Don't get caught! Cycling Laws in Malaysia. A lawyer's point of view.

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 29 авг 2024
  • What does a lawyer have to say about the law in Malaysia on cycling.
    Check out the article here:
    themalaysianla...
    You can connect with me :
    linktr.ee/Melv...
    Or
    / melwind
    / melvintan.cycling
    / melvintanchannel
    / strava
    #CyclingMalaysia #MelvinTanCycling

Комментарии • 71

  • @mavericklimsk
    @mavericklimsk Год назад +4

    In Singapore, helmet is mandatory if riding on public roads.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      As it should hahaha Malaysia have lots of things to update..

  • @vintagedigital108
    @vintagedigital108 Год назад +3

    Would you see in the future that Malaysia will be scooter, skateboard and cycling friendly? I remember skateboarding to uni everyday in Sydney, Australia.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      There is always hope 😂 but honestly... Malaysia is very safe to do those activities is just the roads and terrain and weather makes it hard to skate scoot or cycle to work... And offices have no bath facility. I remember I use to cycle and even roller blade to school too but it was dangerous because it was 8km away and hilly terrain and I have to skate on roads shared by traffic... I guess really depends if u r willing to rough it out... To be same with other countries... Not in the near future because Malaysia have some things to resolve... But the Malaysian people are courteous by default so the people are ready.

  • @albertlee3914
    @albertlee3914 Год назад +1

    Thanks.
    Relevant topic always.
    Law vs Road Users

  • @velanrama
    @velanrama Год назад +1

    Good educational video, should be included Malaysian cycling 101.

  • @zeustwowheels
    @zeustwowheels Год назад +7

    Friendliest cylist in Klang Valley!

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Can't beat that... Leesh is like the friendliest person alive 😂

    • @imleesh
      @imleesh Год назад

      Hi Tim! Thank you for the kind words!

  • @yusoffkadir6945
    @yusoffkadir6945 Год назад +3

    I think a highway especially tolled highway is for motor vehicles only. Hence a cyclist is not allowed to ride on highway. Same goes to pedestrian is not allowed to walk on foot.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Yea just by law... Not everything is executed correctly sadly... And needs to be updated.

  • @Andychungkring
    @Andychungkring Год назад +3

    A very good topic. 👍👍👍

  • @givemeyoursoul5203
    @givemeyoursoul5203 Год назад +7

    Is it legal to tell a fellow cyclist "just another corner and we're there" when its actually another 500 corners ahead?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Absolutely legal..
      This is what I do... When there is 3 more climbs I just tell ppl OK last climb 😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂😂

    • @beavc
      @beavc Год назад +3

      How about your group tell you santai and rolling 25 to 28km/h...ended up pulling and rolling at 33-35km/h😅

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Hahaha ya la... That one legal hahaha 😂

    • @beavc
      @beavc Год назад +2

      @@melvintanchannel all con man! Hahahahaha nearly forget…recovery ride!! Absolutely illegal hahahahaha

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Ahahahaha All. Cyclist... Can't expect less 😂🤣😂🤣

  • @Whoami12000
    @Whoami12000 Год назад +4

    Everytime a police see me cycling they ask me to pecut pecut/sprint sprint

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +1

      Aduh.... Hahaha police officer also probably another kaki kayuh..
      Hahaha

  • @aimanzailani3837
    @aimanzailani3837 Год назад +4

    Maybe the kl car free morning can be kl car free day, from a small targeted area to a larger one 🤷🏽‍♂️

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Susah also concentrated of 1000 cyclist in one small area chaos 🤣🤣🤣

    • @aimanzailani3837
      @aimanzailani3837 Год назад +1

      @@melvintanchannel make sense🤣

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Hahaha u see like kadang kala pères is like carnival wei ratus ratus hahaha fun la but sure motorist kecam 😂

  • @breathestrongcycling3672
    @breathestrongcycling3672 Год назад +3

    Mandatory helmets in NZ and Australia killed cycling. Keep it voluntary pls👍 ...also FYI no helmet on the market today can save you from concussion only non major injuries. I crashed at low speed and no injuries but still a concussion...just my experience✌️

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      U r right... Just last month a cyclist in Malaysia with a usd300 helmet crashed and had a concussion and was hospitalised for a few days...

    • @velanrama
      @velanrama Год назад

      Without a helmet, it could have been worse

  • @brandonkoh8361
    @brandonkoh8361 3 месяца назад +2

    Arent cyclists considered pedestrians? In other words, cant they be used on footpaths because bicycles are not considered vehicles, and the article only references a law regarding vehicles?
    Edit: After doing my own research, im not sure what to think.
    According to Malaysia Road Traffic Rules, 1959:
    Vehicles arent allowed on footpaths. The only exceptions are vehicles for disabled people, prams for babies, or any toy vehicle driven by a child under 12.
    According to ROAD TRANSPORT ACT 1987
    ―vehicle
    means a structure capable of moving or being moved or
    used for the conveyance of any person or thing and which maintains
    contact with the ground when in motion;
    That sounds like a done deal right? But I have a few problems with this.
    1. This means that things like travel suitcases, wheelbarrows, or anything that moves but maintains in contact with the ground is considered a vehicle. So are all tourists who walk around with their travel suitcases essentially criminals? What about the auntie that is just bringing home groceries in her pull bag?
    2. These 2 statements come from entirely different documents. The Malaysia Road Traffic Rules, 1959 document doesnt specify what are vehicles. And while Road Transport Act 1987 does specify what are vehicles, they do not explicitly deny bicycles access to footpaths.
    3. I havent been to malaysia in a long time, but Im pretty damn sure there are a ton of people who just ride their bikes everywhere and anywhere, including footpaths. In fact, Ive heard that bicycles can go on footpaths from more people, than Ive heard that bicycles cant, this video and the article the video references being the only time Ive heard that bicycles are not allowed on footpaths.
    4. Most places in the world allow bicycles on footpaths. Id find it surprising that Malaysia would be one of the few countries that are so cautious of traffic safety, considering that 99% of the people on the road arent.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  3 месяца назад +1

      Maybe becuz bicycles has wheels so considered as vehicles... LOL...

