Yom Kippur War | 3 Minute History
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 3 янв 2016
- Thanks for the 17,000 subs. And thanks to Xios, Alan Haskayne, Lachlan Lindenmayer, Derpvic, Seth Reeves and all my other Patrons. If you want to help out - www.patreon.com/Jabzy?ty=h
Yom Kippur is a special day here since not only is it a religious day of fasting, but there is a tradition here for pretty much everyone to stay disconnected and not drive or use any sort of electronic device(you can find pictures of empty main roads in Israel absolutely abandoned during Yom Kippur).
You could imagine the shitfest that occured when the army started rolling into towns and picking up the men while they were fasting and didn't know that anything happened since they kept thier radios and TV's off for the day.
***** hi
***** No, it was like another Dresden.
***** hey you were the one asking the question.
***** vignette1.wikia.nocookie.net/p__/images/d/dd/Saitama_OK.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20140324041430&path-prefix=protagonist
In Kazakhstan?
I don't think its the amount of information that is compressed into a small amount of time or the art of these videos
as I see it your videos are very good because of your neutrality you briefly explain what was in that time without adding any commentary finding not biased historians is quite pleasing, just facts
Great job i like the vids keep up!
+Rustams Nilobekovs Cheers man
The Great Emu War in 3 Minutes...
May not be very interesting, but it's quite hilarious!
+buddyltd A couple people have recommended that.
I think you should have emphasized more about how important it is that they attacked on Yom Kippur.
Israel is basically shut down for a day in Yom Kippur, the roads are empty, much of the population don't eat or drink, or use electricity. So there was a bit of a shock throughout Israel.
+Stannis Baratheon That's fair.
Stannis Baratheon but dont forget that america gave them food and medics and weapons not for egypt
@stannis , i'm an israeli(means i'm pro-israel) but in tactics everything is valid, including attacking on yom kippur, the problem was that israel thought all arabs are morons and they lack of any capability and just by hearing "israeli army" their balls are shaking so we weren't prepared. we learned many lessons from that war.
Supposedly the selection of the date had to do with tides on the Suez Canal. I've read that attacking on Yom Kippur backfired:
(1) Attacking on the holiest day of your opponents calendar was a PR disaster although it was also during Ramadan.
(2) Most Israelis were home and full mobilisation of the IDF proceeded more quickly than it otherwise would have.
The streets of Isreal were quiet on yom kippur aided the mobilization of the Isreali army...
Jabzy...you managed to do in 4 minutes ,what took documentary makers, almost an hour
to produce. You da man !!!
Excellent video. Golda Meir was prime minister, not president.
Yeah, quite a few people have called me out on that one
:)
People who know which states have a ceremonial president and a strong prime minister and vice versa should wash my dented balls. But you're right. Sharp lady. Great leader. Looks like Ben-Gurion with hair though. B*tch was ugly.
Ben-Gurion used to call her "the best man in the government."
Please take yourself and your -5 IQ and go straight to hell. The world doesn’t need your negativity. Thanks :-)
"remain disputed to say the least" best explanation of the Israel-Palestine conflict
Uaegamers, dumbass
This is literally what Zionists fabricate to say that Palestine belongs to them... The situation is very clear... It is the last direct European occupation till this day... and like the others, it will fall sooner or later
@@AhmedKhaled-wc3kh have u forgotten america. jews were4 there first and are there now. israel has more muslims in it than all muslim coutries combine have jews in them despite israel being 0.04% of their size... facts dont lie buddy go cry elsewhere. start wars on holy days outnumbering ur enemies and still lose... shameful
@@AhmedKhaled-wc3kh bruh shut up
Videos are still amazing, Good on ya mate.
+james mcloughlin Cheers man
Great video as always! Can't wait for the next one. BTW when are you going to do the Philippine-American War?
+Ace Panda I'm terrible at organizing these videos so I'm not too sure. I mean today I've been researching the Dutch flag, the Carlist Wars and the First Gulf War. Plus, I break away every now and then to find some interesting stuff to talk about when I go traveling next month. So if you know any mildly interesting stories (myths, peculiar battles, forgotten books - absolutely anything really) from Japan, Korea, China, Mongolia, Kazakhstan etc. please let me know.
Well for info about (North) Korea I know that they have some mythical creature for their national animal, for China dragons are supposedly the controller of all waters and the most powerful and divine of all creatures in Chinese Mythology, for Kazakhstan there are three juz (tribes/hordes): The Orta juz (middle juz), Uli juz (Great juz) and Kisi juz (Junior juz). For Japan I know that Melons are seriously expensive and that you have to learn ALL of the manners in Japan since (as we all know) there are weird things and different things in Japan. For Mongolia, well I don't know much except that they have two main ethnic groups: the Tuvans and the Mongolians and that the almost forgotten battle of Khalkin-Gol between the Soviets and the Japanese happened in Mongolia. For stories, well for Japan you can check here: www.pitt.edu/~dash/japan.html#mirror for Mongolian stories check here: danielroy.tripod.com/cgi-bin/alternate/mongolia/tales-stories.html and well that's it from me. I don't know much about stories so I do apologise. Thank you.
+Jabzy My history teacher told me Alexander the Great most likely didn't have offspring because he was homosexual, I haven't heard it since (don't know if it's true or not) But maybe that would be an interesting topic?
+Ace Panda Thank you so much
Don't worry about it. :)
This is a great neutral purely historical account of what happened, thank you!
great video!! it's better to watch your 3 minute videos than an 1 hour long documentary
The long documentaries are more detailed
So if you want to know more documentary are your best sources
these are banging. Best thing for revising for tests :)
I think when you said artillery on one occasion, it should have been anti-air systems.
For Israel it was the 3rd war for their survival in 25 years. But that was over 40 years ago and they haven't had another war like that since.
Not really, the Yom Kippur war was an attempt to get Israel to give back the land they occupied in the last war, and for Egypt it worked, that for the Sinai back.
And the war before that? It wasn't a war for their survival, they were the ones who initiated it.
+Siddiq Ismail Egypt got it back because of the peace talks not the war and there regretting it now
+jack cohen What? No, there were no peace talks before the war. Egypt used the war to force the Israelis back to the diplomacy table.
And how are they regretting it? They have full control of the Sinai canal, and even built a secondary canal recently.
+Siddiq Ismail , If the war was to get the land back then what was all the talk about having lunch in Tel Aviv next week, and turning the med sea red, and all that other nonsense.
Sounds like Arafat with all the talk to cnn about peace and then going to his office with a picture of one country on the wall.....palestine. He was a failed terrorist just like nasser, assad were failed leaders.
Egypt was offered sinai back right after the 6 day war, in exchange for peace. Nasser and the arab world said no.
Also,
how was israel initiating '67 war, egypt cut off the straight of Turan and massed 100k soldiers to the border. Same with syria and jordan. Israel just hit the knock out punch early.......
Saddat was a great man, he later understood that peace is more important and made peace, he got the sinai back too. Now look at Assad, dead and recognized as a killer and his son is barely holding power now. That's the difference between them.
***** Anwar Sadat was realistic, his intent was to force Israel back to the diplomacy table to get back Egyptian land, and it worked. A short war with minimal losses, and the achievement of their goals was a major pride/prestige boost for Egypt.
wow the IDF reversed the initial grim situation when they were outnumbered
bullshit, Sadat wan't a dictator...he didn't want to destroy Israel, and his only way to bring israel to the diplomatic table was war
I saw you in the last video lol
@@trollgemomo3823 Israel has a Conscripted army too
Its kind of a recurring theme in the IDF
They are the legendary but not admitted of the world because of the hatred toward them. Sadly though, Israel is genius military and technology. How much American do to Arabs? None. Only Israel defeat them.
Ace video, lots of good pictures of individuals of recent vintage (I like your choice of Henry Kissinger to represent the USA). Cool hardware too, the MiG-19's are nice but my favourite has to be the Israeli Centurion's with the retrofitted 105mm cannons!
