Mindset Of Parents Regarding Property | How It Varies Depending On Children Gender| Family Series 06
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- #DaughterSon
#propertydispute
#indianparents
#amitsangwan
#9911702005
#parentsreact
#parentingtips
#parenthood
#parents
#indianparenting
Sir, You are the only person on the earth who has the guts to show mirror to people with double standard,people intentionally or unintentionally are doing the same mistakes.
All girls who r capable should fight for their rights . Remember U r not against ur brothers but u are paving ways of equal right for ur brothers' daughters.
@THE ZOLDICS parents spent all most same expenditure to both gender..so..if they spent on dowary..they equally paid as gifts..to there daughter in law..in fact they will pay more to daughter in law by giving support in many ways...so no complaint...thanks
@THE ZOLDICS all should b fairly calculated ..... for both. very small calculation ... isn't it ? Dowry exits because girls do not get their share of heritage.
No Stamina to fight against them, No more expectations from them, No more hope, 😭 😔.
how can you compare property value with measly dowry sum...dumb lady
This is mostly impossible for most women as men in India are not so understanding it will make the relationship between her and her father/brother really bad when they face each other in court and in Indian mentality image and responsibility is only considered to be on women's shoulders.This is why women don't go to court.
I am lucky that my parents divided property equally among son and daughter. And even after marriage I live with my husband and kid in my ancestral home. My brother has no issues with it and my in-laws are very supportive to taking care of my parents responsibility during their last days.
Ashiana,Bhiwadi per ek video Bano Sir....wahan lena chahiye...budape ke liye
Parents ka agar ek ghar hai ...wahan ve apne ladke ke sath rehtai hain....usko bech kar behan ko dena mindset mein nahi hai.... parents ke baad bhi
@@sunitasuraj7569 acha yeh bhi hota hai ?
@@tejigill8062 ,I don't get your question
It's good that parents divided property equally among son and daughter.
Real question is that the daughter who received property from her parents ensured that her in laws property also got divided amou her husband's siblings 😂
Old parents are the reason of family issues...they create differences between siblings
I always wondered why senior citizens are not happy in this society, this video has given insight to what's happening in almost all the families. You have really hit the nail in the coffin 🙏
Very true. When parents discriminate on the basis of financial conditions of their children and give more to the weaker one it creates misunderstandings and harsh feelings towards parents. It should be divided equally.
Seriously u are the social reformer..
Gender bias is deep rooted in North Indian society which needs to be questioned..
Great work..
Absolutely true...favortism of parents create bitterness among kids ...parents are the reason who create rift among kids
Sir, I am 35 year old lady, last month my mother asked me to sign NOC on ancestor property.. It was so sudden I didn't have time to think. I signed and felt hurt. Though my brother was against it. But still .. Papers were signed.. it was so shocking, I never wanted anything from the property but the mere satisfaction of calling that my own home.. Now it feels like I don't have a father's home anymore..
Extremely sorry to hear that. Unfortunately most women are kept under the impression by their parents that they are fair, and daughters believe it until suddenly parents betray their daughters. And the daughters still take years to understand the truth. The heights of the parents' hypocricy is that the parents still expect their daughters to care for them when they are in need. Someone once told me that it is propaganda spread by selfish parents that they love children more, but in reality children love their parents more than their parents love them. Their love is unconditional, parents love is always based on the expectation of getting something in return. Now I have started to believe it
As a jaat girl, I'm also facing this.In each conversation since childhood we r conditioned that girls who demand property share are bad girls.But after marriage we don't get anything in sasural readily or have to wait till your partner passes away( which is very unfortunate in itself).
Ab bad daughter bhi nahi ban sakte but rights ke liye nahi khade ho pane n rishton ko khone ka dard pareshan karta hai.
