Lara is an amazing talent. The fact that she would even attempt to cover Streisand is one thing but she didn't do it under the protection of a studio she did it live in front of thousands of people and pulled it off in the greatest of ways. She's amazing. Her voice is the 8th wonder of the world. Also in this concert, she took on performing live Mariah's Vision Of Love and Whitney's I Will Always Love You and crushed them both to another level.
Her parents were in audience that night celebrating their 30th Anniversary. Can you imagine the pride her Papa felt for his daughter that night?? Just amazing.
And for her, knowing how much her parents had sacrificed for her dream... And knowing part of that dream was to sing Yentl... Then to sing "Papa watch me FLY!" It gives me shivers! I've always wondered, at the end when she gestures into the crowd if she's actually gesturing directly towards her parents just before she sings that last line. The romantic/softy/poetic part of me really hopes she is.
i cannot think of another singer now or in the past, male or female who lives their performances so completely while somehow allowing the audience to go along for the ride as well as does Lara Fabian -- for me she is the ultimate artist.
@@achimwollmershauser8328 Hello Achim, thank you for your appreciation of my reaction videos. The stricter copyright enforcement on RUclips past period has complicated things, but I hope to be back 🙂
They are both performing but not to the same thing. Barbara is explaining to a spirit to the ghost who might disapprove of her actions. Laura is pefor😢to a disappointed father who may still be living and begging to be understood.
It is odd that such a talented Story Singer never got into a musical theater play because each time I watch her live she is body and soul into the song specific character. In short she is a theatrical Singer of brilliant artistry.
I love Barbra Streisand, I know Yentle inside and out, and I also live Lara. Both versions are great , just like both artists are fantastic but different. You’re right about Lara’s performances, nobody does it like she does. More please
Lara is one of the best singer in the world. There is no doubt about it. It is only sad that the world is discovering her 20 years too late. Do not miss this one: Lucy Thomas , 17 years old in 2021. Her cover of "Hallelujah" got 5 millions views in less than 4 month... it cannot be bad. I think you will enjoy.
I have listened again for the 8th times today june 20 and my 8th times to go into tears, am crazy with this piece of Lara...makes my Fathers Day so 😊😊😊😊😊 happy thankyou thankyou
I grew up listening to barbra’s version of yentl, and if anything id say the two versions of these songs (papa, can you hear me/a piece of sky) are very similar. When i see this, i see lara having fun, fangirling over barbra who she lovingly calls ‘l’imperatrice’ :-) They both have great resonance in their range, which makes their voices so beautiful to listen to.
Amasing❤❤❤ when you said hopefull i remember one of her class ( you can write lara fabian coages star academy) she said when there is a hard time song you should sing it sith your thaught to the future like it is allready ok now. That what i understud
It's just a damn shame in the United States that hardly nobody knows her. Mix Barbara, Celine, and Cher, with the stage performance worthy of an Oscar, and you get Lara Fabian. To truly understand how great she is, just listen to other (professional) singers try and cover her songs.....only then will you really appreciate how great this woman is.
if you have time, even if it is not for a "reaction" posting but for simply the pleasure of the performance, watch Lara sing her composition "Tango" - live, of course - another of the many, many master classes of emotional involvement she feels with each song she sings --- simply amazing !!!
She shows more vulnerability more emotion and it flows with her voice, Barbara Striesand has super technique but sometimes misses the mark and though she has some emotion ie shaking her head and looking up she doesn't have that vulnerability that this woman has. Love Funny girl!
It's funny because the original never affected me at all and the first time I heard this one I damn near cried. Which shocked the hell out of me because that's not usual for me. I chalk it up to both more life lived and the effect Fabian's voice has on my neural net.
This concert is from 1998. It followed her 3rd studio album, "Pure", launched in September 1996 in Canada and June 1997 in France. Should I remember correctly, you'll find the "crazy smile" in "Je suis malade" (From Lara with love concert), near the end, when she says "C'est ça! je suis malade"...
