Does Roundup Harm Soil? 🧿️🌽🧿️ How Soon Can You Plant After Spraying?
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 9 июл 2020
- Simple experiment shows what happens when you spray Roundup on soil.
Become a better gardener, Subscribe: ruclips.net/user/Gardenfundamen...
Share with a friend: • Does Roundup Harm Soil...
-----------------------
Free Stuff:
Free Garden eBook: 24 1/2 Garden Design Ideas:
www.gardenfundamentals.com/24-...
-----------------------
My Books:
Garden Myths:
www.gardenmyths.com/garden-myt...
Building Natural Ponds:
www.buildingnaturalponds.com/
Soil Science for Gardeners
www.gardenfundamentals.com/so...
------------------------
Free Resources:
Garden Fundamentals Blog - lots of gardening information:
www.gardenfundamentals.com/
Garden Fundamentals Facebook Group:
/ gardenfundamentals
My Garden Myths Blog:
www.gardenmyths.com/
Building Natural Ponds Facebook Group:
/ buildingnaturalponds
-----------------------
Recommended Playlists
Seed Germination - Everything you need to know:
• Improved paper towel a...
Garden Myths:
• Epsom Salt Myths - lea...
-----------------------
Does Roundup Harm Soil? 🧿️🌽🧿️ How Soon Can You Plant After Spraying?
A weed is sprayed with Roundup and them bean seeds are planted every two days to see how Roundup affects their germination and growth.
List of Credits:
Images:
All slides and videos belong to GardenFundamentals.com or are public domain images, except for the following:
Subscribe button by Shamsullah shams khan khiljee: commons.wikimedia.org/wiki/Fi...
Music:
All music public domain or by Kevin Macleod: incompetech.com/music/royalty-... 
Хобби
I remember when crops were rotated though after roundup a couple of seasons the crops kept getting fewer and fewer according to statistics This makes sense from your experiment though because if the spray is used after it seed in the ground it will kill the seed/plant etc. However, in a rotation of continuing this glyphosate is still found remaining in fibrous soils which continues to produce less crop.
The soil is continually diminished as well after every harvest. How are you determining a reduced crop is from glyphosate while excluding this factor from the equation?
Great demonstration. Thank you.
Thanks for another great vid! Glad to know I'm not the only one who is down on air "fresheners."
Great news I want to start a veggie patch but was concerned as I used roundup a few years back, now I know I can move forward with my plan without worry.
Thank you for experimenting and posting out results.
Thank you for this! We're about to replace our lawn with pollinator-attracting plants & needed this exact information.
Good video. Glyphosate is typically a foliar herbicide with poor root uptake. It can slow down plants directly seeded after treatment, but in general if you spray the weeds and not the seeds, they'll do fine. Thanks for standing up for the facts and the science.
Glyphosate is also a hormone disruptor & kills natural micro biome in human stomach
Succinct and informative - thank you
Thanks for sharing very interesting ❤️🙏🏽❤️
thanks for your video!
Thanks for giving us the heads up. I want to use a small paint brush with diluted glysophate on to eradicate nut grass in my veggie patch before it gets out of control. I reckon the same thing use it only when absolutely necessary and sparingly as nut grass is impossible to get rid of. Mulching does not stop nut grass. Digging it up does not stop nut grass.
add some liquid miracle grow at 1 teaspoon per gallon and the nutgrass will absorb it better. And add a surfactant
Thank you for this helpful video. We really struggle w Bermuda grass here and Round Up has always been one of the few tools to help us manage it.
Informative! Non-biased, and you addressed many of my questions & concerns clearly & simply.
THNKS MUCH! 🌱
Thank you. I needed this.
My Black Bamboo has been killed all alongside my fence I’m almost positive something like Roundup has been poured over the fence. How can I get it checked.
great video sir
Farmers I know , spray the roundup out directly in front of the seeder and they still manage to grow fantastic canola,bean,pea, vetch,wheat and barley crops without any problems, been doing it for nearly 30 years now .
I bet that's not all they spray !
Meaning what, ? Idiots put cocaine up their nose, others smoke hemp, others use LSD and the list could go on , no one cares about that , so ?@@MyKharli
Well dotn forget there glyphosate resistant crops are extremely common
Curious how glyphostae would affect well drinking water if used as a cut stump and apply with a brush method, not spraying folliage.???
That’s great explanation. Thank you
Robert, Joe L’ampl recently had the expert witness against Monsanto Dr. Chadi Nabhan, on the podcast. So frustrating and I emailed him to please have you or another individual who can present a counter view.
Thanks for your work!
