Gothic Remake vs Original Early Graphics Comparison
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024
- Gothic Remake vs Original Early Graphics Comparison
Buy Gothic Remake here: amzn.to/3WOpPa0
Many thanks to @vxd555 for help with finding all the spots!
Source video:
Gothic 1 Remake - THQ Nordic Showcase 2024 Trailer | PS5 Games
• Gothic 1 Remake - THQ ...
🌟 Got an idea for my next graphics comparison? I’d love to hear your suggestions! Drop your ideas in the comments, and I’ll see what I can do 😉.
Your likes, shares, and channel support mean the world to me and help make this channel awesome! 🙌
🎉 Support me on Patreon: / cycu1
🎮 Join the RUclips channel: / @cycu1
🛒 Use my affiliate links to buy games and other stuff on Amazon: amzn.to/3LJq6Vk
Thanks for being amazing and helping this community grow! 🚀
Original was captured on following rig:
-Gigabyte RTX 4080 Eagle OC 16GB amzn.to/3pYRibp
-Gigabyte Z790 Aorus Elite AX amzn.to/3rD1sit
-Gigabyte UD1300GM PG5 amzn.to/43toTIc
-Intel i7 13700K amzn.to/3rAzGD5
-Corsair Vengeance DDR5 32GB amzn.to/43x9pmr
-Samsung 980 Pro SSD 2TB / 1TB / 500GB amzn.to/44WEl0F
-Barracuda 4TB HDD amzn.to/3DmANZD
-Windows 11 amzn.to/3PYzmIy
-Be quiet! Silent Loop 2 360mm amzn.to/3KawpRl
-Be quiet! Pure Base 600 BGW20 amzn.to/44y2lam
Kanał GRANALIZA po polsku:
/ @granaliza
Cycu1 Bilibili official Channel: space.bilibili...
Consider supporting my channel for cool bonuses:
/ @cycu1
Looking good quality gameplay for your own videos?
Consider subscribing my other channels to be up to date!
Cycu1 Xbox Archive / @cycu1xboxarchive130
Cycu1 PlayStation Archive / @cycu1playstationarchi...
Cycu1 Nintendo Archive / @cycu1nintendoarchive454
Looking for gift cards?
PSN: amzn.to/3eFkAjM
Xbox: amzn.to/3gzvsl8
Nintendo eShop: amzn.to/2TRMbqf
Looking for RTX Graphics Cards? Check on Amazon: amzn.to/3dzcGYZ
Follow me on Twitter: / cyckiewicz
Find me on Facebook: / cycu1yt
Cycu1's friends:
Jabcook:
/ jabcook
Easy Unboxing:
/ @easyunboxing
Quick Expert Reviews
/ @quickexpertreviews
FA Gamez:
/ mrxboxgamer007
#Gothic #GothicRemake #RTX4080 #PS5 #Xbox 3XboxSeriesX #XboxSeriesS
Buy Gothic Remake here: amzn.to/3WOpPa0
🌟 Got an idea for my next graphics comparison? I’d love to hear your suggestions! Drop your ideas in the comments, and I’ll see what I can do 😉.
Your likes, shares, and channel support mean the world to me and help make this channel awesome! 🙌
🎉 Support me on Patreon: / cycu1
🎮 Join the RUclips channel: / @cycu1
🛒 Use my affiliate links to buy games and other stuff on Amazon: amzn.to/3LJq6Vk
Thanks for being amazing and helping this community grow! 🚀
8:03 - THIS IS GOBLIN not ORC...... how did u made that mistake idk.
I wish they have recreated those red rooftiles from 03:35 they are giving this unique gothic vibe
Yes indeed... I was thinking the same....
Its remarkable how true to size the old camp is compared with the original it looks size wise the same thats good !
Just noticed a small error: 06:01 is most likely the view from behind Asghan in the bottom area of the old mine (area before the crawlers), not the entrance. Also 08:01 shows a goblin, not an Orc
And at 7:30 is not the same place. Original where the troll and snappers, quest with Gorn.
Remake: quest with Lester, with harpys around.
@@janoskasza3091 the original are the cloister ruins where you transform into a meatbug to get through the gate.
We see the transformation scene in the remake trailer and we also see the inside of that place through the gate at that time, it's the same place(they changed it to look more like the cloister from gothic 2).
