel was the undisputed star of the entire performance. Magnificent rendition under Maestro Järvi 's inspired conducting!
Quelle entente, et quelle mise en place de la part de tous ces musiciens, solistes, maestro et orchestre ! de la virtuosité à tous les étages, avec toutes les nuances, et surtout une joie de jouer ce chef-d'œuvre ensemble. Une remarquable version de concert.
What would we do without this wonderful Frankfurt orchestra? and then we are blessed with admirable and multi-talented soloists.... added to which we have a fabulous sound technology... all at a bad time for the world.... thank you again, so very much. Great appreciation from the UK.
Je n’y connais pas grand chose mais l’œuvre est splendide, le chef et les musiciens de haut vol. Un penchant prononcé pour Anne Gastinel: élégance et grâce un rien austère, tellement séduisante !
That Rondo alla Polacca was remarkably well executed. A musical jewel. Congratulations to the soloists, the Orchestra, and the marvelous conductor for making this possible.
Streaming it now on tv. What a bittersweet memory of the late Great Pianist Nicholas Angelich! The amazing soloists Nicholas Angelich, Gil Shaham, Anne Gastinel, Sinfonieorchester conducted by impeccable Paavo Järvi are all that needed to make Beethoven: Tripelkonzert sound so exquisite! Thank you.
A very beautiful concert. Yes Gil Shazam is a great violinist but I really like this cellist. A wonderful cellist. All three soloists are so wonderful. Such a pleasure.
I love the delicacy of this sprightful interpretation of this delightful Beethoven concerti - so many others to feast on, but this one is precious - can one "feast" on a piece of music - I guess they can. The orchestra and the absolutely fabulous soloists... and the wonderful Paavo Järvi gave ALL they had. What a feast it was... and is. How lucky to be able to view all of these superb musicians and conductor for this "feast" that can be heard over and over. Thank you, RUclips!
This is definitely the best version of the Triple Concerto which I have ever watched. There's a lot going on, with three soloists, the orchestra and the conductor, but they all work so well together as a team, to produce a seamless and inspirational performance. The Rondo final is particularly memorable. Overall, this is just brilliant!
This is an exciting performance of the most "classical", least performed, but charming and exquisite, of Beethoven's concerti. It brings out all of its good-natured energy and many touches of genius. I appreciate this work more each time I hear it, especially in this sparkling rendition!
Der Dialog zwischen den drei Solisten ist sehr intim und zugleich perfekt synchronisiert. Der seidige Ton der Solovioline, der milde Ton des Cellos und der brillante Ton des Klaviers sind wirklich wunderschön. Der Dirigent kontrolliert das ganze Orchester echt künstlerisch mit angemessenen Tempi und zurückgehaltener Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Gil Shaham will be remembered well into the next century and beyond. Triple Concerto was fantastic. I saw him (Gil Shaham) in the other RUclips presentations. The Internet and IPhone are amazing.
Gil Shaham is the most exciting performer. I have met him several times and seen him 10-12 times. He is more gracious, friendly and nice as anyone I have ever met. I met him when he was 24 and now he is in his 40s. It has been a great 20 years of following him. That is what a truly extraordinary artist can do to someone like me and many others. I hope he lives a very, very long time.
Himmlisch gut! Ich habe diese Aufnahme mindestens 50 mal gehört und freue mich auf die nächsten 50 mal. Das Werk ist göttlich und die Interpretation hinreißend. Danke den Musikern. Ich liebe es!
In some ways I felt like I was hearing this piece for the very first time because of the excellent performers who all played with such passion and commitment. Bravo!!!
Damn the cellist popped off. I keep coming back to this recording because of her. Also the pianist's trill is insane, at one point it becomes almost undetectable.
My most admired orchestra HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie sur the baton of Maestro Järvi and with three fabulous soloist have given us a super performance of this superb Beethovenian concerto. Thank you. Special mention to the girl with long blonde hair turning the score pages for the pianist.