Kash Hume school bhejte hue parents ye na bolte ki tumme aur tumhare Bhai me hum koi farak nahi karte, tum dono barabar ho, kyunki hum kabhi barabar the hi nahi, na kabhi honge
Husband mostly in our culture take descision regarding purchase or sale of property on his own or with his parental family, wives are not included in such practice, even if she is contributing financially, isiliye lagta hai- har jagah dhokha hai apna ghar Kahan hai
At 37 years of age I bought my own apartment with hard money and lots of struggle. When I moved here with my daughter, first time in my life I realized what is the meaning of home..
Very true 👍
Everyone talks about rights, no-one talks about responsibility
These true hard facts r hidden under the carpet by our society. This is never discussed in our society .
Bold decision to make a video on this bitter truth. Most of the elders above 60 will not accept but actually they are doing it. Thank you Sir. Keep guiding us all
बहुत सही कह रहे हैं आप, मां बाप के गलत निर्णय बच्चों में बहुत क्लेश देते हैं
You are so true and honest. My in laws have sowed the seeds of bitterness between my husband and his brother only to favour and elevate my jeth's economic conditions. It's is bitter truth of society that younger generation is more mature , understanding and empathetic than the older one. Sometimes I realize that our older ones are more kalashi/ kalesh premi and they poison the relationship equation of younger siblings.
Right
So true!!
Yessss, veryyy true
I was planning to show this video to all the oldies of my house......fir socha gallian to fir mujhe e pdni hai.....kahenge aya bda hmko sikhayenge ab ye
Sir let me tell you case of my family
My grandparents (both alive) has 5 children(2son ,3daughters)
My father started job at 18 but my uncle died at age of 30. He died unemployed. My grandparents spend all his wealth on marriages their daughters include selling of plot which purchase in their fertile time besides give more preference to my late uncle thinking my dad to be worthless but the contrary my fathers also handover all his savings from time to time(ie FD maturity and so on).
My father is now left with no wealth neither purchse any land to fulfill my grandparents lavish endeavours.
However my grandparent has their own house but we don’t. For now we are staying with them.
Now the dynamics is like
My father feed my grandparents
And in exchange grandparents let us allow to live in their house.
The sad part is that my father were able to create much wealth but due to his soft corner he let them all his money to grandparents and they foolishly spend and now say “we don’t aware of any money my father gave to them”
Sir This my longest comment ever .
One thing I must say your every suggestion and point raise is too the point.
I really feel blessed to get such learning in my early 30s.
Correct, that's exactly what most parents do; comparison, divide and rule, play dirty games, manipulation and abuse. My parents have treated me so selfishly and taken advantage of my kindness that I am shocked they have no self-respect. After going above and beyond, and providing for them financially, they still compare and had the nerve to say that they made a mistake by giving birth to a daughter.
As a result, I have developed hatred and resentment for my parents. They now talk about give me a share of their little property but honestly I don't want it because I don't want to feel obligated to do anything for them in the future.
Most Indian parents don't realize that they are their own enemies and the damage they cause to their children will have consequences.
Jeevan ki Sacchai hai Apki baaton mein sir...
Wisdom ain't Correlated with Age, Sometimes elders too create blunders, which could have been easily avoided by clear thinking and sense of Justice & Equality among kids...
But still Koi na...
Upar wala sako de & Sabka bhala ho...
🙏🙏🙏
Very true Ishwar sab dekh raha hai
Well said sir ji, regarding daughters share and old people stubborn mind set,pranam 🙏
आप सही कह रहे हैं ज्यादा तर माता पिता स्वंय ही बच्चों में भेदभाव करते हैं और झगड़ा पैदा करके ही जाते हैं।
Sach main
Sir last concept I totally agree with you even in my family same thing happened to us . property distribution was improper by parents n younger brother of my husband inherited most part of property so there's all time bitterness in relationship of them.
Sir you have hit our society where it hurts the most
Hats off to your guts sir! These videos are actually need of the hour. People feel if the daughter is claiming for her right, she is greedy, she don't care for her brother, she will not be welcomed in her "maayka" i. e.father's/ brother's house. These kind of mind set needs to be changed. And boy's mindset can be changed only if parents believe that all their kids are equal in every aspect.
