How to Cut Holes with WITHOUT BOOLEAN | Blender Hard Surface Modeling Tutorial (Arijan)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 22 дек 2024

Комментарии • 120

  • @erishkigal1
    @erishkigal1 2 года назад +128

    buy the book, it's fantastic, put on your shirt (or take it off), start modelling :D

    • @ArijanRace
      @ArijanRace  2 года назад +21

      It means a lot my friend, thank you for the comment 🙏

    • @keeleycarrigan
      @keeleycarrigan 11 месяцев назад +5

      lol

  • @FictitiousCtrlGames
    @FictitiousCtrlGames 4 месяца назад +30

    Theres also a 'To Sphere' option. Select the vertices that you want to become circular. Then, on the top left, click 'mesh - Transform - To Sphere'.
    Then you can move your mouse left or right to control how circular you want it to be.
    Boom! You're done.
    I should have wrote a book.

  • @sassuskrassus3166
    @sassuskrassus3166 5 месяцев назад +27

    Ctrl+Alt+S on an edge loop to create a circle

    • @lusifer2192
      @lusifer2192 2 месяца назад +3

      Better tutorial than this whole video ❤

    • @guiltyflicks
      @guiltyflicks Месяц назад

      i was so confused why he wasnt talking about an inbuilt addon looptools made for this very task

  • @Mehdeal
    @Mehdeal 10 месяцев назад +7

    you can also use the "looptools" tool to make a circle from a square

  • @KanzakiZD
    @KanzakiZD 2 года назад +60

    you can use looptools to circulate vertices on the lowpoly mesh. enable it on the addons on preferences.

    • @Soulsphere001
      @Soulsphere001 Год назад +4

      LoopTools is not quite as accurate, unfortunately, but it is still an option if time is of the essence and the model does not have to be perfect.

    • @interpretedbags
      @interpretedbags 11 месяцев назад

      I'm not sure if it's just me, but looptools feels worse in 2.8+@@Soulsphere001

    • @DarkShroom
      @DarkShroom 11 месяцев назад

      huh i never noticed any accuracy problems, i mean have you set enough geometry? my circles are circles@@Soulsphere001 EDIT: okay if you want a circle that follows the curve, the edge loops trick we use though i see this as "acurate" as that's how something gets drilled, it was accurate for what i was doing

    • @Ov3rTheTop
      @Ov3rTheTop 11 месяцев назад +3

      Yeah only issue with looptools on this curved surface is that it flattens the verticies in Z so you lose the correct contouring. You could project the verts after using looptools tho which would work quite well now that I think about it.

    • @xloltimex38
      @xloltimex38 10 месяцев назад +18

      ​​@@Ov3rTheTop there is a checkerbox you need to deselect. If you deselect "Flatten" in the looptools circle dropdown menu it keeps the original shape.

  • @legionclown2656
    @legionclown2656 Год назад +6

    I have watched you for a bit and had bought your book without even knowing it was made by you! The book was awesome and extremely helpful.

  • @ataurrehman5689
    @ataurrehman5689 11 месяцев назад +18

    You could use the Snap to Vertex option to align vertices to those of circle. That's way easier and more accurate.

    • @samimetahri7277
      @samimetahri7277 7 месяцев назад

      It won't work properly ... Shading problems will apear

    • @dustinrolstad752
      @dustinrolstad752 6 месяцев назад

      You could, but it wouldn't conform to the contours of the original mesh. Not unless you manually placed each of the vertices alaong the z-axis.

  • @TheFLYHiGHx
    @TheFLYHiGHx Год назад +2

    i found you 2 days ago.. your videos are king. i learned very much

  • @Klarified01
    @Klarified01 11 месяцев назад +2

    You are so fast with it wow. I'm impressed. Good video as well!

  • @Greco1114
    @Greco1114 11 месяцев назад +8

    Correct me if I'm wrong, but I think the geometry just looks smooth because there are no reflections shown in the surface, but in the render, the normals will create horrible reflections. Am I correct or am I something I'm missing here?

    • @batman3698
      @batman3698 11 месяцев назад +1

      You are correct, making a hole like this will cause pinching.
      There are a few options to make good holes
      1. is to first apply the subsurf before making the hole
      or 2. make a hidden shape correction mesh without the hole, which you use as a shrinkwrap target. You can use a vertex group to control the shrinkwrap modifiers influence on the visible mesh.