Das ist toll, dass Sie diese Konzert-Aufzeichnung ins Netz gestellt haben. Dem im Vergleich zu Beethovens Klavierkonzerten oder seinem Violinkonzert nicht so tiefem Tripelkonzert geben die drei Solisten, das Orchester und der Dirigent eine ungeahnte Tiefe durch Ausloten der Dynamik, phantastischen Spannungsbögen sowie lustvoller Gestaltung in vielen kleinen Details. Eine wundervolle Mischung aus tiefem Ernst, grosser Freude am Musizieren sowie einer echten Liebe zum Werk und zu den eigenen Instrumenten.
Eine wunderbar „entspannte“ Darbietung, bei der die von den Musikern und dem Dirigenten offensichtlich empfundene Freude am Musizieren mich gefangen nimmt, eimmal ganz abgesehen von der sowieso bekannten fachlichen Qualität der Akteure. Der lange und begeisterte Applaus erscheint mir sehr gerechtfertigt.
Magnificent demonstration of excellence, brilliance, superb technical mastery and undisputed collective musicality perfectly blended into a performance of absolute perfection. Bravissimo.
excelente interpretación, sensacional!! Muy buenos solistas. Dirección impecable, de una buena orquesta. Larga y merecida ovacion. Felicitaciones a todos ellos. Gracias por compartir el video. Sin duda me gusto la obra.
es wäre noch viel schöner anzusehen, wenn die Cellistin und der Geiger so säßen, dass sie sich gegenseitig sehen können und dann noch mehr miteinander interagieren würden. Trotzdem eine wunderbares Stück und eine tolle Interpretation!!!
An exceptional performance of this masterpiece! Beethoven, the supreme genius! One of his greatest compositions! The orchestra under maestro Jaarvi, couples with superb virtuosity of soloists to carve out this marvelous performance! Never heard better! The cellist really excels! Thanks for post! Jamshed Delvadavala from Mumbai.
Tres solistas interpretes maravillosos, a la altura de esta genial e insuperable obra cuyo medio enviado por Dios como transmisor simplemente fue y será eternamente ese genial hombre llamado Beethoven. Bravo !!, y también a la orquesta y su director.
I remember buying the DGG LP around 1965. It was my first DGG recording and it cost around $6.00, series bread in those days. I have long-since moved on from vinyl, but I always remember the casual photograph of the musicians, all of them in open collars and smoking.
Wunderbar, für mich die völlige Entspannung. Schön wäre ein Schnitt gewesen, der das Stimmen der Instrumente nach dem 1. Satz entfernt hätte. Im Konzert sitzend stört es mich nicht aber hier schon. Das Orchester und die Solisten sind aber von großer Qualität.
Gil Shaham's sound in this performance is particularly delightful, as is the cellist. The piano is great, but in my view is slightly over loud in the balance of the recording. Some interesting shots in the filming, I hope the musicians were warned in advance to wash behind their ears. Gil Shaham's enjoyment of the playing by the other performers, such as the cello opening in the second movement, is really nice.
Though I still prefer the Argerich and Capuchon brothers version, this one was all one could ask for. And anytime I see Jarvi on the podium I know I'm in for a good time. Same with the FRSO--my favorite orchestra.
Esecuzione all'altezza del Compositore, il perfezionista Beethoven ne sarebbe soddisfatto.Eccellenti i Professori solisti e gli Orchestrali sono di massimo livello
This was a wonderful recording marred only by the foolish comments of some of the listeners; one who complained about Anne's playing because she was a woman, another annoyed by Gil's E string that was too shrill for his ears. The fault, dear Brutus, was in too much treble inserted by the Sound Engineer. Note that for a moment or two the video wasn't sharp enough because the automatic lens adjustment didn't work properly. It's a good thing that there's no automatic placement of fingers on fingerboards. The musicians have to do that themselves. The result was there was no one out of tune.
This is the most charming music -for me- by Bee. Many, not all, of the rest of his music tends to be -for me again- somewhat too romantically poised and even egotistical at times. This is just pure music.
