Freed Israeli hostage describes ordeal after release by Hamas
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 23 окт 2023
- At a press conference in a Tel Aviv hospital, Yocheved Lifshitz has described her ordeal of being captured by Hamas.
Subscribe to Guardian News on RUclips ► bit.ly/guardianwiressub
She is one of two women returned by Hamas yesterday, the third and fourth of the hostages to be freed. Lifshitz spoke in Hebrew and her daughter translated in English. The former hostage told reporters she had 'been through hell' after being captured by Hamas fighters on motorbikes. Lifshitz described being beaten with sticks and forced to walk, but went on to describe conditions in the tunnels, where she had been treated 'more gently'. The 85-year-old was released with Nurit Cooper, 79. The pair and their husbands were taken from their homes in the Nir Oz kibbutz during Hamas's rampage on southern Israeli communities on 7 October.
The Guardian publishes independent journalism, made possible by supporters. Contribute to The Guardian today ► bit.ly/3uhA7zg
Sign up to the Guardian's free new daily newsletter, First Edition ► theguardian.com/first-edition
Website ► www.theguardian.com
Facebook ► / theguardian
Twitter ► / guardian
Instagram ► / guardian
The Guardian on RUclips:
The Guardian ► bit.ly/guardiannewssubs
Guardian Australia ► bit.ly/guardianaussubs
Guardian Football ► bit.ly/gdnfootballsubs
Guardian Sport ► bit.ly/gdnsportsubs
Guardian Live ► bit.ly/guardianlivesubs
#News #Israel #Palestine #Hostages #Gaza
When i saw this video a few minutes ago they cut out the part they were treated well. Selective reporting at its finest.
English you know it
Exactly.
i thought the same thing!
She wasn’t at a Spa day mate
Her husband is being held captive! She has to be careful what she says.
Why did you cut the part when she said they were treated like humans, had the best food and medical care and the cleanest sheets for sleeping! She also said HAMAS soldiers were so polite and respectful. Why did you cut that ???
Are you afraid that the world will know the TRUTH ?
Where can I find this???!!
חדשות 13 the full interview@@polemicist8150
Because it doesn't fit their narrative duh
Because the owners of all news broadcasts are from Isreal, they will state the truth, FREE PALESTINE 🇵🇸
Her husband is being held captive still so she can’t exactly have full freedom of speech. And kidnapping is kidnapping. This along with the many that were brutally murdered in Israel. The fact that people try to humanity the Hamas is insane to me
They cut the part where they treated her well and were very civil and patient in dealing with her health problems and needs.
Theyre still holding her husband hostage, of course she’ll give great feedbacks
@@justlookn88 lies
@@justlookn88 😂 why hee son did not say that during his interview on Israeli TV Chanel??? Instead he spoke about his mom's right to speak her mind.
Israel lies again and again.
She also shake hand before leaving with hammas armed man
They also cut the part she was hit by stick by children. They mentioned that she was hit by stick only. ISN’T CLEAR WHO ARE THE TERRORISTS????????
Does anyone think the Palestinians held captive in Israel eat the same food as their captors?
Neverrrrrr
yesterday one of the Palestinian prisoner died inside as Israeli jail, actually " tortured to death"
Did Israel cross national borders to kidnap 80 year old civilian females for ransom?
@@khaledswendeh3041lier.
Show facts. Name. Jail name. Who says that? News reported? Something?
Omar Hamza Hassan Daraghmeh, 58, from Tubas, died in the Megiddo Prison in Israel.@@nzothfatherofdream9231
Actually I have seen another uncut video where she was describing in details the medical care she was given and how humanly she was treated.
Its not like shes being nice because they hold her husband at gunpoint 😏
@@koningwillyalex9807right what a dumb excuse u got there
@@koningwillyalex9807لماذا تكذب.😡 الذلة والمسكنة
@@koningwillyalex9807nice try jan. Youre running out of excuses 😘
do u have the link?
