Bubbie is one I'm incredibly suspect of. When you play OB as lateral hazard... take gimmies from 4 feet... yeeeeah. The idea that he's on the same level of Golf Sidekick is bold.
Sidekick would beat Bubbie by 10 strokes playing it down. Like you said, playing OB as lateral and not putting it out can make a huge difference. I like Bubbie but he’s a 8-10 handicap. His ball might go 50 yards left or 40 yards right. Nobody knows.
No mention of Brad Dalke...why? Anyway, think on GoodGood's tournament on 07/02 Luke will take it a little more serious and with Sean will take it...even with the Bryan Bros playing
Kyle Berkshire just shot 67 at Trump national Los Angeles, a very difficult golf course. Kyle is getting close to being as good as anybody on RUclips. He's a 4.5 star in my book.
Definitely agree with all of them except Garret and DOD King. Both of them should be downed one. Also, some of these guys have never played REAL tourney golf by the rules, and wouldn’t ever in their life shoot in 70’s. George is the top dog and the only one of all these guys we’d be nervous playing. We’re trying to figure out how to get in the cool kids club to see where we stack up. We’ll just keep making content hoping to get noticed, sigh. In real tourneys, our guy Eric shot 73-78 most of the time, low 80’s on his worst days. The one Open (regional PGA event) he played he shot 80-78-81 on a tough course with tough conditions (like 210-240 yard par 3’s with lightning fast undulated greens). Hopefully later this year someone will accept one of our challenges or have us out to theirs. We just subscribed to your channel, good video overall!
No Brad in GG? I think he's lowkey the best player in GG. Lets not forget about Ben. Ben's a stick for sure. I'd hazard to guess that Ben and Brad both shoot in the 60s on the regular with an outlying round in the 70s.
He is. That guy’s got an insane short game. I’d take him over Luke right now, Luke is a guy who’s not as much of a natural golfer and needs a lot more practice, which he’s not getting these days.
I think if you enjoy doing these rankings you should do a shout out to all youtube golf content players, minus the actual pro youtube players, to offer them all a chance to be rated against one another via regular ongoing power rankings. No star ratings just bottom to top based on results playing either difficult courses and/or tournaments against one another. That would be so cool, and nobody gets left out.
And when was Micah an "under par" tournament golfer? His stroke average on that 2nd tier mini tour was around 76.25. Did he ever shoot a round under par? Maybe 1?
One thing everyone should remember, when you have these youtube matches such as when Good Good played the bar stool sports guys, filming 9 holes takes forever. Pretty hard to get in a groove for some guys. Another factor is having to golf and film, and the filming is more important than the golf. Cole Lantz is a guy that generally plays better when he is on other people's channels and doesn't have to film. (Madjack) Most of these guys would be better if they were just worrying about going low, rather than having to entertain. Brad Dalke is probably the best along with George. Paige is the best female, though Gabbygolfgirl should pass her up, at some point. What a marvelous young talent. Paige is just a natural golfer, even though her emphasis is on something else. Too bad, she could be important in the space. Her life though, no one gets to decide for her, nor should they.
I really do enjoy these. Maybe consider doing this in the form of YT Golf Power Rankings, like monthly or quarterly, based on the various performances during the period. That would be very cool!
James Ruth who quite often plays on Dan Hendriksen’s channel is hands down the best player not on tour in the uk. I’d love to see a head to head of him v George Bryan.
I’m a fan of bubbies and can see him as lower 3 star. Clutch putter on the scrambles at least. Would say he’s not a fan of course management. Prefers to hit the long ball no matter what the hole requires. Still like watching him play no matter what.
I think James and some of the UK guys are a bit better than 3 ⭐️. They’re teaching pros and shoot very consistently in the 70s and upper 60s sometimes. However, I concede I didn’t see that game in 2023. 🤷♂️
Disagree with putting Bubbie as a 3-star he should be a 2-star in my opinion. When his drives are working he’s decent but the other parts of his game need a lot of work.
