Vladimir Putin Replaces Russia's Defence Minister: Who Has Replaced Him? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
HTML-код
- Опубликовано: 12 май 2024
- Vladimir Putin Replaces Russia's Defence Minister: Who Has Replaced Him? | Vantage with Palki Sharma
In a significant reshuffle amidst Russia's ongoing war on Ukraine, President Vladimir Putin has removed Russian Defence Minister Sergei Shoigu from his position as the country's top defence official. Shoigu was Russia's defence minister for 12 years - and was believed to be a close ally of President Vladimir Putin. He has played a major role in Russia's offensive in Ukraine. But last month, one of Shoigu's deputies was arrested on charges of corruption. This allegation cast a shadow on Shoigu's track record. His replacement is Russia's current first deputy prime minister- Andrey Belousov. Belousov is an economist and known to be part of Putin's inner circle. However, he has no prior experience serving in the Russian military. So, why did Putin choose an economist to replace an ally? Palki Sharma brings you an assessment.
---
Russia | Vladimir Putin | Defence Minister | Sergei Shoigu | Andrei Belousov | Firstpost | World News | News Live | Vantage | Palki Sharma | News
#russia #vladimirputin #defenceminister #sergeishoigu #firstpost #vantageonfirstpost #palkisharma #worldnews
Vantage is a ground-breaking news, opinions, and current affairs show from Firstpost. Catering to a global audience, Vantage covers the biggest news stories from a 360-degree perspective, giving viewers a chance to assess the impact of world events through a uniquely Indian lens.
The show is anchored by Palki Sharma, Managing Editor, Firstpost.
By breaking stereotypes, Vantage aims to challenge conventional wisdom and present an alternative view on global affairs, defying the norm and opening the door to new perspectives. The show goes beyond the headlines to uncover the hidden stories - making Vantage a destination for thought-provoking ideas.
Vantage airs Monday to Friday at 9 PM IST on Firstpost across all leading platforms.
Subscribe to Firstpost channel and press the bell icon to get notified when we go live.
/ @firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Instagram:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on Facebook:
/ firstpostin
Follow Firstpost on Twitter:
/ firstpost
Follow Firstpost on WhatsApp:
www.whatsapp.com/channel/0029...
Lady you wrong! Shiogu is promoted! Not demoted!
His new position is more senior and above defence ministry in Russia.
The hell you talking about?
Maybe she gets news from Western Media
She is right. He dont have acsess to big money, he doesnt make a decisions, only do.
Some of his people got fired or under arrest for corruption.
Eve pescov(secretary of putin) made a joke about him.
People dont like Shoigy, many People died bexouae of him.
you are right. this journo succumbed to jealous prigozhin's accusations of zhoigu. zhoigu is a fantastic manager militarily and in civilian admin. but then again intrigue would add more audience to a news.
She’s an embarrassment to journalists .. He’s been promoted to a high position, Russia need an economy man in for the long haul to this war.
Shiogu had always wanted to resign a long time ago, but Putin beckoned to serve in the last administration. He (shiogu) was actually promoted to a bigger position and role, not demoted.
you are right
She is right. He dont have acsess to big money, he doesnt make a decisions, only do.
Some of his people got fired or under arrest for corruption.
Eve pescov(secretary of putin) made a joke about him.
People dont like Shoigy, many People died bexouae of him.
One thing about Russia, they know what they're doing unlike US and EU.
100%
@_-Rumcajs-_ohh you mean the Russia Rubble will become Rubber right, we still waiting😂
@_-Rumcajs-_ self military capacity of Ukraine was destroyed long ago - let me remind you that if Russia declares this conflict as real War than there would see 20-25 million Russians under arms by Russian Law fighting pathetic Nato hyena feeding itself on Ukrainian blood
@_-Rumcajs-_only one taking about "3 days war" is your government, how's your living standard coming on?
Russia should've never crossed Ukraine's border.
The US changes Defense Ministry every time a new President is appointed. Sometimes more often. Shoigu had been on the job for 12 years, that's a lot of time for a position that is un-elected. Also, his new position is a higher role than Defense Minister.
Yeah? 😂😂 because putin has been president since 2000. What kind of retarded fact is that? “Well america changes president every 4 years but great Russia only have president for life!!!! So it’s way better”
Do you guys like licking boots that much?
a country that has weapons like "satan" does not lose a war. Nobody wants winter in the middle of summer😄
it constantly loses. The West had to finance, feed, clothe and arm them against the Nazis and also destroy all their air force. Anyway, it's the Ukrianians and Belarussians that die all the fighting.
The true face of Satan I guess is USA and EU
@@schloops8473kust to remind you that the 2nd WW ended when the Russian army took Berlin and defeated the Nazis!!!!