I love that you love Lara Fabian! She also did a cover of Mariah Carey’s “Vision of Love” from this same concert if you want another incredible cover performance. Also her “Mademoiselle Hyde”, “you’re not from here” are two phenomenal performances you should check out.
You can listent to her concert in Moscow in Russia in 2017, with her favorite pianist and composer Igor Krutoy. She performs her hits and also other songs of a very famous film (and cd) "Mademoiselle Zhivago". Amazing and huge show!
I'm just here from a video of comparing lara and celine and barbara Streisand and mariah and Whitney belts and in the end of the way even celine and lara and all sing Barbara's song... but lara always the second for me she has this stamina of singing which make her close to barbara.... .. i love lara Fabien 💖 anyway.. god bless her
I love Lara and as you've said, her live performances are the best. The emotion she feeds to the audience is amazing. Loved your reaction also. Keep up the good work. :)
Hey, thank you for this reaction. I loved it. Just an add: there're more performances of her singing this medley in tldifferents dates and places. One is my favorite, it's live in 2004, she held the last note ( D5 ) in chest voice for 18 seconds, with an INCREDIBLE resonance. It's shocking!
Yes they express this a little different and I'm glad that Lara make her own version of it and not tried to copy Barbara. Even if she would have tried it would still sound different. The arrangement and her voice is different. I prefer Lara's voice, her timbre and depth suits my taste more. But both are amazing in their own way. Interesting reaction. Thanks!
Great performance again from Lara Fabian. Sean you have to listen to Lara Fabian's greatest vocal performance. His body language, the power of his voice and HIS FACE will make you vibrate and it is certainly watching a performance like this that Dimash was inspired. PERDERE L'AMORE ruclips.net/video/mcmhCfH9OfQ/видео.html
Here's a live fancam performance of hers to add to your list. You can see her speaking to the audience for the first minute and then singinging a bluesy French song while seated. Another electric "totally in character" performance. She's a chameleon. Being live unleashes her Beast Mode. 🤣 ruclips.net/video/-85T-iR7dfc/видео.html
I hear what you're saying about the difference between Barbra and Lara's performances. And I was trying to figure out why that might be other than the nature of their voices if, in fact, there was an outside reason. And I came to the conclusion that in Barbara's version we, the audience, have been experiencing the story with her through the movie. We see the scenery, the costumes, the lighting, we've been transported to that era. But so has Barbra. And she's had multiple takes to get it just right. And that can make a huge difference in delivery. You hear a lot from actors in period pieces that as soon as they put on the corset or the waistcoat that their posture changes and all of a sudden they're there in the era. Lara doesn't have that "advantage", if you will. She's wearing a very fashionable 1990s suit on a big stage with her band in a pretty big venue in modern day Montreal. Everything has to be in her mind so clearly that she can invite us into that experience with her. Barbra is incredibly gifted at what she does. And still singing into her 70s and I really like and enjoy her music. But as you've mentioned several times, and I've said it before, too, opinions are subjective and, well, subject to change. For me, what makes me enjoy this performance over Barbra's is the way Lara draws me into grief and fear and sadness with her. Barbra hasn't had that affect on me. I know she's had it on others but not me. Lara reaches inside my chest takes ahold of my heart and waits until the time she chooses to squeeze and make me cry, even weep. Even when I've heard her sing a song over and over she will have me sniffing and reaching for a tissue or my shirt sleeve to wipe away my tears. So for me, I would choose to listen to Lara's rendition over Barbra's.
I believe that Lara Fabian was influenced by the version of the duet by Michel Legrand , the original composer/song writer , with Ginette Reno at the Montréal Jazz Festival in 1986. Unfortunately the conversion from the video file to digital have butchered the synchronisation but you still can find it at : ruclips.net/video/qhgSVrOwVWM/видео.html .
If you've seen the Barbara Streisand version from the movie, it's an all different setting. I wouldn't compare both actually, there's a strong link between the two singers anyway.
I'm confused by the comparison. Barbra did this song for a movie and sang it for that. Lara is singing in a concert. Not the same thing at all. Not the same circontances...