UK guy here….James Robinson gets 5 stars for being the most annoying. Mark Crossfield gets 6 stars - really annoying bur Rick Shiels gets 100 stars in the same heading. Loves himself. If he was made of chocolate, he would’ve eaten himself by now. Matt Fryer and Andy Carter both excellent. Best of all here in the UK is The Art of Simple Golf. Alex is a superb golf coach.
You need to check out this little tank that plays golf in SE asia. His channel is "Golf Every Second". This kid is strong and can play. I dont know how much content hes putting out right now but he's a hellavu player
Very generous with the 5 stars. Feb 7th will sort a lot of this out. I enjoy a lot of these guys and their work, but the 5's were over a third of your list.
I think I deserve to be on this list. Just being honest. I’m guessing a lot of people just don’t know me yet. That will change by the end of 2024. Great video Luke!
I’d give James Robinson 3.5 or maybe 4. He has gotten pretty good. Definitely can challenge par at difficult courses. Golf Sidekick can’t hit driver at all and mostly misses fairways with his 1 and 3 irons, so I’d put him at 2.5.
What would make naming the top dog easier is for all the RUclips golf creators to get official handicaps. That will allow us followers to track their improvement, and compare our own game to theirs...would also make 18 hole comps more fair playing of their handicaps...just saying
With the exception of Grant and George. They all have vanity handicaps. Luke, Micah, Steve, Bubbie, FP range between 4 and 10 handicaps. They all cheat their scores and edit out there horrible shots. That’s why none of them break 75 in tournament play.
@@LeszzK Nah. We are talking about average score over 18 holes here. You honestly think Bubbie averages around a 77 over 18 holes? I would guess closer to a 81-82 average.
Steve is an elite putter, George is beating a PGA pro in match play consistently, Kyle is the long drive Goat, Rick is better than Matt and Bubbie in stroke play, Kyle would smoke Martin in stroke play, in summary these ratings are about as reliable as Google Reviews 😂 Nice work on the compilation though 🎉🎉 Edit: DOD King retired bruh
It would be really hard to argue with your list. I feel it is really solid. And like you mentioned, some of these guys fluctuate depending on practice, travel, etc. And btw, if you ever really need to give someone a 1 star, feel free to use my name in that spot haha. Good luck in Feb, it's gonna be exciting.
not a fan of Kyle, but he is much better than 3 star. he is 4 or 5 star. Dude puts up under par rounds at tough courses, and i've never seen a round in the 80's from him.
Bubbie is one I'm incredibly suspect of. When you play OB as lateral hazard... take gimmies from 4 feet... yeeeeah. The idea that he's on the same level of Golf Sidekick is bold.
Sidekick would beat Bubbie by 10 strokes playing it down. Like you said, playing OB as lateral and not putting it out can make a huge difference. I like Bubbie but he’s a 8-10 handicap. His ball might go 50 yards left or 40 yards right. Nobody knows.
Brad Dalke? I mean he's gotta make the list and be a 5 star.
You missed Brad “The Bad Man” Dalke - bro would cook everyone on the RUclipsr list except for George, it would be close
There's no way Bobby and ColdCuts are on the same tier with Stephen, come on now, that's ridiculous.
He didn’t want to put anyone at 1 star though.
Yeah so true Stephen is more of a 13 handicap and bob and Joey like 18
@@albertpritchrd3384Stephen is like a 25 handicap lol
@@CybekCusalno he is not, he is a 10-12
Yes he is. I can do this all day...
Where is Ben Hadden and Brad Dalke?
Would love to see an actual tournament bracket of youtubers. But the last 2 are likely one of the Bryan brothers and Dahlke.
I like the list, keep it going, next time I'd like to see you add in , AJ Puhols, Ben Hadden, and Brad Dalke.
No mention of Brad Dalke...why? Anyway, think on GoodGood's tournament on 07/02 Luke will take it a little more serious and with Sean will take it...even with the Bryan Bros playing
I’d put George and Brad Dalke as 6 stars. Also got to move Steve up.
Check out Taco Golf and his crew from New Zealand…very impressive.
Yeah, bad oversight by Luke.
Taco golf content is awesome.
Would be a 5 star youtube golfer for sure.
…he not only can play, but is hilarious as well!
