Jimin having THAT much tone up it that register is insane. Many can hit those notes, but sing them while maintaining a clear, full tone? Few? Barely any? man can do that.
And that they didn't really intend to train him to sing - he hung around outside vocal lessons and practiced on his own for a while. I'm glad he got vocal coaching & that he's never stopped developing his voice - he's worked so hard on it and we've benefited so much 💜
@@TheBlackcoffeeable what are you on about. he was not the only one with zero experience. jungkook had a tiny bit, but barely and vocal training. jin, jimin, and v had no training at all. jin was studying acting and had no intentions of singing, therefore he did not do any vocal training until bighit. taehyung auditioned by chance and like jin, didn't start training until bighit. jimin was attending a high school to learn contemporary dancing and never received vocal lessons till many many years after debut, so he was initially self taught. as for jungkook, he had a tiny bit of training and practice and later received lessons from bighit. i love v too buy no need to downplay the talent of the others just to make your bias look better
Jk's adlibs are phenomenal and V and Jimins harmonizing is god tier 💜 You'll love "Your eyes tell" but do the live version, it's similar to this one. Jimins vocals on that song are insane!
Jimin, I love him. His tone always amazes me eventhough I already know how amazing he already is. His voice is beautiful, so delicate and Clear 💖. I got into BTS because of him. 🫶💓💜
100% my favorite thing, even more than JK or Jimin singing solo, is when they're blending their voices together. It's one of the most beautiful things I've ever heard.
To be fair, back then Suga wasn't really vocally trained, so he kinda used a little bit of auto tune. But! In my baby defense, now he can SING a whole 2 hours concert!
To be even more fair, he could probably do it without autotune but it's a very monotone line anyway. It's harder to hold a single note without going flat/sharp, and he can't move around to give himself a physical outlet, so....
They all sound so good in this song. Jin and Jimin and Japanese songs have never failed to move me. When they sing their parts, it makes me emotional even though I don’t understand the words (yet). So so beautiful. Those two need to release solo Japanese albums fr.
One of my favorite things about BTS live stages is Jungkook's adlibs and harmonizing. It absolutely makes the song so much better. I love Jimin's parts in this song too.💜 Thanks for reacting to the live version Nathan!💜
Jimin has a unique voice for sure. This one was co-written by the Golden Maknae, Jung Kook. They were singing in Japanese. This was Live but was also during the pandemic, so no real audience at that time, sadly. It was probably broadcast on Japanese TV, I'm guessing.
I love their harmony with the string. It's such a beautifully sad piece, which reminded me of “Lie,” Jimin’s first self-composed song. (I hope you'll consider reviewing it as well.) Sometimes, I find it difficult to watch his performances of “Lie” because it's so painfully sad. And it was the same for him, as he once said, 'Lie might be a song that could kill me.’ Btw, I love your hairstyle!
I cant wait 😊 my Jimin nailed it. One of my favourite BTS song. OT7 vocal was amazing. Jin and Jimin singing Japanese are so angelical. Can not describe it. ❤
“Film Out” is one of my all time BTS favorites. They all literally killed it. Their pristine vocals, harmonizations, and adlibs. You should definitely check out “Lights”. Thanks Nathan! 💜
“They haven’t moved.” “They still haven’t moved.” 🤣 As much as I love seeing them dance, sometimes you just want their voices at full capacity. Love this song. 💜
wow, i love that you like Jimin's voice, i am also a fan of Jimin. Maybe you want to react to Jimin's introduction video 2023. It is more detailed information about Jimin's music, talents, achievements, personality and where he start from a rookie to a legend, you will surely love it.💜💜💜
I actually miss Jin since he is currently doing his military service. The way he sang every Japanese song is angelic. He is effortless in singing high notes. I questioned BTS capabilities before since I've been a fan of Boyband since the 90's. It feels like they are a copycat but hearing them singing live and the meaning of the lyrics on their songs turned me into a fan.
