Try Dashlane Premium free for 30 days by clicking here bit.ly/2Jf6jgH and then get 10% off Dashlane Premium if you decide to upgrade using my code FORMOFTHERAPY
In the Comeback show, Hoony said it was him in the nude scene. He was supposed to wear underwear but did not like the way it turned out so he did it nude. The shoe scene with Mino was all his idea, too. They are fantastic!!!
Winner EXIT era for me; Sentimental, Baby Baby, Pricked as my Winner's holy trinity. My God that album was so phenomenal. Imma replace Sentimental with Serenade if one day they decide to release the studio version of that song.
Fadli Ax oh yes definitely EXIT era was something special. The whole concept and those teasers were an absolute dream (imo some of the best kpop teasers ever), i couldn’t believe we we’re getting rockstar!winner. all the songs were incredible. it’s such a shame it never got past E... but with everything that happened.. well :/ It’s weird how we still don’t have an actual release of Serenade!
@@fz7614 it's obviously supposed to be like that, but yg be trippin and keep playin with winner's emotion until it's too long to wait and then taehyun quit
At first I felt the song was a bit underwhelming but the more I listen to it, I hear something new which adds to the song. At first it sounds simple but I feel it's actually filled with layers. I'd argue it's a masterpiece of a song. And the MV is just amazing.
The first song I heard from Winner was Everyday and it wasn't my thing. Next was Really Really which I liked but it didn't get me to interested. Then Mino Fiance was good, Ah Yeah was nice, then Jinu came out with Call Anytime and that got me more interested in them. Then Soso, amazing! I am really liking Winner now! Such a talented group and great music!
This mv gave me a really melancholy feeling, and I couldn't put my finger on why. After you compared it to depression, or just kind of feeling nothing and going through life, I think that's it, that's the reason. The colors and vibrancy are beautiful. It feels like a big commentary on worklife in general, maybe for WINNER it's definitely personally related to their job being in the public eye. The side to side juxtaposition of messy crowds and then right after the alone shots invoke an Outside/Inside (my heart) kind of feeling. Especially that scene of him naked vs at the party... maybe everyone around him is just doing their thing having a great time, but inside he feels vulnerable, exposed. And seeing all of his reflections looking at himself, maybe is really a reflection/projection of his own insecurities and thoughts that are looking back at him, not the people who are blindly going about. It's such a powerful and jarring moment because you usually don't see those kinds of scenes for male artists, especially not with him looking so frail (in the lighting and posing), but those types of scenes are not uncommon in mvs for female artists (like 2NE1's "Goodbye"). The horse and shoe on the head: it reminds me of that meme of the little kid sad bc there's a boot stepping on his head, but you zoom out and it's his own and in the boot, and he's laughing about it now. In the context I mentioned above, that image is sandwiched between the images of him laying next to the horse. Maybe it's literally an imagery for "workhorse"... like you're nurturing your tired workhorse, but really it's you putting more on your head than you know. Just some thoughts I had. I love the images with the jumpsuit & spikes. I've seen hanging over spikes before, but the spikes attached by strings and he's trapped inside, that's new and such a provocative image!
when i first heard the song, i loved it till the chorus- the chorus threw me off, like ?? But when I've listened to it more and more, and feel the lyrics more and more... it makes PERFECT SENSE. the chorus exactly embodies the lyrics: it's so so, it's not full of emotion, it's not emotionless, it's in that grey middle area, not feeling much of anything, like hanging in the middle (like seungyoon's shot), occupying a liminal space of "..."
I knew this should give you more to say that their previous songs, I'm definitely happy. I really hope one day #WINNER can win your heart but if not, that's totally fine, I'm totally happy with your reactions for them anyway. Ps. PD, did you already upload your reaction to WINNER albums or something similar? Is in your Patreon or where? Thanks again for reacting to them 😊💙
I think the reason why they have been doing quite a lot of upbeat songs for the last few comebacks is that they just freaking love performing more upbeat songs. I honestly think that's why haha. I mean if you look at the songs they released from 2014-2016 (which was not a lot lol) majority of them are ballad-y type of sound especially their first album. And since they are playing more festivals and touring now, looking at their live performances, it's really obvious they loooooove performing to upbeat songs lol which I personally don't mind
PD we are patiently awaiting many reactions 😭 : Hyunah - Flower Shower DAWN - Money Akmu - Need to do listening party (G)-idle - Lion (G)-idle - Put it Straight (Live nightmare version) Nature - Oopsie my Bad Stray Kids - Astronaut Mamamoo - Hip Thank you and hope you’re well 💖
I don't get it why ppl bash on this title track. I mean, it's a huge mood plus the unique representations on how the members' feel and experience after a breakup. Also the fact that it's so artsy and dark.