Steve has made his way to the 3 star for sure now. And having Pat Perez as the picture fore Fat Perez is hilarious
I agree, his game has come up for sure, and when he gets on a putting roll, he doesn't miss.
Kyle Berkshire just shot 67 at Trump national Los Angeles, a very difficult golf course. Kyle is getting close to being as good as anybody on RUclips. He's a 4.5 star in my book.
agreed, i'd take him over Mason (was given 5 stars) in a match
He just doesn’t wanna give the long drive guys the credit they deserve. Doesn’t see them as real golfers. It’s a common golfer complex.
No Brad?! He’s playing better than Luke I’d say
James robinson def shoots in the low 70's he just shot 5 under at Tigers course and beat Pete Finch heads up. Still love the effort though brother
Rick Sheils is at least a 4 star.He beat Grant Horvat once.
And he even tied James Robinson the former tour pro (not the RUclips golfer).
Not even close. He plays a lot more bad golf than good golf.
No way. Grant beats Rick 95 times out of 100.
@danmyers9372 99 out of a 100. Honestly, I believe Grant let him win that match.
lol no. Rick can shoot around par on occasion... but dude is a like a 4-5 handicap as a golf pro.
Although George Bryan Is an Elite golfer, I would have had to put Brad Dalke ahead or tied. Sad you didn't have Dalke on your list.
Brad Dalke might be the top dawg bro!!
Definitely agree with all of them except Garret and DOD King. Both of them should be downed one. Also, some of these guys have never played REAL tourney golf by the rules, and wouldn’t ever in their life shoot in 70’s.
George is the top dog and the only one of all these guys we’d be nervous playing. We’re trying to figure out how to get in the cool kids club to see where we stack up. We’ll just keep making content hoping to get noticed, sigh. In real tourneys, our guy Eric shot 73-78 most of the time, low 80’s on his worst days. The one Open (regional PGA event) he played he shot 80-78-81 on a tough course with tough conditions (like 210-240 yard par 3’s with lightning fast undulated greens).
Hopefully later this year someone will accept one of our challenges or have us out to theirs.
We just subscribed to your channel, good video overall!
No Brad in GG? I think he's lowkey the best player in GG. Lets not forget about Ben. Ben's a stick for sure. I'd hazard to guess that Ben and Brad both shoot in the 60s on the regular with an outlying round in the 70s.
He is. That guy’s got an insane short game. I’d take him over Luke right now, Luke is a guy who’s not as much of a natural golfer and needs a lot more practice, which he’s not getting these days.
Forgot Brad Dalke. ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Brad Dehlke?
Kyle just shot 67 at trump national in CA lol the hardest golf course in CA
That's a sound list, but any list that omits Ron Chopper has missed the memo 🙂
Oh, and same thing with the ladies, so many of them are so good and fun to watch.
Luke!!! You ready for the GG Open?? Got to have CEO on the list.
I think if you enjoy doing these rankings you should do a shout out to all youtube golf content players, minus the actual pro youtube players, to offer them all a chance to be rated against one another via regular ongoing power rankings. No star ratings just bottom to top based on results playing either difficult courses and/or tournaments against one another. That would be so cool, and nobody gets left out.
Did I just zone out and miss Brad Dalke?
Brad Dahlke?
Bubbie a 4 and Steve a 2?
Both are 3
Bubbie was a 3. Wasn't a great list though
I think you devised this list in a hurry. Where's Brad Dalke?
And when was Micah an "under par" tournament golfer? His stroke average on that 2nd tier mini tour was around 76.25. Did he ever shoot a round under par? Maybe 1?
Agreed. I like Micah but he is overrated here.
Micah is a 4 handicap and thinks he’s scratch
I think Micah is super annoying.
Forgot one of the top 5 for sure with Brad Dalke
also forgot ben hadden who is a great golfer and rolls with good good quite a lot
Does Dalke have his own channel? I believe Luke is only reviewing content creators.