@@sc33h3o3 Enjoy them both. 🎉 I enjoy Louder Than Boomb, where I can hear Suga's deep fry vocal, which he only did there and Jimin's whispering strikes to heart directly.
I don't actually think Suga has effect on his voice. He sometimes raps "through his nose", so I always thought that this nasal sound is just one of his common technics when he does soft rap, especially when it is closer to singing. And when I think about it, when he really sings, he sings trough his nose most of the times, with exeption when he needs more powerful sound.
I don't think Suga is autotuned, simply because he sounds the same often singing live. JHope is the same. He has a quality in his voice that sounds autotuned. No one was more shocked than I to find that was his actual voice.
Jimin meu bebê das bochechas gordinhas, fofas ele realmente tem a voz linda como de um anjinho Por gentileza reage a música zero o'clock , tenho certeza que você vai amar Saudações daqui do Brasil !💜🇧🇷💜🇧🇷
Idk how many times I've watched this live performance. I think it was the 3rd time, when I finally recognized where I heard them sing the chorus, that "ooh-woo" from somewhere. It was from Lee Hyun's yt channel episode, where he was working for BTS backstage, he was jokingly conducting Jin & Jimin "vocalizing" & they were singing this part! I remember that part clearly bc of Jin's low register there. U would think it was V at 1st here, but it was Jin after all 😅 I really thought they were just randomly vocalizing there & harmonizing too but it didn't register to me it was this part lol
@@NathanWalters Came back from watching your cover of Fake Love! It was one of the best I've watched! Along with the metal cover of it lol u made it ur own version, great job!🫰also if u want to hear orchestraic sound or strings, I suggest Jin's Awake. Watch a live version, one from their concert, u will see live strings there & overall stage & performance looks majestic 👍
The vocal-heavy performances they do without dancing are some of my favorites. They can show off much more vocally than when they dance, and they don't need as much (or any) support from the track. A small note on their singing ranges - they're all (the vocalists anyway) able to hit some very very high notes. Jimin has the highest natural range, but at one point Jin actually had the highest effective singing range. He might have the broadest in terms of comfortable range... and V is a legit baritone who has sung a G5 live onstage - they sound different up there, but all of them have hit those highs. Their very different voices are fascinating. Jimin's timbre is so unusual that musicians are pretty much always fascinated by him. 😊 Which of them I personally enjoy most as a singer changes 😂
@@NathanWalters Here's the link sir; ruclips.net/video/XZtPna6SOOU/видео.html (BTS Crystal Snow live - Japan 4th Muster) and I still can't forgive the cameraman for not focusing on Jin during the triple high notes part.. 😏😅 Enjoy and Borahae! 💜
@@NathanWalters this is the live performance with the most views. You can hear Jin sing it, but the video is focused on JK, not him: ruclips.net/video/XZtPna6SOOU/видео.htmlsi=T4Gb8vEOPVYdXaUE This one is a Jin focus video (same concert as previous but different day @ 3:35): ruclips.net/video/VwZ0GvC0-jM/видео.htmlsi=cEPhTj0hm8DbptA0
I really appreciate when you tell us what notes they are hitting. I would love for you to listen to Crystal Snow. I have always wanted to know what note Jin sings in when he hits that triple high note. Jimin also does some high notes in that song too.
This song for me is so profoundly sad and beautiful... I cannot listen to Jimin´s crescendo followed by Jin without weeping. One of their highest achievements. I put that next to any other Grammy-winning pop song, and realize again why it´s worth it to try to make the deepest art we can reach. I have to add, Nathan, I am very appreciative of your response. This is a personal pov, but I sometimes see reactors breaking up the song so much with little pauses and comments on minor aspects, that the cadence and full intent of the song is diffused and virtually lost. I wonder what it would be like if it were possible to play it one time through so you get the whole flow, and then repeat with analysis. It would be out of respect for the whole entity and intent of the composition. These are my musings. So glad that you gave this a chance.
Jimin having THAT much tone up it that register is insane. Many can hit those notes, but sing them while maintaining a clear, full tone? Few? Barely any? man can do that.