@@TheTaxxor that are was closed by orc wall in Gorhic 2.
@@janoskasza3091 I mean the one in khorinis, they made the one in gothic remake to have a similar structure
I’m very impressed with how perfectly you were able to line up some of the shots. Good job Cycu and good job Alkimia!
Extremely impressive remake, Alkimia is doing stellar job.
Naive
imagine saying that just now lol have you preordered the game already?
i mean, at the very least environments and visuals do it justice. i could recognise every single area and they have shown a lot of them. character designs are a bit of a mixed bag, but has a lot of winners. im more worried about it being unreal engine (and hence optimisation issues and notorious stuttering), and whether the new additions will fit the game.
@@skadess2107 I am judging what I can see. Obviously judging of the game itself will come when I play it.
@@skadess2107 u cant preorder the game yet, only add to wishlist
Bardzo fajny materiał,ale jeden błąd popełniłeś. 8:01 to nie jest Ork tylko goblin.
Yes. I wanted to point out same. They significantly changed these creatures.
Dzięki boru, bo to jest dosłownie jedyna rzecz, do której mogłabym się przyczepić. Orki były tak charakterystyczne i tak dobrze zrobione w oryginale, rozczarowała mnie ta goblinia morda.
@@KayleeDavisBlueBox Dlatego dodałem ten komentarz bo ktoś mógłby pomyśleć,że to Ork 🙂 Jedna tylko prośba nie pisz Orki tylko Orkowie,Orki są w oceanach 😉
@@MRX98809 Orki w oceanach, mansplainerzy w internecie. Prośba odrzucona :) Smacznej kawusi życzę
@@KayleeDavisBlueBox лицо тех орков которых они сделали, разочаровывают ещё больше 😀
I pray that no quest marks and horrible UI will be here like in other modern games
Great UI takes A LOT of focus. I think most gaming companies overlook it and that's why it undermines their project.
@@SavingPrivateBob The reason modern day UI's are so handholdy is because it's proven to help reign in new players and retain returning players better than a minimal UI where you have to figure everything out. Doesn't matter if you hate it, as long as it works, companies will do it.
There is nothing wrong with quest marks.
@@Leonion6 I like a low-key journal much better. Really immerses you into the game and world
@@Leonion6 Except everything
Gothic is a classic that I love. The remake doesn't look bad, I hope it will be great. The atmosphere is there. Greetings from Poland! 🇵🇱
Great job!
Hope they use your music along with their expanded tracks
Love Your music Kai! One of my reasons to play this Remake is that we will hear Your work again Maestro!:)
Wohoho maestro himself!
Yeah, especially when dude compared an orc with a gobbo 😂
Приятно, что многим нравится музыка Кая
Jedna pomylka z goblinem i orkiem poza tym zajebiscie to zrobiles, juz nie moge sie doczykac kiedy w koncu bede mogl zagrac. Pozdrowienia dla wszystkich fanow Gothica.
This is not the Intro in the beginning. Just almost the same frames. This is not how the Intro will look like in the game.
Also the intro of the original was an in-engine-rendered cinematic that was heavily polished, not a direct in-game-cutscene like in the Remake trailer, so it's an unfair comparison.
The actual Remake intro will surely be much better.
Good to know. Thank you for clarification.
Any chance for 2024 release?
8:02: This is not correct. Those are the new goblins, not orcs. And in the scene before, we had orc elites guarding the Temple of the Sleeper.
It's gonna feel so trippy being back there with these grafix
I dont know how good it is regarding gameplay aspect of the game , BUT HOLY SHIT they NAILED visual and artistic style of ur belowed good old old Gothic !!!
Main characters look great! Environment also beautiful, but not sure about goblins and orcs(i know here a messed up footage at the 8:01. But I'm not about that. Not horrible, but idk).
I'm feel calm now, it's not weird as a "Playble Teaser" and already enough for me to "pass". Maybe in actual gameplay by myself - it's gonna be even better.
For me the Main character is not the same, doesnt have the same vibe, just feels different. Diego and Xardas is good.
