Which Star Wars Faction has the BEST BOMBER? | Star Wars Legends Lore
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 30 сен 2024
- Today's Star Wars Faction Compared video examines Star Wars Legends Lore, looking at the Galactic Empire, Rebel Alliance, Clone Wars Era Republic and Confederacy of Independent Systems to decide which one has the best Bomber style starfighter.
Tie Bombers, Hyena Droid Bombers, Y Wings and B-Wings. Which is best? Find out on Star Wars Legedns Factions Compared.
***
Follow me on Twitch: / eckhartsladder
Want to help the channel out?
Subscribe: goo.gl/vBao71
Join the (superfun!) Discord: discord.io/eck...
And follow me on Twitter: / eckhartsladder
Also check out my second channel here: / eckstoo
Want another chance to win a t-shirt? Comment on my new video on the second channel: ruclips.net/video/s2hq-Xj0MLU/видео.html
Let me know what shirt you'd like!
EckhartsLadder why did you not include the Ressistence bomber
you should do who had the best tank/heavy walker
EckhartsLadder you should compare the walkers
The resistance bomber needs some sort of mention.
It's an awesome bomber for the FFG X WING game!
These are getting repetitive, can you do other universes please?
1:35 Eck: "The Tie Bomber was very ill suited for space combat"; Me: *always chooses Tie Bomber in Battlefront*
The tie bomber had one of the best guns it was so accurate. Personally I like the y-wing better because the second gunner seat. You and your buddy could just like never die in dogfighting.
agreed
@@thelonious2213 Quite an enlightening opinion.
@@thelonious2213 Wasn't the issue getting to the target in the first place?
Yeah, once you're there the enemy can go ahead and just accept they're dead, but, a relatively slow and unshielded craft heading straight towards CIWS's doesn't seems like a good idea.
@@thelonious2213 Dude the tie bombers Hull is rated at 28 Ru and the B-wing is rated at 60 Ru, the B-wing also has a 100 sheild rating, the tie bomber has no sheilds, it accselerates way faster than the tie bomber, is slighty faster in space and way faster in atmosphere, thanks to its deflector sheild, it is better at dogfights because it has more lazer canons, and more powerfull ones too and it has ion canons for atacking sheilds. The B-wing also has only 16 manuvrablitiy points less than the tie bomber at 70, not to mention the fact that it has a hyper drive so you don't even need to keep it in a hanger for transport.
Read Wookiepeidia before posting something dumb.
starwars.fandom.com/wiki/A/SF-01_B-wing_starfighter/Legends
starwars.fandom.com/wiki/TIE/sa_bomber/Legends
Basically:
-the rebels have the best ships
-the republic have the best troops
-the CIS have the most troops
-the empire has the best guns
I think that's not very correct.
-The republic has the best troops
-The CIS has the best ships and most troops
-The Empire has the biggest ships and guns
-The Rebels have the best tactics
Actually, it’s more like:
- The Republic had the best troops.
- The CIS had the most of everything (troops, ships, fighters, etc).
- The Empire had the biggest ships and guns.
- The Rebels had the best fighters, bombers, and tactics/leadership when not counting Thrawn (and arguably best capital ships in the form of the various Mon Calamari ships).
@@coolkidsclub9943 all rebels ever do is die to accomplish stuff
@@whereismycup What?
@@coolkidsclub9943 ruclips.net/video/zdukWtJwlPU/видео.html
At least you didn't include the Resistance Bomber from the Last Jedi, because those were hot garbage. And I say hot because they are all dead and on fire.
MechmanZero especially for a faction that apparently cares about the lives of pilots
For the faction that was fond of hit and run attacks and made the fastest ship having the snail of all ships wasn’t going to ever do well
they are not garbage what-so-ever. one bomber destroyed an entire first order dreadnaught. they hold over 100 proton bombs and they are quite quick. one crossed a 7km dreadnaught relatively quickly. Another thing. the resistance doesn't have money to throw around at everything to afford the best of the best. they take what they can get.
charlie steele they’re a glass cannon. Their payload is their only redeeming quality, by every other metric they’re shit.
Y-wings were a glass cannon with a far less powerful payload. 90% of every Y-wing that went on a mission was destroyed by imperial tie fighters or cannons.
The Y-wing seems very manouverable for a bomber when watching the clone wars. It has done some really sharp turns
Wookiepedia also mentions it is faster and more maneuverable than B Wing.
It has also been shown to have long distance capability’s in the clone wars, it even had a hyper drive so it could warp above a ship bomb it than run away
Manouverable?
Because of plot armor...they didn’t want the CIS to win...sadly
Just4Fun The CIS should have never won by any metric. They made garbage units for the sake of numbers, which proved ineffective when under good rRepublic leadership. It wasn’t plot armor that caused them to lose, it was the fact that they were made (by Palpatine) to lose. They were sabotaged from the start by their own leader.