@@punitapillai5091 the russian army took nothing. The USSR had some victories and only because the West fed, financed, armed it after destroying the Nazi airforce and opening a second front. And even the USSR victories had nothing to do with russians as they did none of the fighting and were just active in pillaging.
@@schloops8473😂😂 the way you guys narrate as if you fought against the Nazi
This lady doesn’t know the difference between a promotion and a demotion.
...bizarrely she remains on air!
Quite dumbfounding.
She was booted out of Wion.
I admire and love this lady's intelligence. But I'm very disappointed at this level of ignorance. UNLESS of course she's reading from the script.
RUclips pays for any blunder😅😅😅😅😅
As far as I understand its a promotion to Shoigu.
yes, a massive promotion... with an office with a large window... keep crawling
@@schloops8473It is a promotion, he's practically head of their military industrial complex. He's an engineer and manager this job is practically perfect for him who had been doing the inspections practically since forever makes him focus more on what he does best.
@@e_x_c_u_b_i_t_o_r_ejiysb7169 yah, makes him able to STEAL more wealth while being a complete clown... typical criminal yes boy of the Bunker Boy criminal regime
While it might be technically a promotion, I think his role in running the war and the war economy will shrink.
@@seneca983 bruh his role will be better serve as that position. He's already doing the job that Medvedev supposed to do on ensuring the military industrial complex produce the necessary weapons. The fabs, lancet, and artillery shells are practically him doing that job.
Give the man some credit instead of trying to belittle his new position, nobody understands Putin
Putin would not do this without reason.😊 I consider it a war tactic.💕
The tiger (Putin) sneaks up to hunt. ☝ Putin is the world's greatest diplomat.💪 Westerners will be confused by this time. 😂😂😂
Shoigu new position is higher than that of defense minister, which he was
lol PATHETIC. Keep crawling for all to laugh at
Shoigu is never even a military person to start with, he was some sort of firefighter or civil defense
Shoigu is failing upwards
Yes. He is promoted not demoted.
@@TsarOfRuss he's a civil engineer. You?
At least they know the difference between a man and a women ...
do they through? Because a man with genitals doesn't crawl in front of a 1 meter tall impotent coward dictator
They called him The Krelim on TV 😂
A war economy need an economist as defense Minister.
Time to turn Victory into Money.
what victory? The victory of losing 500.000 men because the Bunker Boy wanted a legacy?
Shoigu was a firefighter himself, he wasn't a military man and never served in the army or go to any military academy
@sources - western media: cnn : bbc ? Ooooops ! oops8473
@@TsarOfRussmanagement all that requires. Across globe same trend - no general becomes ďiiffence minister..in majority of the cases.
@_-Rumcajs-_be sympathetic to Ukraine. They lost 1/3 of land area. . Sevier damage to infrastructure. Lost military logistics..no possibility of reclaiming lost land.thats fact.
As an economist, I can ensure we know the cost of war and we can make beneficial decisions for government... We are very rational rather than emotional in matter of money ...
Stop covering nonsense! Shoigu was promoted not demoted. He is now the deputy Head of the Security Council. Thats not a demotion but a tactical a restructuring. Shoigu will be overseeing more manufacturing and international military dealings !
He's also an engineer andd a manager so this job is more than better for him. Practically makes him focus on that the the duties of defense minister
Correct decision. 12 yrs same ministry definitely long term.
Thank you for reporting from south Africa ❤️❤️👏🏿👏🏿👏🏿🤝🏿
How are the blackouts there and price of Gas?
@@AuralioCabal-nl8gi1 litre of petrol it's about 1,5$ at most and it has been few months since we last experienced black outs
@@shooter6375 yes, and by that you mean about 15 minutes? Anyway, keep crawling... dictators love that
Demoted ?
.I think you missed this one !
truth is illegal when you support the impotent rat putin
Congratulations sir for your new appointment as defense Minister I hope you will bring victory for the world not for Russia only by helping Iran acquire nuclear weapons to protect the middle East
ah yes, a theocratic dictatorship that promotes terrorism all over the planet and abuses it's own people... getting nukes... what could go wrong?
What a stupidity.. Russia is slowly collapsing..this system cannot stay for a long time.. there is no freedom of expression what really is going on.
The truth is that i used to have great respect for this reporter, now she just saying nonsense, shogui was promoted not demoted
I'm also fed up with her hostility to China. The world won't move on with backward attitudes.
Shoigu's new position is nominally higher, but it's far away from any hefty contracts and kickbacks $$$, so consider it a demotion in monetary terms.
Who says defence minister should have military working experience Palki ?? Its a myth 😂🤣
Spacibo, thank you.
