Kelly's Tigers | Yugoslav “Tiger” movie props

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 8 сен 2024

Комментарии • 238

  • @christineshotton824
    @christineshotton824 Год назад +70

    I am very pleased at the positive things said about the attempts to mock up Tigers for the cinema.
    Because if there's one thing we don't need, it's no negative waves, Moriarty.

  • @carbo73
    @carbo73 Год назад +32

    Great! I LOVE Kelly's Heroes. I've even been in Vizinada, the Istrian village representing "Clermont", the French village with the Tigers and the gold. It's quite intact, and fun to walk through the same streets that Kelly, Oddball, Big Joe and the rest!

    • @mario.-_-.
      @mario.-_-. Год назад +8

      Every year there is a special WW2 event inspired by the movie.

    • @carbo73
      @carbo73 Год назад +2

      @@mario.-_-. yes, I've seen some videos. But when we visited Croatia, I have to search and identify the village only from the footage and looking for pictures of most of the villages in Istria, mostly for the bell tower, which was clearly of Venetian style, so it was most probably Istria.

    • @SuperErikRoss
      @SuperErikRoss Год назад +1

      That sounds like fun !!!!

  • @Ulani101
    @Ulani101 Год назад +37

    The Kelly's Heroes Tigers were pretty convincing, as long as the cameras were kept focused high on the superstructures, and the guns weren't fired. The running gear was a dead giveaway, however, along with the lack of recoil on the main armaments.
    Full marks for the engineers who created them.

    • @MrSteve420b
      @MrSteve420b Год назад

      So was the diesel exhaust smoke 😀

    • @RichardDCook
      @RichardDCook Год назад

      The dead giveaway to a T-34 conversion is always the turret being too far forward. Did any conversions move the turret back? That would have been extremely expensive.

    • @dallesamllhals9161
      @dallesamllhals9161 7 месяцев назад

      @@RichardDCook Wheels!

    • @dallesamllhals9161
      @dallesamllhals9161 7 месяцев назад

      YUP! But the night attack looks GREAT!

  • @MikeKnell2884
    @MikeKnell2884 Год назад +181

    Tigers in the Kelly's Heroes are some of the best "conversions" I've seen. Even with all the details that are out of place for Tigers, inherent to the T-34s used as the base, they were more than enough convincing for me. The whole production level for that movie is top notch with great action scenes.

    • @MrKersey
      @MrKersey Год назад +16

      Those T-34/Tigers still looked better than the one in "Saving Pvt.Ryan"

    • @gerardoramoncesarreynaldo9469
      @gerardoramoncesarreynaldo9469 Год назад +4

      When it was first released, I was already in high school and had seen what the Tiger 1 looked like. Needless to say, I was impressed when these conversions appeared in that movie. The producers really made the effort to come up with a near-real version.

    • @Panzergraf
      @Panzergraf Год назад +8

      Absolutely, and especially when compared to many other war movies at the time (like Patton and Battle of the Bulge), that just painted Wehrmacht markings on an M47 or something and called it a Tiger.

    • @stewartmillen7708
      @stewartmillen7708 Год назад

      "The Battle of the Bulge" movie should have used the same prop specialists...what, using Chaffees as Shermans, and (I believe) M47s as King Tigers? Awful.

    • @wolfehoffmann2697
      @wolfehoffmann2697 Год назад +1

      @@stewartmillen7708 Yes, but Battle of the Bulge was made at a time when Chaffees and Pattons were available in large numbers on the cheap for making movies. The only running German armour left from the war was in active Syrian military service. There are so many more things wrong with that movie other than the tanks. The list is a mile long, at least, and the tanks are near the bottom of the list.

  • @genericpersonx333
    @genericpersonx333 Год назад +140

    In fairness to Oddball and crew, the number of tanks in 1943-44 which didn't have thinner armor on the rear could be counted on one hand!

    • @jlvfr
      @jlvfr Год назад +2

      The correct thing to say, I think, would be "it was a little less thick in the rear"... which still made it better than most tanks!

    • @MichalKaczorowski
      @MichalKaczorowski Год назад +2

      Rear armor of Tiger was only 20mm thinner than front armor but in point blank range even 50mm gun would penetrate it ;)

    • @lisandro2485
      @lisandro2485 Год назад +2

      ​@@MichalKaczorowski thats a myth too, if You see at the rear of a Tiger or Panther you see it's angled.
      Even at point blank You gonna need a high velocity proyectile in order to penetrate.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад

      Fury shows them going for the rear. I think a 76 mm Sherman had to be within 500 yards to penetrate a Tigers front. Not a place where you want to be.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +4

      There was the story of a Greyhound taking out a Tiger with multiple shots from the rear.

  • @johnkelley9877
    @johnkelley9877 Год назад +34

    Kelly's Heroes is one of my favorite movies because of the story and the vehicles, especially the Tiger. Thanks for sharing this and the information about Yugoslavian military movies.

  • @robertmorton38
    @robertmorton38 Год назад +18

    I thought that the effort made to put together a number of ersatz-Tigers for these films certainly raised the bar as far as making a war movie look a bit more authentic. With "Kelly's Heroes", the zimmerit finish on the sides of the hull and turret was the icing on the cake. I first saw this movie when I was thirteen years old...I have it on DVD. I occasionally watch it and I can recite the lines work-for-word. I am in my sixties now. I still love it.

