This concept was originally made by Mariah Unlocked - ruclips.net/channel/UCfyGKP0VDY1mRUwVaxmeXAg (Subscribe,he has great content!) Basically,in the mic feed when you hear parts like this - 0:56 in full acapella mode,means that part has been dubbed,there are some other changes too that don't have that acapella effect,but most changes have that effect This is a comparison between the Undubbed and Dubbed Divas 1998,I used the mic feed to be easier to hear what changed in the dubbed version. Hope you enjoy ❤️
There is a part you might miss out, the part that Mariah start to sing harmonized with Aretha, sing for 4 words, then she had stopped after she realized it's completely Aretha's part.
People : *release mariah Carey DVD Dubbed performance Lamb : OMG HER VOICE IS SO GOOD!!! EVERYTHING IS PERFECT!!!PROBABLY THE BEST PERFORMANCE!! People : *released undubbed footage Lamb : THIS IS SO SO MUCH BETTER THAN DUBBED!!! UNDUBBED >>>>>>>>>>>>>DUBBED. DUBBED WAS SO NASAL AND AUTOTUNE!!! UNDUBBED IS WAY WAY BETTER!! yeah i know undubbed was better but dont discredit dubbed
I think Mariah definitely has dubbed performances, but I think lamb channels need to start taking into account that TV specials and performances (aka, not concerts or one-offs) are usually cleaned and edited after-the-fact. So Mariah may not have gone into the studio to re-record her vocals entirely on a new track, but the post team did their thing to make everything sound smooth and clean for TV. Idk what this is here, but that is a thing as well.
so your telling me her team basically wasted time and effort to dub a performance and make almost no changes not implying that the vocals are bad tho there incredible
You can't improve a quality of the voice of a live performance without getting a mic feed, but then again you can't also improve and eliminate the stage noise that gets recorded on the mic as it will guaranteed will stay on the mic feed. Examples of improving the recordings are MR removed, that's not mic feed but their software only focuses on the vocals and make them more pronounce than the instruments but you can still hear instruments faintly. In these dubbed situation you would hear some part of Mariah like she's in a studio and it's quiet, no music around, that's when it's dubbed. But when you hear the instruments on her dubbed performances that's from her mic feed. That's why this video doesn't make sense to you as you can still hear the undubbed mic feed and treat it as a dubbed version. But the dubbed version only meant that it still has live vocals but certain parts are dubbed. Dubbed versions doesn't mean that all the vocals are recorded again in a studio, it just means some parts are dubbed. Audio comparison for when thinking it's identical: 05:36 = 'TAKE IT' - dubbed, clear voice you cant hear like the mic went far 05:41 = 'TAKE IT' - undubbed, voice minimizes as her mic went far.
@@TheQueenOfLambily dont think so, they exactly the same , the more I watch the video , the more I get confused cause I think Dubbed isn't the right term, dubbing means putting on new vocals to an existing record which to my opinion is not what I heard here, so I agree with the guy who commented here, but Id be more willing to listen if you point out some things where there were some differences like give me a certain minute in this video where that happens because I really cant hear any differences, which leads me to think that they just made the sound quality better not technically dubbing tho, thats all thanks
@@lesteralmarez1003 The E5 belt from My All has the most obvious difference IMO : 2:44 multiple syllables on the word "Just" wherein the first syllable "Ju" is held for a bit, the belt is much clearer 2:49 the syllables of "just" are harder to distinguish + Mariah *quickly descends* from the E5 instead of holding the "Ju" syllable, the belt is raspy & seems a bit cracked but not sure Make It Happen : 5:35 If I could *take - it* 5:40 If I could *takeit*
My Uber driver once told me she was a musician for Aretha Franklin and that Aretha Franklin had to have the temperature at a specific number On this particular night of divas live she told me that she met all the divas that night me being the Mariah Carey fan that I am I kept asking her about Mariah and she told me that Mariah doing vocal warm-ups with Aretha in her trailer sweating bricks she was also telling me stories about the other divas but I didn’t really Paid enough attention but I do remember her talking about Diana Ross Luther and how Aretha hired Luther background Singers when he passed just saw me a story I treasure people and she’s one of the persons I will treasure forever
Is it just or does make it happen sounded less raspy then the dubbed one(it might the quality but still) Edit: ok now i think she in general sounded less raspy in the undubbed preformance of this
I feel like it's partially dubbed cause when you listen closely to the mic feed you can kinda notice the difference between the live vocals and the dubbing
I understand why she had to do the dubbing for this. She went flat/ sharp in quite a lot of notes, those at the end of sentences. Her vibratio in some parts is not stable as well. So of course she would want something perfect for a Divas show. But to choose between raw live and dubbed, the raw one for sure!!