The biggest selling point to the Tie Bomber is that it was dirt cheap to make... much like the Tie Fighter, cheap, and easily replaced.
I feel this advantage doesn’t work with the fact that Tie pilots are extremely well trained which takes time. You’re taking a cheap and easy to destroy bomber and putting a pilot you’ve put a lot of investment in which not only means if it blows up you lose the pilot, but the pilot can’t operate at full efficiency.
@@cryamistellimek9184 mhm, I've always felt the empire is a little fucky with this kind of stuff. Stormtroopers are supposedly highly trained but drop like flies-- their armor and equipment is shittier then clone wars era equipment while still "supposedly" being good, and they miss. Like. Clockwork.
Still more expensive than hyena bombers
Can also spam missiles
Lol
at that pricepoint might as well build Hyenas
You corrected tie bomber with vulture Droid but it wasn't either it was a hyena class bomber, 4:45
Technically although the B-wing is the biggest star fight its attack profile is pretty narrow. Think about it. It’s diving head first to attack capital ships and besides the main body, hitting narrow wings is very difficult. Yet it is easy to shoot on the side which means it’s not great at dogfighting, but it was some what negated by its durability.
the B-wing shown in Rebels was interesting, with the ability to kill an imperial cruiser. The B-wing in ROTJ was quite different
Is it just me or were the resistance bombers in the last jedi so stupidly bad? Seriously a B or Y wing would of been soooo much better at taking out capital ships.
They aren't bad, they are just way more effective in other areas. The Y wing or the B wing are pretty good at attacking capital ships, while the resistance bombers are better at destroying cities or industrial faculties.
wargearinternational nah, I think they are still way too slow to be usefull, they would be an easy target for anti-air
To be honest star fortress was in fact stupidly powerfull, one bomber had 1048 proton bombs, y-wing had 20, it's 50 times more, one bomber could most likely take down an ISD, all you need to do is to protect them until they arive
the protection problem is the issue, they are a big, slow and prime target. provide them with better shields or use them for the proper circumstances and they are effective. they absolutely need to be covered by a fighter screen and they lack the evasiveness to avoid point defense. give the resistance a strike bomber craft and you could escort both and the strike bombers could provide an opening for the heavy bombers.
+Jacob Carney these things arent slow. they crossed a 7km dreadnaught in under a minute. i dont see how that converts to them being slow.
I had the hyena bomber LEGO set. Good stuff, keep up the good work!
Before watching: B-Wing. Versatile, advanced, S foils, can hold its own against fighters. After watching: The outcome was never really in doubt.
The Resistance bomber is the worst. Ever
I agree especially how slow the b bomber is in the last Jedi
Cool yes.
Effective? Not really.
Doesn't help that the occupants breath space.
Or atleast they wouldn't be so inept as to stack ALL OF THEM right next to each other and cause a chain reaction that destroyed all but one of them (that survived for "plot-advancing" purposes.)
well, its firepower is INSANE but the speed made me cringe
I believe that the Hyena bombers deserve 2nd, due to their capabilities, I believe they weren't terrible at fighter combat, I also believe they could out do a Y-wing in combat, easily make it back to it's ship, rearm it's explosives, and bomb the opposing cruiser into oblivion with a second go quickly, if it hadn't already been destroyed from the first run.
TCW just doesn't represent them well. They cost less than a tie bomber, so they would be deployed en-masse. They have a great payload, but moreso they are expendable and replaceable. So as long as some get through, you are going to destroy ships.
I think the lack of shields would lead to its downfall in combat with y-wing and to point defense weapons.
Vultures and Hyenas rule space.
If you make a few tweaks to the AI in order to allow it to use its I part, I think they would be deadliest. Separatist droids, with the exception of Comando droids, (probably) Magnaguards and Tactical Droids, were limited by design in terms of intelligence in order to prevent an uprising, iirc.
Vultures and Hyenas are also incredibly cheap, costing 19-20.000 and 23.000 credits respectively, ordinance not included. This means that for every TIE fighter you could have 4 Vulture droids (and considering how effective Vultures are despite their limitations, we all know how that would go). And for every TIE bomber (which cost 150.000 each) you could have 6 Hyenas (and you would remain with half the required funds for yet another).
And I compared the prices to the already cheap Imperial assets. If we would be talking Republic, then the ratio would be even higher.
@@bluethunderbolt9631 the separatists could have become the strongest faction in star wars if they acted competently which they didn't as their leader darth sidious A.K.A palpatine only used them as distraction soo that he could successfully infiltrate the republic as an high rank member they were Never meant to succeed they were meant to be nothing but a glorified distraction if it wasn't for palpatine and the siths they could have steamrolled the republic even if the republic had the clone army
What's great about Hyenas is that they can either dump their payload and then kamikaze into a vessel's bridge or just full kamikaze into a vessel's bridge, with the payload making a larger explosion. All of this is possible because they are dirt cheap
They also rule the Earth
The Y Wing is by far my favorite starship in all of Star Wars.