This ‘myth’ has not been busted. But, for those who are concerned... my understanding is that planting various types of daisies and sunflowers in contaminated soil, will ‘detox’ the soil. There are many benefits to using sunflowers as a cover crop or a crop to plant in any ground soil or raised beds where roots will reach into the ground. But, daisies were the ones that were pointed out as having the best ‘detox’ ability. I was told that they were used in soils around Chernobyl for radiation. I heard about this about ten years ago and seems like I tried looking into this a few years back and couldn’t find anything about it... but, if you use daisies as a pre crop... it’s not like you are going to make matters worse.
You are getting very confused. Chernobyl was not a Roundup spill. It was radiation, which has nothing to do with this video.
Plants won't detox soil from glyphosate. As you can see from the video - roots don't absorb it very well.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 I experience it in garden - some weeds grow like on fertiliser... I found few dead bees so not sue if plants doesn't absorb some 💩 from it anyway... :]
@@SiwaBuddaglyphosate is an herbicide, not an insecticide
Blame it for killing bees just cross the line of Chemophobia
I’d like to see the follow up on how well the beans produced. My neighbors spray round up so much I wonder if they put it on their morning cereal. I guess they are bad ass huh? One neighbor widely sprays it while her dog is st her side. I think she is an idiot. But I digress. This past year the neighbors sprayed a ton. So much that I went inside because the fragrance was so strong. This year everything in my vegetable garden is small and a lot has hardly produced at all. No peppers to speak of. No beans or peas to speak of. Unhealthy sunflowers too. Even the butternut squash is about the size of a baseball. And although the Brussel sprout plant is tall, it’s not forming Brussel sprouts. Right now my cucumbers have a lot of blossoms but so did the acorn squash and the pumpkin and out of it all there has only been one small pumpkin. I’ve seen tiny pollinators doing their jobs. So yah I’d like to know how well those bean plants ended up producing.
The plants would grow normal. Spraying soil is different than spraying growing plants.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 would you eat those plants or the fruits from them? My neighbour soaks roundup on our property line and it leaches into our garden. We are suffering from lymphoma. Damn right we are certain it's his passive aggressive deliberate poisoning. Lawsuit in the works.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 surely your shill handbook can provide a better answer than that! 😂
@@user-pb2jp5sg8c Chemical firm Bayer is to pay up to $10.9bn (£8.8bn) to settle cancer claims linked to its Roundup weedkiller.
Roundup has been proven not to cause cancer and farmers know it and love it. Roundup is much safer than many of the pesticides organic growers use. @@peterburton3095
I love how you did this. Better than using buzz words and playing on hysteria.
thank you very much... i have a row of arbortivaes along my back yard and have a ton of weeds creeping toward my property from my neighbors neglected jungle. i want to spray them back but im worried about runoff... this has helped me strategize, thank you!
Thank you for the information
Great video! Love your outlook and I agree those air fresheners for indoors are not only not great for the environment they smell disgusting.
Thanks for the very informative video!
I ain't taking my chances with that crap.
I planted Hollyhocks after 1 week in soil that was sprayed with round up I have never had Hollyhocks grow so big in my life the tallest one was 19ft tall
I have been using roundup for my home backyard, but not concentrated as instructed from the product label! I recently planted maize seeds in the ground and just after that I sprayed on top of it, but the rate of germination still at maximum, and the new plants still growing normally and healthier, also I used once with knapsack sprayer after the maize after 6 weeks to control the germinating weed, but carefully not touching the Maize plants, also it worked well. The Maize are still growing well and without weeds.
That's because the corn (maize) is genetically altered to be resistant to Round up! That is the entire PURPOSE of Round up. The problem with Glyphosate is it's persistence in the environment and it's unintended consequences on other life, including humans (leukemia, etc).
2 things...Why didn't you mix the soil after spraying (to simulate cultivation/till)? Also...If Glyphosate binds to the soil then why does it show up on soil tests, water tests, tissue tests, produce tests, etc. etc. ?
1. Glyphosate is not intended to be "mixed" with the soil, but absorbed by health leaves. You probably are thinking about another herbicide
2. About the tests you mentioned, I do ask you to after the authors and find out their political ideologies and religious/mystical beliefs, please
Anyone know how long it stays on hard surface before rain washes it away.
Useful information. Thank you
I have Roundup sitting around for a few years. Will it still work?
Yeah it will still work in a hundred years 😅
What is confusing is that the only measure of whether the plant has been effected by glyphosate is how the leaves look. What about testing for any harmful toxins within the leave when consumed or when the plants fruit has been infested. You can’t possibly suggest that the health of the leaves (which is undoubted a good variable) is the ONLY way it could be harming the other things that grow out of the soil, or the things that touch the soil.
Exactly! Just because the leaves "look" healthy does not mean anything.