This genius fiddler,s performance makes me feel the pathetic of life and the suffering , sadness , and joy when people live . The mind of this genius fiddler might have reached the abyss of man,s soul . 🍎 From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan . Which national are you watching this video ？
amazing. but tip to producers: when the cellist has one of the best solos in the repertoire, maybe focus on her! ugh second movement opening was a mess of focus.
Si bien el Cello es clave en este trio, es muy significativa la interpretación del violinista quien le da una sonoridad hermosa y delicada al trío, tal vez muy golpeado por el pianista. Muy bueno, muy integrado entre solistas y orquesta aunque, a veces, demasiado rudo por el píano. Grande el violín.
![Duet no. 2 [revision+recording]](/img/1.gif)
They say a masterpiece is a work you keep going back to...but what do you say to a masterpiece that just gets better everytime you go back to it? That is the genius of Beethoven, every note enters into your cells.
Amen to that!
Danke, dass es Euch alle gibt: Musiker, Dirigent, Techniker, hr-Sinfonieorchester. Ihr verschönert das Leben anderer.
Ja das stimmt
Einmalig, exzellentes Konzert,!
Alles stimmt, die Solisten jeder ein Meister in ihren Instrumenten, das HR Symphonie Orchester und der Direktor, Bravo Bravo!!
Für mich, die beste Version des Beethovens Trippel Konzert überhaupt!
Yup easily the best rendering of this composition
Watched this again, becoming my favorite version of the Tripelkonzert! - many others available, but the magic of this one is neverending... it is a musical monument that typifies in a small way... what CIVILIZATION is all about.
I love Gil so much, with his incessant smile and pure joy he approaches every piece, but this particular time Anne Gastinel was the undisputed star of the entire performance. Magnificent rendition under Maestro Järvi 's inspired conducting!
Gil and Angelich made Anne a little ⭐️ 🥰👏🏻
I have never seen a more pleasant interaction between musicians...the cellist and the lead violinist were just amazing...WoW!
Everything Mr. Jarvi does is the best!
Quelle entente, et quelle mise en place de la part de tous ces musiciens, solistes, maestro et orchestre ! de la virtuosité à tous les étages, avec toutes les nuances, et surtout une joie de jouer ce chef-d'œuvre ensemble. Une remarquable version de concert.
What would we do without this wonderful Frankfurt orchestra? and then we are blessed with admirable and multi-talented soloists.... added to which we have a fabulous sound technology... all at a bad time for the world.... thank you again, so very much. Great appreciation from the UK.
Je n’y connais pas grand chose mais l’œuvre est splendide, le chef et les musiciens de haut vol.
Un penchant prononcé pour Anne Gastinel: élégance et grâce un rien austère, tellement séduisante !
That Rondo alla Polacca was remarkably well executed.
A musical jewel.
Congratulations to the soloists, the Orchestra, and the marvelous conductor for making this possible.
Streaming it now on tv. What a bittersweet memory of the late Great Pianist Nicholas Angelich! The amazing soloists Nicholas Angelich, Gil Shaham, Anne Gastinel, Sinfonieorchester conducted by impeccable Paavo Järvi are all that needed to make Beethoven: Tripelkonzert sound so exquisite! Thank you.
Il secondo movimento di questo concerto e' pura Poesia idilliaca! L' ovazione del Publico e' tutta meritata !
A very beautiful concert. Yes Gil Shazam is a great violinist but I really like this cellist. A wonderful cellist. All three soloists are so wonderful. Such a pleasure.
I love the delicacy of this sprightful interpretation of this delightful Beethoven concerti - so many others to feast on, but this one is precious - can one "feast" on a piece of music - I guess they can. The orchestra and the absolutely fabulous soloists... and the wonderful Paavo Järvi gave ALL they had. What a feast it was... and is. How lucky to be able to view all of these superb musicians and conductor for this "feast" that can be heard over and over. Thank you, RUclips!
