NEW Troy Saga Tier List + Live Stream Visuals FIRST TIME Reaction & Analysis (EPIC: The Musical)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 2 ноя 2024

Комментарии • 370

  • @OpenArmsReactions
    @OpenArmsReactions  3 месяца назад +67

    We're already up to the Ocean Saga over on Patreon!
    Watch it here - www.patreon.com/collection/686482?view=expanded

  • @LilacRose-rp8vw
    @LilacRose-rp8vw 2 месяца назад +402

    Mason isn’t choosing between you two, HES GOING AGAINST YOU BOTH! We love him for that!

    • @Claudia-B.1987
      @Claudia-B.1987 2 месяца назад +8

      So true in this video is edited is so good and funny, very likeable

    • @juj509
      @juj509 2 месяца назад +11

      WE LOVE YOU MASOOOOOON🎉

    • @MagicMason1000
      @MagicMason1000 2 месяца назад +23

      ;)

  • @loftydabird54
    @loftydabird54 2 месяца назад +399

    Mortius commanding Casper to swear for him is such a funny bit and I hope it continues

  • @sydneylyman8778
    @sydneylyman8778 2 месяца назад +289

    Mason absolutely putting Mortius on blast for the motif confusion around 13:00 was so funny

    • @chibilenne5470
      @chibilenne5470 2 месяца назад +25

      In Mason we Trust

    • @MagicMason1000
      @MagicMason1000 2 месяца назад +31

      Just edited their Cyclops Saga Tier List and there is definitely more of that to come :)

  • @loganfrandrup6590
    @loganfrandrup6590 2 месяца назад +185

    Just thought I would add this for when you move on to the Thunder Saga and rank that:
    Just a Man: "Deep down I would trade the world to see my son and wife!"
    Scylla: *"Deep Down" is repeated over and over and over.*

    • @Azziyaisalwaysonline
      @Azziyaisalwaysonline 2 месяца назад +35

      ooooh never noticed that! My brain skipped that and went “hehe pretty Scylla voice”

    • @skincelled
      @skincelled 2 месяца назад +3

      @@Azziyaisalwaysonline this is so real lol

    • @Blue_foods213
      @Blue_foods213 2 месяца назад +7

      @@Azziyaisalwaysonlineyea I really can’t believe mr. jorgenborgen got the Armando Julian to play Scylla he’s perfect for the role

    • @sigridhorn2408
      @sigridhorn2408 Месяц назад

      And deep down is never reaææy mentioned in between the two songs

  • @alanplays2881
    @alanplays2881 2 месяца назад +363

    Stevens voice is no longer heavily edited. I love the new delivery he brings with his raw voice.

    • @marthafein1149
      @marthafein1149 2 месяца назад +33

      The autotune in the original versions were just hurting. This sounds more real to his voice.

    • @MarzBarz71222
      @MarzBarz71222 2 месяца назад +5

      ​@@marthafein1149 I don't think I noticed it. Who does Steven voice?

    • @laurentloutrance855
      @laurentloutrance855 2 месяца назад +11

      ​@@MarzBarz71222 Polites I think

    • @alanplays2881
      @alanplays2881 2 месяца назад +29

      ​@MarzBarz71222 Polites, and you hear it very clear in Full speed ahead at "Maybe there are people (right here) Lighting a fire" in the original version. But if you listen closely you can tell his voice is far more smooth in the new version compared to it was kinda sharp in the original

    • @BlueCookies1116
      @BlueCookies1116 2 месяца назад +6

      ⁠@@alanplays2881oh yeah i noticed the weird sharpness too and it sort of wavered a bit at that part (or was it another part? Not sure lol)

  • @nasam1273
    @nasam1273 2 месяца назад +434

    I don't see anyone commenting about it, but in the new version of Just A Man you can actually hear the instrumental of Mutiny in the background just as the soldiers start singing! It starts in "when does a comet become a meteor?" but it gets louder in "when does a ripple become a tidal wave?" (This is also confirmed by Jorge!)

    • @Phasmania
      @Phasmania 2 месяца назад +33

      Wait that’s so cool! I noticed the new buildup instrumentals but somehow didn’t put together that it was Mutiny

    • @Impimperator
      @Impimperator 2 месяца назад +2

      where can I find Jorge's explaination for this? I'd like to go and watch it.

    • @nasam1273
      @nasam1273 2 месяца назад +9

      ​@@Impimperator he hasn't made a video about it yet! But someone asked in the comments on one of his tiktoks and he confirmed it

    • @SadfaceCM
      @SadfaceCM Месяц назад

      I had to listen after reading this, but 💯! That’s really cool! I always love those bits of foreshadowing in these songs.

  • @Sapphiregemsasastars
    @Sapphiregemsasastars 3 месяца назад +451

    When I saw this i audibly gasped in excitement and dropped my phone. Can’t wait! It’d be funny if Casper put “Survive” in a low tier because of Polites turning into a pancake.

    • @darrylspicer5535
      @darrylspicer5535 3 месяца назад +16

      now, why do you got to reminding me, man😢

    • @owlishwillow7242
      @owlishwillow7242 2 месяца назад +21

      Probably f tier since you can hear his glasses breaking

    • @hindymarkowitz1340
      @hindymarkowitz1340 2 месяца назад +42

      Wait, THAT's what the whole pancake joke is?!
      Because he GOT CLUBBED?!
      WHY DIDN't I GET THAT UNIL NOW?! What even...?!