  • @andrewphillips8341
    @andrewphillips8341 Год назад +24

    "Can't convince Bovington to loan you theirs?" Caller: "Oh common guys, please! I be careful"

    • @flitsertheo
      @flitsertheo Год назад +1

      I assume the Bovington Tiger wasn't in running condition around 1970 as its original engine had been cut to pieces for display. It only got back to running condition in 2003 after a new engine had been installed.

  • @vukacimovic9196
    @vukacimovic9196 Год назад +8

    My grandfather actually was one of the pilots who represented the planes in užička republika

  • @AbsolutelyStupidGoofball
    @AbsolutelyStupidGoofball Год назад +12

    BABE WAKE UP!!!!!
    NEW TANK ENCYCLCOPEDIA VIDEO DROPPED!!!!

  • @joeharris3878
    @joeharris3878 Год назад +7

    When I saw Kelly's Heroes in 1970 ,
    I was amazed to see an actual tiger tank.
    After seeing so many ww2 movies and tv
    using postwar us army medium and heavy tanks
    painted Grey with a black crosses for German tanks
    In every show, it was certainly surprising. It wasn't
    until the world wide web and youtube that I found out
    about the Yugoslavic movie and learned. I always
    thought they were 1940s tiger tanks.

  • @tasman006
    @tasman006 Год назад +58

    Kellys Heroes was one of my favourite war movies growing up. One of the main reasons was the tanks. But the main reason was the historical accuracy over other Hollywood war movies. Maybe you could also do a vid on them.

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад

      Although never could work out what Tigers were doing in the Lorraine near Nancy. There were none anywhere near the Lorraine.

    • @fazole
      @fazole Год назад

      @@lyndoncmp5751
      Not "officially" but they were protecting tons of gold in the story, so it is plausible.

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад +1

      @@fazole
      Hehe, well no because all the Tigers were sent to Normandy and the few that escaped Normandy headed towards the Belgian border, not the Lorraine. The Tigers in the Lorraine in Kelly's Heroes were so far out of the way 😁.

    • @richardarcher7177
      @richardarcher7177 Год назад +1

      @@lyndoncmp5751 TBH it was probably easier to mock up a Tiger on a T-34/85 hull than try and recreate a Panther or Panzer IV - besides in the 1960s the Tiger had the reputation, heck it still does - just watch Fury. The presence of the three Tigers in the village adds to the odds against the gang and makes their achievement all the greater. In all honesty if they were escorting the lorries carrying the gold from the bank they'd more likely assign Sd.Kfz 234s as escort - faster on the roads the trucks would be using anc carried a 7.5cm main gun making them a lethal proposition even for Oddballs Shermans but doesn't have the same impact as a Tiger in the public consciousness.

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад

      @@richardarcher7177
      Haha yes I totally get the reason why they chose Tigers. Just pointing out it wouldn't have happened. Then again nor would riding off in a truck full of gold. How on earth would they have gotten away with that 😂
      I love the film though.

  • @MrNeil-qs5fo
    @MrNeil-qs5fo Год назад +67

    Bovington Tiger is being retired very soon due to cracks in its frame so will only end up being a static display! Hopefully it get a few more movie appearances .

    • @zamecksaryja
      @zamecksaryja Год назад +12

      "Hanz! Ze Tiger ist KAPUT!!"

    • @ThreeOaks79
      @ThreeOaks79 Год назад +1

      ​@@zamecksaryja a konigstige from der furrersondesug😂

    • @judgedeath3
      @judgedeath3 Год назад +8

      I doubt it, bovington tank museum was displeased with the strain and the things they required it to do that pushed parts too hard and said they would never let it do this again.

    • @dirkmahlberg9612
      @dirkmahlberg9612 Год назад +2

      The Australian Armour & Artillery Museum work on a Tiger 1. Here on You Tube

    • @truereaper4572
      @truereaper4572 Год назад +3

      Where have you heard this from? I looked it up and haven't been able to find anything about it.

  • @gajtrifkovic5299
    @gajtrifkovic5299 Год назад +21

    13:13 This scene is a dramatization of a real event that took place on 13 June 1943 near the village of Ocrkavlje (16 km W Foča), Bosnia and Herzegovina. Heavy Weapons Company of the 2nd Proletarian Brigade (Yugoslav Partisans) acted against orders to bury or destroy all cannon and saved one 37 mm AT gun and 5 shells. When a column of "Panzergruppe Sterr" appeared from the direction of Foča, the gunners waited until the tanks stopped at a destroyed bridge and then opened fire. According to the message sent by German Major Poche to HQ of 118th Jaeger Division, one tank was rendered immobile by enemy fire, while the other was put out of commission due to engine damage.

  • @Bayan1905
    @Bayan1905 Год назад +3

    The Tiger mock ups were sure better than the repainted American tanks in Patton and Battle of the Bulge.

