Badshah khan aur fatima jinna ka left ideology n democratic system ke liye struggle ye darshata h unko Islam aur kuran ko halke me liya tha. Jabki Jinna akalmand tha ki usko pata tha Islam ko weaponise ker sakte h. Shayad jinnah ko ye bhi pata tha Islamic country banaya to democracy to nahi chalne wali, jiski wajah se we khud governor bana.
We still remember both Bacha Khan and Dr Khansahab with great respect and affection in India. There is a very popular market in central Delhi called Khan Market in memory of Dr Khansahab. I had the fortune of seeing Bacha Khan personally in Delhi once. There is also a market in the name of Meherchand Khanna in Delhi. ❤
Very great episode. Best wishes from 🇮🇳 We all Indians have huge respect and immense love for bacha khan. We critic gandhi and find many issues to critic him but when it comes to Bacha khan, there is no aspect of his life and conduct that we can be critical. ❤❤❤❤❤❤
We all love legendary Badshah Khan sahab. A father figure for an entire subcontinent. Gandhi & Badshah Khan cannot be forgotten till this subcontinent exists. . An emotional tribute to Khudai Khidmatgars who sacrificed their life for democracy.
भाई,मुझे पाकिस्तान एक आधुनिक राजा की सल्तनत लगती है,लोकतांत्रिक देश तो बिलकुल भी नहीं लगता है।राजा मुझे फ़ौज के जरनल लगते हैं।भारत में बिलकुल भी ऐसा नहीं है।
2026 Kashmir will get liberation from Pakistan through voting and 2028 Panjab will pass resolution in favor of India and it will be last nail in the coffin as Pakistan people openly invite India to take over.
In this video Dr Sohail mentioned that Sahib Gul MLA met with Liaquat Ali khan in 1954 and said that the issue between pakistan and india regarding kashmir can be solved by Bacha Khan.But Liaquat Ali Khan was assassinated in 1951.Watch 23:32
Khan sahib was in an alliance with the Congress, after independence he had no right to rule, a self respecting person should have resigned himself. Khan was against the NWFP referendum, majority of voters turn out to vote, and nearly 99% voted yes for Pakistan. Khan sahib had no moral authority to rule, a self respecting person should have resigned himself. Why was he ruling when having opposed at every step, and lost? The morally right, and democratic thing to do is to resign.
*What are some things that ordinary people of Pakistan doesn't know about Mr.Mohd Ali Jinnah* What a bloody wisdom he had? The question is. What was the wrong with selecting both URDU and BANGLA Languages as national languages of East Pakistanis only? Wouldn't they have accepted it? The answer is, of course they would have happily? What resulted from it. We all saw that in 1971. (6) Sixth proof, he was so intelligent as, Barrister educated from UK, Politician, leader and founder that he couldn't even form his country's Constitution. As a result of it. The uniquely odd Islamic Republic Of Pakistan had been governed without it until 1973, when the great Leader and politician of Pakistan Z A Bhutto eventually formed it. (Please note,in return, he was rewarded with EXECUTION. (7) unfortunately, it is being taught to Pakistani public that we gained independence through big sacrifices, such as, millions of people were displaced and perished on both sides of the border. The question is. Why? Could the bloodshed which Indians and Pakistanis equally referred to have been prevented? The simple answer is of course. What is the proof? The British presented him with the framework regarding transitional period of about nine months to exchange the migrants in peaceful manner under their respective supervision. But, it was rejected by Mr intelligent.( I do understand. Why he rejected it? He knew that he was suffering from a cronical disease called T. B. And, his life days were drawing closer and closer. Therefore, he wanted to be ensured of having only his own name registered in the international history books as SOLE Champion of Pakistan. He gave no dam about what would happen to the innocent people on both sides. Finally, there is a lot more which could be written on this unique personality. But, I have decided not to. (Please note, strangely, although, he was the Head of Muslim League. But, there are evidences that he never ever consulted other prominent members of his party. He was the SOLE CHAMPION. Some of the members of his party like Mr, Liquat Ali Khan sahaib literally ignored, because he was also like himself merely interested in getting hold onto a high office in the government. What is written in books about two nations theory and he created Pakistan for the Muslims of India is merely one of the propagandas by the writers, because he wasn't even a practising Muslim. He didn't fight against British as many others did during the British rule in india. He was a BROWN COLOUR ENGLISH MAN in his three piece suits. He simply wanted to be known as a Founder of the nation. That's all. Nothing else. Finally, Please note, as I have pointed out above that it is a very complex question to answer. But, nevertheless, I have written some with full honesty away from politics in the light of facts, which are in black and white. To add a little more to it. The reason Pakistan was created HASTILY and DISORDERLY. There were some sections of Pakistani society primarily in West Pakistan, who were highly educated and had businesses. They were the active forces behind it, because they all had their personal interests in its creation. No matter, what ever the order in which it was created.