I love the arc 170.
I would certainly have put it higher than the B wing which is one of the worst ship designs in Star Wars. The Tie bomber might have skipped on shields and speed but at least they got the guns in the right place.
Speed normally is not a problem if your people upgrade the engines, which was why the Spitfire and BF-109 were still in at the end of the war.
Serious Maran I actually like the B-wings design😅
@@sharkzomb1798 the issue I have with the B-wing is it is not a fighter but more to deal with small capital ships, which means you need decent cover. That did not happen in the X-wing PC game, so you ended up trying to deal with tie fighters in a vehicle that was never intended to do that. The guns placed wide and far off centre make it difficult to aim at small fast enemies. They would have been better off with putting heavy armament on an Imperial shuttle along with a tail turret.
Me too
“The B-Wing was capable of even taking down light capital ships used by the Empire.” Anyone else remember that scene from Star Wars Rebels where a B-Wing did exactly that? Granted, the B-Wing in question was a prototype model using a weapon that we never saw on the B-Wings from, say, Endor, but still, very impressive.
The B wing is a nice bomber.
Gerardo Reyes Y wing is a nicer bomber.
Until they added a mini death star laser to it..
The 🅱-Wing 🅱om🅱er
Y wing for sure
Gerardo Reyes the 360° turret of the clone wars era y-wing is really beneficial, both b-wing and y-wing have pros and cons
Which faction had the best space superiority fighter?
Alliance, then Republic, then Empire, then CIS. The X-Wing is unquestionably better than either the ARC-170 or the V-19, the former of which is also far better than an Imperial TIE. Between the TIE and the Vulture, the TIE has a better fuel life, better speed, similar agility, better guns, and a smaller target profile from most angles.
vulture droids have homing missiles tho!
TIE Hunter or Defender FTW
Vulture droids do not require extensive pilot training. you just have to deploy a lot of them
Rebellion and New Republic (Canon and Legends)
I was gonna make a TIE joke but I'm too TIErd.
Ha
Ha
And about that dank af giveaway, any shirt will do. :)
This joke still be better than the Resistance bomber.
Dr. Vanilla the resistance bombers weren’t bad, just poorly chosen for the job. Those bombers are better suited for bombing a city, while y, or b wings are better for attacking capital ships.
jesus
4:48 You can recognise a good RUclipsr when they even get the correction wrong!
Well he wasnt right with either, it was a hyena class bomber that he was talking about
@@unwiser read the comment but slower
I'm DROPPING off this comment!
Darth Vader I could have sworn I just saw you in the comments of the latest Halo funny and lucky moments
hahaha
Darth Vader padme is ded lolz xd
Pff. So you’re my successor? Hah!
GET LOST DARTH
Which faction has the best Corvettes, Frigates, Cruisers or Destroyers
Or Zambonies.
Corvettes would be interesting.
There's a merch giveaway at the end of today's video! For more chances to win, check out my twitter, and the second channel. Also check out the store! www.teespring.com/stores/eckhartsladder
Twitter: twitter.com/eckhartsladder
RUclips: ruclips.net/user/eckstoo
EckhartsLadder that link is just to this channel
how would win.ewok or jawa
daniel wilcox my man, thanks!
enyone
what about me
Do the best interceptor if the four factions: A-wing, tie interceptor, v-wing (I think), and the weird tri-wing droid ship that I don’t know the name of
I'm two years late, but the droid is the Tri-Fighter.
And the tri droid is also a bomber
@@CHANN3L_NAME tri-fighter = everything at once - capital ship
You should do “Who was the best bounty hunter in Star Wars” and compare them.
I love everything of the galactic republic. Their ships, clones armor, capital ships, and anakins twilight
The aesthetic of clones, LAAT, ATTE, Venator is just.👅
+Kenneth Dizon I do agree with you that the ATTE was an amazing walker, however, and I plan to implement an improved version of it for my army.
0 views 10 likes makes sense
With how fast people manage to comment I'm not surprised
Yup
View counts update in intervals.
likes update immediately but you need to refresh the page to see view updates
another idiot who doesn't understand how YT works
I feel like the B-wing is more of an attack craft, like an A-10. But I understand why you did it.
The K-Wing is New Republic, not Rebel Alliance.
and New Republick is also a faction, just like the others, Old Republick, Empire, Rebelion, etc
All of these are Attack craft, the Y wing is like an IL-2, it doesn’t even carry bombs so why is it considered a BOMBER
Do fighters Next
Troop transport please.
I'd like to see a comparison between armor.
Given the drastic difference in clone and storm trooper armor, as well as the different materials droids were made of I'd like to learn more about which faction protected their troops the most.
Also I don't really care what Tshirt I get, they both look like very nice designs
Michael Lurch definitely not the rebels
Alucard definitely not but I was thinking he could briefly mention all of the smaller groups that made up the rebellion. Mandolorians, Alderanians, ex-clone troopers, and many other peoples have some kind of armor as well as stolen storm trooper armor.
