How Did the Preseason Top 25 Teams End Up Doing???

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 25 янв 2025

Комментарии • 199

  • @ScottFisherCFB
    @ScottFisherCFB  2 дня назад +3

    Thank you to MyBookie for sponsoring today's video:
    Link: mybookie.website/joinwithFISHER50
    Promocode: FISHER50
    Promocode description: Up to $1000 Welcome Bonus + $10 Casino Chip

    • @Ejw5
      @Ejw5 5 часов назад

      MIZ-ZOU
      Who here is a mizzou fan

  • @hummushero9428
    @hummushero9428 День назад +141

    Gotta love those 15th year QBs 😂

    • @hyper_7467
      @hyper_7467 День назад +4

      13-10 😂😂😂

    • @hyper_7467
      @hyper_7467 День назад +2

      @ “you can’t claim a national championship without winning ‘the game’ -woody Hayes, Ohio state hall of fame head coach who got 3 natties and a record of 205-61-10.

    • @hyper_7467
      @hyper_7467 День назад +1

      @@LaMotte420 also let me know who has more natties? Conference championships? Leads rivalry? Longest streak? Current streak? Wins?

    • @jucool5
      @jucool5 День назад +41

      @@hyper_7467 Comment is about a Utah qb and you post three comments about Ohio State yall are obsessed😭

    • @hyper_7467
      @hyper_7467 День назад

      @ nah we just take good care of our kids. Notice how u went from “national championship” to “this is abt Utah” real quick. It’s okay lil bro stay doin lil bro things. 13-10

  • @Giancarlo-l3z
    @Giancarlo-l3z День назад +58

    As a FSU fan, I knew we weren’t going to be as good as last year but man, I didn’t expect us to not even make a bowl game.

  • @sedatedsith
    @sedatedsith День назад +33

    I like the 15 year quarterback comments. Funny stuff, Scott.

    • @Ilovefootball1109-v4t
      @Ilovefootball1109-v4t День назад +3

      It is pretty darn close as a Cowboys fan myself.
      Edit: It is true for Cam rising (AKA Horse Mane Hair) too.

  • @calebleeson5662
    @calebleeson5662 День назад +15

    Beating that many top 10 teams in one season is historical. Being the first to do it too, go bucks🌰

  • @chethammer
    @chethammer День назад +21

    Alabama vs Michigan might have been the weirdest game I've ever watched. It wasn't the team that wanted it most that won. It was the team that wanted it least that lost. You could tell that neither team wanted to actually be there.

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 День назад +1

      That feels so true bama literally and more turnovers than yards at a time in the second question it was a so bad it’s good type of game

    • @thomasb.smithjr.8401
      @thomasb.smithjr.8401 День назад +3

      Despite the wins over Ohio State and Alabama, Michigan still didn't crack the season's last Top 25 - AP or Coaches. Opt outs likely make it difficult to truly gauge the non-CFP schools as the mid-bowls have become nothing more than glorified scrimmages.

    • @MaizeBlueMichigan
      @MaizeBlueMichigan 3 часа назад

      I disagree. Michigan had significantly more fight in them. They were yelling and getting hyped before the game and you could tell they had more energy.

  • @1320_ikimasho
    @1320_ikimasho День назад +38

    This is why preseason top 25 is generally a waste of time. Mostly hype, and false expectations. The problem is "optimism bias" ~ the tendency to view teams how someone _wants_ to see them, instead of how they actually are.

    • @rewing84
      @rewing84 День назад +4

      Agreed

    • @rexblade504
      @rexblade504 День назад +12

      Also a lot of SEC bias. Rank as many SEC teams as they can to inflate their SOS

    • @SurferRC
      @SurferRC День назад +5

      And why SOS is not legit until they stop using these rankings!!

    • @tannerorth7027
      @tannerorth7027 День назад

      why does it matter

    • @SurferRC
      @SurferRC День назад +2

      @@tannerorth7027 because it makes SOS opinion not fact

  • @squigglyline2813
    @squigglyline2813 7 часов назад +4

    They guessed well with GA, OsU, Texas, ND, & Oregon.

  • @InsensitiveLout
    @InsensitiveLout День назад +6

    As Michigan fans, we knew there was going to be a step back after losing so many players and the majority of the coaching staff following the previous season. However, I don't think many of us had any idea how truly bad the QB situation was, and that it would take more than half the season for the new defensive coaching staff to hit their stride. Pre-season, the general consensus prediction was 9-3, as it was well known going in that Tex, Ore, and OSU were loaded. That obviously didn't happen. So yeah, without question, M was heavily overrated at the beginning of the season.