Thank you for your contribution!
True understanding of relationships, sir! Hats off to you !
Awesome 👌 you are really courageous and a true reformer.
Grate job sir , this is real problem of society, this is the reason girls suffer in-laws place but boys never suffer. Parents need to treat equally for both girls and boys.
Very good topic sir ,nobody wants to discuss on this aur ye ekdum sahi hai ki parents hamesha apne do beto ke beech barabari karne ki koshish karte rahte hai ye keh kr ki tumahare pass tih sari facilities hai uss bichare ke pass nhi hai hume ysse support karna chahiye aur agar hum ye baat kh de ki aap hamesha uska side lete ho toh hum hi bure ban hatehai.
Aaj ke parents ye family politics toh acche se khel rahe hain apne kgud ke fhar mein but wo ye kabhi nhi sochte ki humare samay mein hamara kya hoga inke pass toh do teen bachhe hai politics karne ke liye but humare time mein toh ek hi bachha hoga aur agar woh bhi parents ko chod kr chala jayega toh ,aur waise bhi aaj kl ki jo generation aa rhi hai sabko pehle se hi mentally prepared ho jana chahiye aane wale samay ke liye ki hume khus hi apna khayal rakhna hai,aur agar sab iss tarah sochne lge toh aadhi problm aise hi sopve ho jayegi ,zyada expectations krne se khud ko hi problm hoti hai,aur property matter ko le kr politics krna bahut hi galat hai.
Sir what u r doing is unique and life-changing... please continue to do this... 🙏
Definitely parents should not do family power dynamics.. . Elderly parents very rigid , stubborn. .
Equality should be the basis.. .
Sir I listen to as My Father. THANKS A TONNE FOR YOUR EFFORTS! 😇❤🙏
Sir, agreed that the girl should get equal share of property and law is also there. But nobody talks out sharing of parental responsibilities for example in a family there are three brothers one is married ,two unmarried studying in the college and two married sisters.
Situation developed parents fell sick and died after hospitalition. The expdr on treatment and all ceremonies linked with parents generally is borne by the son. In this case the eldest married one. After that brothers studies and their
marriage responsibility also fall upon him. Society does not expect sharing of this by sisters. And later also all familial social responsibilities also borne by the son only.
If the girls deserve equal share in parental property then she should also share these responsibilities. But nobody talks about it
F
Itne bache. Aaj kal 2 hi hote hain
You being a son can claim your parents bank balance and their regular income that is enough for their care.. here the point is avout fixed assets that are supposed to be divided equally.
Right and duty should go hand in hand.
What a lame and idiotic reply@@SangoLifeSutras for a genuine question and thought.
AEK dam sahi ho❤
You have good sense to understand deeper things and make translation in layman's language.. we all should appreciate his efforts
Correct girl child have to adjust n compromise everywhere... Good video 👍
Sahi kaha baccho me zehar parents hi bharte hai.... Unme bedhbhav karke.... Tabhi ladle beta - beti unko rulate hai...
So much clarity on such a complex issues… salute 🙏
Main far northeast se hun phirbhi aapka salah mujhpebhi aplicable hota hain sir...big salute...👏👌👍
Great Great keep it up thank you God Bless u
💯 like & agree..... last line the best line..
..4 suits and and then say "I love you " 😀 shared it with many
Actually son maintains parents daughters don't maintain old parents this is the reason parents give property to son then daughter ..This is the law sirji if daughter wants half share in fathers property she has to maintain or share parents expenditure 🙏...then she can claim from father 🙏 ..marriage expenses are same for boy or girl for parents ... 🙏
The daughter will share the responsibility if she is confident that she will be given equal rights
@@ashoktandon4039right. Good reply
You are the only person who is making videos on such important topics otherwise RUclips has billions of videos related to cooking, visiting places etc where millions of people subscribe without much value addition to their life
Nobody except You is making such sensitive and enlightening videos on youtube. Keep on the good work. Regards Shekhar
Very true , I salute you . Kuch father to aise hain agar Betiya apni kidney bhi donate kar de Apne father ke liye phir bhi wo apni property beta ko hi denge or beti ko struggle karne ke liye chor denge or kahenge ki tumari kismat hai kya kare .