Also I wouldn't mind seeing a separate video about where the rebellion got all of their supplies, vehicles and weapons. I feel like everything we see them use has to have a story. I'd like to know
Make it F.O, Imperial, Clone, and Rebel protective gear (Droids don't wear armor)
Nich White yeah but droids are made out of a variety of protective materials. I'd like to see an in depth look at the alloys used. Such as the B1, B2 and droideka as well as the other droids used by the confederacy
Eckhart, we are still waiting for the Top 5 star Wars Empires
Der Katalysator According To Palpatine He creates the First Galactic EMPIRE
Windows. Exe ye, first GALACTIC empire, not the first empire
Three empires that existed before that (long before that) was the Sith Empires
The Sith Empire(s) are no longer canon.
If the resistance was on this list, then their bomber would be last. It has the strongest payload of all bombers, but its soooo slow and can't even take hits from some tie fighters.
If you look at historical use of strategic bombers (which they are based on) they aren't meant to go toe to toe with fighters. That's why they always have a fighter escort and flew very high above ground. They are there to deliver as much ordnance as possible and nothing else. Speed is not important, as you should not be outrunning things, and the turrets are meant to discourage enemy fighters from attacking, not to attack themselves. The resistance did a terrible job of using them like they should have, and flew them right above the dreadnought, and far too close and in too few numbers. The allies flew hundreds of these at once to be effective and were always escorted
Theyre still very bad. They are far to slow. Also WTF happend in this Movie Arent Shields a thing anymore? Naaah I guess a SINGLE Fighter Destroying the entire defenses of an Dreadnought is absolutely Fine. I mean can we talk about that bullshit? Also the Hyperdrive thing. Damn i hate and love that Movie.
OP Physics Same. I have a love hate relationship with episode 8. Also I get that they shouldn't be super duper fast, but even if they have a fighter escort, they should still be able to take plenty of hits in case their escort fails at doing a good job, or if the escort is overwhelmed by larger numbers or stronger firepower.
also the resistance bomber has defensive turrets which should be able to take out some fighters that take them on, but they are on a diffrent catigory of craft.
But that Category of Crafts does not work in the Star Wars universe. Those Bombers cant approach any target that has at least one defensive Turret available. You can Snipe those Vehicles out of the Air and they cant do anything about it. The only way that those things would hit anything is if the Target has no Weapons for whatever Reasons (Ahaem Bullshit single Starfighter action ahem) and no halfway competent star fighter Pilot because no one could miss these things from even a mile away. That is just a very bad design.
I would like either shirt and an idea for factions compared is what faction has the best armour/gear on their troops.
You kept saying the B-wing had a large profile, but that's actually not true. From the Front or back (ie, when its attacking a ship/installation, or being chased) it actually has a small profile due to all the dead space between its wings/s-foils. Even if it was making minor maneuvers, it wouldn't be exposing much of its frame, unlike the other 3.
Replicators vs a Unified Star Wars universe *(101st try now, **_I._** WILL NEEEEEVER EEEEVER GIVE UP!!!)*
YOU CAN DO IT!!!
+Darth Cendius What are you even on about?
+tigersebel *THANKS!!*
coming up on infra-red Stargate Replicators?
+Rensune Yep
SPOILER WARNING
The resistance bomber surely could have placed pretty high. A single one destroyed an *E N T I R E* star dreadnought!
They have plenty of flaws, They carried over 100 bombs while a B-Wing or Y-Wing carried 5-20 Bombs, But this means they are very slow and unlike the B-Wing, they NEED a fighter escort
MC80 Gaming They carry over a thousand actually
Tankdavid7 And I think they're more for atmosphere
Tankdavid7 the exact complement of bombs the MG-100 StarFortress carried was 1048. If you read the book Cobalt Squadron, it teaches you more about the bombers and how they are capable of manuevering away from asteroids. They could also match the speed of a BTL-A4 Y-Wing Starfighter.
Stakuga The Undying they're designed for space.
I love that you talked about the B-Wing here. It's my absolute favorite Starfighter from the entire series, followed by the ARC-170 (apparently I like my heavy assault fighters). I hardly ever see anything about the B-Wing anywhere, so am just super pleased that you did this vid. Also happy that my fave ship took top spot.
BEEE SEVENTEEN BAAAWWWWMMMER
Of the merch, the base design looks best. Too bad your Doge design (#2) couldn't have the X-wing pilot helmet.
I'd love to see you put out a Faction/Universe Versus that focuses on fleet doctrine, especially those highlighted by the Star Wars (of course) Trek, Halo, BSG or more factions. Heck, just the four...er....six major factions of Star Wars is enough material for a good solid video.
As much as you bring up the fighting styles of each, it'd be cool to see that formally highlighted.
Just imagine how deadly an impirial model of the Y-wing with updated weapons and shields would be
The droid bombers did what they needed to. In large numbers, with escorts, they could easily overwhelm whatever the Republic threw at us.