+leakycheese Once again, good spots.
They were fasting and they won,impressive Egypt
TROUBLINGBIRD 2103 Israel’s were literally x2 in numbers and in tanks and airplanes how do u even have the audacity to sneak attack someone like that with multiple countries backing you up. Only the weak attack like that
TROUBLINGBIRD 2103 typical sore loser. U attacked Israel how many times? How many times did u have more soilders than us? More developed weapons? More money more size more everything. U guys claimed u are going to give the European Jews coming into Israel a second holocaust. U guys tried to target people that have been trough hell and got spanked by the Israelis.
Don’t deny the existence of Israel because as a fact. When u guys were fighting the British in ww1 my grandpa(fully Israeli guy) fought amongst u guys and was known as a Israeli by u guys. You’re morale isn’t on anything the truth is. Israeli wars especially vs u Egyptians whilst u had other counties and insane numbers on us in every aspect are literally 1000 dogs compared to 500 lions. You’re morale isn’t one to be proud of considering you’re history. Especially after we beat u so hard into surrendering and recognize the state of Israel and making peace with us. U guys killed you’re own president because he simply made peace with people defending themselves. Try to step out of you’re one sided perspective and look on both sides
Allahu akbar
H Qazi Not even one soilder who isn’t Israeli fought amongst the idf. The enemies of israel at this war were supported by the USSR and China giving them big amount of high tech weapons Israel barely had a chance against
@@Daniel-xj7yp yes but, America always supports it's little dog and you know what I mean
Second Lebanon War (2006) please! Thanks for the good work!
+Waffen Tot Thanks, but I'm afraid it might take a wee while. I have too many scripts on the go at the moment.
@@JabzyJoe
did you ever get around to it
These are quite helpful, thanks!
That's what happened in the war of 1973. Egypt had West Sinai after the war before the ceasefire. The war ended with Egyptian forces maintaining control over the whole East side of the Canal (West Sinai) except for small corridor that Israeli forces could exploit due to Egypt retreating the South Suez Canal battlefront in favor of aiding Syrian army. The plan for Israel was to use this corridor and pass to the East bank of the canal seizing control of the biggest Egyptian city on the West bank of the canal to cut-off the Egyptian army in Sinai, this plan was a failure however due to Egyptian special forces (Thunderbolt Forces) holding-off Israel and heavily damaging the infiltrating Israeli brigades. At this point the United Nations ordered a ceasefire after which Egypt and Israel went through a peace treaty resulting in Israel retreating from Sinai and Egyptians getting back their land.
2 egyptian armies were encircled in sinai and israel crossed the cannal forcing the egyptians to deploy UN troops to save their assets
@@gapa1556 false
@@jesesitofana2071 then why did Egypt beg Israel for peace in exchange for the Sinai 6 years later, explain this to me. Explain to me why Egypt is the first Arab state to recognize and make peace with Israel after they said in Karthoum (1967): "no peace and no recognition"
@@Bolognabeef beg israel for peace ?! lol they begged egypt for peace it was the best strategy becuz egypt was coming harder
great video Jabz
+Munthasir Islam Cheers buddy.
Egypt accepted land for peace, why can't Palestine or Syria
Aidan Clifford cause they have the no rule look it up
lucio mokady lol Egypt broke it
Aidan Clifford never thought about it
Because Sadat was able to sell the peace deal as a victory to his people.. National pride has a very big weight in the Arab culture, sadly much bigger than peace and prosperity.
Egypt wanted peace after 67 but Israel didn't accept until they got defeated in 1973. Israel never give anything back withiut a defeat. Mushe Dayan said it in his book.
PROBABLY THE SINGLE MOST IMPORTANT PART OF THE VIDEO! 0:50
Chicken came back to roost big time!
You make so many great videos!
+Oliver Morland Cheers man
Prime minister golda Meir not president
Thank you for the 3 min explanation of the war . It has to be mentioned that Israel was caught by complete surprise in this war by its neighbors and managed to survive paying a high price in manpower. It changed the entire Middle East .. and Israel prevailed leaving alone the political negotiations and the oil Arab boycott which immediately follow .Lesson learned ...
Not completely off guard, the government lead by Golda Meir received reports about Arab troops moving but she chose to not act, and not call the reserves. But I agree with the message.
whats the lesson learned i didn't get it
Well, Israel has been crushed in this war successfully
Its crazy that Egyptians believe they won this war.
The war ended with the israelis crossing the Suez canel and encircling an entire egyptian army.
The soviets stepped in to save Egypt from an even more devastating defeat.
This is what’s wrong with Israelis. They think wars are always won on the battlefield and disregard the diplomacy aspect of it.
This war resulted in Egypt reclaiming all of their stolen land from the Zionist empire. No matter how you look at it that’s a huge win for Egypt.
If israel focused more on diplomacy instead of massacres and land grabs the region would be much safer
Jesus that speed talking is hard to follow
Great vid, always thought the yom kip war was one of the best wars in history, not saying war is good, but i find it very interesting how both sides in some way won territory and in the end it ended as a stalemate between both sides.
+Omar El-Miedany Cheers man
We weren't defeated if you actually studied this war you would know that both sides found themselves in a weak position and it did in fact end at a stand still, it is true that Israel put in motion one of the best counter attacks but at the end of the day Egypt regained all territory it lost in their last war which no matter how you look at it is not defeat but a victory as they got what they hoped to gain when starting the war. The conflict between Jews and Muslims is very complicated and all the wars between Israel and Islamic countries have been fueled by more than disagreements in religion. In real life not everything is easy to label however no matter who you think won the war the fact that Egypt achieved what it set out to do means they were not defeated.
^ This is typical Arab Revisionism and indoctrination. No right minded, sane man would view a war in which the casualties ratio is 1: 11 as a victory. Not to mention the IDF reached 32km from Damascus after pushing back the invading Syrian army, capturing 500kms inwards to Syria and 100km from Cairo after encircling the 3rd Armia of the Egyptian army which would've been annihilated had the war continued.
Firstly, Egypt still had an army centred in Cairo protecting it. Secondly seeing that Egypt gained all it wanted from the peace treaty after the war clearly means their postition was strong enough to sway the negotiations. They Syrians were clearly defeated. Finally, calling this arab indocrinations is simply wrong and ignorant. I did my own research when learning about this war. My history teacher taught me to look at history from both perspective and the truth always lies somewhere in the middle and that is what I did and what I hope you do to.
Thanks, and merry christmas
Omar El-Miedany The fact Israel gave back the land for peace doesn't mean you won the war, the Camp David Accords started 6 years later! You think the military strength swayed them 6 years later? You're being ridiculous, and this is the exact definition of Arab indoctrination. Go ahead and feel victorious if it helps you sleep at night but all the facts are against you on this.
arabs keep getting owned
You can just go read some books about this war instead of watching a 4 min Video and concluding that idiotic comment
sure that bcuze there is 1.8 bellon muslim in this world and all start n arab . we own the world befor u nation exist . keep crying
Fuck you
@@therocks1682 please define Arabs ?? Exploding themselves ??
Srsly that's a sentence made by a 9 year old
Israelis keep believing thier bullshit, your ass kicked and you cried like girls in 1973 go read Moshe Dayan books.
I wish I could send you donations, those videos are great
+Flying Pig (Hero) Thanks a lot man. And dont worry about it, I know whats its like having no money. I'm sure theres better stuff for you to buy.
For those who claimed "Egypt won because they got Sinai back":
1) They did not get Sinai back after Yom Kippur War, Israel was well inside their territory
2) They got back after Camp David Accords
3) Camp David Accords demilitarized Sinai Peninsula. The Multinational Force and Observers (MFO), an international peacekeeping force, was established to monitor and enforce the terms of the demilitarization. There are 1,200 troops in Sinai from 13 Western countries there to monitor by December 2022. => Sinai is de facto under International control, de jure under Egyptian control.