    • @nickmitsialis
      @nickmitsialis Год назад

      the irony being that Spain HAD actual German armor (Pz mk IVs, Stgs, halftracks) in their army but got rid of it just before those films were made because they got US tanks to replace them. This was before there were 'collectors' willing to buy and restore authentic historical vehicles.

    • @nickmitsialis
      @nickmitsialis Год назад

      And the best 'looking' mock up job I ever saw in a movie was the M41 Walker Bulldog. In the movie, "Is Paris Burning", they were made up to look like Panther tanks. They looked pretty good but they were so fast and 'springy' that it was obvious they were considerably lighter (23 tons) than the Panther (45 ++ tons)

  • @juliusdream2683
    @juliusdream2683 Год назад +4

    They had to do what they had to do. Good job.

  • @okiljognjen
    @okiljognjen Год назад +4

    "Kelly's Heroes" my all time favourite war movie !!! since i was a kid until today, and soundtrack song , epic :)

  • @LeveretteJamesClifford1955
    @LeveretteJamesClifford1955 Год назад +5

    I saw Kelly's Heros when it came out in 1970 and using my memory from when I was a young boy building a 1/76 scale Tiger, I thought the ones in the movie were real! And when I became a serious 1/35 armor builder and knew the difference, I compared the ones made for Saving Private Ryan and the ones from Kelly's Heros and found the Kelly's Heroes much more solid and scary looking. By the way, in Fury, while the real Tiger was used, a partial wooden mock up was made for the scene where Fury shoots holes in the Tiger's rear. That was much better than doing fantastic digital imaging. That wooden mock up was purchased by Australians for their tank museum and great effort was made to turn it into an almost perfect wooden replica, to sit by their real Tiger.
    And, a number of Russian tank enthusiasts who were also mechanics, made an all aluminum Tiger that was drivable for the Movie The White Tank (White Tiger?) but before it could be brought to film, it developed problems and could not be used. Not to be deterred, the builders made repairs and solved the problems and they applied zimmerit and made it appear completely real even to someone stating next to it, unless they tapped it. The the sound gave it away!

  • @jlvfr
    @jlvfr Год назад +79

    "Kelly's" has better tank fight scenes than Fury...

  • @dependablepaul
    @dependablepaul Год назад +6

    Nice presentation! Thank you. I worked as part of the tank crews on Courage Under Fire. We used surplus Australian Centurion Tanks with a lot of welded steel plate to make our Abrams tanks. They looked pretty good, most visible difference was the Centurion has one less road wheel. The tanks were later used on the film Mars Attacks. Another interesting fact is when Denzel Washington is talking to Matt Damon at the base swimming pool is that the tanks in the background shot are painted full size profiles of the Abrams made out of plywood with a man standing on a ladder behind the plywood so his upper torso looks like he is standing in the commander's hatch. Those scenes were filmed outside of Austin Texas and it was cheaper and easier to make the profile fake plywood tanks than to transport the modified Centurions from El Paso where we filmed the battle scenes.

    • @blackplatypus6755
      @blackplatypus6755 Год назад +1

      I remember a magazine article in the 80's here in Australia that some millionaire bought about 80 ex army centurions that were to be scrapped and was selling them for about AUD$8,000 each, - I can still see the picture of rows of them in my head on his property - I remember I wish I had $8000 - I also Iremember hearing that a few of those centurions ended up in the hands of movie makers., I wonder if they are the same Centurions?

    • @dependablepaul
      @dependablepaul Год назад +1

      @@blackplatypus6755 can't remember the name of the Australian company that sold the tanks to Fox 2000 but they bought 13 and the owner of the company along with two of his employees came with the tanks to teach us how to run and maintain them for the full length of the production. Their aim was to keep at least 9 up and running until filming was over. We only had two crap out due to blown clutches.

    • @blackplatypus6755
      @blackplatypus6755 Год назад

      @@dependablepaul It must be the from the same group of centurions - must've been fun to work with tanks without having to be in the military, at the same time, also thanks alot on the info about the fake tanks on mars attacks,.

  • @michaellynes3540
    @michaellynes3540 5 месяцев назад +1

    The T-34-85 mockup of the Tiger tank in “Kelly’s Heroes” and “Saving Private Ryan” looks like the Porsche Tiger.

  • @staticaleel5068
    @staticaleel5068 Год назад +1

    Honestly the fact all these convincing tiger mock ups from Kelly’s heroes and saving private Ryan being T-34’s just amazes me. The prop work that went to tricking me into thinking a T-34 is a proper tiger is nothing short of impressive.
    100 times better than Patton did it.

  • @sirdarklust
    @sirdarklust Год назад +66

    That was interesting. I always thought the Yugoslav and Soviet Tiger mock-us were "good enough" to not make me laugh and keep things "real," unlike the German Pershings in the terrible Battle of the Bulge. Yeah, nothing like Pershings vs. Chaffees in the Belgian desert... Take care.

    • @bv2623
      @bv2623 Год назад +10

      They were not Pershings but Pattons if I recall correctly. But yeah, being Belgian myself, I was wondering were this Ardennes desert was when I watched Battle of the Bulge for the first time... though there is a small piece of "desert" in Belgium. It's close to the Dutch border and is called "lommelse Sahara" ;)

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +4

      I recently rewatched Battle of the Bulge. It was not as bad as I remembered. Shaw and Sevalis were kind of crazy.

