In my opinion you've become the Best reviewer hands down on internet. Great graphics,calm voice,on point with everything that matters, meticulous in everything. My compliments. I look everyday for your content, specially things related to pixels and android
Most of your issues are not even a issue. They are user defaults and mostly will be changed once you get the phone. It is allmost like lot of people complaining about s23's sim card tray hole was right next to the microphone hole. Most users do this once every few months or maximum once every year lol So, finally after watching all the long term reviews I decided to buy s23 ultra, making this move from s20 so hopefully a decent upgrade also at a 30% off price than the launch. Thank you.
You should definitely include camera performance in social media apps like Snapchat and instagram and also video call quality in these apps too Pixel 6 and later uses real time processing and if the phone is hot the quality is degraded, so would love a similar test for these phones which supports Camera 2 extension library
SCREW social media! Grow up, and get a "REAL" life. Your generation is the single worst gen in history, in your obsession with fake life and all things social media.
If only Google didn't mess things up on the performance department, I would have still blindly went for pixel but because of only this single issue, I went with S23 Ultra. If Samsung can bring all the software goodness that Google provides with their smartphone then it will be hands down the true king of Android smartphone
The S23 Ultra is ALREADY the "TRUE KING" of the flagship smartphones. There's nothing Google does that matches the entire package of this phone. NOTHING!
Him liking the Pixel and reviewing it doesnt make him a fanboy , if Pixels were to become bad its probably gonna be the end of videos for them . But their Ui and the things they add are alwaya interesting
Great review and I do agree with many points you've mentioned but highly disagree with your takes on software and resale value. You're judging 1UI 6 beta 1 against stock Android beta 5 which is much closer to stable release. There are bound to be bugs and major changes/overhauls during the testing phase. How is that even fair? You should've compared stable release firmware between the two since most users will not be daily driving beta releases. Also, one of the bugs you've mentioned about the settings button being too close to the QS toggles doesn't exist in stable 5.1, if you even bother to check. Duplicate apps are a problem derived from Google in case you didn't notice. It is a prerequisite for all Android phones to ship preinstalled with some of Google's own software apps. You buy a Samsung phone but don't expect Samsung's own software apps prebaked is like saying pixels shouldn't have Google's own apps preinstalled out of the box. The only downside you failed to mention is that there should've been an easy way for the user to uninstall preloaded "bloat" apps within the OS. Missing features from the pixels you prefer that are missing from the S23U are a you problem. Every OEM ships different software features in their own OS skins. There are bound to be pros and cons to everything as you've mentioned. Finally, resale value is not a sole Samsung issue but an Android problem as a whole. Android phones just don't hold value all that well compared to iPhones which has been a fact for many years now. To be fair, Samsung phones depreciate the slowest compared to many other Android OEM devices in the market but it's still inevitable to drop months after launch. Which other Android flagship holds value far better than Samsung flagships? If you're approaching the review with a preconceived notion that stock Android software is better or highly preferred then you're never going to be fair in doing reviews with personal biases. I suggest you keep an open mind for any reviews you'll do in the future.
With regard to resale values, Samsung devices crash and burn very quickly. Samsung knows this and is why they have good trade-ins. Imagine users just getting market value when trading an S22U to an S23U, they would literally be sick and become aware of the truth. In the UK the Fold 5 already has lost £700+ in a couple of weeks compared to list price!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! As for software, having used both, the Pixel experience is more than just stock Android, it is about those features that push it way ahead of Samsung, from dictation, recorder, translation, to just much better AI and ML. It rises above Samsung phones, that just ply you with thousands of settings and features that mostly you will never use. But clever marketing and spec-chasing by Samsung pleases its fans and they know what the youth demographic want. Once you add in the cost, e.g. in the UK the Pixel 7P was £850 versus the S23U at £1400 for the same 12GB versions, you realise that the Pixel may not be superior in most regards, but bang for buck it is great. As you say, both fall in price rapidly so those list prices can easily be reduced; the Pixel by half now as it ends its life cycle. I agree with the reviews points but understand that Samsung fans love Samsung and will see it different.
For the point about the software all the drawbacks I mention exist in the stable version, look at the notification settings and clear buttons, look at your apps shortcuts if you own a Samsung phone and you will see the same, also the software updates issue is Samsung's issue (they are slow), the smart features quality is not great and I have evidence from my previous videos when I was using the stable version, Samsung's want to clone everything for some reason. For Google's forcing OEMs to put their apps that makes sense because it's their software if Samsung prefer to make thier own apps they should make their own software in the first place to be in control or else stick to Google apps and save the hassle for themselves and the users. The resale value is an Android problem that's true but this doesn't mean its not Samsung' problem too and as far as this review is dedicated to the S23U so am noting it. I used this phone side-by-side with my Pixel 7 Pro what I liked here, I mentioned and what I liked on the 7 Pro side I also mentioned
@@IDTRMost, if not all, software gripes that you have can easily be fixed through settings or through Goodlock (which you have already talked about, however didn't in this video for some reason). It would have made more sense to test it using Android 13 stable versions instead of beta, regardless of if something is still a problem in the stable version. Using two different betas, and actually using betas would mean guaranteed different experiences than on the normal, stable Android 13/OneUI 5.1 versions. You mentions the cons of the 23U to the Pixel, however no cons of the Pixel to the 23U. If you did, please say, however, that's rather ridiculous. This video did start to steam more of a battery on the 23U than much else. Although I do appreciate your problems, one would say, you get used to it after a while. Hence why Galaxy users are used to volume keys, boxy design, etc and don't really complain. If I was just a usual person coming here for a comparison, I would get the impression the 23U is crap while the 7 pro is heaven. However, we both know that's not true. They are both phones with different purposes, uses, prices and intended userbases. I emphasise on the prices. It feels a bit weird to be comparing two phones that are that different in prices. Especially since you wouldn't really be looking at a 23U if you were looking at a 7 pro. I get that it's just a what if scenario. Overall, I like your videos, however, this seems more like a "Coming from Pixel 7 Pro to 23U long term comparison (rant edition)" video rather than your usual.