Egypt didn’t get Sinai back after yom kippur, Yom Kippur proved to israel that an Arab comeback is enevitable and with the early successes of Egypt (breaking their biggest fortification line to date in less than 6 hours) it was clear that no amount of American, British or French support would let them win, and thus, this alongside international pressure from even their biggest Allies would lead to Israel reluctantly leaving Sinai (in short Yom Kippur was a loss (not really though since Israel’s positions in Sinai were destroyed) in the short run but a decisive victory in the long term)
just a note: Golda was prime minister and not president. the president was Zalman Shazar who died a year later and replaced by Ephraim Katzir. Golda won the election of that year but left only 31 days after building her new government, and got replaced by Yitzhak Rabin. Rabin later got replaced by the right wing Menachem Begin, who made peace with Saadat and withdrew from the sinai.
@opener of the world boy you talk so much bullshit...
the usual "we are the arabs and wre are the mightyest even thogh we got our asses kicked every time"
learn some history and for the love of god, leave the internet, your imberrssing yourself
please please please do the montenegrin turkish war
Never heard of this war before now
class vid bro thanks
Egypt *won* the war and got Sinai back.
@Gabriel Petkov I care about reality not about what a video "sound" like.
@Gabriel Petkov The *real* history is that Egypt won the war and got Sinai back.
@Gabriel Petkov are you even an Israeli to defend them?
@Gabriel Petkov Then why are you defending them and their fake history?
Yes of course, that's a known Fact.
Great video! when are more of the flag history vids coming?
+ajlunce The Dutch one should be out quite soon, however I'm afraid I can't be any more specific.
+Jabzy awesome! keep up the great work, I'm getting a better job soon (i hope) and I plan on supporting the patreon thing or whatever
+Jabzy awesome! keep up the great work, I'm getting a better job soon (i hope) and I plan on supporting the patreon thing or whatever
+ajlunce Cheers buddy, I hope you don't feel obliged to though.
well I feel obliged just due to how much I enjoy your vids haha, I cut the cord so RUclips etc is main source of entertainment, gotta support those cntent creators!
Nice vid as usual👍🏻
+Mads Hagen Cheers
I tried to get a look on the yom kippur war i looked on other more longer ones but hear i socceded
i love the drawing, and that the video is not baised to any side, well done just for your information, the Israeli army group that encircled the 3rd Egyptian army was later encircled by the Egyptian 6th army, the israeli Group was cut dry of support wish allowed the both Egyptian army corps to defeat them, a fact that you will not probably come across, i would recommend to hear the story of both sides, just to avoid comment flame wars anyway....
The point is, i wish you a huge success, i subscribed and i have liked the video and will probably see your other videos, good luck :D
The support wasn't for the both armies , it'd for the thrid army , were Israel forces surrounded it
as an Egyptian, I'm honestly impressed that you didn't just insult us and praise the Israelians for the defense. You spoke honestly about the war and talked about everything wrong both nations did in that war.
could you do the 1982 Lebanon war pls
We got Sinai back with our hands
Right after Sadat begged for it with his hands.
@@johnnoah8556 so funny bro
@@johnnoah8556 It's very hard to tell who's won this war !!!!!
But in my opinion i believe that any war had a political object to achieve...
And in this case the Sinai land is the Egyptian goal... And they had it all....
And Israel would never leave that land unless they knew that they cannot keep it and they will defeated very very bad... So they agreed to leave it..
Thanks
Great video, but one important battle was missed towards the end. The Battle of Suez, where the inhabitants of Suez were able to soundly defeat the the invading Israeli army and repel them from amidst their city.
The Arabs just don't get it..
Hey Jabzy, just pointing out a small mistake.
at 04:06 you said President Golda Meir. It should be Prime Minister Golda Meir.
Love the videos :)
+jabzy
+Mostly_ Liberal Cheers, yeah a couple people called me out on this. I always manage to mess it up when countries have both a President and Prime Minister.
nice video hope u make world war 1 and 2 nice as well .
Happy 6th of October 🇪🇬
My father remembers this war. He still has dreams of the attack on his city. Scary times.
Damn. In which country?
@@ghassanassi I assume Israel, the early days of the war were not hopeful
@@ollybears7797 No, it was probably in egypt. As in the war the egyptians didn't attack israeli cities/villages, they only reached the sinai peninsula (former territory of egypt), while israel (because they were super close to major egyptian cities) bombed and sent troops to cities like the suez and port said.
Grandma existed in this war and actually the Israel troops fired at ismalia city destroying hospitals and killing thousands of Egyptians children,womem and they destroyed a hospital with people in it
My family left ismalia when they know that it's getting attacked by isaral
Funfact: this hospital exists and grandma made a surgery in it and thanks god she is ok
Sorry for my bad English and I'm a Egyptian any ways m🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬🇪🇬❤️❤️❤️
It was in Egypt the Egyptian soldiers attacked when Isreal attacked first.
pls do one documentary on 1971 indo pak war
Prime Minister Golda, not President Golda.
Happy Yom Kippur.
Yom Kippur isn't a happy day. Religiously, Festively and Historically.
Yes it is. It is a serious day, but the general tone is serenity combined with gladness since all sins are forgiven.
It isn't. Come to literally any Jewish person and ask him and he'll tell you. Also no one ever says 'Happy Yom Kippur' they say 'G'mar Chatima Tova!' which by my own, bad translation is 'Good final signature'.
Ahura Mazda Ahura Mazda I am literally a Jew and I've studied in Jewish and rabbinical institutions for my whole life, and I've lived in Israel. All the literature and liturgy of the day make it out as a very positive day. Chag Sameach is a greeting along with gmar charisma tova, which correctly means "a complete and good inscription (into the "book of life")
Alejandro Curchitser שמע אני לא יודע מאיפה אתה אבל ב18 שנות חיי לא שמעתי מישהו אומר את המשפט הזה אפילו פעם אחת.
do one on the sino-japanese wars
nice one...sad story but good vid
Brezhnev's take on the war is pretty hilarious:
"We have offered them (the Arabs) a sensible way for so many years. But no, they wanted to fight. Fine! We gave them technology, the latest, the kind even Vietnam didn’t have. They had double superiority in tanks and aircraft, triple in artillery, and in air defense and anti-tank weapons they had absolute supremacy. And what? Once again they were beaten. Once again they scrammed. Once again they screamed for us to come save them. Sadat woke me up in the middle of the night twice over the phone, "Save me!" He demanded to send Soviet troops, and immediately! No! We are not going to fight for them."
Bull shit
There were many wrong or not mentioned information in that video:
Firstly, you did not mention the Egyptian bombing on the bunkers of the barleef line and the anti-craft rockets that Egypt had deployed in trenches to make the Israelis think they are just anti tank divisions.
2- you did not mention the US air operation to send supplies to Israel, which was know as one of the biggest air operations and was made to save Israel from defeat.
3- you did not mention why the Israelis lost many tanks. That was because of the newest generation of anti tanks the Egyptian infantry had
4- the infantry on the Sinai front did not get support from howtizers they got support mostly from tanks.
5- when Egyptian third army got surrounded then got out of it, it was because they fought back not Becuase the Soviets threatened Israel to deploy soldiers on the Egyptian soil. Here is evidence: Moshe Dyan (the Israeli defence minister) said: "... As for the Egyptian third army, they fought back when they got surrounded and invaded a big part of South Sinai, so we cannot say we surrounded or defeated them.
6- you did not mention what the Israelis and the US did during and after the war to show that Israelis were the victorious one on both fronts. Here is an example: during the war the US and Israeli news said that Egypt and Syria were given, by the USSR, the same number of tanks the NATO had and that the USSR gave complete political assistance to both countries. That is actually one of the most stupid lies that were said. Another example, after the war I mean many years afterwards, the Israelis and US always write articles claiming that just on the Sinai front 15000 Egyptian soldiers were dead and Israeli losses were just 3000 and that Egypt had more aircraft loses than Israel, althoung the Egyptian rocket anti aircrafts crushed every Israeli jet that tried to bomb the forces.