    • @sirdarklust
      @sirdarklust Год назад +2

      @@rogersmith7396 Yes, Shaw, his sidekick, Savales were good. However, the movie is overall just too absurd.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +1

      @@sirdarklust Well its actually pretty true to the events and to small unit combat. Charlie Bronson is in it. Probably makes more sense then Patton.

    • @nicktrueman224
      @nicktrueman224 Год назад +3

      Yeah those were a eyrsore to anyone familiar to German armour.
      I thought Kelly's Heroes did a great job during a period in which most movies didn't even try to make a realistic tiger amongst other vehicles.

  • @davidmccann9811
    @davidmccann9811 Год назад +4

    I always enjoyed seeing the M-47's portraying King Tigers in the 1960s 'Battle of the Bulge' movie.

  • @vracarac2120
    @vracarac2120 Год назад +1

    The Kastle keep (1969) is also filmed in Yugoslavia with same tank "Tiger" prop.

  • @codebasher1
    @codebasher1 Год назад +1

    Being the best movie of all time, it was a sheer joy to see the superb beautiful effort put into making these Tigers. Even as a child at the time it was wonderful to finally see a WW2 movie that had German tanks that actually looked like German tanks as it was so rare..

  • @matthewcuratolo3719
    @matthewcuratolo3719 Месяц назад

    Wow man, so many positive waves! Maybe we can’t lose! You’re on!

  • @Stefan-xu5nd
    @Stefan-xu5nd Год назад +6

    Thanks for covering our country yet again!

  • @user-is6pz7nk3u
    @user-is6pz7nk3u Месяц назад

    It was always fun to see this vismod Tigers in a movie.

  • @andreimorar5249
    @andreimorar5249 Год назад +8

    Great video! I'd love to see more videos of this kind covering what other counties of the former Eastern Bloc did in order to create their own German tank props for war films (like in Poland, Romania, the USSR etc). Each of them seemed to have come with their own...soldutions în addressing the issue

  • @jollyjohnthepirate3168
    @jollyjohnthepirate3168 Год назад +1

    Always with the negative waves Moriarty. Always with the negative waves this early in the morning.

    • @rumblehat4357
      @rumblehat4357 Год назад +2

      “Why don’t you say something positive once in a while?”
      “Crap.”

  • @sebbonxxsebbon6824
    @sebbonxxsebbon6824 Год назад +2

    I say Hollywood should manufacture some Tiger tanks for movies.

  • @gordoncordon9779
    @gordoncordon9779 Год назад +3

    Thank you for saying JNA instead of YPA, also nice how you did some pronunciations correctly

  • @sunrayuk
    @sunrayuk Год назад +2

    I always liked the American Halftracks which were done up to look like German halftracks you see them a couple of times in kellys heroes but only in the back ground

    • @rumblehat4357
      @rumblehat4357 Год назад

      They did that nonsense in Rat Patrol. Ugh.

  • @TellySavalas-or5hf
    @TellySavalas-or5hf Год назад +4

    And in "The night of the generals" (1967) this conversion tank was also present.

    • @robertmorton38
      @robertmorton38 Год назад +1

      If you look closely, the mocked-up Tiger tanks are actually put together on the hull of the British Comet tank... Just sayin'.

  • @buckstarchaser2376
    @buckstarchaser2376 Год назад +1

    10:05 I haven't previously seen something that suggestive outside of a cartoon.

  • @CarbonatedLithium
    @CarbonatedLithium Год назад +5

    I've seen Kelly's Heroes a number of times, and I'm pretty sure I remember Oddball saying that they put some piping on the barrel in order for the Germans to think that they are sporting a much higher caliber gun. So, that 'explains' the Sherman having a bigger gun than usual in the movie.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +1

      He was trying to make them think it was a 90 mm or 3 inch which would appear on Pershing. The 76 was considered very good as the TDs had them and in fact the 75 mm was'nt bad. It had a higher explosive round than the 76. Of course the 17 pounder could take care of any other tank.

    • @sergeantmarcusstackerM1903
      @sergeantmarcusstackerM1903 Год назад

      Ironic Germans often targeted allied tanks with the big guns more often than not

  • @Graham-ce2yk
    @Graham-ce2yk Год назад +8

    Thank's for covering this, Kelly's Heroes has long been a family favorite and I've found rememberances of the film all over the internet and the gaming community...
    Will we see this as a full article?

  • @davidnicholas7516
    @davidnicholas7516 Год назад +1

    I can remember being a kid and hearing about "Kelly's Heroes" when it came out. It was pretty much standard at the time that if they told you the tank was a Tiger, it'd be a Sherman with a German cross painted on the side of it. This was the case in "The Big Red One" for example. However, when I saw "Kelly's Heroes" it did look a lot more like a Tiger than in previous movies. The position of the turret looked wrong to me: it's too far forward proportionally to the rest of the tank. On the Tiger the turret sits essentially in the middle of the hull; with both the T-34/76 and the T-34/85, the turret is further forward on the hull, which is longer relative to the width of the vehicle. Anyway some years later a friend told me that if you looked closely at the suspension you could tell it was a T-34/85 with a lot of stuff built onto it: the Tiger's suspension was very unusual, being only used on it and the Panther. Everyone else took a look at the design and said, "Typical Germans. Slightly more efficient, but way more moving parts and hell to fix."