@@danmyers9372 yes he have his own channel
@@danmyers9372 he does have a channel
www.youtube.com/@braddalkegolf
@@danmyers9372yes he has one
Taco golf, awesome content, awesome RUclipsr, easily a 5. He plays some very challenging courses
I think you gotta base Steve's skill on if he gives a damn or not, when he locks in and that putter gets hot he's easily a 3 star
I’m right in that 2 star category. Slowly moving up to 3 ⭐️
One thing everyone should remember, when you have these youtube matches such as when Good Good played the bar stool sports guys, filming 9 holes takes forever. Pretty hard to get in a groove for some guys. Another factor is having to golf and film, and the filming is more important than the golf. Cole Lantz is a guy that generally plays better when he is on other people's channels and doesn't have to film. (Madjack) Most of these guys would be better if they were just worrying about going low, rather than having to entertain. Brad Dalke is probably the best along with George. Paige is the best female, though Gabbygolfgirl should pass her up, at some point. What a marvelous young talent. Paige is just a natural golfer, even though her emphasis is on something else. Too bad, she could be important in the space. Her life though, no one gets to decide for her, nor should they.
The Aussies Get forgotten again lol We do exist I promise
You need to do a ranking list of the ladies of YT golf, that will get some interesting feedback
Brad Dalke is by far the second best golfer and would be a great match between him and Bryan. Ben Hadden also is a 5⭐️.
Micah morris needs to get out of 5 star
Dang. The CEO of Golf disrespect is real 😢
I really do enjoy these. Maybe consider doing this in the form of YT Golf Power Rankings, like monthly or quarterly, based on the various performances during the period. That would be very cool!
Figure out end of year YT Ryder Cup format good luck this year
I have been following Dan Hendriksen and his brother Paul from England, they are very good golfers that should be on your list.
James Ruth who quite often plays on Dan Hendriksen’s channel is hands down the best player not on tour in the uk. I’d love to see a head to head of him v George Bryan.
I kind of forgot about James, he is a very good golfer. James and George would be a fun match to watch.@@YoYoZamolo
Hey Hey Hey Hey .. Hey .. I should be in that 1⭐️ spot
I’m a fan of bubbies and can see him as lower 3 star. Clutch putter on the scrambles at least. Would say he’s not a fan of course management. Prefers to hit the long ball no matter what the hole requires. Still like watching him play no matter what.
Zac is horrendous
I think James and some of the UK guys are a bit better than 3 ⭐️. They’re teaching pros and shoot very consistently in the 70s and upper 60s sometimes. However, I concede I didn’t see that game in 2023. 🤷♂️
Disagree with putting Bubbie as a 3-star he should be a 2-star in my opinion. When his drives are working he’s decent but the other parts of his game need a lot of work.
His ballstriking is very very good. Rarely not making great contact
Just subbed. Today and love it. Nate Edward's is always on top of it. Very accurate sofar
Bubbie’s short game is 1 star…you put him in a tourney he ain’t breaking 80…
Idk id say the guy that’s been on the tour multiple times and actually has a pga tour win… but idk that’s just me 😅
UK guy here….James Robinson gets 5 stars for being the most annoying. Mark Crossfield gets 6 stars - really annoying bur Rick Shiels gets 100 stars in the same heading. Loves himself. If he was made of chocolate, he would’ve eaten himself by now. Matt Fryer and Andy Carter both excellent. Best of all here in the UK is The Art of Simple Golf. Alex is a superb golf coach.
Ol Jittery Jerge with the dub for 2023! Gotta love it!
Mark Crossfield I'm pretty sure is a scratch golfer. He's at least a four star based on your criteria.
Berkshire is a 4 star..
Brad Dalke for way up on the list.
Miss labeled Steve, bubbie and Rick Shiels.
I think Josh Mayer would beat Bubbie in a match. I'd love to see Martin Borgmeier vs Kyle Berkshire too!
You need to check out this little tank that plays golf in SE asia. His channel is "Golf Every Second". This kid is strong and can play. I dont know how much content hes putting out right now but he's a hellavu player
where's the CEO?
golfmates is the best golf youtube by far.
Very generous with the 5 stars. Feb 7th will sort a lot of this out. I enjoy a lot of these guys and their work, but the 5's were over a third of your list.