8:01 is wrong. There is a orc compared to a goblin
@@Eliebl Thanks, but i know that and mention it above. i'm remember what original goblin's looks like and am only talking about original vs the version on the right picture at the 8:01 (not the left one)
great comparison
I don't understand why for example the front gate of the castle is stripped of it's colorful banners and the clear ground looks like someone dragged a broken caravan over it.
because the devs decided a lazy slap on fix using a gray filter is better than redoing the graphics of the game (personally thay should have just gotten modders from gothic that make textures do them since they somewhat know what they do. or atleast be close in color as the original, yet since they try to mix muddy brown washed out colours with intense brightness making everything look horrible instead of as should be its like mixing the atmosphere of multiple games into one instead of focusing on the game their remaking.
Świetna Robota! A w oki aż łezka się kręci gdy widzi się jak wiernie odwzorowali Górniczą dolinę 🥹 akurat przechodzę wszystkie części plus Gothica dodatki i różnorakie modyfikacje fanowskie na swoim kanale w firmie Streamów na żywo i już doczekać się nie mogę tego Remake 🍻
thanks for comparison
Hmmm... the red roofs have disappeared somewhere in the old camp. But that is their main color, their distinguishing feature. The swamp dwellers were perceived as green, the new camp as blue, and the old one as red.
P.S. The sky also became completely different, not so atmospheric.
i also really dislike the slap on job of just adding a filter instead of changing the colour pallete. due to filters fibrant colour become muddy and gray unlike in the original. the new camp is way to orange and isnt its iconic blue. the old camp is way to blue and muddy. the swamp camp is missing its ore lamps. the animals fail completely trying to look recogniseable. the swamp camp people are missing their tatoos and everyone has the smae bodybuild making gorn look too skinny. many errors though atleast it is better than the playbale teaser in every way. i do not like that they made the scavanger into another dinosaur when there are already 4 present.
I think it looks great, but I would like if the faces wouldnt look so polished. the original looks more rough and you easily believe that a lot of the characters are criminals or had some hardships behind them. 8:24
A criminal is not someone who looks like a criminal, but someone who commits crimes. Literally. do not judge a book strictly by its cover, the content may be completely different. The same applies to people. Only a fool puts labels on everyone, guided in his judgments by the appearance of a person.
@@mr_darian Go to prison and repeat that sentence with a straight face
@mr_darian if you're not able to analyse someone's face and stereotype dangerous people from normal people you either grew up privileged or autistic
@@pepehands5510 Dude, your president, your government, the mayor of your city, the chief of your local police are pretty much more criminals than those in prisons. They're just robbing YOU and YOUR KIND legally. They have adjusted the legislative system to suit themselves. Are you familiar with the term Lobbying? This is legalized bribery. In China, the death penalty is imposed for this. You live as if nothing is happening. Because you don't see crimes. And they are being committed.
@@pepehands5510 Dude, your president, your government, the mayor of your city, the chief of your local police are pretty much more criminals than those in prisons. They're just robbing YOU and YOUR KIND legally. They have adjusted the legislative system to suit themselves. Are you familiar with the term Lobbying? This is legalized bribery. In China, the death penalty is imposed for this. You live as if nothing is happening. Because you don't see crimes. And they are being committed.
7:53 How did the tribal orcs of Khorinis create such armor?
Exactly my question
They should have literally a various armor sets made from random metal scrap materials in combination with hand-crafted leather parts
@@shotkikk_priv yes since that would fit them for being less evolved than humans.
It is probably a special Orc type, maybe a sort of mini boss or templar orc? Also if the orc were able to build the sleeper temple it couldnt be too hard to have some sort armor like that for a few special orcs. But I agree if you will find many orcs like this it wouldnt make sense
@@johannesschmitz6370 a mini boss battle would be nice. maybe you can fight him for extra respect to enter areas you would get attacked for.
Why is original so perfect? I am looking it now ,this remake cannot be better ,its really looking perfect and imersive,but why nothing can impersonate that dark atmosphere,and colors from the original i really cant tell 🤔?
I'm looking forward!!! As a gothic fan from the first part! I played through everything from the first to the third with the expansion... I don't classify Arcani as Gothic. I'm waiting and waiting and I can't wait!!! I hope they don't ruin it. Even if I had to wait two more years, it would be worth it :) It's better that they release a proper game than a dud caused by player pressure :)
8:05 you compared old Orc with new Goblin. Should've been an old Gobbo instead.