It is true that Lara Fabian wanted to show what she was capable of at the beginning of her career. A lot of people have taken into not liking her very much at the time because of it (some people used to say she was yelling instead of singing. I never agreed with them, or let's say that in that case, I would love to be able to yell like Lara Fabian). Dimash has that in common with Lara Fabian : he has incredible technical skills and a very powerfull voice, but he still tries to impress people. Anyways, since then, she has gained confidence and now she is more in the emotion and the story telling then the vocal demo and that is all for the best :-)
![MASTERPIECE!! Arab Man Reacts to Lara Fabian - Broken Vow [LIVE: From Lara With Love Broken]](http://i.ytimg.com/vi/4EkHqOi15eE/mqdefault.jpg)
Lara is an amazing talent. The fact that she would even attempt to cover Streisand is one thing but she didn't do it under the protection of a studio she did it live in front of thousands of people and pulled it off in the greatest of ways. She's amazing. Her voice is the 8th wonder of the world. Also in this concert, she took on performing live Mariah's Vision Of Love and Whitney's I Will Always Love You and crushed them both to another level.
Barbra Streisand loves Lara!!!
Her parents were in audience that night celebrating their 30th Anniversary.
Can you imagine the pride her Papa felt for his daughter that night?? Just amazing.
And for her, knowing how much her parents had sacrificed for her dream... And knowing part of that dream was to sing Yentl... Then to sing "Papa watch me FLY!" It gives me shivers! I've always wondered, at the end when she gestures into the crowd if she's actually gesturing directly towards her parents just before she sings that last line. The romantic/softy/poetic part of me really hopes she is.
Lara Fabian is a world star and will remain so forever!
i cannot think of another singer now or in the past, male or female who lives their performances so completely while somehow allowing the audience to go along for the ride as well as does Lara Fabian -- for me she is the ultimate artist.
Yes, she invites us in to share it with her.
She is 27 here (1997). Lara is just one of those artists that is better live. This cover always gives me chills, she is really feeling it.
world class.........lara is amazing
An extraordinary performance by an extraordinary singer and performer. Lara Fabian is a legend.
Hello Northern Lights, I miss your reaction videos 🙂
@@achimwollmershauser8328 Hello Achim, thank you for your appreciation of my reaction videos. The stricter copyright enforcement on RUclips past period has complicated things, but I hope to be back 🙂
@@northernlights9814 I hope you will find a way to be back with more reaction videos 🙏
They are both performing but not to the same thing. Barbara is explaining to a spirit to the ghost who might disapprove of her actions. Laura is pefor😢to a disappointed father who may still be living and begging to be understood.
there is no other Lara
i am quickly learning that.
It is odd that such a talented Story Singer never got into a musical theater play because each time I watch her live she is body and soul into the song specific character. In short she is a theatrical Singer of brilliant artistry.
I love Barbra Streisand, I know Yentle inside and out, and I also live Lara. Both versions are great , just like both artists are fantastic but different. You’re right about Lara’s performances, nobody does it like she does. More please
Caruso by Lara!
Lara is one of the best singer in the world. There is no doubt about it.
It is only sad that the world is discovering her 20 years too late.
Do not miss this one: Lucy Thomas , 17 years old in 2021. Her cover of "Hallelujah" got 5 millions views in less than 4 month... it cannot be bad. I think you will enjoy.
I have listened again for the 8th times today june 20 and my 8th times to go into tears, am crazy with this piece of Lara...makes my Fathers Day so 😊😊😊😊😊 happy thankyou thankyou
I grew up listening to barbra’s version of yentl, and if anything id say the two versions of these songs (papa, can you hear me/a piece of sky) are very similar. When i see this, i see lara having fun, fangirling over barbra who she lovingly calls ‘l’imperatrice’ :-) They both have great resonance in their range, which makes their voices so beautiful to listen to.