Reporter: "Why did you shake hands with the Hamas fighters when they released you?"
Released Israeli woman Yocheved Livschitz: "Because they treated us very nicely."
Nope. Because her poor husband Oded is a hostage. He has not been released yet. She'll be saying anything the terrorists want.
Strange that they cut out the part that the lady says she was treated well.
they hoped she wasn't treated well so they can sell the story
Treated well? She was kidnapped by a terrorist group
@@Mfhollander2did you hear what she said did you see the other videos that was about this?
@@Mfhollander2 The hostage said that !
@@Mfhollander2yes believe it or not. I don’t know who is the terrorist here..
Let the mommy speak by herself and don't cut the video.
"She don't speak no English"
"And you do?!"
- Splash
Meanwhile a Palestinian from the west bank who got imprisoned in the 9th of October died yesterday in Israeli prison
Didn't see that on the news. Oh wait...
Media is playing game and making fools to everyone
I saw in Aljazeera that one of the hostages in died because of the Israeli's mal bad treatment😢
@@Luna.67. Lol imagine believing Aljazeera
@@atomik459 LOL on you because your source of information is Fox,BBC,CNN etc.
the fact that they cut the parts where she said she was treated kindly and had food, water and health care provided to her is crazy to me, not only are they lying but now they are doing it so shamelessly. truly disgusting
the guardien being manipulative? what a rate sight to see
this is sarcasm in case sarcasm flew over the guardian's team
Her daughter has said that at 0:41. Besides, her husband is still in captivity
@@buttcheeksguy sadly its not sarcasm. and i believe the guardian team already know what they are and apparently they dont mind. the first time i watched the video it had all the parts, second time they edited it heavily thats when i posted this comment. nows the third time and they edited it again still some parts are missing
@@_aidid the first time i watched the video it had all the parts, second time they edited it heavily thats when i posted this comment. now's the third time and they edited it again still some parts are missing
@@momolamiarosa4905 I think you watched another video with similar title from the same channel
the full interview on (חדשות 13) she said that they were treated like humans, had the best food and medical care and the cleanest sheets for sleeping! She also said hamas soldiers were so polite and respectful. and they were very friendly
That's why his husband is still under captive .
and why you don't talk about the palestinian prisoner, born in 1998, from the northern West Bank, was killed in “Ofer” Prison today ? and Omar Daraghmeh also was killed in the israele prison yesterday
yesterday .@@gargimandal5992
They have also got her husband still as captive. You can literally see she is shaking and has tears in her eyes... If you were treated that well why would you be behaving like that.
@@lewisbrown5527even if her husband is still captivated, another woman and her two kids said she had the same experience they never hurt her nor her kids and she went out and spoke that truth.
@@rosee6006 Did you miss the part when she said she was beaten by sticks ? It’s all a PR stunt by the Iranian government. You need to actually open your eyes.
We saw her happily shaking hands with Hamas!!!! They are just trying to find something 😂 she was treated well.
17:00 “While she was being taken she was hit with sticks.” Look how frail she is. They beat her with sticks.
@@eh1702maybe she’s old? Has that crossed your mind?
We heard one of the first hostages say Hamas didn't shoot civilians but that the IDF did!!!
IDF KILLED their own guys go listen to Yasmin porat
This woman Yasmin porat was an hostage from Hamas and her interview can be seen her on RUclips just search for Yasmin porat and see for urself
The media didn’t show what the old lady said. They didn’t show how the old lady got treated, shared food and provided nurse to check their health. It’s pathetic media.
Maybe she also has family and people still as hostages and has to talk nice so they don’t get killed?
@@someguy2771nah g people are waking up u carry on sleeping
@@randomvideos4everyone261 what are you on
@@someguy2771and what are you on with the 'maybe' ?
At least she said the truth ❤
But they have power to amed the truth 🥲
She and her husband used to drive Gazans to israeli hospitals.