This is definitely the best version of the Triple Concerto which I have ever watched. There's a lot going on, with three soloists, the orchestra and the conductor, but they all work so well together as a team, to produce a seamless and inspirational performance. The Rondo final is particularly memorable. Overall, this is just brilliant!
Probably one of the best recordings available. Definitely under the best three.
Beethoven incomparable, insuperable, grandioso.Gracias por este momento de paz
This is an exciting performance of the most "classical", least performed, but charming and exquisite, of Beethoven's concerti. It brings out all of its good-natured energy and many touches of genius. I appreciate this work more each time I hear it, especially in this sparkling rendition!
Agreed. This was a crisp, wonderfully done rendition. Thoroughly enjoyable. As an amateur cellist I enjoyed watching her play.
@@craigcowing1107 も8お9
Nicholas Angelich riposi in pace . E' andato via troppo presto.
1st movement
1:09 begins | 11:55 repeat intro | 17:43 ending
2nd movement
19:16 begins
l'une des meilleures performances de cette oeuvre sublime...Bravissimo a tutti!!
Der Dialog zwischen den drei Solisten ist sehr intim und zugleich perfekt synchronisiert. Der seidige Ton der Solovioline, der milde Ton des Cellos und der brillante Ton des Klaviers sind wirklich wunderschön. Der Dirigent kontrolliert das ganze Orchester echt künstlerisch mit angemessenen Tempi und zurückgehaltener Dynamik. Einfach wunderbar!
Instablaster
@@daltonjameson1506 Heißt das soviel wie 'unerträglicher Schwätzer'?
베토벤의 또다른 음악을 발견 했습니다 참 줗습니딘
Gil Shaham will be remembered well into the next century and beyond. Triple Concerto was fantastic. I saw him (Gil Shaham) in the other RUclips presentations. The Internet and IPhone are amazing.
Sadly, the cameras seem to purposedly not show him or deliberately hide him behind the other soloists
Gil Shaham is the most exciting performer. I have met him several times and seen him 10-12 times. He is more gracious, friendly and nice as anyone I have ever met. I met him when he was 24 and now he is in his 40s. It has been a great 20 years of following him. That is what a truly extraordinary artist can do to someone like me and many others. I hope he lives a very, very long time.
Yes. Certainly one of the best contemporary soloists.
A master in his own right.
Himmlisch gut! Ich habe diese Aufnahme mindestens 50 mal gehört und freue mich auf die nächsten 50 mal. Das Werk ist göttlich und die Interpretation hinreißend. Danke den Musikern. Ich liebe es!
The first movement: not a second of rest, constant illumination. What a composition...
In some ways I felt like I was hearing this piece for the very first time because of the excellent performers who all played with such passion and commitment. Bravo!!!
Damn the cellist popped off. I keep coming back to this recording because of her. Also the pianist's trill is insane, at one point it becomes almost undetectable.
Muy buena interpretación de los tres. Gracias por tener esta oportunidad de ver y escuchar esta obra clásica de Beethoven.
My most admired orchestra HR FRANKFURT Sinfonie sur the baton of Maestro Järvi and with three fabulous soloist have given us a super performance of this superb Beethovenian concerto. Thank you.
Special mention to the girl with long blonde hair turning the score pages for the pianist.
Das ist toll, dass Sie diese Konzert-Aufzeichnung ins Netz gestellt haben. Dem im Vergleich zu Beethovens Klavierkonzerten oder seinem Violinkonzert nicht so tiefem Tripelkonzert geben die drei Solisten, das Orchester und der Dirigent eine ungeahnte Tiefe durch Ausloten der Dynamik, phantastischen Spannungsbögen sowie lustvoller Gestaltung in vielen kleinen Details. Eine wundervolle Mischung aus tiefem Ernst, grosser Freude am Musizieren sowie einer echten Liebe zum Werk und zu den eigenen Instrumenten.
Heard many renditions of this work ....simply the best to date
This is AWESOME!!! Love the violinist especially: such a warm, delightful tone and wonderful expressiveness. THANKS for posting this!!!