Thấy 1 người chân thành comment khách quan nãy giờ. MC là hình mẫu Diva nhưng không thể cứ là MC là mặc nhiên nghe nó hay được. Không dub thô không tả nỗi.
Mariah singing with Aretha is goals like to be able to sing with the queen of soul and be showing off her feats she can do and have Aretha smile gives me joy!
Jesus, I need to take a class or something cause I have too much time to sit here and listen to her sing pretty much the exact same dubbed/undubbed,,, hell, constipated/not constipated lol she sounds the same and I'm sure totally unconcerned with us digging and judging her performance from like 20 plus years ago.
I saw this live on VH1 back in the day and I can remember there was some kind of malfunction in the sound while the dance part kicked in on My all, like a power outage or something. By the time it was rebroadcasted and on the home video was released it was fixed.
honestly the only difference i hear is here. maybe some low notes in My All were dubbed to be less sharp too, idk tho. definitely not as dubbed as MSG 1995
Well, not every tv broadcast is the undubbed version. Actualy there are 3 versions. Tv (Undubbed), Tv (Dubbed) & DVD (Dubbed). In this video i can recognise that "Natural woman" are both the dubbed versions. The undubbed is a little messier and you can listen the different mix on the voices and actualy you can listen Carole King singing too.
At 10:33 on the undubbed, when Mariah starts the belt at the end of Chain of Fools, you can hear a really high belt when the mic is miles away from her mouth, before she brings it in and you can hear properly
Yeah there is no day and night comparison, both are exquisite and very authentic to Mariah. Which one is better is completely up to the beholder but both examples came from her lungs.
It’s the same vocal remastered and punched vocals.but I feel sad about her rasp. That is a damage vocal that made her a less confident singer. But that resonance on the top notes are just awesome
I think only some parts were dubbed. When the extracted voice only has the voice itself without any accompaniment, it shows some volume differences. Others were just the undubbed version itself.
It's quite easy to tell the dubbed part on me mic feed! When you can hear the band it's the live vocals and when it's just the voice it's the dudded parts!
Omg i still want to look like her in the divas live performance of my all....😉 that hair and body, the sexy dress....omg 😍 Her voice is really the most beautiful thing in this WORLD...my sweet DIVA💕
Make it happen sounds like it simply had a very good sound mixing after. Chain of fools sounds the same except for a few notes, and very honestly it still sounds good in my ears 'cause her tone was amazing. Now, about My All... hmm, I'm gon' pass on that one
Ya'll never notice the differences between those two audios(undubbed and dubbed one) because she did a very small changes such as; the inflections of the words, the slight changes on some notes (sharp and flats) that you may not hear if you don't have a perfect pitch ear.
This just sounds like the mic feed and the recording of it , because even in the audience it’s sounds way better than the so called undubbed and the dubbed is what’s for the dvd and television version ! Dumb !
This isn't even dubbed vs undubbed lol this is undubbed vs live Mic Feed & the live mic feed sounds so much better because you can hear her voice crystal clear.
The one aired on tv was not dibbed. They probably just used the mic feed so thats why it sounds clearer. Plus in the "undubbed" clearly she sounds muffled due to the quality. Compared to her msg performances these ones dont sound processed and echoed.
They changed so much.. They tried to make some of the runs crisper and quicker.. It didn't really work out for some tho.. But yeah.. The dubbing was nice. Mariah did a great job
F me this only seems Like undubbed was with more reverbe and the dubbed was the voice with another process that make it more clear, but in fact is the same.