Awesome job capturing all those original perspectives for comparison!
I haven't been this excited about a game in two decades. SHIIITTTTT!!! I want to play this already xDDDD
Hey. Why did you turn off the LODs and effects in some shots? The swamp camp wasnt lit at night in your shots and there were no trees visibile around the old camp either. 😢
It looks incredible, i only found out today that they are still working on the remake, and I'm very hyped to see more! 😁
Great vid from you anyway, i like the direction your channel is going. Pozdro! 👏
best rpg in the world
Looks great and I’m really excited for it but don’t you think that during day the picture is too bright?
It became beautiful. But visual is similar to Unreal engine 4 games. I'm a bit tired of seeing looking UE games.
@@RicochetForceI disagree. UE games do often look similar, even if the art style is different. The engine has a certain vibe. Same goes for other engines like Cry engine (I usually love the vibe).
@@RicochetForce I probably own around 200 indie adventures that use UE4. I know visual depends on art director. But it also seems to depend on game engine. Old Electronic Arts titles are also similar to Battlefield in visual.
@@RicochetForce It's only cust-cutting all titles will look the same as it uses same presets under the hood. No matter what and if you want make everything bespoke it won't be cheap and comparable to writing whole thing by yourself the magic of gothic / witcher series was the fact that they wrote their own engine and made things their own way. Which still is great to this day.
@@RicochetForce 90% of games use Quixel assets, so youll see the same rocks etc. everywhere, and its not just UE games either
Orcs and goblins? Man rewatch your video
👍
small mistake, no big deal
@@EyronAVP ye but stupid ppl will complain
Beatufill af. Thanks for the comparison! Now I know it's really a remake as it should be!
Im high and i feel like crying at how good this is.
I can't believe it's real. The boys are back.
Will the orcs still scream their „ucha chak yo, ucha chak yo“ 🤣🤣🤣❤️
I hope this gonna be the second most faithful and succesful remake since RE2 remake!
Nieźle, całkiem nieźle
Bez Twojej pomocy by się nie udało :D
looks good for the most part, i appreciate they've changed the scale of things to be more realistic, this is such a common problem with older 3D games where everything is very scaled down, never really understood why, its not a polygon issue..
Not a huge fan of the trees and the flora/ground cover they've shown, but maybe it'll improve (super important for graphics/immersion overall since it will be noticeable in many places of the game).
If someone said this is UE 5 i would've been a bit sceptical if i didn't know what engine it was (since it can look absolutely mindblowing), but whatever, it still such an immense upgrade from the original graphics and graphics alone didn't make the first game what it was either. I just hope they nail the combat!
I sometimes think they're looking a bit TOO much at the original. For example, Diego stands out in comparison to the other characters, he looks a bit too cartoonish while the other characters does not. Things needs to look consistent.
im pretty sure diego looked different to everyone else in the og too. since lester and everoyne else important all stand out and are able to be recognised as who they were in the og. in my opinion they're way off from the original (the scavanger especially that thing is horrendous since we already have 4 dinosaurs and scavangers are the only birld like enemy in the entire game)
@@hgtugdz2579 that's not what i said though, of course the characters should look different but some can't look very realistic and some almost cartoonish, then its not consistent. yeah the scavenger could look a bit better or more bird like, i agree. these are all minor quibbles though.
@@Vurt72 yes i can agree these are smaller problems, yet i still think remodeling the creatures would be a good idea (scavanger and what i think is the razor since it looks like the 89 godzilla) and also the lighting in the camps should be different and highlight the camps iconic colour which in the trailer they fail at the new and old camp. the swamp camps only complain is no tattoos and ore lamps.
Sehr geil. Das sieht so gut aus. So düster und dreckig. Wenn die Sprachausgabe dazu noch passt. Ich hab mich noch nie so sehr auf ein Spiel gefreut...!
I played all the games until 3 including all expansions, but when it turned into something else I quit playing the risen or whatever that games are. Gothic is one of my favorite games of all time
Muszę przyznać, że przełożenie Śniący na The Sleeper jakoś mi zgrzyta - to przecież Śniący, nie Śpiący. Zrobiłabym z tego chyba The Dreaming One? Chociaż w sumie, to zależy, jak dokładnie brzmiał niemiecki oryginał... Ryje orków też bardziej goblinie niż orkowe, mam wrażenie.
