The recorded version of Secret Oktober is by far the finest single piece of music that Duran Duran ever made. It's not debatable. It's just a fact. Period. Regarding this video, there are many live versions from the 3 tours in 1997-2001( Ultra Chrome Latex and Steel, Let It Flow, and Pop Trash) but for me this is bar far the best. So simple, so pure.
It's an interesting song and it may be "the finest single piece of music that Duran Duran ever made" for you but definitely not for me. A song put together in a hurry to become the B side of _Union of the Snake_ , with Nick Rhodes firing up a drum machine plus some sequencers and Simon Le Bon improvising a melody on top. It's a song with no hook, musically childish with 3 chords and with nothing innovative into it. Compared to wonderfully written, performed and produced songs such as The Reflex, Union Of The Snake, Shadows On Your Side, Vertigo, Downtown and What Happens Tomorrow this appears just what it is: a song made to fill a place.
When I ran into bassist John Taylor whilst doing auditing work in Hollywood, I explained to him how much I enjoy THIS song! John is my favourite DD member but ironically my fav DD song is Secret Oktober - which doesn't have any basslines!
I was at this show! Loved getting to see them in a theater size setting! Kind of wish they would have reworked this version with Warren for Danse Macabre,
I was there! About 6 bodies back. Maybe 4th DD concert.. won a ticket through a fan contest! Felt so blessed to see them again. Met Wes Wehmiller out in the hallways after the show.. :( 🙏 Warren really did add so much musicality to their range of style and songwriting through those years: methinks he got far from enough credit for his contributions, even from me, back in those times, and since. Most of all, of course they hadn't likely played this song live before (or at least not that I'd seen), so this was an Extra-Cosmic Treat. THANK YOU DD, and thanks to scorpion09 for the post!!
These are the moments that make DD concerts the best... when they dont play over played songs like Hungry Like the Wolf and Girls on Film. My favorite moments are when they pull the rare or obscure stuff for the true fans, not the ones who just know the first 3 albums singles. Thats what I didnt like about their current 2016/17 tour. It was just a greatest hits tour.
What I like about the mini tour they did this year in the states is that they pulled some out of the closet (Seventh Stranger, Chauffer, Friends of Mine)
for me, this has been a signature song ... I don't know what Simon's relationship is to this lyric, to the song .... but I've always fancied that it's personal for him, simply since his birthday is an October one, as mine is ... it's been this dreamy sort of anthem that's been there as a Stillness throughout my life. Thank you all yet again, Simon, John, Nick, Roger and Andy and your various partners in musical expression .... what a gift for us all
Meno male che sono tornati ad essere al meno in 4 della formazione originale...vedere questi video in cui ci sono solo Simon e Nick ricorda un periodo triste
They made this totally Pop Trash...one would never know it was Seven and the Ragged Tiger ...unless, of course ,you knew it was from the extra on the 12 inch of Union of the Snake...weird for me to hear it in this context. I saw them for this tour.. they didn't perform it. An extra lyric...pretty cool guys...pretty fuckin cool!
hmmm. I wondered that as well. I always thought Warren was saying; "wait for it, wait". but - I could be totally wrong. I was there that night of this show - but it was so long ago - I couldn't recall. you just may be right about him saying something about the lights. also - thanks so much for uploading this video. this brings back so many happy memories for me. plus - I always LOVED this version of Secret Oktober. well - i love the original - but prefer this version. it's so beautiful.
I have had this mp3 forever - had no idea there was a matching video!!! You take the best sex of your life, mix it with a hazy and perfect breeze and you have this song.
Wise on a birthday party In a world Full of surprising fireworks And sudden silence Lies on a stranger's bed The new day breaks Like a speeding train On an old friend Ever expected, But never knocking Holding your own In a battered car All night parties Cocktail bars And smile When the butterfly escapes The killing jar
Warren and AT so much better than current guitarist!!!!!!!!!!! Warren was best to me.....he must have come up with the idea of the effects he's using on the guitar - totally different to the original recording. Sounds like flanger effect?
He left the band a couple of years before this and didn't return again until the original line up re-united for the reunion concerts that preceded the Astronaut album.
I do love this version; Simon's silky voice - Corr!!
sexiest version of this song i've EVER heard! holy crap!
I love the way this version captures the rich textures of simons voice
I wanted to be Simon as a kid. :)
Beautful, BIG & innocent eyes.......
omg Warren, you are amazing, so much passion, so much power, unique, just you and your guitar... i love Duran Duran and I love you
Warren quit Duran Duran a long time ago!
Filipe Matias lebramos a isse homme
Do you like andy? Andy and warren
Warren is planned to play for DD again 24 years after this performance
The recorded version of Secret Oktober is by far the finest single piece of music that Duran Duran ever made. It's not debatable. It's just a fact. Period. Regarding this video, there are many live versions from the 3 tours in 1997-2001( Ultra Chrome Latex and Steel, Let It Flow, and Pop Trash) but for me this is bar far the best. So simple, so pure.