    • @Sapphiregemsasastars
      @Sapphiregemsasastars 2 месяца назад +18

      @@hindymarkowitz1340 yeah, in the recap Jorge made, he said he killed Polites because he likes pancakes. 🤣

    • @hindymarkowitz1340
      @hindymarkowitz1340 2 месяца назад +4

      u @Sapphiregemsasastars
      I know, I watched that, I just didn't get it until now.

  • @Cheshiregrinn91
    @Cheshiregrinn91 2 месяца назад +91

    Damn the new horse and the infant thing with all the gods singing with Zeus. (especially the part with the 'the blood on your hands is something you won't lose. all you can do it choose') Really makes me think of that thing 'The gods are playing chess but there is only 1 pawn and they take turns moving it about.' That is Odysseus.

    • @adellefletcher
      @adellefletcher 2 месяца назад +5

      That is a great metaphor ❤

    • @AUCreatoer
      @AUCreatoer 2 месяца назад +4

      Damn this is a fricking great metaphor

  • @meganforsthoefel3030
    @meganforsthoefel3030 2 месяца назад +117

    I kind of like the "scary cave" line being more audible. It makes the forshadowing more clear for one, but it also makes Polites' response, ("A cave!"), more interesting because it highlights him as almost willfully naive, trying to be the ultimate optimist by ignoring or maybe filtering out the warning. I kind of see it as Polites talking to the lotus eaters away from Odysseus like in mircsy's animatic, which could mean Odysseus didn't hear the warning. He would go on what Polites tells him, which is just "a cave"

    • @radicaledward84
      @radicaledward84 2 месяца назад +7

      Meanwhile, the cave singing in the background: "I'm just a cave"

  • @____thecommenter1569
    @____thecommenter1569 2 месяца назад +181

    30:52 "give me back my elongated birds"
    42:51 "hey who's that blob singing." "YOU ARE TERRIBLE "
    46:11

  • @LuckasSilver
    @LuckasSilver 2 месяца назад +24

    "Please cut that Mason"
    "That will be 20 dollars"
    Mason MVP for not picking sides and choosing violence and bribery lmao

  • @danieldaza2141
    @danieldaza2141 2 месяца назад +131

    The crew probably did fish a lot, but after the troyan war, Poseidon was a little salty with all greeks, and after polyphemus, even if they wanted to, they probably could never find fish, because the god of the sea would never let them

    • @giuliagabriela9729
      @giuliagabriela9729 2 месяца назад +1

      Was Poseidon on the Trojan side of the war? I can't imagine him being against Zeus even indirectly in a mortals war

    • @danieldaza2141
      @danieldaza2141 2 месяца назад +4

      @@giuliagabriela9729 scratch that, I was wrong, lol, yeah, they didn't in this ocasion, but it is fairly often

    • @AUCreatoer
      @AUCreatoer 2 месяца назад +17

      Pretty sure Poseidon was on Greek's side due to the Trojan's not paying back for him building their walls (just heard this, don't know if it's true). Though he is salty against Odysseus and the greeks due to them not praying/sacrificing to him when traveling on the sea and for using his horse symbol but he let it slide due to him hating the Trojan's more. Though that all went out the window when Ody blinded Polyphemus so yes, they could never catch any fish due to Poseidon now being angry at them and willing to starve them for pay back, he's petty like that.

    • @giuliagabriela9729
      @giuliagabriela9729 2 месяца назад +12

      @AUCreatoer Yeah, when I found out the wooden horse was for ATHENA and Ody was the one who gave that ideia, I was like, no wonder Poseidon tries to kill that dumbass on the way back home
      And that was years ago before epic, so I didn't know about the cyclops

    • @sarahhandberg5185
      @sarahhandberg5185 2 месяца назад +6

      Hehe.. the god of the sea is salty😂😂

  • @akaittou
    @akaittou 2 месяца назад +89

    28:34 "Is that a fin coming out of his neck??" THIS MAN SEES POSEIDON LITERALLY EVERYWHERE NOW I STG
    (Thank you so much for leaving these things in Mason)
    I miss the slightly lingering birds too Mortius, the little quirk made it sound like Ody was being less serious and more relaxed now that they're on their way home :')

    • @RyzeandFall
      @RyzeandFall 2 месяца назад +3

      Casper seeing Poseidon everywhere in Epic was like me seeing Mephisto everywhere in Wandavision 😂😂

    • @coroixiwa
      @coroixiwa 2 месяца назад +1

      You mean Wet Hades? (I will NEVER let Casper live it down XD)

    • @kallandar13
      @kallandar13 Месяц назад

      My ranking is (best to least- best) Just a Man, Open Arms, Full Speed Ahead, The Horse and the Infant, and Warrior of the Mind.

  • @silvertongue231
    @silvertongue231 2 месяца назад +111

    Elongated birds is gonna be another animatic shorts meme I'm calling it now

    • @nudgificator
      @nudgificator 2 месяца назад +1

      Geese. Geese everywhere.

  • @DnDAddictUK
    @DnDAddictUK 2 месяца назад +157

    I love Mason being able to fully join in the banter between the two of you in this. I am so glad that you have had the privilege and opportunity to react to these visuals for the new versions

  • @TheBre1491
    @TheBre1491 2 месяца назад +73

    I love how much more confident Steven sounds in open arms. Completely re-recording the songs is such a feet! For Jorge and the whole cast/crew.

