DOA Shrimp vs. Vudu Shrimp: Which Lure Catches More Redfish? (Day 1 Test)
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 28 авг 2024
- Want to stop paying full price for your tackle and get new inshore fishing spots every week? Click here to join us in the Insider Club: bit.ly/37Oz6nR
To see the gear I was using, check out the blog post here: bit.ly/3oFVqqC
The water is getting colder and that means that shrimp lures are on fire!
But here's the million-dollar question: what is the best shrimp lure?
You've got lots of options...
Gulp shrimp, Chasebaits Flick Prawn, LIVETARGET Shrimp, Z-Man EZ Shrimp...
But in this video, I pitted the famous DOA Shrimp vs. the lifelike Vudu Shrimp.
I found a hole in a creek that was filled with redfish on low tide so I was able to get a pretty fair competition going between these two.
And to my surprise, there was actually a CLEAR winner!
Which do you think won?
Find out in this video!
Have you used these two lures?
Have any other lures you'd like us to test out?
Let me know down in the comments!
Want to stop paying full price for your tackle and get new inshore fishing spots every week? Click here to join us in the Insider Club: bit.ly/37Oz6nR
I j brought the vudu shrimp like a month ago and was able to use it 2 Sunday ago , And I caught more big mangroves on the vudu then the live shrimp and Almost landed a tarpon on the vudu shrimp.
nice minnows
Vudu VS Brazilian, please...
I court a John dory with the shrimp lure good lures and sliced the John dory up in little slices and cooked it in to fish batter amazing fish to eat 😄
@Saltstrong what knot would you use/did you use? Loop knot or something different?
Trouble with these comparisons people don't use the same colour which can make a big difference.
Wondering why I was the only person thinking that.
That is very debatable.
Hey Terry! You're absolutely correct. Unfortunately, due to COVID-19, it was virtually impossible for me to find these two lures in the same color at the time I was out on the water. As I mentioned in the video, I will be using a similar color for BOTH lures on the final day (the gold DOA's you see in the pack will be used alongside the "Golden Tiger" color scheme on the DOA that caught all the reds on the first day) Hope you'll stick around to see the final day of testing!
That is exactly what I thought.
@@Saltstrong I was just noticing the difference in colors my self. I will say that I have and do fish both, but the Vudu shrimp are my favorite. Action is definitely much more attractive with the Vudu. The Pearl/Chartreuse and Purple/Chartreuse are my 2 "got to's". Great video.
VUDU made me a believer caught me my first snook the first time I used it
I have a cheap amazon reel, a cheap walmart reel, and a cabela's salt striker reel. All have been in the salt water plenty of times. The Cabela's reel was in the water for over 48 hours because I lost it when a storm came up and I was hustling to get to an island for cover. That was Friday morning and I went back out Sunday morning and found it in about three to four feet of water. I shook it off to get the sand out of it and fished with it the rest of the day. No problems and caught some trout, a redfish, and a catfish on it. The only thing I do is spray them off with the hose after each trip. I have had these three reels for over three years and haven't done anything else to them. Thanks for the comparison for the two lures. I have only used the vudu shrimp one time and damn lizard fish took the tail off within a few minutes. LOL!
DOA works great here in Florida for, Reds, Snook, Flounder, and Trout but not the pink one. Looks like he's using a pink DOA if he uses the same color as the VuDu it'll probably have different results.
Thanks for sharing!
I'm not sold on your technique using the DOA Shrimp. It needs to be fished much slower. Twitch the rod tip up and not to the side, but give it time to sink back to the bottom. You are fishing it too fast. Also, all the reds you caught on the Vudu appeared to be caught in the same spot, within a 5 or 10 foot diameter. The only cast I could see on my screen with the DOA Shrimp was at least 30 feet to the left of where you were catching the reds. Never got to see a full retrieve of the DOA, just pulling it out of the water for the most part. It appeared you were fishing out of the 'hole' the reds were in. Hard to say from the video.
Hello guys I fish the Lower Laguna Madre area and always use DOA and have great luck with trouts... I think the difference is that the Vudu is weighted at front having a faster drop ... but I think both work well depending on presentation and color
Yeah, Vudu shrimp has always done well for me from Florida to Texas!
Works great on a tandem rig
Vudu does really well in Georgetown, SC. My favorite inshore lure.
Personally I use both, usually for bigger fish in fairly visible water I use DOA, since they have a more general, bigger profile. And the VUDU I use in clear water for usually smaller fish. I think conditions means a lot, even for subtle differences.