hey pd just so you know, when you reacted the second time the commentary could hardly be heard over the mv sounds. idk if it's due to editing or your mic but yeah, we wanna hear what you have to say~
I have been waiting for your reaction since this MV was released. Thank you. Yeah I already watched many other reaction videos about this MV but you may be the first person who pointed out that "red" is the major color in the MV, which actually makes me think further about that. Yoon in red outfit, Mino with red hair, Hoony in red jacket / red scarf, and Jinu with red flames. I feel like I have some more homework to do to finish my review on my blog. Thank you!
knew youd love this, its one of my fave mv's in kpop. (and thats saying a lot) ps. the music is a bit loud in comparison to your voice, especially in the second veiwing. i van barely hear what you are saying.
I listened to Winner's discography first and only just saw their MVs randomly months after I discovered their music. I found SoSo MV very late. My initial reaction was exactly the same: WHAT THE FUCK The visual earned a different level of respect. They've evolved so much since their first debut and original formation.
When you combine the lyrics, the video and the song it gives off a new feel a feeling you know but can’t name it I wish PD had turned on the CC and I can hardly hear him cuz the music is so loud lol
Please react to Savage by ACE. PS. This music video is so beautiful. Though I don’t understand what everything symbolizes it really takes my breath away.
If you watch it again you see that at the beginning to the middle of the song they all were struggling and fighting back and the end they just let go and gave up because "there was no point" fighting back and then just felt whatever and so-so.
not sure if you have a system for reaction recommendations so i’m going to comment it here, REACT TO THE MV FOR DRIP BY HINAPIA!!! debut of a new gg, 4 out of the 5 members are from pristin, and the whole mv is a metaphor of the girls freeing themselves from the terrible management of pledis. it’s sooo good
the more dirt they put in yg ent the more how great their music and production express amazing videos and just keep on go beyond expectations... i dont see any yg ent music or video that pleasing to the ears and eyes that make everyone watched it more and enjoy. WinneR is really great with all their songs and as group, they are diverse as yg ent always vision to all their artists!
Please listen to the final songs from the show queendom!! The girls worked so hard for it and i think these are songs that would really bless your ears!
I like how the way you critique #WINNERs music video. Like a professional. Also, it needs to be dig dipper to the meaning of the lyrics on what's behind of that video.. Thank you for reacting this and I hope for more reaction videos to the #WINNER and other YG artists. 💙👍💙
Try Dashlane Premium free for 30 days by clicking here bit.ly/2Jf6jgH and then get 10% off Dashlane Premium if you decide to upgrade using my code FORMOFTHERAPY
I hope you could have listening party to their cross Album..
get those sponsors pd yes !!!!!
@@RosellaMacabulos yes
Please react to A.C.E. Savage
Form of Therapy PD, PLEASE REACT TO LIM KIM-YELLOW, the song is lit af and I know you’re gonna love the mv💛💛💛💛💛
In the Comeback show, Hoony said it was him in the nude scene. He was supposed to wear underwear but did not like the way it turned out so he did it nude. The shoe scene with Mino was all his idea, too. They are fantastic!!!
Artist
and the tattoo on his body in that bare scene is one of the way we could tell it's real
@@hautejhonny3849 It's real. He did it for Winner and his fans Inner circle. That's why is a W with a semi circle.
In my opinion, this is the beautiful and most meaningful thing winner has ever done, it's art.
To me So So is a masterpiece and as a Winner fan, i’m just so proud of them 💙 To me this, baby baby and fool are Winner’s holy trinity.
Oooh yes
Winner EXIT era for me; Sentimental, Baby Baby, Pricked as my Winner's holy trinity. My God that album was so phenomenal. Imma replace Sentimental with Serenade if one day they decide to release the studio version of that song.
Fadli Ax oh yes definitely EXIT era was something special. The whole concept and those teasers were an absolute dream (imo some of the best kpop teasers ever), i couldn’t believe we we’re getting rockstar!winner. all the songs were incredible. it’s such a shame it never got past E... but with everything that happened.. well :/
It’s weird how we still don’t have an actual release of Serenade!