General Grievous sure and you got shot in the hart by Obi-wan kenobi
I agree with Grievous. Especially with their ability to cripple a large warship in one pass. Wish they had shields though...
On top of the fact that droid ships had less need for g-force countermeasures.
CatsSketches NL Shut up! He was literally clinging onto his life!!!
Yes, but like a smart cyborg, he kept his mind linked to a backup server and had plenty of cloning pods stolen from the Republic to grow new organs...
The Covenant vs the Yuuzhan Vong.
The UNSC vs the Rebel Alliance.
The Eldar (WH40K) vs the Galactic Republic (Clone Wars era).
The First Order vs the New Republic (EU/legends).
The Galactic Empire vs the Eternal Empire (ignoring the difference in technology).
the Separatist Alliance vs the Galactic Republic.
The Rakatan Infinite Empire vs the Tau Empire.
The Covenant vs the Eldar.
The Fallout USA vs the Combine (Half Life).
The Yuuzhan Vong vs the Necrons (WH40K).
Thrawn's confederation vs The Restored Empire.
The New Republic (EU/legends) vs the old Republic (Clone Wars era).
The Resurgent Sith Empire vs the Dark Eldar.
The First Order vs the Covenant.
The Mandalorians (the Mandalorian war) vs Darth Malak's Sith Empire.
Chaos (WH40K) vs Darth Krayt's Galactic Empire.
Bruce Jedi Lee, Hmmmm... Maybe don't use WH40K, (especially Chaos) for versus because I can already see these scenarios as being one-sided fights. Like the Eldar have Craftworlds which have been known to wipe out entire fleets.
Hydrogen One I don't think it is nearly as one sided as some think. The Tau lost to the Covenant in one of these videos, The Imperium of man didn't get an easy win over the Empire and honestly Crafworlds have also been known to be destroyed or at least pushed back by other fleets. And the Eldars are smaller in numbers and have less resources than the Republic
Hydrogen One Also Krayt's empire is huge with plenty of Sith in it. I think they can match Chaos in battle
Everything from WH40k stomps exept of tau vs rakata, here rakata stomp
brak danych The Rakata hasn't demonstrated technology beyond that of the Tau. Nor has anything from 40K shown any levels of technological that is far beyond SW, except for Space Marines.
You should do a video on the best armor worn between factions if that isn't already done
I thought the b wing was the y wing and the y wing was the b wing lmao
How bout tri fighter vs arc 170
I would love to see a comparison of the different cargo ships, from the Empire’s to Dash’s ship to the Falcon. I think there’s a lot of material there to discuss.
Thunderbolt Starfury from Babylon 5 vs the Sabre from Halo Reach. Jahgd mirage from Five Star Stories vs the Imperator Titan from Warhammer 40K. The T-shirt I want is anything in large size men's.
Barry Bend bruh, just a word, we should stop pushing 40k to these versus vids, the universe is deigned to be on completely higher level than anything else ever created. As much as I love watching 40K decimate all There is.
Not the Jahgd mirage as it has the power to destroy planets. Plus Five Star Stories has the tech to rival most of the *Mechanised* forces of the Warhammer 40K series. Read the manga and see what I mean.
Barry Bend in a world where a low ranking Psyker can obliterate a planet... No, it really does not matter what you bring against 40k as it is the power trip fantasy exemplified. I'm not saying five star stories isn't cool and powerful universe. But trying to compare anything to 40k is like asking "who could beat Saitama from One punch man? " the joke is that the power level is so absurd that by asking, one makes a fool out of themselves.
Well for my vs match up suggestions it's if one of these machines can destroy the others with equal experienced crews so no pycher from Warhammer 40k and no divers from Five star Stories, just the pilots and support crews.
if you are still not convinced here is a link for the entire universe vs argument. forums.spacebattles.com/threads/imperial-sol-warhammer-40k-vs-the-joker-cluster-five-star-stories.275937/
I love the design of the B-Wing quite a bit.
1. This video should have used the resistance bomber
2. The rebels and the republic used slightly different y-wings, but still the same ( rebels had automized turret and the armor was removed )
3. Hyena bombers were great because they could crash into their enemy and effectively deliver their payload all on one spot.
The MegaZord Vs The Iron Giant. No? Just me?
Which faction had the best enforcer?
Darth Vader
Kylo Ren
General Grievous
(Can’t think of another, perhaps a Jedi or Luke or Rey)
Kylo ren was bad
+Goaty. yes but his ability to break minds to extract information is unmatched by any other individual in the entire galaxy. That probably gives him some points.
I must have missed that in the Movies
Also General Grievous was the coolest.
you could call this the champion catigory. republic: Yoda, mace or another counsel Jedi. cis could include gevious or count Dokku, empire, darth vader, thrawn, rebellion, all of the main cast. first order, kylo ren and resistance, poe dameron, ray.