  • @ChelTheNerdyPrude
    @ChelTheNerdyPrude 2 месяца назад +80

    One thing I noticed in the remakes is that the old studio seemed to use a little more autotune for certain songs/sections/vocalists, specifically Steven and Teagan. I always noticed the slightest bit of influence in their lines that is thankfully gone in the remakes, it used to take me out of it every time i noticed it and now i just headbang along with everything!

    • @Azziyaisalwaysonline
      @Azziyaisalwaysonline 2 месяца назад +8

      Yes finally someone else mentions this! The second “I fight for us” in H+I was my least favorite of those moments (Edit: I mean the old h+i)

    • @AUCreatoer
      @AUCreatoer 2 месяца назад +10

      Right? I love how there's less autotune in the songs, especially Polites' vocals. He sounds more natural and great in the remake version :D

    • @ChelTheNerdyPrude
      @ChelTheNerdyPrude 2 месяца назад +8

      @@Azziyaisalwaysonline yes, that's another line that I always noticed! Athena was particularly egregious in My Goodbye, and it's so nice to hear it clean.

  • @ghostsurfer23
    @ghostsurfer23 2 месяца назад +31

    I'm glad you guys acknowledged Young Odysseus' laugh being better this go around. It wasn't precisely bad before, just really awkward, and not in a "he's just an awkward kid" way, but a "that doesn't sound like how any human would laugh in this scenario, musical or not" way.

    • @sk3ru
      @sk3ru 2 месяца назад +8

      I don't think it was meant to sound like a genuine laugh. it was more like a smug "HA i was right"

  • @disableddragonborn
    @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад +24

    Luke Holt watches every video when it drops, and Steven Dookie wanted to be kept up to date on the progress of this channel, so it's probably safe to say they've either watched this, or are going to soon. I've never said anything that makes me this proud of someone. Congratulations on all of the success you both have had from Epic.

    • @ezracohen6020
      @ezracohen6020 2 месяца назад

      Wait really?

    • @disableddragonborn
      @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад

      @@ezracohen6020 Yep. Luke commented on one of Mortius's Tik Toks "Dude! Your reviews with Casper are some of my favorite videos! I look forward to watching them when they drop! #wethades😂😂😂" and Steven commented on that same video "Please keep me posted on the new page!!! I’m interested as hell!!" to which Armando replied "LET’S GOOOOOO"

  • @seeschwalbe
    @seeschwalbe 2 месяца назад +25

    12:44 Ohh, I never realised that the "Penelope" in 'Horse abd the Infant' is sung by Odysseus and Penelope! Also I'm pretty sure I can hear Athena in the chior backing Zeus, which makes total sense since it literally says "the Gods", but I never clocked that! Now I have to listen for Hermes and Poseidon in there...

  • @themoonlit-wolf3773
    @themoonlit-wolf3773 2 месяца назад +33

    My headcannon (knowing it’s not cannon but it’s cannon in my heart) is that the “scary cave” winion is the one ody takes into the cave in mercsy’s animatic (rip to the spelling)

  • @gachazally8914
    @gachazally8914 2 месяца назад +66

    I just realized that Odysseus has a small rasp when saying "Imminent" in horse and the infant!

  • @sorinamarcu5357
    @sorinamarcu5357 2 месяца назад +30

    11:11 Personally, I like the choir being louder because in my head, I imagine it as the choir symbolise accually the voices of the future and being part of the profesy

    • @shinraset
      @shinraset Месяц назад +1

      I heard it a little differently personally. To me it seemed more like it was the combined voices of all of the gods that are going to show up in the story said, "I don't think you're ready."

  • @unkn0wnth0rn32
    @unkn0wnth0rn32 2 месяца назад +85

    That choir behind Zeus are the other gods

    • @aniheartsong5102
      @aniheartsong5102 2 месяца назад +12

      I thought Athena that you? Hinting that it is a test since Athena is always testing Odysseus.

    • @amw5288
      @amw5288 2 месяца назад +8

      ​@@aniheartsong5102 Its them all. You can hear Poseidon and Hermes a bit and Athene a lot cause Teagan's voice is just so powerful.

  • @gryfon_gamez8184
    @gryfon_gamez8184 2 месяца назад +54

    This is exactly what I'll need on the bus ride home from work, perfect timing

  • @na.JAM_ming
    @na.JAM_ming 2 месяца назад +6

    22:57 the euryscylla image got me burst out laughing 😭😭😭

  • @beckenfuggle644
    @beckenfuggle644 2 месяца назад +17

    It feels like the first two sagas are performed live and i absolutely love that. It makes you feel like you are there.