    • @72scholato
      @72scholato День назад +1

      Connor Stallions was a BIG loss.

  • @TOUGHBOY_Ruffian
    @TOUGHBOY_Ruffian День назад +11

    Michigan fan here and even when they revealed the top 25 i thought we were way to high given none of the major players from the natty team where there and we lost most of the coaching staff. Essentially we were starting a rebuild with just a hand full of pieces returning from the natty team. If they where going to rank us we should have been no higher then 15 given the situation

    • @missingbuck
      @missingbuck День назад +2

      Amid all that, Michigan had 2 massive upsets. I remember the Alabama game, I said the way UM upset Ohio State I went with the Wolverines and BOOM, it happened again. The Wolverines should return to form in 2025. I got to ask you though, did you see Edwards’ downfall coming? I did not expect the backup (Kalel Mullings) to outplay 7.

    • @TOUGHBOY_Ruffian
      @TOUGHBOY_Ruffian День назад +1

      @ surprisingly yeah I did see is fall off because aside from a big run here and there he was a weak 2nd back to Corum. I’d hoped he would step up but his struggle was not a shock atleast to me. Mullings was a nice surprise and I’m more surprised now that he wasn’t the next up after Corum

    • @rbzae5023
      @rbzae5023 День назад

      @@TOUGHBOY_RuffianI sure hope both of them get drafted but idk if it will happen

    • @WeLoveSheroneMoore
      @WeLoveSheroneMoore День назад

      @@missingbuckHe fell off bc of our OL; He was a 2nd wind rushing rb with a catching threat. When he loses an OL, he cant breaks tackles or hit guys

    • @rickjohnson2299
      @rickjohnson2299 День назад +3

      Michigans biggest loss was Conner Stallions.

  • @jimsmith8797
    @jimsmith8797 День назад +10

    To be fair ohio state Los to Oregon by 1 on the road. And then smoked their ass in the playoff. So yes Michigan best ohio state. No one besides Michigan fans care now.

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 День назад

      I bet other teams that don’t like Ohio state care, which basically includes every big ten team and every team they beat in the cfp

    • @jimsmith8797
      @jimsmith8797 День назад +4

      @ oh well. Don’t matter. Who has the trophy?

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 День назад

      @@jimsmith8797 what does that have to do with my statement?

    • @kingpanda4571
      @kingpanda4571 14 часов назад

      ​​@@jimsmith8797orgeon is gonna get there revenge trust😤

    • @iomibestlefty
      @iomibestlefty 11 часов назад

      Are you f&#kn serious!! More than any other oregon obviosly elliminated ohio st, in a credle sport anyways!!: i dont give a f&%k if oregon got ohio st at home this year!! Next ohio will get it!! Boise went in there and l only ost by 2, and that was their omly loss!! Bit for good measure we saw ohio st get vaporized week 12 in a loss thats measured in its histotorical significance!! And if thats not enough, oregon marched out the next week and beat #3 penn st for a big10 title!! Why even have conferences if even they cant iron anything out anymore!! You know what why even play a seaon if 10 of your final 12 played one or another during a 12 week season and obviosy that didnt iron anything out!!i thats 10games right there bud! It seens to be of far more logic to make thiose ones count instead of the ones on weeknights at 10pm in mid january? In fact how long until society realizes they were beat at shell game and still buying the " high stakes collision" in octiver when georgia goes to texas! Yet 7weeks later society is buying " premium heavyweigh matchup with evrything on the line!! Yet in reality all you need do is look and youll see its georgia and texas again!! But whats most staggering is only 13hours later its revealed on a 2hr candyass espn mega event that their was georgia and texas again!! And theres society buying still buying this embarassing stain and now debating if a f₹&cking 3loss alabama should be playing for a national championship!! There was.not one interesting matchup matchup, that had more value than a bob ross episisode their entire 12week season!! Its so obvious! Dude three of the four power5 conference championship didnt even need to be played!!