@@MB-cd7eoRespect for her. But why did Gazans need a ride before 7th October? 🤔
@@ineedalawyer1240gotcha moment
@@ineedalawyer1240he ain't coming back from that one
This is not the full interview. They edited parts where she talked about her treatment and how she was given medical attention. This is selective reporting. Please upload the entire interview if you want us to respect your journalism
Show the full video. Guardian blatantly ignoring the facts.
Hamas looks more humain than Israël army
Truth tellers preach truth and liars preach lies. Thanks to grandma.
Maybe she also has family and people still as hostages and has to talk nice so they don’t get killed?
@@someguy2771I doubt it, the whole world knows the truth now that Benjamin Netanyahu is a war criminal
*TRUTH cannot be hide for long.* The world is blinded by MAINSTREAM (double standard) MEDIA. 😑
@@someguy2771 Wait, when they get released & tell the same, what will be the reaction of people like you.
@@someguy2771 Source: Trust me bro
She also said that she was treated well and thanked and shook hands with HAMAS before leaving.
YOU EDITED THE VIDEO TO REMOVE THE PART WHERE SHE SAID SHE WAS TREATED WELL.
Yes, they did remove that part
Maybe she also has family and people still as hostages and has to talk nice so they don’t get killed?
@@someguy2771 Who knows her intentions, but it's her story to tell, not the Guardians.
@@SimplyHalalLife well, the guardian is smart. Cutting out all the lies
@@someguy2771 Again, if she's lying that's her choice but it's HER STORY not the Guardians. What you're saying is incredibly dumb.
She literally said, I was treated well!
I saw a video of her release where she shook the hand of her captive. It was truely powerful viewing
we need peace in the world
Yeah because she has likely been threatened with the death of her husband if she did not comply. You can see she is shaking and has tears in her eyes?
@@lewisbrown5527 yeah of course shes shaking , were you not then while got captured or in a session with lots of people whos she didnt know ? f to you watch this video again and tells me again with the same excuse
@@badrulamin8013 in the uncut video she also explained how she was beaten in the chest
Don't forgot she is 85 years old ......
@@gaelh3621 which source tell me , in fact now cnn news has revoked again their false acusation .
They conveniently cut out parts where they admitted to being treated well…selective reporting…
Why did the Guardian just edit out the part where she said she was looked after? 🤔
for the same reason I stopped reading the Guardian about 7 years ago
Maybe she also has family and people still as hostages and has to talk nice so they don’t get killed?
in the other a Palestinian hostage in the Israeli prison has just died last week
They cut the part where they treated her well and were very civil and patient in dealing with her health problems and needs. SHAME on the Western media
She was treated well … what does it signify.. they let her go… and you are bombarding and killing innocent people where there is no come back… 😢
People: ‘She’s too old and didn’t speak truth and scared of her relatives in captive’
‘Not one prisoners released and told that they were treated badly’
BS
Try being imprisoned by Israeli and see whether you will get better treatment!
Have you seen anyone released from Israeli prison and said that they’re happy? Oops they never made it alive.
I just wanted to see the part that they cutted out about being well treated.
This People are taking lying to another level.
funny how you didn't show the part where she
waved goodbye and shared a handshake with a
hamas fighter
Really? You cut the most important part. Shame on you!
Wait till she finds out what Israel did while she was gone...
Why do you cut out the parts where she said she was treated nicely?
Why dont you also report about those 5000 Palestinians in Israeli prisons among which 170 are minors and 33 women. Are they not humans?
I’m so confused, the same guys that killed babies looked after a hostage and gave her cheese. What am I to believe?
It was a lie from the Israeli media. No child was killed. Al Jazeera revealed the source of the lie from a soldier. The White House denied this news.
The truth. You have to seek out yourself. Get as much information as possible from both side and you'll know.
Her husband ia atill there so thry forced ger to say that
Believe the first hand account of the hostage and not lies made up by the media.
@trueselfshinethrough wow really that's what you think . Oh please can't you see for yourself that the isrealy their murdered not hamas
There is a clip of what the mother says directly why cut that out?