For real! His voice is truly impeccable. Ain’t no one sounding like him 🤌🏼
@@bmstratton44 sure ☺️ no one sound like our angel. He is the one and only. ❤️
It's still so crazy to me that Jimin had no singing experience when joining BTS. Most of them didn't, but with his range it just amazes me.
And that they didn't really intend to train him to sing - he hung around outside vocal lessons and practiced on his own for a while.
I'm glad he got vocal coaching & that he's never stopped developing his voice - he's worked so hard on it and we've benefited so much 💜
@@evantesseract737yes and Jin to he never dance or singing before he joined BTS
🥱🥱🥱V was the only one with zero experience but you don’t see him making excuses
@@TheBlackcoffeeable what are you on about. he was not the only one with zero experience. jungkook had a tiny bit, but barely and vocal training. jin, jimin, and v had no training at all. jin was studying acting and had no intentions of singing, therefore he did not do any vocal training until bighit. taehyung auditioned by chance and like jin, didn't start training until bighit. jimin was attending a high school to learn contemporary dancing and never received vocal lessons till many many years after debut, so he was initially self taught. as for jungkook, he had a tiny bit of training and practice and later received lessons from bighit. i love v too buy no need to downplay the talent of the others just to make your bias look better
@@TheBlackcoffeeablehe is not the only one bro,Jin and Jimin too
About Yoongi's rap....Yoongi has a natural tone in his voice that makes it sound that he's having an autotune but he's not having any autotune.... ❤
The Jimin effect always makes us fall in love with his beautiful voice 💕🐥😍
Jk's adlibs are phenomenal and V and Jimins harmonizing is god tier 💜 You'll love "Your eyes tell" but do the live version, it's similar to this one. Jimins vocals on that song are insane!
You mean that live where they all are wearing green clothes? 😊
@@silviamunoz6863nope. There’s another Japanese song of them named “YOUR EYES TELL” he/she meant that song. Not another performance live of Film Out.
@@loa_2314 oh! Yes! Sorry I misread 😬 I know the song, I even watched the movies just to listening to it! 🤣
V's favorite song, You're Eyes Tell. 😊
Your eyes tell live performance but the with the white background
Jimin's voice is so beautiful and angelic
Jimin, I love him. His tone always amazes me eventhough I already know how amazing he already is. His voice is beautiful, so delicate and Clear 💖. I got into BTS because of him. 🫶💓💜
Jimin voice is national treasure ❤❤❤
My favorite performing song of bts ever. Jimin and Jin are soooo good on this one!
Jin and Jimin always slay in Japanese songs💜💜and yet they are so underappreciated
Love Jimin and Jk's voice in this live
I love Jimin’s voice also. He has just an emotional voice and would love to hear him sing a very sad ballad
We all do love jimin..and jimins voice his vocal range is amazingly crazy❤
100% my favorite thing, even more than JK or Jimin singing solo, is when they're blending their voices together. It's one of the most beautiful things I've ever heard.
Jimin in this live is so amazing! Can’t wait for tour reaction
To be fair, back then Suga wasn't really vocally trained, so he kinda used a little bit of auto tune. But! In my baby defense, now he can SING a whole 2 hours concert!
To be even more fair, he could probably do it without autotune but it's a very monotone line anyway. It's harder to hold a single note without going flat/sharp, and he can't move around to give himself a physical outlet, so....
He also just really liked the style for a while there. It was his thing 😅
@@evantesseract737 was fixing to say the same thing you beat me too it :)
7:26 Same that's always my favorite part and that note i can't also do that 😂 but jimin always nailed it.
Their Japanese songs just hit different! So beautiful.
JIMIN OMGG
They all sound so good in this song. Jin and Jimin and Japanese songs have never failed to move me. When they sing their parts, it makes me emotional even though I don’t understand the words (yet). So so beautiful. Those two need to release solo Japanese albums fr.