@@andyH_England I use an s9+ and the performance is the same like 5 years back as for crash and burns my phone hasn't crashed aside from freezes accuring when heavily using the phone which is expectable from a 5 year old phone but still holds up well.i didn't see any burn on the display or any other place and the battery life is only less cause first up its five years so the battery has degraded and it has 3500mah battery
Used to be an iPhone user since 3gs to iPhone10, and I switch to Vivo X50pro and now S23U! Never regret! Bought my first ever Samsung phone S23U on March and until now, it still surprising me till now.
About photo issues, just turn of scenery optymizer in settings and set smoothing on medium in camera assistant form good lock. Now they reflect colors like they should and no over sharpening issues, simple to fix
I have seen lot of s23 ultra reviews, but seen nothing like it. It's too detailed and explained in all the aspects. Awesome review. I think this is the best one I seen as s23 ultra review.
Honestly idk why people complain about a company releasing their software update, if google releases is it then yeah great..just like that treat other OEMs too..they are using the base model of Android 14 but they need to make changes to their smartphone and u will get it it when they release it.. people are excited about getting Android 14 on pixels but people are excited about getting one ui 6 on their galaxy phones, it's not the same. And not liking a particular feature which other phone has and other doesn't, really doesn't make sense, cuz that other phone don't have the features this phones cuz it's a diff phone. Galaxy store is there for a reason, they don't need to get approved from Google before sending an update they can just send it via their galaxy store and there are some apps which u only get through galaxy store cuz it's a galaxy phone, it's just make sense. About default apps, it's the same cuz it's a Samsung phone and the default will be Samsung apps,idk how hard is it to understand.
I 100% agree with you, your buying a Samsung phone not Google, of course there apps are going to be default to Samsung. Also how he goes on about the OS update, he tried to install a beta of course its going to be different to pixel as that is a Google phone, ONE UI has so many more features than the stock android OS, his point is totally moot. Also lol about the scratches on the screen, if your buying an expensive phone, you always put on a glass screen protector, I use the whitestone as mentioned in the video, they are easy to put on. Coming from a S23 Ultra user, so of his dislikes are just stupid.
Having three different phones in the past was a nightmare, iPhone, Pixel & Samsung, had to drop Samsung since Pixel was my daily driver to concentrate on 2 different platforms since each one of them have pros and cons. I preferred my S21 Ultra design to S22 Ultra & S23 Ultra. I am surprised regarding your screen scratches because I have never had this kind of an issue with Samsung phones in the past. When it comes to Pixel phones, your channel is definitely is the exclusive source to follow.
Over the usage of S23 ultra for me. I noticed. That when it comes to photo and video mode given as default settings by manufacturer. It's too much of processing done after you shoot the video or photo. So compared to other Flagship it loses the round.. but! I found a better option in the device itself. And that it Pro photo / Video mode given in device. Using just auto mode in that settings boosts the Qualities of content. Way better than IPhone and Other Flagship. I would recommend to try this who uses S23 ultra and you wouldn't be Disappointed by this.
Not sure why pure google people who can only see stock android in their eyes do even bother to go anywhere else. This is not for enthuciasts but for general people who like overall a good phone with no compromises and excels in all departments. These pixel followes are a pain everywhere who cry on every platform available about the UI instead they should petition Sundar Pichai to at least make a decent phone with a half decent chip and if they cant make Tensot better, they should use snapdragon or even exynos
Not a balanced review in my opinion. Which Android flagship device keeps its value even if someone indeed wants to sell his phone after six months? Is that Samsung's fault and what should they do about it? In terms of camera quality other than the noise everything is subjective but if I'm not mistaken i haven't heard a word about telescope zoom one of the phone's greatest strengths. As for the software there's great emphasis to what the stock Android does best and as for what One UI does best we have merely three seconds of "feature rich" and that's pretty much it. But many people love One UI exactly because of that "feature richness". I wouldn't expect mentioning Good Lock... And what about the S Pen? There's a mention about non symmetrical bezels but the S Pen must be the reason. No other device has an S Pen and for some people that's the reason to buy the phone. I'm quite old and my memory doesn't serve me well... did he even mention it?
Great info about the S23 Ultra. I love my S22 Ultra. I do the same by activating Airplane mode when hitting the settings button. I need to move that. lol I don't games or anything with my phones. I just watch RUclips, music, etc. Coming from the iPhone 8+ & then the Note 10+. Wow! What a difference outdoors! Seeing an HDR Movie in sunlight! Love it! Not a single micro scratch on it. However, I've always kept it in a case & I rotate a TPU Screen Protector every 2-3 months since it's release date. I'm still learning everything the S22 Ultra has to offer me every day in Sept 2023. These phones can do so much & from what I've seen. Samsung is starting to retain its value better. (Amazon) It still has all day battery life, actually mine has never gotten below 50%, etc. I've had it out fishing all day connected to my Watch Pro 5 & a Bluetooth speaker playing music all day on the water here in SE Texas. I almost got the 23 Ultra but it was basically the same as the 22. It's just a great phone. It feels tiny in my hand compared to the Plus iPhone sizes, those are wide in the hand. I'm waiting to see if the S24 Ultra is going to have a flat screen & the Snapdragon 8 gen3 here in the States. If so, I'll update. If not? There's no need for me to update this phone for another 2 to 4 more years.
You are basically nit picking everything in the software. It is a personal opinion and as a reviewer you have to give a neutral review. You better continue using Pixel Phone since you clearly have an issue with UI design difference.
i own s23 ultra but your review gives me a different perspective man it was great watching that even the best phones has so many minuscule issues that actually affects the user experience.
The screen scratch is due to Victus2 protection. Victus 2 helps with screen protection during fall over the scratches. So anyone who is planning for S23 ultra should use screen protection. Without that there is gng to be hell lot of scratches
What a review. One thing also.. lack of focus for close up photos. Samsung should watch this video for further improvements. Im too using s23 ultra. Really liked the video sir. Keep going
GG Victus 2 really scratches more but it's because it's more durable against drops and shatters. It's softer than GG6 so definitely, it scratches easier than previous generations
Thank you for another excellent review. I am a S23U owner and love my phone. My wife has the Pixel 7 which is as smooth as butter, and perhaps a Pixel is in my future, but having traded every two years and pricing going up, I will keep this one for 3 to 4 years.