This concept was originally made by Mariah Unlocked - ruclips.net/channel/UCfyGKP0VDY1mRUwVaxmeXAg (Subscribe,he has great content!)
Basically,in the mic feed when you hear parts like this - 0:56 in full acapella mode,means that part has been dubbed,there are some other changes too that don't have
that acapella effect,but most changes have that effect
This is a comparison between the Undubbed and Dubbed Divas 1998,I used the mic feed to be easier to hear what changed in the dubbed version.
Hope you enjoy ❤️
I want my undubbed daydream clips tooo
I love you 💕 this made my day! thanks sm for this video!!
Somebody getting sued
Fly Like A Lamb omg where you been?
There is a part you might miss out, the part that Mariah start to sing harmonized with Aretha, sing for 4 words, then she had stopped after she realized it's completely Aretha's part.
Another time when dubbed her vocals was unnecessary
As usual
Of course 😉
i think they dub it to also increase the quality?
@Angel Johnson no. She's 28 here
am i the only one who likes the undubbed better
Ur not alone hunny.💖
I was waiting for the typical delusional fan to say that...🤣
Her voice is so amazing!!!
Same here
@@andrese9805 what's the difference between the dubbed and undubbed? nothing
In my mind this is always just the “Hairiah” performance HAHAHHAA
Lionriah dahling
The dubbed version literally further exposed the raspiness of her voice lmao
Dubbed or undubbed, Mariah is such an incredible and unparalleled musical talent.
0:02 **StOp sInGiNg mY pArT nOw bAbY**
I LAUGHED SO HARD AT THIS COMMENT HAHA
@@elusivemariah YOU HEARD IT TOO RIGHT?? TELL ME I'M NOT GETTING CRAZIER THAN I ALREADY AM
Lol i remember that...my MARIAH is so extra and i LOVE her for it, 😂
elusivemariah I can’t un hear it-
@@imjustgoofy09 YES HAHA
All she changed was the sound quality. She didn't even alter any of the vocals.
People : *release mariah Carey DVD Dubbed performance
Lamb : OMG HER VOICE IS SO GOOD!!! EVERYTHING IS PERFECT!!!PROBABLY THE BEST PERFORMANCE!!
People : *released undubbed footage
Lamb : THIS IS SO SO MUCH BETTER THAN DUBBED!!! UNDUBBED >>>>>>>>>>>>>DUBBED. DUBBED WAS SO NASAL AND AUTOTUNE!!! UNDUBBED IS WAY WAY BETTER!!
yeah i know undubbed was better but dont discredit dubbed
Tea...
But I still like the undubbed better 😂💓
Giuliana CR period AHAHA
I mean either way its still her voice
I didin’t understand the DUBBED?
They are known for being delusional
She sounds the same
Arthemis exactly!!! The undubbed HERE! just sounds louder haha
@@JazPatty Yepp, and sometimes the Undubbed version sounds even better!!
@@JazPatty correct
That’s the same thing I said
I think Mariah definitely has dubbed performances, but I think lamb channels need to start taking into account that TV specials and performances (aka, not concerts or one-offs) are usually cleaned and edited after-the-fact. So Mariah may not have gone into the studio to re-record her vocals entirely on a new track, but the post team did their thing to make everything sound smooth and clean for TV. Idk what this is here, but that is a thing as well.
so your telling me her team basically wasted time and effort to dub a performance and make almost no changes not implying that the vocals are bad tho there incredible
I was having to really pay close attention to even notice the slightest difference here 😅
Dubbing doesn't really mean poor vocals, sometimes the sound capture isn't very good (or of varying quality if there are many singers)
Is to make it sound clear
@@facuuaf thank you for this explanation: I've often assumed dubbing was because of poor voice, not sound at all.
Sound identical for me, im starting to think that it was the live vocals which the quality of the recording was being improved
It is
She sounds a lot more raspier undubbed her original voice is very raspy
You can't improve a quality of the voice of a live performance without getting a mic feed, but then again you can't also improve and eliminate the stage noise that gets recorded on the mic as it will guaranteed will stay on the mic feed.