Good afternoon President Putin and Gen Shoigu ❤️🇷🇺🇮🇳🦾😇👋
Go mother russia, russia will win
Russia should go home. This war is Putin's war ONLY.
🙏from the UK our corrupt unelected scumbags in government aren't wanted or needed. It's as if they want us all dead. Depopulation agenda under guise of proxy war.
Voice of nabi asli @3:50 😊
Get this people..I’m Polish and Polish defence minister now is a medical doctor,yep,imagine tactical decisions he is going to make one day😂
He spent 25 years in Academy of Sciences which was literally a KGB research and planning center. I wouldn't be so sure he is just an economist.
THANK YOU 🙂
Lol... They have a new Soldier in the War "The Russian Economy"
Miss confident who know everything
🤣🤣🤣 She is probably an extension of the US propaganda machine
Shes a great reporter
She is a new world order.talking head . good at her propaganda post
@@akinfabunmi8186 when you don't have anything to do with the discussion. At least we have free press unlike yours. She may have her biases but definitely not USA propaganda.
@@AK-fd1tb you really gat free press?😂
It's just business. Nothing personal.
❤❤❤❤❤❤❤
I think Shoigu is too soft in the war efforts against Ukraine
yes, you think they aren't raping enough children? Typical of your kind.
The previous defense minister was a construction engineer so🤷♂️🤷♂️🤷♂️
India stands on international politics, which is not clear, and it is something very confusing.
Today our beloved palki is confused as hell😂😂😂 how is a promotion a demotion?
This was more like a promotion to Shoigu. Thought she would know that. 🤷🏻♂️
The General Staff is in charge of the war in Russia, not the Minister of Defense. The Minister of Defense is engaged in the economy: military enterprises, construction of houses, roads, supplies. And Shoigu was appointed to a higher position in the hierarchy. So everything that is told in this issue is a lie and outstanding incompetence!
interesting perspective indeed!!!!!!
Mother Russia will win this war, go go mother russia
"mother russia"... you know the dictatorship where 1% (putin, his family and oligarchs) have stolen all the wealth, all the rights and send the rest to die in Ukriane... or as eunuchs would say: a mother
❤❤❤❤
Its means the war is over in Ukraine
GOD BLESS RUSSIA VICTORY WILL ALWAYS ON YOUR SIDE. SALUTE FROM SOMALIA AFRICA
The power of the employers
Palkia's analysis shallow. Shoigu is going to hold the most senior and powerful security council.
strategically the economist is most ideal to manage war economy.
Strategic for the long war to come US/NATO imperialistic driven war. It's going to be a real big fight.
Already a president, it will be a tough call to take on the defence ministry.
Shoigu has a PhD in economics too. He also is not fired, rather given a different office.
No, he doesn't. His degree is in civil engineering (and it's not a Ph.D.).
its a promotion for shoigu, a change of strategy for long term planning in my view
I've strong feeling of 1989 Afganistan invasion 😂
Stupidity at peak 🥴
Surprise move
surprise... the tzar finds more scapegoats for his own incompetence
You should listen to the Duran
He didn't dump him. Shoigu got a promotion.
How can Ivonov only use the job. Don't people go to jail for stealing a zillion rubles? I would imagine his boss was in on it, as well as Putin. Russia what a screwed up country.
Sergei Shoigu did not support the war.
I Hope Russia K New Minister work Goody Goody 😮
Hey my beautiful Queen 👑👑👑
Even without military back ground he look bad azzz then shaigo
Shoigu's new job description:
Secretary of the Security Council. He will also become the deputy in Russia's Military-Industrial Commission, retaining influence within Putin's administration. I think he has more power and more influence now in Putin's circle. He has two functions. One is to oversee the security of Russia (internally and internationally), second is he is in charge of the MIC (Russia's military industrial complex). Shoigu and not a military man. He was a civilian, a civil engineer. Being the head of the MIC is in line with his technical knowledge. The securty aspect of Russia is weak in terms of technical capability and that is where Shoigu's experience will shine. He will marry the Russian technology to the country's security function to make it more effective and powerful. He will bring Russia's security playbook to the next level. I think this was the result of the last terrorist attack. Putin mentioned to use all of Russia's resources and technogy to identify the source and brain of that terrorism. They didn't get much positive information that's why the issue died down. Let's follow how Shoigu will accomplish his task. My hyperbolic hypothesis. Just saying.
I don't doubt Putin choice, balancing economy in all fronts is very vital, he is smart
Let the show begin. 🍿🍕
Shirgu need to move to America
News mens and womens should mind there own country business
There 10.000 poutine's in russia
There 50.000 defence ministers in russia
Palki Sharma Shoigu is the new Sec Gen of Russian National Security Council and that position is even more powerful than being a Defence Minister.