Seema beta tum sahi keh rehi hoo aaisa he hota hai
Allah ka shukur hai meri 3 betiyan hain, beta nahi hai.
AAP ke sasural me kuchh n Mila aapko vaha aapne aapki nanand ko kuchh Diya?
Very needed discussion for parents.
Yes sir u are right mare papa to betao ko hi respect karte h beti ko kuch nh diya bus achi shaadi kar di ab bete rakh nh rahe mare pass aa nh sakte kyounki beto ko sab kuch divide kr diy a soch soch kar mari health bhi theek nh rahti
My father has been no more since..2022 ... property is in My name only because I have to pay a loan emi of 60 since 2019...same type 2 Bhai ek behen....saari log ek khatta hokar...mujse gift deed maang rahi hain...is mein bhi favourite chal rahi hai..1aur property bhi hain woh papa ke naam par hain....maa abhi deed maang raha hi hai...Sab property ki..
Very valid point is touched………. Actually people avoid talking about this important issue.
You have touched a very relevent and complex issue. Your viewpoint is absolutely valid. Kudos
Very valid video.Very brave of you to have touched this angle.Already working in this direction.
Aapke sabhi points bilkul sahi hain sir.Reallly 360 degree view and not only that a 100 year life cycle view of each member of family.I would like to add to this..
1. The total property should go to all the children equally included the huge wedding expenses which are spent from the parents hard earned money.In consequence to this, all children should take equal responsibillty of parents at their end age.It may be mutually decided between siblings owing to their physical proximity.Some may contribute financially or physically.
Sir, dil se bolta hu - God Bless You 🙏
Kudos for selection of the topic. Fully in agreement
Aapki baaton ki shat shat pranam 🙏.Just awesome
U r eye opener of our society...mazza agaya video sun ke...keep it up sir...accolades 🎉🎉🎉
Om Sai ram ji 🙏🙏 excellent vedio ji 👏 👏 great words 🙏🙏 society should be changed their veiw🙏🙏👏👏👍💐
You always give right advice. In Islam we already a share for daughter as described in our holy book Quran but due to the Indian culture this has not been strictly followed by all.
Hindus too have a system of share for the daughters as described by sir in the beginning of the video. Don't blame others for you faults.
The relevant Indian law has made all clear.
Woman have only half the property share to men in islam . And here sir is talking about equal property share . And Muslims usually say that only men have financial responsibilities so they get more inheritance . The thing is in Islamic shariah a woman can only work / study if her father /husband gives permission and she can only work if it is in a female only environment which automatically means a career only in teaching medicine cooking food stitching clothes mehendi makeup that’s it . Imagine being in Afghanistan and as a woman she get inheritance what’s the use when acc to Islamic shariah she cannot even step out of the house without her husbands permission .
I have forwarded this video to many people.
Videos on relationships and wealth creation and distribution and wise use of wealth are of great value and importance as most Miss to know how to handle these and hence make big mistakes and then regret
You are very right, very wise & logical. This way everyone will be happy. Sort out everything before you get too old to manage things. One should be wise & fair to distribute your assets.
Sir, you are bang on. Very eye opening topic. Keep making more videos on different topics.
Hello Sangwan Sahab- Great video ..your video just popped on my RUclips ...and quite frankly last part seems to be affecting my family..I went to school with Ashima and you can do 2+2 ..I have met your parents few times.
Thanks sir, for providing such valuable information.
It's the preconditioning of our family system that actually ruins the bond . One has to take the initiative to learn and find out the changes that are much needed. But it's only few who understand them. And when one says it, they are pointed out very badly by all the members of the family.
Great work keep doing
I am a daughter having only one brother and no sister but my father did not give me a single penny in his will although I was only 26 years old when he died and mother had already passed away
Good and very useful tips in this video.