The Pixel lacks tons of features that this phone has. And this phone is a smooth as any on the market, if you know how to actually set it up. I have no idea how anyone can actually have this phone, and think about going to a Pixel, which is the phone I got rid of to get this phone????????? You're thinking seems to be going backwards...
@@AquaStevae Oh, I agree that my S23U is the best phone on the planet for now and the near future. Like I said, I'm planning on living with it for 3 to 4 years. Then perhaps, the Pixel will also be extraordinary and worthy of my consideration. My wife's phone is smooth as butter, but I agree with you that the S23U is no slouch in that department too.
@@prashantn687 It is great on both counts. The only thing missing is the Google Voice Typing that automatically inserts question marks among others. I wish Samsung would work on that.
This review is really good, very different from other review videos and for that I like it. So many useful information here that's not mentioned anywhere else. Thank you sir.
You are the only youtuber that brought small buttons issue. I don't know why no one is talking about it. I hate that notification clear button too and was hoping that it will be fixed with ONE UI 6 but I guess that's never gonna change. Honestly I never understood the company that is spending too much time and money on software optimization is missing such a silly thing which is there right infront of screen. Thanks for the full review. Appreciate it.
You made no mention of Good Lock, which any Galaxy owner should know of. It offers modules to customize every aspect of your phone including notifications, adding a quick toggle floating menu that can be brought up by swiping from either edge etc. The latter will allow you to adjust the volume without having to reach for the physical button.
The cut corners make it look unique and really good. It's not as annoying as the iPhones sharp edges cause you'll feel those more often. It's like you were looking for things to complain about.
Hi. I disagree with your point that you didn't like the OneUI experience. It's best imo. 1. To drag and drop. Hold the app and then push to the upper edge and you will be directed to the home screen and put anywhere you want. 2. You can change how many quick settings you want in the notification panel. Also can use a good lock module to theme the panel and everything. 3. You don't get many suggestions if you use the keyboard less. There is a feature where you get the clipboard items on top of the keyboard. In addition, you can view multiple clipboarded items if you want. Other than that I accept the software upgrade part and photo editing are not so good.
I agree with you except Software. When I used pixel. I like the pixel Asthetics but didn't like the practicality of pixel like UI is not one handedly accessible. You cannot move multiple apps from one to another Homescreen. No Stack widgets, cannot remove the at a glance, google search widget, Cannot apply Icon pack 💀, No Advanced Powerful back swipe gestures like One Hand Operation+ , and lot more.
I agree with you but those things are to be mentioned in the Pixel review, when I talk about the things I didn't like in OneUI it doesn't mean that I love everything about Pixel software, I just mentioned the pros and cons of the software
Thank you so so much...I have been reaearching the phone models that you featured for 3 months now and basically just learned more from you in 15 minutes!!!!
I totally disagree about the software! Security updates come out super fast, even faster than the pixel phones some times... Also the customization and options the ui has on pixels is a joke compared to Samsung's one UI... I'm writing this on a pixel phone and I'm really missing one ui...
This is a great and much awaited video, thanks for this. But I wouldve really loved it when you have ran some benchmarks after 6 months and comparing it with new model or with rivals. This might really give an idea of why (may be one of the reasons) the drastic price drop is. Cheers!
Premium Samsung phones came standard with a factory screen saver. Not sure if this model does but it might. If that is the case your screen may be fine you just might need a new screen saver installed. I know the factory screen savers used to be almost impossible to see with the naked eye. So you might not have any scratches in your screen.
I like the way you embrace your Egyptian accent and not even try to cover it while sounding perfectly clear 👍 also great review from end user prospective just what viewers need.
im highly considering getting the s23 ultra, i have a s8 plus, stil working condition. im not in a rush to buy a new phone just yet, the s8 plus is working like a charm atm.
Every time I get tempted to leave Pixel I find videos like this that reinforce how many little things my current phone does that would be impossible on others. Just interested in what your view would be on the Nothing phone 2, something that again looks tempting
@@kirillt6422 I don't really, but the Nothing phone 2 flat display with equal bezel looks too good to ignore. Then I remember call screening, voice typing and all other Google smarts that I use without even noticing and realise that the grass is not greener😄. It is just gear envy/ lust...I am a pixel boy though
This year alone I've had the S23U Pixel 7 Pro and OP11. I decided to give the NP2 a go. Nothing OS is phenomenal and extremely well optimised HOWEVER the camera is very erratic and the speakers are average. Stick with the Pixel or go with the OP11 as both are great devices and relatively bloat free. The S23U has so many duplicate apps and personally I'm not too keen on OneUI but that is subjective. The S23U is an ergonomic nightmare too.
for me the 23U is the best , i love the Spen feature that it has that just kills the competition even if i dont use it all the time it comes in handy when i need it .. every camera on flagship phones are pretty much the same so no complaint there.. its a beast
One Ui experience is still far superior to the Pixel experience. Pixel ui is for nerds only for who have a weird hard on for stock design. One ui has more features and looks more pleasing to eye.
And the kid colour design icons on one ui😂 And the messy inconsistent transparent background here and no transparency there. Mess of colour contradicting each other's under the transparency background
@fantasytky28 goodlock allows all that to be customized. All those issues you have can be turned off or changed if you don't like it. Skill issue it seems
I like this guys battery review. Idk how other youtubere get 2 days of battery. I have the same phone and get about the same screen on time. Well done thank you for your review.
You complain about not having "what's playing" feature and then you complain about your phones listening to you all the time... 🤔 And about the size of the icons you can always change them completely with goodlock
Best review I’ve seen for Samsung!!! Wish more reviewers would spend more time on cell signal and reception. Not everybody live in or near a city. When I was in Caribbean a hurricane damaged a cell tower. iPhone wouldn’t work at all but somehow Samsung lowered it cell reception to receive 3g and was crucial to allow me receive news and internet data.
