Why an Iran-empowered Hezbollah may not want an all-out war with Israel | DW News
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 11 сен 2024
- Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is promising an “extremely powerful” military response to recent Hezbollah attacks on northern Israel. Fires broke out in communities along the Israel-Lebanon border following rocket attacks launched by Hezbollah from Lebanese territory.
In August 2006, Hezbollah and Israel adopted UN Security Council Resolution 1701, putting an end to 33 days of fighting. The cease-fire is officially still in place, but both the Israeli military and Hezbollah militants have continued striking targets on either side of the border for years.
Since the October 7 Hamas terrorist attacks those cross-border exchanges have begun to intensify.
Casualties on the Lebanese side have primarily been soldiers: Of the 400 people killed since the October 7 attacks, 70 of them have been civilians. In Israel, 15 soldiers and 10 civilians have been killed by Hezbollah strikes. The impact has been catastrophic on both sides of the border with thousands of people forced to leave their homes and communities.
Human Rights Watch has accused Israel of deploying white phosphorus on residential buildings in at least five towns in southern Lebanon. The use of white phosphorus on a civilian population is a crime under international law.
Hezbollah is not the only actor in southern Lebanon: both the Lebanese army as well as the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL) have a presence in the south of the country.
#israel-hezbollah #nasrallah #lebanon
Subscribe: www.youtube.co...
For more news go to: www.dw.com/en/
Follow DW on social media:
►Facebook: / deutschewellenews
►Twitter: / dwnews
►Instagram: / dwnews
►Twitch: / dwnews_hangout
Für Videos in deutscher Sprache besuchen Sie: / dwdeutsch
Why do you refer to the Iran backed Hezbollah but not the US backed Israel?
hezbollah is a terrorist group you compare very different things lol
because the US only _helps_ Israel, the US does not enable Israel's _existence._
the same _cannot_ be said of Iran's tentacles.
Because Hezbollah is a proxy militia of Iran whereas Israel is a national state. Just a fact, not an opinion on the right or wrong of any of this horrendous situation.
They both have sugar daddy's funding them and people say the cold war is over naaa we're entering phase 2
@@YaMumsSpecialFrienddo all countries recognize Isreal as a national state? Do some countries recognize hezbollah as a legitimate government of Lebanon?
I suggest Israel to be named america backed Israel for fair
💯💯
May be Israel has forgotten 2006 like they've forgotten Andalusia. They have weak memories after all
They only remember the holocaust which they use as a political Instrument.
I remember very well, how Nassrala admitted defeat, saying he would have never kidnapped that soldier if he knew israel would respond in such way, and that was back then when israel didn't have the iron dome.
@@GabrielBTzar😂😂😂😂😂
Andalusia was colonized Spain.
We don't want to remember the dark times.
This is not 2006. Are you still stuck in 2006??
Brilliant guest. Very good analysis of the situation. I wish there were more people in the current media landscape like him providing detailed and in depth commentary. Well done DW for getting this guy on.
The problem is they always bring on 80000000 retired American military and intelligence personnel who never leave their houses
@@swaguelclemens9164 And they always fail to mention that they are advisors to, or sit on the boards of weapons manufacturers. A bit of transparency would go a long way increasing trust.
I agree the guest is beyond amazing well done calm and to the point! I am trying to find his podcast please help if you have link 🔗
Are you kidding? He implies Israel is escalating when the entire situation has been tit for tat, more or less and hizbollah began this latest exchange. Not to mention Netanyahu issued this “threat” after hizbollah sent cruise missiles into Israel lighting their “bread basket” on fire and destroying homes
Agree. Interviews with analysts are often disappointing. This fellow's name is Ronnie Chatah.
Do we ever say the american backed ukirainans or just when its iran
Exactly, this is the Western narrative
Western media hypocrisy
Islam= death destruction problems trouble
Hizbollah is not a state it's a proxy.
Hezb is not the state military. You can't have 2 governments in one country
Israel is dreaming 🤣😂
Palestinians never wake up again. 🤣😂
@@ihateorangecat How the situation of the Gaza war?
it seems 400,000 IDF still getting beated by 40,000 starved orphans in tunnels.