Free Palestine ❤❤❤
From the world
🤓🤓🤓@@gargimandal5992
The truth will prevail, Humanity still exists. If there were fair justice for both sides there would be no war and suffering innocents and both Palestinian and Israeli people could live together peacefully.
Humantiy Exists for isreal ppl but do not exists for palestine ppl what peace u talking about ? 5000 ppl in gaza killed by Isreal air strikes include 1600children and is still going every day no food no aid no water no electricity more bombing for homes churches mosques hospitals u blind u don’t see what’s going on in gaza
The hamas massacre was horrible, and so are the Israeli bombings
*TRUTH cannot be hide for long.* The world is blinded by MAINSTREAM (double standard) MEDIA. 😑
There is no war there is only colonization by Israel fir 75 years and some resistance every now and then... media try to make it look like a war but how can you say it war when terrorist Israel are filled with weapon including nuclear and resistance builds home made rockets with pipes and drives motorcycles to attack
Our land. We Palestinians will not support people living in peace as long as they are in our land
Yet another channel that cuts half of the old woman's speech, where she specifies that they were treated well and given their medication as well a assigned a doctor to keep check on their well being
They treated her kind. Period ☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️☝️🤐
Unlike the Americans in Abu Ghaib prison in Iraq and The many more in Afghanistan.
17:00 “While she was being taken she was hit by sticks.”
YOU ARE LYING ABOUT WHAT WE CAN HEAR FOR OURSELVES ON THE VIDEO!!!!
oh, so they kidnap her to treat her kindly, ok.
Stockholme syndrome, or she was threatened with reprisals if she said anything else publicly.
They cut out the part where she said "they sent a doctor and nurse regular to see her, gave her all the medications she received at home, shared their food with us and we're friendly" even when Israel was making food and medical treatment almost impossible in Palestine
Sky news and Guardian editors have the same brain cells where they conveniently remove or cut any clip or audio to slightly alter the narrative
Everyone must be aware what the media is showing and what's cutting so we can get the full view of things.
Free Palestine.
Ok but who is talking about the 5,000 innocent people who Israel has murdered in the last two weeks? Or are their lives less valuable?
at the time a saw her offer her hand shake at the Hamas guy at the early video of her release, I know they treat her well. Pro Israel media must hate that scene.
Oh yeah for real they don't like it.
@@rakuun8986next interview they might try to control what she says
At least they are not hypocrites like the so called politicians.
Why did you cut the part ??? This is why no decent person follow your news , there no such thing as journalism!
She said they were treated very well, hostage received same food like Hamas, some hostages received specially medical care and women receive their hygiene products, but the western media keep cutting and editing the video, say the truth be human
Many claim she is being forced by Hamas to say these things, then please do explain why she revealed information about the tunnels?
what information? its well known hamas is holding the hostage in the tunnels. and she praised hamas for 'treating her well' because her husband is still held captive...
@@yanaymigdal8110her husband died 4 years ago
@@yanaymigdal8110 Publicly, she shared detailed information such as the distance she had walked, how it looked, and more, all of which could potentially be used to trace the entrance and the location where she was held.
Ita a bit out of the context of what u all saying, but, isnt the fact that she is an 85 year old woman that was taken from her own house hostage isnt enough to explain that hamas are terrorists and cannot be trusted?
@@yanaymigdal8110 you dont know that and you have no proof and the way she shaked hands with hamas soldier before leaving doesnt show anything about her being forced also hamas let go two american girls were they forced too? and the speaker of hamas said they wanted to let go two more hostages for Humanitarian reasons without compensation but the idf refused because they want to push a certain narrative
Ministry of Health in Gaza: The number of victims of the Israeli regime's attack on Gaza has increased to 5,791 martyrs including 2,360 children and 1,292 women. Israeli bombing of health facilities resulted in the martyrdom of 65 medical personnel and the destruction of 25 ambulances. Source: Shehab News
Ministry of health in Gaza is run by Hamas, that trusty terrorist group. They were caught inflating and lying about numbers of deaths when it came to the hospital. These numbers can’t be trusted. There have also been around 400 misfired Hamas rockets which fell in Gaza and killing their own ppl. How everyone accept the numbers they provide as true and accurate is ridiculous
Just curious, how is half of the population children?