The most stunning part is the way he died. Daughter not with him. His sister looking after him. Deserted by the British and muslim league alike after his role in getting their agenda was over. His Father was born a Hindu and this is what happens to ambitious Hindus that don't conform. The whole story of India and Pakistan is a very sad one. Selfish people drove that story to suit individual agendas rather than any common national agenda. Old history is best forgotten. There is nothing there except war after war how invaders and kings ruled us for personal gain/power. There is no example of accountable self rule by the citizens. Unless we self develop an accountable form of government functioning that is answerable to the people ( 1.4B) , there is no hope out of this vicious circle
You know how to write, but I'm shocked you don't know how to read, because you don't know anything. All you've written is nothing but lies created from your wild imagination. Pathetic 😂
बाचा ख़ान का नाम भारत में सम्मान से लिया जाता है,उन्हें हम सीमांत महात्मा गांधी कहते हैं,स्वर्गीय राजीव गांधी के समय उनका बीमारी में इलाज करवाया था।सीमांत गांधी बिलकुल भी नहीं चाहते थे की देश का विभाजन हो।अगर आज हम अलग न हुए होते तब हम बहुत तरक़्क़ी कर चुके होते ।
The guest seems too opinionated to be a historian. He has clear political bias. For instance, if people come out in support of the cause he supports its democracy. If its in support of the cause he doesn’t support then the public is silly and mislead. He’s too emotional to state facts. First half of the podcast was amazing but the second half was too politically biased.
“I am the punishment of God... If you had not committed great sins, God would not have sent a punishment like me upon you.” - Highly Respected Mr. Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan
I guess there is some confusion while referring to Peshawar university quote the words can't be the don of new age it should be the dawn of the new age
Well there is no partition all states were independent and separate unite to kia hi in empires ne partition to just punjab ka hua also they just adopted this "India" in 1947 just adopted nothing elese
Jinnah shaib ki family islamic republic of Pakistan kyu nhi gaye ? Jinnah shaib nay khan baba k sath kya keya ? Sach truth pura bolna padtha hai sach nanga ugly he bolna padtha hai. Jinnah shaib k pura sach boley shaib
good job Imran.... like your other work(s) ...& a big thanks to Dr. Sohail for gracing your podcast an important work (& i say this for your other work(s) as well) not only from entertainment/recreation point of view but also a very cerebral work/exchange as a matter of record hope you expand your flock (& subscribers) on both sides of the radcliff line :)
After a very long time.. I have some hope for Pakistan. But I know, no one in Pakistan will take this seriously as they lack the intellect to absorb this discussion. 😂😂😂😂😂
बाचा ख़ान का नाम भारत में सम्मान से लिया जाता है,उन्हें हम सीमांत महात्मा गांधी कहते हैं,स्वर्गीय राजीव गांधी के समय उनका बीमारी में इलाज करवाया था।सीमांत गांधी बिलकुल भी नहीं चाहते थे की देश का विभाजन हो।अगर आज हम अलग न हुए होते तब हम बहुत तरक़्क़ी कर चुके होते । महोदय आपसे निवेदन है कि बाचा ख़ान का नाम सम्मान से लें।
Please invite pervesh shaheen sab from swat manglawar on history of gandhara and pashtoon culture .he wrote 56 books and also attend many international conferences.He also very knowledgeable person.