    • @RichardDCook
      @RichardDCook Год назад

      Yes the turret location is the big giveaway. Did anyone ever go to the expense of moving a T34 turret back? If it's even possible.

  • @josephwolosz2522
    @josephwolosz2522 Год назад

    Kelly's Heroes was probably the best Tiger with the exception of Saving Private Ryan.
    You can tell with the Turret placement and shape.
    Plus the Wheels and tracks look different.
    But still effective effects.
    Knock it off with them negative waves!

  • @garycamp3389
    @garycamp3389 Год назад

    Kelly's Heros is my favorite movie of all time!!! I am avid historian.. those 2 tigers were really close. Nice job they did.😮😮😮

  • @JamesLaserpimpWalsh
    @JamesLaserpimpWalsh Год назад +2

    They looked alright from head on. It was quite easy to tell from the side tho. Cheers.

  • @stevew6138
    @stevew6138 Год назад +1

    I must admit, when Kelly's came out, I was a young teen and the "Tiger's" fooled me.

  • @RichFoster-zk3jo
    @RichFoster-zk3jo Месяц назад

    The amount of detail on the commander's cupola and hatch (early production version) of the Kelly's Heroes "Tigers" is astounding. Compare them to photos of the real thing and videos of "Tiger 131" in The Tank Museum. I wonder why they went to so much effort.

  • @robertgraves2321
    @robertgraves2321 Год назад

    "When we go into battle, we like to play music, very loud! It kind of calms us down...."

  • @dondemers7439
    @dondemers7439 Месяц назад

    I love the video !!! I actually made a 1/35th scale kitbashed model of the Kelly's Heroes Tiger-34.

  • @guykurtz422
    @guykurtz422 Год назад

    gotta luv a plywood tank !

  • @garfieldsmith332
    @garfieldsmith332 Год назад

    Give the Yugoslavian producers credit for doing a great job making the T-34s resemble Tiger Is. When I saw the film I thought they were real Tigers as I new the basic shape of the tank. I did not know about the suspension until later and realized they were mockups. Better than using American tanks in the "Bulge" movie or trying to pass of a Sherman painted grey and with a Swastika as a Panther.

  • @johnelliott7375
    @johnelliott7375 Год назад

    Quite clever and the budget comparison to others is adequate but small. Great video and good afternoon and day to you all,God bless.

  • @AnthonyGenualdi
    @AnthonyGenualdi Год назад

    My all time favorite movie. Thanks for sharing.

  • @rogersmith7396
    @rogersmith7396 Год назад +2

    They fooled me in Kellys. The other movies not so much.

  • @milosvojinovic5710
    @milosvojinovic5710 Год назад +1

    Hey Hey Hey!
    Big mistake at the end of video!
    In Kelly's heroes, Donald at the beginning of introduction with Clint Eastwood is saying that his tanks are "modified" to resemble 76mm, but they are in general ordinary 75mm guns. He says that his crew did it in order to make Germans fear them more. So at least, here, we have justification for having Sherman with old turet and 76mm gun

    • @VIC-20
      @VIC-20 Год назад

      Clint, is the correct spelling

    • @milosvojinovic5710
      @milosvojinovic5710 Год назад

      ​@@VIC-20 yes. That's right. I will correct it..

  • @SuperErikRoss
    @SuperErikRoss Год назад

    Yea definitely raised the bar

  • @paulwee1924dus
    @paulwee1924dus Год назад +1

    Aah I also spotted this converted T-34/85 in the war movie "The Uprising" from 2001. And I saw T-34s without Tiger make-up in "The night of the fox" (1990) and "Force 10 from Navarone (1978).

    • @TellySavalas-or5hf
      @TellySavalas-or5hf Год назад +1

      Oh yes! George Peppard played Standartenfuehrer Vogel in "The night of the fox"

  • @Magpul_Germany
    @Magpul_Germany Год назад +1

    Would love to see the Merkava and Namer variants on Tank Encyclopedia!!!

  • @robertfogelberg7538
    @robertfogelberg7538 Год назад +1

    Nice video and niece tank Spielberg did the same in save private Ryab seam a bit shorter than a real tigre

  • @RichardDCook
    @RichardDCook Год назад +1

    Nowadays with CGI they could use any tank, painted a solid colour with reference dots at critical points, and CGI any tank they wanted over it.

  • @davvvvo
    @davvvvo Год назад +1

    14:55 i seem to recall that Clint said they received unmodified T-34-85's.

  • @leeroyloke8415
    @leeroyloke8415 Год назад +6

    Tankova Brigada (1955) - "Tank Brigade" Czechoslovak film: ruclips.net/video/of1jM1x8QpU/видео.html
    Considering the time this film was made and the fact it's a Czechoslovak film, I think the German vehicles and tanks shown in the film could be authentic WW2 German vehicles, including the Panzer IVs and assault guns.