Wouldn't the burden of proof work the other way around though? I agree that it would be fantastic for someone to do more research like this, but from a speculative point of view: what harm should we be looking for then? Assuming there is harm when there are no signs of harm is a fine place to start when asking questions but perhaps not when jumping to conclusions.
@@rammcconnell would you mean the proof that Glyphosphate destroys the biome of the human gut which had been shown. So I'm guessing what your saying is we should just say since the plant looks fine we can consume it even though it may contain a poison that can harm us?
@@rammcconnell an 11 billion dollar class action lawsuit leads me to err on the side of caution for this chemical. Clearly there are consequences to using this chemical. This is also Monsanto, which if the devil himself was a ceo, it would be for Monsanto. I couldn’t care less if it was bought by Bayer.
@@rammcconnell The documented cases of cancer. The class action law suits. There is plenty of alleged harm from these chemicals. And the assumption of no harm doesn’t work as well. Just ask yourself, would YOU be willing to be the test subject to see if it causes harm. It protects everyone to assume harm, then test, rather than to assume no harm, and find out later it’s causing cancer. It is the same principle in the medical field, do no harm first, then test.
Definitely wouldn’t use on plants I consume, but yes I’ve seen people smoke the yard and put grass seed down after a few days and a lush lawn after month
Should have sent the beans to be tested. To see if the round ended up in the bean seeds.
Thank you!!!! 😊
Can I add Roundup directly to my drinking water as well?
Comparing the LD50 for both substances, table salt is twice as toxic as glyphosate
So if the soil absorbs round up is it safe for food to sustain your family garden or will it go into your food and into your body?
Once it is absorbed to soil, very little is absorbed by roots. Keep in mind that it is less toxic than vinegar. If you ingest it, it passes through your gut without being absorbed.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 hands up, I love your channel. However, for the sake of knowing, I would be interested to see the results of experiments which look into the effects of these chemicals on our microbiome. The human microbiome is currently mirroring the Earths loss of Biodiversity and I would be very concerned about these chemicals affects on our microbiota flora and fauna.
Chemical firm Bayer is to pay up to $10.9bn (£8.8bn) to settle cancer claims linked to its Roundup weedkiller.
@@peterburton3095 Roundup has been proven not to cause cancer and farmers know it and love it. Roundup is much safer than many of the pesticides organic growers use.
Good vid. Generally agree with the 'science' but especially your disclaimer about avoiding, if possible, using any chemcial. But sometimes it's a necessity. We must also keep in mind that science is always evolving and our understanding advances with time and new data. What may seem harmless today may not prove to be so as new data appears. One wonders who is really investigating these products and are the reserachers neutral. The real harm done to society by this chemcial is economic, especially in poorer regions of the world where the necessity to marry roundup with genetically modified seeds tailored to roundup has often proven fatal. I've read that thousands of Indian farmers have been driven to poverty upon the promises of the chemcial system, and many have taken their own lives. Science, like life, is complicated.
Your post is ignorant. Roundup HAS NOTHING to do with Indian farmers suicides and they continue to use the herbicide year after year.
Setelah rumput dibunuh dengan round up..mengapa akan tumbuh lagi rumput,bahkan rumput yang jenisnya berbeda..apakah round up bibit rumput?
Chemical firm Bayer is to pay up to $10.9bn (£8.8bn) to settle cancer claims linked to its Roundup weedkiller.
Convincing a jury of nonscientists, esp if its "poor suffering Jim Bob vs the Great Corporation", isn't hard. As Americans we root for the little guy, and most Americans understanding of science is vague warm fuzzies.
roundup actually can't kill Philippine corn it is like a fertilizer in corn here in our farm and we don't know why 😂 and there is one kind of grass here that roundup can't kill not even dehydrate the leaves. roundup is safe but make sure to wear PPE
Thank you for your fact based presentation.
If I sprayed my entire lawn with Tenacity twice last August, would it be safe to start a vegetable garden bin April? I'm done with lawn chemicals.
You would have to research that product.
That was really good! Thanks
How dare you conduct an experiment LOL
My home in FL has many pavers, front, back & sides. The weeds coming up between then are horrible & relentless. My biggest concern on what is best to use not only for the lasting results, but most importantly is my concern for the health & well being of all my dogs and cats. Any suggestions? Hard to lock them up in the house, as they are in & out through the pet door all day up until bedtime. Thanks.
Go and buy bulk bags of desert salt.
10 bucks for 50 pounds make a 5 litre solution.
Mix in a pre emergent with the round-up- get one that won't stain your pavers.