  • @MikkiElle
    @MikkiElle 2 месяца назад +16

    The thing I appreciate the most about your shared reaction channel is the actual teasing bordering on spiteful without context banter you two have. That’s real friendship right there 😂

  • @inkyma175
    @inkyma175 2 месяца назад +23

    I’m interested where you guys put ‘Polyphemus’ because it’s actually in my like top 3 because the melody of the parts like ‘have a drink, one sip and you’ll understand…” even Polyphemus’s part of it absolutely gives me such a dopamine rush similar to the feeling I get at the very beginning of ‘suffering’

    • @Azziyaisalwaysonline
      @Azziyaisalwaysonline 2 месяца назад +3

      Oooh yes I love the beginning of Suffering so much! That song might be my favorite Thunder Saga song (it’s a close competition, but still)

    • @Okaychan09
      @Okaychan09 2 месяца назад

      @@Azziyaisalwaysonline Suffering is currently my favorite of the entire musical, maybe because its fresh but the beginning of it hits every time

    • @ezracohen6020
      @ezracohen6020 2 месяца назад

      When it came out it was my favorite, now I would say its 3rd or 4th (Ruthlessness taking 1st, underworld taking 2nd, and I’m still deciding between Scylla and Polyphemus for 3rd and 4th and then just a man takes 5th)

  • @disastrouslylargeicedmocha
    @disastrouslylargeicedmocha 2 месяца назад +23

    54:45 Accurate Athena with auburn hair??????!!!!! That’s amazing!!!

  • @kylorestell9420
    @kylorestell9420 2 месяца назад +6

    "Jorge, when I find you Jorge" -Mortius 2024 best quote. Makes me giggle everytime

  • @IvanIsYda_
    @IvanIsYda_ 2 месяца назад +12

    “That’ll be 20 dollars”
    MASON BEING A SAVAGE😭

  • @MondSwiss
    @MondSwiss 2 месяца назад +34

    12:46 I think the bit you're saying you like a little less with the choir is adding Penelope's voice to some words as like, Zeus using her to manipulate Odysseus?

  • @KhmyhVKB
    @KhmyhVKB 2 месяца назад +11

    Everything about this video is so darn good - the commentary, the reactions, the banter, the information, Wet Hades, Mortius's villainous laughter, the motif mistake - EVERYTHING!!!!! But as someone who dabbles in video editing, Mason's hilarious editing really made it special this time around.
    I need a collection Mason’s funny edit here so I can refer back to them and show my friends when I try to convince them to watch these videos. lol
    • “Leans into mic” 1:41
    • Mortius commanding Casper to swear - 2:41
    • Moving texts, including “that’ll be $10” 3:17
    • “No he didn’t” 13:22
    • “He’s getting confused with the motif from Survive and Mutiny” 13:35
    • “No” 13:38
    • “2nd” 13:42
    • “Right song, wrong motif” 13:48
    • Zoom in on Mortius being a villain 14:12
    • “He’s learning!” 14:32
    • Wet Hades 14:35
    • “Because you’re thinking of the wrong [motif]” 15:08
    • “There was” 16:30
    • Zoom in on Casper as he panics on VA’s name + Casper’s Scylla VA goof up 22:45
    • “Dropping us” … 23:48
    • Mortius goes BOOM - 26:16
    • Zoom in on Mortius’s serious question 28:16
    • Zoom in on Casper ignoring Mortius 28:21
    • Goating Casper’s swear again 28:36
    • “I’ll leave it in ‘cause I left this in:” 28:59
    • “My weirdly elongated birds” - Mortius, 2024 30:59
    • “What is wrong with him?” 40:25
    • Zoom in on Casper’s “You’re terrible” 40:59
    • Casper goes mooooooo 44:55
    • Zoom in on Mortius being done with Casper 47:28
    • Wet Hades 2 48:07
    • “That will be 20 dollars” 48:11
    • “First” 55:53
    • The DAB 56:29
    • “Wrong direction LOL” 1:01:31
    • “Who’s your favorite sandwhich” - Mortius, 2024 1:02:13
    Also my favourite Troy Saga song is definitely Warriors of the Mind! Especially the remade version has some awesome divine chorus, befitting of our beloved Divine Sugar Momma! And Teagan is an absolutely Goddess on Earth!

    • @MagicMason1000
      @MagicMason1000 2 месяца назад +5

      I love this comment! I'm glad you enjoy my edits! I put a lot of work into these videos :D

  • @KhmyhVKB
    @KhmyhVKB 2 месяца назад +26

    OMG OARIONS ARE SO WELL FED! 🧅
    So excited to see you both react to the new version of THATI (YOU CAN HEAR TEAGAN'S VOICE IN THE GODS' CHORUS), WOTM harmonies and Teagan's vocal again! And of course, Steven Dookie's Polites. ❤‍🩹 (Those are the differences that I especially love from the new versions. The divine chorus for our beloved Divine Sugar Momma is very fitting and has yeeted me into the heavens.)
    So curious about both your song rankings!

  • @rhov-anion
    @rhov-anion 2 месяца назад +4

    Mortius cackling while Casper looks like he's reliving trauma with his eye twitching.... love your dynamic together!
    Mason, you're awesome for being able to put up with these two, hahaha!

  • @maximotheone
    @maximotheone 2 месяца назад +25

    my thought on the added choire to horse and infant is that they are all the gods that will apear in the musical

  • @justanaveragehumanbean
    @justanaveragehumanbean 2 месяца назад +3

    Fun fact: In the remastered Full Speed Ahead, you can distinctly hear Steven’s (Polites) voice in most of the chorus lines after he’s introduced! I like that detail, we were missing the boi in the original :)
    RIP Polites and the singular Odyssey braincell, you will be missed

  • @jazzyjaz5910
    @jazzyjaz5910 2 месяца назад +9

    You two are my favorite epic reactors hands down. This video was amazing and im loving all ur takes tbh. And omfg Mason makes the videos so much better lol. Love u all

  • @MusicLover0430
    @MusicLover0430 2 месяца назад +2

    Mason’s “That’ll be 20 bucks” made me laugh lol. So cute 😂

  • @Via_art101
    @Via_art101 2 месяца назад +2

    56:26 you finally caught it man. High five.