One of my favorite things about BTS live stages is Jungkook's adlibs and harmonizing. It absolutely makes the song so much better. I love Jimin's parts in this song too.💜 Thanks for reacting to the live version Nathan!💜
love your emblem photo :)
@@sc33h3o3 My profile picture?☺
Since you like string instruments and Jimin, I highly recommend Jimin's solo song Lie. Musicians always find it an interesting listen. :)
Lie is such a Masterpiece
Oh My God, our Jimin 😭😭😭
Thank you for watching this with us, Nathan... We really appreciate it 💜
Jimin’s voice so beautiful
One of my Favs! Jimin’s voice in Film out is simply beautiful and I love when he and V harmonize at the end. 7 amazing artists in one group! 🔥
Our boy jimin never disappoints no one can do it like him, jimin is love thanks and appreciate your reaction
Jimin's high note always amazed me.
Jimin, i love you!
Jimin is a unique and beautiful angel. 😍😇🧚♂️
Jimin has a unique voice for sure. This one was co-written by the Golden Maknae, Jung Kook. They were singing in Japanese. This was Live but was also during the pandemic, so no real audience at that time, sadly. It was probably broadcast on Japanese TV, I'm guessing.
❤ Jimin #JIMIN #JIMIN #JIMIN#JIMIN
Jimin 💜
I think you would enjoy Lights, Stay Gold (live) and Your Eyes Tell. Beautiful harmonies. Thanks for your reaction. This is one of my favorites. 💜
yours eyes tell, makes me cry one of my all time favourites.
@@akeliasmith8416 mine too. 💜
.also Crystal Snow.,
Crystal snow and let go too
Crystal snow
My boy jimin❤❤❤ his voice is so amazing❤❤❤
I love their harmony with the string. It's such a beautifully sad piece, which reminded me of “Lie,” Jimin’s first self-composed song. (I hope you'll consider reviewing it as well.) Sometimes, I find it difficult to watch his performances of “Lie” because it's so painfully sad. And it was the same for him, as he once said, 'Lie might be a song that could kill me.’ Btw, I love your hairstyle!
waiting. jimin did a great job and live is better than the audio.
I cant wait 😊 my Jimin nailed it. One of my favourite BTS song. OT7 vocal was amazing. Jin and Jimin singing Japanese are so angelical. Can not describe it. ❤
Are you blind or deaf jungkook is the one one background of there voice😂 he is there backbone😂
Sim, amo a voz do Jimin 😍😍😍
@@Jkforever-jknot always ,
i always prefer Jin and jimin's voices.
i like Bts songs..
But i only save Jin and Jimin's solos playlist in Spotify.
Suga does not do auto tune.he’s hates it
No doubt I also love his voice ❤
Jimin have unique voice ❤❤❤❤
“Film Out” is one of my all time BTS favorites. They all literally killed it. Their pristine vocals, harmonizations, and adlibs. You should definitely check out “Lights”. Thanks Nathan! 💜
the lyrics to this are so moving.
Mine tooo,love BTS ballads.🤎🤎
Jimin's voice is alway incredible i love it especially his line here my favorite high note👌💯
Jimin is my boy too, he´s very talented
I don't know why I like Jimin's voice, but I just like it. Jimin joined the military. I missed him so much that I came here.
i love your love for jimin cause SAME
Jimins voice is just truly incredible!! He blows me away every single time I hear his voice 🥺
If u love Jimin check filter;serendipity;lie live performance ❤❤
“They haven’t moved.”
“They still haven’t moved.” 🤣
As much as I love seeing them dance, sometimes you just want their voices at full capacity. Love this song. 💜
That's my favorite part of the song, too! Love Jimin and of course the 6 bangtannies!
This is a beautiful song and I am here for Jimin
Jimin will always be my forever artist😭 he’s incredibly good and amazing😭
Seriously!!
@@Jkforever-jkis there a problem?