You can neutralise RoundUp in the soil with an Epsom salt solution. Two teaspoons per liter of water
The new plants might look good... however, you don’t know if the new plants have, in their systems, some of the chemicals that were in the round up or how they are affected. This is fine for ornamentals, but I would still question whether eating a plant grown in a product that has PROVEN to cause cancer and god knows what else. There are a LOT of conditions brewing inside our bodies that we don’t know about but become problematic after years and not just in people over 65, but young adults and children. But it is difficult to pin the cause on things like this stuff. But with that said, the best way to use this product is in an ornamental landscape and spray on weed seedlings as soon as they pop up to avoid dousing the whole yard... I just moved into a house that had been neglected by the tenants and the landlord practically doused the yard with this stuff... several landscape plants are suffering. Fortunately I’m not planting food plants or medicinal herbs out there... glad to know I can plant some ornamentals now and they will probably be fine. But the danger of this chemical is not a myth in terms of how it might be affecting the food grown in it. It is a SERIOUS question that needs to be analyzed in a lab. Perhaps it has been. Hopefully I will find the results. I know of a lab that tests for metals in food... it’s on my bucket list to contact them and find out for myself how round up might be affecting food plants on a molecular level.
You do know they did not pick up glyphosate. If they did - they would die.
Where has it been PROVEN that glyphosate causes cancer? Please link the study. I can’t find it. I know that a couple of juries awarded damages to a couple of people who developed non-hodgekins lymphoma but that is far from scientific proof. It is their opinion and sympathy for the plaintiffs. I don’t like glyphosate used on anything so to convince people I need to present the evidence.
@@elsagrace3893 ruclips.net/video/NBhwqyK84U0/видео.html
Ironically it becomes fertilizer after it breaks down - glPHOSATE. phosphorus...
@@elsagrace3893 they have know hehe
toundup can kill permanent plants plz ans
Thanks for doing experiment as I need a way to get rid of weeds without bending much. 🙂 This should work
So test the leaves to see if they have absorbed Glyphosphate....just guessing is not very smart if you plan on earing them.
I think you could have gotten results with about a 10th of he glysophate.
Good information about Roundup. But if I spray roundup in my stone landscaping , would it kill my plants and bushes that are already planted and have growth? If so what suggestion do you have to kill weeds and grass in the stones and not affect my plants and bushes. Thanks, I’ll be waiting for your response before I do anything. 😊🌺🌸
Paint it on the target plant with a paintbrush.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 we can no longer get Round-up in Barbados so what other chemical would you suggest as a substitute?
I grew up a conventional farmer, never really thought to much about chemicals, trusted the fda and epa that had our best interest
At heart, Glycphosate which I have used on thousands of acres has it origin in mineral bindining in boiler pipe. It does the same thing in soil which cause higher fertilizer use as it binds nutrients in the soil. And using it as a desicant on wheat right before harvest is irresponsible as it it absorbed into the plant right before consuming . Spraying on corn, soybeans or wheat I early growth stages is one thing, they have 100nds of days to grow out of exposure, but wheat as a burn down.... no, I don't want that in my grandchildren, grow your own, and let them eat as grandma did
Z
So, are you saying that glyposate breaksdown in the soil overtime? That it is OK to use if you have well water? I've always heard that it doesn't breakdown and will seep into the ground water and poison your well. I've also worried that if you consume foods that have been grown in soil previously treated with glyposate, that the plants would retain some glyposate and be consumed. Finally, how do you know? Do you have a degree or other type of expertise? Too much out here with too many people talking about crap that they really don't have a clue about.
It breaks down quickly compared to many chemicals. It's half-life is about 45 days which means that in 45 days half of what was there is gone. It also sticks to soil, so it does not move through soil very quickly.
The information I present is science based - it comes from researchers that study this stuff - and yes I do have degrees in Chemistry and Biochemistry.
www.gardenmyths.com/truth-roundup-glyphosate/
@@Gardenfundamentals1 just a quick question. Can you explain WHY glyphosate is found in nearly everything (including breast milk)?
This guy doesn't have any medical degrees and is probably work for round up.
Scanning through this guys website makes it obvious he's a shill.
@@peterburton3095 wonder how much he gets paid by Bayer to do all this marketing. Claiming you are a scientist doesn't mean you are ethical or truthful.
We sow and spray over the same day. Everything comes nice and clean. Tried and tested on thousands of hectares.
The cancer industry thanks you.
@@OfftoShambala Even after seeing evidence you have to say something stupid.
I used some weed killer granules and I couldn't get grass seeds to grow for the rest of the year.
What kind of herbicide was in the granules? 2 4 D granuals that are used on lawn dandelions do break down Very slowly and will kill if absorbed thru the roots
Did you read the label? The fact that you just identify it as "weed killer" sounds like you have no idea what you put down.