  • @dakotaXmae
    @dakotaXmae 2 месяца назад +14

    If the characters showing up aren’t canonically romanceable we riot lmao

  • @franciscofigueiredo4346
    @franciscofigueiredo4346 2 месяца назад +2

    In the clouds are Athena,Hermes and Poseidon and the others are just like the normal style like unidentified

  • @isaacmartin503
    @isaacmartin503 2 месяца назад +2

    Dude mason is our mascot for open arms he’s the little wood guy I will die on this hill 😂

  • @Azziyaisalwaysonline
    @Azziyaisalwaysonline 2 месяца назад +9

    14:45 Mortius 😭 it’s pronounced like Julia
    I have a friend named Giulia, and I call her Gweelia all the time lol

  • @F_doesnotwanttobehere7
    @F_doesnotwanttobehere7 2 месяца назад +14

    It’s ridiculous how big my smile is when open arms starts playing😭 Oh Polites,too soon. (If u don’t like this song,u don’t know happiness apparently🤨)

  • @Andi_Dreams
    @Andi_Dreams 2 месяца назад +12

    I love how evil Mortius's laugh sounds. It's so amazing

    • @b_w_j
      @b_w_j 2 месяца назад +2

      Proper villain cackle he has

    • @Andi_Dreams
      @Andi_Dreams 2 месяца назад

      @@b_w_j indeed

  • @KingdomEllipsis
    @KingdomEllipsis 2 месяца назад +2

    Personally, to answer the proposed question for the engagement of the video, my favorite of the Troy Saga has to be Open Arms, and the more upbeat / almost tropical vibes that it has are such an atmosphere (I love beaches a lot). :D Also, I totally think it makes sense what was said about the story parts bringing down the song, but I actually like the "downtime" part of it myself, because that tone change made the transition back to the more bubbly parts more profound for me, but that's just a personal take! For me, if it didn't have those moments, I think that the return to the lighter and happier tune wouldn't feel as joyful as it is, because now Polites is "making his point" about his philosophy. While the Winions / Lotus Eaters themselves sound a bit dorky and not as "elegant" song-wise, that doesn't really bother me personally. (Also their little "ooo" part is so pretty actually.) If anything, it makes an interesting contrast between the higher, soft, crystal-clear voice and their lower, almost distorted-sounding ones. So it's just very interesting to me, which is why I love it. And naturally Polites is my favorite of the characters. I just love him so much haha. He's such a beautiful ray of sunshine.

  • @Into_The_Sin
    @Into_The_Sin 2 месяца назад +2

    How could you guys NOT react to "This is the will of the gods" :OOOO It's so much more dominant and thunderous than the prev version

  • @Viillustrations
    @Viillustrations 2 месяца назад +14

    The Eurylla flashback lol

  • @Majesticskyyy
    @Majesticskyyy 2 месяца назад +5

    I love you guys so much as a duo, I'm so glad you both made a channel together! Also can we talk about how AMAZING Mason's editing was in this? Excited for cyclops saga 😁

  • @disableddragonborn
    @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад +6

    It's refreshing to hear Mortius say he's a Eurylochus defender, because I support Eurylochus so much that I straight-up changed my Tik Tok bio to "I will defend Eurylochus beyond my dying breath."

  • @dorothyrosenberg1301
    @dorothyrosenberg1301 2 месяца назад +6

    I’m not able to choose a favorite song. That you two are able to put them into tiers is amazing.

  • @navimcfarland9113
    @navimcfarland9113 2 месяца назад +2

    Something i noticed that i really enjoyed was that Athena's voice is very straight-laced, direct toned. Little to no waver which really goes into the whole "Athena doesn't do emotions things"

  • @jordanNCM
    @jordanNCM 2 месяца назад +1

    I agree on Warrior of the Mind being the best of the Troy Saga! It was the first thing I heard from Epic and the song that made me fall in love with these characters and seek out this musical.

  • @kjrstenschindler3140
    @kjrstenschindler3140 2 месяца назад +3

    Something my mom and I were talking about is that even though a lot of the lines haven’t been changed very much musically, the delivery of the lines are slightly different which makes it have so much more emotional depth! Super cool 🎉

  • @charismaticshere2405
    @charismaticshere2405 2 месяца назад +4

    The Horse and the Infant is probably my favorite song in Troy Saga. Because from a bit of an artist perspective, when I listen to this musical I'm always thinking in the back of my head how this is all going to work on a stage. I actually have a lot of fan staging in my head of how I would do everything and so the song where I have more clearer imagery in my head tend to be the ones I like more. and the Horse and the Infant has that for me. But also theres just a lot of things I really like overall, "please don't make me do this. don't make me do this" is my favorite line in the whole musical, the delivery always gets me, the desperation in it just hits me like a freight train. and I really like when Odysseus is telling the soldiers their roles. Its a part of the song that itches my brain really well.