@@poisonaga I thought that EXIT like MADE Series, E, X, I, T. I think X : Really Really T: Love me love me I : 2nd Album (?). Oh EXIT It just E
@@fz7614 it's obviously supposed to be like that, but yg be trippin and keep playin with winner's emotion until it's too long to wait and then taehyun quit
I'll sell you my soul to see an A.C.E "Savage" reaction.
June O SAME
@@kannabby I FEEL YOU!
Same omfg
Same with AB6IX blind for love 😫🙈
I totally agree! I'm really desperate to promote them, they deserve more of everything!
At first I felt the song was a bit underwhelming but the more I listen to it, I hear something new which adds to the song. At first it sounds simple but I feel it's actually filled with layers. I'd argue it's a masterpiece of a song. And the MV is just amazing.
Can we please talk about how other kpop reacters where like:" oh, I'm interested of form of therapy react to this". Know its here
I know right! I saw that too!
Yeah i saw it
Dezzy March ?? 😂😂😂😂
I can barely hear pd’s voice when the mv is playing...is it just me 😭
Same, sadly
It's the same for me. I first thought it was because I was listening on a phone but even on my computer it's hard to hear.
I'm listening to it on my pc with headphones and I can barely hear PD
No worries folks I think pd just forgot to adjust the sound from both audio of the mv and their mic
faced the same problem
"i don't seem as stoked bc im emotionless and dead inside" same
The first song I heard from Winner was Everyday and it wasn't my thing. Next was Really Really which I liked but it didn't get me to interested. Then Mino Fiance was good, Ah Yeah was nice, then Jinu came out with Call Anytime and that got me more interested in them. Then Soso, amazing! I am really liking Winner now! Such a talented group and great music!
This mv gave me a really melancholy feeling, and I couldn't put my finger on why. After you compared it to depression, or just kind of feeling nothing and going through life, I think that's it, that's the reason. The colors and vibrancy are beautiful. It feels like a big commentary on worklife in general, maybe for WINNER it's definitely personally related to their job being in the public eye.
The side to side juxtaposition of messy crowds and then right after the alone shots invoke an Outside/Inside (my heart) kind of feeling. Especially that scene of him naked vs at the party... maybe everyone around him is just doing their thing having a great time, but inside he feels vulnerable, exposed. And seeing all of his reflections looking at himself, maybe is really a reflection/projection of his own insecurities and thoughts that are looking back at him, not the people who are blindly going about. It's such a powerful and jarring moment because you usually don't see those kinds of scenes for male artists, especially not with him looking so frail (in the lighting and posing), but those types of scenes are not uncommon in mvs for female artists (like 2NE1's "Goodbye").
The horse and shoe on the head: it reminds me of that meme of the little kid sad bc there's a boot stepping on his head, but you zoom out and it's his own and in the boot, and he's laughing about it now. In the context I mentioned above, that image is sandwiched between the images of him laying next to the horse. Maybe it's literally an imagery for "workhorse"... like you're nurturing your tired workhorse, but really it's you putting more on your head than you know.
Just some thoughts I had. I love the images with the jumpsuit & spikes. I've seen hanging over spikes before, but the spikes attached by strings and he's trapped inside, that's new and such a provocative image!
when i first heard the song, i loved it till the chorus- the chorus threw me off, like ?? But when I've listened to it more and more, and feel the lyrics more and more... it makes PERFECT SENSE. the chorus exactly embodies the lyrics: it's so so, it's not full of emotion, it's not emotionless, it's in that grey middle area, not feeling much of anything, like hanging in the middle (like seungyoon's shot), occupying a liminal space of "..."
Thats "whoa" "wow" every single time make me proud😅😅
PD at low volume: The color palette in-
Video at high volume: SO SO SO SO
Me:huh, what are you saying
We INNER CIRCLE DEMAND A FULL ALBUM LISTENING PARTY TO THE MINI ALBUM "CROSS"
YES! OMG & WIND are masterpieces!
It's so mature and subtle, I love both the mv and the song. Thank you for the reaction!
This song and MV are just so RAW. The way it starts upbeat and build to the chorus only for it to drop into something so heart wrenching was amazing.
I knew this should give you more to say that their previous songs, I'm definitely happy. I really hope one day #WINNER can win your heart but if not, that's totally fine, I'm totally happy with your reactions for them anyway.