@@marklundeberg7006 Well my story is long, let's just say that I needed to jump in and rescue our property last season and hadn't a clue. After spending the entire off season reading, watching and listening, now I know exactly what I'm doing, what to buy (or NOT buy), what's good or no-good and what works and what don't work. Now I starting off my season with my grass coming in quite beautifully from seed, I have sprinkler timers, I've used Tenacity with Johnathan Green Black-Beauty Ultra, I'm taking my time and everything is looking beautiful and the season has only just begun, I figure by August my lawns will look like Yankee Stadium. I'll start spreading Spectracide granules twice a year, in February and then in August and water it in as a pre-emergent and I'll be fine. If need be I'll change, adapt and get better at this as time goes by. But thanks.
Glyphosate does disrupt the soil microorganism communities. There is a lot of research on this. if you disrupt the soil microbiology it will have a negative effect over time, so you won’t see the damage done immediately. Soil microorganisms are what cycles nutrients in the soil, without a diversity of species of microbes in different trophic levels, you will not have plant available nutrients, and you will become addicted to chemical fertilizers which are costly. The soil microbes also play a role in soil structure, which influences air and water flow. Just seeing that plants grew after 6 days of application, does not indicate that glyphosate is safe for use or a good idea, since it disrupts the soil ecosystem, which is essential to sustainable growing conditions over time.
My experience conflicts a little with his conclusions. True that after a month plants will grow where roundup was used. Years later I can see a difference in what is now a lawn, in the area where is was used. Use with caution!!
When it gels in the ground, I see no problem. It doesn't. I wouldn't eat whatever is produced by seeds after the Roundup. I would use the Roundup on what I would not eat.
Since the glyphosate did not harm the seedling - it was not absorbed by it either - so the food produced will be glyphosate free.
If you buy veggies in stores, markets, etc , as well as eat in any kind of restaurants, you eat things grown with glyphosate.
Dont worry...most water glasses in any cafe have more toxicity by washing products then any glyphosate.
Your post is ignorant. You can NOT use roundup on any vegatable!!!! @@srantoniomatos
My Father put round up on my outdoor/indoor plants today
Just being petty do u think thy will still be alive once I get home by the end of the week ??
Probably not - depends on how much was put on them.
thanks for sane scientific information. Rare these days.
But would you eat the vegetables and beans grown in that soil? My neighbour soaks roundup through our property line into our garden every year. We now are suffering from lymphoma.
Yes - glyphosate is less toxic that vinegar or caffeine. Besides, if the plant absorbs some it will kill the plant so you know it did not absorb any.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 glyphosate is not less toxic than vinegar. Vinegar is not carcinogenic. If a plant absorbs glyphosate, then that plant, its roots and fruits (veggies) are now questionably toxic. They don't always die out Based on your comment, would you prefer to rinse your produce in glyphosate rather than vinegar? Would you substitute vinegar in your salad dressings for glyphosate? Do you not eat salads? I'm not trying to be disrespectful here. Just trying to make sense of your interesting logic.
@@user-pb2jp5sg8c right on. Also, I wouldn't listen to a farmer for medical or scientific advice.
@@Solid_Snack Robert is a gardenner and an investigator, with a science degree...
The owner of this channel sounds like a luciferian shill.
Its misuse is causing lots collateral damage .
Example please?
@@usx06240 well up my track the guy killing rhododendron with it killed all the mature trees around , i have seen tree deaths with excessive use on himalayan balsam and knotweeds . So anecdotal from me .
Nice video, subscribing
Is it safe to eat the plant like tomatoes
yes - glyphosate is not very toxic at all - and there will be almost nothing in the plant.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 explain that to the millions injured from it.
Chemical firm Bayer is to pay up to $10.9bn (£8.8bn) to settle cancer claims linked to its Roundup weedkiller.
Then why can't you grow veggies in washed herbacides drums ...warnings not to use drums or containers that have had herbacides in
1) You can grow vegetables in them. Just wash them out well enough.
2) Each chemical is different - this video talks about glyphosate - not other herbicides.
I wonder how many of you will be claiming compensation from Bayer in a couple of years..good luck to you..dont say you havent been warned
That the plaintiffs were awarded compensation is not scientific proof that glyphosate causes cancer. It means that the jury had sympathy for the plaintiffs. It means that the plaintiffs had great lawyers. I don’t like the use of glyphosate but also I cannot find studies that prove it causes illness. I keep looking because I would like to convince people not to use it. It does cause erosion by killing off all the weeds whose roots hold the soil in place. Also as a weed, such as mallow, becomes weak and poisoned they succumb to rust disease which proliferates in the field and spreads to who knows where. 🤢
I don't think this is entirely accurate. Sorry, but last year I accidentally sprayed my tomato plants with the wrong sprayer. I was in a hurry and I grabbed my roundup sprayer. It has been 10 months since I did that. I am getting glyphosate damage on tomatoes that I planted this year. So I think it does stay in the soil.
