Supreme Court of Appeal: Interview of Judge M Makaula - Judges Matter (October 2022)

Поделиться
HTML-код
  • Опубликовано: 5 окт 2022
  • Judicial Service Commission October 2022 interview of Judge Mandela Makaula for a position on the Supreme Court of Appeal.
    Judges Matter is a South African non-profit organisation dedicated to encouraging broad-based public engagement with the important process of selecting the judges of the superior courts of South Africa.
    For more info: www.judgesmatter.co.za

Комментарии • 16

  • @africamymotherland5962
    @africamymotherland5962 Год назад +2

    Hard luck my Homie. Maybe it was not your time👏🏿✊🏿

  • @monwabisisimon8861
    @monwabisisimon8861 Год назад +2

    They crushing him he won't be appointed

  • @agreementmokoena2299
    @agreementmokoena2299 Год назад

    Good judge Maya to expose him nothing to hide anything no favorites at all on this work

  • @clementmabunda3131
    @clementmabunda3131 Год назад +2

    Talk about being on the hot seat...

  • @shusshus8487
    @shusshus8487 Год назад

    Was that an interview 😳? Or what?

  • @littleKasuni
    @littleKasuni Год назад +1

    Was this an Interview or a disciplinary committee dressing down session ?🤣

  • @msimelelo1000
    @msimelelo1000 Год назад +2

    He is not arrogant at all. He was just responding to the ambush he found himself in.

  • @sandisomtshotshisa9861
    @sandisomtshotshisa9861 Год назад +1

    This Judge is not serious...SCA is not a child's play.

  • @shusshus8487
    @shusshus8487 Год назад +1

    Malema didn't have questions for him ? I wander what's in his mind.

    • @Thabzalzk
      @Thabzalzk 9 дней назад

      They had huge altercation in previous interviews hence he had no questions for him. Justice Makaula is very strong human beings

  • @thembamayinga
    @thembamayinga Год назад +6

    Was it necessary for Justices Maya and Petse to attack and humiliate Judge Makaula? Could they not have argued during deliberations why they thought he wasn't fit and proper for the position? By the way, have you noticed how they structure questions to their preferred candidates?

    • @monwabisisimon8861
      @monwabisisimon8861 Год назад

      It's politics

    • @tankisomoeketsi6163
      @tankisomoeketsi6163 Год назад +1

      They had to put those questions to him because they are not allowed to raise issues during deliberations that they did not raise with the candidate in the interview. The questions you label as attacks are meant to determine the person's suitability. Some SCA candidates like Judge Meyer had smooth interviews because they performed well during their SCA acting stints. Watch judge Makaula's interview where he was trying to be a JP and you may notice how good he is at running away from responsibility. ruclips.net/video/hG-3DsRQ9T0/видео.html&ab_channel=JudgesMatter

  • @shusshus8487
    @shusshus8487 Год назад

    He's not going to get a job. Malema answered already.