  • @jademuseplays
    @jademuseplays 2 месяца назад +4

    Mason, genius editing. Thank you for that input

  • @akaittou
    @akaittou 2 месяца назад +9

    "Yes obviously" they say about Just a Man being S tier... Meanwhile, my list:
    *S* - Warrior of the Mind
    *A* - The Horse and the Infant
    *B* - Open Arms
    *C* - Just a Man | Full Speed Ahead
    *D* -
    *F* -
    Reasoning:
    Athena revealing her callousness, the lone viola playing the danger motif as soon as young Odysseus has caught her eye, everything highlighting that their dynamic is very unequal but they have still made it work before - Warrior of the Mind is just SO GOOD.
    The Horse and the Infant is the DEFINING song that sets the stage for everything from Odysseus' skill in leading men (other kings and princes even) to the demands gods place on mortals, all while incorporating and incredible range of ambient sounds directly into the music.
    Open Arms is dang good, but it IS also very much the kind of song you get a few of on the radio almost every summer and just keep as background music at the pool, HOWEVER the tone shift with the lotus eaters and the ensuing bakc and forth elevates it.
    Just a Man is definitely mechanically incredible and it works perfectly for what it is, but what it is is a ballad for establishing a character, not something I'd skip in a playlist but also not something I'd listen to on its own on loop - especially as the new soldier choir no longer sounds like the entire Greek army of hundreds if not thousands of men is watching Odysseus holding the infant on the wall, losing the culmination some of its original intensity.
    Full Speed Ahead is another establishing song, and while it's catchy and arguably very singable, the overlapping call and response style makes it impossible to actually sing alone - it's still a really good, solid song, just not better than the others.

  • @disableddragonborn
    @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад +3

    I never knew "I still intend to make sure you don't fall behind" was directed to adult Odysseus. I thought it was to Kidysseus, meaning even after they harmonically bonded, she intends to treat him like a pupil instead of a friend.

  • @Platinum_Imp
    @Platinum_Imp 2 месяца назад +10

    Not the weirdly elongated birds

  • @montavious4748
    @montavious4748 2 месяца назад +4

    I’m so happy you guys have a channel together now, and I love the official Epic albums, they sound so clear now!

  • @EditorOfTheGods
    @EditorOfTheGods 2 месяца назад +3

    I didn’t notice much new differences in the remade versions (I didn’t doubt they were there I am just much more story inclined and can’t catch many musical details on a first listen which is why I watch these lol) but one of the few things is the added harmonies of the gods on some of Zeus’s parts. Specifically on “this is the will of the gods” I think because of how story driven I am lol. I love it so much because while it might not be the best musically as mortius pointed out it is SO good for storytelling. Because it adds just so much more threatening vibes to it. Not only is this the king of the gods but it’s all the Olympians backing him up. Like how could you say no to that?

  • @imagoatiswear1938
    @imagoatiswear1938 2 месяца назад +5

    I always heard it as "why should we take when we could give" and I think it still sounds like Athena says "Well done, you lied to me" ngl lol

  • @Smk42217
    @Smk42217 2 месяца назад +3

    Mason, providing that levity and keeping us honest all at the same time.

  • @Jashter21
    @Jashter21 2 месяца назад +2

    Casper has given me such a greater appreciation for this musical with his incredible knowledge of music production and singing I love it so much
    Mortius just continues to personify me in aspect when reacting to these songs though
    Absolutely the best duo

  • @silvertongue231
    @silvertongue231 2 месяца назад +6

    I adore full speed Ahead it gives me Drunken Sailor, Wellerman vibes

  • @colt1903
    @colt1903 2 месяца назад +3

    You're talking about all these changes... Everything literally sounds the exact same to me, so I got no idea what the fuck you're on about.😂
    At best, I hear new sound effects, but the instruments and vocals, I literally can't tell the difference.

  • @darkmirror21
    @darkmirror21 2 месяца назад +3

    honestly, best part ofthe remade versions is that less autotune in general and everything is much clearer to hear

  • @Akajaro
    @Akajaro 2 месяца назад +3

    "There's no way this video end up under an hour"
    *glances at video length*
    I mean.... Mason did his best?