Interview lene wale ki samjh ko salaam- dawn of the era ka matlab "area ka badmash' . Aur saamne wale ne usse correct b ni kiya inko usse b bada salaam.
Sirs,creation of Pakistan was the best event that ever happened in indian subcontinent in 1947. It is only after that Pakistan lost its way becoming embroiled in one war after another. These wars have sapped them extracting a very high cost.
@@AI-ok1chNot a problem cuz "India" its self came from here Sindhu 😂 they just adopted this India in 1947 just adopted nothing else all names and whole subcontinent belongs to Pakistan 🇵🇰💪
Jinnah shaib nai tho letter to editor nhi likha haha haha jinnah per research kyu nhi kr skthy ? Jinnah aur winston Churchill k beech letters se kya communication hua tha ?
OMER AYUB'S GRAND GRAND FATHER RISALDAR MAJ MIRDAD KHAN OF 9 HODSON HORSE REGT EAST INDIA COY & SON OF DICTATOR AYUB KHAN IS SECY GEN OF PTI & NOMINATED NOMINATED NOMINATED OPPOSITION LEADER !
611!! I'm shocked!! There were around 379 people that were massacred at Jallianwala Baug!! This was almost double...and forgotten in history!!
Thankx to Jinnah for making Pakistan.😊
Why are you guys everywhere? Why the fuck you don't stick to your own podcasts and shit? Go fucking away shit brains
Mind your own business. Go watch your own stuff, stop commenting on our stuff. Get lost already
@omer19951 please enjoy your stuff 😊
😂😂😂😂😂😂😂
He created a problem for India as well . Both permanent enemies have nuclear weapons .
Badshah khan aur fatima jinna ka left ideology n democratic system ke liye struggle ye darshata h unko Islam aur kuran ko halke me liya tha. Jabki Jinna akalmand tha ki usko pata tha Islam ko weaponise ker sakte h. Shayad jinnah ko ye bhi pata tha Islamic country banaya to democracy to nahi chalne wali, jiski wajah se we khud governor bana.
Absolutely spot on.
Exactly.....lot of muslims Still ignores the Islamic rule/islamic principles are itself a frankastein monster ....
pakistan is land of oldest civilizxations ,mashallah
we are , were never part of RUNDIA
bhaarat matsa ka ch ....
Exactly Sindhu Indus🇵🇰💪 this India its self born in 1947 just adopted this name from British nothing else
Welcome to Islamic Cult.
Kya Karte Ho Yaar Enjoy karo
4 Niqah Karo Talaq do Niqah karo.
Fir Jannat Me Dalla (No Al Lah) Aap Ko Hoors Supply karega
lol hindooiazm says tp supply 16,000 apsaras
shiva ka l..nd poojari kaallla india n
hanuman is hangumaan mon..key
gandnesha the elep..nt
shiva l..nd poojaris
a hindoo tanatan drama follower saying lol
Pakistan is the land of sinshu indus 🇵🇰😘
What a quality podcast. Absolutely pleasure to listen to Dr. Sohail Khan Sahab. Loved it.❤❤
We still remember both Bacha Khan and Dr Khansahab with great respect and affection in India. There is a very popular market in central Delhi called Khan Market in memory of Dr Khansahab. I had the fortune of seeing Bacha Khan personally in Delhi once. There is also a market in the name of Meherchand Khanna in Delhi. ❤
Bacha khan gaddar tha. Usko Nehru bacchiyan supply karta tha isiliye yaraana tha.
Very great episode. Best wishes from 🇮🇳
We all Indians have huge respect and immense love for bacha khan.
We critic gandhi and find many issues to critic him but when it comes to Bacha khan, there is no aspect of his life and conduct that we can be critical.
❤❤❤❤❤❤
Love India ❤ from pak
pashtuns are not rundians
@@AI-ok1ch u are rundikabacha? isn't true?
We all love legendary Badshah Khan sahab. A father figure for an entire subcontinent.
Gandhi & Badshah Khan cannot be forgotten till this subcontinent exists. .
An emotional tribute to Khudai Khidmatgars who sacrificed their life for democracy.
Role of Islamist supremacist had not been discussed....
This man has is very deep knowledge of history.