Amasing❤❤❤ when you said hopefull i remember one of her class ( you can write lara fabian coages star academy) she said when there is a hard time song you should sing it sith your thaught to the future like it is allready ok now. That what i understud
Watching this song I can hear Barbara singing although I have never hear her sing it. Love this what a voice ..... ❤️🤘🇦🇺
It's just a damn shame in the United States that hardly nobody knows her. Mix Barbara, Celine, and Cher, with the stage performance worthy of an Oscar, and you get Lara Fabian. To truly understand how great she is, just listen to other (professional) singers try and cover her songs.....only then will you really appreciate how great this woman is.
yet again, loved your reraction
CutNPaste i agree i agree with you man!!!!
Lara Fabian broken vow next
I agree with you. If this was sung in the same fashion as Je suis malade, this would have been a completely different song.
if you have time, even if it is not for a "reaction" posting but for simply the pleasure of the performance, watch Lara sing her composition "Tango" - live, of course - another of the many, many master classes of emotional involvement she feels with each song she sings --- simply amazing !!!
She shows more vulnerability more emotion and it flows with her voice, Barbara Striesand has super technique but sometimes misses the mark and though she has some emotion ie shaking her head and looking up she doesn't have that vulnerability that this woman has. Love Funny girl!
It's funny because the original never affected me at all and the first time I heard this one I damn near cried. Which shocked the hell out of me because that's not usual for me. I chalk it up to both more life lived and the effect Fabian's voice has on my neural net.
Hello
I understand and fully agree with your analysis
barbra and lara two
very great singer but with different characteristics
This concert is from 1998. It followed her 3rd studio album, "Pure", launched in September 1996 in Canada and June 1997 in France. Should I remember correctly, you'll find the "crazy smile" in "Je suis malade" (From Lara with love concert), near the end, when she says "C'est ça! je suis malade"...
Salut, en écoutant cette vieille version de Lara,on se croirait dans une comédie musicale avec plusieurs voix,André
Amo a Lara, me encanta como interpreta 😍😍
I love that you love Lara Fabian! She also did a cover of Mariah Carey’s “Vision of Love” from this same concert if you want another incredible cover performance. Also her “Mademoiselle Hyde”, “you’re not from here” are two phenomenal performances you should check out.
You can listent to her concert in Moscow in Russia in 2017, with her favorite pianist and composer Igor Krutoy. She performs her hits and also other songs of a very famous film (and cd) "Mademoiselle Zhivago". Amazing and huge show!
Am I watching a play? This keeps me agitated and at the edge during the whole show, with all mixed feelings.......awesome Lara,
I have to agree, it was really something special to watch. It was a lot like theater
I'm just here from a video of comparing lara and celine and barbara Streisand and mariah and Whitney belts and in the end of the way even celine and lara and all sing Barbara's song... but lara always the second for me she has this stamina of singing which make her close to barbara.... .. i love lara Fabien 💖 anyway.. god bless her
I love Lara and as you've said, her live performances are the best. The emotion she feeds to the audience is amazing. Loved your reaction also. Keep up the good work. :)
Hey, thank you for this reaction. I loved it. Just an add: there're more performances of her singing this medley in tldifferents dates and places. One is my favorite, it's live in 2004, she held the last note ( D5 ) in chest voice for 18 seconds, with an INCREDIBLE resonance. It's shocking!
Yes they express this a little different and I'm glad that Lara make her own version of it and not tried to copy Barbara. Even if she would have tried it would still sound different. The arrangement and her voice is different. I prefer Lara's voice, her timbre and depth suits my taste more.
But both are amazing in their own way. Interesting reaction. Thanks!
Great performance again from Lara Fabian. Sean you have to listen to Lara Fabian's greatest vocal performance. His body language, the power of his voice and HIS FACE will make you vibrate and it is certainly watching a performance like this that Dimash was inspired. PERDERE L'AMORE
ruclips.net/video/mcmhCfH9OfQ/видео.html
Here's a live fancam performance of hers to add to your list. You can see her speaking to the audience for the first minute and then singinging a bluesy French song while seated. Another electric "totally in character" performance. She's a chameleon. Being live unleashes her Beast Mode. 🤣 ruclips.net/video/-85T-iR7dfc/видео.html
Yes, perfect suggestion for a Cut N Paste reaction!