It is obvious that whatever phone you are more used to is the one you would prefer. I have mostly used Samsung Galaxy phones in the past and about 6 months ago changed to the Google Pixel, after watching many reviews. I HATE the Pixel with a passion. I have never wanted to change a phone so quickly in my life. If not for the price I paid for it I would have changed straight back. My son is gifting me another Galaxy for Xmas. I can't wait.
You complain too much and you seem to really prefer the pixel. While OneUI has too many features, most are so useful that once you get used to them you'll have a hard time using the barebones pixel UI, where you have to download an extra app to obtain certain features. Plus the s23's hardware and battery life are far superior to the pixel 7 pro's
The best phone ive ever owned my only gripes with my s23 ultra is that they removed micro sd card I hate that and also losing tiny features with updates that android 10 and early kernel 13 had and a few other things otherwise incredible phone
I meant to add in my last comment that you are the first reviewer I've seen to call out the ridiculously small "Clear" button on the S23U notification shade. I'm not blind but I still miss hitting it sometimes because it is way too small. There is no need to have it so small on a giant screen.
@@marasion0862 I still prefer the Bixby button. I can just do single pressing to turn on/off DND, double pressing to on/off immersive mode, and long pressing for other thing. I think it's more efficient than using the power button.
I was planning to buy s24 and upgrading from iphone 14pm. I was worried about the price drop and now it is even clear. Resale value of Samsung really hurts. Hello from Sharjah :D
Hello! I’m considering switching from iPhone to Android for the first time in my life. What phone should I get? Am I gonna miss MagSafe and the other iPhone exclusive features that I use a lot? Thanks!
Hey mate Get a S23 Ultra it's a beast, also get a glass screen protector, the whitestone one he mentioned I have on mine, they are the best and easy to install. Performance, battery life and camera are amazing! Some of his dislikes are stupid, as you are buying a Samsung phone not a Google hence why Samsung apps are default. Also he goes on about the updates, ofcourse they are going to be delayed on the S23, as ONE UI, has so many more features than the pixel. The S23 Ultra is the best Android phone at the moment but this is just my opinion. It will be different from your iPhone as they are so many more customisations compared to a row of icons on the iPhone.
@@downundajoeI'm a pixel 7 pro user and I would to switch to samsung only for a colder cpu and a better multiapps, and maybe for a definitely better customization despite the fact that I like Google 's style and a definitely better selfie camera. But looking at this video I confirm that I just can't like the one graphic and practical side; In addition, the features of pixels such as now playing, the transcription of Google Assistant and multitasking. They definitely are a game changer for me. The bloatware problem can be solved and that is not the main problem. If it weren't for this I would already have S23U for sure.
In my opinion you've become the Best reviewer hands down on internet.
Great graphics,calm voice,on point with everything that matters, meticulous in everything.
My compliments.
I look everyday for your content, specially things related to pixels and android
I really appreciate it, many thanks
Yes I agree with you, he always goes farther than other youtubers and explains every thing in details
Just switched from pixel 7 pro to s23 ultra. Best decision ever. Great battery life
Totally agree, Pixel 7 pro battery sucks
@@2ya911 and its thermal management sucks too
You dont get like because this dude is a pixel fanboy😂
Everyone talks about how long the batery lasts, mine doesn't last that long
its because samsung co - designed the tensor chip 💀
Most of your issues are not even a issue. They are user defaults and mostly will be changed once you get the phone.
It is allmost like lot of people complaining about s23's sim card tray hole was right next to the microphone hole. Most users do this once every few months or maximum once every year lol
So, finally after watching all the long term reviews I decided to buy s23 ultra, making this move from s20 so hopefully a decent upgrade also at a 30% off price than the launch. Thank you.
You should definitely include camera performance in social media apps like Snapchat and instagram and also video call quality in these apps too
Pixel 6 and later uses real time processing and if the phone is hot the quality is degraded, so would love a similar test for these phones which supports Camera 2 extension library
SCREW social media! Grow up, and get a "REAL" life. Your generation is the single worst gen in history, in your obsession with fake life and all things social media.
If only Google didn't mess things up on the performance department, I would have still blindly went for pixel but because of only this single issue, I went with S23 Ultra. If Samsung can bring all the software goodness that Google provides with their smartphone then it will be hands down the true king of Android smartphone
The S23 Ultra is ALREADY the "TRUE KING" of the flagship smartphones. There's nothing Google does that matches the entire package of this phone. NOTHING!
@@AquaStevaeAI
Had the phone since it came out. Love it and every single way. ❤
The square look is much better. Reason I always got the Note series. Seems more professional and modern imo
Up-voted for the detailed battery life & performance reviews, plus the summary at the end. This is exactly what one looks for in a long-term review.
This is the only honest youtuber...
Yes, honest review by a Pixel user😂
Yeah sure
It's not honest it's pixel fan boy it's only like pixel
Definitely sure
Him liking the Pixel and reviewing it doesnt make him a fanboy , if Pixels were to become bad its probably gonna be the end of videos for them . But their Ui and the things they add are alwaya interesting
Great review and I do agree with many points you've mentioned but highly disagree with your takes on software and resale value.
You're judging 1UI 6 beta 1 against stock Android beta 5 which is much closer to stable release. There are bound to be bugs and major changes/overhauls during the testing phase. How is that even fair? You should've compared stable release firmware between the two since most users will not be daily driving beta releases. Also, one of the bugs you've mentioned about the settings button being too close to the QS toggles doesn't exist in stable 5.1, if you even bother to check.
Duplicate apps are a problem derived from Google in case you didn't notice. It is a prerequisite for all Android phones to ship preinstalled with some of Google's own software apps. You buy a Samsung phone but don't expect Samsung's own software apps prebaked is like saying pixels shouldn't have Google's own apps preinstalled out of the box. The only downside you failed to mention is that there should've been an easy way for the user to uninstall preloaded "bloat" apps within the OS.