Putting Steve with Bob and Joey 😬
Jimmy Bullard should be in here
Think Rick will definitely be more annoyed at the fact you spelt his name wrong 😂😂😂
and........where do you come in on this list?
It’s fucking wild THE DART ISNT EVEN MENTIONED HERE
No Brad Dahkle? He’s second only to George Bryan.
Rick should be a 4. Yes he does shoot in the 80’s but he is a very good golfer.
I think I deserve to be on this list. Just being honest. I’m guessing a lot of people just don’t know me yet. That will change by the end of 2024. Great video Luke!
Brad and Kwon vs George and Wesley. I wanna see it
How about Taco New Zealand.
Good job. Pretty accurate I think.
I’d give James Robinson 3.5 or maybe 4. He has gotten pretty good. Definitely can challenge par at difficult courses. Golf Sidekick can’t hit driver at all and mostly misses fairways with his 1 and 3 irons, so I’d put him at 2.5.
No rating for remec?
What would make naming the top dog easier is for all the RUclips golf creators to get official handicaps. That will allow us followers to track their improvement, and compare our own game to theirs...would also make 18 hole comps more fair playing of their handicaps...just saying
With the exception of Grant and George. They all have vanity handicaps. Luke, Micah, Steve, Bubbie, FP range between 4 and 10 handicaps. They all cheat their scores and edit out there horrible shots. That’s why none of them break 75 in tournament play.
I think Micah is a Four Star. Grant is not far behind George. I would rate them 1A and 1B.
Nooo way Jose, u craaaaazy. You think Grant would also be able to make the cut at a PGA event? 😂
He beat George and almost beat Wes on the same course that George made the cut!@@LeszzK
There is this one guy. You've probably heard of him. His name is Luke Peavy. Lol. What's up, cuz.
Group III has a very, very broad range of golfers.
Maybe I can make the one star list next year...😂
Nobody would disagree with Number 1 Golfer. George is a pro level player as a side gig lol
Where are the ForePlay guys?
Bubbie a 3? Dude get outta here, Bubbie is a 10 handicap at best.
Best 10 handicap in the world then. He is a 5/6
@@LeszzKyou’re high af. Bubbie sucks and doesn’t follow the rules of golf
@@LeszzK Nah. We are talking about average score over 18 holes here. You honestly think Bubbie averages around a 77 over 18 holes? I would guess closer to a 81-82 average.
The Dod King just posted a video saying he’s leaving RUclips to play college golf.
Some of these are waaaayyy off, Crossfield is like a +2 golfer and you have him at 3 star??????
You did Steven Quesadilla bad, bro
Josh is 3 star.
Kyle Berkshire is at least a 4! dude just shot 3 under at trump national!!!
Steve is an elite putter, George is beating a PGA pro in match play consistently, Kyle is the long drive Goat, Rick is better than Matt and Bubbie in stroke play, Kyle would smoke Martin in stroke play, in summary these ratings are about as reliable as Google Reviews 😂
Nice work on the compilation though 🎉🎉
Edit: DOD King retired bruh
Martin when he is playing seriously shoot around and under par on a good day.
I think DOD king trolled us all
🤔 George
It would be really hard to argue with your list. I feel it is really solid. And like you mentioned, some of these guys fluctuate depending on practice, travel, etc. And btw, if you ever really need to give someone a 1 star, feel free to use my name in that spot haha. Good luck in Feb, it's gonna be exciting.
not a fan of Kyle, but he is much better than 3 star. he is 4 or 5 star. Dude puts up under par rounds at tough courses, and i've never seen a round in the 80's from him.
Micah being a 5 star is kinda insane
Set it up! I’ll play!!!!!!!!
no way Kyle is a 3 star
My goal for 2024 is to make it on one of these videos! Been watching your videos for a long time brother!!
You forgot Brad Dalke and Ben Hadden - definitely 5 Stars, as well as AJ Pujols (3 or 4 stars).
Rick Shiels*
Maybe go with guessing handicap instead of stars...also i told you months ago to collaborate..why aren't you making it happen?
No Brad Delke, no respect!