Examples of improving the recordings are MR removed, that's not mic feed but their software only focuses on the vocals and make them more pronounce than the instruments but you can still hear instruments faintly.
In these dubbed situation you would hear some part of Mariah like she's in a studio and it's quiet, no music around, that's when it's dubbed. But when you hear the instruments on her dubbed performances that's from her mic feed. That's why this video doesn't make sense to you as you can still hear the undubbed mic feed and treat it as a dubbed version. But the dubbed version only meant that it still has live vocals but certain parts are dubbed. Dubbed versions doesn't mean that all the vocals are recorded again in a studio, it just means some parts are dubbed.
Audio comparison for when thinking it's identical:
05:36 = 'TAKE IT' - dubbed, clear voice you cant hear like the mic went far
05:41 = 'TAKE IT' - undubbed, voice minimizes as her mic went far.
What matters is she's still on pitch. And still a legendary voice.
She didnt need to dub cause both sounded the same
@J. C. i mean the quality of her voice, not the volume
@J. C. normaly it would be louder because she dubbed it on studio
OMG i love the production of this video! Definitely so interesting to see the comparisons.
Ikr we need Daydream next 🖤
Y is the dubbed more raspy and the undubbed more lighter like "Daydream Era"?? OMGGG 🤭👀👀
Both sounds identically, of course dubbed version sounds with more quality which is necessary for tv.
Wolfgan Rodríguez they don’t,the lows in my all are way shakier and some are taken from the studio version
@@TheQueenOfLambily dont think so, they exactly the same , the more I watch the video , the more I get confused cause I think Dubbed isn't the right term, dubbing means putting on new vocals to an existing record which to my opinion is not what I heard here, so I agree with the guy who commented here, but Id be more willing to listen if you point out some things where there were some differences like give me a certain minute in this video where that happens because I really cant hear any differences, which leads me to think that they just made the sound quality better not technically dubbing tho, thats all thanks
@@lesteralmarez1003 The E5 belt from My All has the most obvious difference IMO :
2:44 multiple syllables on the word "Just" wherein the first syllable "Ju" is held for a bit, the belt is much clearer
2:49 the syllables of "just" are harder to distinguish + Mariah *quickly descends* from the E5 instead of holding the "Ju" syllable, the belt is raspy & seems a bit cracked but not sure
Make It Happen :
5:35 If I could *take - it*
5:40 If I could *takeit*
3:01 I personally like this better
Secret exposed: Mariah is the queen of the universe
Hmm we been knew though 😏
My Uber driver once told me she was a musician for Aretha Franklin and that Aretha Franklin had to have the temperature at a specific number On this particular night of divas live she told me that she met all the divas that night me being the Mariah Carey fan that I am I kept asking her about Mariah and she told me that Mariah doing vocal warm-ups with Aretha in her trailer sweating bricks she was also telling me stories about the other divas but I didn’t really Paid enough attention but I do remember her talking about Diana Ross Luther and how Aretha hired Luther background Singers when he passed just saw me a story I treasure people and she’s one of the persons I will treasure forever
5:26 this is so hard to do and so easy to fail, she's a God
My all is a little better in dub (lows)
MIH is better undubbed (much clearer)
Chains of fools dub (in the first belt)
Natural woman is the same
Didn't you hear her little growl on "YOU MAKE ME FEEL!" right after her part
On the undubbed one, or it's just the quality?
wiratamaris I don’t know I honestly don’t hear it
All I can hear is that the dub increased the volume of her lows. That's it.
This is still one of my favorite performances of her. So enjoyable and her butterfly tone is so pleasant 😍❤
😍💕me too
Perfectionariah is a perfectionist 👌♥️🔥
Sorry I'm late I was in 2021😊😇
Mariah Unlocked ❤️❤️❤️
@Mariah Unlocked ....anything from 2020 is a threat I moved on , Everything is so beautiful here in 2021
@@Hoodriah no 😏
Her face and her voice is gorgeously gorgeous. One of a kind. One in a billion.