Ps. PD, did you already upload your reaction to WINNER albums or something similar? Is in your Patreon or where? Thanks again for reacting to them 😊💙
'But if not, that's totally fine' WOOOWWW THIS IS SO MATURE ♡
please, please Cross Listening Party ! Winner killed it with this comeback !
i love their comeback so much!! they really don’t know how to disappoint i love them so much !!!
The more I listen to this song/watch this MV, the more I love it. Winner is soooo good!
i like how in awe you were for hoon’s scenes
I think the reason why they have been doing quite a lot of upbeat songs for the last few comebacks is that they just freaking love performing more upbeat songs. I honestly think that's why haha. I mean if you look at the songs they released from 2014-2016 (which was not a lot lol) majority of them are ballad-y type of sound especially their first album. And since they are playing more festivals and touring now, looking at their live performances, it's really obvious they loooooove performing to upbeat songs lol which I personally don't mind
Who else is waiting for Kulture Study: GOT7’s Call My Name Album?
I struggled to hear you over the music in this video, but I still loved your commentary
before watching it, i already know pd's gonna LOVE the mv
Yes!!!! It's WINNER's best MV 💙 Love the song 💙
Still waiting for your album review perharps EVERYD4Y since its a full album.
PD we are patiently awaiting many reactions 😭 :
Hyunah - Flower Shower
DAWN - Money
Akmu - Need to do listening party
(G)-idle - Lion
(G)-idle - Put it Straight (Live nightmare version)
Nature - Oopsie my Bad
Stray Kids - Astronaut
Mamamoo - Hip
Thank you and hope you’re well 💖
Literally watched the SoSo video and went PD is going to like this I've been waiting for this video since 😂😂
This song and MV give me some real hard BigBang vibes!! And I love it!!!! ❤️🔥
FINALLY!!! Haha, I'm just starting the video but I'm hella excited for your WINNER reaction >n
I was waiting for this reaction!WINNER is art I am proud
It’s been so long :( I miss pd
do u know where he is or if something happened?
@@zhiwooyi I don't know :c i guess he's just been busy
I’ve been waiting for this.
I haven't even watched yet but the video length makes me happy 🥰I love this song and video
I don't get it why ppl bash on this title track. I mean, it's a huge mood plus the unique representations on how the members' feel and experience after a breakup. Also the fact that it's so artsy and dark.
People like to bash everything Winner puts out without even giving it a chance lol
Drinking game:
Do a shot for every “whoa”.
I feel like I would get alchohol poisoning.
hey pd just so you know, when you reacted the second time the commentary could hardly be heard over the mv sounds. idk if it's due to editing or your mic but yeah, we wanna hear what you have to say~
Immediately clicked when the notif came. Thank you!
I especially love Hoony's and Mino's part of the MV and vocal/rap soooo much…
Im agree with u, SOSO MV is the best MV i ever saw, its cinematic n artistic, n the song can be related to our daily life also
Love winner 😍
Please react A.C.E - Savage with their "Intro: Escape w/ Lia Kim"
I have been waiting for your reaction since this MV was released. Thank you. Yeah I already watched many other reaction videos about this MV but you may be the first person who pointed out that "red" is the major color in the MV, which actually makes me think further about that. Yoon in red outfit, Mino with red hair, Hoony in red jacket / red scarf, and Jinu with red flames. I feel like I have some more homework to do to finish my review on my blog. Thank you!
i would really appreciate if u have a listening party to their CROSS album
This is all I've been waiting for!
Please react to A.C.E’s new comeback SAVAGE.... wont regret it
This song.. this mv♡♡♡
I'm so proud of themㅠㅠ
Please dont forget to add their Intro : Escape w / Lia Kim. Its so important.
YES PLEEEAAASSSEEEE 😭😭❤️❤️
Thank you PD for reacting to WINNER's SO SO
knew youd love this, its one of my fave mv's in kpop. (and thats saying a lot)
ps. the music is a bit loud in comparison to your voice, especially in the second veiwing. i van barely hear what you are saying.
I clicked like before watch this video!! Thank for support WINNER!!
i love the feeling i get when i listen to this song, and i actually enjoyed it although a lot o people said they didnt like it
pd, i am sure you will love winner - fool MV. it has a very similar vibe
Winner always amazing,another level.. SOSOgood, best music best song best vocal best rapp best lyric,best visual ofcourse best MV..