Explain then how a product that is foliar applied to to achieve a kill is taken up out of the soil by the roots.
It just doesn’t happen, just like I can’t maintain life by eating with my anus.
I think you need to consider spray drift as a possibility or a residual chemical you’ve used in the past in your soil dinging up your tomatoes. I would actually nearly put my money on the fact you are missing a micro nutrient from your soil.
If it is a soil residual herbicide you will see it by digging up your tomatoes and see damaged or distorted roots.
Most likely it’s actually 24D hitting your crop from an inversion situation in which the chemical is being applied during an inversion some kilometres away and landing on your crop by moving in that inversion layer.
This happens way too often to our cotton farmers who lose their crop from this exact weather condition.
@@brenttonks4249 It can drip into the soil from the plant.
@@dovey6259 if that’s the case you are using the products wrong. There are very few weeds that need soaking and round up is a contact herbicide which means it only needs droplets on the leaves to be effective. If you are drowning your weeds in it then you in general are over applying it and in most cases using it off label which is in most countries an offence.
That being said, clay tends to neutralise round up somewhat. This is why we are told not to use dam or dirty water in its preparation, because the clay particles reduce the products effectiveness.
Personally I try to avoid Round up most of the time, not because it’s a bad product, it’s due to plant resistance to using it too often. We have round up resistant ryegrass in parts of my country meaning that pissing on the ryegrass has a higher chance of killing it than using round up.
This resistance is all due to the turkeys who cannot read labels and use the products incorrectly, and these are the same turkeys that have given round up a bad name. Everything has the potential to kill if not used correctly, chemicals, cars and guns to name a few. Don’t fear any of them provided they are used as intended!
@@brenttonks4249 You are wrong. Ive been using Gly for over 25 years. Glyphosate will kill many weed and tree species if sprayed around the roots. I've had it kill 5' Red Oak trees in my yard
Roundup and RU ready seeds is/are one of the top 10 leading inventions/discoveries/ in the history of Agriculture. I have used RU for over 25 years on/around my fruit and nut trees. DO NOT use it around Oak tree roots. It will be absorbed thru the roots and kill the tree. I have accidently done this many times. My brother has had this happen to him also. iF the oak tree survives it may take up to 3 years before leaves are normal and growth resumes. I don't care that Monsanto says that it can only be absorbed thru the leaves. NOT True. There are other tree species that can handle it around the roots. Doesnt seem to harm Walnuts, Birches, Apple, hickorys at 2 oz/gallon hand sprayer rate but of course do not get any spray or mist on the foliage, bark or root collar. Just Guessing: maybe its killing the mycorr fungi in the soil that the oak tree roots need.
how soon after spraying can i plant anything and can i use vinegar or bleach instead
Vinegar does not kill plants - but you can use it. You can plant a couple of days after spraying Roundup.
So nice to see you dressed more like a gardener, lol, to hear you, and see you continuing the search for truth.
I've been growing roundup ready sweetcorn for years and it gives me great pleasure seeing anti herbicide/pesticide tinfoil hat wearers buying it all up saying how tasty it is.
Caffeine has a half life of 20,000 years in the aquatic environment but you don't here people complaining about that.
Exactly…….The LD of coffee is higher than the majority of herbicides, yet we all are happy to drink copious amounts of coffee.
Haven’t yet seen anyone use coffee as a herbicide or have a morning round-up.
Just saying!!!!
Dont spray herbicide if you want grow Vegetable, use alot compost instead
Are you really sure with that. I appreciate your experiment. Limiting is the key. That’s why weeds grow back in their next respective season. But we don’t tend to eat weeds. I don’t think I would like to eat veggies from my garden that I have pre sprayed with glyphosate. a good experiment would be to test how much glyphosate is in the vegetable. But you will probably get shot before the glyphosate will kill you. So let’s test that everybody.
The recommended amount of 100% Glyphosate I put on a square foot to kill a Dandelion is 16 oz per 43560 ft or .0035 oz./ft.
Grassy weeds are much more affected than broad leaf weeds as a rule.
Water containing Ca+ will Neutralize part of the Glyphosate. NH4 SO4 is added to counter this.
Using a rope wick with small amount of 25% Glyphosate will greatly reduce the
Glyphosate needed to kill.
Robert, looks like you used a very large amount of Glyphosate.
Would you mind elaborating on what you mean a bit? What do you mean by using a rope wick? Do you put the wick in the ground next to the plant? I'm very interested in what you're describing but can't picture what you're doing. Thanks
@@catsinq5726Agreed. The wicking idea needs explaining.