  • @anastasija6866
    @anastasija6866 2 месяца назад +10

    For me its definitely 1 Warrior of the mind, 2 horse and the infant, 3 full speed ahead and 4 just a man and open arms are equal, hope Casper doesnt forget that the entire reason they visit the cyclops is because of polites who also was convincing Odysseus to lower his guard even though they are on an unknown island
    Edit: The reason this war happened the way it did is because when suitors came for Helens hand Tyndarius her father didn't know how to avoid the bloodshed from picking any of them, Odysseus who decided to forgo Helens hand for the pretty and smart niece of Tyndarius Penelope, he told the Spartan king that if he can gain Penelopes hand he would tell him a solution, it being the oath of Tyndarius, where the suitors would give their word that they would protect the right of the one Helen chooses. Now fast forward later Paris gains an apple(the apple of discord from Eris) and 3 goddesses ask him to gift the apple to one of them, Hera promises him the throne of Troy, Athena battle knowledge and tactics and Aphrodity the love of the prettiest woman of the land, Paris chooses Aphrodity and becomes her champion goes out and comes back with Helen. He also tried to act Mad, like he lost his mind in order not to go to the war since he didn't swear any oaths but one of the seers that the Greeks possessed said to succeed in this war they needed Odysseus and Achilles so they weren't letting him not participate
    The men mentioned in Horse and the Infant are in order -Diomedes he was managed to wound Aphrodities wrist in the war and recovered the Palladium(Mark of Athena for pjo references) that provided troy protection when he came home he discovered his wife was unfaithful(a punishment from Aphrodity) and that his claim to the throne was disputed and he left to settle somewhere else.
    -Agamemnon was Meneleuses older brother he married Helens sister Clytemnestra, he offended Artemis somehow before they sailed for troy and to appease her he sacrificed his daughter Iphigeneia(don't know why that worked a virgin maiden sacrificed and killed in the name of the protector of maidens) and he caused some problems in camp like taking Achilles war prize Briseis when his (Kassandra) was returned to her father, something that made Achilles refused to fight a time, he also angered Apollo which caused a plague on their camps, he was later killed by his wife when he returned home.
    -Meneleus was a mostly ok guy, he was married to Helen, he delayed his journey because one of his crew members was killed so he waited until he was properly buried and he in some myths did gain Helen back.
    -Teucer was Ajax the greaters younger half brother, one of the few that did not commit some sacrilege, he was a great with a bow, he after his brother basically commits seppuku manages to insure a properl burial even if some of the other generals said he didn't deserve one, one of his supporters being Odysseus(Odysseus kinda caused Ajaxs death because Ajax either lost in duel or Athena made him hallucinate to lose a duel) when he returned home his dad didn't let him in because he didn't bring his brothers son back, even if the son came back later.
    -Ajaxs the Lesser was a real piece of work, he was boastful and arrogant, he violated Kassandra infront of Athenas statue and was nearly stoned to death by his allies the Greeks, when they were leaving Troy Athena and Poseidon collaborated in killing him, Athena by wrecking his ship and Poseidon by casting him to the sea and drowning him when he managed to swim to a rock and boast his superiority to the gods
    -Nestor was the son of Neleus(king of pylos) and Chloris(nymph goddess of flowers) his brothers were all slain by Herakles, he was about 70 in the Iliad and he tells Telemachus what he and the rest of them suffered in the war.
    -Neo(Neoptolemus) was the son Achilles, which he sired while being hidden in Scyros as a woman by his mother Thetis, because he angered Apollo and was prophecies to die in the Trojan war, Neo was brought to the war by Odysseus because a Trojan seer that they gained Helenus the twin brother of Kassandra(after he left because is some tellings Helen did chose him to marry after Paris died, or that he was captured by Odysseus or he left because of the treacherous murder of Achiles) prophesied that they could only take troy if they had a descendants of Aeacus who helped build the walls, Neo committed the sacrilege of killing the aged king Priam at an alter, he married Hermione the daughter of Helen but took Hektors wife Andromache as a concubine and Helenus with him to Epirus, he later died in Delphi when he demanded Apollo atone for his father's death, Helenus and Andromache married after his death and ruled Epirus.

  • @Beeker10
    @Beeker10 2 месяца назад +6

    The based opinion is putting every song in best of the best

  • @helixnebula8363
    @helixnebula8363 2 месяца назад +1

    Warrior of the mind is my favorite from the Troy saga. It’s just really fun to jam to

  • @seeschwalbe
    @seeschwalbe 2 месяца назад +4

    21:21 the only thing I personally have to criticize (like, mild mild criticism) about the remastered soldiers, is that they sometimes sound like less people then in the first version because you can hear the individual voices now, which lessens the effect of there being fewer and fewer voices in the chior as the story progresses a little bit for me. But I'll take it for those beautiful new harmonies!

  • @verthandi8672
    @verthandi8672 2 месяца назад +1

    Great thoughts on the saga! Love Troy so much, it's truly great from start to finish.
    Pretty sure nobody agrees with me on order, heh, but that's what's so fun with a musical so consistently outstanding! I gotta go with:
    -The Horse and the Infant
    -Full Speed Ahead
    -Warrior of the Mind
    -Just a Man
    -Open Arms

  • @Spectralyzed
    @Spectralyzed 2 месяца назад +3

    Ooooh! I understand now... I mentioned in the Premier chat that the trailer's "Early access to the Cyclops and Ocean sagas" confused me a bit; I didn't realize you guys were doing multiple episodes of this for all the sagas, so I thought it was a typo/mistake. Now it makes _much_ more sense. Very excited to revisit the whole musical thus far!

  • @scarecrow4611
    @scarecrow4611 2 месяца назад +8

    30:20 They didn’t fish cause they aren’t fishers they were living from Ravaging Villages and stuff (which is why Eurylichus suggested to raid the Island with the Lotus Eaters) or just from supplies.
    Tho it’s still isn’t the Smartest decision for the Warrior of the Mind not to take even 1 Person who could fish (like if he would have taken 1 person who could fish she wouldn’t have met Polyphemus)

    • @i-will-bite
      @i-will-bite 2 месяца назад

      One one hand - agree. On the other hand - I'm pretty sure he picked those who can fight, not those who can fight fish/lh

    • @MildlyPerturbed
      @MildlyPerturbed 2 месяца назад +3

      Fishing wouldn’t have been sustainable regardless, as they had to feed 600 men. Also, Ancient Greek warships wouldn’t have had to storage to store 600 men’s worth of fish.

  • @licilicky
    @licilicky 2 месяца назад +2

    I noticed that Zeus's melody(? Idk music terms lol) in Horse and the Infant comes up in Survive and Mutiny; those three songs also happen to be followed by songs where Odysseus is forced to make a difficult decision between himself and others. Horse and the Infant is followed by Just A Man where Ody chooses to yeet the baby, Survive is followed by Remember Them where he spares Polyphemus, and Mutiny is followed by Thunder Bringer where he chooses to spare himself over his crew.