Don't ask for a ceasefire !!!
@@ihateorangecat nothing as ironic as your name
@@laithmughrabi8990it was always the Arab media who lied in previous conflicts with Israel.
I am amazed how much noise a country with only 10M people make.
There must be a lot of favor giving back-and-forth.
Iran is doing everything it can to use it proxies to the max
$$$$$
Sir, it's colony, not a country. Countries have to obey international laws, but colony like Israel shouldn't.
Which noise country? Are you on drugs or what . So Israeli can’t defend itself?
@@tojomedicalbcscoaching1544lol no laws applies against maslims. So every maslim country is a colony.
What kind of world we are living in … they think Palestinians child are not human .. but what kind of human they are they hv killed 14000 thousands child in GAZA --human can not do this …
Don't start wars
@@laserdolphin6483 don't kidnap civilians if you don't want the same to happen to yours
@AmonTheWitch Arresting someone isn't kidnapping, you liar.
@@laserdolphin6483 unless you're admitting that Israel is occupying Gaza, Israel holds no jurisdiction in Gaza so yes it very much is kidnapping
Arrest criminal Satanyahu, now !!
Why USA backed Israel hnn don't make double standard and hypocrisy mam journalism doesn't suit you
Ever heard of mutual relationship?
U think USA backed Israel for free?😂😂 U think USA tech just come from nowhere????
Ask Iran to back his bull ahh more n we will see😅😅
@@Escarlatejoy😂Iran had Putin in charge
@@LekoBuh So did you mama, Putin can really put it in
Historically they fought twice and the Lebanese side didn't lose either war.
That’s a lie
IDF messed up Irans terrorists in Lebanon
Surviving is not winning!
@@gearsloverguy1 It is when the other side has the stated ambition of making your survival impossible.
@@gearsloverguy1 the Lebanese side did not lose, and now they are bigger and have advanced weaponry.
It would be very illuminating if you were to research them.
It was shocking when i found out that cartels in Mexico have amoured vehicles with police lights and wear military fatigues.
It was even more shocking when i found out that the Lebanese side is actually a full sized army with tanks and advanced technology and weapons.
Lebanon was laid to dust though
How far corruption and greed can go!
Been a while i heard a very objective analyst
Objective? 😂😂😂
Lol
Great guest! So educated, well spoken, clear and reasoned. Please invite Mr. Chatah back soon, and often.
On behalf of all Iranians, we apologise for what our regime is doing 😢
Detailed analysis. He's well-informed and we can learn more from him.
She seems excited. She should go join the IOF and see what happens.
IDF.
Which has all right to attack Hizballah!
I hope she does. She thinks Hezbollah is Hamas. She’s is deeply mistaken
What's the IOF?
Is she supposed to conduct the interview while wheeping? She's smiling. Get over it
whats IOF?
Last time they tried they had to retreat as they got beat so bad.
Israel levou uma surra do Hesbollah, vai levar novamente!
Who
Iran and Israel never fought one on one
Why are you guys lying ?
If that was true they would never stopped, Israel didn't want the spending and the international backlash
@@JeffEbe-te2xs Israel was annihilated in 2006 by 2 Iranian commanders, imagine 3
Excellent interview from an expert that seems to have no axes to grind.
Superb analysis, thank you.
USA empowered Isreal :p
While Iran is creating terror groups all over the region
This story ALWAYS comes back to Iran.
Just makes Iran look smart!
@ciaronsmith4995 and your comment makes you look pretty ignorant.
@@ciaronsmith4995 Iran 👍 if ya know what I mean.
@@walsterdoomit Aww poor baby. You can't beat the Persians. They run West Asia. Always have. Always will!
I think you miss spelled USA.
Great analysis and great questions! Thanks for the insight DW
Nethanyahu joker not able to face even smallest group of hamaz . Instead he is killing civilians. Shame on you
Hamas using civilians for shields
Very good guest. Good clear analysis backed with plenty of detail.
The end of the US backed state Israel has come to an end
Quality take and journalism. Thank you DW.