Ale tak ogólnie? Łezka się w oku kręci. Naprawdę wygląd rimejku zrobił na mnie wrażenie. Patrząc na stare i nowe lokacje obok siebie naprawdę ma się wrażenie, że... wreszcie udało się osiągnąć wizję oryginalnych autorów. Że tak to wyglądało w wyobraźni twórców i graczy. Mocna dawka nostalgii.
W oryginale też był jako The Sleeper
Absolutely fantastic. Best is the new camp. It looks amazing.
I am really happy with what they showed! I pray the game is good and more ppl will buy it so G2 remake can me made!
Man I love the original so much... some my fondest gaming memories that shaped my tastes in games.
Same here man. This was my first 3rd person open world rpg that I played ,and since then,I alvays look for similar games to play only. But none can match original gothic 1 ,and 2. Maybe first Risen,only.
@@Karadjordje-rb9ms Risen 3 is really good and I consider it almost as good as the first one, it's genuinely amazing how they've done it. Sadly it's their last great game imo
@@Crazey yeah risen 3 was also a good one. I gave a chance to elex too,you can see in gameplay that it is a Piranha bytes game,but I dont like that sci fi environment and story.
@@Karadjordje-rb9ms Yeah Risen 3 for me will always be their last goodbye to these amazing series Gothic-Risen series. I saw Elex and it doesn't look that fascinating.
@@Crazey i was so sad when I heard that pirahna bytes studio is closed for good . But obviously ,elex 2 was the final nail in their casket... 😔
This is too good to be true!!! Super-job!
Author, could the transitions have been even more brighter!?
Just say how much, Viewer
The Orcs were different. The marsh grass did not sparkle.😢
A lot of soap in the landscapes, no vibes of autumn, animation curves.😢
What will be the character's progression?
This is fire, only thing that characters doesnt look the same. I mean diego and Xardas looks actually good.
But our Bezi and Drax doesnt feel the same
Cant wait tho
i dont like how the bulding style of the orks looks extremely modern
Wrong 😂😂
@@Retro-Design-4033 kinda does since the design unlike the original isnt made out of mined cave and some carved stone but the one in the trailer is something you would see in more modern temples like rome or even newer
@@hgtugdz2579 Gothic era is far newer than Rome. Gothic era of Europe is the 12th centry while Rome fell nearly 700 years before it
@@crestofhonor2349 now that i think of it your right. yet i was talking about how in gothic most buildings dont look too special or modern such as the castle. and now they made the ork buildings look more advanced than the ones of humans. those ork structures look like something i'd find in an amusment part today or some sort of artwork and not something like that. personally i'd like it to be out of stone or something that fits the orks more than something that looks like it was poured with cement.
@@hgtugdz2579 Wood building were far more common of the time than stone. Of course these are video games and they're not trying to be historically accurate to the time. There is a lot wrong a lot of fantasy games get about medieval or gothic architecture
Glad to see Dutch van der Linde made it to the Gothic!
why did you delete a skull?? 6:36
Oglądając stare intro ma się ciary, w nowym brakuje tego czegoś. Nawet lektor średni.
Orka z goblinem pomyliłeś
Good job, but it seems you have compared the new Goblins to an old Orc. Nevertheless, this is a good reference.
8:00 ??? Orc and Goblin
I am 100% sold into the game, and hoping they will remake the whole trilogy!
Impossible
Im fall in love with this game
Woooooow!!!!!!
I will wait with my final opinion until I play the game on gamescom but so far it's looking not bad. Just hope that 4k res will be supported and DLSS.
0:58 Loss and desolation vs pick the holiday's resort. Gothic was not great because of graphic so focusing on that for a remake... we'll see. The teaser, on the other hand, shows a complete different game as a mockery of original.
Too much green, too many trees where there shouldn't be any
6:36 to mi wygląda, bardziej jak wejście na terytorium orków, niż na ich cmentarzysko.
7:55 to jest ork elita, nie ork wojownik.