7- you did not mention when a division of Israeli tanks got behind Egyptian lines and crossed the bridges that were made on the Suez canal to invade port said, and when the *CITIZENS * of Port saed made this Israeli attack a failure by defending with RPG's
This is only a 3 min oversimplified video
@@Makky265 Egypt (I am not talking about syria) had won that war and here is the proof:
You must understand what were the objectives of Egypt first and they were: cross the Suez canal and destroy the Barlev Line then advance and occupy from 12-20 kms of Sinai and make Israel suffer heavy losses to make it in a bad situation on this front and hence be forced to negotiate (unlike the sixth day war). These were the missions, now let's see if Egypt accomplished them..
On the 6th of October Egypt launched operation badr and started with bombing the fortifications near the Barlev line then the troops started marching to Sinai with the cover of Artillery and with hoses the Barlev line got destroyed. After crossing the Suez canal and destroying the Barlev line, the Egyptian troops occupied about 15 kms from the canal and made the Israelis suffer heavy losses, especially Israel's airforce because of the Egyptian Air Defense wall and the Israel's tank divisions because of the advanced anti tank systems. Syria was not doing good so Egypt had to do an offensive against Israel to Relieve the Syrian forces but it failed and led to the encircling of the Egyptian third army. The Israelis then discovered a demilitarized area in Sinai between the Chinese Farm and the Great Bitter lake so they decided to go through it to seize the City of Ismalia and Port Said in order to cut the supply lines for the Egyptian second army. So, the Israelis passed successfully and entered the city of Ismalia and Port Said but they failed to take it and were Pushed back to the Egyptian mainland in the Battle of Ismalia (en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Battle_of_Ismailia )
Now you said that the Egyptian third army got surrounded and defeated but that is wrong; they got encircled and continued fighting that they even invaded parts of eastern Sinai and this was confessed by Moshe Dyan himself when he said:
*"... And as for the Egyptian third army, They continued fighting and invaded parts of eastern Sinai, thus, we cannot say we defeated or encircled them"*
Plus, it is only one Egyptian battilion that got partly encircled, but do you even know how many Israeli battilions got not surrounded, but completely annihilated in the operation of Badr, battle of Ismalia and others? MANY of Them. So, Egypt made all of its desired accomplishments in this war and with all these failures from Israel, they forced to negotiate.. if they had won according to what you said, then Israel would have done like the Sixth day war; when they were demand to negotiate they refused because they are the winners and so they don't have to follow any rules; But in the war of 1973, they were in a bad situation on the Sinai front and had suffered heavy losses so they were forced to negotiate and return Sinai... If they were the winners, they would not to do that.
----------
Now, you said that Egypt got a lot of support from the Soviet Union... But Israel got EVEN MORE support from the USA and other western countries- don't you know that operation called "Operation Nickel Grass" which was the biggest strategic airlift operation since WW2 ? And this was made to supply Israel with tons of weapons, especially on the Sinai front, why?
Because as I told you, they suffered heavy losses... (en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Operation_Nickel_Grass )
-------------------------
So, with all this proof do you still think that Israel won the War on the Sinai front? Well, if you still do, then you literally understand nothing about wars..
To conclude this, here is a good lesson that you should have learned;
*Before you speak, check your information, or you will be severely roasted*
🇪🇬✌️
🇮🇱☠️
@@hatemeldmerdash585 ok
@@Makky265 lol you got so roasted that you didn't reply 😂😂
@@Makky265 Firstly, the Egyptian third army would not have been defeated if the campaign continued because as I told you, they did not just continue fighting but they invaded parts of eastern Sinai which means they were nearly successful in breaking the encircle. And yes Israel did suffer heavy losses at the beginning of the war- and at the end of it as well due to their unsuccessful offensive and their failure in the seizure of the city of Ismalia and Port Said which led to the complete annihilation of many of their batillions so we could not say that Egypt is the one who suffered heavy losses, for the only Egyptian operation that was unsuccessful was the operation to relieve the Syrian forces while Israel's unsuccessful operations in that war was more; Israel failed to stop the crossing of Suez canal, they failed to prevent the annihilation of the Barlev line, they failed to seize the city of Ismalia, they failed to Seize the city of Port Said and got pushed back, they failed to cut the supply lines of the Egyptian second army, they failed to completely defeat the Egyptian third army- so would you disregard all of these Israeli Failures? And that Egypt only had one minor objective that had not been completed? Moreover, you said that Egypt failed to forcibly take all of Sinai,but that was not an objective; Egypt wanted to cross the Suez canal, annihilate the Barlev Line and invade parts of Sinai not all Sinai but make the Israelis suffer heavy and let them be a bad situation in the war so THE ISRAELIS would sue for peace and they did as they were in a bad situation in the war: if the ISRAELIS won they would have made like the Sixth day war- when they were demanded to negotiate they refused because they are the winners so they do not have to follow any rules but in the October war the ISRAELIS suffered heavy losses and were not doing well on the Sinai front so they were forced to give the rest of Sinai. You said that we cannot state who is the real winners by seeing what happened in the beginning of the war, so let's see how the war ended:
-The Suez canal regained to Egypt
- The Israeli Barlev Line annihilated
-Eastern Sinai invaded by Egypt
-The Egyptian Third army partly surrounded, nearly breaking the encircle and invaded parts of eastern Sinai (this was confessed by Moshe Dyan himself and I gave you the speech in the previous comment)
- The Israeli battilions in Ismalia and Port Said are completely defeated by the Egyptian second army, some of the Israeli battilions are also encircled, some are taken prisoners and some went missing.
-The United Nations deployed peacekeeping forces on the Sinai front, ending the war.
-As Israel was in a bad situation in the war they were forced to give Sinai back and in return Egypt made a peace treaty with them .
As it told you: if the ISRAELIS won according to what you said, they would have made like the Sixth day war- when they were demanded to negotiate they refused because they are the winners so they do not have to follow any rules but in the October war the ISRAELIS suffered heavy losses and were not doing well on the Sinai front so they were forced to give the rest of Sinai.
One last thing, jordan did participate in the Yom kippur war but their role was insignificant and did not impact or make a changes in the war so you could not say that after jordan left the war, it was impossible to do something.
Okay my question did Egypt win them in 6 hours Bc looking at this they look like they did not
1965 and 1971 indo-pak wars...plzzzzz!!
The Israelis were obliterated in both of their attacks on Suez and Ismailia which only allowed them to be encircling the third army but not attacking it from the back.
At least Jordan was the only good Arab country, thank you guys for warning Israel.
@Eslam Saber aywa kosomohom
what is the music at the start of the video?
Informative!
Clearly attacking Israel is an act of sadomasochism.
Babylon, Assyria and Rome might disagree. Unless they played the sado part.
David Cantu
In that instance, it was the Israelites playing the masochist. They turned away from God, and he allowed them to be conquered. You'd think they'd learn after 2000+ years of repeating the same mistake.
The entire Egyptian army occupied most of the lands of Israel, occupied Jerusalem, Fallujah and the Negev, and besieged Tel Aviv before the armistice, while in the 1967 war the Egyptian army did not fight and most of it was fighting. In Yemen, the war lasted 6 years between the two countries. We completely destroyed the Israeli city of Eilat in 1969, and the war ended with the victory of Egypt in 1973 🇪🇬🇪🇬💪...
@@user-dj7vx4em3z And still the overall winner is Israel
Egypt didn’t lose tho lol
@trosky677
In fact quite the opposite, Soviets failed us desperately , despite their weapons ( which still I have to say was the only reason we were able to even start combat)
Clear facts and results on the ground:
1-Egypt won the war by achieving the overall objectives of a LIMITED military operation to force Israel to negotiating, and eventually won Sinai back.