    • @DarkShroom
      @DarkShroom 11 месяцев назад

      at 4:40 he has good edge loops, can't fault those.... maybe you mean where the tutorial finishes@@batman3698

    • @Greco1114
      @Greco1114 11 месяцев назад

      @@batman3698 Do you have any tutorials with the second method? Because this is where I'm getting troubled all the time. My model looks smooth when I do the basic shape, but after the details are added like holes, cuts, etc, there is a lot of distrorsion and pinching. I've noticed that 3DS Max has something normal smoothing maps that fixes this problem but the only relevan I manged to find in Blender the the weighted normals modifier which sometimes fixes things but doesn't do perfect job.
      PS: I am referring to modelling without subdivision, like models for video games.

    • @batman3698
      @batman3698 11 месяцев назад

      @@Greco1114 I dont have a tutorial on hand. But I can break it down. Method 2 is basically the non destructive version of method 1.
      In method one you apply the subsurf, and make the hole after. that way you have the full geometry there for when you make your hole. But the drawback is that its a destructive operation, and it takes alot of clean-up with the big number of loops.
      Method 2 is the non destructive approach.
      What you do is you copy your subsurfed mesh without the hole into a hidden collection. You can call it something like "guide mesh"
      On the visible original copy of the mesh you then add the hole. Add a shrinkwrap modifier *after* the subsurf modifier, targetting the guide mesh in the hidden collection.
      This way it will snap all the extra vertexes which are added by the subsurf modifier to the hidden mesh.
      Assign a vertex group to the shrinkwrap modifier where you set the weight to 1 in the areas where you want the mesh to follow the original shape, and 0 where you want the mesh to be independent. For example if you make a tube into or out of the hole, you would make the tube have a vertex group weight of 0.
      I usually use this for automotive 3d modelling, in order to get consistent reflections over different panels.
      I hope the explanation is good enough!

  • @samresto4782
    @samresto4782 5 месяцев назад +3

    why not just alt+shift+s to warp the points into a circle?

  • @Cookie131_
    @Cookie131_ 2 года назад +4

    Awesome video as always! Cant wait for your next video on the M1 Abrams!

  • @ArijanRace
    @ArijanRace  10 месяцев назад

    If you liked this video and want to learn more about the many modeling tools and techniques in Blender, check out my Blender eBook:
    shorturl.at/gzEW1

  • @Youshisu
    @Youshisu 11 месяцев назад

    I started modeling week ago and you make very useful guides :D

  • @artemaung5274
    @artemaung5274 11 месяцев назад +1

    I remember first time I tried to do something like this I did the same thing - inset and then I asked chatGPT to make python script to arrage vertices in a circle. It took couple of tries to describe precisely what I want but it was still faster than manually arranging vertices. And if you had more vertices to arrange or more holes to make in one go - it'll increase productivity even more so.

    • @DarkShroom
      @DarkShroom 11 месяцев назад +2

      what is wrong with add->mesh->circle? you can set the verts there
      i can write all the python code, it doesn't increase productivity if you spend more time faffing with the code for something you can press a button for

    • @shovel_salesman
      @shovel_salesman 11 месяцев назад

      packing that into an add-on seems like way more trouble than its worth

  • @tcapozzoli
    @tcapozzoli Год назад +7

    Your videos are
    Awesome man. Really helpful for a noob like me! One question though, for getting started in Hard Surface would you suggest using the Bool Tool, etc and learning that way first before doing the more advanced stuff like this? Or, better yet just grab Box Cutter and call it a day since some of this advanced stuff gets over my head (for now). Thanks again!

  • @gordonbrinkmann
    @gordonbrinkmann 4 месяца назад +1

    How is an actual hole in a mesh non-destructive compared to a hole made with a Boolean modifier? And you should take a look at Loop Tools to make it more efficient...

    • @AM-yk5yd
      @AM-yk5yd 2 месяца назад

      It's not. It's as destructive as you can get. At most you can assign vertices to vertex group "I cut there" to reselect them quickly and or maybe copy them into other model

  • @NotEvenARealAnimation
    @NotEvenARealAnimation 11 месяцев назад +1

    Really good tutorial, you just taught me something new, thanks alot!

  • @TheBallaGames
    @TheBallaGames 8 месяцев назад

    How you move the vertices locked like that?

  • @photonstudio7844
    @photonstudio7844 6 месяцев назад

    O cara vai direto ao ponto, fala apenas o necessário, não enche linguiça com firulas, resolve as dúvidas.

  • @lachainedespotes2503
    @lachainedespotes2503 3 месяца назад

    Insane man.

  • @stoopidbastid6420
    @stoopidbastid6420 4 месяца назад

    shift control x. spacebar to circle, w/x to adjust verts. easy

  • @dongiovanni1993
    @dongiovanni1993 10 месяцев назад

    Maybe such things as loop tools/circle, snap to vertices, knife project will help.