His unique voice is incredible
@@Jkforever-jkkeep burning 🔥🔥
I also Thank that Names are beter , the Voice is unigue 👏👏😥👏
wow, i love that you like Jimin's voice, i am also a fan of Jimin. Maybe you want to react to Jimin's introduction video 2023. It is more detailed information about Jimin's music, talents, achievements, personality and where he start from a rookie to a legend, you will surely love it.💜💜💜
Jimin my man too❤
I actually miss Jin since he is currently doing his military service. The way he sang every Japanese song is angelic. He is effortless in singing high notes. I questioned BTS capabilities before since I've been a fan of Boyband since the 90's. It feels like they are a copycat but hearing them singing live and the meaning of the lyrics on their songs turned me into a fan.
Loooove the song ., they are amazing live 🔥💜 but Jimin voice so beautiful 🫶🏻
Jimin's vocals on Japanese songs hits different ❤ please react to crystal snow you will love it❤
It is always interesting to hear from someone who is really in the business. 👏
Next please Louder Than Bombs. 🎉
oh my god, yes maybe he's ready for Louder Than Bombs :)
@@sc33h3o3
Yes! Louder Than Bombs is a way much better than Film Out, isnt it?
@@friede. I think I like them equally :)
@@sc33h3o3
Enjoy them both. 🎉
I enjoy Louder Than Boomb, where I can hear Suga's deep fry vocal, which he only did there and Jimin's whispering strikes to heart directly.
I don't actually think Suga has effect on his voice. He sometimes raps "through his nose", so I always thought that this nasal sound is just one of his common technics when he does soft rap, especially when it is closer to singing. And when I think about it, when he really sings, he sings trough his nose most of the times, with exeption when he needs more powerful sound.
Yes, i love Yoongi's voice😊
I totally agree.
I love how Jimin's voice is delicate yet powerful
I can't wait to watch this! my fav film out live performance.
Jimin's vocals just really hits differently 🥹
I love Jimin voice so much it has so much depth emotions and feelings it's so ethereal
I don't think Suga is autotuned, simply because he sounds the same often singing live. JHope is the same. He has a quality in his voice that sounds autotuned. No one was more shocked than I to find that was his actual voice.
That's why i love watching their live and jimin hight notes everyone loves it! can't blame you nathan.
Jimin meu bebê das bochechas gordinhas, fofas
ele realmente tem a voz linda como de um anjinho
Por gentileza reage a música zero o'clock , tenho certeza que você vai amar
Saudações daqui do Brasil !💜🇧🇷💜🇧🇷
Idk how many times I've watched this live performance. I think it was the 3rd time, when I finally recognized where I heard them sing the chorus, that "ooh-woo" from somewhere. It was from Lee Hyun's yt channel episode, where he was working for BTS backstage, he was jokingly conducting Jin & Jimin "vocalizing" & they were singing this part! I remember that part clearly bc of Jin's low register there. U would think it was V at 1st here, but it was Jin after all 😅 I really thought they were just randomly vocalizing there & harmonizing too but it didn't register to me it was this part lol
Oh so cool. Thanks for sharing this
@@NathanWalters Came back from watching your cover of Fake Love! It was one of the best I've watched! Along with the metal cover of it lol u made it ur own version, great job!🫰also if u want to hear orchestraic sound or strings, I suggest Jin's Awake. Watch a live version, one from their concert, u will see live strings there & overall stage & performance looks majestic 👍
Don't go by hairstyle, go by their 7 very distinct breathtaking beautiful voices
The vocal-heavy performances they do without dancing are some of my favorites. They can show off much more vocally than when they dance, and they don't need as much (or any) support from the track.
A small note on their singing ranges - they're all (the vocalists anyway) able to hit some very very high notes. Jimin has the highest natural range, but at one point Jin actually had the highest effective singing range. He might have the broadest in terms of comfortable range... and V is a legit baritone who has sung a G5 live onstage - they sound different up there, but all of them have hit those highs.