Also, I believe the vudu is better for deeper, or faster moving water. And the DOA kills in shallow-ish slow moving tide.
The best analysis and comparison of both lures! Best Comment on this Vid! thank you
They work EXTREMELY well in fresh and brackish water for largemouth bass. In fact when I do freshwater fish .. I use Vudu and doa more than culprit worms, spinner baits or other more traditional bass lures.
Great video Wyatt! Both are great lures, but I can see how the Vudu was better in this situation.
DOA were originally created to slowly straight retrieve over grass flats. It’s a slow sinking lure so I expect the current where you were fishing took it downstream before it could sink where most of the fish were.
I definitely recommend using the same color for the next test. I probably didn’t that matter much with the stained water that you and I both have (NC/Galveston TX), but it will take away some doubt from your viewers.
I use VuDu shrimp in the Tampa Bay area and I've caught reds, flounder, snook, trout, cobia, pompano, mangrove snapper. It's the absolute best shrimp bait out there in my opinion.
Which size do you prefer
What color?
Never had luck with vudu in Tampa Bay area. But I always had luck with DOA here
@@calallen8786I’ve never had luck because mine always get melted
pinfish will bite the tail off those vudu shrimp (which is a drag) also the DOA shrimp you actually need to pull the hook up and super glue it to the shrimp or it will slide down the hook after one bite and make the presentation terrible... but a few drops of super glue fixes that problem. Although i personally feel we should not have to do that to make a lure work correctly but it is what it is i guess, i like and use both lures but seem to learn towards the DOA because having to re-rig with the vudu after a pinfish bites the tail off is a drag. Great video thanks! Texas here
Hey Wyatt, another possible difference (other than color) is that voodoo is weighted and you are not using the weighted Doa. I have actually caught many more on DOA a than the voodoo in the past. This makes a marked difference in the drop rate towards the bottom where the fish are. Darrell
Marks lures in the right color and correctly weighted smoke all other shrimp imitations for me when it comes to price and consistency w trout, reds, and flounder. While its clunky looking, Mark's research on balance, weight, and float is the most accurate presentation when compared to natural shrimp imo.
@@SoloUnoMasfishing I slay everything with a small DOA shrimp with a rattle. The big one isn't as effective inshore. The Doa is a shrimp marionette. You have to know how to work it. The scent also gives it an edge.
I'm just starting saltwater fishing and now I'm sold on the vudu shrimp. Thanks saltwater sensei. 😃
I recently went to Walmart and all they had was the tsunami tough tail shrimp. It’s weedless and the color is brown and gold. OH MMM Geee! Those things suprised me. The action is incredible. I was so surprised when I caught a nice sheepshead on it. Not to mention countless snook & jacks! If you see them try them!
I can’t wait to go redfish hunting with them!
I remember when the DOA shrimp came out and we were excited to try it. I threw them enough without any luck that I gave up on them. I got more bites my first time trying a Z Man shrimp than all the times I tied the DOA. I haven't tried the Vudoo shrimp, and the next shrimp imitations I buy will be your Power Prawns. I love how the Z Man shrimps look but I have a bad hookup ratio with weedless rigs.
Definitely check out the Power Prawns. They are an excellent lure...and not just saying that because they are ours. We catch a lot of fish with them! Have been using the FRED color lately on the nearshore reefs with great success!
How did that DOA Shrimp go from Gold to Pink and VUDO from Gold to White?.. The ones at introduction was DOA-Gold and VUDO-White/Blk striped.. Just wondering..Color makes a big difference this time of year..Nice Reds, keep up the Great Work..... !Roll Tide!
Aha, someone besides me noticed that too!!
Looks like the vudu is being retreived slow, and DOA fast, he said it was deep so the DOA wont go down with the speed. Not completely fair scenerio
Vudu shrimp is the way to go. I bought mine a month ago and I was able to use it 2 Sundays ago and Caught more big mangroves on that then the live shrimp and I almost landed a big tarpon on the vudu.
I think they work way better than doable, look more realistic too
Doa
Both those lures hold a special place in my heart I'm sponsored by vudu Mark Nichols is a good friend but you can do a lure comparison if the color scheme is not the same
Capt.Mike
I and many will report that when your DOA shrimp is torn up and the tail is gone, we remove the hook and hook through the tail remnant and it catches just as many fish. I believe the VUDU shrimp is superior though. The way it sinks and the tail action are a winner.