Eine wunderbar „entspannte“ Darbietung, bei der die von den Musikern und dem Dirigenten offensichtlich empfundene Freude am Musizieren mich gefangen nimmt, eimmal ganz abgesehen von der sowieso bekannten fachlichen Qualität der Akteure. Der lange und begeisterte Applaus erscheint mir sehr gerechtfertigt.
Bei Frau Gastinel ist die Freude leider nicht immer so gut sichtbar ...
excelente. gracias al director, solistas y orquesta por esta maravillosa interpretación.
Magnificent demonstration of excellence, brilliance, superb technical mastery and undisputed collective musicality perfectly blended into a performance of absolute perfection. Bravissimo.
des solistes fabuleux,un orchestre de merveille,un chef grandiose,admiration profonde
This piece is like cello concerto from Beethoven. Cello part is main role in this piece.
Such a beautifully, expressive rendition as it gently glides along. Wonderful.
Agradezco la posibilidad de escuchar este maravilloso concierto del gran imperecedero Maestro
une grande réussite la connexion de la musique de chambre et de la musique symphonique,admiration
excelente interpretación, sensacional!! Muy buenos solistas. Dirección impecable, de una buena orquesta. Larga y merecida ovacion. Felicitaciones a todos ellos. Gracias por compartir el video. Sin duda me gusto la obra.
La parte final del coro, sencillamente fascinante!!
Estupendo concierto.Estupendos los tres solistas y la orquesta,que me gusta mucho.
Love Gastinel! Beautiful portamenti and phrasing
es wäre noch viel schöner anzusehen, wenn die Cellistin und der Geiger so säßen, dass sie sich gegenseitig sehen können und dann noch mehr miteinander interagieren würden. Trotzdem eine wunderbares Stück und eine tolle Interpretation!!!
This recording is amazing! The audio from the individual trio members is so crisp and detailed.
And the photography is amazingly clear too. It's as good as being there, if not better.
Brilliant correlation of the Soloists and Orchestra...
Great performance from everyone! Super cellist!
Anne Gastinel forcément !!
de très loin la plus belle exécution de ce triple concerto,triple bravo !
So schön...danke...Liebe Grüße aus Istanbul
Je trouve Gil Shaham tellement humain et exceptionnellement musical!
Ein musikalisches Spektakel! Brillante Interpretation.
1:08 - I. Allegro
19:16 - II. Largo-attacca
23:26 - III. Rondo alla Polacca
Grande, grande oeuvre... et mon violoniste préféré!
An exceptional performance of this masterpiece! Beethoven, the supreme genius! One of his greatest compositions! The orchestra under maestro Jaarvi, couples with superb virtuosity of soloists to carve out this marvelous performance!
Never heard better! The cellist really excels!
Thanks for post!
Jamshed Delvadavala from Mumbai.
Wow, that opening statement contains a kind of advanced, Beethovenian Manheim crescendo..
And possibly his best final concerto movement..
Tres solistas interpretes maravillosos, a la altura de esta genial e insuperable obra cuyo medio enviado por Dios como transmisor simplemente fue y será eternamente ese genial hombre llamado Beethoven. Bravo !!, y también a la orquesta y su director.
Este genio músical es un verdadero benefactor de la humanidad!
This is as Beethoven as it can get. Better version than another I came across earlier here at youtube.
A truly marvellous, neglected work. Any city with a fine piano trio should program it.
The violinist played with soul.
BRAVO!!! GRACIAS POR ESTA MAGNIFICA VERSION!!!!
Absolutely stuningly divine and beautiful. Excallent recording and artists superb
8:12 The buildup and return of the main theme in a different key here is just glorious. So satisfying!
Esta pieza es para disfrutarse mucho más que para analizarse. El rondó es la gloria para el oído.
wonderful performance. wonderful audience.
I remember buying the DGG LP around 1965. It was my first DGG recording and it cost around $6.00, series bread in those days. I have long-since moved on from vinyl, but I always remember the casual photograph of the musicians, all of them in open collars and smoking.