I have been waiting for this!!! Thank you PD 💖
ive been waiting for this for so long thank you pd
Thank you PD LOVE your view! I knew you’d love the MV. It’s just so cinematic and arty
Take your time with life and know we are all here to support you! Enjoy Korea and feel the love!
I think this is my favorite mv of the year,
Omg I was waiting for you to review this MV, so glad you got to it, thank you 😊.
I listened to Winner's discography first and only just saw their MVs randomly months after I discovered their music. I found SoSo MV very late. My initial reaction was exactly the same:
WHAT THE FUCK
The visual earned a different level of respect. They've evolved so much since their first debut and original formation.
I can't wait for the mamamoo hip reaction
Please react to HINAPIA's debut song Drip !! Four of the members are former PRISTIN members with the addition of their hidden member.
When you combine the lyrics, the video and the song it gives off a new feel a feeling you know but can’t name it I wish PD had turned on the CC and I can hardly hear him cuz the music is so loud lol
Finally., ive been waiting on ages for your reaction 😍
WINNER ARE MASTERPIECE 💙💙💙💙
I put up and watched the whole dashlane bit in the middle for the love of Winner, lol.
Liked.
I"VE BEEN WAITING FOR THIS!
I've been waiting for these soooo long
Please react to Savage by ACE.
PS. This music video is so beautiful. Though I don’t understand what everything symbolizes it really takes my breath away.
I was waiting for this 😍
The freaking reaction i was waiting for!!! FINALYY
Waiting for dear love that others youtubers reactioners ignored 😭😭🙏
REACT TO ACE ‘SAVAGE’
IVE BEEN WAITING FOR THISSSSSSSSSS AHHHHHHH
Am waiting for ateez's listening party PD come ooooonnn
I just discovered your channel and I'm regretting that I only found this now so I'm binge watching your videos hahahaha keep it up!!
If you watch it again you see that at the beginning to the middle of the song they all were struggling and fighting back and the end they just let go and gave up because "there was no point" fighting back and then just felt whatever and so-so.
I clicked so fast 😂 finally
YOU SHOULD LISTEN TO MAMAMOO'S NEW ALBUM REALITY BLACK ITS SO GOOD
not sure if you have a system for reaction recommendations so i’m going to comment it here, REACT TO THE MV FOR DRIP BY HINAPIA!!! debut of a new gg, 4 out of the 5 members are from pristin, and the whole mv is a metaphor of the girls freeing themselves from the terrible management of pledis. it’s sooo good
SOSO's MV and the song itself is so meaningful!! Definitely one of my faves!
"Woah" "wtf?!" "shit" lmao ikr that was my initial reaction too we went from flowerish ah yeah to bold soso
FINALLY I’ve been waiting THANK YOU!!
Please do a listening party for ‘WE’ and ‘CROSS’ 🙏🏼
YES IM SO EXCITED
fyi, victon finally came back with "nostalgic night" today, hope you'll react to it soon :>>
always love MVs with storytelling!! Really like this new song
When are you going to post a reaction video of got7's comeback "you calling my name" and the listening party for their b sides
Finally winner 😍
This is my no.1 mv of winner, the song too
Yeah its the best of Winner's mv ... thank you pd for the reactio...the whole Cross album is masterpiece thanls for appreciating this Mv
the more dirt they put in yg ent the more how great their music and production express amazing videos and just keep on go beyond expectations... i dont see any yg ent music or video that pleasing to the ears and eyes that make everyone watched it more and enjoy. WinneR is really great with all their songs and as group, they are diverse as yg ent always vision to all their artists!
U should hear their debut song, EMPTY.. It's also masterpieces
Waited for so long!
Interesting video. Thank you for all those reactions. ^^
Please listen to the final songs from the show queendom!! The girls worked so hard for it and i think these are songs that would really bless your ears!
not sure if you know, but hinapia (the group with four former pristin members) is debuting with their title track, "drip" ! in case your interested !
i think your love for music it's really beautiful
PD could u please do a dive deeper into winner pls! I think there are a lot of songs that u would like
I like how the way you critique #WINNERs music video. Like a professional. Also, it needs to be dig dipper to the meaning of the lyrics on what's behind of that video.. Thank you for reacting this and I hope for more reaction videos to the #WINNER and other YG artists. 💙👍💙