Halo UNSC vs the Yautija clan (Predator)
Or
Halo UNSC vs the Xenomorph (Aliens)
I like the one that says your RUclips name on it, I'm an XL please
Warhammer 40k vs the flood
A minor correction: Republic Y-wings had a gunner controlled laser cannon turret, while the Alliance locked them forward and replaced it with an ion cannon controlled by the gunner.
In my opinion that's another point for the Republic Y-Wing. It gives them a better field of fire for offensive purposes, and makes them better able to defend themselves from fighters, and to protect each other when they're in formation.
The ion cannon is great for knocking out capital ships but as a pilot I'd take a gunner any day.
Great video as always though
Will versus ever be back? (Not faction versus)
I hope so. I'm still waiting for him to do the T-70 X-Wing VS E-Wing
the B-wing was actually slower and less well armored than the Y-wing. but was better shielded and it's heavy firepower made up for it's other shortcomings.
No mention of the Resistance B-17? Figured the tie bomber would at least beat that one.
braith117 Well I guess it wasn't included because everybody knows it's the worst bomber.
Regardess of how bad it might be, I'm still surprised it wasn't included. It is, after all, a bomber, and has the advantage of a payload that's an order of magnitude larger than the other bombers listed here. Even if it's still last, it would have been interesting to compare and contrast it between the others.
It's probably the best classic example of a bomber out of all of them. The downside of that being that it, like classic bombers, needs an escort on missions because it's almost entirely defenseless. Also it doesn't seem like it was designed for combat outside of atmosphere.
it is so much better than a tie bomber. a single resistance bomber completely destroyed a 7km long first order dreadnaught. the resistance bomber holds over 1000 proton bombs and is actually quite quick. it did not take long for it to cross a 7km long dreadnaught
7km in space is a very very short distance, even in SW. Also it was an extremely flawed design in all aspects, poor defences, poor armour and shields, poor speed and manoeuvrability, poor layout, poor bomb deployment (If it was actually able to move other than a snails pace all those bombs would be spread over a 3km area which is not effective at all), Its no where near cost efficient for the New Republic to have since its obsolete in all aspects, you got better Anti cap bombers: B wing and hell the Y wing and strategic bombing is obsolete since you got Orbital bombardment which does the job better. It makes no in universe sense, and visually it was not even able to capture the essence of WW2 bombing raids.
why not the resistance.....
what would happen when 2 X-304 Deadalus class jup into the battle of eath form halo
the shirt without the dog:)
Can we see a best main field general (Anakin, Grevious, Vader, Luke)
Luke is not really a general he was a commander, but more of a special unit, Leia was the general.
Admiral Zaarin!
DragonAngel yes but admisable
Grevious would definitely be #1
Anakin Skywalker VADER AND YOU ARE THE SAME PERSON
Which faction has the best tank?
The last time I was this early Obama was president.
Last time I was early Bush was still president
Last time it was George Washington Wwww🤣
jun tanizaki last time I was this early the Trojan war was happening
The last time I was this early, good old America was still a good child of England.
Last time I was this early, there was no such thing as early.
Do Resistance vs Rebellion fighters, bombers, and cruisers? (PS I'll take that eckharts shirt at a x large)
Those Resistance bombers though. Who thinks a big tower with, like 2 guns was a good idea?
Can the UNSC and the Covenant survive and beat the Angel Zeruel from Evangelion on Earth when the Covenant first attacked? Zeruel appears out of nowhere in this and is laying waste to everything and everyone that it sees and gets in it's way while trying to look for Lilith on this version of Earth to start the next Impact
coming up on infra-red I think everything in Evangelion is stronger than anything in Star Wars. Especially Zeruels A.T. Field which is one if the strongest. They have nothing to neutralize the angels A.T. Field
Well it does say in the wiki a directed energy weapon can pierce the field so the covenants beam weapon (called an energy projector) might do the job.
+shadow carthage Yeah but 2.22 Zeruel can spam *_multi layers of A.T. Fields_* at a time....
shadow carthage but Zeruels A.T. Field is stronger than those of the other angels (Tabris excluded) and for Ramiel it even took japanese whole Energy. I know there are many stronger weapons in Star Wars but Zeruel has also a strong "skin" and in 2.22 in needed EVA-01s particle beam to break the rips and I think that is stronger than many Star Wars Weapons. Also the core needs to be destroyed and that thing is also durable and Zeruel has strong weapons himself so it will be hard
Yes but the covenant have quite a few ships with that weapon on it at the time. And even with the multiple layers of shielding that Zeruel has Those weapons are pretty strong.
Which Star Wars Faction has the best Force Users?!
nunouno001 Palpatine is the most powerful sith lord ever
nunouno001 It’s obviously the Galactic Republic
Clash Gamer pretty sure he isn’t but ok
Alucard George Lucas has said it
Alucard If we take legends he is easily the most powerful sith lord ever
Factions compared, Military Commanders
Kenneth Kates lol I’m pretty sure Thrawn has no equal there
Sarge Large That depends. Thrawn wins for best Admiral. Grievous wins best General.