  • @tannerchristenson07
    @tannerchristenson07 День назад +5

    Do away with the preseason top 25 poll. It gives waaaaay too much influence on late year rankings. Rankings shouldn't come out before week 6

    • @andycockrum1212
      @andycockrum1212 16 часов назад

      You act like they won’t still have sec bias. The difference will be we’ll only have 6 weeks to set the record straight instead of 12

    • @jordandennis6794
      @jordandennis6794 10 часов назад

      We'd still have SEC bias. SEC teams could play FCS schools all year and they'd still be stealing all the top spots

  • @nonameking4874
    @nonameking4874 День назад +1

    Scott keep uploading. Your channel is doing good brother. I’m a fan from San Francisco

  • @thomashugus5686
    @thomashugus5686 7 часов назад +2

    Greetings from a very proud very happy BUCKEYES FAN!!

  • @WT-Sherman
    @WT-Sherman День назад +4

    Ann Arbor Rodents - where are they ?

  • @mecahhannah
    @mecahhannah День назад +6

    GO BUCKEYES NATIONAL CHAMPIONS ❤🎉

    • @rokellc
      @rokellc 5 часов назад

      GO BLUE!!!

  • @rewing84
    @rewing84 День назад +1

    This is the best channel for college football opinions

  • @zphs7219
    @zphs7219 3 часа назад

    7:55 you slick with that jab, 15th year 😂😂

  • @bernardmayles6564
    @bernardmayles6564 День назад +4

    Media overvalued SEC, like they do every year. 12 team playoff finally proved it

  • @bradball
    @bradball 8 часов назад

    Gotta love those 15th year quarterbacks.
    Overall a good video… missed some context on a couple of teams…. Such as a quarterback going down with a season ending injury or a coach/coordinator leaving midway through the season (i.e. Utah #12 which had both)… but overall a fun watch.

  • @MuhGlassRibs
    @MuhGlassRibs День назад +1

    People have to realize that the AP pollsters play the rankings for matchups they want to write/talk about.

  • @JackieDurall
    @JackieDurall День назад +4

    So indiana only losses were against ohio st. And notre damw😆

    • @kingdrake5054
      @kingdrake5054 11 часов назад +4

      coincidentally the only two real teams they played

  • @mecahhannah
    @mecahhannah День назад +9

    NATIONAL CHAMPS GO BUCKS!❤🎉

  • @AJEmrick-i8q
    @AJEmrick-i8q 19 часов назад +1

    Michigan starts at #9 and finished unranked. The furthest fall in NCAA

  • @XTotter5505
    @XTotter5505 6 часов назад +1

    I don’t care what people say, CHANGE THE PLAYOFF SEEDING SYSTEM. THE TEAM WE BEAT IN THE BIG-10 CHAMPIONSHIP GETS SMU AND BOISE STATE AND WE GET THE NATIONAL CHAMPIONS IN THE FIRST ROUND

    • @cannon3267
      @cannon3267 5 часов назад

      go to an 8 team, no bye playoff. there is not, has never been, and likely never will be a 9+ ranked team that is championship caliber. and this year proved that #8 SEED can win it all, but that is because a couple of conference champs were artifically elevated into bye seeds.

  • @Ilovefootball1109-v4t
    @Ilovefootball1109-v4t День назад +1

    I’m an Oklahoma State fan and Oklahoma fan, (1 parent went to each) and both obviously had terrible seasons, and on the way back from OU getting blown out by South Carolina, I said I would rout for UCO the rest of the year.

  • @Gh0stRider
    @Gh0stRider День назад

    I would love to see how the internet talking heads did with their pre season picks vs. what actually happened. Which one was most accurate and which one was least accurate?

  • @drumusic5665
    @drumusic5665 День назад

    How did you mention Miller Moss but not the QB change? 😂 still a good video js

  • @laughingstock1991
    @laughingstock1991 День назад

    Can you rank the punters whose teams finished top 25?

  • @rcl1955ca
    @rcl1955ca 12 часов назад

    I thought one of the big reasons if not the biggest reason Ok.State was such a disappointment was on the HC/OC. They ran Gordon almost 100 fewer times than they did the previous season (maybe he was banged up) which meant they had to rely too much on 10th season (sic) QB Alan Bowman which was never a good plan. I find myself disliking coordinators who feel the need to have elevated passing games, turning away from what got you a good record the season before which, in this case, was ground and pound.