And never say that Israel gave back Sinai willingly for peace, if so, then y try to take it in 1956 and 1967? And y Israel denied Sadat many initiatives when he first took power to withdraw behind the passages ( not to give whole Sinai) as starting peace negotiations ? It has always been part of "Great Israel from Nile to Euphrates". Israel even built settlements and started drilling for oil. They considered it theirs already.
Telling me after all that that, Israel won the 73 war and "bestowed upon us" with Sinai for the love of peace and humanity is just childish and naieve.
Egypt also achieved a more important objective that is destroying Israel sense of security coming from absolute military dominion, I think this message was very clear to the Israeli society.
2- Egyptian victory was obviously not a clear cut victory, because of the third army problem , which was all to compensate for the Syrian incompetency and weakness in combat, but still the strategic objective of Sadat was a JUSTFUL PEACE anyways, not to throw the Jews in the sea like the stupid Nasser said , and by the way Sadat paid the price for that peace. And the Arabs alienated Egypt for years being a traitor. And yet a small give aways for peace.
But remember that Israel couldn't take tiny cities like Suez and Ismailia and Sharon was directly ordered not to take s step towards Cairo because they couldn't take any more casualties. Actually the third army advanced East a little 😄and here comes fact no.3
3-USA put Soviets in their back pocket since day one, not only did they stall Soviet "real" military aid to Egypt while USA gave Israel phantoms and TOW missiles in early stage , but also in the end they maintained a situation where Egypt needs aid and supplies to the third army and YET NOT ALLOWING Egypt to pull back the behind lines forces doing nothing and not sharing in any combat, from east to west to annihilate the Israeli forces behind the third army,or to mobilize the army in Cairo from the west . brilliant!, hence years after this war Egypt leaves the Soviet camp and enters western camp, also as a consequence Israel managed to make political gains after all, and that is also why the Soviets were never a part of the peace settlements.
Since many years before the war the Soviets insisted on not balancing the technology and that is why we tried to counter this by numbers
We begged them for the "Quadrat" a self propelled surface to air missiles that would not allow the disaster happend on 14 October but they always denied us. Even during combat, we asked for tanks on 8 October and were actually delivered in November! After combat was over
The Soviets didn't have a clear vision of what exactly to do and what strategy to take in this crisis, and paid for it.
@trosky677
If u speak any Hebrew or Arab, check an honest Israeli analysis, Egypt was the only victor in this war:
ruclips.net/video/YomlFhIJQKU/видео.html
Also check this from HAARTZ Israeli press telling the same :
www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-so-who-won-the-yom-kippur-war-1.5450784
Source if u have time :
military.wikia.org/wiki/Yom_Kippur_War
But to summarize:
"Despite being surrounded, the Third Army managed to maintain its combat integrity east of the canal and keep up its defensive positions, to the surprise of many.[183] According to Trevor N. Dupuy, the Israelis, Soviets and Americans overestimated the vulnerability of the Third Army at the time. It was not on the verge of collapse, and he wrote that while a renewed Israeli offensive would probably overcome it, this was not a certainty.[184] and according to David Elazar chief of Israeli headquarter staff on December 3, 1973: "As for the third army, in spite of our encircling them they resisted and advanced to occupy in fact a wider area of land at the east. Thus, we can not say that we defeated or conquered them."
"Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Dayan stated that "The cease-fire existed on paper, but the continued firing along the front was not the only characteristic of the situation between October 24, 1973 and January 18, 1974. This intermediate period also held the ever-present possibility of a renewal of full-scale war. There were three variations on how it might break out, two Egyptian and one Israeli. One Egyptian plan was to attack our units west of the canal from the direction of Cairo. The other was to cut-off our canal bridgehead by a link-up of the Second and Third Armies on the east bank. Both plans were based on massive artillery pounding of our forces, who were not well fortified and who would suffer heavy casualties. It was therefore thought that Israel would withdraw from the west bank, since she was most sensitive on the subject of soldier's lives. Egypt, at the time had a total of 1,700 first-line tanks on both sides of the canal front, 700 on the east bank and 1,000 on the west bank. Also on the west bank, in the second line, were an additional 600 tanks for the defense of Cairo. She had some 2,000 artillery pieces, about 500 operational aircraft, and at least 130 SAM missile batteries positioned around our forces so as to deny us air support."[194]"
"The final situation on the Egyptian front
Despite Israel's tactical successes west of the canal, the Egyptian military was reformed and organized. Consequently, The Israeli military position became "weak" for different reasons, "One, Israel now had a large force (about six or seven brigades) in a very limited area of land, surrounded from all sides either by natural or man-made barriers, or by the Egyptian forces. This put it in a weak position. Moreover, there were the difficulties in supplying this force, in evacuating it, in the lengthy communication lines, and in the daily attrition in men and equipment..."
So the Israeli forces were is a shit position after all, the Egyptian third army was in very grave danger but still operating, Cairo was fortified, Israel forces fails to meet most of their objectives on the west side.
And net result is Egyptian flag is in Sinai now because of that military position
Can I download this music somewhere? Where did you get it from?
+Shirukröte RUclips audio library. Its called Nevada City
Jabzy Thank you.
Great Infomation Jabz, well done
Btw, some addition, the Arab call that war as Ramadhan War since it was happen during Ramadhan (Scared month for Muslim to Fasting for a month) according to Islamic Calender.
Keep up the good work!!!
+bladebladerz93 Cheers man.
Who gives a shit about your calender?
@@charlesayache6801 we do asshole
@@charlesayache6801 well u seem nice
@@charlesayache6801 we do, you piece of shit.
It's very hard to tell who's won this war !!!!!
But in my opinion i believe that any war had a political object to achieve...
And in this case the Sinai land is the Egyptian goal... And they had it all....
And Israel would never leave that land unless they knew that they cannot keep it and they will defeated very very bad... So they agreed to leave it...
Thanks
Yah good point - '..any war had a political object to achieve.."
Egypt win - got Sinai back.
Israel draw - lost Sinai but kept Golan heights precious water source.
Syria loss - did not recover Golan Hieghts.
Israel gave back Sinai years later for a peace treaty with Egypt. I know because I was there. Israel won on all fronts, any other conclusion is just propaganda.
Lennart Pesonen but that’s like saying I gave the schoolyard bully my lunch money so that we can have peace. No, it’s because you didn’t want to get your ass kicked.
Joseph Magdy, the Israelis argue that the Arab objective was to take all of Israel and so because they were unable to do so the arabs failed and Israel won. A lot of heresy from both sides. But the fact is that the Egyptian army did not advance their artillery past Sinai after capturing it.
In my opinion, Egypt won the war as they had one Goal in mind, And that's to get Sinai back, which they did
Arabs fighting Israel is like hitting your head on a wall. When it’s bruised you go back home to analyze why it’s bruised to only try it again in the future
Fuck you
Israel is the worst and most scared country in the world
The problem is they don't even analyzed
you didn't mention that when the Soviets threatened to join, Israel armed it's Nuclear missiles, preventing Ivan getting nuked in sandie town was the incentive for the Yanks to step in
When did the six day war start being referred to thus? Was it pretty soon after or did it take some time? Was this a media led thing or did one of the belligerents start this? Same question for the Yom Kippur war.
It was 6 years before... If you had a basic grasp of Israeli history you'd know Israel captured Sinai, Gaza Strip, Judea and Samaria, and the Golan Heights in 1967, in 6 days of fighting. 6 Days war was started by Egyptian Navy blockading the Tiran Straits, in addition to mobilization of the Egyptian and Syrian armies, what was particularly alarming for the Israelis is the fact that Egypt amassed troops near its border and that it kicked off the UN peace keepers, Israel knew that it was going to be invaded and thus it strike first, completely destroying the Egyptian and Syrian air forces, achieving total air supremacy, later Israel tried to convince Jordan to not join this war but it did anyways and Israel had to fight them too. *Another important bit to know is that a week and half before the war started the Egyptian president said:"Our basic objective will be the destruction of Israel. The Arab people want to fight". Hope this settles it but I could go to further lengths if you really wanted.