Albedo politely disagree
Sarge Large How so?
Albedo to me one of the most important leadership qualities is the ability to delegate intelligently. Troop management is essential to victory. Grevious HATED his soldiers, often smashed them himself. Thrawn took what he had and was 15 minutes from defeating the new republic. He knew who to put where and I think that makes him superior.
10/10 Covenant Fleet vs Imperial Fleet
Krogans (from the Mass Effect series) VS Brutes (from the halo series) and/or perhaps Elites (from the Halo series) VS Turians (from the Mass Effect series) ps I love the shirt with your logo
the B-wing was actually slower and less well armored than the Y-wing. but was better shielded and it's heavy firepower made up for it's other shortcomings.
MajorButtons question is how many y wings can be made
For every b wing, plus the y wings were old and were being given away for free
Speed: B-Wing 91MGLT, Y-Wing 80MGLT = B-Wing is faster (X-Wing 100)
Acceleration: 16MGLT/s vs 11MGLT/s = B-Wing Accelerates faster
Manuverability: B-Wing 70DPF, Y-Wing 59DPF = B-Wing is more Manuverable (X-Wing 100)
Shieldstrength: 100SBD vs 75SBD = B-Wing has stronger Shields (X-Wing 50)
Armor: 60RU vs 40RU (X-Wing 20RU) = B-Wing is stronger armoured
The only two stats were the Y-Wing outperforms an B-Wing is Hyperspacespeed (Rating of 2 for the B-Wing and 1 for the Y-Wing, lower is here better and price. a B-Wing costs a lot more (220K Credits vs 135k Credits)
Schwarzie x the fudge i didnt expect this
@Timothy Miller the same can be said for armor. being a mon cal design it favors shielding to armor to save weight. it also benefits from being very maneuverable if slow. while a flight of b-wings can't out-run a flight of TIEs, the B-wings can out-fight them. that said it's not made to fight TIEs, it's made to fight star destroyers.
@@schwarziex3563 I was going off the old canon, it seems. and I prefer the old cannon where the B-wing is a compromise where they ditch armor to gain payload and maneuverability and make up the difference with enhanced shielding.
4:48 gets it wrong even when he’s correcting himself lol
Spartans (Halo) vs N7 (Mass Effect) and UNSC Marines (Halo) vs System Alliance Marines (Mass Effect)
It would be the Halo soldiers its not really a compatition
Um... I think you forgot a certain bomber that was featured in the last star wars movie...
The B-Wing may have a large target profile, but that’s only from the side. When it’s coming at you, it’s pretty slim and it was made specifically to be that way, to have a narrow profile from straight on; you’d mainly see it when it’s coming for you, straight on.
The tie bomber however, has a rather large target profile. Ironically, it has a large target profile, no shielding, it’s slow, and it’s not very maneuverable; it’s ironic because it’s packed to the brim with explosive ordinance, so it can’t take any glancing hits because that’ll trigger some of the bombs (even 1 is enough), which will blow ALL of them in a quick chain reaction. It’s essentially a suicide ship that goes out with a bang (pun intended).
Suggestion: which faction has the best force user.
The Grenadier That's a good idea for a video
SuperLatios333 wouldn’t Dooku be the Force user for the CIS?
If it's Galactic Civil War period, it's the Empire with Palpatine. If it's just stronger in general, then it's the Rebel Alliance with Luke.
? The Emperor was stronger than Luke.
OP Physics During Episode 6, yes he was. So was Vader. Luke didn't become the most powerful until much later. Heck in Dark Empire, Luke only defeated reborn Palpatine because Leia was with him. Once Luke reaches Grandmaster status though, he is the best of the 4 factions. But that is years after Episode 6.
EckhartsLadder! Great video. Could you do a galactic verses. A unified Star Wars galaxy, during the Clone Wars vs a Unified Star Trek galaxy right before the dominion war. Also this is the full star trek galaxy, so the Borg and the entire Dominion empire will be in on this.
James Hagberg Star Trek would win because of the Borg they could adapt turbolasers so they wouldn't do any damage
James Hagberg, Honestly to many variables/ factions for Star Trek to make an accurate fight. Like all the almost God like beings.
Though it would be fun to see.
Not sure if they could. They arent Phasers most likely not even beam weapons (More like Plasmaweapons and who said that they have the same Frequency with every shot? No i guess this would break down to whatever Side has the Bigger Fleets and Recourses. Another thing is the Technologie Level. If its nearly the Same then an Star destroyer would easely be able to destroy most Warships of the Dominion and the just because there far larger than those ships and are more durable build. However the Ships in star Trek focus more on Speed than their Star Wars equivalents but in my opinion lack the overwhelming Firepower of the Stardestroyers. ( I dont count in those OP Torpedos of Federacy because powerlevels in Sci fi are basically like those in Anime: Unresonable overpowered in some points but not consistent. Correct me if im mistaken anywhere) So id Say the Empire would win because their Fleet is bigger with larger Ships in general. But thats just my Opinion.