@@golfer4039 The older generation die a lot younger because of malnourishment bad medical care they live in a prison
@@golfer4039because they killed almost everyone and only children are left most of those children have no parents.
Are the 500 people that Hams lied about being killed when Israel never bombed a hospital included in that number lol?
Please post the full interview, uncut
They were very friendly and shared their food.
They were seen by doctors and even given their medicine. Why are NBC News and other US news channels cutting out these parts?
Ask Isreal terrorists, how they treat innocent Palestine?
Why did you cut it, you didn’t show that they said, they were well treated and cleaned and they took care of there médecine. The world need infos to calm it and give it the truth
So you cut the part we're she said "they were treated well" ?? ...yeah about right with you isn't it
And I ain't even a supporter of those hooligans either they're both wrong in my eyes, maybe moreso Israel for occupying that land in the 1st place, but that still doesn't give hamas the right to do what they did., then again if your going to oppress people for decades, theres a saying like "you reap what you sow"...
They want to make hamas look like a bad person..... free palestine
The craziest part for me was when she says, they broke down the wall the very high-tech wall. I’ve always known Gaza was an open air prison, but to hear someone that lived so close to it openly admit that they live close to a wall where they know people were being held l. Refugees of their country is insane. It’s amazing that she’s out and safe and that they treated her well. That’s more than people can say for how that Israeli government has treated Palestinians. This is all absolutely insane.
Every freed person said that they were treated well
Only logical person here, thank you, you use your brain
Not every freed person because hundreds of Palestinians were freed from Israeli prisons with disabilities or insane. Google it.
They will not let the next ones speak like this about Hamas, how dare she, that’s not what Israel needs right now.
While Palestinian children are slaughtered every say😭💔
Why it’s Palestine children slaughtered we are writing - they slaughtered kids too so if one slaughter 2 other slaughter 10 we cannot say cry and say Israel is slaughtering - both are wrong here and humanity is missing but painting bad picture for only one is wrong and is being blind sided
@@rishu2008tiwariDon't lie to yourself, children in Gaza are dying many times more than in Israel
Почему вырезали ту част которая женщина сказала сто с ней обрашалис хорошо?
Wow they cut half of video 😂😂
Why you cut the full interview ??
I wish they could ask the 2000 children that died in Gaza what their ordeal was like ? And the children that are still traumatised by the bombs that are ongoing. Shame on the west. 😢
Lol those western media channels love to cut parts of the videos
I didn’t expect my favorite news channel to cut the important part of the interview
the lady say the truth. we can see this in her eyes
This comment section is like a Hamas rally 😂
Release the full press conference bro!
Well something doesn't add up here. How come those "terrorists" treated her well?
More than what we can said for the 2 million people in Gaza who are being starved to death and bombed out of existence.
The guardian doing selective reporting?? Who would have thought!
Wow yes the video was definitely was cut off
to everyone here praising hamas for 'treating her well'....well daaaa hamas is still holding her husband hostage what else would she say?
IDF learn something
Hamas murdered babies and families, streaming the attacks online. But the more important thing is that they treated this lady kindly.
I love when i realize that am more enlightened than most o the people who are simply sheeps to their media waitin for grass to be fed some ppl still think the babies thing is real
@@user-td4do3op2dIs there any Proof for the babies Killed or OR Maybe its a Lie told by Western media
Omar Daraghmeh a senior Hamas leader was held in an Israeli prison, he died recently. The prison released a statement saying that he died after "feeling unwell and going to the prison clinic for tests." However, they are known liars and Hamas accuses Israel of assassinating this man. If this is true; so much for Israel’s high ground.