I knew VooDoo was winning this one before I watched it. If you've ever done or seen a side by side comparison of shrimp lures in a swimming pool, VooDoo clearly has some of the best action of any shrimp lure. Combine that awesome tail kick with a rattle and it's an obvious winner. DOA wins on most comfortable T-shirt though! Just love their t shirts LOL.
test like colors in different situations; shallow, deep, clear, stained, etc..
What is that green net you have for your kayak? I like that size and don’t know which brand that is.
I haven't tried the Vudu I got but DOA and Tsunami glow shrimp work amazing where I'm at.
I know I'm late to the party. But I just wanted to say, I use BOTH! I prefer the DOA at night, dock fishing. The DOA, skips much better and does sink slower. It also has replacment tails, which is a big deal! You can always add nail weight in the nose of a DOA, if you like! 😮
I was throwing doa and my buddy was throwing vudu 5 feet away from each other and the flounders were definitely liking the vudu more.
Thanks for the video. This was a pretty clear winner.
do you recommend rigging those weedless in that low tide flats situation? - like putting the hook tip back into the body ? Thanks for the great vid, will try the Vudu next - I am dealing with a frustrating low tide "mudflats" situation in the cedar key FL area.
Going to go buy the Vudu Shrimp tomorrow. Great video.
El DOA es un señuelo muy bueno..ahí lo q marcó la diferencia fue el peso...si hubieras puesto un jig al DOA otra historia sería...ya q la Corvina anda abajo...ademas el DOA trae orificio para una sonaja...dándole un plus y haciendolo todavía mas efectivo...saludos.
That flounder on the DOA doesn't surprise me. It seems to drop slower and more vertically.
What about the color difference? Would it make a difference in those water color conditions? Good information. Thanks!
I just bought some voodoo shrimp, and a popping cork. How far above the hook do you guys recommend that the cork be? I am thinking somewhere around 10 inches.
That depends on the depth and structure you are fishing.
Check out this video for some tips.. www.saltstrong.com/articles/power-prawn-under-popping-cork/
I've been using the VUDU Shrimp for years in Louisiana, mainly with corks. I've caught numerous speckled trout and redfish with them. Also, these baits are far more durable than most other soft plastics. Each one will last on many fish. The only drawback is the hooks, especially when you are fishing redfish. The hooks are sharp, but not very strong. So, also be careful when using pliers to remove hooks in deep-swallowed hooksets.
Hey, you probably won't answer to this, but iv only ever used live shrimp on a kale hook (with popping cork) do you need to set the hook for these Vudu Shrimp?
What about gulp?
I have done this experiment myself although opposite results. I must point out that I only fish with the gold speckle DOA. You showed it in the intro but fished a different color. I keep trying the Vudu but not a lot of results. Also caught everything from pinfish to Tarpon on the Gold DOA.
I've been using the Savage Gear shrimp and it's been slaying fish on the flats. I wouldn't mind seeing a comparison or review of that lure
Savage gear vs chase baits
Good video on technique! I will try it on flats fishing in Key West
Can’t tell you how many fish I’ve caught since I began using the Vudu...the Vudu has dominated my catches on my channel as well...
Would you suggest using the Vudu Shrimp 3.5 “ or 4” jumbo when kayak fishing?
Jumbo always
What do you use for scent?
The doa works best with the glass rattle. In my opinion the rattle is the game changer. If you tip both with shrimp flavored fish bites you’ll increase your bites more like a gulp as those smaller fish will peck at it. In my opinion, if the small fish chase the big fish will get interested.
the video was a hit. thank you wayne.
There is times when the slow fall of a DOA shrimp will get bites when nothing else will for me but I’ll admit overall the vudu is more versatile.
I like the vudu weedless shrimp far better than any other shrimp lure.
The one with the rattler in it too
Chasebaits flick prawn. Expensive but my go to
Anyone else having trouble with VUDU changing their material? Softer and pulling away from the front too easily? I went from catching dozens of fish on one to a lure now only lasting 2 hours with or without a bite.
What you can do to fix it from sliding down is pull the shrimp down and put some superglue on the shank and eye of the hook then slide the shrimp back up. still won’t help it from getting all torn up though.
Which scent did you use?
Try the doa 2.75” shrimp. They hold up a lot better.
I’ve never had good luck with artificials but imma get me a couple and go try those voodoos out
Rig 2 rods up different baits same colors and alternate after each cast.
Compare with the same color. There is clearly a difference. There was also a very large tag end on the DOA at 8:33
nice video ,very revealing ,I'm going to have to try those Vudus
I prefer the Z Man shrimp, IT Sink at a good rate. Last longer, except when blowfish are around. You can also buy replacement bodies cheep
Hey guys! could you do a comparison between vudu and chase bait shrimp video? I would be very interested in seeing that!