Missing features from the pixels you prefer that are missing from the S23U are a you problem. Every OEM ships different software features in their own OS skins. There are bound to be pros and cons to everything as you've mentioned.
Finally, resale value is not a sole Samsung issue but an Android problem as a whole. Android phones just don't hold value all that well compared to iPhones which has been a fact for many years now. To be fair, Samsung phones depreciate the slowest compared to many other Android OEM devices in the market but it's still inevitable to drop months after launch. Which other Android flagship holds value far better than Samsung flagships?
If you're approaching the review with a preconceived notion that stock Android software is better or highly preferred then you're never going to be fair in doing reviews with personal biases. I suggest you keep an open mind for any reviews you'll do in the future.
🎉🎉🎉
With regard to resale values, Samsung devices crash and burn very quickly. Samsung knows this and is why they have good trade-ins. Imagine users just getting market value when trading an S22U to an S23U, they would literally be sick and become aware of the truth. In the UK the Fold 5 already has lost £700+ in a couple of weeks compared to list price!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
As for software, having used both, the Pixel experience is more than just stock Android, it is about those features that push it way ahead of Samsung, from dictation, recorder, translation, to just much better AI and ML. It rises above Samsung phones, that just ply you with thousands of settings and features that mostly you will never use. But clever marketing and spec-chasing by Samsung pleases its fans and they know what the youth demographic want.
Once you add in the cost, e.g. in the UK the Pixel 7P was £850 versus the S23U at £1400 for the same 12GB versions, you realise that the Pixel may not be superior in most regards, but bang for buck it is great. As you say, both fall in price rapidly so those list prices can easily be reduced; the Pixel by half now as it ends its life cycle.
I agree with the reviews points but understand that Samsung fans love Samsung and will see it different.
For the point about the software all the drawbacks I mention exist in the stable version, look at the notification settings and clear buttons, look at your apps shortcuts if you own a Samsung phone and you will see the same, also the software updates issue is Samsung's issue (they are slow), the smart features quality is not great and I have evidence from my previous videos when I was using the stable version, Samsung's want to clone everything for some reason.
For Google's forcing OEMs to put their apps that makes sense because it's their software if Samsung prefer to make thier own apps they should make their own software in the first place to be in control or else stick to Google apps and save the hassle for themselves and the users.
The resale value is an Android problem that's true but this doesn't mean its not Samsung' problem too and as far as this review is dedicated to the S23U so am noting it.
I used this phone side-by-side with my Pixel 7 Pro what I liked here, I mentioned and what I liked on the 7 Pro side I also mentioned
@@IDTRMost, if not all, software gripes that you have can easily be fixed through settings or through Goodlock (which you have already talked about, however didn't in this video for some reason). It would have made more sense to test it using Android 13 stable versions instead of beta, regardless of if something is still a problem in the stable version. Using two different betas, and actually using betas would mean guaranteed different experiences than on the normal, stable Android 13/OneUI 5.1 versions.
You mentions the cons of the 23U to the Pixel, however no cons of the Pixel to the 23U. If you did, please say, however, that's rather ridiculous. This video did start to steam more of a battery on the 23U than much else. Although I do appreciate your problems, one would say, you get used to it after a while. Hence why Galaxy users are used to volume keys, boxy design, etc and don't really complain.
If I was just a usual person coming here for a comparison, I would get the impression the 23U is crap while the 7 pro is heaven. However, we both know that's not true. They are both phones with different purposes, uses, prices and intended userbases. I emphasise on the prices. It feels a bit weird to be comparing two phones that are that different in prices. Especially since you wouldn't really be looking at a 23U if you were looking at a 7 pro. I get that it's just a what if scenario.
Overall, I like your videos, however, this seems more like a "Coming from Pixel 7 Pro to 23U long term comparison (rant edition)" video rather than your usual.
@@andyH_England I use an s9+ and the performance is the same like 5 years back as for crash and burns my phone hasn't crashed aside from freezes accuring when heavily using the phone which is expectable from a 5 year old phone but still holds up well.i didn't see any burn on the display or any other place and the battery life is only less cause first up its five years so the battery has degraded and it has 3500mah battery
Used to be an iPhone user since 3gs to iPhone10, and I switch to Vivo X50pro and now S23U! Never regret!
Bought my first ever Samsung phone S23U on March and until now, it still surprising me till now.
me too.
About photo issues, just turn of scenery optymizer in settings and set smoothing on medium in camera assistant form good lock. Now they reflect colors like they should and no over sharpening issues, simple to fix
I have seen lot of s23 ultra reviews, but seen nothing like it. It's too detailed and explained in all the aspects. Awesome review. I think this is the best one I seen as s23 ultra review.
This dude was trying soo hard to complain about s23 ultra,the (only) downside of this phone is its too much weight
Honestly idk why people complain about a company releasing their software update, if google releases is it then yeah great..just like that treat other OEMs too..they are using the base model of Android 14 but they need to make changes to their smartphone and u will get it it when they release it.. people are excited about getting Android 14 on pixels but people are excited about getting one ui 6 on their galaxy phones, it's not the same.
And not liking a particular feature which other phone has and other doesn't, really doesn't make sense, cuz that other phone don't have the features this phones cuz it's a diff phone.
Galaxy store is there for a reason, they don't need to get approved from Google before sending an update they can just send it via their galaxy store and there are some apps which u only get through galaxy store cuz it's a galaxy phone, it's just make sense.
About default apps, it's the same cuz it's a Samsung phone and the default will be Samsung apps,idk how hard is it to understand.
I 100% agree with you, your buying a Samsung phone not Google, of course there apps are going to be default to Samsung.
Also how he goes on about the OS update, he tried to install a beta of course its going to be different to pixel as that is a Google phone, ONE UI has so many more features than the stock android OS, his point is totally moot.
Also lol about the scratches on the screen, if your buying an expensive phone, you always put on a glass screen protector, I use the whitestone as mentioned in the video, they are easy to put on.
Coming from a S23 Ultra user, so of his dislikes are just stupid.