I agree!!!!
John Rappaport Warren really does the song justice here.
It's an interesting song and it may be "the finest single piece of music that Duran Duran ever made" for you but definitely not for me. A song put together in a hurry to become the B side of _Union of the Snake_ , with Nick Rhodes firing up a drum machine plus some sequencers and Simon Le Bon improvising a melody on top. It's a song with no hook, musically childish with 3 chords and with nothing innovative into it.
Compared to wonderfully written, performed and produced songs such as The Reflex, Union Of The Snake, Shadows On Your Side, Vertigo, Downtown and What Happens Tomorrow this appears just what it is: a song made to fill a place.
op is an idiot. there is no FACT when it comes to music
@@adamlewis5073 that's the point you fucking moron and obviously I know that. I'm having fun wit my opinion.
The man asked for honey ! You gotta love Simon. I could live in this song forever
@5:33 Simon's gettin' all Jim Morrison on us!
Love Simon’s screaming
Y'know what else is great about this? The absence of glowing rectangles in the audience.
Beautiful song, my favorite DD song❤️ Simon's voice is haunting❤️
Warren's contributions to D2 is sorely missed... this and Save a Prayer from that same tour were absolutely spellbinding... he is missed. :(
Simon is such a poet...amazing lyrics...always!
robbelliii This song is actualy Nick's :d
robbelliii Nick is the poet 😍🥰
Simon wrote it, that is.
Simon Lyrics, Nick syn
When I ran into bassist John Taylor whilst doing auditing work in Hollywood, I explained to him how much I enjoy THIS song! John is my favourite DD member but ironically my fav DD song is Secret Oktober - which doesn't have any basslines!
Which totally explains why this version has a bassline .... (this is possibly one of my favourite versions of any track, ever)
I can't get enough of this ❤
Bellissima voce di Simon 💞😘
Never get enough of this song, it;s got everything in it!
I love that I share October birthday with Simon
LOVE this version....so slinky and theatrical!!
I love what Warren does with the guitar line here ... symphonic treatment ... spatial expansiveness
Mistrzostwo świata i tyle co mam do napisania 👍👍👍
Bellissimo Simon ♥️ e bellissima canzone, è davvero molto carino con quel cappello da cowboy 🤠.
My favorite DD song. 🔥
A great song from the best band in the world
I was at this show! Loved getting to see them in a theater size setting! Kind of wish they would have reworked this version with Warren for Danse Macabre,
me either , is like i want just close my eyes and enjoy it ... this version so powerful so haunted get me so exited ...
I was there! About 6 bodies back. Maybe 4th DD concert.. won a ticket through a fan contest!
Felt so blessed to see them again. Met Wes Wehmiller out in the hallways after the show.. :( 🙏
Warren really did add so much musicality to their range of style and songwriting through those years: methinks he got far from enough credit for his contributions, even from me, back in those times, and since.
Most of all, of course they hadn't likely played this song live before (or at least not that I'd seen), so this was an Extra-Cosmic Treat. THANK YOU DD, and thanks to scorpion09 for the post!!
WOW! Never expected to see this, I was at this show!
This is so brilliant so dreamy, sexy and i love Simon in that hat too :P
Everything with Warren sounds perfect!!!
so intoxicating... love it
Thank you Nick for your love of Halloween and for the idea of a Halloween album ! What a phenomenal album !!!!
I was at that show. Simon had a bit of a sore throat. At one point he took a drink of water and sprayed it all over the crowd. And I caught his cold.
Same! I was about three people back from stage left! I remember just standing there with a wet face glowering at SImon.
Orgasmic, melting me everytime , i love you warren
this is the best version ever of this song , melt me , make me fly ... i love so much this ! awesome warren !! i love DD
Warren rules, fucking good performance, perfect sound, dark atmosphere
i have this bootleg and i hear it all the time , amazing set list , awesome warren for ever the best
These are the moments that make DD concerts the best... when they dont play over played songs like Hungry Like the Wolf and Girls on Film. My favorite moments are when they pull the rare or obscure stuff for the true fans, not the ones who just know the first 3 albums singles. Thats what I didnt like about their current 2016/17 tour. It was just a greatest hits tour.
What I like about the mini tour they did this year in the states is that they pulled some out of the closet (Seventh Stranger, Chauffer, Friends of Mine)
They did “Hold Back The Rain” in Vegas @ The Chelsea, December 2017
Fantastic! 🎶💋🎶
The greatest hits is how you indoctrinate the next generation, though.
because i can never get enough or tired of this !! best SO version ever !!! only warren !
i love love love this !!! amazing warren , for ever the best
i never get tired of this ! melt me
for me, this has been a signature song ... I don't know what Simon's relationship is to this lyric, to the song .... but I've always fancied that it's personal for him, simply since his birthday is an October one, as mine is ... it's been this dreamy sort of anthem that's been there as a Stillness throughout my life. Thank you all yet again, Simon, John, Nick, Roger and Andy and your various partners in musical expression .... what a gift for us all
amazing amazing amazing!!!!