13:00 Dawn of the era ... matlab era ka badmash 🤔🤔 🤣🤣 नये युग की सुबह ..beginning of something new
भाई,मुझे पाकिस्तान एक आधुनिक राजा की सल्तनत लगती है,लोकतांत्रिक देश तो बिलकुल भी नहीं लगता है।राजा मुझे फ़ौज के जरनल लगते हैं।भारत में बिलकुल भी ऐसा नहीं है।
2026 Kashmir will get liberation from Pakistan through voting and 2028 Panjab will pass resolution in favor of India and it will be last nail in the coffin as Pakistan people openly invite India to take over.
In this video Dr Sohail mentioned that Sahib Gul MLA met with Liaquat Ali khan in 1954 and said that the issue between pakistan and india regarding kashmir can be solved by Bacha Khan.But Liaquat Ali Khan was assassinated in 1951.Watch 23:32
Khan sahib was in an alliance with the Congress, after independence he had no right to rule, a self respecting person should have resigned himself.
Khan was against the NWFP referendum, majority of voters turn out to vote, and nearly 99% voted yes for Pakistan.
Khan sahib had no moral authority to rule, a self respecting person should have resigned himself.
Why was he ruling when having opposed at every step, and lost?
The morally right, and democratic thing to do is to resign.
कभी आपने सोचा कि पाकिस्तानी मुस्लिम और हिंदू आपस कौन हैं ? नहीं सोचा तो सोचें
*What are some things that ordinary people of Pakistan doesn't know about Mr.Mohd Ali Jinnah*
What a bloody wisdom he had? The question is. What was the wrong with selecting both URDU and BANGLA Languages as national languages of East Pakistanis only? Wouldn't they have accepted it? The answer is, of course they would have happily? What resulted from it. We all saw that in 1971.
(6) Sixth proof, he was so intelligent as, Barrister educated from UK, Politician, leader and founder that he couldn't even form his country's Constitution. As a result of it. The uniquely odd Islamic Republic Of Pakistan had been governed without it until 1973, when the great Leader and politician of Pakistan Z A Bhutto eventually formed it. (Please note,in return, he was rewarded with EXECUTION.
(7) unfortunately, it is being taught to Pakistani public that we gained independence through big sacrifices, such as, millions of people were displaced and perished on both sides of the border. The question is. Why? Could the bloodshed which Indians and Pakistanis equally referred to have been prevented? The simple answer is of course. What is the proof? The British presented him with the framework regarding transitional period of about nine months to exchange the migrants in peaceful manner under their respective supervision. But, it was rejected by Mr intelligent.( I do understand. Why he rejected it? He knew that he was suffering from a cronical disease called T. B. And, his life days were drawing closer and closer. Therefore, he wanted to be ensured of having only his own name registered in the international history books as SOLE Champion of Pakistan. He gave no dam about what would happen to the innocent people on both sides.
Finally, there is a lot more which could be written on this unique personality. But, I have decided not to. (Please note, strangely, although, he was the Head of Muslim League. But, there are evidences that he never ever consulted other prominent members of his party. He was the SOLE CHAMPION. Some of the members of his party like Mr, Liquat Ali Khan sahaib literally ignored, because he was also like himself merely interested in getting hold onto a high office in the government.
What is written in books about two nations theory and he created Pakistan for the Muslims of India is merely one of the propagandas by the writers, because he wasn't even a practising Muslim. He didn't fight against British as many others did during the British rule in india. He was a BROWN COLOUR ENGLISH MAN in his three piece suits. He simply wanted to be known as a Founder of the nation. That's all. Nothing else.
Finally, Please note, as I have pointed out above that it is a very complex question to answer. But, nevertheless, I have written some with full honesty away from politics in the light of facts, which are in black and white. To add a little more to it. The reason Pakistan was created HASTILY and DISORDERLY. There were some sections of Pakistani society primarily in West Pakistan, who were highly educated and had businesses. They were the active forces behind it, because they all had their personal interests in its creation. No matter, what ever the order in which it was created.