I hear what you're saying about the difference between Barbra and Lara's performances. And I was trying to figure out why that might be other than the nature of their voices if, in fact, there was an outside reason. And I came to the conclusion that in Barbara's version we, the audience, have been experiencing the story with her through the movie. We see the scenery, the costumes, the lighting, we've been transported to that era. But so has Barbra. And she's had multiple takes to get it just right. And that can make a huge difference in delivery. You hear a lot from actors in period pieces that as soon as they put on the corset or the waistcoat that their posture changes and all of a sudden they're there in the era.
Lara doesn't have that "advantage", if you will. She's wearing a very fashionable 1990s suit on a big stage with her band in a pretty big venue in modern day Montreal. Everything has to be in her mind so clearly that she can invite us into that experience with her.
Barbra is incredibly gifted at what she does. And still singing into her 70s and I really like and enjoy her music. But as you've mentioned several times, and I've said it before, too, opinions are subjective and, well, subject to change.
For me, what makes me enjoy this performance over Barbra's is the way Lara draws me into grief and fear and sadness with her. Barbra hasn't had that affect on me. I know she's had it on others but not me. Lara reaches inside my chest takes ahold of my heart and waits until the time she chooses to squeeze and make me cry, even weep. Even when I've heard her sing a song over and over she will have me sniffing and reaching for a tissue or my shirt sleeve to wipe away my tears.
So for me, I would choose to listen to Lara's rendition over Barbra's.
lara fabian :caruso
The reason why this sounds Disney to you is, she is really annunciating and ending all her words. You can hear hear all the consonants.
Next please react to her vision of love and I'll always love you from the same concert😎😍😍😍
You definitely must react to "you're not from here" ruclips.net/video/tIY2Dfqcnvs/видео.html ,epic song, one of her best.
I believe that Lara Fabian was influenced by the version of the duet by Michel Legrand , the original composer/song writer , with Ginette Reno at the Montréal Jazz Festival in 1986. Unfortunately the conversion from the video file to digital have butchered the synchronisation but you still can find it at : ruclips.net/video/qhgSVrOwVWM/видео.html .
your over/under on the number of " Tony's " Lara would have won if she had chosen to perform on Broadway /// my number is 7
Please! Can you react to Caruso by Lara Fabian.
If you've seen the Barbara Streisand version from the movie, it's an all different setting. I wouldn't compare both actually, there's a strong link between the two singers anyway.
that's because Barbra couldn't sing like this anymore by the time she made Yentl..still good but not at here peak.
I've always thought that Lara was a better singer than Barbara.
I'm confused by the comparison. Barbra did this song for a movie and sang it for that. Lara is singing in a concert. Not the same thing at all. Not the same circontances...
You can also see this version, newer, if you want to compare : ruclips.net/video/0_Bqg9pGPek/видео.html
She doesn’t have a vibrato on long high key notes! Only Barbra can do it!
I have a new request for you: "Vincent Marcus Rapper Impressions (Dr Dre, Eminem, Biggie & more)"
ruclips.net/video/qivzSa_rWa8/видео.html
My take: Barbra's version is better acted. Lara's version is more for showing off vocals. I think this version is over-acted.
It is true that Lara Fabian wanted to show what she was capable of at the beginning of her career.
A lot of people have taken into not liking her very much at the time because of it (some people used to say she was yelling instead of singing. I never agreed with them, or let's say that in that case, I would love to be able to yell like Lara Fabian).
Dimash has that in common with Lara Fabian : he has incredible technical skills and a very powerfull voice, but he still tries to impress people.
Anyways, since then, she has gained confidence and now she is more in the emotion and the story telling then the vocal demo and that is all for the best :-)
@@laurebarrault66 I agree with you. I might add that Lara has never shouted. Never ever.
Barbra's version was directed and filmed and recorded, not sung live, I believe.