Impressive analysis and insight
Very good guest here. Objective
Very excellent interview, your guest's analysis was topnotch
DW always choose analysts or people who hate Iran or Hizb or Ham... very biased
Evil will always do evil deeds.
Netanyahu -> "anything i can do to stay out of jail, I will do". Just like Trump
When Trump returns Iran will definitely be clipped
”Many of the homes have been evacuated for months… many who fled the region have no idea when they will be able to return.”
Whom do you report about, exactly?
@@shmuelaryehkoltov241 thanks for enlightening me
North israel
Most setlements are destroyed
Population evacuated
700,000 Israelis have left
Most Lebanese people probably don't want war but they are never the main factor in Iranian calculations.
Lebanon is in crisis many people are in very sad situation coz of hezbholla
ماذا عن حسابات إمريكا في دعم الاحتلال الصهيوني
Do not forget china and Russia
wow Mr Chatah is amazing
A real knowledgeable expert for once. Great interview!
When Israel starts retaliating fully some fools would start claiming Israel to be the aggressor and mean.
That has already happened. Israel is the big bully according to some.
This channel is just shameless.
What should they be ashamed of factual reporting or not parroting your personal narrative.
Thoughtful view indeed. Good on you
Is Hezbollah stronger than the Lebanese army? Are they stronger than the July 2006 war?
A chihuahua who is hiding behind America
This Chiwawa has a stronger bite than any dog you can think off!
But without the US @@goldylocker
Keep crying.
@@goldylocker ok then you don't need our money
The chihuahua hiding behind toddlers and have so far lost over 16k terrorists with close in 10k in Israeli jails
What about US-empowered Israel? Talk about it too please.
… us plays its own games
Half of them are not beneficial to israel..
Israel doesn't need any backing to defeat Hamas.
The USA is supplying Israel just in case others like Hezbollah or Iran decide that they want to expand the conflict.
Also Israel is an independent nation. Hezbollah is a militia group and does not represent Lebanon.
Lebanes love Palestinian people ☝️
people don't like to be displaced do they
Germany unalived 6 million but Lebanon and Palestine are the ones paying the price and Germany doesnt even speak up. Make that make sense.
iran is twiddling their thumbs happy
Persians are smart.
It may not matter what anyones wants
Bibi's. army cannot win with Hamas, but talk about Lebanon, the entire army is so tired of the current situation to manage 😂😂😂
John 3:16: "For God so loved the world that He gave His only Son. Whoever puts his trust in God's Son JESUS will not be lost but will have life that lasts forever."
Israel is too strong
Nope 👎🏼👎🏼👎🏼
😂😂😂😂
🇿🇦🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇿🇦
CAN YOU NOT SEND HER IN THE FIELD WITH HIGH PROFILE FOR A WHILE HER LINE OF QUESTIONING IS AWKWARD
Praise Israel....your God is with you!
4:30 If Israel is getting attacked continously by Hezbollah, not the Lebanese army, and Israel is not able to talk to Lebanon and make them stop the attack. Not even UN is is demilitarising Lebanon as they promised. Israel need to defend themselves, against proxies as ordinary forces attacking them in any violent way.
Quality journalism, as i expected. Advice though dude, say "important question", "difficult question to answer" etc "great question" is a touch condescending.
That is a war that they will ultimately lose-but that will have a negative consequences to the question of Palestinian freedom and resistance...
🇵🇸 PALESTINE 🇵🇸
He should look at his own big mistakes before threatening others.
Why don't you ask the spokespersons of Hezbollah and Hamas want they want ? Why ask all kinds of mouthpieces about this issue ? It is a simple question which you can and should address to the actors themselves.
What Hamas wants they will never ever ever get it ever
Why should the opinions of terrorists matter?
Return home ?.... Whose home
Good analysis.