EXCELLANT STRATAGEM.👈
maybe WASH.DC, should put an economist-WHO WONT BE TAKING A BRIBE- as a defence minester👈.
As for The General, generals don't sleep at night like we do. 800 days of generating COMBAT situations, he needs a break.
BUT, THERE IS MORE.
THE war has turned into a route.
THIS can all be handled by others.
GOOD MOVE.period.
THE Indians know all about war and tactics.
USA 76-79 dustoff
Newly appointed Economic War minister to recover russian frozen foreign assets , he knows who to attack.
It might be an economically strategic idea to align the interests of the military (russias biggest expense) with the interests of the economy during war times, but im sure tactical planning is definitely being done by someone else
I’m not too sure on this decision to hire an economist as the country’s defense minister. In a war, the ability to effectively execute the fire power is more important than skill sets in mitigating the costs related to executing the fire power.
There shouldn’t be any ceilings on defense budgets, especially when a country's at war, as in the case of Russia, or even when a country faces a constant threat due to hostilities with some other nation. It’s the country’s sovereignty at stake and there shouldn't be any compromise in conserving it.
Президент - актёр более эффективен.
Russia is about a decade ahead of the collective West and can leverage this technology in commercial industries generating wealth. Also, everyone will want to buy Russian military equipment, at any price
hahahahah lol
First Post has got this wrong. Look at Shoigu's record and note in what areas he has always excelled. The Ivanov matter had to be addressed. Because Shoigu had been betrayed it appears that he offered to resign from all public positions but Gerasimov, Putin and Belousov (for the PM's office) refused and Shoigu had in any case been getting more involved with Russia's Security Council -- especially as it would be primarily responsible for regional expansion and Shoigu had done a similar job for 20 years in his native south Siberia.
Moscow watchers have long said that this body (we do not have equivalents in the west) needed a heavyweight director/secretary with a cabinet brief and not 2nd tier as it had been. Shoigu's degrees are in civil engineering and logistics rather than direct military matters so in some ways he was wasted as a Defense Minister. Further, Gerasimov, some of his most educated younger officers and Shoigu himself had been critical of duplication, which gave a wrong impression to armed forces staff.
By filling the Defense seat with a high-end economist for the duration of the 'SMI' and enhancing the Security Council with Shoigu, Vladimir Putin has shown his commitment to the best people for post-conflict jobs and greater momentum in Russia's Asian development. This is therefore consistent.
Ivanov will lose more than his job. Note also that the Security Council covers all strands of security including weeding out corruption.
First Post does not usually jump to western narrative conclusions but has done in this.
My suprise too!
Wow my people please just watch the Duran because this woman dont know what she is talking about she is just reading a script
So next is trade war...😂
PROMOTED TO A HIGHER OFFICE
Well done to you Mr Putin Sir
the new defence guy is a environmentalist
Because he is slated for other positions
*Narendra Modi should learn something about Dictatorship from Putin* ❤
All part of MSM.
He not demoted. He went somewhere. To retire
Vantage noticias internacionais
He needs to rest
Shoigu was not sacked he was promoted to a high position, get you facts right. Z.V.
Some times right ✅️ some times kissing western hands, that's firstpost
Palki’s narratives about Russia and China took at 280 degree after she started on Firstpost. She almost sounds like an American mainstream media anchor.
Cheaper drones
Look i told them to chill
This lady is so wrong in all senses, shiogu was promoted on a more sensitive and senior role than before, overseeing all the defense and military complex’s and more close to Putin than before. Being the chairman of a military council is A HUGE promotion in the Russian government.
You do know that he sits on the council which is the most powerful organ that makes all the decisions that affect the country? Only media sees a shift and promotion as demotion.
And assuming the shifty narrative was true, it would be a good thing that Russia leader takes a hard stance on corruption unlike Ukraine which is always faced with scandal after scandal.
Russia leadership is an example of a country with a vision while the west is busy chasing narratives while tanking its own economy
This woman can over exaggerating things😂😂😂
President Putting as patient a lot Shoigu shoud be sack long time a go for the cause of the death Russian Military during the start of Russia , ukrain war
First Post on the spot. Palki raises true and accurate facts and figures in this status while no any media talks about this. Brilliant journalism 🎉❤
Replacing an incompetent Shoigu with a bean counter, no military experince, is surely gonna go well for the Z Army...
🤣😂🤣😂
Good afternoon Mr Dmitry❤️🇷🇺🦾😇
Hypocrisy
I don't know how this guy will work but if the guy is as smart as people say he is then sure
We support Russia.
"lying collective west
this is more incorrect news Shoigu was not demoted he still sits close to Putin and was promoted so sick of fake ass news
It's such kind of reporting I hate! He has been promoted and not demoted please!!!!!!