  • @waynescarpaci5332
    @waynescarpaci5332 Год назад

    Going from memory I think the 'Tigers' used in Kelly's Heroes were conversions of US M107/M110 SP artillery piece chassis'.

  • @charlesburgoyne-probyn6044
    @charlesburgoyne-probyn6044 Год назад +2

    One scraps the one's not destroyed at the end of WW2 only to find decades later that there aren't any availabile to go into action on a film set

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад

      And are worth millions to collectors. 50,000 Shermans, 60,000 T 34s.

  • @lyndoncmp5751
    @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад +2

    I love Kelly's Heroes. It's my absolute favourite war film, but I always wondered what Tigers were doing in the Lorraine. None were ever there. Even those very few Tigers that escaped Normandy were far to the north, nearer to the Belgian border. North of Reims, near Saint Quentin and Marle.
    Also the 'Leibstandarte' (ie Schwere SS Panzer Abteilung 101) Tigers in France never had red turret numerals on the 1st Kompanie tanks and none had the old style dustbin like commanders cupola and Feifel air pre cleaners.
    Well just saying. Good effort in Kelly's Heroes regardless 👍

    • @CarbonatedLithium
      @CarbonatedLithium Год назад

      The SS man in the movie was from the 1SS as shown by the Key symbol on the Tiger. We can only imagine that they were on special assignment to guard the gold. Of course, the incident never happened, so it's easy to pretend that Tigers were in Lorraine for the purposes of thwarting Oddball and company!

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад +2

      @@CarbonatedLithium
      Well, as I said, the Leibstandarte (1st SS) Tiger company personnel in spring 1944 and some even before, (Kelly's Heroes takes place early September) were reformed into Schwere SS Panzer Abteilung 101.
      1st SS lost its organic Tiger company in 1944 and instead an independent Tiger battalion, SS101, was formed out of its personnel such as the well known Michael Wittmann etc. It was technically under SS Panzerkorps command and no longer organic to 1st SS, although it kept it's Leibstandarte 'key' symbol.
      All the SS101 Tigers were sent to Normandy. They were all lost in Normandy or on the retreat soon afterwards so I can't even "imagine" a scenario where three SS101 01 Tigers were in the Lorraine.
      Love the movie though. It's still very enjoyable. 👍

  • @megalostylo2043
    @megalostylo2043 Год назад

    Essentially, we can call them Toyer Tanks!

  • @massafelipe8063
    @massafelipe8063 Год назад +2

    I hear "Neretva march" I click like.

  • @aleksazunjic9672
    @aleksazunjic9672 Год назад

    Germans actually did use StuG III and even Pzkw IV in Yugoslavia, but later in the war (1944) . Some of them were captured and pressed into Yugoslav service after the war, but only for the short time (early 1950s) . Yugoslav partisans did have various anti-tank guns, m0stly captured Italian 47mm, German 3.7 and 5.0 cm. but there were also Soviet 45mm, British 6pdr etc ... Allied guns came mostly from 1944 onwards when partisans gradually transformed into regular army .

  • @bobkohl6779
    @bobkohl6779 Год назад

    Just look at the road wheels, always the tell tale

  • @davidbrennan660
    @davidbrennan660 Год назад +5

    The JNA had a lot of German military equipment to destroy.

    • @PeoplecallmeLucifer
      @PeoplecallmeLucifer Год назад +1

      well yes, they didn't have parts to repair it so ... let's use it for one last show

    • @agrameroldoctane_66
      @agrameroldoctane_66 Год назад

      No, almost nothing. Except helmets and small arms.

    • @aleksazunjic9672
      @aleksazunjic9672 Год назад +1

      Very few things were actually German. Some FlaK guns, helmets and that is about it. Rifles were Yugoslav made licensed Mausers, as were MG-42s (Zastava M53).

  • @kodama44
    @kodama44 28 дней назад

    considering when it was built, and the budget they had, this is the best T34 Tiger ever made. Those who shot this movie seem to have really cared to make it look good ; not only the feature of the tank itself, but also how to shoot them(angles, composition etc.etc.).
    (Actually they had 3 Tigers, I remember)
    Private Ryan Tiger had to be better considering the date of production… or am I too asking?)

  • @diegodicastelletto
    @diegodicastelletto Год назад

    in Saving Private Rayn the Tigers are the same models used in Kelly's Heroes

  • @Condottiere1978
    @Condottiere1978 Год назад

    Excellent documentary, l was waiting for this one for ages

  • @raymondyee2008
    @raymondyee2008 Год назад

    Damn interesting.

  • @LeveretteJamesClifford1955
    @LeveretteJamesClifford1955 Месяц назад

    A more believable fake Tiger has been made by someone in the USA. They figured out a way to take the whole hull and turn it around so that there is more space up front allowing for the driver and radio operator's hatches to be in the right place, then they also replaced the tension drive wheels with a sprockets. I suppose this also necessitated new tracks and they are certainly not the tracks from the Russian tanks. Of course, that I am writing is based on some authoritative-sounding post on a forum, but I have seen a video of the tank rolling over the countryside in Kentucky as well as it being in the movie Come Out Fighting. It is possibly more accurate to say that this was made from the ground up, as I have seen a video about a fake Panzer 4 that was made from ground up to be rented to movie companies. It was also made easy to break into half for easy transportation.