Glyphosate ( the active herbicidal compound in Roundup) is rapidly bound to organic material and metals in the soil and thus is inactivated.
Wow. ! Thank you! !!!
And I've also flooded my back yard like thrown new soil on top and really dissolved a ton of clay and loam down in there - thanks so much !
Yes... Glyphosate binds those metals and deprives the plants of those micro nutrients, slowing growth and rendering plants susceptible to any stress or disease. Even the decay by products will keep doing this 20 years later.... especially if you have very alkaline soil! God help you! Your remediation efforts will be slow, EXPENSIVE and have limited success. You can't even trust composted leaves of trees affected by this stuff. Your compost will recycle this chemical to continue binding micro nutrients and slashing the growth of your future plants.
The multiple ingredients in roundup also are toxic to beneficial soil microbes and leave your soil open to be replaced by harmful ones to your plants. There is so much more going on here than is commonly known.
There is a new product that is available to farmers that was developed in recent years from breeding beneficial mycorrhizae mutations that survived in old roundup treated soil to eat the glyphosate and its associated chemicals and byproducts. Not yet available as a casual retail product, unfortunately. Only sold to farmers. Ask the Florida citrus growers. I had to watch several Don Huber videos to learn about this product. Dr. Ken Hamilton (Utah) and Dr. Frank Dean (Texas) are the original developers.
ruclips.net/video/kwdn_DVWxAA/видео.html
@@dwightchang4848 is there a link in that video description to buy it? Thank you so much!
@@hamster1169 I have been trying to respond but each time I try I get blocked.
Here’s a real scientist
Help I used 365 round up to kill my all weed yard. When may I sow grass.?😩
If it contains glyphosate - after a couple of days.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 18% glyphosate,1.6 Imazapic and0.73 Diquat.
Trust the sciencr
Glyphosate
The hormone disruptor & micro biome killer
www.gardenmyths.com/truth-roundup-glyphosate/
Ground clear kills for 1 year
???
@@Gardenfundamentals1 ground clear works good too but not for planting
Yes it’s kills the microbes
Glyphosate might be safe when properly used topically on specific plants, but unfortunately, that is not how it's being used by some farmers. They use it to dry out their crops before harvest in order to get a more consistent grade when selling their grain. They also apply it in mass over GMO grain crops to kill everything but the crop. It's these kinds of uses that are problematic. Using glyphosate to surgically kill specific plants or trees, vines and other invasive plant is extremely efficient and precise. One way to do it for example, is to cut the stem of a plant near the end of the summer and then immediately (within minutes) apply a dab of Round-Up to it using a paint brush. If you do it when the plant is drawing nutrients towards its roots (as opposed to spring when it sends them to the upper parts of the plant), then the roots will suck it up and kill the plant without a single drop touching the ground.
LoL :)
I wonder why Roundup gets such a bad rap when the real problems come from aminopyralid products.
Yes, that aminop. is really really bad news. But, round up causes cancer and god knows what else. You could look at it this way... humans can live for many years surrounded daily by cigarette smoke... and some may make it to a hundred years without any debilitating symptoms, but most people won’t. If you continually consume food that has been grown in soil where round up is actively used... what part of round up ends up in your body doing god knows what? If you feed this to your kids, maybe their behavioral problems or their asthma or the cancer they’ve developed could be caused by this... but it is difficult to pin these conditions on this stuff. The product has been proven to to cause cancer, but it is naive to think it’s not causing or contributing to a host of other problems. And not just to humans, but bats and butterflies and ants and worms etc etc etc .... and round up isn’t the ONLY one, as you point out. And maybe round up is the lesser of the evils... but it is still evil. On a different note, the company, years ago... sued a farmer (and possibly more than just the one guy whose personal testimony I listened to), who had a farm next to a Monsanto farm ... some of the seeds from the Monsanto farm volunteered on his property and the company sued him for growing their patented ‘copyrighted’ plants without ‘authorization’. Something is seriously wrong. I could say more about the testimony of others in the industry.
@@OfftoShambala The lawyers try to get you into thinking roundup causes cancer. If you thing about the advertisements, they say a jury found that it may have caused cancer. Lawyers select the least knowledgeable for a jury.
Yes I know I may missphrased my wording and my intention was confusing.
Let me clarify my remarks.
Roundup has gotten lots of bad press. I only mentioned 2-4, D as an example and it however has had a long history of usage with far less negative opposition from its use. It is a known component in Agent Orange which was used with far deadlier results. Round up has been a victim of aggressive legal tactics. Any chemical if it is not used according to printed directions could have negative consequences. Round up used according to directions should be very safe for normal people under normal conditions. Unhealthy people with preexisting medical conditions should probably exercise good judgement and refrain from any type of herbicide. Your video on Roundup is spot on and You
clearly explain the safe use and show clearly effects of proper use of Roundup on plants using scientific methods, observation and analysis.