  • @Slumshady412
    @Slumshady412 День назад

    Video idea: what went wrong with the Pitt Panthers this year

  • @JaySeyko
    @JaySeyko День назад +1

    15th year QB is crazy 😂

  • @mitchell8940
    @mitchell8940 День назад +3

    As a Michigan fan, if you're going to have highs and lows, you might as well have the highs at the end of the season.
    Right or wrong, It does give you a sense of optimism. Beating Ohio state and Alabama are big wins any year, especially ending a disaster of a season 😅

    • @chethammer
      @chethammer День назад

      Legit curious, did you watch the Michigan bowl game?

  • @markmoseley5083
    @markmoseley5083 10 часов назад

    "Alabama whined more than anybody to fet in the playoffs." I love this.

  • @SteveAllen-x2m
    @SteveAllen-x2m 8 часов назад

    Considering Ohio state had a semi-pro team it turned out like it was supposed to.

  • @johnbarton41
    @johnbarton41 День назад +7

    Alabama was overrated they are going back to the Shula days. And I couldn't be happier. Down goes Bama

    • @frederickgraves1340
      @frederickgraves1340 День назад

      Yea yea whatever

    • @johnbarton41
      @johnbarton41 23 часа назад +3

      @frederickgraves1340 I guess being beat by Vanderbilt wasn't an eye opener. Can't wait for this season to start so my point will be valid and you might not be in denial

    • @loganerb3952
      @loganerb3952 7 часов назад

      @@johnbarton41it cracks me up… years OSU lost to Purdue or Iowa was met with all sorts of mockery from everyone else (and deservedly so tbh)
      But the second Bama loses to Vandy… All of a sudden Vandy is a good team that should be ranked in the top 25 😂
      The SEC bias in the rankings is so crazy and apparent it’s nuts

    • @johnbarton41
      @johnbarton41 6 часов назад +1

      @loganerb3952 Alabama can't do what they have been doing for decades collecting all the best talent and letting them ride the bench. That's why Sabin left he knew his ways were over. Hell the SEC only has a few decent teams the conference as a whole is sub par.

  • @Justin1021
    @Justin1021 День назад +1

    2 things never changed this year. Penn State can't beat Ohio State and can't win it big

  • @scottturner1504
    @scottturner1504 День назад +1

    Michigan might have beaten us but we both flopped like hell we beat our rivals only difference Michigan got a participation trophy

  • @OliverLawrence-b5m
    @OliverLawrence-b5m День назад +3

    I’m so glad Alabama did terrible this year

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 День назад +1

      If terrible is 9-4 in the with best or second best conference (depends on your opinion) then you’re perception is extremely skewed.

    • @TheMitmiter
      @TheMitmiter 22 часа назад +3

      @@KingE34 3 losses to unranked opponents in 1 year sounds awful.

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 21 час назад

      @ who’s your favorite team? And no it isn’t probably like 70% of the nation has that statline

  • @TotallyNoires
    @TotallyNoires 6 часов назад

    Did I hear "15th year quarterback"??

  • @scottrichards3587
    @scottrichards3587 День назад

    How about a bit of D3 coverage?

  • @SurfCityBill
    @SurfCityBill День назад

    Magical year in Boise!

  • @zackjalamani
    @zackjalamani День назад +1

    Ohio State Buckeyes won both inaugural national championships for 2014 and 2024 seasons, Wow!

  • @lindencamelback2305
    @lindencamelback2305 День назад

    I believe Penn State ended number 3, not 5. Next year will be similar.

  • @ogama843
    @ogama843 День назад +3

    As an Ohio State fan, I argue that the Buckeyes could be the winners of both the worst AND best season. But I am biased.

    • @theemsa3110
      @theemsa3110 День назад

      Yes the natty winner had the worst season

    • @cbjm36
      @cbjm36 День назад +4

      When you win the National Championship, you had the best season. Pretty simple.

    • @johnjenkins7497
      @johnjenkins7497 День назад +1

      I hated that Michigan loss…..but the Bucks had already got a spot in the playoffs and had a huge break before the playoffs started….they didn’t have to play the Big Ten championship game and that loss to Michigan gave the Bucks a kick in the ash…..

  • @jimmy5634
    @jimmy5634 День назад +1

    Mythagain Cheated

  • @miketoth7000
    @miketoth7000 День назад +1

    I was satisfied with the way Michigan's season played out. They were the most improved team throughout the year in my opinion.

    • @thomasprice1320
      @thomasprice1320 6 часов назад

      But not good enough to finish on top this year.

  • @midwestslim
    @midwestslim День назад

    talk transfers why not a better qb (like Mendoza ) for Mizzou.