I love the dubbed, this proves she has perfect pitch to go in and edit her vocals so effortlessly
Is it just or does make it happen sounded less raspy then the dubbed one(it might the quality but still)
Edit: ok now i think she in general sounded less raspy in the undubbed preformance of this
I feel like it's partially dubbed cause when you listen closely to the mic feed you can kinda notice the difference between the live vocals and the dubbing
*Can we just appreciate the quality contents The Queen Of Lambily gives us on every video she does???*
You're a dreamy right??
*sure*
@MIAM Era ew *who* called *you* outta *your* grave?
Yaaas
@@drunkriah8693 SCREAMING at your name adjsfiodsjfiodsanbfuy 💀
It literally sounded the same but clearer and louder.
I understand why she had to do the dubbing for this. She went flat/ sharp in quite a lot of notes, those at the end of sentences. Her vibratio in some parts is not stable as well. So of course she would want something perfect for a Divas show. But to choose between raw live and dubbed, the raw one for sure!!
Thấy 1 người chân thành comment khách quan nãy giờ. MC là hình mẫu Diva nhưng không thể cứ là MC là mặc nhiên nghe nó hay được. Không dub thô không tả nỗi.
THANK YOU for this! I'd never seen MIH and Chain of Fools undubbed before.
Dubbed sounds raspier/hoarse & I don't know why or how 👀
Okay but this show literally has Butterflyriah's best F5 & F#5 belts 😌
5:27
Same tone of 1996 in tokyo, but a little more husky, I found little difference
I don't care if undubbed or not but still she is the best singer around the world
Mariah singing with Aretha is goals like to be able to sing with the queen of soul and be showing off her feats she can do and have Aretha smile gives me joy!
Dubbed or undubbed she sounds amazings Dahhhhhling!!!!
The *un-dubbed* footage was _better_ than the dubbed. 👏👏👏
It’s just louder😛 quite different from the MSG performances, you clearly hear the difference between the dubbed and undubbed
*For a second i thot mariah unlocked uploaded this video but then i see it was from The Queen Of Lambily* 💖
*I'm* *Scared* *To* *Play* *This*
*Because* *Something* *Would* *Pop* *Out* 😖
* Girl you’re fine if I can take people saying I’m autotune then you can play this video*
Jesus, I need to take a class or something cause I have too much time to sit here and listen to her sing pretty much the exact same dubbed/undubbed,,, hell, constipated/not constipated lol she sounds the same and I'm sure totally unconcerned with us digging and judging her performance from like 20 plus years ago.
Mariah Unlocked who?
@Mariah Unlocked ups
I wonder how they dubbed it. Because the open of mouth to the voice are perfect timing
Because there’s only very minor dubbing, they barely changed anything
When i say this was still her prime I meant it 😍
It's the same audio, the louder is the mic feed that leaked years ago, but these are the same
I love the HD Footage
I saw this live on VH1 back in the day and I can remember there was some kind of malfunction in the sound while the dance part kicked in on My all, like a power outage or something. By the time it was rebroadcasted and on the home video was released it was fixed.
9:05 'weak' is different
honestly the only difference i hear is here. maybe some low notes in My All were dubbed to be less sharp too, idk tho. definitely not as dubbed as MSG 1995
Lambs4lyf I heard a lot of inflection changes in Make It Happen. They were subtle but once I noticed them, they were pretty clear.
Well, not every tv broadcast is the undubbed version. Actualy there are 3 versions. Tv (Undubbed), Tv (Dubbed) & DVD (Dubbed). In this video i can recognise that "Natural woman" are both the dubbed versions. The undubbed is a little messier and you can listen the different mix on the voices and actualy you can listen Carole King singing too.
I didn’t even notice the rasp until you isolated her vocals. Both performances were freaking stellar, objectively lol!
At 10:33 on the undubbed, when Mariah starts the belt at the end of Chain of Fools, you can hear a really high belt when the mic is miles away from her mouth, before she brings it in and you can hear properly
Her voice is amazing 👑❤
I don't think it's dubbed. I think they just enhanced the vocals of Mariah.
I loved how you differentiated video into sections. I appreciate that😊.