In 1973, the October War as called by the Arabs was started by Egypt and Syria (wew what a surprise eh) on the holiest day of Judaism in which you fast and you don't use any electrical things like cars, television , radios and even lights. Most of the IDF was at their homes or at a synagogue at the time the Arab attacked and so there was a major panic and delay in Israel's response but later after some intense fighting it vanquished over the vile Arab states, reaching 32 km from Damascus, and 100km from Cairo, the war ended because of international pressure against Israel as usual, but had it continued the 3rd Egyptian Army which was encircled would've been annihilated and the Arabs would've been brought to their knees.
The name was actually decided by the Israeli government on the 26th of August the same year.
@@Yougottacryforthis fuck you and your basic grasp shit talk. Answer the direct questions asked or fuck off. Thanks. 😏
Im Egyptian 🇪🇬 expected to see an lie about Israeli victory but surprisingly it was pretty unbiased and mostly factual 👍
@@GabrielBTzar We as Egyptians aren't ignoring the part when Israel slipped past our defense, but Israelis tend to ignore the existence of Abtal Sina' which literally means "Sinai's Heroes". Those guys are civilians who were trained by the military in 1967 (when Israel first took Egyptian land) and then went on with their normal lives, the purpose of this was that if Israelis attack Egypt and enter their land, the civilians would put up a fight, and they did.
The Israeli brigade was ambushed by these civilian fighters, and therefore, that part didn't play a big part in the war. But it showed Israel that every Egyptian was ready and able to fight back.
So with that in mind,
-The Egyptian goal for the war wad to push Israel into talks for returning Sinai (ACCOMPLISHED)
-They also held the Sinai for a while.
-They also ENTERED the Sinai which itself was virtually impossible.
-Repelled Israeli attack into Egyptian mainland embarassing the IDF
-The war also resulted in Sinai's eventual return to the Republic of
Egypt
That's why we consider it a victory.
The Golan front was a swift victory at first, but then IDF concentrated on the Syrians and the Pals. I think possibly because the Golan heights had a smaller area, and the Syrians and Palestinians were making great progress and nearing to Israel's"mainland" so they had to concentrate their attack which resulted on heavy losses for the Arabs. Which is also the reason for the Egyptian push that was known to be failure on the words of Israel. In reality, the attack was destined to fail. All the martyrs that went in there probably knew what they were getting into. It wasn't a fail attack, it was an attempt by the Egyptians to get pressure of th Golan fighters. I honestly dont know much about the Golan front tho.
Edit: I think the name Abtal Sina' is wrong. Sorry about that. Either way here are some photos.
images.app.goo.gl/8NWih8wMG1jy6BTu7
images.app.goo.gl/c4suUS8LhnpMRSoz8
ibb.co/JckG2BW
Last photo is near impossible to find. And IS impossible to find if you're searching in hebrew/English/etc (western language or most languages other than Arabic).
@@typh0n33 How is that a victory if 20000 men were killed w/ massive support of the soviet union?
but enjoy your victory anyway we already know who won (hint: the one who has the better influence and economy)
@@Ultrapro011 Soviets won world ww2 but take a look at the casualties. yeahh... Millions. Also we didn't have support from the soviets. We kicked them out. And we achieved the impossible by even getting in the peninsula to begin with. So we will enjoy our victory, and sing our victory songs just like we always had been, way more than you, bc we know who really won. ( Hint: The guys who currently own Sinai. Not the people who took money from Americans fkr their economy, thats not a victory :\ )
Yk at first i thought you were actually looking for an answer, but you didn't surprise me all that much. I gave a decisive explanation to how Egypt got the most out of the war, aka won. Even provided PHOTOS as vindication, but your only arguement is people died? No shit. And btw every Egyptian went in there ready to die bc we have faith, Islamic faith, or Christian faith. Death doesn't faze us. We aren't scared of death. You should listen to some of our war songs you probably won't, but if you do you'll find Egyptian forces were ready to win or die.
@@typh0n33 Soviet union helped alot to syria and egypt while israel barely got any support from the US untill the mid of the war
you don't seem to understand what is it when everyone are fasting while two coward armies attack each from the opposite side
also show me how you won and how does it translate now that egypt is poor while israel is rich?
@@Ultrapro011 I say this once more WE KICKED THE SOVIETS OUT BEFORE THE WAR. The Americans gave you state of the art weapons and vehicles we gpt defensive weapons from the soviets, moreover they wouldn't train us to use it. So we kicked them out and disassembled learned how it works then reassembled them. Also you fast for 25h we fast for a month. And it was the tenth day of said month, Ramadan. And cowards don't fight nations technologically more advanced with defensive weapons.
Habibi your money means nothing the US pours billions into your nation every year aldo Egypt easnt poor at the time, and war isn't won by money. There are nations that win and remain poor or lose and remain rich depending on how much their resources were exhausted. How about you stop looking at money and look at a map because sinai is back to its people. And don't say you chose to give it back bc we all know it would never happen. It's not like you have a history of giving land back to the natives.
You forgot to mention the Arabs started the war.
no but i started your bloodline
Only to restore their lands
امي حبيبتي you guys got funcking whooped
@@Aqua.man045 but we won and we got our land back
so its 1 to 1 for now.
also israel could not win alone. it was backed by america. obviously
Salman The Nub No you didnt Israel left the area because it had no use to them. You have never came close to beating israel.
Horrendous loss of life by Egyptians and Syrians compared to Israel. Why does a country think so little of human life as to use men as cannon fodder. The huge disparity in loss of life and equipment between opposing forces is incredible. Very interesting looking at the advanced weaponry soviet tanks compared to Israeli tanks and how they were used by each opposing force.
@Isaac Maker
Israelis lived for generations knowing that the October 1973 war was a defeat for Israel, a fact that all Israelis know, while Egyptians have been celebrating every year since then.
The famous victory speech given by Sadat in the Egyptian Parliament on October 6, Egyptians celebrate the National Day of the Great October Victory. Then with the spread of the Internet and communication sites, the Israelis woke up from a deep slumber. Then they remembered and said we won. This is ridiculous.😆.....
The losses of the Soviet Union were greater than Nazi Germany, and yet they won😆
Smaller country means aircraft can easily reach one side to other
In basic meanings, Egypt shot at Israel, Israel shot at Egypt, Egypt shot at Israel, Israel shot at Egypt, at the end the 2 wanted peace, so it was an army win for Israel but a political win for Egypt since they managed to pressure Israel into giving them Sinai back.
Nah, Israel was crippled America have have to intervene
@@johnsonsmith3421 Nah Egypt publicly admitted Israel was a sovereign state basically admitted they were completely wrong in the 7 days war
Egypt won that war, Israeli soldiers themselves admit it ! Not to mention the genius idea of the destruction of Bar-Lev line with WATER in 3 hours (instead of 48 hours as Isareli generals calculated). President Sadat stopped the war because his intentions were NOT to invade Israel (That would trigger a world war, possibly a nuclear was involving URSS and USA) it was a CLEAR, MASTERFUL win, I am not Egyptian but truth is truth. Long live Egypt !
but how did u won if israel get sinai back?
@@melatus9394 they never got it back
@@johnsonsmith3421 we did and brought it to Egypt back in 1978 for peace offering.
@@melatus9394 when Egypt took back the land america (un) had to intervene so the arab forces wouldn’t attack Israel and take everything, so they settled on just giving up the land and not fighting for it anymore, after this Israel loss the current president was killed by his own people, although the same thing happened to the Egyptian president for accepting Americas peace plan, to be fair Americas influence on the region is huge, you can’t really do anything without americas intervention like the Kuwait iraq war.