  • @Willysmb44
    @Willysmb44 Год назад

    When I was a kid, I remember some adults at a hobby shop getting into a heated argument over if those tanks in Kelly's Heroes were original German Mark VIs or not

  • @marcelgalban9088
    @marcelgalban9088 Год назад

    very good video coongratulations

  • @billevans7936
    @billevans7936 Год назад

    Would take 200 trucks haul all that gold...but still....its a movie

  • @eltenda
    @eltenda Год назад

    Very interesting video and subject!

  • @nanab256
    @nanab256 7 месяцев назад

    15:35 like they said in the movie-this is fake barrel only make it looks like firefly

  • @jeffleach2668
    @jeffleach2668 Год назад

    I’m really happy that they’re at least making an effort to have German tanks look like German tanks. Still haven’t gotten over the movie makers using Patton tanks for the German tanks in a movie about Patton the man with George C. Scott. I think that was the one. My friend, who I spent hours and hours building model tanks together as kids, actually did his thesis in college on that movie and this issue. I guess it scarred us.😂. He said his professor didn’t really get it.😔. In our late 50’ he said he was happy that Saving Private Ryan used real German Tigers unlike the old days. Had to break it to him that if you looked closely that the wheels weren’t right for a real Tiger. On a positive note I told him to watch Fury if he wanted to get a look at the only running Tiger left in the world in a movie…….at that moment. Hopefully there will be more someday…….

  • @kenmazoch8499
    @kenmazoch8499 Год назад

    until the t-54/55 mock-ups from saving private ryan and other recent films, the yugoslav ones from kelly's heroes were the best. and kudos for mentioning that at close range, the 76mm sherman could take out a tiger.

  • @davey7452
    @davey7452 Год назад

    Another movie with T34/Tigers is a Night of the generals staring Peter O tool in 1967 scene involving destruction of a Warsaw.

  • @dasboot5903
    @dasboot5903 Год назад +1

    A two Polish "TIGER" mock-up tanks, they were adopted from T-34/85 soviet era tanks, for the purpose of filming Polish TV series called: "KOLUMBOWIE" at the part #4 called: "Oto dziś" [Here it's today] @16:16, which was based on the author Roman Bratny famous book: "KOLUMBOWIE - rocznik 20-ty".
    ruclips.net/video/28xsfS8zTOs/видео.html
    The story itself it was all about the Polish Underground National Army (Armia Krajowa = AK) fighting with German Wehrmacht in the ruins of Warsaw, during the Warsaw's Uprising in the summer of the 1944. Filmed was made during the summer of 1970. It was part number 4.
    Those "TIGERS" were attacking Polish barricade, pushing in a front of their armour the large group of civilians .... to provoke Polish fighters to give up their fight and position of their stronghold !!
    Those scenes were filmed in Warsaw in the Old Praga District, on the Mala Street.
    During the brakes in filming .... I was jumping on the painted plywood, which was put on the top of the real armour of T-34 tanks.

  • @ihatecabbage7270
    @ihatecabbage7270 Год назад +3

    I mean, the T-34 did a great job and started the trend of using cheap surplus as replicas for movie prop. Even a tank enthusiast knows the limitation, of having highly accurate mockups, is a appreciation of efforts to make it look like the real thing or the very least tried, compared to the "I don't care' attitude and straight up using Pershing tanks as German tanks without any changes, a simple slap of the German cross, YEAH GOOD ENOUGH!!!

    • @flitsertheo
      @flitsertheo Год назад

      The irony is that all the effort to change a T-34 into a Tiger wasn't actually necessary. The Germans used captured Russian vehicles including the T-34 in areas where these would not be mistaken for enemy tanks such as Yugoslavia.
      All they needed to do for the movies was repaint these T-34s in German camo colours (not grey), add numbers and Balkenkreuze and maybe as a final touch a text indicating which unit captured this "Beutefahrzeug".

  • @karlbraun5382
    @karlbraun5382 28 дней назад

    Yes "such positive waves" The best war film by far.....except obviously having no real Tigers at hand the film had to make do with a mock up. another line I loved was referring to the Tiger tank in Yank hands "its a piece of junk....leaking fuel everywhere"

  • @darkovidic6885
    @darkovidic6885 Год назад

    Similar tigers were shown in the Soviet film series Liberation

  • @garyneilson1833
    @garyneilson1833 Год назад +2

    I think the tiger mockup from Saving Private Ryan is still on display at IWM Duxford land warfare hall

  • @notmenotme614
    @notmenotme614 Год назад

    99% of movie watchers are not tank fans or hobbyists. Therefore every tank looks the same to them. They wouldn’t know the difference between a M47 Patton and a Tiger Ausf.B. Or that the panzer VI Tiger Ausf. E had overlapping and interleaved road wheels.
    So there’s no need for the film producers to make the tanks look historically accurate if most movie watchers wouldn’t know or even care.

  • @SamuraiAkechi
    @SamuraiAkechi Год назад

    Cool. How about other SocBloc Tigers, like from Liberation, Czterej Pancerni i Pies, Night of the Generals?