Yeah there is no day and night comparison, both are exquisite and very authentic to Mariah. Which one is better is completely up to the beholder but both examples came from her lungs.
Daydream concerts next plz 🙏🙏🙏
look at this hair, definitely stunning
queen of the universe🦋♥️🐏
It’s the same vocal remastered and punched vocals.but I feel sad about her rasp. That is a damage vocal that made her a less confident singer. But that resonance on the top notes are just awesome
Her Voice almost about to crack. 😬
You should do a video about MTV Unplugged.
I love her raspiness here
The differences are barely noticable....
Yassss ❤️
I think only some parts were dubbed. When the extracted voice only has the voice itself without any accompaniment, it shows some volume differences. Others were just the undubbed version itself.
It's quite easy to tell the dubbed part on me mic feed! When you can hear the band it's the live vocals and when it's just the voice it's the dudded parts!
lit my fav lamb channel🥺
I love her hair
Even greater in undubbed version
Both sounded pretty good! But I guess dubbed is just to make her vocals sound more consistant, in other words, to seal her voice perfectly☺️
For DVD is dub because the sound seems Studio, with no audience and environment sounds. Less echo as well. Normal ...
Omg i still want to look like her in the divas live performance of my all....😉 that hair and body, the sexy dress....omg 😍
Her voice is really the most beautiful thing in this WORLD...my sweet DIVA💕
I just love that video sz
Basically comparing a hd extracted vid to a vhs. 👀
Next:
• Homecoming '99
• Proctor's Theatre
• VH1 Save the Music
• BET Blueprint 2005
hopefully yes
We need to find undubbed footage of those preformances first
Bye I need Homecoming Special that's literally the only time she really performed live-live (if you get me) in late 1999 💀
Make it happen sounds like it simply had a very good sound mixing after. Chain of fools sounds the same except for a few notes, and very honestly it still sounds good in my ears 'cause her tone was amazing. Now, about My All... hmm, I'm gon' pass on that one
Ya'll never notice the differences between those two audios(undubbed and dubbed one) because she did a very small changes such as; the inflections of the words, the slight changes on some notes (sharp and flats) that you may not hear if you don't have a perfect pitch ear.
This just sounds like the mic feed and the recording of it , because even in the audience it’s sounds way better than the so called undubbed and the dubbed is what’s for the dvd and television version ! Dumb !
This isn't even dubbed vs undubbed lol this is undubbed vs live Mic Feed & the live mic feed sounds so much better because you can hear her voice crystal clear.
MIH umdubbed sounds like 1996riah kinda we stan
The one aired on tv was not dibbed. They probably just used the mic feed so thats why it sounds clearer. Plus in the "undubbed" clearly she sounds muffled due to the quality. Compared to her msg performances these ones dont sound processed and echoed.
all the high belts are so good, good she didnt dub most of them here. (like he f#5 which was perfect lol)
They’re just two incredibly talented women sharing a stage, not competing, just relishing in eachother’s talent; love to see it
9:04 the only part where the dubbed veraion sounded better
They changed so much.. They tried to make some of the runs crisper and quicker.. It didn't really work out for some tho.. But yeah.. The dubbing was nice. Mariah did a great job
Great video! Would be nice of the dubbed vocals had music behind them too though, that would make it a fair comparison.
Undubbed is FAR better!!!
I understand that the dubbed is good for the quality of the sound, but the vocals are more alive on undubbed with no doubt
It sounds exactly the same and syncs perfectly
Some times her voice is so deep I can't hear it at all
the only parts overdubbed are the parts where the music cuts out, the rest has to be live cuz its the live instrumentation leaking into the mic feed
wow a clever comment finaly
The undubbed sounds a mixture of daydream and rainbow, dubbed is pure rainbow tone.
What are dubbed and undubbed vocals😅? Are like studio-recorded vocals of tge version of a performance?
I only noticed the dubbed ones were louder 🤨
The undubbed is so much better
F me this only seems Like undubbed was with more reverbe and the dubbed was the voice with another process that make it more clear, but in fact is the same.
Perfect anyway dahhhlirgnssss!!!!!