There may be much more dangerous products in the marketplace than Roundup.
Your Gardening presentations and accurate explanations of true Gardening Science are invaluable to everyone. Thanks.
Sorry for any misunderstanding I may have caused. It was not my intention.
So big chemical Monsanto is a victim? They dont try to ruin the lives of farmers through their legal shenannigans?
you need to be a little more educated on how glyphosate work. Glyphosate is a Kelation agent that works systemically in the plant by shutting the immune system down, which is why after a few days it will bind with the minerals in your soil or if you use extremely hard water it has very little effect because it binds with the minerals in the water. Once the Glyphosate shuts the immune system down the plant extrudes the glyphosate and will kill the good microbes in the soil and promote pathogens in the soil since it is Glyphosate is an ANTIBIOTIC and the plant is actually killed by a systemic infection. Try your experiment in steril soil and natural soil and then re do the video.
Before you try to lecture me - learn how to spell Chelation.
You are spouting nonsense - glyphosate does NOT shut down the plants immune system.
If you want to learn the facts read this: www.gardenmyths.com/truth-roundup-glyphosate/
@@Gardenfundamentals1 you are basing your facts and life on a single article and negates the whole medical scientific community. Interesting
It’s poison, why would you spray it near your food
You have been brainwashed.
www.gardenmyths.com/truth-roundup-glyphosate/
@@Gardenfundamentals1 project yourself unto others much? The definition of poison is a chemical substance that harms life. Tell me again how a product marketed as a poison, isn’t a poison. The specific type of poison that it is, an herbicide, means plant death.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 something else the article (which was probably written by someone paid by Bayer) neglects to mention is the other 49% of their product. What is it? Well it’s inert ingredients, anything that doesn’t kill a plant in approx. a week, so it could be literally anything! They could legally put radioactive stuff in there and you wouldn’t know. But, you know, have fun spraying it around your food.
Why not? More money in his pocket because he can raise crops better with cancersate
More and more people are getting cancer better stick with mother nature and not man made synthetic chemicals....
Glyphosate is safe
Amazing how many people research and worry about using chemicals in the garden but then happily went and rolled up their sleeves to allow an untested chemical to be put into their bodies that will have life-long permanent effects.
Nobody puts untested chemicals in injections.
@@Gardenfundamentals1 Umm can I say vaccine
The m44ar6k of the b1ea56st. Remove the numbers.
@Garden Fundamentals Oh the chemicals have been well tested alright.
sadly, I don't think any of this is helpful at all. If I was a company worth a billion dollars my science would prove that the products I produce are safe, but if I don't have any money, I can't prove that the products are safe. Proof costs money
Who is paying You? Which gm beans did you use?
Not really a fair comment. I've watched and read plenty from Robert Pavlis now, and he seems pretty independently minded. Seems more than a little conspiratorial to think someone's out there bribing small youtubers to promote herbicide use.
Only soybeans are GMO. They are only bought by big crop growers. I think these are runner beans or climbing beans. Listen to the end and he says he doesn’t like using chemical sprays. He wouldn’t say that if they were paying him.
Robert Palvis, Master Gardener, author of numerous gardening books, curator of the Garden Myths blog. I own 2 of his books. His contribution to the world is to dispel misinformation. That's what he is doing here. He is very much against the use of pesticides, herbicides, and overusing fertilizers.
I have some fans - thanks for defending me :)
1) pole beans are not available as BMO crops - check your facts!
2) How does this test make money for anyone??
Fraser Valley Rose Farm if you don’t think something like that is happening, you have no idea how internet marketing works
आर मराठी मधै सांगत ज तुझं काय बोललेत समाजत नाही
Enjoy poisoning the soil. One program I will not be promoting. What kind of gardeners are you?
Intelligent, science-based, fact-based etc.
If you care to know the truth about Roundup, read this: www.gardenmyths.com/truth-roundup-glyphosate/
Garden Fundamentals this is not an experiment that determined whether it is a good idea to actually eat the crops grown in the soil.
@@OfftoShambala good point
@@Gardenfundamentals1 and what about all the others that you are not mentioning..I hope you also wont be one of the people claiming from Bayer for cancer...or rather your children will...
It's obvious you watched only a portion and made a emotional knee-jerk comment.
Dude nice little experiment! I love this! short sweet an proof!
RFK JR.
NEXT
POTUS
HE KNOWS OF ROUNDUP
AND WILL ACT FAST❤🎉❤