  • @wespenwald1297
    @wespenwald1297 2 года назад +2

    Best of luck with your book! :)

  • @MrHadane
    @MrHadane 4 месяца назад +1

    Isn't it just faster and easier to just use loop tools addon and convert selected vertices to circle?..

  • @No1001-w8m
    @No1001-w8m 10 месяцев назад

    How do you join 2 objects together, you didn't explain?

  • @rosie...3574
    @rosie...3574 5 месяцев назад +1

    o baby its so goood

  • @mau_1135
    @mau_1135 2 года назад +1

    I love your stuff keep it up!

  • @SZMIDEL
    @SZMIDEL 11 месяцев назад

    nice one...last trick was mega helpful!

  • @TertiaryChrome
    @TertiaryChrome 2 года назад

    Couldn't it be done through Knife Project as well?

  • @wMuki
    @wMuki 3 месяца назад

    its 10/10 tuto, i hate boolean af and it doing his job with better topology

  • @Doomer__
    @Doomer__ 4 месяца назад

    You can use "knife project" also

  • @TheAnimeist
    @TheAnimeist 11 месяцев назад

    Top notch!

  • @Ceresdesign
    @Ceresdesign 8 месяцев назад

    What is the positive point to work without boolean ?

    • @burn435353
      @burn435353 4 месяца назад

      Booleans can be computationally intesive, depending on their complexity

  • @LikelyLink
    @LikelyLink 8 месяцев назад

    Thanks this was super helpfull

  • @aosh-t8s
    @aosh-t8s 9 месяцев назад

    Thanks!!!!你帮了我大忙了!

  • @SKKEE
    @SKKEE Год назад

    Good to see you wearing a shirt.

  • @thomas7726
    @thomas7726 7 месяцев назад

    Sorry to ask, I'm a beginner, but in other videos I've heard a lot about avoiding using booleans. Why?

    • @arvin24ph
      @arvin24ph 6 месяцев назад +1

      It's a messy render not smooth.

    • @ConcavePgons
      @ConcavePgons 4 месяца назад

      Topology is not the best with booleans.

  • @omermagen824
    @omermagen824 2 года назад +2

    bruh i forgot i turned up the volume then an ad almost gave me a heart attack xD

  • @nothing6909
    @nothing6909 2 года назад +1

    Nice video! You look a lot like Scream, a former cs:go player hahaha

  • @Semi-Cyclops
    @Semi-Cyclops 10 месяцев назад

    me watching the tutorial and saying, oh i know this, and then he get control+shift+rightclick and my mind blows, how was i living without this all this time

  • @AlienFromFlorida
    @AlienFromFlorida Год назад +3

    Отлично!

  • @moritzpollich5165
    @moritzpollich5165 2 месяца назад

    Is there a reason why I shouldnt use boolean?

    • @AM-yk5yd
      @AM-yk5yd 2 месяца назад

      No. Just dont assume that blender is cad. Eg cutting 8 vert cube with cylinder is bad idea. But if you prepare area by having enough vertices its fine. Josh Gambrel said he uses bool in 90% of his models and reddit hivemind think his content is good

  • @hexicore789
    @hexicore789 10 месяцев назад

    But what about looptools

  • @CGSTUDENT15
    @CGSTUDENT15 10 месяцев назад

    At 3 mint u can just join the circle with that mesh then fill faces with f

  • @r0naldhuber578
    @r0naldhuber578 10 дней назад

    It would seem to me that "knifeproject" would be easier than the shrinkwrap method. No filling with face. No creating shrinkwrap. No applying shrinkwrap. No joining objects.

  • @bencebenedek2610
    @bencebenedek2610 5 часов назад

    It's a shame looptools itself doesn't have some feature for following surfaces. It would be very useful in this situation.

  • @만든다비디오
    @만든다비디오 Год назад +2

    nice video but please you gotta increase the volume man

  • @Neoprenesiren
    @Neoprenesiren Месяц назад

    People glazing the edge loop tools have never used them before lol. Goddamn things work like one out of four times.

  • @SamandarSaidkhujaev
    @SamandarSaidkhujaev Год назад

    yo bro I don't know even how to support you, thank u very much

  • @saintelmo5590
    @saintelmo5590 Год назад +1

    Good video presentation, but audio is disastrously weak. Thankfully, I recorded this with subtitles on.

  • @maciejryko9165
    @maciejryko9165 2 года назад

  • @tallyman138
    @tallyman138 2 года назад +1

    Why don't you simply use the loop-tools....?

    • @ArijanRace
      @ArijanRace  2 года назад

      The loop tools 'circle' function creates a flat circle, which is not good for a curved surface.
      I have used loop tools in the previous tutorial mention in this video, they are good for that.