  • @Ejw5
    @Ejw5 5 часов назад

    MIZ-ZOU
    Who here is a mizzou fan

  • @champagnekhas
    @champagnekhas 12 часов назад +1

    Someone explain how Miami starts 9-0 loses only 2 games to finish the season with the #1 offense in CFB and isn’t respected enough to make the playoff

    • @jordandennis6794
      @jordandennis6794 10 часов назад

      Have you've seen how terrible their defense was?

    • @champagnekhas
      @champagnekhas 8 часов назад

      @@jordandennis6794 sure I also seen how terrible every team in the playoff offense looked and how every game was a snooze fest

  • @benjaminholmertz4827
    @benjaminholmertz4827 4 часа назад

    Go Buckeyes!

  • @calebmigues
    @calebmigues 2 часа назад

    15th year QB 😂😂😂😂😂

  • @tylerove2495
    @tylerove2495 День назад +5

    Alabama did not whine that much to get into the playoff. It was mostly salty Ole Miss, South Carolina, and other historically mid-tier SEC teams (+ Paul Finebaum) who raised hell. Most Bama fans knew they didn't deserve it. Still, as Joel Klatt said, their resume was more impressive than SMU's. I feel bad for the team, because they mostly played well, but Milroe had to be the leading scorer for Oklahoma and Michigan in those games.

    • @rexblade504
      @rexblade504 День назад +6

      Bro this is some serious revisionism. Alabama was by far the biggest crybabies about not getting in. Y'all only quieted down when you got embarrassed in the Reliaquest Bowl

    • @tylerove2495
      @tylerove2495 День назад +2

      @ no real Alabama fan thinks a 3 losses is the standard, the 4th loss cemented it for the casuals. The goal for us is to win, not just to get in. Losing to Vandy, Tenn, and Oklahoma was proof that they wouldn’t

    • @closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0
      @closetglobe.IRGUN.NW0 День назад

      Damn Joel was right.
      Bama and ole miss losing or winning up north would've been much better either way.
      Too bad people scared the committee
      Hopefully won't happen next season

  • @RandyReneau
    @RandyReneau 17 минут назад

    The big spenders won. If you willing to spend

  • @JackieDurall
    @JackieDurall День назад

    Dame

  • @adambaum9732
    @adambaum9732 День назад

    Alabama had the worst season in all of the post Paul "Bear" Bryant years, Alabama should not have been ranked at all. Bama should not be ranked in the upcoming 2025 preseason poll, and I am a HUGE Alabama football fan. Our coach, Kalen DeBoer, needs to be fired, one absolutely disastrous season is enough evidence to terminate this obvious loser! Alabama will lose 6 or 7 games this coming year, so why wait for the inevitable disaster. Who would hire the Captain of the Titanic after its maiden voyage to the bottom of the sea?

    • @OhioOwns
      @OhioOwns День назад

      what do you mean, man, they had a cpl 2 and 3 win seasons before Saban got there lol

    • @adambaum9732
      @adambaum9732 День назад

      @@OhioOwns The team's performance in relation to skill level of the players, was a complete failure. If Saban didn't become a quitter, Bama would have had an undefeated National Championship season. The former "Saint" Nick Saban is now a bum in my opinion.

    • @MichaelJW72
      @MichaelJW72 День назад

      Ray Perkins, Mike Shula, Mike DeBose, and Dennis Franchione say hello. Mike Price says”it’s rolling.”

    • @KingE34
      @KingE34 День назад

      @@adambaum9732dang yall bama fans really are born on third base. I’m a Florida fan and I’d be happy with 9 wins a lot of years since urban left and were considered the 3rd or 4th best program in the sec. A man wins yall 6 titles in 12 years and now you wine because you’re only top 20ish in the country when there are fans of teams who don’t even sniff a bowl game for years? If I didn’t like Dixieland delight yall would probably be at a Georgia-ut level of hate for me.

    • @adambaum9732
      @adambaum9732 День назад +1

      @@KingE34 Bama has future NFL starters up and down the depth chart on both sides of the ball, Florida never had players like that, not even close. In a few short years, this will not be the case, Bama will have lost all of those blue-chip athletes.

  • @rtfootball24
    @rtfootball24 День назад

    Slow the hell down man

  • @nle94
    @nle94 День назад

    michigan had the best 8-5 season of all time

  • @lono3332
    @lono3332 День назад

    I love this new nil.