This is one of their many masterpiece that's so underrated it's beautiful and awesome
One of my fave Duran songs!!
@RXRom4 yes i cant get enough of this , make melt pure passion pure art !hugss
Amazing version, the absolute best!
I can't ever get enough of this... awesomeness.
my favorite version ! i have this in mp3 and can;t get enough of it , awesome warren ! i love it
I can't get enough of this. Amazingness. Makes me feel like melting every time
Amazing Warren. Love this ,then, now and always
Meno male che sono tornati ad essere al meno in 4 della formazione originale...vedere questi video in cui ci sono solo Simon e Nick ricorda un periodo triste
Warren!! You are amazing!
Duran Duran forever 💜
I have NEVER seen Simon in a cowboy hat, until now! Well.........I guess there's a first time for everything. .......
Wow, a six minute version! One of my all-time favorite songs. Thank you for uploading.
yes yes ! i love this !! for ever warren the best !
@RoccioDD I am back again watcing again for the 100th time. I don't get sick of it. LOL
I love when they just do music
Love this song sicreat october ! so power!
This is bliss !!! Loooooooooove love love this song. I'm fllying..🥂.
Thanks for posting this! I saw this live in Phila., PA back then and was blown away when I heard this, loved how they changed it up!!
Only just came across this, excellent version, would have loved to have seen this tour.
So beaytiful...I beeded this to understand better...thank uou!
RIP Wes..
Mistrzostwo świata !!!!! DD
They made this totally Pop Trash...one would never know it was Seven and the Ragged Tiger ...unless, of course ,you knew it was from the extra on the 12 inch of Union of the Snake...weird for me to hear it in this context. I saw them for this tour.. they didn't perform it. An extra lyric...pretty cool guys...pretty fuckin cool!
hmmm. I wondered that as well.
I always thought Warren was saying; "wait for it, wait".
but - I could be totally wrong. I was there that night of this show - but it was so long ago - I couldn't recall. you just may be right about him saying something about the lights.
also - thanks so much for uploading this video. this brings back so many happy memories for me. plus - I always LOVED this version of Secret Oktober. well - i love the original - but prefer this version. it's so beautiful.
Think you so much
Superb
VERYNICE 👍
I have had this mp3 forever - had no idea there was a matching video!!! You take the best sex of your life, mix it with a hazy and perfect breeze and you have this song.
Adoro questa versione
Que de souvenirs j'adore
@RocioDD It certainly is! I uploaded this version awhile back, but I'm glad to see someone has offered the live video!
i just feel like melting ... so sexy so soft so amazing ... like warren ... for ever duranie !
Wise on a birthday party
In a world
Full of surprising fireworks
And sudden silence
Lies on a stranger's bed
The new day breaks
Like a speeding train
On an old friend
Ever expected,
But never knocking
Holding your own
In a battered car
All night parties
Cocktail bars
And smile
When the butterfly escapes
The killing jar
minha mãe ama muito
Wow! look like featuring Robert Smith , in the and feat Jim Morrison
Oh Man I can imagine the Cure covering this..it would be unbelievable
Increíble la profundidad ,.guau..Esta es la prueba de que la interpretación puede cambiarlo todo. La versión original no tiene nada con esto.
This is such a beautiful song... I miss Warren too.
Whoosh! 😍💋
I have an autographed (by Nick) drum head from this concert!
@RocioDD I second that! Warren really stood out with his playing in DD. =D
The bests performance ever.
Bellissima canzone che non è apprezzata come dovrebbe essere
Great gunshot at 4'15👍
*melt*
Sorry Simon, I won't tease anymore, we know it's your birthday, Happy Birthday!
I sure want to ride that Cowboy!
Warren le aporta a esta versión, esa atmósfera dark con el sonido tan distorsionado de esa Gibson, único Warren y se lo extraña.
👍
Warren and AT so much better than current guitarist!!!!!!!!!!! Warren was best to me.....he must have come up with the idea of the effects he's using on the guitar - totally different to the original recording. Sounds like flanger effect?
Pucci Cinzia Novembre 1963😀😀😀
"Lights Alex light" i think
Why is there no john taylor at this performance? I did read in his book about a time he punched a glass and couldnt play.
He left the band a couple of years before this and didn't return again until the original line up re-united for the reunion concerts that preceded the Astronaut album.
Pucci Cinzia Scorpione Simon Lebon 😀😀😀
What was the date of this? Which HOB was it?
Not the same without John there. He is the glue that keeps them great! This is not great!
Warren is the best from DD