This news channela editing real video
No doubt
Every video is edited well
You must share her mother’s speech don’t hide the truth she said that she was well treated by hamas and they were all the time kind with her and she said this is the truth that people must know free Palestine 🇵🇸
They cut the part when she says how wonderfully taken care of in there captive.. you hypocrites
And they removed the bit where he said she wa beaten with sticks.
The video is cut, the part where they treated her in humane way has been cut 😮
I wouldn't be talking bad about my captors after being released, knowing my significant other was still being held captive.
Why was the bit west they said they were treated well cut out, why? Guardian caught in the act here, shameful
I just couldn't stop looking at the guy's t-shirt "May the frog be with you".
Is it surprising that Israel does not want the hostages to be released?😂
Why would you cut out some parts of the clip? How should there be truth if truth is kept afar
They are treated well
Nice try Guardian
Guardian is not pro-palestine
@@mega99999it's pro israel so
Notice how no media were allowed to speak with the recently freed hostages? I wonder why!
She treate better as a hostage..better than what the occupiers treat the Palestinians
Peace! Live in harmony!
Ah yes true news
I'm pretty sure she said nothing about *being treated nicely like a human by hamas and did not get blown up and killed by the israelen heroes*
Why the part in which she explained that her mother was treated very friendly and was being provided with medicine and food is cut?
Why cut the footage?
Huh beating an 85yr old woman with sticks is being treated well?
I mean. Sure it would have been kinder if they had given her tea, painted a picture and not abducted her. Yes, that would have been kinder, I agree
@@TheblazingSwordlook for other videos. She says at the beginning.
@@TheblazingSwordlisten to it again this time put on your listening ears
@@nowgrownup Just type in the time stamp bruh
What is the motive of taking around 200 people captive and why they killed a lot of innocent civilians in Israel ?
My opinion: I think its to show the world what they have experienced for the last 70 years
@@himazhaneez1310 Was it necessary? Were they aware of Israel's reaction? Because in retaliation what Israel is doing is really heart wrenching. More than 5000 people died in Gaza. It seems like they don't care about the people of Gaza.
@@anikettirkey8504 And were they aware I think yes but they thought the world is kind and humane enough to stop the genocide but seems like they were not aware about the rest of the world
Well. I'm gonna ignore the Part where she said. She was beaten with sticks. Dragged and carried away on a motorbike, not to mention her husband is still in captivity, thus she isnt speaking because she would cry . Imagine. An old lady in a wheelchair beaten with sticks and put in a tunnel. But she was treated nicely though. If you cannot see through this. I don't know what to say.
Govts Doesn’t want to show this , They Don’t Want The People To Be Happy With Eachother , Politicians Wants To Divide The People And Rule
Absolutely 💯..this is the truth
An ordinary person with an impartial opinion 👍
cutting video is not going to serve you in the age of social media
even though they did cut the video it still doesn't serve their agenda, truth will prevail
What about the Israeli kids at the music festival how were they treated , and the hostages found dead the 12 year old with ,autism and her granny not to forget the hospital patients deaths. that they tried to blame on the IDF
It was the idf. Naftali confirmed it on his tweet later deleted it
Whoever was killed at that time was killed due to clashes and most likely from Israeli bullets because they were shooting at Hamas members and the hostages they were with. One of the freed hostages said that beforehand. Refer to the statements of the freed hostages and you will know the truth.
And how about the thousands of Palestinians killed for the last 70 years
Your history starts from the 7 th I guess but it's more than 70 years old
Before the hour, there will be years of deception. The truthful is regarded as a liar, and the liar regarded as truthful and there is betrayal. The trustworthy will be considered treasonous and ruwaybiḍah will speak therein. Surayj said: And ‘ruwaybiḍah’ will speak. They said: And what is the ruwaybiḍah? He said: The base wicked-doer, he will speak in relation to the affairs of the general public.