    • @tallyman138
      @tallyman138 2 года назад +3

      @@ArijanRace The loop tool creates only a flat circle if 'flatten' is checked. Otherwise the circle follows the shape. Just tried it out...

  • @UlfricStromcloak
    @UlfricStromcloak 11 месяцев назад

    Why not use loop tools? You could have easly made that edge loop into circle.

  • @sleepingbag2424
    @sleepingbag2424 11 месяцев назад

    hey, pretty late comment but you couldve just used the snap function and set it to snap to vertices. nice vid tho

  • @sebastianosewolf2367
    @sebastianosewolf2367 Год назад

    tbh its faster and easier to use loop tools
    mark the Vertices, right klick loop tools circle, mark the faces and extrude

    • @ArijanRace
      @ArijanRace  Год назад +4

      Using the circle tool will create a flat circle, not curved as it should be on a cylinder in this case. In most other cases however, that would work

    • @DarkShroom
      @DarkShroom 11 месяцев назад

      ah flat vs curved circle i got ya... that said most of the time something like this has a hole in it, it's done with a drill so most real world shapes prob have a flat circle@@ArijanRace

    • @xloltimex38
      @xloltimex38 10 месяцев назад

      ​​@@ArijanRaceThey propably updated it since last year. There is a checkerbox in looptools. If you deselect "Flatten" it keeps the shape

  • @battou2501
    @battou2501 11 месяцев назад

    right

  • @sebastianosewolf2367
    @sebastianosewolf2367 Год назад +1

    nice video, but you could be a bit louder if possible

  • @gswhitedevil6631
    @gswhitedevil6631 11 месяцев назад +1

    more easy way is Shift + alt + s

  • @facundomunch371
    @facundomunch371 3 месяца назад

    alguien que traduzca en español porfavor 🙏

  • @edypixel
    @edypixel 8 месяцев назад

    The cool thing about beginner modeling is that you start with booleans, then you learn that shit, and in the end you learn that modeling has to be uniform for almost all scenarios, then you choose what is easiest and generates more work, or go for the uniform path like this video ehehehehhehehehehehe........
    or buy a course from the Booleans masters and dream that it's right ehehehhehehe... but you can't open the UV ok...

  • @chrishubka7486
    @chrishubka7486 2 года назад +4

    Why is your shirt onnnn? 😂

    • @ArijanRace
      @ArijanRace  2 года назад +1

      At least it's unbuttoned

  • @jinglebell9107
    @jinglebell9107 11 месяцев назад

    Wow, seems not that difficult. I work with cinema 4d and it work almost the same manner. I guess, I will try blender. The question is the rendering.

  • @notaday2033
    @notaday2033 11 месяцев назад

    Or just Alt shift S

  • @unp2louad
    @unp2louad Год назад

    bro.. u are epic! thx for vid

  • @Sykogene
    @Sykogene 2 месяца назад

    pain in the hole

  • @ofecer007
    @ofecer007 11 месяцев назад

    Метод с шринкврапом и вертекс группами был поприкольней =) хотя в данном случае он наверное не сработает.

  • @mhaythamabdel5929
    @mhaythamabdel5929 6 месяцев назад

    👍

  • @goncalobarreto7537
    @goncalobarreto7537 Год назад

    Falas demasiado rápido filho, fiquei perdido no primeiro vértice

  • @DIABULUSKIRA
    @DIABULUSKIRA 7 месяцев назад

    Aryan have great tutorials but he sounds like he is going to beat the 💩 out of you if you don't sit and listen carefully what he is talking about 😅😂

  • @platinums99
    @platinums99 10 месяцев назад

    your audio is low

  • @CamioFox
    @CamioFox 11 месяцев назад

    Пиздец, 10 минут чувак повторяет 30 раз одно и тоже, а после берёт и руками делает то, что делает булева операция в автоматическим режиме.

  • @yuvarajgs2168
    @yuvarajgs2168 11 месяцев назад

    😐

  • @pondoitzme
    @pondoitzme 6 месяцев назад

    "yeah that's a pretty good hole"

  • @CihanTezcanakcentboracay
    @CihanTezcanakcentboracay 11 месяцев назад

    this is absolutely fake, cuz the boolean is quite different you showed

    • @ArijanRace
      @ArijanRace  11 месяцев назад +3

      Yeah you're right, I'm gonna delete my channel now

  • @sercancolak6117
    @sercancolak6117 10 месяцев назад

    no thanks

  • @IveNeverStoodUp
    @IveNeverStoodUp 4 месяца назад

    really? 9 fucking minutes long?