@@melatus9394
Yeah because you were scared lol
I don't think I would have given up the Sinai, (or however you spell it), Peninsula, just to be recognized by Egypt
That was a public reason the real reason was because the Egyptian second army could've advanced more into sinai and for the "Egyptian third army" that Israelis claims to be captured wasn't really encircled even the Israeli general David Elazar (the general that clashed with the third army) said that they didn't fully encircle the third army
It'll never end
Everyone says that israel lost to eygpt in 1973 but israel actually won because eygpt mabye got the barlev line and suez in less than a day but israel didnt give up and they managed to take back suez and barlev line
They didn't. What are you smoking?
I agree because they had soundly defeated the Syrian and Egyptian armies and didn’t lose territory
Maybe look at the map of the world before talking?
@@noyou404 eygpt got sinai back dou to peace treatment between eygpt and israel. They didnt earn that back from fighting. They earned it from our deal.
@@user-ef6rx8ce8j and that's cuz we destroyed Israel army and won militarily
Egypt did this peace treaty cuz USA was gonna send support tome Israel and Egypt didn't want to go in a war with USA
Don't forget what happened to Destroyer Elat and Barlev Line my guy
Israel won again, even though all Arab neighboring countries attacked. Good job Israel. Israel is the most democratic and technologically advanced country in the Middle East. I am not a Jew, I respect the Israelis so much.
*The war almost lasted 6 hours, Egypt took back Gaza and was planning to take Jerusalem, but the USA gave them 25% of the army equipments*
So it was Egyptian victory at the start, what kept Israel alive was USA
Edit: Israel didn't pass the Suez canal they claimed they did. But they didn't
Like darn in the entire west bank of the Suez canal their is no destroyed tanks tanks at all.
Tu2525 Gaming keep telling urself that, how brainwashed can u get?
Israel son of amirca
It's hard to say who won. Depends on perspective. The Syrians definitely lost and they lost badly. But regarding Egypt, because of the enforced ceasefire, Egypt did end up with a partial success in Sinai, holding their position there. But there is no doubt that if the Soviets/Americans had not forced a ceasefire, Israel would have destroyed the Egyptians as their 2nd and 3rd armies were cut off with no supplies able to reach them. The very fact that the Soviets forced a ceasefire is proof that Egypt were about to lose badly.
MezMezMez1
The Egyptians succeeded in breaking into a water barrier along 160 kilometers and destroying its fortified fortresses.
Make headers and repel the main counter-attack.
Israel broke through the two armies and failed in the main task of the occupation of Ismailia and Suez
XD Golda at 1:21
Become fuck that, fuck you, and fuck everything
+Kobi Libero Because*
+Kobi Libero I'm terrible at drawing women.
+Jabzy Actually it's quite an accurate one, from what I know at least XD
Also, please keep going with your videos! You're almost the only one which speaks of history, and only history. without leaning naratives to either sides.
It's an outstanding work, the artwork is fun to look at and the reaserch is done in depeth, truly a pleasure for any history fan!!!
Going to have to update this video with all the documents released by the Egyptian government
this war ended the myth of Israeli invincibility.
They still won tho
And the palestinians only suffer
Anyways Jazby great video once again
+Sadiq Rahman -_-
They got fucked in the arse by the Arab league
EresirThe1st yup ! organisations that caused the Black September in Jordan , the Lebanese civil war , and the suffering of the Gazans , which is greeted by the vast majority of Palestinians with joy .
+EresirThe1st Definitely. Just like the Jews. Completely 100% innocent. Kicked out of 109 countries... but yes, it's everyone else's fault. All 109 times. Derp.
Alex Leaud let's just say both are wrong and not innocent , they both committed crimes equally , it differs in the place of that crime
I have to remind of the Port Said offensive, a Disaster for Israel in the last day of Fighting: Moshe Dayan, wanting some Legacy for himself, although knowing of the upcoming Ceasefire, have led thousands of Soldiers into the Egyptian city of Port Said, on the Mediterenean Coast. However, the City was full of Egyptian snipers, and thousands died without realising what the heck was going on.
+MrMapperIL I spent too long explaining the build up so I had to leave a lot out.
Jabzy I mentioned this offensive just to remind of how Disastorous this war was for Israel. This war had the most deaths per time fought for Israel, and even though it's considered a Victory, it is remembered much less Heroically than the war of 1948, the Six-Day war and the two Lebanese wars. Speaking of which, you should make a vid about the Lebanese CW.
***** The arabs did have one objective: They retook control of the west bank of the Suez Canal, making it useful again. Plus, Israel did not succeed in doing anything, and didn't manage to expand their control in neither the canal nor Syria, thus making this war very useless. Most leaders of the war quitted their jobs, and the Chief of General Staff committed Suicide.
אחי התפיסה שלך מעוותת לגמרי, כן המלחמה הזאת הייתה גרועה בשבילנו כי היא לא הייתה מלחמת ששת הימים שתיים, אבל מפה ועד לומר שלא השגנו כלום. לא רק שהעפנו אותם מהאדמה שלנו, אנחנו גם היינו ממש קרובים לדמשק ולקהיר ואם לא היו אונסים אותנו להפסקת אש, אז בכלל היינו מחסלים לגמרי את הארמייה השלישית ומביאים את הערבים לברכיים. זה ממש לא הפסד.
great job
+dr history cheers
Even though Israel won the Yom Kippur war and the Arab armies were totally destroyed, the Arabs had a feeling of (false) victory.
Because of that, there was real peace between Egypt - Israel and Jordan - Israel.
The Arabs would not have accepted a peace treaty after the six day war because the defeat of the Arabs was tremendous.
This teaches you shouldn't attack Israel, even if you're the strongest country in the world.
OmenOfWar I don't if you could say that.
OmenOfWar tell that to the roman empire sir SPOR. The jews in Judeah were a huge pain in the ass for biggest empire at the time.
OmenOfWar I think for most of history the number of Jews hav been too small and the amount of Jewish states in the past too weak in order to really say their weak
Are you serious? Russia, China, USA..etc could obliterate Israel (and all their Arab neighbors) If they wanted do. You are severely under estimating the power of the big boys.
Arabs suck at wars. They suck too. Only reason they won was weaponry and tactics/training from alloes
one minor issue you claim it was Egyptian Artillery that protected their troops in the initial counter attack and it was the when they moved out of its support that they had problems it wasn't actually artillery it was SAM batteries that protected them as It kept the Israeli air force from creating air superiority and it was when they moved away from these batteries at the behest of the Syrians (who didn't make a similar investment in SAMs or use the limited ones they had in a similar fashion thus allowing the Israeli Air force to destroy Syrian forces) that the Israeli air force were able to quickly gain air superiority and then fly ground attack sorties at will degrading the Egyptian land forces the superiority of the Israeli air force was also one of the reasons Israel was caught of guard as they didn't believe they would be attacked until the Egyptians had recovered their air force losses from the 67 war when the Arab air forces were decimated and didn't anticipate that they might be able to offset this imbalance in air forces with advances in soviet SAM technology as their was a massive leap in capability of SAMs between 1967and 1973 due to advances in computing technology and experience gained from the ongoing Vietnam war. But apart from that well done. As the original Egyptian plan was a bite and hold operation in which they penetrated a few miles into Israeli territory but stopped and dug in while still within range of their fixed SAM batteries with the knowledge that the Israeli Air force would attempt to ground strike the trench lines while they would whittle the Israeli air forces down with defensive SAM fire till they reached a point that the Israeli air force was destroyed and then the Egyptian army would break out once their was no chance of air attack and out attrition the Israeli forces. the plan was working very well but due to the failure of the Syrians to set up a similar system an their defeat the Egyptian Army was put under extreme pressure from their political superiors who were over confident in their ability due to encouraging early results underestimated the resolve of the Israeli force and over ruled the local field commanders forcing them to break out and abandon their plan when it was on the brink of total success thus dooming their forces to a devastating counter attack
+Jon south I actually had a whole bit on the development of weapons and the arm suppliers in the build up to the war (mainly focusing on tanks though). However I ended up cutting it out when editing it because the video was far too long.