If it was the Empire, they would win almost certainly, the Star Wars universe is just more advanced then Star Trek and there is no way around that. Thats why i'm saying we should compare during the Clone Wars that way it would be a little more fair. Venators are smaller then Star Destroyers, and actually some star trek ships are as large as Star Destroyers. Dominion, Jem'Hadar Battleships are only a few hundred meters shorter then a star destroyer, and are basically the star trek equivalent.
How come you think the SK Universe is not as technological advanced as the SW Universe?
My favourite bomber is the tie bombers just because it makes such a cool and iconic noise
K Wing
The whole Great British military Vs a single rebel alliance Home 1 capital ship
1:26
"Figher"
Christian Caisley same thing at the start
Gunships!!!! Compare gunships!!!!!! You must!!!!! Hehe!!! I am not crazy!!! Listen!!!!
I agree. Such a comparison would be beneficial when designing my army.
Which Faction has the Best Intercepter?
Why not do a comparison of everything from the republic to empire and see if it got better or worse
The ones that the resistance used are obviously the best.
Which star wars faction has the best head quarters?
The CIS, it was well hidden, and was never destroyed. The Rebellion didn't really have a headquarters, so they wouldn't count.
2 Harrower Dreadnaught vs Imperial Star Destroyer
Amazing video keep the factions series coming!
Which Star Wars Faction has the best Naval Admiral? Also, I like hoodies
Take a look at the best bomber of WW2, the B-29. Good speed (max speed was around 350 mph, cruise at 290 mph) and plenty of bombs, machine guns and armor. Just like the B-wing. Comparing the B-29 to pre-war fighters the B-29 could outrun many of them (the Soviet I-16 maxed out at ~320 mph, according to pilots from the Spanish civil war the I-16 was one of the best fighters of the war). I think the B-wing was a excellent first choice.
CIS vs the Borg!
Nice one
The malevolence would be very effective in this case
CIS would win immediately, as the Borg would have very little to assimilate. Only organic commanders would have much, and even then, they were very few, and very difficult to reach.
How easily can the Borg adapt? One Borg cube might be sufficient. Also behind the CIS are planets with lots of... assimilatable people.
how do bombs drop in space?
Internet Zen Master Yeah there are a lot of things that don’t make sense in Star Wars from a physics standpoint. Sound in space, wings on planes in space, etc.
I think the visual guide explained they were using magnetic mines or something like that iirc
Welcome to star wars where physics is taken into a back alley and violently has it's head kicked in. xD
I assume they fire bombs as opposed to just dropping them. Apply some force to the payload and it'll just carry on going in whatever direction it's shot in, at whatever speed it's shot at, forever or until another force acts upon it.
Exactly this. They're launched, not dropped.
The Enclave of the fallout universe VS UNSC? Would be interesting to see how power armour faced the Spartan program
2 years late but I think the Spartans would win handedly against Power Armored troops. The latter are, yes, stronger than the average soldier because of the armor but much less mobile and under the armor, they're still normal, unaltered people while Spartans have not only also very strong armor, but are also fast, strong, and altered in a way that gives quite an advantage, not to mention also having the possibility of having an AI assist them.
CLEARLY the Resistance Bomber from Ep.VIII.
Because having an OPEN bomb bay that drops bombs relying on gravity in the middle of SPACE is pure genius! How did no one think of that before?!
Referred as a sitting duck
What the hell is a duck!
Top 5 Imperial commanders from canon
I like the 🅱️ wing 🅱️om🅱️er
Faction Weapons also large doge shirt
ARGH... Bomber... Y-wing was a torpedo bomber, first and formost it was for torpedo runs (See TBF-Avenger). Tie Bomber wasn't actually a bomber, it was an attack aircraft, it carried lighter loads then true bombers, but could be configuerd for light bombing, missile strike, torpedo, or mine laying runs (see A-1 sky raider), the B-wing is either an attack fighter or strike fighter, true multi-roll heavy fighter/attack (the difference between strike and attack is nuclear. A strike aircraft is capable of dropping a nuke, so most strike fighters can carry out attack jobs, but most attack aircraft can't carry out strikes). Finally the vulture droid. the vulture is most often seen doing CAS duty (close air support), though can attack heavier targets, small nimble its more closely related to the A-4 Bantum Bomber. the first REAL bomber we see is in the last jedi... that thing would be consdiered a medium or maybe Heavy bomber. Consider for a moment, a tie bomber would carry 4 proton bombs or 64 detonators. A B-52 would carry 100 750 pound bombs. Even a ww2 B-17 would carry 16 500 pound bombs or 32 250 pounders. 4 proton bombs +6 torpedo's +6 rockets is actually closer to the A-4's or a6's loadout.
Which faction had the best land vehicles (walkers, tanks speeders etc.) My favorite t-shirt is the doge one