The most stunning part is the way he died. Daughter not with him. His sister looking after him. Deserted by the British and muslim league alike after his role in getting their agenda was over. His Father was born a Hindu and this is what happens to ambitious Hindus that don't conform. The whole story of India and Pakistan is a very sad one. Selfish people drove that story to suit individual agendas rather than any common national agenda. Old history is best forgotten. There is nothing there except war after war how invaders and kings ruled us for personal gain/power. There is no example of accountable self rule by the citizens. Unless we self develop an accountable form of government functioning that is answerable to the people ( 1.4B) , there is no hope out of this vicious circle
Totally agree with you.
Very well said.
You know how to write, but I'm shocked you don't know how to read, because you don't know anything.
All you've written is nothing but lies created from your wild imagination.
Pathetic 😂
Well there is no partition all states were independent and separate it's a divided subcontinent unite to kia hi in empires ne
Such guests should be invited more often to educate the general public. Rafiullah Kakar should be invited for a podcast.
बाचा ख़ान का नाम भारत में सम्मान से लिया जाता है,उन्हें हम सीमांत महात्मा गांधी कहते हैं,स्वर्गीय राजीव गांधी के समय उनका बीमारी में इलाज करवाया था।सीमांत गांधी बिलकुल भी नहीं चाहते थे की देश का विभाजन हो।अगर आज हम अलग न हुए होते तब हम बहुत तरक़्क़ी कर चुके होते ।
AHUMDOLILLAH WE ARE INDEPENDENT
JINNAH ZINDABAD FOREVER
611 shaheed huay, bachy khawateen samait. 😭.. Kiya ye sb Qaid e Azam Mohammad Ali Jinahh ne karwaya????? 😥
The guest seems too opinionated to be a historian. He has clear political bias. For instance, if people come out in support of the cause he supports its democracy. If its in support of the cause he doesn’t support then the public is silly and mislead. He’s too emotional to state facts. First half of the podcast was amazing but the second half was too politically biased.
Fakher-e-Afghan Khan Abdul Ghafar Khan Bacha Khan says You have throw us in the front of wolves.
“I am the punishment of God... If you had not committed great sins, God would not have sent a punishment like me upon you.” - Highly Respected Mr. Khan Abdul Ghaffar Khan
Eye opening discussion. What a knowledgeable Man.
great book and great teacher.
I guess there is some confusion while referring to Peshawar university quote the words can't be the don of new age it should be the dawn of the new age
Sir at that time Islamabad was not existed - then how come Islamabad airport ?
Jinah and Iqbal was English men creation. Both was confused and very cleaver
Well there is no partition all states were independent and separate unite to kia hi in empires ne partition to just punjab ka hua also they just adopted this "India" in 1947 just adopted nothing elese
Sir sohail khan saab the great..❤❤
Minus one ka concept ye Qaid e Azam ne eejad kiya.. Bacha khan ko Qudai khidmat gar sy alg kr ny ky liay 😥
Thanks jinnhah , the host is pro Afghanistan
Jinnah shaib ki family islamic republic of Pakistan kyu nhi gaye ? Jinnah shaib nay khan baba k sath kya keya ? Sach truth pura bolna padtha hai sach nanga ugly he bolna padtha hai. Jinnah shaib k pura sach boley shaib
good job Imran.... like your other work(s)
...& a big thanks to Dr. Sohail for gracing your podcast
an important work (& i say this for your other work(s) as well) not only from entertainment/recreation point of view but also a very cerebral work/exchange as a matter of record
hope you expand your flock (& subscribers) on both sides of the radcliff line :)
Aur pakistan k naam mai Bangladesh se kia liya tha?
After a very long time.. I have some hope for Pakistan. But I know, no one in Pakistan will take this seriously as they lack the intellect to absorb this discussion. 😂😂😂😂😂
Haji sb, di de podcast awaz mu lag slow dy
बाचा ख़ान का नाम भारत में सम्मान से लिया जाता है,उन्हें हम सीमांत महात्मा गांधी कहते हैं,स्वर्गीय राजीव गांधी के समय उनका बीमारी में इलाज करवाया था।सीमांत गांधी बिलकुल भी नहीं चाहते थे की देश का विभाजन हो।अगर आज हम अलग न हुए होते तब हम बहुत तरक़्क़ी कर चुके होते । महोदय आपसे निवेदन है कि बाचा ख़ान का नाम सम्मान से लें।
Bacha baba ko leader bannaya hota pakistan nay tho aaj yeh haal nhi hota Economics is secondary character is Primary.