Exactly
These devices are built differently so they can't have same advantages it is just the matter of choices. I choose S23 ultra 😊
Having three different phones in the past was a nightmare, iPhone, Pixel & Samsung, had to drop Samsung since Pixel was my daily driver to concentrate on 2 different platforms since each one of them have pros and cons. I preferred my S21 Ultra design to S22 Ultra & S23 Ultra. I am surprised regarding your screen scratches because I have never had this kind of an issue with Samsung phones in the past. When it comes to Pixel phones, your channel is definitely is the exclusive source to follow.
Over the usage of S23 ultra for me. I noticed. That when it comes to photo and video mode given as default settings by manufacturer. It's too much of processing done after you shoot the video or photo. So compared to other Flagship it loses the round.. but! I found a better option in the device itself. And that it Pro photo / Video mode given in device. Using just auto mode in that settings boosts the Qualities of content. Way better than IPhone and Other Flagship. I would recommend to try this who uses S23 ultra and you wouldn't be Disappointed by this.
OMG!!! THANK YOU BRO!!! It works really better!!!
Got yourself a sub because you said the most glaring defects that other youtubers did not say
This is called a real and honest review in every detail. Love your videos ☮️
Actually, I can't understand, why you have so much scratches on screen. My s23u 6 month too, but no one scratch. With no screen protector.
Not sure why pure google people who can only see stock android in their eyes do even bother to go anywhere else. This is not for enthuciasts but for general people who like overall a good phone with no compromises and excels in all departments. These pixel followes are a pain everywhere who cry on every platform available about the UI instead they should petition Sundar Pichai to at least make a decent phone with a half decent chip and if they cant make Tensot better, they should use snapdragon or even exynos
Not a balanced review in my opinion. Which Android flagship device keeps its value even if someone indeed wants to sell his phone after six months? Is that Samsung's fault and what should they do about it? In terms of camera quality other than the noise everything is subjective but if I'm not mistaken i haven't heard a word about telescope zoom one of the phone's greatest strengths. As for the software there's great emphasis to what the stock Android does best and as for what One UI does best we have merely three seconds of "feature rich" and that's pretty much it. But many people love One UI exactly because of that "feature richness". I wouldn't expect mentioning Good Lock... And what about the S Pen? There's a mention about non symmetrical bezels but the S Pen must be the reason. No other device has an S Pen and for some people that's the reason to buy the phone. I'm quite old and my memory doesn't serve me well... did he even mention it?
Exactly..... Incomplete review.... And what about Dex, S-pen, Notes.... in 6 months he didn't manage to go through those things, maybe.
Lol a negative is that you had to change the default keyboard and browser?? You kidding? 🤣🤣
This is an extremely good review showing the shortcomings in everyday use
Great info about the S23 Ultra.
I love my S22 Ultra. I do the same by activating Airplane mode when hitting the settings button.
I need to move that. lol
I don't games or anything with my phones. I just watch RUclips, music, etc.
Coming from the iPhone 8+ & then the Note 10+.
Wow! What a difference outdoors!
Seeing an HDR Movie in sunlight! Love it!
Not a single micro scratch on it. However, I've always kept it in a case & I rotate a TPU Screen Protector every 2-3 months since it's release date.
I'm still learning everything the S22 Ultra has to offer me every day in Sept 2023. These phones can do so much & from what I've seen. Samsung is starting to retain its value better. (Amazon)
It still has all day battery life, actually mine has never gotten below 50%, etc.
I've had it out fishing all day connected to my Watch Pro 5 & a Bluetooth speaker playing music all day on the water here in SE Texas.
I almost got the 23 Ultra but it was basically the same as the 22.
It's just a great phone.
It feels tiny in my hand compared to the Plus iPhone sizes, those are wide in the hand. I'm waiting to see if the S24 Ultra is going to have a flat screen & the Snapdragon 8 gen3 here in the States.
If so, I'll update. If not?
There's no need for me to update this phone for another 2 to 4 more years.
You are basically nit picking everything in the software.
It is a personal opinion and as a reviewer you have to give a neutral review.
You better continue using Pixel Phone since you clearly have an issue with UI design difference.
i own s23 ultra but your review gives me a different perspective man it was great watching that even the best phones has so many minuscule issues that actually affects the user experience.
Did your screen also get scratches? Or do you use a screen protector?
The screen scratch is due to Victus2 protection. Victus 2 helps with screen protection during fall over the scratches. So anyone who is planning for S23 ultra should use screen protection. Without that there is gng to be hell lot of scratches
it scratches...s22 did too. Shitty victus
What a review. One thing also.. lack of focus for close up photos.
Samsung should watch this video for further improvements. Im too using s23 ultra. Really liked the video sir. Keep going
GG Victus 2 really scratches more but it's because it's more durable against drops and shatters. It's softer than GG6 so definitely, it scratches easier than previous generations
Galaxy s2 and s3 were better
From using iPhone in 7 years, I purchased s23 ultra and never looked back.
do you think its worth upgrading from ip 14 pro?
Thank you for another excellent review. I am a S23U owner and love my phone. My wife has the Pixel 7 which is as smooth as butter, and perhaps a Pixel is in my future, but having traded every two years and pricing going up, I will keep this one for 3 to 4 years.
How's the battery life and overall performance?
The Pixel lacks tons of features that this phone has. And this phone is a smooth as any on the market, if you know how to actually set it up. I have no idea how anyone can actually have this phone, and think about going to a Pixel, which is the phone I got rid of to get this phone????????? You're thinking seems to be going backwards...
@@AquaStevae Oh, I agree that my S23U is the best phone on the planet for now and the near future. Like I said, I'm planning on living with it for 3 to 4 years. Then perhaps, the Pixel will also be extraordinary and worthy of my consideration. My wife's phone is smooth as butter, but I agree with you that the S23U is no slouch in that department too.
@@prashantn687
It is great on both counts. The only thing missing is the Google Voice Typing that automatically inserts question marks among others. I wish Samsung would work on that.
Don't get me wrong, I really love and appreciate my phone. The Pixel has a different set of features that is very accommodating.