Wunderbar, für mich die völlige Entspannung.
Schön wäre ein Schnitt gewesen, der das Stimmen der Instrumente nach dem 1. Satz entfernt hätte.
Im Konzert sitzend stört es mich nicht aber hier schon.
Das Orchester und die Solisten sind aber von großer Qualität.
Gil Shaham's sound in this performance is particularly delightful, as is the cellist. The piano is great, but in my view is slightly over loud in the balance of the recording. Some interesting shots in the filming, I hope the musicians were warned in advance to wash behind their ears. Gil Shaham's enjoyment of the playing by the other performers, such as the cello opening in the second movement, is really nice.
Though I still prefer the Argerich and Capuchon brothers version, this one was all one could ask for. And anytime I see Jarvi on the podium I know I'm in for a good time. Same with the FRSO--my favorite orchestra.
Excellent performance!!
Esecuzione all'altezza del Compositore, il perfezionista Beethoven ne sarebbe soddisfatto.Eccellenti i Professori solisti e gli Orchestrali sono di massimo livello
probably my favorite part of this performance is how often the flutist looks at Gil
Espectacular, Wunderbar, spectaculous
This was a wonderful recording marred only by the foolish comments of some of the listeners; one who complained about Anne's playing because she was a woman, another annoyed by Gil's E string that was too shrill for his ears. The fault, dear Brutus, was in too much treble inserted by the Sound Engineer. Note that for a moment or two the video wasn't sharp enough because the automatic lens adjustment didn't work properly. It's a good thing that there's no automatic placement of fingers on fingerboards. The musicians have to do that themselves. The result was there was no one out of tune.
This is the most charming music -for me- by Bee. Many, not all, of the rest of his music tends to be -for me again- somewhat too romantically poised and even egotistical at times. This is just pure music.
prekrasna interpretacija!
Amazing! I found a bit sad that the violinist was completely hidden by Anne, they couldn't make eye contact...
Bad camera angles and poor television direction! This wonderful performance deserved better visual coverage than was given here.
@@gayludington682 Ah yes, I totally agree!
BRAVÍSSIMO 📯🎹🎺🎷🎶👏👏👏👏👏
This genius fiddler,s performance makes me feel the pathetic of life and the suffering , sadness , and joy when people live .
The mind of this genius fiddler might have reached the abyss of man,s soul . 🍎
From effulgent Tokyo in profound Japan .
Which national are you watching this video ？
It sounds beautiful !!!
Una interpretación antológica por los solistas y la orquesta
2nd Movement: 19:12
3rd Movement: 23:26
Elegant, sincere music making
Espectacular presentación,
Prachtige muziek.
Extraordinario.Buenísimo.Estupendo.
excellent performance !!!!!!!!
Beautiful playing but strange camera-work - just when you want to be watching a beautiful solo the camera goes off into the clouds.
Agree!
It's also nice to hear the sustaining pedal on the last chords. I didn't hear it.
Бетховен в исполнении оркестра под управлением Пааво Ярви Великолепен.
🇺🇦❤️🖤
amazing. but tip to producers: when the cellist has one of the best solos in the repertoire, maybe focus on her! ugh second movement opening was a mess of focus.
Si bien el Cello es clave en este trio, es muy significativa la interpretación del violinista quien le da una sonoridad hermosa y delicada al trío, tal vez muy golpeado por el pianista. Muy bueno, muy integrado entre solistas y orquesta aunque, a veces, demasiado rudo por el píano. Grande el violín.
une splendeur d'entre les splendeurs
robynsalain oui oui
Así es!!
This how Beethoven meant it to be interpreted as.
素晴らしいです
Un pianista no es solo un reproductor de partituras; debe incorporar su personal sensibidad interpretativa.
The cameramen got crazy, do they think the dim cut is something original?
Как приятно; послушаешь такое чудо музыку, и жить хочется!
¡ CELESTIAL ! GRACIAS