Superb
Pakistan abhi chor baazar main nahi bik sakta 😂😂
The land of Pakistan khareedi nahi ja skti it's the land of Sindhu indus
Excellent discussion
Aare jinnah to wo insaan tha, jo apne dost ki 16 saal ki beti ko bhaga ke le gaya tha... 😊
At last he was follower of sexullah.. (Rasoolallah) 😅😅😅
Nice. Fear of IM the DIM remained there. Thanks for not letting him out from his dwelling in a cell.
Loved your podcast. Love from India, brother ❤❤
Please invite pervesh shaheen sab from swat manglawar on history of gandhara and pashtoon culture .he wrote 56 books and also attend many international conferences.He also very knowledgeable person.
Such a great discussion.. Salute.. India we don't have this type of discussion now. Eye opening.. Thanks.
We have ,just listen to those. In your heart you might belive pakistanis more than Indian.
Wow absolutely amazing ❤
Good one
This podcast would have been better in Pashto, the mother tongue of both these gentlemen.
He is educationist and he should be asked regarding education
Great correction towards the history of Pakistan ❤
Fantastic Conversation. Love and Respect.
Interview lene wale ki samjh ko salaam- dawn of the era ka matlab "area ka badmash' . Aur saamne wale ne usse correct b ni kiya inko usse b bada salaam.
Sirs,creation of Pakistan was the best event that ever happened in indian subcontinent in 1947.
It is only after that Pakistan lost its way becoming embroiled in one war after another. These wars have sapped them extracting a very high cost.
lol nothing called rundian subcontinent exist
it is south asia
Btw "India" its self came from here Sindhu river🇵🇰🗿 all other names too😂 Pakistan is the land of Sindhu Indus
Btw "India" its self came from here Sindhu river🇵🇰🗿 all other names too😂 Pakistan is the land of Sindhu Indus
@@AI-ok1chNot a problem cuz "India" its self came from here Sindhu 😂 they just adopted this India in 1947 just adopted nothing else all names and whole subcontinent belongs to Pakistan 🇵🇰💪
Come out of partition hangover 😅
Also there is nothing like partition all states were independent and separate unite to kia hi in empires ne partition to just Punjab ka hua
Jinnah shaib nai tho letter to editor nhi likha haha haha jinnah per research kyu nhi kr skthy ? Jinnah aur winston Churchill k beech letters se kya communication hua tha ?
❤❤
Very nice and informative discussion. THANKS 😮
Find a controversial topic to promote your podcast. Invite a celebrity. Your voice needs to be heard.
@@sabrinakhan8217 apki ammi ka yaar ha kiya?
OMER AYUB'S GRAND GRAND FATHER RISALDAR MAJ MIRDAD KHAN OF 9 HODSON HORSE REGT EAST INDIA COY & SON OF DICTATOR AYUB KHAN IS SECY GEN OF PTI & NOMINATED NOMINATED NOMINATED OPPOSITION LEADER !
YOU MAKE YOUR OWN CONCLUSIONS NOT BASED ON FACTS !
JI.NAH WAS GORAS TOUT LIKE IK IS YAHOO O NISARA & QADYANIS TOUT .
KIA AFGHAN HONA MOHAMMADI HONE SE AFZAL HAI?
watch exmuslimsahil and adam seeker to know truth about islam with proof from quran and hadis.
no watch ex hindoo channels and see rreality of tanatan drama
kissa sims
hanguman mnkey
ganesha the elephjant
shiva l..nd poojaris
see the reality of hindooiuzm saar
kaaluz hindooz
bhaarat mata ki ch....
ARE PASHTUN MUSLIM FIRST OR MUSLIM FIRST ?
ARE PASHTUN MUSLIM FIRST OR PASHTUN FIRST.?
JINNAH WAS IMRAN KHAN NO 1