This review is really good, very different from other review videos and for that I like it. So many useful information here that's not mentioned anywhere else. Thank you sir.
Wow i discovered your channel today….and the quality of the reviews and details provided and the unbiased method used…..just thank you
You are the only youtuber that brought small buttons issue. I don't know why no one is talking about it. I hate that notification clear button too and was hoping that it will be fixed with ONE UI 6 but I guess that's never gonna change. Honestly I never understood the company that is spending too much time and money on software optimization is missing such a silly thing which is there right infront of screen. Thanks for the full review. Appreciate it.
You made no mention of Good Lock, which any Galaxy owner should know of. It offers modules to customize every aspect of your phone including notifications, adding a quick toggle floating menu that can be brought up by swiping from either edge etc. The latter will allow you to adjust the volume without having to reach for the physical button.
The cut corners make it look unique and really good. It's not as annoying as the iPhones sharp edges cause you'll feel those more often. It's like you were looking for things to complain about.
Hi. I disagree with your point that you didn't like the OneUI experience. It's best imo.
1. To drag and drop. Hold the app and then push to the upper edge and you will be directed to the home screen and put anywhere you want.
2. You can change how many quick settings you want in the notification panel. Also can use a good lock module to theme the panel and everything.
3. You don't get many suggestions if you use the keyboard less. There is a feature where you get the clipboard items on top of the keyboard. In addition, you can view multiple clipboarded items if you want.
Other than that I accept the software upgrade part and photo editing are not so good.
I agree with you except Software.
When I used pixel. I like the pixel Asthetics but didn't like the practicality of pixel like UI is not one handedly accessible.
You cannot move multiple apps from one to another Homescreen.
No Stack widgets, cannot remove the at a glance, google search widget, Cannot apply Icon pack 💀, No Advanced Powerful back swipe gestures like One Hand Operation+ , and lot more.
I agree with you but those things are to be mentioned in the Pixel review, when I talk about the things I didn't like in OneUI it doesn't mean that I love everything about Pixel software, I just mentioned the pros and cons of the software
@@IDTROk Got it 😊
Great Review brother Emad every concern for a end user is covered which shows throughout the video.
Thanks 😂
Thank you so so much...I have been reaearching the phone models that you featured for 3 months now and basically just learned more from you in 15 minutes!!!!
I have it and I love it. I took many videos with it and crazy zoom, plus on camera I use portrait and is fantastic
The bricky feeling of The s23 ultra,is what got me interested in. I love how big The screen is
I totally disagree about the software! Security updates come out super fast, even faster than the pixel phones some times... Also the customization and options the ui has on pixels is a joke compared to Samsung's one UI... I'm writing this on a pixel phone and I'm really missing one ui...
Much reliable, calm, straight to the point. This guy deserves millions of subs.
But the s23 Ultra has Gorilla Glass Victus 2 compared to Pixel 7 Pro with Gorilla Glass Victus 1 how could it have more scratches...?
I really like the part u compare the price when you buy the phone, recent price drop, and also the resale price 👏
Does the battery in ultra models tend to drain after a newer S model is released?
Watching using my S23 Ultra ❤
This is a great and much awaited video, thanks for this. But I wouldve really loved it when you have ran some benchmarks after 6 months and comparing it with new model or with rivals. This might really give an idea of why (may be one of the reasons) the drastic price drop is.
Cheers!
Premium Samsung phones came standard with a factory screen saver. Not sure if this model does but it might. If that is the case your screen may be fine you just might need a new screen saver installed. I know the factory screen savers used to be almost impossible to see with the naked eye. So you might not have any scratches in your screen.
This channel is a treasure box of honest reviews
I like the way you embrace your Egyptian accent and not even try to cover it while sounding perfectly clear 👍 also great review from end user prospective just what viewers need.
I still follow a couple other reviewers. You are the only one i regularly click on to view.
Please do s23 ultra vs ip15 promax performance test
im highly considering getting the s23 ultra, i have a s8 plus, stil working condition. im not in a rush to buy a new phone just yet, the s8 plus is working like a charm atm.
the fingerprint reader inscreen is one of my favos
Anyone… when asked directly which do you prefer Android or iOS, what immediately pops into your head?
Dude your speedily grow 😊
Every time I get tempted to leave Pixel I find videos like this that reinforce how many little things my current phone does that would be impossible on others. Just interested in what your view would be on the Nothing phone 2, something that again looks tempting
Why do you want to leave Pixel?
@@kirillt6422 I don't really, but the Nothing phone 2 flat display with equal bezel looks too good to ignore. Then I remember call screening, voice typing and all other Google smarts that I use without even noticing and realise that the grass is not greener😄. It is just gear envy/ lust...I am a pixel boy though
Nah not very much diffence in phone 2 , maybe wait for phone 3
This year alone I've had the S23U Pixel 7 Pro and OP11. I decided to give the NP2 a go. Nothing OS is phenomenal and extremely well optimised HOWEVER the camera is very erratic and the speakers are average. Stick with the Pixel or go with the OP11 as both are great devices and relatively bloat free. The S23U has so many duplicate apps and personally I'm not too keen on OneUI but that is subjective. The S23U is an ergonomic nightmare too.
for me the 23U is the best , i love the Spen feature that it has that just kills the competition even if i dont use it all the time it comes in handy when i need it .. every camera on flagship phones are pretty much the same so no complaint there.. its a beast
Finallt someone talked about banding. I was suffering a lot especially at night and night mode turned on.
One Ui experience is still far superior to the Pixel experience. Pixel ui is for nerds only for who have a weird hard on for stock design. One ui has more features and looks more pleasing to eye.
And the kid colour design icons on one ui😂
And the messy inconsistent transparent background here and no transparency there. Mess of colour contradicting each other's under the transparency background
One ui is Garbage
@fantasytky28 goodlock allows all that to be customized. All those issues you have can be turned off or changed if you don't like it. Skill issue it seems
nice video! i think s23u is the best! love ur vids! have been subbed since 1k
I like this guys battery review. Idk how other youtubere get 2 days of battery. I have the same phone and get about the same screen on time.