Jabzy
i guess 3 mins is a very tight schedule but its a very nice overview
Is this Rimworld background music?
Jabzy sorry but your video is full of wrong historical info specially about israeli gap in Egyptian side the israili fail to inter the al Sewies town and a lots of destroyed israeli tanks still until now there then they back to the same line they start with near the canal , In Egyptian part they make new fourth army and name it " Badr forces" and surrounding the israeli forces to start attack and finish them then henry Kissinger call AL Sadat to stop it and tell them if u did it so we are in "War" ..and continue..we will not let the soviet union arms win again on us ( means Vietnam war ) then Al Sadat stop everything and he say the famous speech in the parliament (( I can fight the israeli and win but i cant fight the US and them both ))
Yes the Israeli Tanks are still in Sinai i see them there.
Clear facts and results on the ground:
1-Egypt won the war by achieving the overall objectives by forcing Israel to negotiating, and eventually won Sinai back
And never say that Israel gave back Sinai willingly, if so, then y try to take it in 1956 and 1967? And y Israel denied Sadat urge when he first took power, to withdraw behind the passages ? It has always been part of "great Israel from Nile to Euphrates"
2- Egyptian victory was obviously not a clear cut victory, hence acknowledging Israel as a nation, the idea of negotiating, and peace, and by the way Sadat paid the price for that peace.
3-USA put Soviets in their back pocket since day one, hence years after this war, Egypt leaves the Soviet camp and enters western camp
4- u want Sinai again, come and take it 😏
@Gabriel Petkov
Not true, at most u can say Israel made a military draw, and even that is questionable
If u speak any Hebrew or Arab, check an honest Israeli analysis, Egypt was the only victor in this war:
ruclips.net/video/YomlFhIJQKU/видео.html
Also check this from HAARTZ Israeli press telling the same :
www.haaretz.com/opinion/.premium-so-who-won-the-yom-kippur-war-1.5450784
For military details that show that Israel only made a propaganda to cover its loss, that was only reflected by giving back every inch of Sinai (an we have no problem with that :-)) check this link on Qura, the first guy there made references from very interesting books
www.quora.com/Did-Egypt-Syria-win-the-Yom-Kippur-War#
I mean u try to say that Israel fought 3 wars for Sinai, eventually won, and yet gave it back for humanity love and peace
Ohhhhhhhh how cute 😍😍
Just childish
Peace from sharm el sheikh 😜
@Gabriel Petkov
Source if u have time :
military.wikia.org/wiki/Yom_Kippur_War
But to summarize:
"Despite being surrounded, the Third Army managed to maintain its combat integrity east of the canal and keep up its defensive positions, to the surprise of many.[183] According to Trevor N. Dupuy, the Israelis, Soviets and Americans overestimated the vulnerability of the Third Army at the time. It was not on the verge of collapse, and he wrote that while a renewed Israeli offensive would probably overcome it, this was not a certainty.[184] and according to David Elazar chief of Israeli headquarter staff on December 3, 1973: "As for the third army, in spite of our encircling them they resisted and advanced to occupy in fact a wider area of land at the east. Thus, we can not say that we defeated or conquered them."
"Israeli Defense Minister Moshe Dayan stated that "The cease-fire existed on paper, but the continued firing along the front was not the only characteristic of the situation between October 24, 1973 and January 18, 1974. This intermediate period also held the ever-present possibility of a renewal of full-scale war. There were three variations on how it might break out, two Egyptian and one Israeli. One Egyptian plan was to attack our units west of the canal from the direction of Cairo. The other was to cut-off our canal bridgehead by a link-up of the Second and Third Armies on the east bank. Both plans were based on massive artillery pounding of our forces, who were not well fortified and who would suffer heavy casualties. It was therefore thought that Israel would withdraw from the west bank, since she was most sensitive on the subject of soldier's lives. Egypt, at the time had a total of 1,700 first-line tanks on both sides of the canal front, 700 on the east bank and 1,000 on the west bank. Also on the west bank, in the second line, were an additional 600 tanks for the defense of Cairo. She had some 2,000 artillery pieces, about 500 operational aircraft, and at least 130 SAM missile batteries positioned around our forces so as to deny us air support."[194]"
"The final situation on the Egyptian front
Despite Israel's tactical successes west of the canal, the Egyptian military was reformed and organized. Consequently, The Israeli military position became "weak" for different reasons, "One, Israel now had a large force (about six or seven brigades) in a very limited area of land, surrounded from all sides either by natural or man-made barriers, or by the Egyptian forces. This put it in a weak position. Moreover, there were the difficulties in supplying this force, in evacuating it, in the lengthy communication lines, and in the daily attrition in men and equipment..."
So the Israeli forces were is a shit position after all, the Egyptian third army was in very grave danger but still operating, Cairo was fortified, Israel forces fails to meet most of their objectives on the west side.
And net result is that an Egyptian flag is in Sinai now because of that military position
@Gabriel Petkov
Only when u focus on what you want to see, not the conclusion and the end result militarily and politically
@Gabriel Petkov
U see, every political gain is only a reflection of the military situation
And Israel did gain some, but to compare, Egypt was the victor as it achieved all her objectives
Again let me tell u Israel never wanted peace, Sadat offered them peace when he took power, but they in return built settlement Yamit and digged for oil in Sinai
If they won they would have stayed just like the Golan
@Gabriel Petkov
Also listen and read their OWN testimony in the video and HAartz article
These are the final verdict
jabzy you should also do a Israeli independence war has a lot of stuff that goes on there
and would you consider doing a thing likes this but about battles instead of wars
+jack cohen I'm not great when it comes to military formations and what not. Particularly naval stuff.
So I'm a patron ($10 per month) and I'm wondering where I can claim my rewards?
+Numberad Sorry, I didn't see you changed the pledge. I'll send you a message on Patreon.
Egypt army and Syria army lost 73 war ..israeli cross canal ...israel was 26 miles from Damascus ..israeli just 60 miles from cairo ..syria had 1200 tanks and 200 small tanks .Egypt army had 2300 tanks ..Arabs lost war again israel have captured thou,s of tanks from arabs ..thou,s of APC and vehicles .hundreds of SAM sp and SAM 7 .AA A gun SP anti AA guns. millons tons equipment
Mark Brown so from where u got all these israeli tanks huh?
ofc by america
Mark Brown and u didnt sort events true because in 73 israel was taken Sinai of egypt and taken golan of syria
and israel wasnt near to cairo or damascus because france britian left the battle
lol without a war or not,Israel was 60 miles already...it is the distance between Cairo and the canal better check another website than wikipedia
Egyptians are not even Arabs, the Arabs were just our allies, look to the bright side We have took back Sinai to our motherland Egypt
Saher Hassan you mean israel gave it back to make Egypt its ally cause it couldn't maitain sinai.
🇮🇱 #1
🇮🇱 - Sinai 😂
🇮🇱=💩💩
The only real issue I have with this vid is that the history didn't start in 1967 with Israel "taking" these territories . You have to either look at everything in context , or else just not make comments about these Arab countries "losing" the land to Israel.
Golda Meir was a prime minister - not president
but other than that - well done :)
+Ohad Ben-Haim My bad.
Egypt always won allover history by help of god and her brave ppl and her great army ...that's the truth.....
you say bullshit when you stop eating sugar
3:01
LOL, Prophet Mohammed was a filthy disgusting paedophile, nothing more. May he burn in hell forever for his sins!!
epgz2004 - Ignore that bastard ..
And btw. you probably also heard about the great news, USA and Israel - friends forever!!!
www.bbc.com/news/world-us-canada-42259443