  • @slobodanmitic1354
    @slobodanmitic1354 Год назад +1

    Most part of the video is about yugoslav partisan movie Neretva, however many "viewers" talk only about the Kelly's Heroes part. I love the movie, but did you even watch the video at all, or just commenting about the title screen?

  • @SabastianMoran
    @SabastianMoran 27 дней назад

    August 12, 2024 - As a big fan of the film "Kelly's Heroes" ( I have several copies of the film on DVD and on thumb drive), and as an avid Military history student. I have to admit that I am embarrassed by the fact that I believed the "Tiger" tanks were the originals in the film, and not mock ups. I have a number of books with great tank illustrations and photos. I owe a gentleman who posted on a forum that the tanks were mockups, and I contradicted him saying they were obviously real Tigers. He never replied and he probably rightly put me down as being "uninformed" and possibly an idiot. Apologies to him wherever he is.😊

  • @FurryCruz
    @FurryCruz Год назад

    The Chaffes I think it is in Patton makes me ill everytime I see that movie. The T34/76 was captured and used by the Germans but with history we can follow exactly where they was used.

  • @akizeta
    @akizeta Год назад

    Diegetically, Oddball's Shermans actually used a short-barrelled gun; Oddball put a length of pipe on the guns so that they'd look like the long-barrelled weapons. Exegetically, I have no idea which Shermans were used in filming the movie.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +1

      Oddballs tank was a 76 mm. The others were 75mm.

    • @akizeta
      @akizeta Год назад

      @@rogersmith7396 Is that so? It's been a while since I saw the film last; I only recalled the extensions.

    • @rogersmith7396
      @rogersmith7396 Год назад +1

      @@akizeta He wanted them to think he had the 90 mm of the Jackson or Pershing.

  • @ALPINA527
    @ALPINA527 Год назад

    I have seen and touched TIGER 131 @ Bovingdon tank museum a couple of years before they restored the running gear and made a Frankenstein maybach engine out of numerous spare parts.

  • @LeveretteJamesClifford1955
    @LeveretteJamesClifford1955 Год назад

    The Tiger could be penetrated from the sides and the rear where the armor was thinnest. That is a fact. In WW2 studies showed where to hit the Tiger E to knock it out and when Tank Destroyer crews and Tank crews of Shermans learned that, the idea was to know a Tiger was coming and get into position to ambush it from the sides of backs. Only an 88 or a 17pounder (British gun) could penetrate the frontal armor of a Tiger in NW Europe. Don't know about the Soviet tanks. After reading numerous books on American armor, most being personal experiences, when M10 Tank Destroyers learned about the Tiger soft spots in Italy, they discovered that knowing how to take a Tiger out also took the fear away of knowing a Tiger was coming. According to another source, Clint Eastwood bought the fake Tigers and had them taken to Oklahoma where he enjoyed driving them around for years. Not much to get in your way in much of Oklahoma!

  • @Strelo
    @Strelo Год назад

    One of the Shermans used in Kelly's Heroes still exists and is standing in front of one of the museums in Novi Sad. I don't know what the fate of the other Shermans is, but I've seem a couple Shermans around the country. Don't know if those were the exact ones used in the movie, though.

    • @dragankostic9253
      @dragankostic9253 Год назад

      Na poligonu na Manjaci nekada kasarna Dobrnja kod Banja Luke tamo je bilo groblje starih Sermana, Patona i kamioni Jems, sluzili su kao mete za gadjanje a zatim rezani u staro gvozdje.... zalosno, mada su ih imali pojedine kasarne kao eksponte....

  • @plasmadrone3123
    @plasmadrone3123 Год назад +1

    YEEESS!! :D :D
    Please more of movie prop vehicles, even the one that are not converted :D :D
    P.S.: 08:56 - 09:18 I don't think it's "Kelly's Heroes". What is the title of that movie? O__O

  • @havareriksen1004
    @havareriksen1004 Год назад

    in all fairness, using T-34s painted gray and with german Balkenkreuz in movies to act like german tanks isn't that far fetched. The Wehrmacht did indeed use many captured tanks, and they used a german modification of the T-34, named T-34 747(r). They were used all across on the Eastern front it seems the germans used primeraly light tanks in the role of fighting partisans.

  • @oliverpetroski4205
    @oliverpetroski4205 Год назад +1

    The Shermans from the "Kelly's Heroes" are now in a museum in Serbia, painted with hippie colours.

  • @youtrubadur
    @youtrubadur Год назад

    The funny thing is that historical films are not reconstructions of a period of history but the imagination of that period, so why would tanks be their own "original replica"?

  • @polishcosmonaut6324
    @polishcosmonaut6324 Год назад

    4:44 thats true

  • @MichalKaczorowski
    @MichalKaczorowski Год назад +4

    "Kellys Heroes" even it's (anti)war comedy heist movie is in my opinion far mor realisic than "Fury".

    • @lyndoncmp5751
      @lyndoncmp5751 Год назад +2

      Yep. And far more entertaining and more rewatchable than Fury or Saving Private Ryan (which ironically turns into a kind of Kelly's Heroes remake).