Their very different voices are fascinating. Jimin's timbre is so unusual that musicians are pretty much always fascinated by him. 😊 Which of them I personally enjoy most as a singer changes 😂
Lovely reaction. Jimin's high notes are insane
Their Japanese song Stay Gold live performance is also great your gonna love it for sure.
That’s why we love and are sooo proud of all of them,specially my beautiful Angel Jimin,we miss you guys too.😍😘💜😇👍🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
Jin's voice is so angelic here 💜 full of emotions and feelings))
One of my top songs. So beautiful. All their Japanese songs are so amazing.
Can someone send Sir Nathan the link to their live performance of 'Crystal Snow' and Jin's triple high notes? Borahae!😉💜
Yes! Can you put the link here?
@@NathanWalters Here's the link sir;
ruclips.net/video/XZtPna6SOOU/видео.html
(BTS Crystal Snow live - Japan 4th Muster)
and I still can't forgive the cameraman for not focusing on Jin during the triple high notes part.. 😏😅
Enjoy and Borahae!
💜
@@NathanWalters this is the live performance with the most views. You can hear Jin sing it, but the video is focused on JK, not him: ruclips.net/video/XZtPna6SOOU/видео.htmlsi=T4Gb8vEOPVYdXaUE
This one is a Jin focus video (same concert as previous but different day @ 3:35): ruclips.net/video/VwZ0GvC0-jM/видео.htmlsi=cEPhTj0hm8DbptA0
ruclips.net/video/XZtPna6SOOU/видео.htmlsi=8Z_DWk5LSFFu6LTf this one isn't it
Love Jimin's voice in this song!!!
Your Eyes Tell. Another Japanese song that is great live
JK's lovely adlibs and stable voice, main vocalist indeed!
Theyre all great
In the group song every reactor repeats jimin part😂❤️
it might sound like that but suga is NOT USING autotune he just made a little effect to his voice during the rap💜
I love how you replay Jimin's part 💛
Jimin's voice 😘
The vocal line and the rap line nailed it
Suga doesn’t do autotune. That’s his real vocal. They can play they’re vocal
Our Seokjin’s voice versatility was amazing in this song!
I really appreciate when you tell us what notes they are hitting. I would love for you to listen to Crystal Snow. I have always wanted to know what note Jin sings in when he hits that triple high note. Jimin also does some high notes in that song too.
I think Jin's top note in Crystal Snow is a G5. I could be wrong, but I think it's an F, F#,G.
Now I want to go listen and check 😅
Restarting jimins part is so real of u😭😭
This song for me is so profoundly sad and beautiful... I cannot listen to Jimin´s crescendo followed by Jin without weeping. One of their highest achievements. I put that next to any other Grammy-winning pop song, and realize again why it´s worth it to try to make the deepest art we can reach.
I have to add, Nathan, I am very appreciative of your response. This is a personal pov, but I sometimes see reactors breaking up the song so much with little pauses and comments on minor aspects, that the cadence and full intent of the song is diffused and virtually lost. I wonder what it would be like if it were possible to play it one time through so you get the whole flow, and then repeat with analysis. It would be out of respect for the whole entity and intent of the composition. These are my musings. So glad that you gave this a chance.
Quien reconozca el gran talento de Park Jimin tiene mis respetos. Gracias por apreciar el talento de mi Jiminie.
My favorite live performance in terms of vocals. Just amazing.
Pure vocal talents-all of them!
Stay gold live performance next
You are going to fall madly in love with your eyes tell live it is a chef's kiss 💋 you need to hear this.
They have a mood 💜💜🤌🏻
Love Jimin and all of them!
日本語の曲を聴いてくれて嬉しいです。彼らの日本語の発音は完璧。
Next jimin filter live performance 😊
Jinnnnnnnn y Jimy 👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏👏
Jimin tem a voz de anjo 🥰🥰🥰
I love jimins voice!!!react other jimin song
Jimin y su voz angelical ❤❤❤❤ mi favorito también ❤❤
Let's not forget Crystal Snow and Autumn Leaves!
They always sing life, they don’t auto tone.