Satellites can focus on any target immediately, then “why can’t jets respond asap”??❤
TL;DW war is scary
What do you mean they dont want war? Israel Lost the first war in 2006!!!! Why do they want round 2
What lies
The IDF did not loose
The terrorists cried like doing now and got the US to back off the IDF
Nope it did not. The Lebanese side was compelled to move over the Litani river and this comes after Hezbollah losts hundreds of combatants while Nasrallah still hides like a mole in his bunker
Sad, very sad. Goodbye Lebanon 🇱🇧, the Switzerland of the Middle East.
Stopped being that when Lebanon was tricked into taking in Palestinians
DW 🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥🤥
International forces should enter south Lebanon, they had nothing to do in Afghanistan but fighting Irans proxy army who has taken over the Government would be obvious, if the rest of the people in the Government would just ask for it. Many many innocent people in south Lebanon suffers from Hezbollah.. and the international community does nothing!
Yaweh =Allah ="Whatever God "= NOTHING
curious how tough israel would be without the US support
I think people knows who is terrorist or are not
Isreali jet fighters invaded Lebanese airspace.
Netanyahu is playing head of the snake
what America says it wants is different from what Israel is doing. What are you trying to arrive at?🤷
Maybe Lebanon, Jordan, and all the Arab states should deny any flights in and out of lsrael the use of their airspace.
Now we know who is next.
I couldn't see where he answered the question: what Hezbollah wants? What is the ideology behind Hezbollah?
It's Iran
Afraid of strike back in no time???
This guy sounds VERY educated! A pleasant to listen to... BUT, are you for real?! Its about to start, how can you be so sure of the opposite?!
Israel be protected by the almighty God
By "almighty god" you really mean ......
"almighty daddies USA & Germany"😂😂
@@CowneloAlvaroid Israel's real god is USA and britain.
ok guess you don't need money then
@@CowneloAlvaroid Many Arab countries in the region want a peace deal with almighty Israel
Israel's real god is USA and britain.
Don't die for -Netanjahu- Mileikowsky!
Netenyahu is a dream president with a very strong backbone. Many leaders would fold under the international pressure
Netanyahu looked jaundiced in that clip. He is not getting much sunshine at bare minimum. He is ill at maximum.
Ok Bibi because that s really worked out for you guys in the past. What a clown
its quite easy to criticize when you're not in a position of leadership and cannot see through the same lens of an opposing side; this is the reason why there are conflicts today. Nobody wants to die in a senseless war but justifications are made typically because of prejudice and unnecessary pride. I love Lebanon but hezbollah really has been a problem as they continually seek out external conflicts instead of focusing on improving the lives of their compatriots. As for the Israelis, fear is the problem and this fear has been shouldered by many generations.
Clown is a eufemism…
God does not protect those who kill children
Squatter netanyaho
Mileikowsky and is Polish
Is it Nataniyahus real name is?
Having Polish surname doesn't make you Polish. Steve Woźniak?
@@Northerner-Not-A-Doctor both woz and mileikowsky are of polish descent
@@wikittywhacktv "From Poland" does NOT mean "Polish".
Is ICC SEEING WHAT IS GOING ON
Israel wouldn't stand a chance if it s a fair fight. So Netanyahu stop talking tough.
You lack every sense of history my dear. Israel has never lost a war in the middle east. The same place Hezbollah is right now was under Israeli occupation for years until 2020 when Israel handed it over to Lebanon again. 6 Six Arab nations came against Israel in 1967 and previous years and couldn't do anything to Israel. Instead Israel took their lands for booties. Don't try Israel at all
It would be a fair fight israel has airsuperiority it has naval superiority it has numerical superiority and it has a robust logistics the war will be bloody but Israel without doubt would kill Lebanon.
Go Lebanon Go ! Go Lebanon Go ! Go Lebanon Go !
💪🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱❤️
🇿🇦🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇮🇱🇿🇦
israel should visit Lebanon.
you tried it in 2006 . you can try it again.
WAKE UP HUMANKIND, Be Happy get out of religion!!!😊
Wishful thinking 😂
🇮🇱
Velma
The title is misleading.
What happened to breaking bread? They've got it all wrong
Mohammad nothing but problems and trouble
People who are anti-Israel have a pathetically broken moral compass. This, more than any issue, informs me of a person's ethical bearings.
Bee Dee eS