    • @brandonkoh8361
      @brandonkoh8361 3 месяца назад

      @@melvintanchannel By that logic, a wheelbarrow is considered a vehicle.
      Also by that logic, skateboards, wheelchairs, inline skates are not allowed to be on footpaths since theyre considered vehicles.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  3 месяца назад

      😂🤣 True....

  • @GabrielAuYong
    @GabrielAuYong Год назад +2

    Terbaik 👍

  • @qihengwang8506
    @qihengwang8506 Год назад +3

    Hi, Sorry I'am bad at English , Can i ride bicycle in motorcycle lane and pesdestrian lane(walkway beside road)? And also can i install both reflective Front White Light and Rear Red Light that wont light itself instead of the battery one? 🙏

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +1

      Heya ur English is fine.. You can cycle motorbike lane but Not pedestrian walk way. Reflective lights are fine... But again... If a police should stop u just listen and don't argue... Usually nothing happens... Better get a battery light if possible... MR DIY very cheap LOL

  • @Manasseh_Tribe
    @Manasseh_Tribe Год назад +1

    How about law enforcement officer not even sure acts and simply enforced to public?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Guess like what leesh said just comply jher and when in court hope the judge is leniant... Don't get into an argument with the enforcer... Nanti lagi teruk.

  • @velanrama
    @velanrama Год назад

    WCE Expressway has digital and physical signs showing cycling is not allowed in the highway😢. Sad as the views are beautiful.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +1

      Yea lo... Perhaps they should allow cyclist from 6am to 9am weekend 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @360Scuderia
    @360Scuderia Год назад +2

    So does that mean a fixie is an illegal bike?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      So it seems...

    • @imleesh
      @imleesh Год назад +3

      What would be against the law is a fixie bike used on the road and if it doesn’t have brakes at the front and rear wheel. So if you ride the fixie brakeless and on the road, yah, this would break the law under the Road Traffic Rules.

    • @velanrama
      @velanrama Год назад

      @@imleesh This is a more correct answer👍

  • @ambroseling2053
    @ambroseling2053 18 дней назад +1

    Can we ride on SUKE Highway?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  15 дней назад

      I dun think so ... Hahaha but I dun seethe. I. Cycling sign la... LOL.

  • @malepig003
    @malepig003 Год назад +3

    Is it mandatory to bring a IC with us while cycling?

    • @imleesh
      @imleesh Год назад +8

      Hi Zijeat, it is mandatory to still bring your IC because there is always the chance that a law emforcement officer can ask you to show your IC. It is then an offence when you cannot produce your IC.

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад +2

      Hahaha ic should be with you even when you go public toilet... 😂

  • @kaptajnsejersen6303
    @kaptajnsejersen6303 8 месяцев назад +1

    How are the roads to cycle compared to Indonesia?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  8 месяцев назад +1

      I've never had the chance to cycle in Indonesia.... But I would guess like all countries there are some good roads and bad roads... Lol

  • @badhusin
    @badhusin Год назад +1

    Are you saying that wearing a helmet is not compulsory but a bell is?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Hahaha like leesh said the law is outdated.... Hahaha since 1959 bro... Anyway bell will save u when u fall... Make sure ring ring in time 😂

    • @badhusin
      @badhusin Год назад +1

      @@melvintanchannel aiyoo,,,very funny la the law...anyway where got time to ring ring when u fall...if you fall, then you fall la...haha

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Lol

  • @babyrabies
    @babyrabies Год назад +1

    if i drink and cycle then ran over a stray, how much will i be fined?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  Год назад

      Hahaha stray I dun think got any fine kot... Law states must cycle with 2 hands on the bar... But believe that means cannot cycle while holding an object throughtout the ride... But occasional water drink shud be fine depends on court I suppose... But very grey... Especially since the law is 1959 😅

  • @kinmeng.cycling
    @kinmeng.cycling Год назад +2

    Leesh my idol 😊

  • @douglasyong6939
    @douglasyong6939 Год назад +1

    Does the rear lights have to be red?

  • @yunusakthar9732
    @yunusakthar9732 5 месяцев назад

    Do we need permit to cycle on the highway?

    • @melvintanchannel
      @melvintanchannel  5 месяцев назад

      Nope... No permit needed... Unless u r organising an event... But if it's just cycling casual in a group not needed... Just avoid expressway or roads with tolls as usually those roads have no cycling sign boards.

  • @alfredyoyo9420
    @alfredyoyo9420 Год назад +1

    Helmet is compulsory. Becuz it transforms u into a cyclist, hensem haha

  • @alexmark9147
    @alexmark9147 Год назад

    Stupid law. Helmet not mandatory???😂