In-laws with their daughters ruin the life of their son and his family
14.37 point se jo point aapne bola hai.That mentality of parents has been an age old problem with parents through many generations which is the seed of dispute on all families.I have seen this from my grandparents s generation and continue to see this even now around me in many families.
Very hard hitting content sir...awesome
Divide equally in 3 parts one for yourself
This video i watched after a year of its birth... Thanks, I have started liking ur videos n like every video before starting to watch it. 😅😊😊
Thanks for all ur efforts ❤
Good tips. Parents must openly declare the ratio of their assets among children and seek agreement of all children. If one of the children is financially weak then parents with consent of remaining children may decide to give that poor child little more. Copies of Will must be given to all children as record and fair understanding. Discrimination between sin and daughter be avoided. Also, till parents are alive,the right on assets be of parents and if assets are transferred before death of parents then two conditions as per law be incorporated in will: That till parents are Ali e they shall be fully taken care if by children and if children fail to do so, then gifted assets shall be taken back by parents.
You are correct.. I like and agreed- I think more than 80% families are doing same -
I completely agree....just amazed to listen you
Hats off to your reality check !!!
Very wonderful video.
Thank you for this information. I have the same problem and trying to clear this property matters. My ideas have been clarified somewhat
Right sir, we faced this situation
Bahut khub
Kaash aap jaisi soch hoti sab parents ki..i had a fight with my mother today when i said that girls are second class citizens in their mayka and sasuraal..if we ask for our right in our parents home we are greedy...
I have only one daughter and she will get everything, she will not have to wait for her inlaws to get property .
Completely agree,pl gv share to girls.
Zamana badla hai.
Good topic for discussion. From 2005 Government has given daughter equal rights but they are not getting their rights because firstly daughter does not take interest in her parents assets and always keep a eye on her in-laws property, she herself commits wrong with her family . Secondly the brothers never like to distribute property properly and in time, they keep it avoiding.
Government should make proper laws to make it compulsory to file a affidavit with district magistrate that these are the details of property and distributed in following manner.
Brilliant!! absolutely brilliant :)
I agree with you💯From the very first video of urs ..i m stunned..we need more people like you🎉🎉🎉
Aap ko very thx h sir apne y msg logo ko dia ki girls k baare soche🙏🏻
Sir, girl parent take responsibility till the marriage. Then she is left to the mercy of husband. Whereas boy parent responsibility of boy even after marriage.
Sir ,you have really nailed it....
Thanku so much Sir🙏 God bless you, 🙏👌👍👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌👌
Today parents can cheat their child also leave parents property if a parents snech child property what a child can do
Apki baat sunke samajh ata hai ki i am sane. Mai hi sahi thi warna mere ghar wale to mujhe pagal banane pe tule hue hai.
As funny as it sounds, my in laws are more concerned about their daughter coz she stays in france and is super successful as compared to their only son as per their logic. And my husband is quiet and is not concerned about our child's future.
Success make proper
Yes very true parents stress 👍
Absolutely correct interpretation Sir. Parents do falter in such issues.
2 Bhai vala fuckin' true
Mere grandparents ne y kalesh sown Kari and end abhi tk nhi h iska...!
Sir I like your videos just when it starts
100% True and scientific issue
Yes I fully agree I have faced all this in my life
A friend of mine spent all his savings on his younger brother's studies, coaching, etc. for the first decacde of his job life, while living frugally. Now his parents have decided to transfer the ownership of their only house to his younger brother's name, stating that my friend did not take care of them (while he was enslaving himself to support his brother and family). My friend, as usual, did not complain. But I could feel his pain. My friend, now 36, has little savings and a family to support. He carries on his life as if nothing happened! So tragic.
Tussi great ho bai. Fantastic topics you bring across. Lovely keep it going. Thanks
I fully agree with you sir
Sir ye sahi kaha kalesh ho jata hai same here in our family ❤️🙏