Well done thank you for your review.
100% disagree about the screen protector. I've had the base s23 since launch day and I don't have 1 micro scratch.
You complain about not having "what's playing" feature and then you complain about your phones listening to you all the time... 🤔 And about the size of the icons you can always change them completely with goodlock
Just got my s23 ultra yesterday and I'm loving it!!
What is better to get better S23 Ultra or Pixel 8 Pro? Right now there is discount in Amazon, and price is almost the same.
Man you're awesome, on point and honest. I just hope you try Xperia phones too in the near future... Cheers
Best review I’ve seen for Samsung!!! Wish more reviewers would spend more time on cell signal and reception. Not everybody live in or near a city. When I was in Caribbean a hurricane damaged a cell tower. iPhone wouldn’t work at all but somehow Samsung lowered it cell reception to receive 3g and was crucial to allow me receive news and internet data.
It is obvious that whatever phone you are more used to is the one you would prefer. I have mostly used Samsung Galaxy phones in the past and about 6 months ago changed to the Google Pixel, after watching many reviews. I HATE the Pixel with a passion. I have never wanted to change a phone so quickly in my life. If not for the price I paid for it I would have changed straight back. My son is gifting me another Galaxy for Xmas. I can't wait.
so far its my favorite phone. had it for about a week or so now. last phone was a note 9
Another great review. Please keep up the honest no nonsense reviews. Great stuff. I too own S23U and P7P and agree with your comments.
Very honest review, as a s23u user for 2 months, 90% mentioned was all true and only people actually used about to point it out..subscribed
Perfect video. Nothing is missing . Thanx
This was an amazingly well structured review. Really liked hearing what annoyed you about it compared to the pixel. I might get one soon
Good content. When you put a case on, there's no problems for feeling or comfort. No wobbling. Pixel 7pro isn't close to s23 ultra.
You complain too much and you seem to really prefer the pixel. While OneUI has too many features, most are so useful that once you get used to them you'll have a hard time using the barebones pixel UI, where you have to download an extra app to obtain certain features. Plus the s23's hardware and battery life are far superior to the pixel 7 pro's
I really liked your review. It's concise and just your opinions and experiences
The best phone ive ever owned my only gripes with my s23 ultra is that they removed micro sd card I hate that and also losing tiny features with updates that android 10 and early kernel 13 had and a few other things otherwise incredible phone
What tiny features did you lose?
*BRO I LOVE BOX DEGIN WHY YOU DON'T LIKE*
So detailed review. Good job man 👏👏👏
I meant to add in my last comment that you are the first reviewer I've seen to call out the ridiculously small "Clear" button on the S23U notification shade. I'm not blind but I still miss hitting it sometimes because it is way too small. There is no need to have it so small on a giant screen.
This youtuber took like the only things that oneui cant do and was annoyed. Very quiet about spen features or oneui features overall.
Most of these problems aren't even problems between the s23 and pixel. Other from first world issues great vid
Did you notice the 100° temperature on the weather widget? 🤪
I hope u can make video about rattling sound on camera of s23ultra...I think most of s23ultra owner is worrying about that rattling sound
One of my favorite tech RUclipsr now.
i agree, resell value is #1 issue.
2nd duplicate app also is insane.
UAE based tech youtuber ?! Imma subscribe
I'm a big guy, and so I have big hands, and so I appreciate the extra large, boxy feel of the S23 Ultra. It feels substantial in my big hands. 😃
Really good and honest review!
The phone costing less is good for everyone, that's not a negative. We don't need another Apple.
It's good thing if you are a new buyer
Otherwise
You literally got scammed
By loosing over 40% of it's value
There is no company like Apple 😂
@@wonderofu5490 that's why I'm not a day one buyer.
Apple is better than samsuck
I wish they brought back the Bixby button and allow us to remap it. It was really useful for me 😢
You can use the power button by double tapping or long pressing. It's configurable
@@marasion0862 I still prefer the Bixby button. I can just do single pressing to turn on/off DND, double pressing to on/off immersive mode, and long pressing for other thing. I think it's more efficient than using the power button.
Love your intro music.
6 to 8 months after the Launch
Best time to buy any android phone
I did order it last week, some good deals on. Getting bored with iPhones especially the same phone every single year with different name
Your videos definitely keeps up with the name of your channel
I was planning to buy s24 and upgrading from iphone 14pm. I was worried about the price drop and now it is even clear. Resale value of Samsung really hurts. Hello from Sharjah :D
Hello! I’m considering switching from iPhone to Android for the first time in my life. What phone should I get? Am I gonna miss MagSafe and the other iPhone exclusive features that I use a lot? Thanks!
Hey mate
Get a S23 Ultra it's a beast, also get a glass screen protector, the whitestone one he mentioned I have on mine, they are the best and easy to install.
Performance, battery life and camera are amazing!
Some of his dislikes are stupid, as you are buying a Samsung phone not a Google hence why Samsung apps are default.
Also he goes on about the updates, ofcourse they are going to be delayed on the S23, as ONE UI, has so many more features than the pixel.
The S23 Ultra is the best Android phone at the moment but this is just my opinion.
It will be different from your iPhone as they are so many more customisations compared to a row of icons on the iPhone.
@@downundajoe thanks! What about the standard S23? I don’t like big phones. That’s why I have the standard iPhone 14 Pro (6,1”).
@@Ale7ityou can get flat s23 which has small-normal dimensions.
@@downundajoeI'm a pixel 7 pro user and I would to switch to samsung only for a colder cpu and a better multiapps, and maybe for a definitely better customization despite the fact that I like Google 's style and a definitely better selfie camera. But looking at this video I confirm that I just can't like the one graphic and practical side; In addition, the features of pixels such as now playing, the transcription of Google Assistant and multitasking. They definitely are a game changer for me. The bloatware problem can be solved and that is not the main problem. If it weren't for this I would already have S23U for sure.
@@x7nick7x48 I have the s23. It's a beast in every aspect. The bloat doesn't really affect the speed but it kind of bothers me so I removed via ADB.