  • @Punmaster900
    @Punmaster900 2 месяца назад +5

    Caspers sheer ptsd due to the wet hades and posiren hyjinx is hilarious........... also umm eurilafin anybody the fullspeed ahead part

  • @disableddragonborn
    @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад +5

    Mason's edits honestly contribute just as much enjoyment for me as your reactions. I love the wit.
    "That'll be $10"
    "These take 8 minutes each."
    13:21 "No he didn't" 😆
    The brief flash of "No" 😂
    "What is wrong with him" 40:26 🤣

  • @ChaosOnyx
    @ChaosOnyx 2 месяца назад +3

    Something a LOT of people miss in the new Just A Man, listen very very very closely to the background when the "when does a man become a monster" part starts
    (spoilers for it below)
    You can hear the mutiny motif, the violins. The fact that it's here is crazy, it makes me think of Ody trying to reason with the crew by saying I'm just a man

  • @Akajaro
    @Akajaro 2 месяца назад +2

    Y'know, I agree with that smiling thing, because there are some song where i have to keep a smile on my face, and some songs where I have to keep a neutral expression, or they just don't sound right.

  • @madog2010
    @madog2010 2 месяца назад +3

    While I would put my tier list differently I also 1000% respect and understand their reasonings. It actually made me reconsider songs like Full Speed Ahead

  • @disableddragonborn
    @disableddragonborn 2 месяца назад +2

    I think that in the new version, they had the actual voices of the soldiers (Luke Holt as Elpenor, Armando Julian as Eurylochus, etc.) be the soldiers voices. I could be very wrong, though.

  • @EternalNightDreams
    @EternalNightDreams 2 месяца назад +5

    I can't wait to see the reactions to the new Cyclops songs. I like the new versions way better. The emotions are insane

  • @Jimmy-tb9pe
    @Jimmy-tb9pe 2 месяца назад +1

    33:15 "I can't quite justify Banger with howmany songs we have ahead" For me, Full Speed Ahead is going straight into Best of the Best, It recently became my favourite song from the Troy saga.

  • @Lun1te
    @Lun1te 2 месяца назад +1

    I love that you are doing this Tier List thing.
    My ranking so far is:
    S: Warrior of the Mind, Just a Man
    A: Open Arms
    B: The Horse and the Infant
    C: Full Speed Ahead
    If we only talk about the song, Just a Man probably would be over Warrior of the Mind for me, but I just love it so much more, to sing along to Warrior of the Mind, that it is my Top Song of the Troy Saga.

  • @niewierniczka
    @niewierniczka 2 месяца назад +2

    My favourite is without hesitation "Open arms" 😊

  • @hannahmiller4930
    @hannahmiller4930 2 месяца назад +1

    Fantastic editing from Mason! Really funny additions :)

  • @CelestialMoonDragon
    @CelestialMoonDragon 2 месяца назад +2

    I don't know much about the technical aspects but the new versions are so much clearer. I don't know if its mixing or just recording quality but there's quite a few spots that I couldn't quite make out the words in the original that are much easier to understand. Zeus/Ody's bit at the end of The Horse and the Infant is just one example.

  • @StormTalara
    @StormTalara Месяц назад

    I’m soooo glad Jorge was able to re-record all this. It’s just even more insanely brilliant. Sucks that he was screwed over for it but it really elevated these first few sagas.
    In song one, not sure if you noticed the connection (because you commented how Luke’s voice rolled) but the way he rolls his lyrics, his voice rolls like thunder. Incredible.

  • @boomgirlbucko
    @boomgirlbucko 2 месяца назад +2

    47:24 Casper pulled a Mortius

  • @TheGoldenGuard16
    @TheGoldenGuard16 2 месяца назад +1

    41:21
    Hoot.

  • @JMJH1000
    @JMJH1000 2 месяца назад

    I love watching you guys react to epic and hearing you guys puzzle out where are you gonna put things. But at the same time I love hearing this hilarious custody battle over Mason happening at the same time.😂

  • @kiram.3619
    @kiram.3619 2 месяца назад

    Yes! love this dissection of the new songs! Tier list is also an awesome way to keep things fresh

  • @Okaychan09
    @Okaychan09 2 месяца назад

    Mason is so funny! I just wanted to share because you both mention it sometimes about having long videos. I absolutely enjoyed the long form of this video. You and Casper bounce off eachother so well, you stopped to appreciate all the good moments of the new songs and I really enjoyed this video. Also I was definitely yelling at my screen for some of these tier list choices :D

  • @Someone___Somewhere
    @Someone___Somewhere 2 месяца назад +1

    "a vision, of what it's to come..."
    Well, we do know odysseus still got stabbed even after dropping the baby so zeus was still right😂

  • @liminalpsych
    @liminalpsych 2 месяца назад

    I really need to watch these on RUclips as well as Patreon. Mason’s edits and comments are *amazing.* (I always run the videos in the background when they go on RUclips for the hits/algorithm support, but I don’t usually pay much attention-now I want to fast forward through them all looking for the Mason commentary)

  • @ravenscamander
    @ravenscamander 2 месяца назад

    The Horse and The Infant will always have a special place in my heart because while it's maybe not my favourite song from the whole show it immediately made me cry. On the first listen (specifically the "I could raise him as my own"). That's some raw skill from Jorge there