Hey bro, do you think the color of the shrimp played a part in your outcome? Looks like you were fishing two different colors in your test.
I've caught nice fish on both, however, Vudu has caught me more as well as nicer fish.
Good to know!
The color makes a big difference
In some cases yes in others no
Try using the same color for a fair comparison, one is red or pink and the other is sand the same as the bait in the water.
Awesome video just picked up three packs of vudus for a trip to Florida! Whats your rod and reel setup for throwing this bait? Thanks
Should have tried the same color
We'll keep that in mind!
Would have been better though if the color and weight would have been the same. Color can make a huge difference if their keyed in on a particular type of bait.
I use the DOA Shrimp with greater success. What not do is use like colors between the two Shrimp. I use the golden flake and in clear water and white Shrimp in dirty water DOA only. Also the Red flake DOA in dirty or turbulent water.
Vuduu is good and I like the Savage Gear 3D shrimp too. And they do a real good crab Ive had big sheepshead on.
Thanks for the feedback!
Test the tsunami pro shrimp like if you agree it is a better price
Hey man quick question what size rod is ideal for back bay reds? Soft plastics and popping cork? My 9 foot feels too long for fishing soft plastics back there. 5.5 too small?
Email our Customer Support Team at fish@saltstrong.com and they can get you a recommendation
Put both baits on same line kind of like a bottom rig. That's the only way to truly tell which one they prefer. .. when they have both in front of their face at the same time.
Now y would u use 2 different colors and work them differently to me seems a little bias lol
Thank you🎣
How trying savage gear shrimp vs voodoo shrimp
We'll add it to the ideas list!
You can put a rattle in them
Tandem rig works too
The doa was slid down on the hook looked like!
Vudu shrimp is like magic!
Wouldn't a better comparison be both that same color?
Good video
The vudu is use for both waters?
Great comparison! I see in your blogpost you used medium rods with fast action on 2500 reels.. Would a medium/heavy fast action with a 3000 size reel be too much to be able to cast these lighter lures as demonstrated here?
What kind of knot did u use or recommend ?
I’ve been crushing it on the 3.5 natural colored Vudu shrimp. I’ve been really happy with it.
Vudu is the go to shrimp lure for me as well
I have not had great success w DOA shrimp. About the only DOA products I like are the CAL 3.5 minnow ($$$$$) and the jerk shad.
Have you tried the Power Prawn USA?
Pausing right at the start to say I target trout when I can get down south and fish almost exclusively Vudu shrimp under popping corks. I can catch over 20 speckled trout, including a few monsters, on one Vudu shrimp, but if three 12 inch reds hit it the back half is gone. I know the DOA shrimp are much more durable, but I don't catch the trout on them. Just curious to see if the reds tear your Vudus up like mine.
Some Vudu’s will catch 100+ trout with no problem. They look like hell but still work. The hook often breaks B4 the lure tears. Toughest of the bunch for sure.
What was the size of Vudu were you using
I've caught grouper near rocks with vudu,
Where are you fishing?
winner take on the flick prawn?
Wyatt- what waders do you wear when you’re out in your kayak?
Are there any redfish down here in south florida say around the Hollywood area?
Vudu Strong all day long!!! No Cork. More action by far.
What color slam shady did you use in this video
Thanks for your question! Make sure to ask this over on the actual blog or in the Community (www.saltstrong.com/) where the coaches spend their time. The blog can be found here:
bit.ly/3oFVqqC
DOA has always done well for me but it hasn't lately. Might give Vudu a try
Gotta use them in the right scenario
Vudoo definitely gets me more fish. I only wish that tail wouldn't come off so easily. 1 lady fish and it's over sometimes.
My only issue is the fact the fish are in one isolated hole. After a fish or 2, they get spooked and you're not getting accurate results. In my experience, the doa does better in light current situations. My buddy and I usually do test year round and very rarely use the same baits unless it's a clear case of the fish wanting one certain bait/color. That's lead to some pretty epic trout trips where we get dialed in pretty quick while others struggle to get even get bit
Hope you were able to find this helpful!
D.O.A. has a glow in the dark shrimp, does glow help in medium darkness ? How much does it help if at all ?
It helps a little because of the tint more than the glow itself. It’s just a good color
I love your content man!
What setups are you using
Will the Shimano vanfords be in stock before Christmas?
extra days yes PLSSS
Day 2??