8:00 nie no c'mon. Przecież to jest goblin XD
8:00 lol XD
Ty to jesteś jednak dobry cyc ❤️
A dziękuję! Zajrzyj na kanał @Granaliza ;)
Tickels my fancy!
PLEASE KEEP THE RED TILES ON THE GOTHIC BUILDINGS
if they don.t put back the pillars with glowing ores back in the sect camp , the wholse sect camp will be fucked,,,,in the night was that bluish collor from the lumps of ores...now it.s simple candles...why it looks ridiculous.
Area seems to be bigger?
Graphical fidelity is good but I feel like much of the style or Gothic aesthetic is diminished. This is a common problem with modern graphics and I think developers need to solve it as most modern games just look the same. This looks like Resident Evil 4 remake. It also looks like Dragon's Dogma 2. Barely any aesthetic or art direction.
original : low settings
remake : ultra settings 😂
Will they add DEI stink?
06:30 wrong scene
New Camp looks the closest to the original❤
Це ми граємо, нарешті!
Diego hat einen "Unterbiss".
I am glad that you have labeled original and remake. Otherwise I wouldn't have been able to tell them apart😄
looks good for the most part, but I hope they put some work into making those npcs faces look less atrocious I also hope they make intro from scratch because intro scenes in this look worse than the original
as well as like in the og have the camera further away instead of the usual zoom in we see in every other game that has dialog. since then facial features become less visible and errors while in dialog are less noticable. the wildlife should be redone fully. unoriginal or just not fitting in the slightest (scavangers)
Diego is used to be Mexican.
He is Georgian/Armenian now 😁
00:21 PATCHES?
Hyped
Looks like game from 2010
many things cut/changed
Хорошо что подписали где оригинал а где римейк. А то непонятно было))))
Как похорошел Хоринис при Собянине.
Diego wcale nie jest podobny.. Hmm może dlatego, że ten w oryginale ma niebieskie oczy.. Ten oryginalny wygląda mroczniej.. prawdziwy zakapior.. a nie taki wujek..
😮😮😮😮😮😮
This will be Great
Będzie dobrze 😊
Diego nawet podobny 😂
Adiós a los colores hermosos del juego original, ahora todo es color azul
Muchos se quejaron de que el juego debia tener una ambientacion oscura, ya que el ambiente colorido no representaba a la saga Gothic, cuando eso es algo totalmente falso.
Gothic siempre tuvo ambientes coloridos en lugares "normales," como el Valle de las Minas en Gothic 1 (antes de que este fuera destruido), el Valle de Khorinis, y el Valle de Jharkendar en Gothic 2, mas la isla de Archolos en Chronicles Of Myrtana, y el continente del Gothic 3, donde todo se veia muy colorido, por lo que esa afirmacion de que siempre fue oscuro, es falsa.
Solo los lugares peligrosos son "oscuros", como el Cementerio Orco, el Templo de Krushak, la Zona Orca del Valle de las Minas, la Fortaleza en Ruinas y el Faro de Niebla de Gothic 1, como tambien el destruido Valle de las Minas, el Templo de Irdorath de Gothic 2, mas la zona de las Alcantarillas, los Cementerios y las Ruinas de Vardhal de Chronicles of Myrtana.
No cuento a Gothic 3 en ese aspecto, por que considero que el juego es demasiado luminoso en cuanto a ambientacion, siendo Nordmar el unico lugar dizque "oscuro" en esa entrega.
Zapowiada się bardzo ciekawie
I would like to take a look at the ancient armor made of ore and urizel + the design of Baron Scar, I also wonder what the armor of paladins and dragon hunters will look like in the second part in the future
Hope Legacy of Kain gets this sick also
Fucking amazing!!
Dzięki za film ! Jak dla mnie,to lokacje wyglądają solidnie.Martwią mnie za to twarze NPC,które wyglądają jak z Wiedźmina 2 oraz animacja chodzenia - sztywno to wygląda.Dodatkowo przy fragmencie gdzie Bezimienny idzie z Diego do Starego Obozu wygląda jakby byli przyklejeni do płaskiego podłoża.
А Велая где?
Diego's ears in the remake aren't big enough!! /s
This will be sweet!!!
doesnt't look as good as some other remakes like Demon's souls but still good
После ремейка первой мафии, чудес от ремойков не жду 😢